Видео

Callas wins on expression & roundness of the full expression of the voice. But... Tebaldi is wonderful.

Is it possible? I think that is made by Artificial Inteligence! Well, no, I think that even artificial inteligence can not sing as Callas.

he was truly amazing, but to keep that a sharp for all this time is not a good choice. Is far from being musical

This performance is ridiculous.. what a talent!

Великая певица! ❤ И кто сказал, что она стала хуже петь?! Жалко, что так рано ушёл от нас этот бриллиант😢

Tebaldi canta maravillosa Tosca. Callas es Tosca

Sembra abbia 30 anni!!! Vocalità integra dopo quasi 40 anni di carriera!!! FENOMENO

At times a very open sound...so natural...even sounded tenor like.

Fantastic!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ My favorite aria!!! 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

"Comparing me to Renata is like comparing Champaign to... Coca-Cola." - Callas (What a BAR)

Maria callas , unica en la historia de la opera

Y hay quien dice que era solo una Soprano "Lirica".

She wasn't just an opera diva. She was a magnificent actress who brought soul to her characters and broke them out of their classical monotony. For this reason, and for bringing forgotten operatic classics to life, she was revolutionary. When Callas was on stage, she was unmistakable and incomparable.

Tito Gobbi should not have touched this role. This role is for strong bass, not for a light baritone. Gobbi is an actor, but his voice is not for everything. Sorry! I have many strong basses in this role and Gobbi is nothing in comparison. See Mozart's partitura; he says, the role is for bass.

This

O mundo jamais esquecerá Maria Callas!O seu nome ficará na história como a voz que o mundo jamais ouviu nem ouvirá nunca mais❤❤❤❤🇵🇹

La dimostrazione che Gobbi se voleva sapeva cantare ! incredibile

Del Monaco arbeitet, dramatisch ergreifend - Corelli singt, lyrisch göttlich…

Due fenomeni ma la voce di mario del monaco e qual cosa di impressionante

I'm crying.......

Renata Tebaldi singt Tosca, Maria Callas ist Tosca !!!!

♥️🎼🎼

Both are superb sopranos. I adored Tebaldi in Madame Butterfly. See her magnificent acting and Japanese gestures in that white kimono , singing Un Bel Di. It is on You Tube. She looks like a porcelain Japanese doll and sings like an angel with powerful emotion. In the above Tosca comparison, Callas wins.

Epic!!!!❤❤❤

Vissi D'arte just Tebaldi could sing it as god

🎉❤ bravi tutti maestro🎉🎉🎉

Renata is not performing well at 1:53-1:57. Leontyne Price does that nicely. I'm listening to Tebaldi's Si, Mi Chiamano Mimi and I guess if I want to hear A DECENT pianissimo, I better put on Caballe.

I still prefer Corelli

БОЛЬШЕ АРТИСТОВ, ХОРОШИХ И РАЗНЫХ. Я ХОЖУ НА РАЗНЫЕ ИСПОЛНЕНИЯ ОДНОГО И ТОГО ЖЕ СПЕКТАКЛЯ ,С ИСПОЛНИТЕЛЯМИ ДРУГОГО СОСТАВА И СЛОВНО СМОТРИШЬ НОВОЕ ПРОИЗВЕДЕНИЕ!!❤❤ ТРИБАЛЬДИ ХОРОША БЕЗУПРЕЧНЫМ КЛАССИЧЕСКИМ ВОКАЛОМ, КАЛЛАС ЖИВЫМИ ЭМОЦИЯМИ. ОБЕИМ БРАВО!! И СКАРПИА ЗДЕСЬ РАЗНЫЕ . СПОРИТЬ НЕ О ЧЕМ . У КАЖДОГО СВОИ ПЛЮСЫ.

Sooooo.... anyone got any idea why she stabbed that guy in the fourth clip?

Could we have the dstes of these performances, please? 🙏🏻

Praticamente omogeneità di colore e di volume in tutta la gamma vocale. Una magnificenza. Altri grandi bassi non hanno altrettanta caratteristica.

💖💖💖🎉

after listening her singing I become an artist myself and cry my heart out. only regreat is I can not listen any other lady singers other than Maria . what a great lady .

Due mostri sacri! ❤

Those who say that his voice topped out at B-flat are noticeably silent.

С Образцовой лучше сравните :)

No nació ni nacerá otra igual❤

Callas made me shed tears... Tebaldi makes me smile... both human temperaments hard to do... LOVE THEM BOTH!

Thanks for the remastering. Finally in the good pitch!

Mario del monaco tutta la vita e oltre

Para mí gusto el más grande Barítono de todos los tiempos,gracias

Bonjour superbe notre immense beau tenor immortel qui vivait tout ce qu il chantait pour notre grand bonheur bravos au maître et Merci pour la vidéo ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

Grande Mario Del monaco quella de 54 Fanciulla del west e' da brividi

Wonderful. Conductor knows what he's doing. Superb pacing.

Don't forget that we're listening to their voices on youtube. In my opinion, Tebaldi's voice sounded spectacular in a theatre while Callas voice was perfect for recordings... That's the difference and that's why I wouldn't want to hear Callas sing live as I wish I could hear Renata's voice live, which must have been something really special. I heard a story (Bergonzi) about Tebaldi being a superstar while she was still studying in the Conservatory in Parma, way before her debut... when she had her singing lesson all the other students gathered outside the door to hear Tebaldi sing. Maria, on the other hand, is almost like a pop singer to me, her voice can speak to anyone and everywhere. So, if you ask me who do I prefer in this performance of Tosca, we're on youtube so I'd say Callas, but I wish I could hear Renata sing this live.

Del Monaco, of course!

Cesarone e' un ' esperienza mistica.

in my humble opinion, Callas owns this but reading through the comments I decided to listen to Renata Tibaldi's studio recording from 1950. while it is marvelous in its technical quality, it feels melodramatic to a fault. the extension of phrasing makes it feel too much of a spectacle if that makes sense, and it strips it of the emotion and grief. you feel the pain in Callas' voice, the destruction and resolve, the anguish and anger. to me it will always be Callas and then everyone else. the only other that I've come to enjoy is from the incomparable Leontyne Price.

Meraviglioso