Dude when I heard this at the end of that Bill & Frank episode, I got teary-eyed. I was like “Damn you, Neil Druckman!! You just had to go and make a sad story even sadder, didn’t you??” Lol
This bitter earth Well, what fruit it bears Ooh, this bitter earth And if my life is like the dust Ooh, that hides the glow of a rose What good am I? Heaven only knows Lord, this bitter earth Yes, can be so cold Today you're young Too soon, you're old But while a voice within me cries I'm sure someone may answer my call And this bitter earth Ooh, may not Oh, be so bitter after all This bitter earth Lord, this bitter earth What good is love Mm, that no one shares? And if my life is like the dust Ooh, that hides the glow of a rose What good am I? (What good am I?) Heaven only knows
As I listen, a delicate symphony of melancholy and light envelopes me, the soulful voice of the singer weaving through strings straight into my essence. 🌌 Each note vibrates with profound emotion, stirring the deepest chords within me. This piece isn’t just heard; it's felt, echoing in the silence of my being, haunting me with its beautiful resonance. 🎶💔 A personal exploration of life's tender poignancy.
So sad song too profound ... and expresses how life with humans is too bitter ... earth is beautiful but humans are worse than any other creature ... 😢😢😢
This is the only cover I've found to do Dinah justice. Thank you for posting this hauntingly beautiful rendition of the great Dinah Washington and Max Richter.
PIERCING..., the voice, the music, the words perfect combination for reflection of life and the meaning OF..... Listen to Dinah Washington's version often.
Realy love this song. I only did hear it by this way... marvelous voice Joy Denalane 🎙 and the best violine artist ever Daniel Hope 🎻. Let my soul bleed every time.
@@sailorhaderslev Yes...the original tape is marvelous to... You know that Max Richter and Daniel Hope are friends by music and by heart... The Recomposed FOUR SEASONS... They Made TOUGETHER
Wow! Just wow! Why does this violin make me cry? So beautiful. If God could grant me just 5 minutes to do something exceptional, it would be to play like this violinist. Much respect to all of you. I can only imagine how many years of practice and dedication it took to be the greatest in your talents. Just brilliant . Thank you. I have been blessed to see this.
This song is the singular reason that I let the credits play out every time I watch Shutter Island… Also, the first time I watched Arrival, I BROKE DOWN into tears. It so perfectly encapsulated my Complex PTSD and how I project it towards my incessant fear of losing my five year old daughter (who is btw currently healthy and has no indication that she will die early). I’ve even told my therapist before I ever saw this movie that my ptsd has forever altered my perception of time: Everything that can happen IS happening. Everything that has happened is STILL happening. Even though I know these are illogical feelings, my thoughts can do little to nothing to dampen the effect that both loss and fear of loss have on my emotional state. So it causes me to have these ‘episodes’ where my brain, as a defense mechanism, will randomly imagine what it would be like for my wife/daughter/best friend/etc to die. I imagine their funeral. The music that will be played. How hard everyone I know there will be crying. The eulogies given. I imagine years after the death and how everyone will be struggling to cope and/or even simply just struggling to get out of bed each and every day. And it’s not until the tears start steaming down my face that I realize this isn’t actually happening yet and I snap back to reality. These episodes happen about once or twice a week and I don’t even need a therapist to understand the psychological reasons as to why. My brain has been conditioned (through enough loss and trauma) to believe that it needs to prepare itself ahead of time in order to spare me from the pain of these things inevitably happening again. But I know how illogical this is, as I’ve witnessed how just because it might somewhat dampen the effect versus those who aren’t prepared at all (like I once was), nothing can actually spare me from that pain when those tragedies inevitably occur. Therefore when I watched Arrival and saw how her seeing her daughter dying (before she had ever even been born) and how her life would play out… it hit so hard. And so, all of that is just to illustrate what this score by Max Richter and the version so beautifully sung by Dinah Washington means to me every time I hear it. Not just the lyrics, but the chord progression itself captures what if feels like every time I have one of those ‘episodes’. “And if my life, It is the dust, That hides The glow of a rose, Then what good am I? Heaven only knows…”
Simply stunning🌏
Oh, my goodness, I've longed to hear someone do this live since I first heard it. Thank you!
very incredible Voice Joy Denalane , the performance is outstanding
What an incredible voice. Just amazing.
Always memories to Dinah
With love to Dinah Washington, great singer, salutes from México.
Such a beautiful tribute to Dinah Washington and Max Richter, bravo! Got me a bit teary-eyed.
Dude when I heard this at the end of that Bill & Frank episode, I got teary-eyed. I was like “Damn you, Neil Druckman!! You just had to go and make a sad story even sadder, didn’t you??” Lol
This bitter earth
Well, what fruit it bears
Ooh, this bitter earth
And if my life is like the dust
Ooh, that hides the glow of a rose
What good am I?
Heaven only knows
Lord, this bitter earth
Yes, can be so cold
Today you're young
Too soon, you're old
But while a voice within me cries
I'm sure someone may answer my call
And this bitter earth
Ooh, may not
Oh, be so bitter after all
This bitter earth
Lord, this bitter earth
What good is love
Mm, that no one shares?
And if my life is like the dust
Ooh, that hides the glow of a rose
What good am I? (What good am I?)
Heaven only knows
😭😭😭
Thank for the lyrics.
Immediately brought me to tears! This is so impressive!
Will always prefer the fabulous Dinah Washington mix. Sublime 🌟
Pierces my heart and soul each time I hear it
As I listen, a delicate symphony of melancholy and light envelopes me, the soulful voice of the singer weaving through strings straight into my essence. 🌌 Each note vibrates with profound emotion, stirring the deepest chords within me. This piece isn’t just heard; it's felt, echoing in the silence of my being, haunting me with its beautiful resonance. 🎶💔 A personal exploration of life's tender poignancy.
Another loss brings me to listen to once again....
Beautiful rendition to a beautiful song ❤️❤️❤️
So sad song too profound ... and expresses how life with humans is too bitter ... earth is beautiful but humans are worse than any other creature ... 😢😢😢
Fantastic. Great selection, from the first time I heard them together until now, I’m still blown away by how perfectly they compliment the other piece
Extraordinarily beautiful, I think that is the kind of song many of us would want as your last song. X
I agree. If this were the last piece of beautiful music played in my memory it would be wonderful.
My god ❤😢❤😊❤
I just knew the Richter version, but these words are perfect for the sadness of the music.
Wow, what a fine version of this extraordinary mix of music and lyrics. Gratitude beyond words.
This is the only cover I've found to do Dinah justice. Thank you for posting this hauntingly beautiful rendition of the great Dinah Washington and Max Richter.
Absolutely, this is my favorite song by Dinah Washington.😍
PIERCING..., the voice, the music, the words perfect combination for reflection of life and the meaning OF..... Listen to Dinah Washington's version often.
I am completely surprised by the nature of this piece. Absolute pleasure.🌞🌱❤🌿🔥
She Put The Stank On It Emotionally, Live!!Thought Provoking.❤
Absolutely gorgeous and majickal. Ty! Dinah would be proud.
Realy love this song. I only did hear it by this way... marvelous voice Joy Denalane 🎙 and the best violine artist ever Daniel Hope 🎻. Let my soul bleed every time.
Try this “original “ version ruclips.net/video/jXHGoaEtmFM/видео.html
@@sailorhaderslev
Yes...the original tape is marvelous to...
You know that Max Richter and Daniel Hope are friends by music and by heart...
The Recomposed FOUR SEASONS... They Made TOUGETHER
Beautiful and touching. It stays with you for a while.
lacrime, gioia, bellezza, abisso, poesia, dolore, speranza, Amore, pensiero e Anima. Una Meraviglia.
Your delivery is so beautiful it grab my soul and move me into tears ❤❤
Wow! Just wow! Why does this violin make me cry? So beautiful. If God could grant me just 5 minutes to do something exceptional, it would be to play like this violinist. Much respect to all of you. I can only imagine how many years of practice and dedication it took to be the greatest in your talents. Just brilliant . Thank you. I have been blessed to see this.
Grossartig! Gerade entdeckt, zart, berührend und in seiner Einfachheit genial. Die beste Version seit Dinah Washington => MASTERPIECE
Sublime merci 🥲🥰
J'ai versé ma petite larme
SOULFUL HEARTRENDING
AWESOME ❤❤❤
This feels so personal to me right now, it goes so deep ,
Dinah would be proud. Excellent rendition.
Incroyable ce mélange et cette puissance dans la voix . Sublime merci
You did a beautiful job with this incredible piece of music and devastatingly beautiful lyrics.
Times... To rub salt into the wound because they know no better... Is no excuse...
love
Well done !
sublime !!!
Unbelievable great ❤😢🎉
Many can enjoy this.
Wouah ❤❤magnifique chanson 🌹🌹
Che delicatezza , ho sentito il brivido 💌
Ciao, prova a sentire la versione cantata da Dinah Washington poi mi saprai dire! Ciao
Wow...
Great.This is……..speechless.
Wow. Wow. Joy’s voice is like a warm and soulful melancholy.
Outstanding tribute bravo!
Why do I feel like I've known this song all my life😪☺️🤍❤️
Because the great Dinah Washington recorded it decades ago?
@@oceanlanguage Haaaa ,that's why😉🤣🤣👍🤍
You probably heard someone play this song when you were a young child 💞
Got damn. So glad I found this ❤😍😍
Breathtaking
Amazing work.
heaven only knows.......
Ganz groß!!!
Danke!💜
Herrlich, bestes Cover dieses Klassikers. Gefällt mir sogar besser als das von Veronica Swift, auch sensationell ❤
Amazing
❤❤❤❤
Gosh
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
OMG!
❤️🔥
heart
❤
As a transgender women, I know this world all too good!!! This is the truth in our reality.
This intro and accompaniment are not to this song. It is an Alan P tune.
😭😭😭😭😭😭
putain que c'est beau !
Lordy lordy..
I like the just instruments version way better.
This song is the singular reason that I let the credits play out every time I watch Shutter Island…
Also, the first time I watched Arrival, I BROKE DOWN into tears. It so perfectly encapsulated my Complex PTSD and how I project it towards my incessant fear of losing my five year old daughter (who is btw currently healthy and has no indication that she will die early). I’ve even told my therapist before I ever saw this movie that my ptsd has forever altered my perception of time:
Everything that can happen IS happening. Everything that has happened is STILL happening.
Even though I know these are illogical feelings, my thoughts can do little to nothing to dampen the effect that both loss and fear of loss have on my emotional state. So it causes me to have these ‘episodes’ where my brain, as a defense mechanism, will randomly imagine what it would be like for my wife/daughter/best friend/etc to die. I imagine their funeral. The music that will be played. How hard everyone I know there will be crying. The eulogies given. I imagine years after the death and how everyone will be struggling to cope and/or even simply just struggling to get out of bed each and every day. And it’s not until the tears start steaming down my face that I realize this isn’t actually happening yet and I snap back to reality. These episodes happen about once or twice a week and I don’t even need a therapist to understand the psychological reasons as to why. My brain has been conditioned (through enough loss and trauma) to believe that it needs to prepare itself ahead of time in order to spare me from the pain of these things inevitably happening again. But I know how illogical this is, as I’ve witnessed how just because it might somewhat dampen the effect versus those who aren’t prepared at all (like I once was), nothing can actually spare me from that pain when those tragedies inevitably occur.
Therefore when I watched Arrival and saw how her seeing her daughter dying (before she had ever even been born) and how her life would play out… it hit so hard.
And so, all of that is just to illustrate what this score by Max Richter and the version so beautifully sung by Dinah Washington means to me every time I hear it. Not just the lyrics, but the chord progression itself captures what if feels like every time I have one of those ‘episodes’.
“And if my life,
It is the dust,
That hides
The glow of a rose,
Then what good am I?
Heaven only knows…”
Wow...🙂
Excellent. However, the vocals are way too loud.
That's a point. The instruments need to come forward more.
How about” this was the most incredible heart piercing performance “?
Ive heard a few good remixes using Dinah's voice - they are all fantastic. This cover version is dreadful
Meh I don’t like the choice to riff. Sorry.