Did Tomek and Eli really scaled Nanga Parbat in 2018 Winters?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 17 окт 2024
  • One of the most viral Search and Rescue Operation ever conducted has still some unanswered questions. Pakistan Explorer delves deeper to find the answers.
    All rights reserved to Pakistan Explorer-- A Travel and Media company licensed with Ministry of Tourism Pakistan.
    Follow us on
    / thepakistane. .
    / pakistanexp. .
    For climbing expeditions and guided tours winters/summers check our website
    www.pakistan-explorer.com
    #2018 #disaster #winter #nangaparbat #updates #killermountain #tomaszmackiewicz #elizabethrevol #diamirface #travelogue #climbing #endurance #sports #commercialclimbing #searchandrescue​​ #ispr​ #pakistanarmy #pakistan

Комментарии • 19

  • @realbounty5221
    @realbounty5221 2 года назад +13

    If summit ascents were only counted as such when the protagonists were back down alive, there would perhaps be fewer dead climbers. Greetings from Germany (alt. approx. 20m) to Pakistan!

    • @22leggedsasquatch
      @22leggedsasquatch 2 года назад

      Why? How would that change the death rate? Take a photo at the top.

    • @johndurrer7869
      @johndurrer7869 Год назад

      I count their summit as more legit than those that left their trash on the mountain.

  • @thetypetwolife3602
    @thetypetwolife3602 2 года назад +4

    Best 8,000 meter channel ever!

  • @longshot3236
    @longshot3236 2 года назад +4

    Great show , thank you for your time, sorry about losing your friend.

  • @annieoscar
    @annieoscar 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for another great video! Very sorry about Tomek.

  • @alexdevalera4550
    @alexdevalera4550 Год назад +1

    Thank you for your enlightening comments on this tragic story. Elisabeth has the stamina and the passion that Herman Buhl, Bonatti and Messner had, Tomak was a fine mountaineer, but first of all he was under the spell of Nanga Parbat. At last he rests where he belongs. I would never doubt the accomplishment of these two. I don't care if there is no video. I have very few pics of my climbs and none at the summit in winter, why would anyone take his gloves off and risk frostbite manipulating a camera ? After all Elisabeth came back and if she had left her companion from the beginning she would have made it on her own.

  • @emmaphilo4049
    @emmaphilo4049 2 года назад +1

    Very good video, thank you for sharing. I am from same country as Eli. Very moving event. RIP Tomek

  • @arsalansarwar888
    @arsalansarwar888 2 года назад +2

    Love to see more videos like this. Excellent content.

  • @keiththompson2172
    @keiththompson2172 2 года назад

    Great video again.

  • @sasodominko4248
    @sasodominko4248 Год назад

    Tnx nice chanel bro

  • @majahallberg8287
    @majahallberg8287 2 года назад

    I have a question: If one does not succeed to take oneself back down from a mountain that one has summited, does this still count as a successful summiting? Also in John Snorri, Ali Sadpara and Juan Pablo's case: If it can be proved that they have summited K2 before they perished, can one still call it a (successful) summiting? And by the way: Are there any results from trying to evaluate the electronic gadgets found on the three perished climbers? And if not, can we reasonably expect any results sooner or later?

    • @PakistanexplorerTM
      @PakistanexplorerTM  2 года назад +4

      Summit success is practically reaching the summit regardless one was able to get down alive. If a climber claims to have reached the summit after descending, it is normally considered a summit success although there are many controversies in this regard. If there is a proof, even better. There are no further confirmations in case of Ali, John and JP.

    • @majahallberg8287
      @majahallberg8287 2 года назад

      @@PakistanexplorerTM Thank you very much for your interesting answers!

  • @nataliemeenakshithegreat7780
    @nataliemeenakshithegreat7780 2 года назад

    So we have to trust Elisabeth

    • @JL-nk1pc
      @JL-nk1pc 9 месяцев назад

      Never trust these people they are the most egotistic narcissistic selfish people in sport.