Видео

Thank you ☺️. I'm listening ⬆️🌬️⬆️🙏⬆️🙌🪃 Steven Richard's quantum healing Australia 🦘🌏

27:05 anyone know what systems or IPs he runs? Because... dude does _not_ strike me as one for the Grim Darkness...

I suspect that the location of the museum to Athan Prime, much as with Yorktown Station from Star Trek Beyond, was chosen to avoid accusations of geographic favouritism by non-human member worlds.

Sisko was the best officer but Janeway the best captain. Sisko led a strategically vital post and won a political war. Janeway led her people best.

Only a small percentage of the Royal Navy was engaged in the war of 1812, Its real war was against Napoleon, which was reaching its climax. Only after Napoleon defeat. We’re bigger and more able ships sent across the Atlantic, but again only a few.

PLEASE finish safehold 😢

Gianeto gianeto

So close to being Joe Biden's alma mater if he had actually gotten an appointment to the Naval Academy.

My former supervisor RM2 Jerry B. Farr died on the USS Stark as a result of the attack. He was my supervisor back at NAVCAMS MED at the NATO Base in Naples, Italy. He had a wife and they had just adopted a child not to long before Jerry was stationed on the USS Stark. R.I.P. RM2 Jerry B. Farr 😢 💐

I couldn't watch. You know your stuff, but are in serious need of an editor and a director. 9 or 10 of the first 12 minutes should have been edited out. If you refer to something out of camera view, then the camera needs to swing over to show it. . . . . . I bailed out after 12 minutes, not having seen any of the cemetery. I know you mean well, and a lot went into this video, but it needs to be redone.

Who's the Young, Handsome Man? He's HOT!🔥 🥰😍

What is that book he's holding and keeps referring to?

Interesting fact, while some asset that the Mexican American war was result of Mexican aggression and American blood shed on American soil, a later investigation would show brought by a state representative of Ohio to the military affairs department that not only was the territory in mexico, but Polk assumed powers that he did not have the rights to hold by sending troops to mexico without congress approval, and because of the undisciplined garrison and army on Mexican soil, the event that Polk claimed as hostilities now can be said as commenced were really his attempt to stage a war with Mexico as a victim. Mr Giddings would even go as far as to call for impeachment of Polk and further investigations on the war, with commander Thornton, the general who was on the border would be arrested for provoking a war without consent from congress. I’ll attach the link here pretty interesting to see the assertions are true and that the Mexican American war was really an unjust and unnecessary war provoked by Americans manifest destiny. libraries.uta.edu/usmexicowar/node/5797

Hi I’m from satawal island and I love watching this cause it’s true ❤❤❤thank you ❤

Great vid about a very nice guy who really knows his business and shares with us his masterful knowledge. And he does it with real enthusiasm! Too bad those cadets don't seem to be that excited...personally, i would have attended to this lecture with a smile from ear to ear!

This gives a great lesson about the different size freeboard on the hull of ships.

I was sick when I watched this interesting video over different ships that served in the wars of 1812. We talk about differences between a ocean liner, cruise ship & riverboats this man points out interesting views of different size hull. Thank you for this interesting video of different flag ships.

Captain Paul Rinn was just on another level. He makes the other guy look bad.

Ironic, a panel discussing an untested government approved detonator which failed to work while wearing untested government mandated masks that failed to work.

Pew Pew

I potentially agree with you that the. Starfleet museum should be closer to Earth. But let's get a couple things. Starfleet is Earth's space force. The federation is a Is just that a federation of over a hundred and fifty different species or planets. So my first question, is it a starfleet museum or a federation museum? If it's a federation museum, then the museum should be centered in the middle of the federation, and if Earth is not the middle of the federation being in the alpha quadrant which we know it's not quite the center because there's also the Delta quadrant, the gamma quadrant, and the Beta. Quadrant It may be appropriately placed. Yes, I love the contents in regard to Scifi and fact. And I'm interested in learning more from yourself in this regard.

Is that the real table? I took a tour of the Mighty Mo and they tell a story that the table was mixed up with other tables when it was brought back to the enlisted mess and it might or might not be the table.

Did you enjoy grinding your axe to a nub? Because that's some serious axe-grinding you were doing there.

Yes for day to day long term country policing, the large carriers are the most cost effective. Problem is, in a real shooting war with China, the big carriers would be gone in a a week or forced to be staged too far away to do anything effective.

A good many years ago, I had the good fortune to have dinner with David Weber. I regret to say that I came across as a bit of an idiot. Maybe when you are in the light of someone who has their shit together, one's own failings are more brought to light.

One thing to say, the Starfleet Museum is the former Spacedock One (Earth Spacedock, replaced by Probert Station as shown in Picard).

Why do we as (ex-)military professionals make extensive use of the exaggerations of a poet? Imagine that, a Navy Officer using an Army Operation as a metaphor for a Naval Operation. Did the Sea State at the time of the battle present a similar, if more fluid, situation to the battle of Balaclava or is the metaphor strictly referring to a lightly armed force attacking a more heavily armed force? To my mind the so-called Charge of the Light Brigade is overused in the same way Clausewitz is, distorting important details about the battle in order to make the lecture more "understandable" to a wider, less professional, audience.

Incredible instruction - thank you!

boring

Thanks. I n had the honor of helping design and then making the taffy3 memorial in san di a go. I met a few of the sailors. Hearing from these guys too just reminds me of the dedication loyality they a ll had and how that engagement was so amazing. On paper we woukd have lost. But these men are not paper sailors. Their bodies and souls gave all and the outcome surprised even them. I saw the bond they had w each other and especially to those who didn't make it. Working with them and interacting w them is one of the great points in my life. Regular guys who acted like superman.

Is there a list of the more than 600 factories locations of imperial-munitions-board? Can recall some sites with serviceways around shelburne, queens and lunenburg counties related to bridgeworks and grottos as well as mining works.

Thx for sharing, I have to visit

I clicked on this thinking, "this museum guy's probably gonna use some points about Star Trek that were written down for him." I was wrong. This guy knows his Star Trek. Kudos!

I find it highly offensive that you highlight the USS Texas, the last of the New York class Dreadnought Battleships, a ship that the Navy abandoned.

Hello from Groton Connecticut!

I would think a first piece looked at would be security. That is why ours are in DC as it is one of the most secure places in the country, at least what's considered the government district. Outside of that is a half warzone but in it everything is secure. Now how better to increase that security then but only allowing people to visit it via holodeck? In a holodeck everything is real to the touch smell and other senses after all. The ships would have a actually location as they do to allow their safe protection. Someone pissed at the federation is not going to want to hit a museum who knows how far away from it's center but one right at it's core would be a target. Overall if we had that level of holotech our museums would be very much the same, everything far from actually people touching and yet easily accessibility to everyone. As for the space, yes SpaceDock is a massive space but it itself is also a piece of the museum so I see that as a fitting having so much space. As for the walking issue you would not be as even in current VR I would have to walk all over a museum, I can just see what I want and then go and check out other things later and I think that is what you had missed here. Pick up a VR headset and visit a museum with it and you will see how a holodeck Museum would work somewhat.

The USS Constitution is an odd bird. The ship itself is operated by the US NAVY Ceremonial Guard. The support faculty is run by the Navy Historical And Heritage Command.

You got to think of the Four Founding worlds of the federation. You can't have everything on Earth. Or in the Sol system. They already have Starfleet command the shipyards and etc. If Athan Prime is within the same distance from Vulcan, Andoria, Tellar Prime and Earth it makes more sense

Well while I'll agree with most of your assessment of this video, is 1 major discrepancy. The United States military does display many captured war trophy's in it's military museums. Tanks and Armored Personal Vehicles just to name a few. If the United States Navy would have captured the Bismarck or the Yamato, it's a guarantee those would be on display.

Love this! As someone who volunteers in the independent museum sector I had similar thoughts! The other question I'd have is... why aren't the ships all INSIDE, not only to protect them from radiator and meteors but also just to use the existing berths inside Spacedock?

How about the Barque Eagle? Didn’t we capture that tall ship?

I find the notion of learning about naval museums really cool and hence this was really cool. However.....I couldn't care less if the star trek representation of a naval museum is faithful at all to the real thing.

Its central to many other planets. Do you know how annoying is to go to the Smithsonian? Its so far!!! Its illogical. The station is most likely a retired space station, they dont have to show you everything just to satisfy your curiosity, it's probably a hotel too, Athan Prime is probably footing up the bill to maintain the museum because...they want to, the klingons don't care about ancient ships and most likely they okay it, the cloaking device is there for story purposes, Geordi runs the museum as part of the deal with Athan Prime, LaForge is playing it safe and is just coasting retirement because of his two daughters, at least one is close by.

Thanks for this video! It is refreshing to hear a first-hand experienced voice critique these details that I don't think we, let alone the writers, think through enough.

I find your assessment very informative. However you overlooked one very important thing about the placement of the fleet museum. And that is plot armor. You can't have a fleet Museum where you're going to go get the ship that's going to rescue the Galaxy close to the point in space that being invaded or all shot up. And given how long it didn't take them to get to the fleet Museum I would guess it's not that far away from the Terran system

The Klingons ship are likely trophies claimed by the UFP while the Romulan ship is still there since the Romulan government has collapsed and no one is around to say that the Federation can’t have it in a museum.

I need point out that Starfleet didn't have problem with resources. With replicator tech that is most likely not a issue. But active shipyards probably did have limit on how many ships they could made, in relatively short time frame. Especially as it seems that many shipyards were closed after 23'th century. Still I would say largest bottleneck of Starfleet was the personel. It is why over time ships were heavily automated.

I really appreciate the in-universe canonical attempt to rationalize what was clearly meant to be an (almost?) over-the-top fan servicey moment. I know I couldn't stop grinning at seeing a true to form, faithful, 100% canonically accurate TOS Connie (USS New Jersey, NCC-1975). I wonder if you'll do a followup video about how utterly ridiculous the "resurrection" of the D was. I can't imagine that's how it works IRL.

Thinking about this, while they call it the museum, it may just be the nickname, it is really more of a drydock. All the ships are functional so I can see them being lent out on tours, With replicators, maintaining the ships would be easier. They seem to use canned life support so you can fill the ship with inert gas when not in use. As for no one there, the major fleet day was taking place. Since the changelings were pulling strings, they would have not wanted the old ships around so did not request them. Star Trek also seems to keep people in grade longer with much longer tours. This may be due to humans living longer on average than now.

I suspect the "Fleet Museum" may have been a fan-service kiss, giving us something back to the 1970s fan-generated space docks, space stations, and starbases that contained ships and large grassy promenades. It's incredible and humbling the level of detsil fans and aircraft engineers put into Star Trek "engineering and history" in print. Thus, the Cygnus website is always a heartwarming site to visit. When I was aboard the USS FLINT (AE-32) from Jann85 to March 86, several of the GMGs, BMs, and others played the FASA Star Trek games, using die and deck drawings. I can still hear them rolling hex die, consulting a cheat sheet of damage and regenerations and what not in the Ship's Library (a MT 53 SHIPALT'd into the library...). I didn't play, but I did buy the game sets for the alternative and supplementary view of the Federation, Klingon, and Romulan Star Empire ships. But, I also drew my interpretation of USN SSNs and SSBNs to enough detail (in 1982 a 7-bladed propeller on one of my SSBNs with realistic take, skew, and pitch) that torqued him pretty badly (he yelled at me and declared they blade I drew represented USN Top Secret information. Well, after I saw the cover picture, I immediately hated my earlier props. So, I cut an aluminum beer can and tested 2-10 bladed props cut and shaped, and placed arop a Bic pen. The 7-bladed when blown down on lififted so fast it cut my face. So, heart warmed, I picked it, lol). I otherwise only took cues from the cover of a USNIP Issue showing a tarp-covered JMSDF or European navy diesel sub sporting a 7-bladed prop. It was an article on how Toshiba compromising the USN's ability to reliably track then-Soviet subs. As for the Federation museum, Geordi could not run that facility alone, so, it's lamentable that STP didn't show any digital crew, docents, and security. Perhaps even midshipman and special contractors theoretically would visit and spend 2 to 6 week stints there for officer and contract repair quals, like SIMA/NAVELEX/MOTU/MTT/AIMD, etc?