Love Emma Watson's sarcasm here. She does the line very straight faced and how i imagine Hermione (who is not naturally a comedian but is clever enough to get it) attempting sarcasm.
That's Emma Thompson playing her, almost missed it. She practically disappears beneath the character. All the Harry Potter movies have excellent casting.
i think that this is one of the many scenes that prove hermione is a gryffindor, not a ravenclaw. a ravenclaw wouldn't be brave enough to knock over a crystal ball of their divination professor and storm right on out with a huff, snatch back their own hand from the grasp of a professor reading their palm and scoff. the courageous hermione we all love.
In the chapter "The Second War Begins", Hermione is shown to have changed her mind about Divination and now believes it's more legitimate than she originally thought.
I love how Hermione couldn't conceive of Divination having any merit, while she, herself, was creating temporal paradoxes with a Time-Turner that very year.
This scene not only legitimately made me laugh, but it also made me realize that I don’t actually like Hermione’s character all that much. She stubborn, and has the inability to think outside the box, which is probably why she could never grasp divination.
I've always liked this side of Hermione and what it says about the wizarding world. Hermione left the class after being insulted, but her general disdain toward divination suggests that she's a skeptic, which is very fun to consider. In a world teeming with literal magic, there are still skeptics who consider divination complete bullshit, like in the real world.
Imagine Snape who wasn't too fond of Hermoine either, more exactly her personality, witnessing this scene live. Not only do I think it would've been twice as hilarious (maybe he would have joined the 'roasting session'), but I think this would've make him smile/chuckle in secret...😂😂😂 Since I consider Hermoine to be highly annoying, too rude for her own good etc., this had me LOLing the whole clip long.....😂😂 She got read alright. Trelawney might have been a fraud, but damn, did she have a precise view of peoples' personalities if she called Hermoine out like that!
She was annoyed. She was dressed completely quaffed and groomed when she knows this is a class for a more relaxed stream and then she looks at her and says something in a mean nonchalant tone and she looks at her dead in the eyes as if she's serious when she's obviously being vicious. It's not the attitude to have in a class.
Just realised, her asking "have I said something" makes you wonder if she actually lapsed into a trance state, like she does when she makes the other prophecy.
please no one hate me but i'm a little sorry for Trelawney yes she's a fraud but I think she just wanted to make herself known and just couldn't control when she could make a real Prediction
I've been thinking about it, and I thought in addition to why Hermione was always so sassy in divination, is because she literally has the power to reverse time in this movie. She can literally tell Trelawney off, say how stupid and ridiculous this class is, and just go back in time, and be as sweet as pie next time (of course, after studying a bit harder). It's a literal Groundhog Day scenario. Her words have no real consequence as long as she holds a flipping time-turner. Heck, why stop there, Hermione? Go up to Ron and tell him you love him, and go on a killing spree and start Avada-Kedavraing Draco and friends!
If memory serves right, the time turner is just time travel. So, she actually can't do that. If I recall correctly when she time travels with harry and they don't take the place of their past selves. So, if people see two Hermiones in the same place, they will know that she is abusing the time-turner or did something she wasn't supposed to do. Even the clips shown of her randomly appearing indicate that she is appearing out of nowhere and is not already present in the room. There is few moments where it shows time travel like that in the entirely of fiction. In fact on the fandom powerlisting the power you describing is Chronoskimming not Time Travel. Putting it simply, if you had Hermione's schedule you would be able to see her in two different classrooms at the same time.
I really think Hermione needed to be called out by both Snape and Trelwaney. While she is very gifted and intelligent, she's far to prideful, stubborn and a desperate know-it-all. She needed to learn some humility. Because students like that hurt the classes ability to learn.
I've seen clouds and smoke in dreams and in our world not necessarily encompassed by a crystal orb but it's interesting to have an idea of how it was in antiquity.
Love Emma Watson's sarcasm here. She does the line very straight faced and how i imagine Hermione (who is not naturally a comedian but is clever enough to get it) attempting sarcasm.
What is this one the first one?
@@Mcgonagall4life Prisoner of Azkaban
@@sallyw3000 k ty
Why is Hermione upset at Trelawny?
How are you confused?
Hermione said this without saying it in her gestures She was like “B***h! F**k you and your crystal ball bulls**t ! I’m out this motherf****r”
I love Emma Thompson. 😂😂😂
🔮
How come Hermione can believe in magic that turns people intor ats but not divination even though it has been proven right already?
🔮
🔮
That's Emma Thompson playing her, almost missed it. She practically disappears beneath the character. All the Harry Potter movies have excellent casting.
How could you miss it when she plays the same person in all 8 movies?
i think that this is one of the many scenes that prove hermione is a gryffindor, not a ravenclaw. a ravenclaw wouldn't be brave enough to knock over a crystal ball of their divination professor and storm right on out with a huff, snatch back their own hand from the grasp of a professor reading their palm and scoff. the courageous hermione we all love.
I wish Trelawney had read Dolores Umbridge's palm.
Which movie again. Azkaban?
In the chapter "The Second War Begins", Hermione is shown to have changed her mind about Divination and now believes it's more legitimate than she originally thought.
"Hermione, did your parents teach you about respecting elderly people, didn't they ?"
ruclips.net/video/mi9a8SeSehs/видео.htmlsi=nFewfTvwZUCECH31
I love how Hermione couldn't conceive of Divination having any merit, while she, herself, was creating temporal paradoxes with a Time-Turner that very year.
Hermione: The Grim... Possibly. Trelawney: *she's not even trying*
She might’ve been a fraud but man did she earn my respect for calling out that know it all bitch for what she is
🔮
💎
🔮
Howl at this scene 😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂
This scene not only legitimately made me laugh, but it also made me realize that I don’t actually like Hermione’s character all that much. She stubborn, and has the inability to think outside the box, which is probably why she could never grasp divination.
HELPP RON SLEEPING HAHA HES SO SILLY
I've always liked this side of Hermione and what it says about the wizarding world. Hermione left the class after being insulted, but her general disdain toward divination suggests that she's a skeptic, which is very fun to consider. In a world teeming with literal magic, there are still skeptics who consider divination complete bullshit, like in the real world.
ruclips.net/video/gvg-zt6oooc/видео.htmlsi=pI8I1Nli1w4H-nai
Love the creepy music towards the end
0:24 ❤ 1:03
I always thought this was Edina Monsoon from abfab. 😅
0:50 Hermione's got a watch
Emma Watson & Emma Thompson have same birthday April 15th
Hermione really dropped the ball with this one
Aby chL teri ma ki chot itni c bat samj nhi arahi behn k lordo tum logon se bat nhi krni
Imagine Snape who wasn't too fond of Hermoine either, more exactly her personality, witnessing this scene live. Not only do I think it would've been twice as hilarious (maybe he would have joined the 'roasting session'), but I think this would've make him smile/chuckle in secret...😂😂😂 Since I consider Hermoine to be highly annoying, too rude for her own good etc., this had me LOLing the whole clip long.....😂😂 She got read alright. Trelawney might have been a fraud, but damn, did she have a precise view of peoples' personalities if she called Hermoine out like that!
First Snape calls Hermione a know-it-all and takes 5 points from Gryffindor. Then Trelawney calls her out in the most passive-aggressive way
She was annoyed. She was dressed completely quaffed and groomed when she knows this is a class for a more relaxed stream and then she looks at her and says something in a mean nonchalant tone and she looks at her dead in the eyes as if she's serious when she's obviously being vicious. It's not the attitude to have in a class.
roasted
Just realised, her asking "have I said something" makes you wonder if she actually lapsed into a trance state, like she does when she makes the other prophecy.
When she said the Grimm I swear to god I heard “I’m pregnant” when I was watching the movie and was like “excuse me what the fu-“
Happy Birthday to both of them
Saying Hermione Granger isn't perfect at something, is more hurtful than calling her mudblood 😂
It hurts cause it's true.
please no one hate me but i'm a little sorry for Trelawney yes she's a fraud but I think she just wanted to make herself known and just couldn't control when she could make a real Prediction
I've been thinking about it, and I thought in addition to why Hermione was always so sassy in divination, is because she literally has the power to reverse time in this movie. She can literally tell Trelawney off, say how stupid and ridiculous this class is, and just go back in time, and be as sweet as pie next time (of course, after studying a bit harder). It's a literal Groundhog Day scenario. Her words have no real consequence as long as she holds a flipping time-turner. Heck, why stop there, Hermione? Go up to Ron and tell him you love him, and go on a killing spree and start Avada-Kedavraing Draco and friends!
If memory serves right, the time turner is just time travel. So, she actually can't do that. If I recall correctly when she time travels with harry and they don't take the place of their past selves. So, if people see two Hermiones in the same place, they will know that she is abusing the time-turner or did something she wasn't supposed to do. Even the clips shown of her randomly appearing indicate that she is appearing out of nowhere and is not already present in the room. There is few moments where it shows time travel like that in the entirely of fiction. In fact on the fandom powerlisting the power you describing is Chronoskimming not Time Travel. Putting it simply, if you had Hermione's schedule you would be able to see her in two different classrooms at the same time.
0:44
I really think Hermione needed to be called out by both Snape and Trelwaney. While she is very gifted and intelligent, she's far to prideful, stubborn and a desperate know-it-all. She needed to learn some humility. Because students like that hurt the classes ability to learn.
I've seen clouds and smoke in dreams and in our world not necessarily encompassed by a crystal orb but it's interesting to have an idea of how it was in antiquity.
I remember seeing this for the first time and feeling so out of pocket to see Hermione be mad over a lesson.
That's what make Hermione a Gryffindor, not a Ravenclaw.