A few things I have to say to the complainers.I tried to make this video as fair as possible, because I am a fan of both and I don't believe in making biased videos. 1. I used Mariah's "old" notes because she was closer to Ariana's age. It was just fair 2. Some of Mariah's notes are louder because I downloaded a concert, and all the footage from that concert is loud. I tried to increase Ariana's volume, but Windows Movie Maker is a bad editing program. When I played the video back, it did absolutely nothing for her volume. When I tried to lower Mariah's, I could barely hear it. 3. All of the notes on here are completely live, except two of Mariah's notes (edit: Ariana's F6 and F#6 are playbacks as well). This was in effort to showcase Ariana's upper belting range. Secondly I did not do Mariah's full live vocal range because it would not be fair. She has over five octaves and Ariana does not
Angelfully hey! dont hate on windows movie maker, it may be simplistic but it's free firstly and secondly it's simple to use... i cried trying cyberlink powerdirector and i was like... yeap sticking to wlmm lol :P
I love u for being an Ariana fan yet not being butt hurt about Mariahs talented voice and I luv them both but honestly come on,im glad u have enough common sense to admit the obvious!
7:14-Mariah and 7:21... exactly one of my examples. I heard power AND emotion in Mariah's voice--and then there's Ariana who sounded like a hamster with all that squeakiness. The faces i was making while listening to her was unconrolable. lol
Mariah, in her prime, can not be compared to Ariana. Mariah's voice is much more striking, strong, full of emotion. As our friend said down here, Mariah is a legend. We will thank her for so many wonderful songs that she sang throughout her career. Today we know her voice is no longer the same, but deserves all our respect. Incomparable.
Rafa Medina I know right! The higher Ariana goes, the more she sounds like she has a mouthful of almonds whilst singing. I guess that's what happens when you spend to much time emulating somebody else's technique rather than minding enunciation. Lol.
Justin Carbon No Mariah In Her Prime 1990-1996 Is So Invincible Even After Her Prime She Is Still So Invincible Because Of Her Insane Runs&Riffs And Melismas specially during Rainbow And Butterfly
Supreme Master 101 The funny thing is Mariah never had a prime becuz of her nodules her "prime" was far below levels of her "true prime" if she doesnt have the vocal nodules
Thank you! This is a fair opinion! I'm glad to see someone give credit where it's due to both artists, instead of rising one up and putting the other down.
It is astonishing how great Ariana Grande's voice is. But it was sadly destroyed by Mariah note by note. Just goes to show on what level Mariah was in her prime.
Anyone in this world is not replaceable. It is the nature ! So simple and people start to make this comparison just to get attention and viewers. The world would be better if people stop making these stupid comparison. All we have are preferences. if I like Ariana more than Mariah it just my test and people around me have to respect or vice versa. My mother always says: what would be of the green colour if everyone would like purple? lol
I'm a huge Ariana Grande fan but let's be real here, Mariah Carey is a legend. It's a compliment that Ariana gets compared to Mariah. But I believe Ariana has one of the best voices in this generation.
Ariana's voice is too safe. It's beautiful to listen to her alone but standing next to Mariah, that's another level of understanding. Mariah's voice is a trademark. Nobody can imitate that voice. But I bet there's many Arianas out there, if you know what I mean. Prove me wrong if you don't agree. :-)
Ariana is the closest thing to Mariah so their ain't many Ariana's cuz she the only one can do the notes an scream Mariah is just has a bigger voice Ariana' is still young don't forget that
@@laura6360 Then that would be unfair already cause it's in Daydream-Butterfly era, one song would already beat her, even the Daydream interlude (Her intro song before the concert starts)
Mariah win , Her voice is amazing in every octave . She sing deeper than Ariana in low octave . Her high note is so smooth . Ariana's note sound very sharp
Because she is able to sing she's mocking Mariah? I love Mariah and I acknowledge her vocal talent but you stans do the absolute most. Both are talented and you shouldn't try to bring Ariana down instead you should be happy that she can even be compared to Mariah. Mariah's voice isn't what it used to be anyhow.
Sera Johnson "You stans do the absolute most..." I agree that your essay in my reply is *absolute most*. Ariana's stans call her Mariah's replacement all the time, so my comment is well placed. Besides, Ariana's voice isn't that good.
low notes: mariah carey mid belts: mariah carey high belts: mariah carey head voice: mariah carey.. whistle notes: mariah carey.. this pretty much sums it up lol
When Mariah was Arianas age she was singing way better than Ariana can ever do now. Its only fair to compare old footage of when she was younger. Lets face it Arianas voice will never live up to Mariahs.
Mariah Carey single handily changed the industry. Her voice, her songwriting, and producing. This lady’s Christmas song is old as me. She’s still around touring every single day of the year nonstop. That speaks to her legacy.
no doubt ariana is an amazing singer. but she doesnt stand against mariah carey. and i dont mean only her - NOBODY can beat mariah. she's a freaking legend.
Philip Vicencio well mariah was ten times better than ariana she was the same age as ariana is now but now im not too sure just cause she's in like 45? now
Ariana is certainly not just a pop star with a good voice. She is a pop star with a legendary voice. she was invited to the White House for the Women of Soul performance along with other legends like pattie labelle, Aretha frankin, and Melissa etheridge. She is probably the most talented pop artist to have as many hit singles as she had in 2015. Mariah has an amazing performance ethic and voice while Ariana gets very nervous for big performances so sometimes her raw talent doesn't shine all the way through in her performances. But she still manages to blow the audience away: if you look at more performances she's done like tattooed heart at the 2014 amas, some of her acoustic performances, and many more you can clearly see that she has a legendary voice, just like Mariah. Plus, Mariahs voice isn't that legendary anymore, I'm sure you've seen her All I want for Christmas performance at the Rockefeller center.
Judging technically: Lower Register: OH Mariah. You definitely win in this vocal register. Much better support. Can make her larynx stable. Dark and Resonant. Doesn't dissipate like air rushing outside a popped tire. And can sustain too. Belts: Mariah. Legendary resonance. Better pitch. Better breath control and sustain. Supports her belts. Much stable larynx. Better vibrato(ariana's are sometimes uneven and wobbly). Falsetto: Mariah. Greater agility and pitch. Head Voice: Mariah. Ariana doesn't use it. Whistle: Mariah easily. Ariana has only shown it once and it's in the studio. Ariana has a long way to go to be able to challenge the Queen.
Let's put it this way. Mariah Carey made her own name in the music industry competing to the top female singers such as Celine Dion and Whitney Houston. Ariana Grande compare to Mariah Carey. It's like comparing Buggati and Mercedes.
Different tones of voices. Ariana hits the high notes just like Mariah Carey and just cause she doesn't sound exactly like her doesn't mean she can't sing. and also they lowered the volume on her parts to makes mariah's one sound even louder. I hate people I swear 😒
Kelsayy A They hit the same notes but they are on equal. Ariana mixed her belts better and she could go higher and sustain her mixing belts as well. However, Mariah's blooming spot lies in her mids and uppers up to around G5 and she only sustains to F5s. She's got the whistle up to Bb7, though and she was/is more agile at it.
The current Ariana supports up to B4/C5 but barely resonates while Mariah’s soars up to even G5. What’s the point of belting higher than Mariah while she couldn’t even support? That’s bad for her. I’d wish she can work on those to be better future. But downline-No, Ariana can’t be compared with Mariah. She’s way below Mariah, that’s just too unfair. Younger Ariana (before fame) produces large resonance though, I missed her old days
Neungkrub TS Actually Ariana is not best at Mixing .. i wont say Head dominant is bad but it makes her voice is light and unpowerful while Mariah can belt balanced .. if you want hear Head Dominant so amazing .. go watch SoHyang .. she is using Head Dominant constant but her resonance makes it powerful
Listening to Ariana is like listening to a very good singer from earth. Listening to Mariah is like listening to an Angel from Heaven... simply Magical.
For real? Ariana doesn't touch Mariah. Yes, they can both go high but Mariah's voice is smoother and she has a very low register as well. Not to mention Mariah's songs are so much more classic. Problem and Side to Side are never going to become beloved songs in the long run.
no she cant lol. ariana cant sale with her voice like mariah. adele has that spot in this generation. ariana isnt special like mariah. mariah innovated and broke down barriers. she had a solid tone all the way through and a limitless range. all ariana has is range and some soft runs. her voice is small. thats why her ballads are not as effective.
But Mariah and Whitney are quite a bit more agile than Celine, and that’s a fact, not an opinion. Even look up videos comparing them. Celine has absolutely beautiful tone though. I’m just being objective. The third member of the vocal trinity is still yet to be found. Sorry, but it’s true.
The Difference between Mariah Carey is her Voice and Pronunciation is more Clearer than Ariana Grande. Ariana Grande sang though her nose which means she staining. Yet Mariah Carey Sing Effortlessly Clear. Still both are Great Singers
Most of Ariana belted notes were very unstable and really "weak/inconsistent" back then, she improved a bit now (and I'm happy for her), but she still can't match Mariah's quality (I'm not even talking about resonance). So "the new Mariah" title that media and some fans put on Ariana was just another failed experiment.
Thi Hills Music i agree. And Lambs just need tl give a chance to improve her self she started to wake up on her life and im sure till her new era she will prove alot and the comparisons are older then what u thing. People compared mariah to whitney and people compared whitney to Aretha and before people compared Aretha to Ella and there will be people that will say that Mariah and whitney are nothing near Aretha and Ella.
Well but when Mariah came out you could tell she was not only an amazing vocalist from the very first live, but also a unique all around singer. Nobody in their sane mind would think that about Ariana. The "New Mariah" is only a marketing label to give the girl some credit and sales. If Ariana were the New Mariah, she would already have couple of hot 100 number 1s and two grammys.
Not even close. Mimi kills her on every note. But have y'all noticed how when Mimi belts she significantly furthers the microphone away from her mouth and Ariana glues it to her mouth and Mimi still sounds more powerful. Damn baby
So basically people are saying that Ariana copies Mariah because of what? because they can hit the same notes? Smh. That's Ariana's voice! She aint trying to copy nobody! She said herself that shes forbidden to sing with a false voice bc it hurts her voice. So people are hating on Ariana for singing with her own voice. They dont sing the same kind of music, dont dress the same, dont act the same,have different voices.... wow Ariana is copying Mariah!
Hayes D Her management is trying so hard to make her as the 'new mariah'. Also, people are not hating on Ariana for her voice. It's just that the style she sings in is a direct copy of heavily imitated of mariah.
There's no comparison really. Mariah is a legend! Ariana has a long way to go. She will never reach or even come close to mc's fame, talent and achievements. No other female artist in that matter. Smdh
Whitney was wonderful, don't doub it, but don't compare her with Mariah, she was wonderful, but Mariah is not only a great singer, she is also producer and songwriter, NO ONE like her!! she has been also very important in the music industry, also an inspiration for many singers, like this Ariana Grande, I don't know who is she...
she is still famous, and she actually sells a lot of albums, I just think it's not fair to compare her with a young talent, she has run a looong hard road. and opened doors for many artists today, it's not something about generations, it's just for me there's no comparison, Mariah is Mariah, no one like her, nobody can surpass her and be better than her. That's my opinion. I've studied music for 12 years, it's my career and I can't find a better singer than Mariah, she can sings whatever she wants, including opera
Even if Ari has a long way to go, remember at the age Ari is now, Mariah was making famous hits like "emotions", "can't let go" for example and also her famous "Merry Christmas Album". Ari is far behind what Mariah was in her day.
Mariah Carey has more range (B2-B7), Is a songwriter, impeccable technique, Achievements. Her voice is more powerful and resonates throughout her range. she can play with her range anyway she wants with so much control and precision. On Ariana's defense, I can say she doesn't have the experience and the lengthy career that Mariah has. Maybe her technique improves and maybe she'll hit those low notes someday.
I really wish people would stop putting Ariana in these vocal comparisons with legends like Mariah, Whitney, Beyonce, Leona..Just cause the girl can hit a strained high note doesn't automatically give her the right to be compared to people who support the same note effortlessly..
to the new generation. don't get it twisted .. Mariah is a WOMANN with one of the powerful voices to ever grace the mic okay??? Ariana is a little girl with dreams to achieve a fraction of what Mariah has accomplished in her lifetime.. she can't hold a candle to her and never will.. there is no comparison i'm sure even Mariah would find it cute. at 16:02 I rest my case.
You do realise that the fact Ariana is being compared to Mariah says how good Ariana is. It's fine loving Mariah, but you don't need to put down other artists to do that. Instead of being a dick about it, you could have said "Ariana did well, but I personally think Mariah is better." See? It says your opinion, without being a douchebag. You should try it.
i'm a dick and a douchebag because I dislike Ariana Grande? Im sure she's a sweet girl but her voice I just find irritating.. she yells too much like she's trying too hard.. that's my opinion you don't have to like it Cat lol
I'm fine with you not liking her, completely. But I'm not fine with you putting her down because you don't like her. You may find her voice annoying, but her talent is fact, not opinion. If she wasn't talented, she wouldn't have ever been compared to someone as good as Mariah. Dislike Ariana, love Mariah, do what you want. But don't put her down because you like Mariah.
Ariana has a nice upper register. But Mariah hits her low notes with such ease, fluidity, and richness. Ariana is very inconsistent is this part of her voice. Gonna have to go with Mariah.
This comparison is so ridiculous...ariana is not trying to be mariah...why can't the world just appreciate different talents...i know I'm gonna get 8000 mariah fans telling me my opinion is wrong but ariana will always be better in my eyes!!! She is queen and i think she is better than mariah...after that tree lighting mess, ariana will always be seen as a better singer to me...go ahead and give me hate but honestly your opinion means nothing to me and i don't care what you have to say to me
Did you read the info of the video? The video isn't meant to be that way. Btw you shouldn't compare current Mariah to Ariana. Mariah is a lot older and has vocal nodes. Ariana could sound the same or worse when she gets to Mariah's age.
xlllxEoNxlllx have you heard her emotions cover??? And i don't Care that you think Mariah is better, i don't...just accept my opinion and leave me alone please
Hey Dina, I respect your opinion. You like Ariana better, and that is perfectly fine. You brought up the tree lighting performance as if to discredit Mariah's great vocals. You have to keep in mind that Mariah has been performing over 20 years, and recorded 14 albums + other singles. To top that, her songs are some of the most difficult to sing. Her vocals are worn, and that will eventually happen to Ariana Grande if she works nonstop like Mariah did. Outside of the digitally enhanced studio world, Ariana would not attempt to sing a Mariah song, more so because she acknowledges the fact that she can't live up to it.
Angelfully i understand that Mariahs vocals are worn because of years of performing and that that will eventually happen to ari but its funny how your are arguing that my opinion is wrong...i think ariana is better and that's my opinion do plz leave
Ariana is a great singer, But Mariah will be remembered for hopefully hundreds of years, there will never be another to match her in her prime. She has inspired 10's of millions of young and old people to sing. Mariah isnt just about range, its about her breath taking tone control and resonance. No need to mention Mariahs the greatest female song writer in history.
😱😂Pffft. Of course she out sings them. They're on entirely different levels. Vocal peers to Ariana: Demi, Tori, Adele, Beyoncé, Christina, Some members of FH, etc. Vocal peers to Selena: Rihanna, Katy, Miley, Fergie, JLo, Other members of FH, etc. 💯
All the people saying Ariana's better than Mariah are the uneducated millennials who don't know Mariah at her prime and compares CURRENT Mariah to a YOUNG Ariana. Mariah in her Prime VS. Ariana Grande now? We will never get another Mariah Carey in our lifetime. Irreplaceable.
THE ONLY THING I CAN SAY IS: ONLY MARIAH'S INTRO FOR "You're So Cold", KILLS ARIANA, RIHANNA, KATY, CELINE, BEYONCÈ, ADELE, WHITNEY, MADONNA, SHANIA, TONI, TAMAR, LEONA, SHAKIRA, BOTH KELLYS, FERGIE, JLO, DEMI, ARETHA, DIONNE, REGINE, CHARICE, PATTI, MILEY, ELLA, DENIECE, DONNA, DIANA AND SELENA GOMEZ ENTIRE COLECTIVES VOCALS :)
We actually haven't seen anyone to compete with the holy trinity of music yet - Mariah, Whitney and Celine. Adelle and Christina are pretty strong but not on that level.
I agree that is Christina didn't spend half the time showing off her voice and stuck to singing the song than she could be incredible. I really thought she would've improved more with age and experience about controlling her voice and how to make a song really effective, sadly I think her ego gets in the way. She's incredibly talented though.
When Ariana first made her breakthrough, people were saying she was going to be the next Mariah. Fast forward to 2019, I'm still not seeing how Ariana is anything like Mariah vocally. Ariana has a great voice and she's not bad, but that's about it. Mariah, especially 90s to early 2000s Prime Mariah, far surpasses anything Ariana has shown since her debut. Even if Mariah doesn't sound like she did during her prime years, she can still sing circles around the majority of mainstream singers, including Ariana.
@@MrMan-vn7rg there is no next nobody. We didnt say mariah is next whoever so why say that about ariana? Everyone is different and no one needs replacing.
@@vg6761 omg gurl I never said that if you even had social media you would know when Ari covered emotions people tried to replace her in the industry and end Mariah’s career Mariah didn’t do that Ari’s fans did that to her so don’t play like the lambs are bad
Arianna is good by today's standards but had this been the 60s 70s 80s 90s I doubt she would be as big as she is.... With that being said Mariah wins this for me!
If you think Ariana is better than Mariah you must be under 18, tone death or in denial 😂 Ariana has great vocals but she sings from her nose and pushes her voice too much. You can't understand her half the time and she has no soul in her voice. Ariana also sounds squeaky when she belts like her voice is gonna crack at anytime Mariah on the other hand has great technique, can sing high and low with ease. Her voice is also louder and stronger when she belts. You can understand her words and she sings with emotion. Her voice is amazing
+Cat wut haha dont make me laugh, mariah produces her own music, writes her own music wrotes co wrote 17 out of her 18 number 1 single, 4 of her songs from her first album been number, can you tell me how many number 1 songs ariana got now just kindly update me, besides whats her latest single dangerous woman when christina ate her whole in their performance on the voice, most of all i wanna see her sing live if its over of mariah carey flawlessly
zero lamperouge Don't be ignorant. I didn't mention sales, just critical acclaim (for the record Ariana's single 'Problem' sold 7.5 million - more than ANY of Mariah's singles from a studio album). It's a simple fact that Ariana's albums have received much better scores from media critics than Mariah's did. That's all I was saying. If you want proof, I can link to the wikipedia pages?
zero lamperouge Success doesn't determine how good someone is. Critics say that Ariana is even better than Mariah. And because they analyse music for a living, who are we to say it's wrong. Mariah was better at singing and producing hits. Ariana is overall a better artist. That's my opinion anyway (and critics.)
Ariana loses support from B4 on, sounds scretchy, throaty and tensioned, her lows aren't that low and barely audible and. Mariah notes here were all supported and can support lower notes and go higher than the notes displayed here, she is definitely the best singer, there is not even comparison
Don't get me wrong ariana can sing but her high notes does sound like a whimpering dog in comparison to marriage effortless on point high notes....also notice it's a lot of effort for ariana to reach those notes but for mariah it's just so naturally for to hit it plus it's sounds nice to the ear where as Arianas sound a bit like dog whistle when she's trying like too hard
But ariana is in her 20's, mariah was 19 when she started making it big and her best years were when she was starting out in her 19 to 20's. Also Ariana has been in musical showbizz since very young 14 (musical show victorious) .....BUT lol mariahs mum was an Opera singer and a vocal coach so I guess mariah had a lot of training as well but naturally her voice has been stronger and better range
You can see from F5 Ariana starts screaming (singing technique to heat the note) also her volume almost disappear. Mariah actually hits the notes and still maintains full volume. Sit down Ariana you are not match....
Mariah can hit the lowest notes much better than Ariana, and she also hits the highest notes way better. Her whistle register is more powerful and can be held for longer notes, her vocals in general are stronger in all registers, thicker and truly soulful, unlike Ariana, that sounds to thin and poppish, and that has a weak whistle that she can hold only in short notes. Also, unlike Mariah, Ariana tends to exaggerate and force her vocal acrobatics, a bit like Xtina Aguilera. Now, I have heard Ariana singing in a more soulful way, but it seems her producers, just like they did with Britney and the first 2 years with Xtina, want to ruin her voice by making her sing with a poppish, childish voice.
Andrew Charalambous Ariana did it and you have to deal with that: Ariana began to take of Mariah's breathy, angelic sound. She she began to mimick Mariah's tone. Songs: Mariah-Copycat Impossible-Wit it for christmas I've been thinking about you-Too close Secret love-Baby I I'll be lovin' you long time-Lovin' it. She also used almost the same clothes that Mariah has used. She did the same damn dance step in "Problem", that Mariah used in "Honey". Copycat Grande copied Mariah blantantly in music videos: It's like that-Right there-> it's the same thematic and the most obvious lol. Don't forget about us-Problem->Baby doll pose. My all, The roof-Love me harder. It's so sad to see the lack of originality that Copycat has hahahaha.
Andrew Charalambous You should abstain from writing shit. Let's talk when Ariana is 46, meanwhile you must compare them at the same age. "Slays" with her terrible technique, bitch you wish.
Nelly MSP if you're basing your 'views' off of RUclips, you're wrong. Her songs came out way before RUclips, so stfu. you know nothing, go back to msp where you belong immature bitch.
Ariana sings with no soul at all. She's so robotic. I always wondered what I disliked about her and now I realize. She hits every note the same no matter what song she's singing.
A few things I have to say to the complainers.I tried to make this video as fair as possible, because I am a fan of both and I don't believe in making biased videos.
1. I used Mariah's "old" notes because she was closer to Ariana's age. It was just fair
2. Some of Mariah's notes are louder because I downloaded a concert, and all the footage from that concert is loud. I tried to increase Ariana's volume, but Windows Movie Maker is a bad editing program. When I played the video back, it did absolutely nothing for her volume. When I tried to lower Mariah's, I could barely hear it.
3. All of the notes on here are completely live, except two of Mariah's notes (edit: Ariana's F6 and F#6 are playbacks as well). This was in effort to showcase Ariana's upper belting range. Secondly I did not do Mariah's full live vocal range because it would not be fair. She has over five octaves and Ariana does not
Eya Xo the clips are from when they were closer in age.. He just said that.
Angelfully
hey! dont hate on windows movie maker, it may be simplistic but it's free firstly and secondly it's simple to use... i cried trying cyberlink powerdirector and i was like... yeap sticking to wlmm lol :P
Angelfully
hey angelfully! where did you get ariana's Eb3 from?
Angelfully To be fair, Ariana's F6 in The Way was also lipped. Not the one at the Ellen show, the first one with VMA in the corner.
Angelfully I think Jessie J has a pretty damn high voice. I think you should make one with Jessie/Ari/Mariah.
As much as I'd want Ariana to win this, Mariah's vocals are simply legendary and of that of another scale to Ariana's.
I love u for being an Ariana fan yet not being butt hurt about Mariahs talented voice and I luv them both but honestly come on,im glad u have enough common sense to admit the obvious!
+#Lambily Is strong!!
Mariah voice is way more louder and more powerful
ArianaGrandeVevo o wtf
VERY true. Ariana has this type of squeakin her vocals. I'll be honest, i can't listen to Ariana with the music on high. imo.
7:14-Mariah and 7:21... exactly one of my examples. I heard power AND emotion in Mariah's voice--and then there's Ariana who sounded like a hamster with all that squeakiness. The faces i was making while listening to her was unconrolable. lol
duyen nguyen say what?
Fiesty Chick, Ari does lack power in her whistle register. I thought I was the only one thinking this.
Mariah, in her prime, can not be compared to Ariana. Mariah's voice is much more striking, strong, full of emotion. As our friend said down here, Mariah is a legend. We will thank her for so many wonderful songs that she sang throughout her career. Today we know her voice is no longer the same, but deserves all our respect. Incomparable.
Diogo Stewan exactly!
Amen preach it.
Mariah's voice is LITERALLY a *Butterfly.* It has this sort of Metamorphosis that it undergoes EACH and EVERY era of her albums.
Her voice is not "literally" a butterfly. 🙄
Her voice is always in constant change .. and I love it, her tones, voices, textures and colors🧡🍂🦋
Mariah's not just a teacher. She's a professor, a master of vocal
She's got the Ph.D, she's the dean lol
Mariah's the subject. And Ariana's failing in it..
CassieJazz96 Hahaha spot on!
Abdullah Abbas Come on, I think she passing: barely! Lol jk Ariana's actually a great singer. Mariah is unbelievable!
Abdullah Abbas where ???????????
Is it me or the higher Ari goes it's more difficult to understand what she says?
its not just you ..
I've always noticed that I think her articulation isn't good (even though I'm French)
just you
For me, it is I like I can listen to the note but have no idea what she is saying
Rafa Medina I know right! The higher Ariana goes, the more she sounds like she has a mouthful of almonds whilst singing. I guess that's what happens when you spend to much time emulating somebody else's technique rather than minding enunciation. Lol.
Whilst Ariana is a very good singer, no one and I mean NO ONE matches Mariah's prime. Her prime cannot be touched.
Justin Carbon HELL NO
Justin Carbon No Mariah In Her Prime 1990-1996 Is So Invincible Even After Her Prime She Is Still So Invincible Because Of Her Insane Runs&Riffs And Melismas specially during Rainbow And Butterfly
Supreme Master 101 The funny thing is Mariah never had a prime becuz of her nodules her "prime" was far below levels of her "true prime" if she doesnt have the vocal nodules
Mahzyy_
I disagree
Mahzyy_
Wasn’t asking. Besides, Celine can hit the notes and all, but Mariah makes them sound beautiful.
I am an Arinator but when I whached this video I'm like DAMN!!Y'all should not compare Mariah to anyone. She the QUEEN💎
If they are of same age there will be bloodshed
@@jaguarmilo3231 wdym?
I can only compare ari by the fanbase you’re right
Ariana is very talented and has an extraordinary voice.
But Mariah in the 90s and early 2000s is much better
Thank you! This is a fair opinion! I'm glad to see someone give credit where it's due to both artists, instead of rising one up and putting the other down.
90s-2010
It is astonishing how great Ariana Grande's voice is. But it was sadly destroyed by Mariah note by note. Just goes to show on what level Mariah was in her prime.
I'm sorry but just like the late Ms. Houston... there will never be another Mariah Carey..
Idk why these new girls even try.
I concur
so true.. mariah is the queen 👑
exactly.
Anyone in this world is not replaceable. It is the nature ! So simple and people start to make this comparison just to get attention and viewers. The world would be better if people stop making these stupid comparison. All we have are preferences. if I like Ariana more than Mariah it just my test and people around me have to respect or vice versa. My mother always says: what would be of the green colour if everyone would like purple? lol
Ariana is so talented but Mariah's ability is just on a whole other level :O
I'm a huge Ariana Grande fan but let's be real here, Mariah Carey is a legend. It's a compliment that Ariana gets compared to Mariah. But I believe Ariana has one of the best voices in this generation.
AGREE!
right you are good sir
Wrong Charice is one of the best vocalist in this Generation
Uh, Sharice isn't anymore. Sadly, I heard that she had taken Male Hormones and it has lowered her voice. It really is ashame.
*Charice
Ariana's voice is too safe. It's beautiful to listen to her alone but standing next to Mariah, that's another level of understanding. Mariah's voice is a trademark. Nobody can imitate that voice. But I bet there's many Arianas out there, if you know what I mean. Prove me wrong if you don't agree. :-)
~high five~
You nailed it(well said)
Hands down best comment so far
best comment
Ariana is the closest thing to Mariah so their ain't many Ariana's cuz she the only one can do the notes an scream Mariah is just has a bigger voice Ariana' is still young don't forget that
Mariah is queen. like, it's not even possible to compare their skill level.
Sanchita Chakrabarty It is but you can't because you are stupid
@@arianastasiagrande8428 You can't compare a Legend to a Basic Pop Girlie
@@arianastasiagrande8428 Bitch c'mon! You know a Airiana next Mariah is a back up singer 😂😂😂
@@laura6360 Then that would be unfair already cause it's in Daydream-Butterfly era, one song would already beat her, even the Daydream interlude (Her intro song before the concert starts)
@@laura6360 ariana had more technique? lmfao
Mariah win , Her voice is amazing in every octave . She sing deeper than Ariana in low octave . Her high note is so smooth . Ariana's note sound very sharp
Mariah Carey: *The Songbird Surpreme*
Ariana Grande: *The Mockingbird*
HAHAHA CLEVER!
Haha! This made me laugh. I like Ari though.
Lissandra Freljord I kind of like her. I have no reason to dislike her, so her soul doesn't bother me
Because she is able to sing she's mocking Mariah? I love Mariah and I acknowledge her vocal talent but you stans do the absolute most. Both are talented and you shouldn't try to bring Ariana down instead you should be happy that she can even be compared to Mariah. Mariah's voice isn't what it used to be anyhow.
Sera Johnson "You stans do the absolute most..."
I agree that your essay in my reply is *absolute most*. Ariana's stans call her Mariah's replacement all the time, so my comment is well placed. Besides, Ariana's voice isn't that good.
low notes: mariah carey
mid belts: mariah carey
high belts: mariah carey
head voice: mariah carey..
whistle notes: mariah carey..
this pretty much sums it up lol
FACT.
well as of now ari takes upper belts and arguably falsetto (atleast imo)
Mariah Carey all the way
Judy 17 funny
@@hhsjsjense7537 stfu
Ari all the way
Without music? Mariah vocal is instrument. Mariah goddess of music.
No ari
When Mariah was Arianas age she was singing way better than Ariana can ever do now. Its only fair to compare old footage of when she was younger. Lets face it Arianas voice will never live up to Mariahs.
Good Man Yasss
Good Man and the thing is, mariah can still outsing her aha
Justin Carbon Stop Using Uppercase Letter On Each Word.
Good Man ariana is way better: ruclips.net/video/6kSl6j8nNOM/видео.html
Riri Work If Mariah sing live I'll be an Alien
Mariah Carey single handily changed the industry. Her voice, her songwriting, and producing. This lady’s Christmas song is old as me. She’s still around touring every single day of the year nonstop. That speaks to her legacy.
Mariah Carey is vocally superior.
***end of discussion***
@@cl7717 The same as 3 years ago
@@cl7717 Still lol
Mariah is irrelevant now y'all stop💀replying to an old comment😂💀
@@cl7717 If that's irrelevant then I want to be that irrelevant
Mariah&WhitneyLamb yasss
no doubt ariana is an amazing singer. but she doesnt stand against mariah carey. and i dont mean only her - NOBODY can beat mariah. she's a freaking legend.
wait Ari can beat Mariah :)
+Ariana Horan she cant beat Mariah, even in her worst times
Philip Vicencio well mariah was ten times better than ariana she was the same age as ariana is now but now im not too sure just cause she's in like 45? now
+julie franco worst times as in her prime - if she was sick or something like that at Ariana's age
+Ariana Horan NO, and even if she beat Mariah in singing, people will still love Mariah more than Ariana because originality is the best quality.
Mariah wins by far. Much fuller and mature voice, more resonance, more creativity and you can really understand what she sings when she sings high :)
YOU CANNOT COMPARE ARIANA TO MARIAH.
Mariah has a legendary voice, Ariana is simply a pop star with a nice voice.
+Aidan Totally agree!!!!!
+Martina Candelaria Mariah wasn't even famous in the 70s or 80s
+Julian Grimes okay?
Ariana is certainly not just a pop star with a good voice. She is a pop star with a legendary voice. she was invited to the White House for the Women of Soul performance along with other legends like pattie labelle, Aretha frankin, and Melissa etheridge. She is probably the most talented pop artist to have as many hit singles as she had in 2015. Mariah has an amazing performance ethic and voice while Ariana gets very nervous for big performances so sometimes her raw talent doesn't shine all the way through in her performances. But she still manages to blow the audience away: if you look at more performances she's done like tattooed heart at the 2014 amas, some of her acoustic performances, and many more you can clearly see that she has a legendary voice, just like Mariah. Plus, Mariahs voice isn't that legendary anymore, I'm sure you've seen her All I want for Christmas performance at the Rockefeller center.
+julia grande that was a year ago and Mariah also have nodules. This year she did it great Mariah is a true legend.
Judging technically:
Lower Register: OH Mariah. You definitely win in this vocal register. Much better support. Can make her larynx stable. Dark and Resonant. Doesn't dissipate like air rushing outside a popped tire. And can sustain too.
Belts: Mariah. Legendary resonance. Better pitch. Better breath control and sustain. Supports her belts. Much stable larynx. Better vibrato(ariana's are sometimes uneven and wobbly).
Falsetto: Mariah. Greater agility and pitch.
Head Voice: Mariah. Ariana doesn't use it.
Whistle: Mariah easily. Ariana has only shown it once and it's in the studio.
Ariana has a long way to go to be able to challenge the Queen.
Totally agree!
Why?
99 % goes to Mariah and the 1% goes to Ariana and that is the truth
yep!
+Lamb Forever Yaaaasss! Agreed!
Let's put it this way. Mariah Carey made her own name in the music industry competing to the top female singers such as Celine Dion and Whitney Houston. Ariana Grande compare to Mariah Carey. It's like comparing Buggati and Mercedes.
Different tones of voices. Ariana hits the high notes just like Mariah Carey and just cause she doesn't sound exactly like her doesn't mean she can't sing. and also they lowered the volume on her parts to makes mariah's one sound even louder. I hate people I swear 😒
Kelsayy A Ariana's voice is unoriginal and her high notes are light and Mariah's are powerful
Kelsayy A They hit the same notes but they are on equal. Ariana mixed her belts better and she could go higher and sustain her mixing belts as well. However, Mariah's blooming spot lies in her mids and uppers up to around G5 and she only sustains to F5s. She's got the whistle up to Bb7, though and she was/is more agile at it.
The current Ariana supports up to B4/C5 but barely resonates while Mariah’s soars up to even G5. What’s the point of belting higher than Mariah while she couldn’t even support? That’s bad for her. I’d wish she can work on those to be better future. But downline-No, Ariana can’t be compared with Mariah. She’s way below Mariah, that’s just too unfair.
Younger Ariana (before fame) produces large resonance though, I missed her old days
Neungkrub TS Actually Ariana is not best at Mixing .. i wont say Head dominant is bad but it makes her voice is light and unpowerful while Mariah can belt balanced .. if you want hear Head Dominant so amazing .. go watch SoHyang .. she is using Head Dominant constant but her resonance makes it powerful
Listening to Ariana is like listening to a very good singer from earth. Listening to Mariah is like listening to an Angel from Heaven... simply Magical.
Thank you
Agreed
For real? Ariana doesn't touch Mariah. Yes, they can both go high but Mariah's voice is smoother and she has a very low register as well. Not to mention Mariah's songs are so much more classic. Problem and Side to Side are never going to become beloved songs in the long run.
Melanie P ikr preach
lololo 🙌🙌🙌
at least ariana isnt trash now, also ariana slays mariah because she can hit those low notes
jasmine on pointe Oh Yea a C#3 compared to an E2 !!Nice try , until she can actually hit it in a neutral larynx than we can talk
no she cant lol. ariana cant sale with her voice like mariah. adele has that spot in this generation. ariana isnt special like mariah. mariah innovated and broke down barriers. she had a solid tone all the way through and a limitless range. all ariana has is range and some soft runs. her voice is small. thats why her ballads are not as effective.
Don't even compare the two. Mariah is queen.
Say it!
aaliyah Yeaaa!!!!
lustforlove OK Grandma
@@arianastasiagrande8428 what happened to your grandma 😥
Mahzyy_ they’re not being mean, just saying that Mariah is obviously better than Ari. 🤷🏾♀️
mariah carey, celine dion, whitney houston ..you can never compare with this, QUEENS pls respect.
Then why can she do a perfect impression of all 3 and have her own voice
@@illestbobby5231 call me when she can even begin to match any of their techniques
Ear th yesssss thats right
Who? 🤣
But Mariah and Whitney are quite a bit more agile than Celine, and that’s a fact, not an opinion. Even look up videos comparing them. Celine has absolutely beautiful tone though. I’m just being objective. The third member of the vocal trinity is still yet to be found. Sorry, but it’s true.
Ariana needs to learn to enunciate. That's my biggest pet peeve with her voice. She'll still never touch Mariah of course
Right i can barely understand what she be saying😂😂
It’s stylistic, I love her but I agree it’s really hard to understand her. But from some videos she can but she doesn’t choose to.
okay but we’re talking about vocals in this video..
She did. She grew up doing musical theatre but as her style developed
i’m super late, but she has gotten better at that!
The Difference between Mariah Carey is her Voice and Pronunciation is more Clearer than Ariana Grande. Ariana Grande sang though her nose which means she staining. Yet Mariah Carey Sing Effortlessly Clear. Still both are Great Singers
RebelliousBarbie Mukbangs absolutely right!!!
RebelliousBarbie Mukbangs being nasal doesn't mean you're straining but it still bad technique
I just commented on that, I cannot understand what Ariana is singing. Especially in that whitney Houston cover of I believe in you and me.
RebelliousBarbie Mukbangs • ASMR Mariah's music is also far, far better, even now.
She used to sound more clear now she just mumbles
Most of Ariana belted notes were very unstable and really "weak/inconsistent" back then, she improved a bit now (and I'm happy for her), but she still can't match Mariah's quality (I'm not even talking about resonance). So "the new Mariah" title that media and some fans put on Ariana was just another failed experiment.
Thi Hills Music good presentation of mariah un christmas e xd
Mariah's resonance itself kills everything Ariana has ever done..
Thi Hills Music i agree. And Lambs just need tl give a chance to improve her self she started to wake up on her life and im sure till her new era she will prove alot and the comparisons are older then what u thing. People compared mariah to whitney and people compared whitney to Aretha and before people compared Aretha to Ella and there will be people that will say that Mariah and whitney are nothing near Aretha and Ella.
Arianators don’t want Ariana to be the next Mariah😊 Ariana is Ariana.
Well but when Mariah came out you could tell she was not only an amazing vocalist from the very first live, but also a unique all around singer. Nobody in their sane mind would think that about Ariana. The "New Mariah" is only a marketing label to give the girl some credit and sales. If Ariana were the New Mariah, she would already have couple of hot 100 number 1s and two grammys.
When ariana sing i dont understand what she sing.mariah sing from her heart and soul
Not even close. Mimi kills her on every note. But have y'all noticed how when Mimi belts she significantly furthers the microphone away from her mouth and Ariana glues it to her mouth and Mimi still sounds more powerful. Damn baby
And mariah sang in 90s, with less sophisticated sound system and all than nowadays
So basically people are saying that Ariana copies Mariah because of what? because they can hit the same notes? Smh.
That's Ariana's voice! She aint trying to copy nobody! She said herself that shes forbidden to sing with a false voice bc it hurts her voice.
So people are hating on Ariana for singing with her own voice. They dont sing the same kind of music, dont dress the same, dont act the same,have different voices.... wow Ariana is copying Mariah!
Hayes D Her management is trying so hard to make her as the 'new mariah'. Also, people are not hating on Ariana for her voice. It's just that the style she sings in is a direct copy of heavily imitated of mariah.
Ryan Smith Ariana's style is not even similar to Mariah. Mariah has more vibratto and holds the notes longer.
Im saying in terms of how ariana's melismas and vocal runs and such
Ryan Smith but a lot of artists can do that
No just a video
There's no comparison really. Mariah is a legend! Ariana has a long way to go. She will never reach or even come close to mc's fame, talent and achievements. No other female artist in that matter. Smdh
ArianaGrandeVevo o That doesn't mean anything in terms , Mariah had a stronger voice and way better technique
Whitney was wonderful, don't doub it, but don't compare her with Mariah, she was wonderful, but Mariah is not only a great singer, she is also producer and songwriter, NO ONE like her!! she has been also very important in the music industry, also an inspiration for many singers, like this Ariana Grande, I don't know who is she...
she is still famous, and she actually sells a lot of albums, I just think it's not fair to compare her with a young talent, she has run a looong hard road. and opened doors for many artists today, it's not something about generations, it's just for me there's no comparison, Mariah is Mariah, no one like her, nobody can surpass her and be better than her. That's my opinion. I've studied music for 12 years, it's my career and I can't find a better singer than Mariah, she can sings whatever she wants, including opera
+ArianaGrandeVevo o And Mariah is the song bird supreme, don't forget that.
Even if Ari has a long way to go, remember at the age Ari is now, Mariah was making famous hits like "emotions", "can't let go" for example and also her famous "Merry Christmas Album". Ari is far behind what Mariah was in her day.
Mariah Carey has more range (B2-B7), Is a songwriter, impeccable technique, Achievements. Her voice is more powerful and resonates throughout her range. she can play with her range anyway she wants with so much control and precision. On Ariana's defense, I can say she doesn't have the experience and the lengthy career that Mariah has. Maybe her technique improves and maybe she'll hit those low notes someday.
F2-F#8
@@MC-wd7jc maybe she has more range in the low part because she got old, and her F2 score was reached after that....
@@lucasdean9358her F2 is from 2003 in a tribute to stevie wonder
I really wish people would stop putting Ariana in these vocal comparisons with legends like Mariah, Whitney, Beyonce, Leona..Just cause the girl can hit a strained high note doesn't automatically give her the right to be compared to people who support the same note effortlessly..
Aurora You clearly don't know anything about vocal technique. She is a star vocalist, she is up there
@Aurora Beyoncé actually doesn't use Auto tune and is a wonderful vocalist
Probably the reason why ariana is always compared to Legends because she's talented.
Aurora Beyonce is definitely up there. sorry bud, but it's true
@@cloroxbleach1342 yess
This is like comparing Michael Jackson to Justine Bieber, something you just don't do
wouldn't even put anyone on michaels level
ahahahahaha lmao
Exactly!
Justin bieber is no where near Michael Jackson's level bieber is good but not that good
+Brad Peat basically like comparing nutella to crunchy peanaut butter.
Ariana has definitely improved from these clips you used, she definitely not on Mariah level but shes finding her voice tho
Mariah has the Soul, R&B, and Pop trio in her voice.
Until Ariana can even attempt to top Mariah's runs and vocal range in her single "Butterfly" I'll never be convinced.
to the new generation. don't get it twisted .. Mariah is a WOMANN with one of the powerful voices to ever grace the mic okay??? Ariana is a little girl with dreams to achieve a fraction of what Mariah has accomplished in her lifetime.. she can't hold a candle to her and never will.. there is no comparison i'm sure even Mariah would find it cute. at 16:02 I rest my case.
You do realise that the fact Ariana is being compared to Mariah says how good Ariana is. It's fine loving Mariah, but you don't need to put down other artists to do that. Instead of being a dick about it, you could have said "Ariana did well, but I personally think Mariah is better." See? It says your opinion, without being a douchebag. You should try it.
i'm a dick and a douchebag because I dislike Ariana Grande? Im sure she's a sweet girl but her voice I just find irritating.. she yells too much like she's trying too hard.. that's my opinion you don't have to like it Cat lol
I'm fine with you not liking her, completely. But I'm not fine with you putting her down because you don't like her. You may find her voice annoying, but her talent is fact, not opinion. If she wasn't talented, she wouldn't have ever been compared to someone as good as Mariah.
Dislike Ariana, love Mariah, do what you want. But don't put her down because you like Mariah.
okay Cat.. you have a point my favorite song from her is Love Me Harder with the Weeknd :P
Awesome, I like that one too. Ironically the song I'm really obsessed with at the moment is Emotions.
Ariana has a nice upper register. But Mariah hits her low notes with such ease, fluidity, and richness. Ariana is very inconsistent is this part of her voice. Gonna have to go with Mariah.
for those who say Mariah cant sing anymore these days..please comment back here when Ariana reach 46 years old😊
Mariah sings very well right now see a caution album
@@thefun512 & Quarantine era is 🔥
@@charlie27203 yes I agree with you my comment is one year old
@@thefun512 🐑 🐑❤️❤️
Maybe ari can still nail it, like patti labelle still nail it in her 70s. but let's not forget she doesn't have nodule issue
This comparison is so ridiculous...ariana is not trying to be mariah...why can't the world just appreciate different talents...i know I'm gonna get 8000 mariah fans telling me my opinion is wrong but ariana will always be better in my eyes!!! She is queen and i think she is better than mariah...after that tree lighting mess, ariana will always be seen as a better singer to me...go ahead and give me hate but honestly your opinion means nothing to me and i don't care what you have to say to me
Did you read the info of the video? The video isn't meant to be that way. Btw you shouldn't compare current Mariah to Ariana. Mariah is a lot older and has vocal nodes. Ariana could sound the same or worse when she gets to Mariah's age.
xlllxEoNxlllx have you heard her emotions cover??? And i don't Care that you think Mariah is better, i don't...just accept my opinion and leave me alone please
Hey Dina, I respect your opinion. You like Ariana better, and that is perfectly fine. You brought up the tree lighting performance as if to discredit Mariah's great vocals. You have to keep in mind that Mariah has been performing over 20 years, and recorded 14 albums + other singles. To top that, her songs are some of the most difficult to sing. Her vocals are worn, and that will eventually happen to Ariana Grande if she works nonstop like Mariah did. Outside of the digitally enhanced studio world, Ariana would not attempt to sing a Mariah song, more so because she acknowledges the fact that she can't live up to it.
Angelfully i understand that Mariahs vocals are worn because of years of performing and that that will eventually happen to ari but its funny how your are arguing that my opinion is wrong...i think ariana is better and that's my opinion do plz leave
Dina Richards I did not say your opinion was wrong, I was refuting what you said about Mariah's tree lighting performance. Don't be so defensive :)
Mariah Sang AND composed most of her hits
Mariah have G2 and G#7 SHIT UP
Daniel San F2-Bb7 just to correct
No she does have a B7 in studio it's harmonised I don't remember the name of the song tho.
TayTay BeyNippy live she did a C8
TayTay BeyNippy her highest notes live are a Bb7 and a note thats off the piano. A person who helped her warm up is a reliable source
Her highest note is F#8
Mariah carey is often imitated never duplicated 💝best selling female singer of all time.legendary and unique💖
No madoona is best selling artist
@@fnb8171biggest* best selling is for those who sold most in a certain time frame which is Mariah, Biggest is for OVERALL
Mariah carey mariah carey 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
❤❤❤❤❤❤
abiya Ali ....yessss mariah.....
Mariah is a vocal goddess and it’s a shame how damn perfect her voice is unbelievable
mariah is soooooooooooo much better
Better but not by much
Jayden Phillips you must be stupid or something
TroxpicOcean Ariana is better
@@acua2leody569 funny joke🤣
Ariana is a great singer, But Mariah will be remembered for hopefully hundreds of years, there will never be another to match her in her prime. She has inspired 10's of millions of young and old people to sing. Mariah isnt just about range, its about her breath taking tone control and resonance.
No need to mention Mariahs the greatest female song writer in history.
DayDream Album 1996 Destroys Ariana Whole Existence !!! hahahahha
Thumbs up if you Agree
Then And Now Official *1995*
i'm a real arianator, yes, mariah has a better voice, but you gotta admit it, ariana can outsing her peers, (selena, fifth harmony)
+ArvinAlviar of coarse Bridget Mendler need to come out she has pipes to.
😱😂Pffft. Of course she out sings them. They're on entirely different levels.
Vocal peers to Ariana: Demi, Tori, Adele, Beyoncé, Christina, Some members of FH, etc.
Vocal peers to Selena: Rihanna, Katy, Miley, Fergie, JLo, Other members of FH, etc.
💯
Honestly, don't even compare Selena to Ari xD..Selena can't sing for her life
+AxjionAlesandres
who of Fifth Harmony
Hahaha TOTALLY AGREE :V
All the people saying Ariana's better than Mariah are the uneducated millennials who don't know Mariah at her prime and compares CURRENT Mariah to a YOUNG Ariana. Mariah in her Prime VS. Ariana Grande now? We will never get another Mariah Carey in our lifetime. Irreplaceable.
I was just on tiktok arguing with 13 year olds calling ARIANA the queen of r&b
Mariah is the queen 😍❤❤❤
Legend
THE ONLY THING I CAN SAY IS:
ONLY MARIAH'S INTRO FOR "You're So Cold", KILLS ARIANA, RIHANNA, KATY, CELINE, BEYONCÈ, ADELE, WHITNEY, MADONNA, SHANIA, TONI, TAMAR, LEONA, SHAKIRA, BOTH KELLYS, FERGIE, JLO, DEMI, ARETHA, DIONNE, REGINE, CHARICE, PATTI, MILEY, ELLA, DENIECE, DONNA, DIANA AND SELENA GOMEZ ENTIRE COLECTIVES VOCALS :)
but it depends, Mariah is obviously one of the best in a lot of vocal aspects, but Whitney and Patti also has a lot of vocal aspects that are better.
Beyoncé
maray isn't the Best singer hás a lot of opera singer that beat her easily
+Bey Stick that sentence was a fuck up from the start (literally).
Bey Stick Opera singer aren't in the mainstream category lol and you even said "Beyoncé" that was funny
It comes natural to Mariah - seems like a struggle for Ariana.
😒😒 uhmm.....Mariah is clearly the QUEEN!!!!!
Zandy Moyo ....Not even close
@@arianastasiagrande8428 you must be born in the 2000's or 2010's.
@@ricque9459 I'm born in 2002,and i know the mariah's voice is very satisfied than ariana to hear (in the same age of course)
@@arianastasiagrande8428 tasteless kid
*CLEARLY*
Well see if Ariana Grande still sounds the same when she ages like Mariah.. Mariah can be imitated but Can Never Be Duplicated. I love Mariah
Mariah Carey is a living legend. She can still sing better than Ariana, and other singers nowadays.
I'm not agree with you because Ariana can sing she's not like Selena or justin demi and ari are the best singer of our generation
Díselo al concierto de año nuevo XD
@@kissheyla4603 yesss
Yes, Mariah's supported range IN 2020 is bigger than Ariana's, has better resonance, enunciation and agility
We actually haven't seen anyone to compete with the holy trinity of music yet - Mariah, Whitney and Celine. Adelle and Christina are pretty strong but not on that level.
Melanie P Beyoncé. I don't think Christina or Adele match.
Melanie P If Xtina had a decent technique maybe but Adele? Adele is literal trash
I agree that is Christina didn't spend half the time showing off her voice and stuck to singing the song than she could be incredible. I really thought she would've improved more with age and experience about controlling her voice and how to make a song really effective, sadly I think her ego gets in the way. She's incredibly talented though.
Dangerous Guy AKA Sparksy Chill Adele is not trash. It's her technique, that's the problem.
adele sorry? she's -b rated by the criticts. the way she sings damage her. she has a bad technique also.
Mariah Is A Queen
No
@@unknownkid3142 stfu
@@courtneyjaylyn1335 you really have the queen as your profile picture 😂 you dont have the rights to talk anymore. Bye bitch
@@unknownkid3142 The person said Mariah is a Queen not Mariah is the queen of England stupid bitch.
@@unknownkid3142 notice how nobody liked ur comment besides YOU when u said ‘no’
I do not know much about singing but Mariah's voice sounds spectacular as an angel but powerful
MARIAH IS MARIAH QUEEEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tatjana Todorovic Yes grandma
@@arianastasiagrande8428 child. You 12?
Why comparing? Why not accepting them as two great individual singers?
Thank you🙏🙏
+Sara D what if people just wanted a comparison and still respect them as individuel singers, like me for instance?
Right
+Sara D Because Mariah is a legend and comparing her to Ariana is offensive.
They both are good and I think that Ariana will turn out to be a legend, just not exactly like Mariah
Mariah win it.
She's a legend..But to be honest,Ariana Grande are really good.
Pulchérie. Yes finally some one gets it
Mariah is so much better don't compare her to Ariana.
Come on she's not that better
¯¯¯¯¯
Maria X coming from a lamb??? weird, of all the people out there, the lambs knows Mimi’s vocal prowess and talent in general 💀
When Ariana first made her breakthrough, people were saying she was going to be the next Mariah. Fast forward to 2019, I'm still not seeing how Ariana is anything like Mariah vocally. Ariana has a great voice and she's not bad, but that's about it. Mariah, especially 90s to early 2000s Prime Mariah, far surpasses anything Ariana has shown since her debut. Even if Mariah doesn't sound like she did during her prime years, she can still sing circles around the majority of mainstream singers, including Ariana.
They started saying that when Ari covered emotions lol but while She is very vocally talented I don’t think she can be the next Mariah or wants to be
@@MrMan-vn7rg there is no next nobody. We didnt say mariah is next whoever so why say that about ariana? Everyone is different and no one needs replacing.
@@vg6761 omg gurl I never said that if you even had social media you would know when Ari covered emotions people tried to replace her in the industry and end Mariah’s career Mariah didn’t do that Ari’s fans did that to her so don’t play like the lambs are bad
Mariah is queen and ariana just small new artists
yeah
but bitch look where she is now
@@jaydenwanga ikr
@@thatguyjohnmarston3480 she/he said that a year ago but 1 year ago she was already one of the biggest artist of this generation
Now look what??
Arianna is good by today's standards but had this been the 60s 70s 80s 90s I doubt she would be as big as she is.... With that being said Mariah wins this for me!
If you think Ariana is better than Mariah you must be under 18, tone death or in denial 😂 Ariana has great vocals but she sings from her nose and pushes her voice too much. You can't understand her half the time and she has no soul in her voice. Ariana also sounds squeaky when she belts like her voice is gonna crack at anytime
Mariah on the other hand has great technique, can sing high and low with ease. Her voice is also louder and stronger when she belts. You can understand her words and she sings with emotion. Her voice is amazing
I prefer Ariana!! You should respect people choices
Moonlight_Ari
And I prefer Mimi🖕
I prefer Ariana
@@moonlightvibes767 k I respect yours
lmao literally emotions
not to mention mariah's music is a million times better
Critics would disagree. Ariana's work has garnered so much more critical acclaim than Mariah's work did.
+Cat wut haha dont make me laugh, mariah produces her own music, writes her own music wrotes co wrote 17 out of her 18 number 1 single, 4 of her songs from her first album been number, can you tell me how many number 1 songs ariana got now just kindly update me, besides whats her latest single dangerous woman when christina ate her whole in their performance on the voice, most of all i wanna see her sing live if its over of mariah carey flawlessly
zero lamperouge Don't be ignorant. I didn't mention sales, just critical acclaim (for the record Ariana's single 'Problem' sold 7.5 million - more than ANY of Mariah's singles from a studio album). It's a simple fact that Ariana's albums have received much better scores from media critics than Mariah's did. That's all I was saying. If you want proof, I can link to the wikipedia pages?
Ok what a pity at least she already got 1 edge to mariah's success
zero lamperouge Success doesn't determine how good someone is. Critics say that Ariana is even better than Mariah. And because they analyse music for a living, who are we to say it's wrong. Mariah was better at singing and producing hits. Ariana is overall a better artist. That's my opinion anyway (and critics.)
Yeah Mariah! You're great!
Patoto Azul is that why Ariana won the writing of the year 2016 oh ok
Pmlo Goes That's is why Mariah has 18 number 1s Lol
Anjik
Jingle- riah 19 now
Ariana loses support from B4 on, sounds scretchy, throaty and tensioned, her lows aren't that low and barely audible and. Mariah notes here were all supported and can support lower notes and go higher than the notes displayed here, she is definitely the best singer, there is not even comparison
Eb3: mariah
E3: mariah
F3: mariah
F#3: mariah
G3: mariah
G#3: mariah
A4: mariah
Bb4: mariah
B4: mariah
C5: mariah
C#5: mariah
D5: mariah
Eb5: mar- fuck it mariah won
Don't get me wrong ariana can sing but her high notes does sound like a whimpering dog in comparison to marriage effortless on point high notes....also notice it's a lot of effort for ariana to reach those notes but for mariah it's just so naturally for to hit it plus it's sounds nice to the ear where as Arianas sound a bit like dog whistle when she's trying like too hard
But ariana is in her 20's, mariah was 19 when she started making it big and her best years were when she was starting out in her 19 to 20's. Also Ariana has been in musical showbizz since very young 14 (musical show victorious) .....BUT lol mariahs mum was an Opera singer and a vocal coach so I guess mariah had a lot of training as well but naturally her voice has been stronger and better range
+Sabrina Raymah you put marriage instead of Mariah.
I think you are rude you can tell your opinion without being disrespectful
+u2hubbard age has nothing to do with Ariana's lack of resonance above B4.
lmao whimpering puppy
mariah obvi
Imran Aliff you said Mariah but you profile pic is of ariana..
Aaron Grant Hahahah I forgot to change 😂 thanks for telling me
Justin Carbon no they dont ariana has 4 octaves mariah has 5 so shut up
You can see from F5 Ariana starts screaming (singing technique to heat the note) also her volume almost disappear. Mariah actually hits the notes and still maintains full volume. Sit down Ariana you are not match....
And Mariah doesn't scream
how can your volume "disappear" if your are screaming lmao
The volume of ariana's clips is lowered, i've heard most of this clips and they sound louder than this
It becomes thinner as you go higher.
@@greedyforari2969 Just what i tought
There both good to me but Mariah has a more powerful voice
Mariah can hit the lowest notes much better than Ariana, and she also hits the highest notes way better. Her whistle register is more powerful and can be held for longer notes, her vocals in general are stronger in all registers, thicker and truly soulful, unlike Ariana, that sounds to thin and poppish, and that has a weak whistle that she can hold only in short notes. Also, unlike Mariah, Ariana tends to exaggerate and force her vocal acrobatics, a bit like Xtina Aguilera. Now, I have heard Ariana singing in a more soulful way, but it seems her producers, just like they did with Britney and the first 2 years with Xtina, want to ruin her voice by making her sing with a poppish, childish voice.
Mariah, obviously.
Mariah is the greatest vocalist ever even tho I do prefer Ariana's voice
+Sam grande you prefer arinana voice but mariah wins
+andre sousa Are you stupid? That is EXACTLY what she said??
Ariana vs Mariah is just like a dust vs a diamond 😂
@Aiyana Bond Ofc
@Anna Valencia you wish lmao
@jeremy Some arianators can be delusional sometimes 🌝💞
Jason Rivera NO IM A BIG LAMB I THOUGHT HE WAS TALKING ABOUT MARIAH! :( Mariah is the queen here ugh Ariana could never
jeremy check my message above this :(
billion light years away difference between Queen Mariah Carey to this umm.. who???
Like Mariah fans know "I don't know her".......yessss you said that so right though
+Isabella Doyle i love you😘
mariah is miss piggy
+Tony Lankford I think miss piggy is basses on Mariah diva side 😂😂😂
Both have great voices, But Mariah takes the cake all the way! She's a legend. But Ariana also has talent, compared to Selena lol
Mariah carey vs selena gomez lol
Mariah = original; Ariana = imitation.
Andrew Charalambous Ariana did it and you have to deal with that:
Ariana began to take of Mariah's breathy, angelic sound. She she began to mimick Mariah's tone.
Songs: Mariah-Copycat
Impossible-Wit it for christmas
I've been thinking about you-Too close
Secret love-Baby I
I'll be lovin' you long time-Lovin' it.
She also used almost the same clothes that Mariah has used. She did the same damn dance step in "Problem", that Mariah used in "Honey". Copycat Grande copied Mariah blantantly in music videos:
It's like that-Right there-> it's the same thematic and the most obvious lol.
Don't forget about us-Problem->Baby doll pose.
My all, The roof-Love me harder. It's so sad to see the lack of originality that Copycat has hahahaha.
Ariana Grande And Copycat Grande either, honey.
Andrew Charalambous You should abstain from writing shit. Let's talk when Ariana is 46, meanwhile you must compare them at the same age. "Slays" with her terrible technique, bitch you wish.
Ariana Grande Inspiration?! She copied and that's it.
Ariana Grande To copy, to take inspiration and steal are three different words, with different meanings.
I love Ariana but her songs are almost has “Ohh baby!” Lyrics. It’s annoying l0l
Liam Capili haha 😆
WHY EVERYONE TRYNA COMPARE THEM...STOP ...MARIAH IS QUEEN...THATS THE TEA SIS
She’s a legend not a queen
And Ariana
Mariah paved the way for these new artists there will never be another Mariah
I love Ariana, but when it comes to vocals, SLAY MARIAH SLAYYYYY
Mariah spent her teen years already doing her thing and Ariana's just there making covers in her bedroom.
Haha funny that her covers have more views than Mariah's originals songs.
Nelly MSP if you're basing your 'views' off of RUclips, you're wrong. Her songs came out way before RUclips, so stfu. you know nothing, go back to msp where you belong immature bitch.
Nelly MSP your grammar is hilarious too.
Nelly MSP at least my idol doesn't sing using her nose, bitch.
Clydee ummm actually she was on broadway when she was 13
Mariah Carey basically won
Hands down Mariah!
Ariana sings with no soul at all. She's so robotic. I always wondered what I disliked about her and now I realize. She hits every note the same no matter what song she's singing.
And the worst part is, she has a software behind her mic that auto tunes her voice live. Not only is she soulless but she also needs auto tune 😒
Danté Riccelli listen to the microphone feed from her performance at the Grammy's. She does not use auto tune.
Marco Crespo Jr. thank you!!!
Danté Riccelli u really sound stupid .
She doesn't use auto tune. Just sayin
Winner:
Eb3-C7: Mariah Carey