- Видео 10
- Просмотров 901 412
JanTec Engineering
Германия
Добавлен 30 сен 2023
This channel is all about 3d printing, filament testing and electrical engineering.
Imprint/Impressum:
jantec.xyz/imprint.html
Imprint/Impressum:
jantec.xyz/imprint.html
The Best 3D Printer Filament Brand is...
Visit PCBWay, the sponsor of this video: www.pcbway.com/ [AD]
What’s the best 3D printer filament? In this video, I tackle one of the most common questions in the 3D printing community. I asked my audience and fellow content creators to find the top filament brands and materials.
I’ll also show you how to compare filaments like a pro, read technical datasheets, and avoid falling for marketing tricks.
Whether you're a beginner or an experienced maker, this guide will help you to find the best filaments for your 3D printing projects!
Polymaker, Prusament, Sunlu or Bambu Lab - who will win?
This video in German: ruclips.net/video/pD7952e1etQ/видео.html
💚 Support Me
AliExpress Affiliate: s.click....
What’s the best 3D printer filament? In this video, I tackle one of the most common questions in the 3D printing community. I asked my audience and fellow content creators to find the top filament brands and materials.
I’ll also show you how to compare filaments like a pro, read technical datasheets, and avoid falling for marketing tricks.
Whether you're a beginner or an experienced maker, this guide will help you to find the best filaments for your 3D printing projects!
Polymaker, Prusament, Sunlu or Bambu Lab - who will win?
This video in German: ruclips.net/video/pD7952e1etQ/видео.html
💚 Support Me
AliExpress Affiliate: s.click....
Просмотров: 10 805
Видео
Always Perfect 3D Printing Support Structures: The Ultimate Guide
Просмотров 155 тыс.Месяц назад
Save big with PCBWay‘s new year sale! Check out: www.pcbway.com/ [AD] This video dives into the world of 3D printing support structures, covering everything from optimizing slicer settings and designing better 3d models to testing breakaway and soluble filaments. I'll also take a look at unique tricks, like using a permanent marker as a release agent, and learn how to simplify or eliminate supp...
The Game-Changing Filament for Airless Basketballs: PLA-HR Tested!
Просмотров 39 тыс.2 месяца назад
Unleash Your Creativity with JLC3DP WJP Full-Color Printing, Up to $60 New User Coupons: jlc3dp.com/?from=JanTec In this video, I test the PLA-HR filament from Biqu, which was specially developed to print the perfect airless basketball. To do this, I analysed the mechanical properties (resilience, flexural modulus, tensile strength, notched impact resistance) and then printed a full-size airles...
How to 3D Print Warp-Free on any Printer! Peel-off Layer Trick.
Просмотров 226 тыс.3 месяца назад
Happy Black Friday with FlexiSpot! Up to 65% OFF! and chance to win free order and use my code “YTE730” to get $30 off for E7 standing desk! Also code ''24BFC7'' to get $50 off on the C7 ergonomic chair FlexiSpot E7plus standing desk: bit.ly/47O93Mc (US) bit.ly/4gLM884 (CA) FlexiSpot C7 Ergonomic Chair: bit.ly/4fE8OpJ (US) In this video, I’ll share how to print challenging filaments like ABS, A...
Top 6 Mindblowing 3D Printers I found at 3D Printopia 2024!
Просмотров 19 тыс.3 месяца назад
Watch this video in German: ruclips.net/video/1LvwfGyV29o/видео.htmlsi=M4sFEek3AWDR6H6S In this video, I share some insights from the 3D Printopia 2024, also known as the East Coast Rep Rap Festival, and show you 6 innovative 3D printers from the community. From a revolutionary belt printer to a modular MSLA printer, the projects presented offer exciting insights into the future of 3D printing....
You’re Printing ABS Wrong! No Warping & Less Energy Consumption with This Trick!
Просмотров 76 тыс.4 месяца назад
JLC3DP 3D Printing Starts at $0.3, WJP Full Color Printing Newly Online, Up to $60 New User Coupons: jlc3dp.com/?from=JanTec In this video, I test and analyze which 3D printing filaments, including PLA, PETG, TPU, and ABS, can be effectively combined for multi-material prints. Using a custom tensile test setup, I explore the best combinations for adhesion, support structures, and practical appl...
The Best Filament for Affordable & Versatile 3D Prints: HIPS tested!
Просмотров 65 тыс.5 месяцев назад
JLC3DP 3D Printing Starts at $0.3, Up to $60 New User Coupons: jlc3dp.com/?from=JanTec (Advertisement) In this video, I test HIPS filament (high-impact polystyrene) in detail and show why it is more than just a support material. I determine the mechanical and thermal properties, compare expensive and cheap HIPS and show the advantages and disadvantages compared to PLA, PETG, ABS and many other ...
The most underrated filament for 3d printing: PP and PP-CF tested!
Просмотров 160 тыс.7 месяцев назад
In this video, I test PP and PP-CF filament from PPprint. I discuss the aspects of printability, mechanical and thermal properties and other exciting special features of polypropylene. 🇩🇪 Watch this video in German: ruclips.net/video/9mHORCMyvVM/видео.html 🔗 Useful links My website: jantec.xyz PPprint: www.ppprint.de Adhesive for PP: amzn.to/3VeXQ2L (aff) Cheaper PP Alternative: s.click.aliexpr...
The strongest filament you can 3D print at home! F3 PA-CF Pro
Просмотров 123 тыс.7 месяцев назад
In this video I test Fiberthree F3 PA-CF Pro filament. This material is based on polyamide-6, also known as PA6 or nylon, and is reinforced with carbon fibres. The filament has extremely good mechanical and thermal properties and outperforms all the filaments I have tested so far in terms of tensile strength and layer adhesion. What's more, it can be easily printed on machines such as the Prusa...
ABS alternative: Olefin filament tested!
Просмотров 32 тыс.7 месяцев назад
In this video, I test olefin filament, a promising material that could be an alternative to ABS. I analyse its printing properties, perform mechanical and thermal tests and compare the results with ABS and ASA. Olefin impresses with its high strength, low density and odourless processing, which makes it interesting for lightweight and heat-resistant components. Find out how Olefin performs in p...
This seems like a really smart workaround to printing more challenging materials in printer without a heated chamber! I am trying to impliment this technique to solve a bed adhesion issue printing ASA in my BBL P1S, but I am having trouble... I get an error that says "Unable to print filaments which have large temperature differences together. Otherwise, the extruder and nozzle may be blocked or damaged during printing". I am using Bambu Studio Version 1.10.1.50. Any suggestions would be appreciated.
Have you tried to print abs on abs plate? It should behave like a raft.
I can't really print pla, but love petg for everyday use and cf nylon and pctg for functional parts. My printer is a heavy modified prusa i3 mk3s with a bondtech lgx shortcut copperhead, the entry level hotend from sliced engineering. I mostly print petg or even pet. Pla just doesn't really solidifies in times to be useful to me
Polymaker all the way. Qidi's new ABS is really good too, great results with it.
Hah! I still have my Super Duper Deluxe Tough High-Speed PLA++ from Polar Filament (great filament, btw). I wonder what April Fools filament filament they're going to do this year.
Dude, that's so cool - wish I had one!
i use gluestick instead of sharpie. good adhesion and doesn't stain the parts
Thanks for the tip, I'll make sure to try out a few more possible release agents.
Best means affordable too.
That's true!
The sharpie release agent really makes a ridiculous amount of sense. Now I'm waiting to see the market provide different or low/no color options with chisel tip applicators to optimize this.
I'm always amazed by how much variability there is even just between brands. Even with materials that don't advertise additives like plain PETG there ends up being a lot of variability. WRT favorites, Duramic PLA+ has been pretty great for my puzzle projects. It's very impact resistant but still easy to print accurately. It's just not very fast and requires aggressive cooling. It's similar in spirit to Polymaker's PolyMax PLA+ but way cheaper.
PolyMaker definitely seems like a solid brand, tho I'll usually go for whatever is cheap (not too cheap; I have several from inland as well) and easily accessible if I don't need some special color; if I do I'm kind of at the mercy of whatever I find..
My two favorite brands so far are Tinmorry and Siraya Tech. Tinmorry makes amazing PETG-CF and PETG-GF. Siraya Tech makes great engineering filaments and their 85A TPU performs great for me. I also like Eryone for their cost to performance. I've had good luck with most brands I've purchased. I have some Polymaker Fiberon series filament I'm excited to test out too.
Never enjoy seeing jeno-side Jonathan AKA The Next Layer in a video. He has abhorrent views.
What do you mean exactly?
@@kndztr His Twit feed is absolutely awful. He believes in getting rid of an entire nation and people.
I love the Overture Rock series PLA and their PLA matte series and pro series. I find the rock series in marble or the red tan combos look amazing on statues and also mountain type scenery or even for things like a gridfinity large storage box. These are very nice high quality filaments. I also like many of the filaments made by Qidi and Siraya tech. ABSGF25 being one of my favorites. I have to be honest the Polymaker stuff has not really impressed me much on some of the rolls I have tried out. I just got in a bunch of Anycubic PLA in grey which I use all the time just a great all around general purpose filament. I have a few new brands that I have yet to test out, but snatched up a few dozen rolls of various PETG and PLA filaments to test out. I tried out some PETG from Creality recently and was not impressed. Most of the stuff out there seems ok, but I do have certain brands that I stick with, most of the stuff I actually print is higher grade engineering type filaments, ABS is still my favorite all around filament and most used one along with ASA.
Skipping water soluable supports just to show an overpriced proprietary solvent soluable product seems a little bit like being a shill. Great information but not covering PVA feels like a fail
I've had really good luck with eryone
Fil X SBS
Very disappointing video. A big middle finger to the entire thought of any kind of scientific or useful information. But I guess it's worth it to get those clicks, huh?
I appreciate your honesty. While the community poll and content creator interviews are indeed not scientific at all, I think the rest is. 60% of the video is about scientific facts, such as how carbon fibres really improve filaments. While most people say things like „CF filaments makes your parts stronger“ I at least tried to explain it. Second, this video didn’t make a lot a of clicks. in fact, I made way more with scientific videos, such as in-depth material analysis. I still get your point and will work on more scientific videos!
I'm just starting out and I can already tell it will be extremely application dependent. Right now I'm using a bunch of matte PLA, PET-G HF and Translucent PET-G because I'm making boxes and drawers for my modeling stuff, and PLA and PET-G have a really low coefficient of friction against each other. However, I need to make about a zillion arms and shoulder pads to magnetize my Grey Knights, and I'm told the Sunlu PLA Meta makes the most detailed prints. I've got a spool and will start experimenting with it once the drawers and a PLA prototype dreadknight are done. So yeah, I think I'm going to be using a lot of different materials as I get further into this.
The sunlu pla meta is very nice, and can print very fast. I like it.
For me my go to's are sunlu and creative pla's bang for the buck wise and also availability... And don't hit me but for petg it's the Amazon brand... Prints great on my K1C..
I mostly buy eSun, Sunlu and Polymaker, because they are similiar in price and on the lower side of that, whilst I never had problems printing with them. I often notice a weaker color in these, compared to like Prusament, but this is also not always the case. PETG Signal white from Prusa is way more white than any other white PETG I own, but the "Signal" in the same indicates that. I'm yet to find a filament that can compete with Galaxy black.
This is a stupid video. I guessed Polymaker before I clicked on the video, skipped to the end, and got it right. By this metric, you are rating brands based on Amazon search listing optimization (availability and pricing), not any technical merits.
Exactly. Dumb clickbait video. Dude wouldn't even compare the datasheets for the filaments...
I agree, the video isn’t perfect. But one of my main goals was to teach how to properly compare filaments to NOT get influenced by search optimisation/marketing. You skipped through the video so you probably didn’t see when I showed how to properly compare prices, clarify various misconceptions and talk about datasheets.
@Remus1033 I will rethink about the title and thumbnail. It’s truly not about clickbait. I just wanted to get some insights from the community and other creators while explaining important things to consider when actually comparing filaments based on facts, such as TDS.
What I dislike is chinese brands, Sunlu is good and fine but their specs are always useless. On every site and shop or spool they list difference print settings. From documentation to distribution, it's horrible while the filament itself is good. I mean, some shops have colors they dont even have on their own site ! Same as Creality printers, parts from Ali Creality shop but nowhere to find on the offical site. They just can't make it reliable from source of purchase to settings, guess business in Asia is different.
PLA is absolutly the worst material. ASA or Nylon 1000x better. PLA is weak, hard to print and expensive and likes to clog.
Hard to print and clog? I never print PLA but it's by far the easiest to print and has significantly less of a chance to clog vs most other filaments out there. 😂
Q1: colorFabb Q2: PLA/PHA and PHA
A question like this is going to end up fairly subjective IMO, there will be objective things the people using these filaments will extract from using them, but once many try a few, get burned by some others, then preferences tend to start forming from there. The only 2 I've even used from that pie-chart are hatchbox and overture. I can't even use the overture half the time, because the fumes it makes are kinda obnoxious for 'PLA'.. no idea why it off-gasses as much as it does compares at normal temps, compared to all the other off-brand ones I've tried.. yet is one of the frequently praised ones? So again just one of my (subjective) experiences, vs others.
I think my favorite color of filament is Overture Army Green PETG. It's a gorgeous color. I don't really have a go-to brand or type because it all depends on the application and desired color. To do a lithophane or filament painting, Bambu PLA because my X1C with 2 AMS units just automatically works and the settings are already known quantities for transmission distance, flow rate and color.
Q1: Azurefilm for color prints, for gray/white whatever I find in bulk for 10eur per kg Q2: PLA For color filament I like to go to store and get it there, so I can see what I'm buying.
Wait.. There are stores that sell filament? Where can you find them? (I have never seen one around where I live)
@@HannesMrg I'm from Slovenia. There is Azurefilm store in Ljubljana. Store is small part of their office/production space. All filaments at the store are also cheaper then online. Last time PLA was 15eur.
didnt know this brand, they have in fasct very interessing colour!
Beautiful Rotring 800 tho.
Sunlu PETG
I build and sell huge, powerful 3D printed nerf blasters. My go to filament is CC3D PLA MAX PLUS, also sold as HZST3D PLA Plus The stuff is cheap and rigid without being brittle and is perfect for the high abuse applications I put it under. I've printed about 150 spools of it in the last couple of years and I'm not sure what I would switch to if it disappeared. Runner up is Esun PLA+
Great brand nobody knows about...Ziro. I really like their PLA.
First off - I don't know why anybody still prints with ABS and PETG when ASA and PCTG exist. They're just objectively better. Secondly - those tasty Polymaker ad dollars make me very sus about any RUclipsrs' stated brand preference. Thirdly - great channel, keep the videos coming! 😄
they are better but there is always a but. price, selection, availability, and from my experience petg prints slighly nicer than pctg if you care about aesthetics.
1. I personally prefer ASA over ABS too, but PCTG is a different material imo, its more expensive and a bit harder to print. 2. I asked for their honest opinions but some might certainly be influenced by theirs sponsors. 3. Thanks! Will do ;)
ABS is probably the cheapest filament I print. Usually around $15/kg, sometimes a little less. ASA is almost always significantly more. I wouldn't pick it for this reason, but ASA also doesn't adhere to any smooth plate I am aware of without some kind of adhesive. ABS works great on my PEX plate. Adhesives are messy to deal with.
@@RichFreeman I have found that high temp garolite ("G11"), wet sanded with ~600 grit, works really well with ASA. You have to run it a little hotter; I usually have it around 110-115C. I've run dozens of kg of ASA with flawless bed adhesion this way and no adhesives. I've long since abandoned PEX as a print surface. I never found that it worked any better than PEI.
@@nikwoac I'll have to try that - I have a Garolite plate (though it is G10 - not sure if that will create problems at 110 though I've probably already run it at that temp for Nylon). I don't have a decent smooth PEI sheet so I haven't tested as much with that.
Nice video. I am surprised that eSun is not even in top10 in chart at the end. About impact test, very often manufacturer include Charpy impact test, but they forget to mention its a Charpy (supported from 2 sides, resulting bigger impact load)
yeah esun is pretty big and they have a wide selection. regarding impact tests, they sometimes also use some units other than kJ/m2 which doesn't make any sense.
@@riba2233 in US they use often kJ/m (thickness of test objects) ASTM. The ISO standard is in kJ/m² (cross section area).
@@MyTechFun yes and I totally don't understand how kJ/m should be calculated while /m2 makes sense :D
Thanks for adding this and participating in the video!
@@riba2233 Same, kJ/m feels strange.
Keep in mind that many of the plastic base material is sourced from the same factory for many brands. And secondly, even the filament produced in one factory is then rebranded half a million times before it reaches end consumer. So next time, you will have a need to argue with your friend about which brand is best, remember, that they both can be not only from the same factory, but also from the exact same chemical plant making the material.
You're right. But I think especially the bigger brands, like Prusament, Sunlu or Bambu, but also local manufacturers do make their own filament with their own blends.
I use sunlu because its cheap and does the job.
Same sunlu and creative are my go to except for petg than it's Amazon brand...
Whatever is the cheapest PLA in a color I like with at least a tolerance of 0.03 (preferably 0.02) and good windings. If I need something that has to handle slightly higher temperatures I go with PETG (same requirements as PLA). I stay away from ABS/ASA because I would have to print outside and people put way too much trust into insufficient filters. CF prints ideally need to be coated in something to be "save" to touch which everyone also happily ignores. Besides from 3d printed stuff there isn't a single commercial carbon fiber thing out there that is not coated in resin with zero exposed fibers.
you dont need to print outside. i have my printer in a closet that i sealed with gaskets around the door & a 3 stage filter with a VOC meter. it is not ideal, and i replace the filter monthly, but the VOC management is much better than i thought. it peaks after about 40 mins of printing & is mostly filtered out after an hour once complete. also, there are plenty of filaments that hold fibers in the core of the filament very well. phaetus aeworthy abs-gf is my all time favorite for that - fibers dont stick out.
@ Sure that works and with a proper activated charcoal filter that gets replaced regulary you can make it work but for most people just not printing inside is easier and cheaper. Either way I am pretty sure that almost everyone who prints abs/asa does it in an unsafe way. Same with cf, most just don't care or know about the exposed fibers
that think about CF is just not true.
i feel like this question is so difficult to answer because it is heavily influenced by the use-case for a particular part. most people tend to stick to the materials that are most applicable to their primary use case. i pretty much never use PLA or PETG. my main projects require high rigidity, high heat resistance, and/or high tensile strength. so i mainly use ABS, ABS-GF/CF, PC, PC-CF, PET-CF, etc. high temp - high strength. i feel that this survey is missing the crucial "what is your primary use-case?" question. my opinion: sure, i understand that this isn't meant to be a concrete result of your survey - but it is more misleading in my opinion. maybe i am biased, but i do not like polymaker. they only have 2 main positives for me & theyre consistency & availability. polymaker ABS is definitely not pure ABS - my main issue with polymaker is that everything they make is a blend. when i am buying ABS, i am not looking for a PETG-ABS blend like polymaker has. blends are the biggest frustration when buying filament in my experience. i praise atomic filament for their insanely high quality ABS, but it seems like there are very few brands that manufacture genuinely pure filaments as they are advertised.
it is certainly not a petg+abs blend, it is something else in it. it can just be a different ratio of it's a, b and s components.
pet-cf is so underrated
@@mrrooter601 yep, 100%! I assume we will see a lot more of it in the future.
@@mrrooter601 I agree, it's sure not my go-to but agreat filament. Friends of mine even got to recycle old PET-CF (from BASF filaments), works like a charm!
Q1: Any brand that will print well on my MagnetoX Q2: Any material that will print well on my MagnetoX Thank you for this great resource on filament. Keep up the good work!
The best visually appealing filament is cookiecad PLA, The most consistent filament is BAMBU, poly maker is a great filament for the price, and worst is prusa.
did you have bad experience with prusa?
An NDA prevents me from disclosing what company I worked for but they are a VERY large company that runs about 60 FDM printers 24/7 and has used and extensively tested every filament brand out there. The worst price-quality ratio filament is unfortunately PRUSA filament. @@riba2233
I find it depends on what type of plastic as to which brand is best. Polymaker PETG, for example, can be an absolute pain to print with and is very sticky and has additives that cause it to be more oozey. Meanwhile, their PLA and ASA are great, print exactly how you expect those plastics to print. Prusa, on the other hand, has amazing PETG, performs perfectly and as expected (haven't tried other plastics, not available in Canada). So it completely depends on the type of plastic and then the brand.
I often find that we miss all those nicest filament here in canada. our choise is pretty limited compared to other parts of the world.
sunlu petg and prusament pla
It never made sense that they sell filament by the weight rather than the meter. As you pointed out, the densities are different. My 1KG ASA rolls are almost always right at the edge of the roll, fuller than any PLA or PETG rolls.
I think 1KG is better for shipping, as every Roll of Material weighs the same like that.
Take a benchy for example. I can't measure how much length of filament it took to make. But instead how many grams. Likewise a spools length matters little as it's being extruded through nozzles of varying sizes.
I worked for a resin manufacturing/3d printing company and the reason given when I asked why we always sell 1kg of each resin instead of full bottles was that it was defined by the shipping label and selling by the kg makes that much simpler for all parties involved (except the consumer I suppose)
Before filament run-out sensors were a common place and way before automatic filament changing it was very easy to weigh a spool and know down to the gram how much filament was left on the spool. Polymaker still prints the weight of the spool on the spool. At minimum, you can still quickly check if a manufacturer is short changing you by doing an initial weighing.
Q1: Polymaker Q2: PLA for cosmetic parts CF PETG for functional Also I have had the same experience with limonene and abs/asa. I've also found that using HIPS/polycarbonate together in multimaterial systems drastically degrades the strength of PC even without limonene.
Thanks for adding this!
Subscribe or your nozzle will clog!
If only permanently preventing that was so easy..
Jokes on you my nozzle is already clogged xD will sub anyway, might get unclogged by itself :D
Phone case comes to mind!
Any idea on nylon?
Maybe a whiteboard marker would be better than a permanent marker, because the residue can be removed more easily? Or UV markers. They are only visible under UV light.
The sharpie is alcohol based, and I was wondering has anybody ever experimented with Hairspray which is alcohol based which would be quicker
Great video. I have a model where I stuck magnetic tape on the bottom of a reusable support and painter's tape on the top. I add a pause to the print job and drop in the reusable support. The magnetic tape holds it to the bed. When the print job is finished, I pop off the support, remove the tape, and stick on new tape for the next print. It's the Towel Bar Mounting Bracket from my Printables page. It allows me to have a clean recess on what becomes the back of the part without creating support waste.
That is a very cool idea!
Fot parts like the T shape (large square overhangs) I put kapon tape between the support and part. It works flawlessly