Видео

Now I understand why people have been asserting that Beethoven created Boogie Woogie or Rock n Roll. Those genres of music are similar to this. It's somewhat amusing that when I first learned about boogie woogie, I misremembered it as having a pattern which is displayed by this sonata.

WAY too much pedal where NONE is required by the score

Sounds more like Bach. He also used swing rhythms in some of his works.

SER HUMANO EXQUISITO..NOBLE Y EXTRAORDINARY SU SACRIFICIO POR LOS COMPOSITORES..CREADOR INCANSABLE DE AYUDAS Y FUNDAZIONES PARA JOVENES MÚSICOS..SER ÚNICO ...DIOS LO PROTEJA SIEMPRE..

5:41 I like how Pollini lifts/depresses the pedal on the 1/4 notes instead of the bass notes as many pianists do.

I used to play this on my hifi to people and asked them to guess when it was composed. They were astonished when I told them it was in the early 1820s. When I first heard it I burst out laughing!

It’s this kind of stuff that makes those old dead white guys big guns in music. People may hate them but they taped into some amazing stuff.

Atrocious playing , im pretty sure a modern AI would play with more humanistic soul than this.

goes to show white truly invented all music forms. funny how other races try to steal their culture all the time

Who is playing? Andras Schiff? let us know!! From which recording? THX!!

Who listening to this in 2024?

Not only did Beethoven discover an apparent swing rhythm before swing was a thing, but so did Bach. If you look at the second fugue in The Art of Fugue, it’s a rhythm identical to this.

멋져요

baby beethoven 👼🏻🤍

Ludwig Van Gershwin

Interesting interpretation of this piece.

😂 🙌🏻👏👏👏

Beethoven really predicted ragtime in 1822

Amazing.

Auf den Bonner Meister...Ein Wohl 🙏

ignoring the staccatos... why? ignoring dynamics... why?

a mi me suena twist

About 20 years after this in Texarkana, a German piano teacher taught a young boy. ruclips.net/video/BweSQtoc8D0/видео.html

Can’t believe this was “only” 100 years before jazz. Sounds so weird coz I always think that Beethoven came way before

If this were to translate to a boogie woogie context then the 16th note/32nd note pattern would be swapped for a triplet pattern as the swing is too severe.

Superb

rag

I dreamed to have met a guy called "Scott Joplin" in 1902. He played something like this... Weird, isn't it?

This is right up my street ❤

Beethoven invented jazz music

1:30 Beethoven + Jazz

Sounds very Nintendo/Mario Has it ever been featured?

Beethoven: "I guess you guys aren't ready for that yet. But your kids are gonna love it."

Here he was, completely deaf by this time, 100 years before jazz was invented and almost as much before blues, channeling it from above like a true creative master. This section deserves its fame, as it is one of the most visionnary passages of music's history.

It has not so much to do with boogie woogie. The main characteristics of boogie woogie is that is a fast played blues with a repeted swinging ostinato pattern in the left hand. However I do think this piece has some jazzy feeling to it because of the rhythm.

VÁLASZZ

errtzz ttztzz ....

Louisiana Ludwig.

Wish someone had told Beethoven about the swing tempo equation

What was the public’s reaction this this when it was released?

Andras Schiff just despises when people refer to this as boogie woogie. I'm not really sure what to make out of it, other than it's great stuff.

well that got old quick lol

It shows only how popular music has rotten our sense of hearing. A friend of mine who was a gifted pianist, called popular music, bang-bang parking. He even made this kind of music, but never liked it.

Great music is discovered as much as it is invented - especially in the case of Beethoven's approach to composition. It is the humility in the face of the material that makes for true genius. Here he is discovering the special energy of consistent syncopation which is what made boogy woogy popular and appealing a few generations later. There is no issue here except with pianists who will try to break that in the most absurd attempts at following what Beethoven has written but otherwise doing everything they can possibly manage to prevent the full boogy woogy flow the composer has obviously discovered. I have always assumed this to be either snobbery or racism on the part of those pianists who intentionally stiffen up against the flow here

This is why he was a great innovator and bridged the classic and romantic periods of music...As a general rule" purists" are great as a barometer but some need more fiber in their diet so they can feel better ...

I guess it depends on how you hear it. If you listen to this without knowing the piece, it sounds merry and hopeful. But in the context of the thunderous first movement and the Arietta... to me this part sounds desperate, like an outburst of helplessness despite the major key. Beethoven is such a genius, expressing despair in C major.

lmao look at all the salty Beethoven purists down here

Thanks for sharing this! I was dancing in my chair.

A piece of poop written by Ludwig....must have had a bad hairing (pun) day.

bruh y’all need to liszten to contrapunctus 2 by bach