Видео

They are hobbits 😝who cares what u call them

It se3ms they put black people in it just to do. Why?😊

Not it's not. Read the books. Even her mum called her man-maiden. She learnt wisdom and peace over the 1000s of years before you see her in the LoTR movies. Most of the wowsers probably haven't read the books, or don't care if it gets them clicks

Most =a small fringe willing to have sludge served to them, then tipping their waiter

That's not true. Almost no one talks about this horrible show. Most people don't like this show. People who do mostly either have no critical sense in them whatsoever, and/or they only want to see their bitter agenda served. This disastrously shameful cinematic garbage gives exactly that to those lost souls. This horrible piece of garbage comes from human hate, whose empty bitterness successfully found a path even into the legendary story that is LotR. You are likely part of that small minority of troubled people who think that the current wave of bullshit created by your hate, is a good thing.

@@jonnycrono8694 Nah, I'm pretty sure after your message you're the one full of hate😂😂😂😂

@@RTDKRunner You boring..... The show is good, and we love it!

@@conolade3290 yeah look. Some people like to stare at a burning trash can. To each their. But it despoils Tolkien's legacy and name with its stupidity, ridiculous writing, and reversal of his timeless themes and placement of shipping, low-brow melodrama, atrocious acting and other elements his work should never be associated with. This should be a CW homemade fantasy show and should not bear his name. Go back and reread or listen to the real material. You will see then this is like the latest manufactured popsong compared to The Beatles of Beethoven's symphonies.

@ADR-x4d I'm glad you agree ❤️

@paulbitgood2117 exactly, they are trying to do marketing and they are not even doing good job in that. Imagine ruining a show for a modern look and a better sell and not even doing that .😂

Much of what you write is true, but part of the problem was that the producers were strictly limited to the book LOTR and its appendices. They legally are prohibited from using anything in The Silmarillion, or indeed any of Tolkien’s works other than the above mentioned. While the appendices have an outline of events earlier in Tolkien’s world, there’s not a lot to flesh out many characters that are just names in lists and in timelines. As for Peter Jackson’s “The Hobbit”, much of the flaws in that trilogy was due to studio executives, who in their greed, insisted on making three movies, based on a book that is much shorter and simpler, than the epic scale of LOTR. Jackson, who really didn’t want to direct that project (there were other directors considered, and one was hired, but then backed out), was left with no real control, and a fraction of the time for pre-production that Jackson had with LOTR. So everything had to be rushed, and they had to try to come up with filler material to get three movies out of one book, which was very different in style than LOTR, even though both works were written by the same author. That’s how we got that monster of a trilogy. The other problem is that Tolkien himself was a perfectionist, and was never satisfied enough with what became The Silmarillion in his lifetime. He never thought it worthy of publishing, and it was only published, along with other works, after his death. Who knows what might have happened had he lived another twenty years. He would probably be surprised at the widespread desire to read and see more of the whole story, which, though mythical, reads like a history, right down to disputes and debates over events that aren’t historical, but are fiction. It’s very hard to ask someone else to take up Tolkien’s work, and somehow add to it, or adapt it. He was the sole creator, and sadly, he has been gone for just over 50 years now, and even his children have all (as far as I know) passed. So it’s incredibly difficult to get “inside” a late author’s head, and see the world as he did (much comes from his experiences of the horrors of the trenches of WWI, where he lost all of the friends of his youth, save one), and also to look at the entire set of works through the mind of a philologist. Plus, there’s the fact that the producers CANNOT use any of Tolkien’s other works, including his letters, where he answers questions of readers Finally, one minor point. The term is “canon”, not “cannon”. The latter is an artillery weapon, the former comes from a word which means rule or law, and in a literary sense, it has to do with a list of the works known to be written by an author. It was probably used first in determining the Biblical canon (which books are considered to be divinely inspired) or, in the Catholic Church, canon law, which is a codex of church law. And unfortunately for the producers of this series, the producers did not have the legal rights to use other parts of Tolkien’s canon. Why this is so, I cannot say, especially as there is a member of the Tolkien family who is a consultant to the production. I don’t know if the producers didn’t want to pay more for access to the rest of Tolkien’s canon, or if the Tolkien family is divided over whether or not to ever sell the rights to adapt the rest of Tolkien’s works. The result are characters that seem one dimensional, largely because Tolkien himself didn’t really develop most of the characters that are often just mentioned in passing in the appendices. Remember, the events of the LOTR happen over just a few years time, with most happening in one calendar year. But this series is trying to tackle events that occur over thousands of years. That’s extremely difficult to do, especially when you have characters like elves who live for centuries, as does Sauron, yet they are interacting with mortal humans, dwarves, hobbits, who aren’t going to live for hundreds of years. Finally, I do think most of the first season was a waste of time. Season two seems to be much better written.

Thank you, oh great gatekeeper

​@lonelydwightfrye Hey Star Wars, Star Trek, and ASIOF fans put up as much if not more opposition. That didn't stop the people who loved stuff like Star Wars Sequels or GoT from pretty much ignoring anything the original fans had to say.

@42stek thank you for sharing your thoughts. I very much appreciate it.❤️

Oh my god, exactly. I used to be a marvel fan but it's just hard to see DC and not loving it. They're doing great.

@@t.k.1319 thanks for sharing that 👍

@White-Ray-Ray thanks a lot for sharing. I totally hear you the books are too long and if you're not a big reader you are going to have a hard time. I enjoyed the movies more than the books too. Anyway I appreciate you telling us what is on your mind. I would be more than happy to have you in my brand new channel. Please subscribe to see more videos about movies and show that are worth talking about.❤️

Not sure what complainers you’re talking about. There are critics that have actually read all of the books several times that are doing much more detailed criticisms of every episode. If they were doing this for the New York Times, they’d be TV critics, but, because they’re doing this on RUclips, they are “complainers.” Ok.

@@t.k.1319 I wasn't talking about this channel nor this video. I was talking about people like the Critical Drinker.

@@t.k.1319 After thinking about it, I do agree with you and your thoughts now. I guess because I didn't full read the books, I just enjoy the Rings of Power for its own story and I like its telling of LOTR history, even if it is not correct.

Evil can not create,only deform and destroy!

Yes, i totally hear you😂

And to be honest, it doesn't look like they are going to make it better.😂

Its because there is so much frankly ludicrous and nonsensical writing, poor production values and bad acting. Which the vast majority of people can see.

L

Have you actually watched the show?

Because it has a lot to talk about

I would describe your family and the people at work as traitors to the species, forsaking the millions of years the human race spent developing forebrains and rational thought. Let's forget everything known about the lore of Tolkien, shall we? You're okay with fast travel? Arondir being six-foot-sword-stabbed in s2e7, then getting up and fighting in s2e8? Halbrand taking stab wounds to the side/gut, desperately needing "elvish medicine", forgetting in a previous episode they said the Elves had no healers, then riding SIX DAYS NON-STOP NO SLEEP ON HORSEBACK? A volcano erupting, taking the flow to the face and waking up the next episode with NOT EVEN SINGED HAIR? I realise I come across as rude. You need to realise precisely what you're admitting to your family and work people liking. You need to realise "people like to troll" is a nonsensical garbage Amazon-PR statement, when you've just admitted to what your family and workpeople have admitted to their brains being incapable of processing.

😂😂😂 Right?😂

But that was brilliant compared to how the characters behave and move.

you'd think so

@deusadalua1 Thanks a lot for sharing. i appreciate your idea. But in this video, i mainly focused on the differences between the show and the books. As i said in the video, i agree with some of them, but of course, some of them did nothing for the show, so i pointed them out. But anyway i'm glad that you wrote your opinion. My channel is definitely brand new, and I'm trying to grow it. I would love to have you in my channel.❤️

The show is a contradiction of Tolkien's themes and story. A warped disfigurement rather than adaptation

Thanks a lot Would love to have you with us ❤

More videos like this one will help

@DanielBo1979 yes i agree thanks a lot for supporting my new channel. I would love to have you in my community please subscribe ❤️

My bad I meant show's screen writers

@@JwZ777 And isn't that heartbreaking?🥲

Thank you exactly 👍 It is full of things that if they did from the last season, it wouldn't have been this bad

Not really, the same cringe rubbish, more like a parody of Tolkien than Tolkien.

@bdleo300 yes it's just a little bit of hope sometimes and they don't even give us that🥲😂

Indeed it is horribly, cringingly worse on so many, many levels.

Glad you enjoyed it 😂

Exactly i can't agree more on the "forced" part of your point. Of course, there is nothing wrong with diversity. Actually, it is very well needed, but im sure we both agree they are just doing a poor job in presenting this diversity.

@@CinemaEnigmaa Diversity is needed, of course. But as per what JRR had, casting choices in the show straight away fall under blunder bucket. Diversity or different skin tones need to be part of the story, anything more than that is basically forced.

Yes, l absolutely agree. If you want to make a movie based on a book, the least you can do is respect the writer and their work. But as i said in the video, the book is basically 70 years old, They have to restructure it for modern audiences. And to be honest, i don't think it's a matter of choice anymore.

@@CinemaEnigmaa I disagree. Fans follow the work based on the main literature, screwing it up to match the audience is plain stupid. But anyway, I get what you are saying.

I mean, there is nothing wrong with diversity, but what bothers you is probably the bad execution of diversity representing.

@@CinemaEnigmaa No. In Appendix F of The Return of the King, he explicitly describes Elves as "fair of skin": Elves has been used to translate both Quendi, ‘the speakers’, the High-elven name of all their kind, and Eldar, the name of the Three Kindreds that sought for the Undying Realm and came there at the beginning of Days (save the Sindar only). This old word was indeed the only one available, and was once fitted to apply to such memories of this people as Men preserved, or to the makings of Men’s minds not wholly dissimilar. But it has been diminished, and to many it may now suggest fancies either pretty or silly, as unlike to the Quendi of old as are butterflies to the swift falcon - not that any of the Quendi ever possessed wings of the body, as unnatural to them as to Men. They were a race high and beautiful, the older Children of the world, and among them the Eldar were as kings, who now are gone: the People of the Great Journey, the People of the Stars. They were tall, fair of skin and grey-eyed, though their locks were dark, save in the golden house of Finarfin; and their voices had more melodies than any mortal voice that now is heard. They were valiant, but the history of those that returned to Middle-earth in exile was grievous; and though it was in far-off days crossed by the fate of the Fathers, their fate is not that of Men. Their dominion passed long ago, and they dwell now beyond the circles of the world, and do not return.

Wow, thanks, and yes, you are absolutely right about this. But as i said in the video, the book was written in 1954, and so they have to restructure it for modern audiences. And to be honest, although I totally see your point, but i find it wrong.

@@CinemaEnigmaa PJ did well with his 'adaptation' despite its flaws and differences from the books but he did not 'restructure for modern audiences'. What are you saying?

@goodputin4324 I'm not talking about lord of the rings. I believe Peter Jackson did the right amount of everything. My point is the overdoings we see in rings of power.

@deanog2577 guilty 💀✋️ But seriously, yes! I did make this video to promote my brand new channel ,but when i went deep into it, i realised it does have a lot to talk about. Don't you agree?

@@CinemaEnigmaa Nothing wrong with turning lemons into lemonade.🤣 I subbed

True 😂👍 Very glad that you joined us

@@steppenwolf5956 RIGHT? and it's just heartbreaking