Видео

1) 12 (I just love Capaldi, I like him as a duo with Clara more than 11, I like him with River more than 11, I love Bill) 2) 10 (He has both my least favorite season and my favorite, it averages pretty high) 3) 9 (If he had more stories, he might be higher, but he started the show with a great season) 4) 13 (Her era was fine; I think the negative qualities get overstated. Her seasons were better than seasons 2 and 6 by a mile) 5) 11 (As I have gotten older, I find I like the Moffet era of the show less and less, though I still love Matt Smith) 6) 14 (just due to his short run, I almost considered grouping him with 10) I just recently started catching up after taking a break after 12 left the show, and I just got to 15's first season.

Rory didn't wait 2,000 years. Auton Rory did. A plastic copy that stood in while Rory was spending some time dead again.

Heaven Sent .. That hooded thing endlessly following the Doctor in that shape shifting castle.

Series 12 was not bad 😂

Dude black Doctor sucked ruined Doctor who

I am sorry but not sorry, Ncuti Gatwa is worse than Jodie Whitaker in a lot of ways. The writing for his series is horrible, with quite literally no explanations given for anything besides, oh it just happens. He is too overtly sexual in his performance and The Doctor is not supposed to be sexual. He doesn't care about his companion Ruby because during the entirety of the episode Rouge, he is trying to get with a random bounty hunter, by being super sexual, and is not there to help Ruby when she is in peril. He cries in every scene he is in. The Doctor crying used to be an actual moment, see when Matt Smith's doctor cries for Amy and Rory, now its played as just a quirky thing. For his writing, it is so bad. Only like 2 good episodes of his run and he also got the worst ratings of any season multiple times, including the one that originally got Doctor Who canceled. My personal ranking 11 (From his first episode, he portrays the seriousness, the comical, and the downright zany aspects all perfectly. His theme, I Am The Doctor, is one of the best songs in the entire series. Amy and Rory are wonderful. He just is The Doctor to me. 12 (My personal favorite. He plays The Doctor so well. He has the best relationship with a companion since Rose and 10, this being Clara. One of the best episodes, Heaven Sent, and just overall phenomenal acting) 10 (Almost the pinnacle of Doctor Who, but alas has some really bad moments. I think he honestly could have been #2 but he also flip flops too much in performance. Sometimes he's the best and sometimes he's near the bottom. ) 9 (I really like him, but he just needed more time to work. I think if he got a second season, he could have been top 2) 14 (Semi-good but had a lot of flaws. He didn't have the same spark as 10 did. Maybe if we got more it would have been better, but I also didn't like the writing of his episodes) 13 (Could have been good but the writing suffered horribly. Will also say her season almost ruined Doctor Who with the retcon about The Doctor but that isn't her fault.) 15 (see given)

My Rankings: 1. Twelve (Capaldi is god, Series 8-10 are all superb) 2. Eleven (I love him and the ponds, and Moffat cooked with Series 5) 3. Ten (Series 2 was mid but as you get to the end of his run, from the latter half of Series 3 it just gets phenomenal, leading to Waters of Mars which is my second favourite Doctor Who episode ever, behind only Heaven Sent) 4. Nine (Wish we could've seen more) 5. Thirteen (She was a great Doctor but Chibs and his writing let her down) 6. Fifteen (When given good material (aka Boom) Ncuti shines, but most of his episodes so far have been really mid and we haven't seen much of him yet) 7. Fourteen (As much as I loved Tennant, I really didn't like the idea of a newer doctor being an older doctor)

So honestly I am curious without taking the writing of the episodes into consideration would any of these rankings changed? I ask bc 13s personality is so fun but yeesh her writing

My faves from best to worst are 9, 12, 10, 11. The others don't count because Chinball's timeless child changed who the Doctor was and ruined the show for me.

Thanks for giving Ncuti Gatwa a chance.

This franchise died with Peter Capaldi which was already showing signs that it would be totally bastardized/vandalized into nothing but another boring, plotless DEI Woke-Wank Mob megaphone with the infestation/infection of it by that laughable, grotesque Mary Poppins rip-off version of the Master, "Missy" (gag-a-maggot creature, but she went with the bad writing that increasingly afflicted Peter Capaldi series). But there was far worse yet to come in the form of that clueless, man-hating "boss female" (gender DEI Woke-Wank: ~CHECK!~) "dr who" (lowercase = in name ONLY!) braying that she was an "upgrade" over all the previous male incarnations and now a scaredy-cat, twirling gay (LGBTIQA+ DEI Woke-Wank: ~CHECK!~), black (racerDEI Woke-Wank: ~CHECK!~), crybaby "dr who'", (story all about "the gay", endless DEI messaging, no plot, utter garbage!). Of course the DEI Woke Wank Mob came out in full force with the complete erasure/vandalization of the entire history/cannon of the original series in with The Timeless Children, whose only purpose was to try and "justify" the "appearance" of more "diversity" in a character for whom that would be impossible as "regeneration" under there original cannon was nothing more than cloning of the original Dr. Who (impossible to have all the "diversity" the DEI Woke-Wank Mob envisions for this character in a series where even historical characters like Sir Issac Newton, who was very definitely a white, English male, now portrayed by an Indian actor, but then this group of culture thieves also tried to pretend that Cleopatra was black, when all the evidence shows she was a Macedonian Greek!)

Eccleston will always be #1 of nuwho for me. I’m alot older then many of your watchers, i grew up with watching reruns of classic who, Tom Baker being my favourite of all time. If you told me to close my eyes and imagine Doctor Who and ask me the first Doctor I imagine is, it would be Tom. However i grew up slowly and slowly hating Doctor Who because after school (where i lived in Canada) it was the only thing on for an hour before Star Trek came on tv, and the public access tv station was in love with showing reruns of Colin Baker‘s Doctor series, which i still hate. I didn’t even know there was a 7th doctor until Paul MacGann’s tv movie. So i was done, me and the Doc had parted ways, They stopped showing Baker eps, i had no interest. Then came Eccleston, this leather jacket wearing silly Doctor that was nothing like i had seen before but i could still feeling that mystery Baker’s Doc had…i haven’t missed an episode since.

Graham’s actor was the best part of that series, i will fight you

I'm so happy to see the comment section so... normal 😭 you just see everywhere now people hating on the latest season for probably being too ""woke"" but here even though some comments ranked 15 low they actually were reasonable about it and recognized that there isn't enough yet to fully tell

Three words. Raggedy man, goodbye.

Snowflakes get over yourself we can't change the past we can change the future. Classic BBC fraudsters doing their best to ruin it for others. Yk if they doing it for dirty Huw why didn't they do it when Noel Clarke was being investigated! Oh no they can't because he not one of theirs and there will be huge backlash over the fact nearly very Tennant episode would be missing!!!! BBC wankers

Tosin Cole, who plays ryan in Whittaker's era, Is ironically a rather good actor. just watch him in well, anything else, like Supacell

mine is probably 11,9,13,10,15,14, Its kind of ironic that 10th is so low because Martha is my favourite companion, theres just something with Matt Smith portrayal and the 9th doctors bad wolf storyline

I loved the episode. This video is insightful.

My favourite doctors are Tenant, Smith, Capaldi, and I'm warming up to Ncuti... anything is better after Jody Whitaker's dreadful performance and and horrid writing. Never cared for Eckleston's rendition of the Doctor, the darkness of his character and the writing..

Good video, but you didn't include what I consider the saddest: I won't spoil what actually happens for anyone who has never seen it, so I will just say what happens near the end of Season 4, Episode 9, Forest of the Dead.

You said matt smith was not a good doctor bro the eleventh was the only one that could possibly come after 10. The playful doctor that came when the doctor was getting to dark and he needed a new perspective at life

My ranking of top 3 is just like yours!

I’ve seen a few clips of Matt and David and feel like both of them are great

Oh, people were saying that the Slitheen were too silly _during_ Series 1. A lot of the fandom _loathed_ the Slitheen since like half of their characterization was fart jokes. :P

For me it wasn't the Absorbaloff design at all. It was aggressively _fine._ not awful, not great, just incredibly and intensely okay. (It _was_ yet another "fat evil guy" villain, but you can't blame RTD for this one ar least.) The love stories (both of the budding relationships inside LINDA) were both really cute, all the members were written well. The way Mr. Blue Sky was used was great in just the way you described. Really, everything before the reveal was a great episode. It's just two big things that make me hate it. For one, it was the waste of the LINDA concept as a one-off episode where nearly the entire group got killed. I felt like there was a lot of potential there and they burnt the idea off too fast, and I would've loved to see more. Plus, if you take the interpretation that LINDA was a troll attacking the Doctor Who fanbase, then the episode is basically saying that the troll _wins._ There's only Elton and Ursula's face left, and they've both left the "fandom" because of the troll that went after them. Which is a _weird_ message for that allegory. And for another, it was that absolutely horrid ending. Not Elton's realization, but the literal final scene. Doctor Who existential horror is great, but treating it like a positive thing and then also making a blowjob joke out of it was a total miss for me. It was essentially fridging her for Elton's pain and then going "no it's okay, she can still be a living fleshlight for you" on top of that. If the Doctor had actually saved Ursula as one of the last-second pulls he always manages and she and Elton continued with LINDA in the name and memory of the dead members, it would've been an easy 8-9/10 for me, but I think RTD fumbled the landing just about as much as it's possible to fumble one.

Great video!

More vids with the camera? Or back to the voice overs? Let me know 👌

Pyramids of Mars

Heaven Sent should be there

no midnight...

For me it’d be 12,10,9,14,11,15 (purely due to lack of time seeing him but I think he’s great he needs to stop crying though) then 13 is just a absolute shambles

Hang on! if you're from Cybus Industries that means you work for John Lumic lol

Musk is so incompetent that we don't have to worry about brain implants for a long time. Neuralink is mostly BS. Musk will have been frozen for decades before humanity is able to interface to a brain like the Cybermen can in Who.

I'm glad they didn't bring the Daleks back. I find them way overused and they've lost their impact. Once per Doctor would be more than enough.

Add Midnight to the list, along with Wild Blue Yonder, and probably Under the Lake.

I was watching this at night, and as soon as Blink came up, the light in my room flicked.

Agreed!

Midnight needs to be in here! But scary Who needs to make a comeback in new seasons imo

Love this, Elon Musk maybe won't

Loved making this one 🎉

I love seeing all the 11 love here in the comments. it literally makes my heart ache thinking how we could've gotten so much more of him and clara. matt smith literally said he regrets it. ugh. sobs.

i absolutely loved peter. no other doctor other than 10 is getting close imo.

My Top 3 NuWho Doctors 1. Matt Smith 2. Peter Capaldi 3. Christopher Eccleston

Love all the New Who Doctors, but 11 and 14 are my favourites. Loving Ncuti so far, he could defnitely rank up top if Season 2 and 3 land.

Probably yeah, obviously she's at least controlled freaking self-absorbed. Get out of the 1800 S, lady you are narcissistic.

I didn't like plants at all. I did not trust like them at all. I've gotten invisible, so I've heard. The Doctor the Doctor paid torches. The scratch chatter when you, what the Doctor did to Rose? Very much deserve it

Ok. So... the thumbnail is basically the most extreme clickbait possible for this video.

I could go back and watch Davids seasons to this day. I loved his series. I cried when he said, “ I dont want to go”

Where is Clara? The worst companion in history.