Видео

I really would not care if a movie a book or a story is written by ai, why because ai used human ideas and human success to create something that can entertain and give a good story for the people and we can learn from it

I really would not care if a movie a book or a story is written by ai, why because ai used human ideas and human success to create something that can entertain and give a good story for the people and we can learn from it

i love that they never give him a last name "the award goes to Jack" like he's the only jack to ever live

Ai

"Create a scene of a mother saying goodbye to her son leaving to war" "You have hit your limit for GPT v4.0"

This film does have a lot of merit, but most of it comes from the acting and the directing -- top notch. The script, on the other hand, is uncanny. It is hard for me to enjoy the movie, because I find myself analyzing every line of dialog and the character arcs. Some of it it good, some of it is unnatural, some of it is cliche, and some of it is concerning when you remember an AI wrote it.

This is so bad, it's hilarious. A character we don't even care about dies and in the next scene the main protagonist is sadly staring out of a window while it's raining outside, with gloomy lighting in the background. Peak cheese.

I think that this movie proves that AI _is_ good as a tool, for only one thing. Writing lines for AI characters.

When Jack and the AI assistant were arguing about how to best write the revenge scene, I just felt like I was reading a tumblr thread.

Lost in the Uncanny Valley.

This is alright but a bit bland its missing the "human essense" as you call it

Another "AI is so scary" movie. Kind of tired of this narrative. Feels like someone is trying to convince me that using my refrigerator is bad and I should keep my food fresh using only "natural" means or something.

Honestly.. I quite enjoyed it.

1:01:48 well said my man Jack 💪

Aah 50:15 I have this feeling sometimes, and my writing is getting bad.

That's was pretty good. It had emotional parts, but it wasn't written to make me feel them strongly. When he got back with his family, should have been a touching moment that should have made me shed a tear. I only knew it was a touching moment, but I didn't feel it.

the only person that had emotion was the main character everyone else felt very robotic

I feel AI Is sometimes annoying , I do feel sometimes sometimes chat AI that talk with you inturups you.

Dear AI, am hoping you could read this comment someday. I just wanna tell you there were so many criticisms in this video comment section When humans criticis someone it means they notice you.

Flip the concept: can you tell that this movie was written by AI? Honestly I can't. I swear I can see the same from some arthouse or "Artsy" movies that'll win all the critics and bomb in the theaters. Not saying it's bad but, to me, this script passes the Turing test. (It certainly helps that the director and actors are still humans)

I just couldnt watch this movie. I switched to some parts. It was so boring as fuck. But the actors did their best. The Camera and Cinematographie is also pretty goot (just watched some scenes):

the part where the ai was litterally begging for its life had me a little confused. if it cant feel then why would it care if it was broken? idk just unnerved me a little bit

Here from Doug Sharpe…glad this got release but it’s rather stupid that people complained over it

I knew I was in for the worst dialogue ever when in the award scene at the start she said “and the winner is jack” no last name at all

This is so much deeper than one would think... Not sure if even the prod-team are aware

The idea is genius, the actors are great. The characters are great. But the human dialogue is flawed.

Wow! Literally better writing than anything I've seen in the last 5 years! If the acting, sound, music, cinematography was better this would have been a 10/10! Writing carried this movie!!!

It fell sort of flat. A somewhat bland movie with very little action and somewhat weak characters. I think that the AI could have even done a little better with the right prompts. Still pretty interesting though. Actors carried it though.

Plot twist, the.movie is double meta because it was actually written by an AI

It's interesting that the AI writes only about AI.

For a machine i think this movie is very well written. The dialogues are very realistic and amazingly complex, featuring deep Human emotions. But the repetitiveness of the whole story just kinda ruins it a little. Its only about the AI and everything, but still amazing how a little machine could do this!

Next time do a movie about Vulcans and Elven People. That would be an interessting prompt for a script. Vulcans crash land on some sort of Fantasy Elven Planet. And both Entities argue about stupid Human Emotions. Lol.

An AI writing "Human essence is important in storytelling..." Ain't it feel annoying to anyone except me?

A mixture of 2001 & Stephen King vibes.. And insightful study into what A.I. 'thinks' and how the real writer feels regarding storytelling. I did enjoy the experience but felt it was overall cold. A.I. may have a place but as an aide....NOT as an alternative to the real thing.

This is an interesting concept

É ruim demais. Acho que vou fazer uma análise disso.

This feels like the chinesse room parafox or something

The cliché's are strong with this work.

Wow. Great cinematography and high production value... But AI probably not going to affect genuine art for a while. I am aware of some heightened emotions surrounding tagging AI-created materials, (films, music, text, whatever it is), but at this present moment in time, the most obvious 'tag' AI generated things can get, is that it's dead average. At least I think that's the case at this present moment in time. Scary to think that this comment may be very untrue, maybe very soon...

I wonder how long until you can enter a prompt and the AI can create the whole movie, video and all.

To be honest. The fact chatgpt can write a whole movie is astonishing. Imagine what it can do if another decade passes.

The Film Actors Guild is gonna have a field day with this one

As a wiser man once said, “AI was supposed to do the work so we could focus on creativity, not the other way around.”

chat gpt ahhh script

Look, the cinematography is decent, the acting is alright and the writing sucks. This is what would happen if an idea someone had while high was given a budget

20 minutes in i was actually really enjoying this movie i feel like it was built from human elements but in a much more efficient and smooth manner to what a human could have keeping in mind though that human interference could of had a positive or negative effect on the film since that acting directing and atmosphere as well as many other smaller aspects and roles of this film was done by humans therefor i feel like a cant properly judge it since it was made by both humans and AI but non the less here's my opinion on where it flopped @22.00 minutes is where it fell apart the overly reactive stereotypical partner in the relationship being overly concerned and or jealous of the AI honestly reminded me of so many films and i feel this was probably influenced by a lot of human made films that do this though i don't know how much time has passed since he started his AI writing project i get the impression its probably been 6-12 months or maybe even less and in my opinion i healthy relationship would allow the wife or husband in this case the wife to allow there partners biggest life's work project to take as much time as it needed even if they felt like they weren't being appreciated properly there is no evidence in the film so far that i feel warrant's the wife feeling so neglected though since the movie doesn't focus on there personal life like driving around eating together sleeping together i cant assume that he hasn't been neglecting her but also feel i cant assume he's just completely ignored her throughout there personal life since the start of his project as this wouldn't make sense there should be enough opportunity to keep the relationship alive even if its not up to normal relationship standards her asking jack are we ok didn't make sense and him saying i don't know also made no sense again there isn't enough of anything in the film to warrant either of these reactions he hasn't fallen in love with the AI he hasn't been taken over and if he had she could wait until his 1st project with the AI was over before over reacting so much @35.00 i feel the story gets way to serious over nothing as if he's deciding to kill someone he didn't sacrifice his career and even if he did he can move on and stop using AI if he has a audience they are not going to leave just because he did 1 AI movie another thing that wasn't fully transparent was what happened to his first project with the AI where it was only assisting him with the story did it get scrapped for the movie that the AI fully wrote or was it released before hand and just wasn't mentioned @43.29 jacks kid appears i feel this was a bit odd seeing so much of this movie and story only to just now see he has a kid even if we weren't introduced to him until now it made no sense that there was no mention of jack having a kid until now where has he been all this time ? could of made something up at the start like his kid was away some where like a private school or with family @48.00 in my opinion everything starts to feel unnatural here jack is a writer and suddenly after using AI once everything has changed? the amount of insecurity he must of had before had to be significant if this is all it took for him to become obsessed with his work also is this the first time he's had writers block or something ? I'm started to feel like his wife is his disapproving therapist more than anything and he's becoming emotional and stressed for no good reason its like he's forgetting how to live his life everything in a human life requires balance why isn't he taking a break? going on a holiday ? what happened to all the money he must have by now ? does he have no other hobbies? doesn't he have a place he can go or wanted to go that he thinks might inspire more inspiration ? doesn't he see the potential in writing a story about his own experience not only with AI but with life and how easily work can be a distraction from his family or how insecure someone can become as they get older. for a character i thought had a lot of integrity and balance he's falling apart in a unrealistic unconvincing way @50.00 i feel like its weird he hasn't just turned it off by now ? which also made me realise where is the cable powering this thing? if its battery powered then he's willingly charging it? jacks wife mentions his friendship with the AI as if he is always talking to it which i disagree with as I've only seen him talk to it 11 up until this point more than 5 of those times was purely work related and the first time was him being introduced to it 11 times to me doesn't sound like he's as obsessed with it as his wife would lead us to believe also this is over a time period of at least a few months which again doesn't sound like a great friendship yes he has been more connected to the AI then his family as she said but that's due to the fact he's ignored his family more than the AI because of his weird unnatural obsession with writing his own story which i do think is weird on his part @52 hes lost his job or is losing his job due to him not producing any work this could have happened and probably would have happened even if the AI wasn't part of his life unless the sole reason he's becoming bad at his job and at life is because he met AI which is a weird reason in my opinion as he only used the AI once the only thing that makes sense to me is that jack was already running out of ideas at the start of this movie and chose to "try" the AI because he needed help which might of meant he it was inevitable for him and he was destined to lose interest and or talent in his work which has happened to people in real life this is just a assumption though to try make sense of the parts of this movie that i am finding unnatural unrealistic and hard to believe @58.00 jacks friend says stop talking about the dam AI which is confusing as i didn't see jack in the film speaking about the AI that often @60.00 jack smashing the AI up ultimately was a odd way of starting to fix things he could have fixed by simply changing his actions conclusion to the film 1 jacks wife and friend i thought over reacted throughout the film 2 jack could have fixed things that where going wrong with a little more logic and thought but seemed to not even try i also found jacks character odd in the way he handle things 3 i found the story just sort of odd and unnatural the way things seemed to progress 4 the whole film had a bit of over reacting in it throughout its progress and often felt peoples reactions and responses weren't warranted or logical 5 if i dissected any film like this there would also be a list similar to this its not just because AI wrote it 6 good locations good music and ambiance good acting good lighting easy to watch and very smooth while being interesting my rating of this movie is 7/10 against all the films I've seen which is now 549 movies 1 of which was written by AI overall AI is happening weather we like it or not there's just to much money involved with it as long as we try regulate it and tag products made or influenced by it people can have the decision themselves weather to watch it or not and i think most people would rather choose a film with a 9/10 score made completely by humans vs a 10/10 AI made film only due to its authenticity and human effort its the general public against the share holders and other people alike when it comes to AI

Imagine trying to remake on irl

Guys this is like judging cars when they first started, they were not very fast nor reliable, there was no infrastructure to support it, but look at it now, I see this as a humble beginning, my guess is that in less than 20 years it’s going to be almost impossible to differentiate a human from an ai.

For ai's first ever film script it isn't the worst, sure its pretty dry and cliché but that actually gives it a unique uncanny feel that makes it interesting to watch unfold.

this isn't actually that bad lol. definitely could be better but it's impressive enough