Видео

Thank you for this insightful video!

and it in fact killed him

They were never a 'band'. They were an exercise in marketing. They didn't sweat and practise together on their instruments. They didn't do live gigs to get recognised. No wonder they didn't get on.

Watching this today, makes the take that much depressing

Interesting video. Watching the day after poor Liam Payne died under horrific circumstances in Argentina. So sad.

This stopped right in the middle of your sentence! Ugh!

I love Hozier, boy genius, tenacious D, Sabrina carpenter, noah kahn, lana del reys fenway drop, and laufey's book club merch!! they're honestly all so perfect for the respective artist!

not really a celebrity but my absolute favorite merch designer is crumb cuptoast, theyre a twitch streamer and youtuber who designs all their own merch and they always make the absolute cutestttt things omg highly highly recommend ive gotten a few of their things myself and its always soso cute

cool video!

{[{Hi Harmony..love your channel you’re really funny!}]}

babe wake up harmony posted

so fun to watch and i didn’t know any of this. my sister was obsessed with them, she’s gonna love this vid. 🫶🏻 keep it up u killed it once again

That dramatic cliffhanger… lol. I hope you are planning a part 2 from where you got cut off.

Oh jesus move on it's 2024

I have never seen that clip from Louis’ audition. He’s been my celebrity crush since I was 8, and I’m 20 now, but I took a break from the fandom and holy shit that killed me wtf

In terms of niall he is a very easygoing go with the flow guy so I beleive he is speaking his truth.

great insight and informative , subscribed!

it was a bad idea to watch this during class, i’m bawling all over again

unpopular opinion but i don’t want one direction to come back. 🫢 i kind of want to see a video about this because a lot of problematic behaviour has been unearthed about the boys ESPECIALLY zayn and obviously liam but i can’t find many people talking about it ughhh. we’re the same age, and it’s hard to be unbiased when they were such a massive part of our lives growing up, but honestly now i’m realizing the only ones i even bother keeping up with are harry and niall.

I don't want them to come back, honestly. They are doing great solo. And I'm so proud of them. But, poor Harry and Louis....

I like your necklace. Is it Jade?

Definitely not overthinking, especially Niall's part. It seems he’s either in denial or trying to sugarcoat the whole situation. Only after his solo albums did he actually have the chance to shine on his own. Also, thank you so much for shedding light on Liam's situation. Although he was never my favorite, I feel like nowadays, every time someone mentions him, it's always in such a negative way. While I agree he’s done some questionable stuff, like the whole interview with Logan Paul (that "I'm such a scary big strong boy" vibe really gives me the ick), I still think he doesn’t deserve all of this. People aren't really taking into account that each member was traumatized during the time in the band.

niall was definitely not forgotten 😭 it was louis

Enjoyed this and learned a lot

they released the history music video in 2016 and the promo ended in 2016 that’s why the hiatus officially started in 2016

Louis' jealousy is partly what made the band break up. According to Liam and Niall, it was Louis who pushed for the band to change genre in early 2014. Liam said he did not agree with it but Louis pushed for it. Why would Louis do that? Louis had a vision of what the band should look like and where he would stand in the band. You have a band member who has issues with the music and yet he pushed to change the genre in 2014. If you watch the video of their tour in 2014, he sometimes refused to harmonize with Zayn. Zayn went up to him once in July 2014 at the end of the song "Moments" and asked him why wasn't he singing, he smiled and replied "I didn't feel like it". He purposedly ignored him during interviews, even Niall called him out on it in their interview with Scott. Julian Bunetta said in his 1D 10th anniversary Rolling Stones interview that there was so much tension in the band, he was just hoping Zayn would last until the end of the 5th album. It is a fact that Louis and his minion Liam are the only member of the band to talk trash about Zayn. Harry purpose said in his Zane Lowe interview that he wrote his music with Zayn in mind. Why? Because Louis and Liam was writing the music and purposely limiting his time on songs. Then Louis gets on very interview for the past 6 years and talk about how he is mad at Zayn because he did not show up for his show. Lies. He has issues with Zayn from late 2013. He has never mentioned in the past 8 years that the boys were expected to perform at the show but they refused. No. That would make them look bad. But he had no problem trash talking Zayn. "He is not ready to have the talk yet". Ego much? Zayn ever said he wanted to talk to him? He tried to get Zayn out of the band because he saw the band as 4 members. He never expected Harry to leave. Harry lasted 4 weeks after Zayn. He put in for his break in April. It was approved in July. He had the nerve to put on his profile 1/4 of 1D. He meant 1/3 of 1D. As James Corden said "i see 1D as 5". Harry is never coming back unless there is 5. That is what he means when he says he is open to coming back if the situation is right. Out here playing Larries to sell merch and tickets.

Nialls voice wasn't really strong to begin with, like Louis's, but they did get better...

Naill wasn't the forgotten, Louis was....

Ohhh no. Is the cliffhanger supposed to be one? This was a great and informative watch. Thank you for sharing it!

24:40 "While he -" ... yesss?

You just gained a new subscriber

I think throughout the end of OD it was clear that Harry would like to leave . And there is nothing wrong with that. They needed OD to break up and get on their respective different paths in life .One funny thing stood out for me in your video, really a detail...you ´ve said he was not allowed to paint his nails and there are several videos from the live shows where he has his nails painted black . (I need to find it :)

damn what a cliffhanger to end on

Great job! But i wanted more on your commentary.

1:06 felt that 😭

Such a nice video, great job!

did the video cut off werid at the end? Im loving the video and want to hear more omg I love your voice!!

such an interesting topic! wow I didn't realise how much those poor boys went through 😔

Tell me more ❤

just called my boss and said i can’t come into work today as harmony posted another video and i’m suddenly busy all day

first view and so excited to feel like its 2010 again

I wasted so many hours and likely days watching that man. All the while telling myself it’s just because he’s cute but it’s ok lol come to find out all this. I would only feel more so upset if I were to watch him again because this guy knew all the while his career likely wouldn’t last and was playing us all for a fool. Speaking for myself I want to know the person in front of me is still active and not completely ship jumped (lol) from their own channel and are no more😢 I like your video!

Honestly loved the concept of this video and something I kinda wondered in myself after the Cody Ko drama. I’m glad to see RUclips recommending videos like this not just what is going viral.

I think it’s ok to separate the art from the artist if they aren’t a ped0file or predat0r

excited to see what other videos you have in store!

I'm curious about your thoughts on JK Rowling as she isn't featured in her art like Stanley Kubrick (as a trans person I cannot separate her and no longer consume HP content after being a very big Potterhead)

i think the concept of separating the art from the artist has moved from actual Art to just “creations.” in a LOT of situations, the creator and their creation are intrinsically linked- esp for Content creators. there may be merit or worth in these creations that are beyond the individual, but if it IS the individual, any person engaging in the content for Any reason is Still supporting the artist. as it goes w music and movies, i do still see those, as many more people than just the artist benefit & because i believe Art can be separated in a sense. but content creators in a social media world, who singularly benefit… yeah, no

Kia Ora

Fantastic video!!!

me when I see 'new zealand' in ur bio omggg heyyy yasssss representtt!!!