Dr Blunt
Dr Blunt
  • Видео 57
  • Просмотров 50 478
The Ethics of War: Are Nuclear Weapons Immoral? 4K
Since the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki there has been a deep debate about whether it can ever be ethical to use nuclear weapons. This video will look at the debate in the context of jus in bello.
Inside track: I had pneumonia while recording this!
Chapters:
0:00 - 0:50: Proportionality and intrinsically immoral weapons
0:50 - 2:17: The Consequentialism and Deterrence
2:17 - 5:27: The Supreme Emergency Exemption
5:27 - 8:31: Hiroshima Reconsidered
Просмотров: 150

Видео

The Ethics of War: Is it ever permissible to harm civilians?
Просмотров 2102 месяца назад
In this video made with the University of Sydney we look at one of the most tortured elements of the ethics of war: its effect on civilians. There is a longstanding tradition that one cannot deliberately target civilians but in an age of total war civilians are more and more in the line of fire. Chapters 0:00 - 1:34: Jus in Bello, Justice in War 1:35 - 3:53: Jus in Bello, history and practice 3...
The Ethics of Resistance: Fidelity to the Law
Просмотров 4162 месяца назад
If you break the law out of principle should you have to go to jail? That is the question for this final video in the lecture on the ethics of resistance. Chapters: 0:00 - 1:16: The problem of civil disobedience in liberal democracies 1:16 - 2:49: Civil Disobedience as Communication 2:49 - 4:10: Should you accept punishment for protest? 4:10 - 5:28: Problems with the Fidelity to the Law Princip...
The Ethics of Resistance: What is Resistance?
Просмотров 1022 месяца назад
In the second part of this lecture I talk about the nature of resistance and how it can sometimes comes from unexpected sources. And yes, I talk about rap music... Chapters: 0:00 - 1:18: Resistance and Politics 1:19 - 3:33: Resistance and Infrapolitics 3:34 - 5:00: Impure and Offensive Resistance 5:00 - 5:58: Resistance as Extraordinary Politics
The Ethics of Resistance: Should we Obey the State?
Просмотров 1273 месяца назад
In this three part lecture for the University of Sydney I explore the ethics of resistance. We begin by looking at the controversial actions of Just Stop Oil and explore whether we have an obligation to obey the state. Chapters: 0:00 - 1:15: Politics isn't working, what is to be done? 1:15 - 3:58: Just Stop Oil: Jackasses or Principled? 3:58 - 5:08: The Problem of Injustice 5:08 - 8:04: The Dut...
Conspiracy and Democracy IV: The Case for Democracy
Просмотров 1639 месяцев назад
Conspiracy and Democracy IV: The Case for Democracy
Conspiracy and Democracy III: The Case against Democracy
Просмотров 44010 месяцев назад
Conspiracy and Democracy III: The Case against Democracy
Conspiracy and Democracy II: Is Conspiracy Thought Bad for Democracy?
Просмотров 69610 месяцев назад
Conspiracy and Democracy II: Is Conspiracy Thought Bad for Democracy?
Conspiracy and Democracy I: What is a Conspiracy Theory? What is Conspiracy Mentality?
Просмотров 70211 месяцев назад
Conspiracy and Democracy I: What is a Conspiracy Theory? What is Conspiracy Mentality?
Republicanism, Explained: Republicanism vs Monarchy?
Просмотров 574Год назад
Republicanism, Explained: Republicanism vs Monarchy?
Republicanism, Explained: The Value of Liberty
Просмотров 1,3 тыс.Год назад
Republicanism, Explained: The Value of Liberty
Republicanism, Explained: A Third Concept of Liberty
Просмотров 2,2 тыс.Год назад
Republicanism, Explained: A Third Concept of Liberty
Republicanism, Explained: Two Concepts of Liberty
Просмотров 2,4 тыс.Год назад
Republicanism, Explained: Two Concepts of Liberty
Thought Experiment! The Gentle Giant (or Can you be Free in a World with Superman?)
Просмотров 399Год назад
Thought Experiment! The Gentle Giant (or Can you be Free in a World with Superman?)
Thought Experiment! The Ring of Gyges (or the Ethics of Super Powers)
Просмотров 3,2 тыс.Год назад
Thought Experiment! The Ring of Gyges (or the Ethics of Super Powers)
Thought Experiment! Does Saving a Drowning Child Mean You Have to Give Away All Your Money?
Просмотров 2,4 тыс.Год назад
Thought Experiment! Does Saving a Drowning Child Mean You Have to Give Away All Your Money?
What do We Owe People Resisting Injustice? On the Ethics of Resistance and Assistance
Просмотров 319Год назад
What do We Owe People Resisting Injustice? On the Ethics of Resistance and Assistance
Is it Permissible to Harm an Innocent Person? On Violent Resistance to Global Poverty
Просмотров 2,1 тыс.Год назад
Is it Permissible to Harm an Innocent Person? On Violent Resistance to Global Poverty
Gates Foundation, Global Health, and Domination
Просмотров 487Год назад
Gates Foundation, Global Health, and Domination
Redistributive Wars: Reasonable Chance of Success, Proportionality, and Final Thoughts.
Просмотров 177Год назад
Redistributive Wars: Reasonable Chance of Success, Proportionality, and Final Thoughts.
Redistributive Wars: Can Unjust States Fight Just Wars? Do Just Wars have to be the Last Resort?
Просмотров 122Год назад
Redistributive Wars: Can Unjust States Fight Just Wars? Do Just Wars have to be the Last Resort?
Redistributive War: Do Just War Require Right Intentions?
Просмотров 1612 года назад
Redistributive War: Do Just War Require Right Intentions?
Redistributive War: Is Global Poverty a Just Cause for War?
Просмотров 2,6 тыс.2 года назад
Redistributive War: Is Global Poverty a Just Cause for War?
Can Global Social Movements Produce Solidarity Across Borders?
Просмотров 3002 года назад
Can Global Social Movements Produce Solidarity Across Borders?
What if Theories of Justice Can’t Motivate Action?
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.2 года назад
What if Theories of Justice Can’t Motivate Action?
What is Violence? & Why Does It Matter?
Просмотров 6372 года назад
What is Violence? & Why Does It Matter?
What is Civil Resistance?
Просмотров 8662 года назад
What is Civil Resistance?
Is Illegal Immigration Wrong?
Просмотров 6492 года назад
Is Illegal Immigration Wrong?
What is Poverty? and Why Should We Care?
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.2 года назад
What is Poverty? and Why Should We Care?
Is Global Poverty a Crime Against Humanity? Part II: Poverty, Slavery, & Apartheid
Просмотров 4 тыс.2 года назад
Is Global Poverty a Crime Against Humanity? Part II: Poverty, Slavery, & Apartheid

Комментарии

  • @Rotebuehl1
    @Rotebuehl1 День назад

    Back then parliament had ab-so-lu-te-ly-no-thing-to-do-with-"the"-"people"! That's a modern lore!

  • @TheNationalConservative
    @TheNationalConservative 3 дня назад

    I think.a limited democracy is preferable

  • @josephgoldman2481
    @josephgoldman2481 Месяц назад

    Sarah Zoabi: Proud Muslim Zionist ruclips.net/video/yTh4ReWk_jY/видео.html

  • @josephgoldman2481
    @josephgoldman2481 Месяц назад

    Please direct me to your comments on hiding behind civilians while keeping kidnapped civilians in tunnels in Gaza

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 29 дней назад

      I’m going to assume this is a good faith challenge and not at shitpost. Here’s my take: The conflict in Palestine is an obvious ethical morass but the implicit claim in your comment is that Hamas is justified in a human shield strategy (or rather that I would think so). I don’t think so. And that is because there is a clear and obvious duty to minimise harm to non-combatants even in instances where it puts combatants at greater risk. Waiving principles of non-combatant immunity is an incredibly high bar and it is unclear that this conflict meets it. This duty also attaches to Israel. As I mention at the end of the video there is a principle of double intention that needs to be followed in war and it applies universally.

  • @jimmyjohnson1870
    @jimmyjohnson1870 Месяц назад

    I don't know how I feel about Just Stop Oil. On one hand, I wish they didn't ruin that painting. That was really mean. On the other, I can't help but feel how insignificant the loss must be, compared with the destruction of entire cities and nations, such as Venice and Tuvalu. How much art and culture would be lost if flooding in the Basilica di San Marino, not to mention the museums of Venice, fell into disrepair, or once, not if, the people of Tuvalu are scattered? I guess I would object to their actions on the grounds of how much they've really accomplished. I think that they could be using their time better, maybe through guerilla gardening or obstructing construction vehicles and oil tankers specifically, to slow specifc destructive projects. To me, Just Stop Oil is as effectual as an awareness campaign, but as obnoxious as direct action, and that they should just commit to direct action. Edit: They didn't even ruin the painting. I should've watched ahead.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 29 дней назад

      Thanks for your comment! I had the same reaction when I saw the first protest. I was fuming but it got me thinking. However there is certainly an issue with people getting so angry they don’t pay attention to the message. What’s the point if your actions only alienate?

    • @jimmyjohnson1870
      @jimmyjohnson1870 29 дней назад

      @@drblunt So true! I'd definitely be more inclined to that latter viewpoint. Then again, who am I to judge their acts of protest and resistance when I do so little to help myself? Maybe while I complain about their actions, I should consider how I can resist, and thereby put some weight behind my words. Perhaps all this concern about the failings of others should be paired by actively demonstrating my viewpoint's superiority. Not accepting the failures of others as an inevitability but also doing better wherever I can. I don't know. Btw, your videos are really interesting. I've been binge watching them over the past couple days. Thank you so much.

  • @jimmyjohnson1870
    @jimmyjohnson1870 Месяц назад

    I love this idea of the law having to prove it's worth to the public, rather than demanding submission as an inherent obligation. I believe that all laws and all institutions should should serve the greatest share of humanity possible, to the greatest extent possible, and if they fail to do so they should either be reformed or abolished. Respect those not mean an unquestioned subordinance to authority, but mutual respect between people and customs which serve a positive purpose.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 27 дней назад

      Indeed, lots of people conflate what 'is' with what 'ought to be'. The simple fact of a law does not make it worthy of respect. It is in how it is made and how it effects people that determines its value.

  • @TheNewYear75
    @TheNewYear75 Месяц назад

    great video! I appreciate this and your clear breakdown of arguments justifying war.

    • @TheNewYear75
      @TheNewYear75 Месяц назад

      i do think it could benefit from on screen titles and writing out concept/key terms on-screen.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt Месяц назад

      Thanks! Glad you liked the video and I’ll take effort to get some more titles for the next run of videos!

    • @TheNewYear75
      @TheNewYear75 Месяц назад

      @@drblunt ❤

  • @dennis2376
    @dennis2376 Месяц назад

    Murder and killing are different motives. I wonder how an A.I. war would classified or the use A.I. war robots? Thank you.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt Месяц назад

      Very true. AI is going to present some serious problems in the ethics of war. In the one hand it could be used to limit battlefield casualties by being coded against killing non-combatants. On the other it it could automatically cause escalation if certain boxes get ticked. I might do a video because there is a lot to unpack including who would be ethically responsible for AI weapons. Thanks for asking and for watching!

  • @hoffy1955
    @hoffy1955 Месяц назад

    “He who joyfully marches to music in rank and file has already earned my contempt. He has been given a large brain by mistake, since for him the spinal cord would fully suffice. This disgrace to civilization should be done away with at once. Heroism at command, senseless brutality, deplorable love-of-country stance, how violently I hate all this, how despicable and ignoble war is; I would rather be torn to shreds than be a part of so base an action! It is my conviction that killing under the cloak of war is nothing but an act of murder.” ~Albert Einstein

  • @michaeldunn8972
    @michaeldunn8972 2 месяца назад

    Law is deadly force it is up to the individual to carry their cross and decide how far they are willing to go. BOOM!

  • @pieterwillembotha6719
    @pieterwillembotha6719 2 месяца назад

    all's fair in love and war

  • @JobAur
    @JobAur 2 месяца назад

    Dr Blunt always keeps it real

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 2 месяца назад

      Always fam

  • @Cyborg_queen
    @Cyborg_queen 3 месяца назад

    I love being a republican!

  • @DanFradenburgh
    @DanFradenburgh 3 месяца назад

    Boris Johnson but with a conscience? That's like saying an astronaut that doesn't go into space!

  • @TheNewYear75
    @TheNewYear75 3 месяца назад

    can't wait to watch this

  • @camilapaz3829
    @camilapaz3829 4 месяца назад

    Hi Dr Blunt. Thank you so much for explaining this subject. I'm studying Political Theory and I still don't fully understand the relationship between positive freedom and totalitarianism and/or similar regimes. I think I got confused when I read the sections about "status" and "Sarastro's temple"

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 3 месяца назад

      Hi, thanks for watching. I’ll be posting up some new content soon and will try to do a quick video to answer your questions. Sorry for taking so long answering!

  • @kenmcrae8591
    @kenmcrae8591 4 месяца назад

    The government dictators imposed a jab mandate upon us, thereby violating our freedom of choice. Refusing it was unacceptable to them, and punished. Communism cloaked beneath an external facade of "democracy".

  • @EMlNENCJA
    @EMlNENCJA 4 месяца назад

    It is one of those things that make up deciding factors within the equation determining whether particular persons life is even worth living.

  • @fifacentral6628
    @fifacentral6628 5 месяцев назад

    I am so happy that I stumbled across this channel! Funny and smart host, and also a great communicator. Thank you for making these videos on Republicanism.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 3 месяца назад

      Thanks so much! New content is coming this weekend. Hope you tune in!

  • @dco8562
    @dco8562 5 месяцев назад

    Hmmmmm... Anti-Masonic, anti-Catholic, anti-"international banker", and anti-communist conspiracies u say ..? Ya all four of those groups like to make the paranoia accusation huh.

  • @marcosnobuhara1126
    @marcosnobuhara1126 5 месяцев назад

    I really like your videos. And I became interested in republicanism. However, it seems to me that it contradicts itself at a specific point. From what I understand, democracy can only be maintained if there is a network of shared beliefs and non-interference from arbitrary power. However, how to establish this network of belief? Who will establish which are the best beliefs to be shared? Doesn't this necessarily have to be an imposition? Going deeper, doesn't the government impose its will on citizens from school? Don't parents also impose their will? I know the word of the day is "responsibility," the government and parents can't do as they please. Because if they do, they will be punished, but who chose this punishment? And this only works if the system discovers these infractions...

  • @dylanhudec979
    @dylanhudec979 6 месяцев назад

    It would make sense if it was Homelander

  • @CCLilja
    @CCLilja 6 месяцев назад

    Republicanism seems a bit flawed. A part from non domination - the arbitrary power of someone else - it hasn't got any intrinsic values. I'd say that the Libertarian Left, with Hillel Steiner, is more to my liking. Better both. In juxtaposition. Like Thomas Paine.

  • @CCLilja
    @CCLilja 6 месяцев назад

    Parliamentarian democracies, such as my native Sweden, don't have checks and balances. Hence the parliament reigns supreme. It sucks.

  • @sahanglp3i-271
    @sahanglp3i-271 6 месяцев назад

    Because global poverty is "designed" so the MNCs and Rich Countries can benefit from the poor as their global market. I can't blame the MNCs and Rich Countries to do so, because they are opportunistic. My question is, can you make a book that outcrop the ways, how is a poor country can become a Rich Country or escape poverty? We knew that Singapore was poor back then, but now it is become a Rich Country in southeast Asia. I belief if you write that book, your book will become the standard manual book for many countries and societies to escape poverty. I belief the richer the poor countries can lead to the richer the MNCs and existing Rich Countries.

  • @TheNewYear75
    @TheNewYear75 7 месяцев назад

    woah just found your channel, AMAZING thoughts.

  • @greglamothe5942
    @greglamothe5942 7 месяцев назад

    Complete nonsense

  • @daringarner3306
    @daringarner3306 8 месяцев назад

    Promo*SM 😴

  • @westrnite
    @westrnite 8 месяцев назад

    Did you mean federal districts? What about 2 tiered justice system? What about globalist agenda 2030,WEF? Dude you live in a nice protected bubble.

  • @homosexualbiologicalmale--3
    @homosexualbiologicalmale--3 8 месяцев назад

    democracy dont seem to accept personal decision , democracy utilise popularity to decide for someone else and that nazi

  • @Coraxiom
    @Coraxiom 8 месяцев назад

    "Conspiracy Theorist" is a pejorative term used for discrediting criticism and avoiding criminal liability.

  • @fernandoa518
    @fernandoa518 8 месяцев назад

    Conspiracies do not exist. Therefore, everyone convicted by the courts of conspiracy has been a victim of a miscarriage of justice.

  • @JordanScottMills
    @JordanScottMills 8 месяцев назад

    It's almost like we all realize something isn't right, but dunno what to do about it

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 8 месяцев назад

      Good point, conspiracy theories often seem like distractions from actual and very daunting social problems.

  • @marcosnobuhara1126
    @marcosnobuhara1126 8 месяцев назад

    4:39 omg so funny

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 8 месяцев назад

      Living out my secret dream of being a comedian instead of an academic.

  • @cornbreadjenkins2494
    @cornbreadjenkins2494 9 месяцев назад

    You are mush, you make me sick.

  • @AJ-di4df
    @AJ-di4df 9 месяцев назад

    We aren’t a democracy we’re a republic Dr.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      You want to talk republicanism and democracy? Stay tuned.

  • @finnredmond3192
    @finnredmond3192 9 месяцев назад

    Conspiracy theories because of all the conspiracies. Democrats against democracy. Good man

  • @bottomline3669
    @bottomline3669 9 месяцев назад

    "What is a conspiracy theory ?" For real ? We are still stuck at that ? Let's see how hard it is to 'define' "conspiracy theory". Conspiracy theory. Conspiracy theory.... It's a theory about a possible/potential conspiracy. Theories are helpful in science because they help find answers. There we go. That was fucking easy.

  • @mykegoh
    @mykegoh 9 месяцев назад

    Yeah.. Like US government planting CIA and FBI in social media platforms. What do u call that?

  • @Anton.Realtor
    @Anton.Realtor 9 месяцев назад

    who starts a sentence with "however"?

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      Someone whose spliced this out of longer content

  • @peterfraser1152
    @peterfraser1152 9 месяцев назад

    Virtually all politicians and media have never had a proper job but insist on foisting their views on grateful Western populations. It's called kakistocracy and we see the collapse of Western countries thanks to these people.

  • @raymondB-f4p
    @raymondB-f4p 9 месяцев назад

    There is no democracy 😂😂😂

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      It’s pretty feeble.

  • @nellymanson
    @nellymanson 9 месяцев назад

    Talking about " conspiracy theories" then quotes the actual conspiracy theory that the capital was " attacked" , it also seems like people in every country apart from America knows that Bidens win was dodgy AF! Now there is a conspiracy to stop Trump running for the office, an actual conspiracy.

  • @meeksde
    @meeksde 9 месяцев назад

    Joe Biden couldn’t steal a passing grade in college without getting caught.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      Just so, but a large number of people think he stole that election (without proof)

  • @joshb7415
    @joshb7415 9 месяцев назад

    The truth always shines through in a democratic system, in authoritarian systems the truth is punished.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      I hope you are right but without strong civic culture democracies can descend into delusion.

  • @mightychondriaofthecell3317
    @mightychondriaofthecell3317 9 месяцев назад

    If only algorithms, viruses, and hacking couldn't make all this go horribly wrong.

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      Yeah, the idea of AI utopia just doesn’t convince. Best case scenario they keep us as pets.

    • @mightychondriaofthecell3317
      @mightychondriaofthecell3317 9 месяцев назад

      @drblunt Lol, yeah, true!

  • @joviannagasaki84
    @joviannagasaki84 9 месяцев назад

    So a silicon dictator

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      Yep, I don’t like it but that is the argument that AI epistocrats make.

  • @JernFlums
    @JernFlums 9 месяцев назад

    Void of all our biases but kinda loaded with creators biases... 🎉

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      Yep and that’s the ultimate failing of AI Utopianism

  • @patmays7344
    @patmays7344 9 месяцев назад

    So you don’t want democracy! What does that make you?

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      I want democracy, I just want a better democracy that can meet these criticisms.

  • @scott1395
    @scott1395 9 месяцев назад

    This is unbased propaganda! You opinion hasn't been proven, it all speculation!

    • @drblunt
      @drblunt 9 месяцев назад

      Sir, my propaganda is very based

    • @scott1395
      @scott1395 9 месяцев назад

      @drblunt You said that right, YOUR PROPAGANDA!