The left considers Jewish people to be ‘white oppressors’
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2025
- The Times of London columnist Melanie Phillips says the left considers Jewish people to be “white oppressors”.
Ms Phillips told Sky News Australia that most Jewish people in Israel “are not white”.
“Most Israelis are brown or black skin, both Jews are brown or black skin, but they’re considered to be white because they’re considered to be oppressors.”
I wish everyone could listen to this courageous lady
Everything she said is a lie. And she knows it, and you know it, and I know it, and everybody knows it. Jews, a self destructive nation, they went through trains of Holocaust and still trying to jump on the same train. Shame.
she used to appear on BBC's Question Time but she spoke too much sense so they don't want her back .
This lady speaks the truth.
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
She speaks with such steady clarity and strength! Refreshing after four years of cancelation threats.
@dianegreyson8787 Of course she is selling a crappy book promotion by her biased friends Sky Murdoch
@ricky-o2z : Yep, you are going to troll this entire thread with your usual Ultra-Left bias ?
🤖 Finally, someone not afraid to speak the truth. 💯
You only go to jail if you say the opposite of what she said
*Melania Phillips, finally someone with knowledge and common sense.*
A brilliant lass...with a brilliant mind...
@@veronicagallo2624 Common sense the new elite word like safe and effective and unprecedented LoL 😆 people see through the B.S LoL
@ricky-o2z : Are you going to troll this entire thread with your usual Ultra-Left bias ?
@@ricky-o2z *Melania Phillips, definitevely not a DEI (didn't earn it) appointy.*
I really don't care what the left think - the left are the oppressors; China, North Korea, Russia, Venezuela and Cuba. Left wing sophistry has been exposed, the cults of identity and gender politics widely ridiculed for their lack of honesty, merit and hostile divisiveness. Their push for the apartheid politics of DEI and CRT exposed and called out for the explicit marxism and racism they promote. Their support for the hate filled beliefs of Iran and its proxies, ridiculed and defeated. Their intellectual failures to understand science and history exposed. Australians are no longer fooled by the ALP its dishonesty.
Mrs. Phillips is a journalist, and she used to be liberal, but when she stop doing what the party said and spoke out on behalf of Jewish people in her news and opinion columns, she got cancelled by her friends and co-workers. Opened her eyes.
Exactly.
You only get canceled if you speak against jews, or even question one of their claims.
The WOKE stole the word Liberal. A real Liberal is not a WOKE support.
@@boazsayar1193 Where are these people, do they not have voices?
@@boazsayar1193 but liberals are weak, they let their movements become controlled by lunatics.
As a 55 year old retired U.S. Army veteran who just finished my Bachelor's of Arts in Political Science, everything you're saying is 100% correct, unlike the education system in so many of the American Universities and Colleges.
55year old retards opinion not worth much 🤣.
As a 55 year old retired U.S. Army veteran, your opinion means less than nothing to me.
@@dogzdigitalsorry i thought you meant retard 🇦🇺🇮🇱👍🤣
@@dogzdigital True opinions don't matter.
But holding the choice of words against the statement doesn't shake the truth of what is being said.
@ However what was said was complete BS regardless.
Melanie is great 👍
Thank God, people are putting the truth into the public arena. I am TIRED of this pro Palestinian bullshit.
Beep boop
if you are tired what israeli jews feel ?
Then why do you listen? Most people are tired of hearing stuff they don't want to hear, what makes you special?
BTW it ain't ever ending lol ever.
Will you be happy when you own nothing?
Zowy, this lady is amazing. She tells it like it really is.
She missed the bit about pretending this is not just about ethnic cleansing and land theft.
@@dogzdigital
So moving terrorist Muslims is ethnic cleansing but destroying the state of Israel is what? Over the decades with all of the billions in aid they have received they could have created something decent but decided that death and destruction was the way to go. No other Muslim nation wants anything to do with them and there is a very good reason.
@@dogzdigital ask youself, do the pals deserve a country after 7.10?
Your argument is entirely backward. The only ethnic cleansing and land theft in the region came from the Arab-Islamic conquests, which wiped out native Jewish, Samaritan, and other indigenous populations across the Levant. Arabs, Arabic, and Islam originate in Arabia, not Israel, not Jordan, not Lebanon, not Syria. Read a map, study real history, and stop projecting.
No she’s not, she’s just identified the thieves.
Melanie Phillips is a courageous lady.
Hard to hear the truth
Are we awake now🕊
Everything she said is a lie. And she knows it, and you know it, and I know it, and everybody knows it. Jews, a self destructive nation, they went through trains of Holocaust and still trying to jump on the same train. Shame.
❤
She is 100percent correct i love her
@@MichaelMorse-q2f rubbish 😂
@ricky-o2z : Yep, you are going to troll this entire thread with your usual Ultra-Left bias ?
@@buildmotosykletist1987 I'm actually right, and yes I Will
Beep boop i love it aswell fellow real human
@ : ROTFL. Why are all your comments left biased?
The Palestinian narrative is one of the greatest cons in modern history...
The greatest. The concept of a “Palestinian” identity is a modern invention, crafted in 1964 by the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) to reframe global perception. Historically, no distinct ethnic or cultural group identified as “Palestinians.” The term “Palestine” itself was used only as a geographic designation, originating from the Romans who sought to erase the Jewish connection to the land by renaming Judea as “Palaestina” after the Philistines, a people who were not Arabs and have been extinct for millennia. “Palestine” was never a nation, never had defined borders, and never existed as an independent political entity.
One could argue the usury banking system is the biggest and we know who is behind that don't we
@@OrcHunter-fj9gv None of this matters. It has a defined population and defined borders NOW, and is recognised as a nation state by over 150 UN member countries.
The holocaust is, they still making money out of that.
Everything she said is a lie. And she knows it, and you know it, and I know it, and everybody knows it. Jews, a self destructive nation, they went through trains of Holocaust and still trying to jump on the same train. Shame.
Pro tip- America isn't listening to "the left" anymore.
- an American
They have become too radical to have a cohesive goal. The left never condemns its extremists
Thank G-d!
@@jennylasseter9162 left and right morons, your playing the Elites division game 😂 promotion by mainstream media Shills
so, the richest man on the planet is to stop helping the poorest, sickest and most desperate on the planet. Seems like the mango madman is ok with it, what about you?
Any chance of sending Trump to Australia to give the people here a kick up the backside, The ANZACs would turn in there grave to see what has happened to this country
Spot on!
Nobody talks about the Soviets oppression of the Kulaks during the 1930's, to the degree that that whole ethnic race was virtually wiped out. Nobody talks about the Turks oppression to the Armenians during WW1. Nobody talks Mao about the millions of Chinese people who were killed during his regime. I could go on and on. And yet, there are people who are talking about the Jews being white oppressors. These narrow minded unintellectuals know nothing about the history of brutal mass murders. Israel is a very small country, and since 1947 was able to withstand the military forces of Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, and Jordan. It is surrounded by these countries, with only the deserts on their left flank and rear. Israel gave the Palestinians in Gaza the opportunity to democratically govern themselves. Not so with Hamas, who rule with the bullet and no with the ballot. They are no better, than Stalin, Hitler, and Mao where their power was ruled with oppression and fear.
Kulaks were not an ethnic group. they were slightly wealthier peasants. ppl who perhaps hired a farm-hand or owned some land. the Soviet's propaganda treated them like rich landowners - politics of envy. once soviets had deported the Kulaks, they then stole all the lands and forced the peasants into collectives.
They are Egyptian and Jordanian.. and are calling for genocide
Exactly
Free Lebanese Christians from Palestine
She used to be progressive but realised it was wrong, I hope many more progressives follow her path
Nothing wrong with progress mate
@LucyJrts agreed, more than that, progress is important to our society,BUT the kind of 'progress' many on the far left aim for does a lot nore damage than good and frankly feels a bit 'regressive "
@@RonZatuchny-sx8ye in what ways?
@@LucyJrts normalising antisemitism, being against freedom of speech, not condemning violent attacks here in this country or atrocities overseas like oct 7th
@@RonZatuchny-sx8ye I’m just gonna say this then - look at who’s ACCUSING “progressives” of those things, and what those accusers stand to gain from the discourse.
Because basically none of those things are actually true. Nobody’s normalising antisemitism except the far right Nazis. What the LEFT are doing is criticising the state of Israel and its military actions in Gaza. That’s not antisemitism. None of us are against Jews or even against Israelis. We’re against war crimes, apartheid and genocide, and in this case it happens to be the Jewish state that’s perpetrating those things. They don’t get a free pass just for playing the antisemitism card. It’s not antisemitic to criticise the state of Israel, unless you’re doing so purely BECAUSE of Judaism, which none of us are.
As for freedom of speech, the majority of leftists and progressives are all for it, at least until it comes to Nazis (you know… because we’re not antisemitic!)
We want some level of content moderation on social media to protect vulnerable people, and potential punishments for intentionally spreading disinformation (saying vaccines cause autism, or climate change is fake, that sort of thing), but we’re not against freedom of speech. Actually, you know who is? The Zionist Federation of Australia who pushed for any Palestinian protestor to have their citizenship revoked and be deported, or face mandatory jail time, simply for criticising Israel. If you’re for freedom of speech… that extends to the right to peacefully protest, even if it’s against something you might happen to like. Remember “I may not agree with what you’re saying but I’ll defend your right to say it”??
As for violent attacks, ALL of us condem all those that happen here. The vast majority of us also absolutely unequivocally condemn Hamas and their actions on October 7th too. Not all, unfortunately, but most. We just also don’t believe that the Israeli government’s and military’s actions are a legitimate or lawful response to that attack, and since Israel’s civilian casualty count is 20x higher than Hamas’ was on October 7th… and that Israel has a long history littered with dead Palestinian men, women and children, a history of blockading Palestinian territory, stifling their development and continually absorbing more and more of their territory… yeah, there’s one side that gets talked about more and that does tend to overshadow any condemnation of the other.
She hits the nail on the head 👍🏻 so refreshing to hear someone just get to the FACTS !!!
As a proud jew who lives in Israel, and will defend its existence to its last breath, I couldn't care ANY LESS what the left thinks about me and my people. Yes, my country is far from perfect, and I'm not ashamed on calling it out on it, but it's still my country, and I want to see it evolving to its best version. However, one of the things needed for that to happen is for my state to SURVIVE, and because of that, I will defend it for as long as I live!
AM ISRAEL CHAI!😁🇮🇱
Everything she said is a lie. And she knows it, and you know it, and I know it, and everybody knows it. Jews, a self destructive nation, they went through trains of Holocaust and still trying to jump on the same train. Shame.
@daneyal7162
You are 100% right and your pride is justified.
I support Israel.
Am Yisrael Chai.
May I ask you a question
What would your government do if the Messiah turns up
Would they accept him with open arms
Or would they try to unalive him
Maybe they have already tried it
Actually it’s not your country, you are occupying someone else’s country.
@@walterbrowning have you ever been here?
As always, Melanie sums it up perfectly.
Ms. Phillips said it all, short and sweet, 100% support ❤
Brilliantly said ❤
Thank goodness, finally someone who is speaking truth!
Excellent factual discussion!! 🇺🇸
@@tt7963 what's with the American flag? 😂Is that for uncle Sam
@ricky-o2z : Yep, you are going to troll this entire thread with your usual Ultra-Left bias ?
@ricky-o2z it's only to fish out left losers like you😂
I love this women, she know her facts👍👏👏👏👏
Wow, she hit the nail on the head. I agree totally with her.
This lady spoke the truth
Sharp lady.
no shy telling the truth.
She is absolutely correct, spot on
That woman is fearless 👏 sad you have to be fearless to speak the truth in today's society
she gets it - and make perfect sense.
You can’t colonize your own indigenous land. This is about religion plain and simple. Israeli is the only country I know of where people live in their indigenous land, speaking the same language, worshipping in the same way with the same traditions for 4,000 years.
@@rac736 Amen🙏
The Jews who moved to Israel were white Europeans.
@@rac736 I think you will find Hebrew now is quite differently spoken to ancient times. FYI the chinese have much longer history so don’t be so arrogant in your assertion. Would be interesting to some proper DNA a testing and see where the real origins are but Israeli authorities discourage this.
they have different dialects but Australian Aboriginals have been here for 65,000 years but seems it’s ok to colonise someone else’s land!
@@wayjoh1955 thank you - my mistake to forget that. I hate arrogance and there is a lot of it about lately especially from some peoples
Thank you so much the wisest speach Ive heared for a long time! Ordering the book!❤
Thank you Melanie….succinctly and intelligently said!!
This is the most complete and succinct explanation of the “woke left” I’ve ever heard. One thing left out though, is that the wacky “woke right” conspiracy nuts are in full agreement with the “woke left” about Israel and the Jewish Threat.
Point it out to them though, and they will call you the nazi. They cannot self reflect
F the L
@@keepussafeUSA you know the left doesn't really exist LoL only media promotes it as real 😂
A brilliant commentator who sees reality and articulates it. Thank god!!!
Listen to this was like hear from heaven. Thank You.
Everything she said is a lie. And she knows it, and you know it, and I know it, and everybody knows it. Jews, a self destructive nation, they went through trains of Holocaust and still trying to jump on the same train. Shame.
The voice of right minded people!
She is correct that this so called palestinian identity is the same arabs of Jordan, Egypt and those who are Israeli arabs.
Words of truth not often said.
🙏❤AMERICA 🇺🇸/🇮🇱 ISRAEL❤🙏
@@wilbur1884 Yeah Trump's Cabinet really does show that.
Clever Lady ❤
What a shame we have no thinking columnists or reporters on the ABC or SBS.
The marxistmedia is ALWAYS ready to devote coverage to the left!!!!!!
The Left will win. Israel and America are Fascist states. 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Thank you for this. Am Yisrael Chai
Well said
Bravo! 🎉🎉🎉
Amen.
I'd have more sympathies for Palestinians if they genuinely made the point that they consider themselves native people of that land and feel a deep connection to it but its obvious that the main thing on their minds is Islamic conquest.
Jerusalem appears 80 times in the Torah and 0 times in the Koran, so who really is the rightful heir to Jerusalem? Judea and Samaria is an Israeli Jewish area and is not intended for Palestinians who cannot pronounce the word Palestine, use your brain a little
It's a secular issue, not religion v religion
Remarkably astute guest
We cannot tell the Jews not to have a state of their own on the land from where they were scattered around the world, colonized among others, by the ancestors of the Russian-Egyptian invention, the so-called Balestinians, while their other peaceful fellows have their own states, but occupy the lands of others, from the Western world.
Melanie still not cutting corners. 👍
Exactly right.
Wow, I just found gold and her name is Melanie!! Great analysis. Precise! Please let us see and hear you more.
Very well commented....! Very good orator indeed....!
If it wasnt the romans the word palestine wouldnt even exist😏🤣
Prime Minister Peter Dutton.
Australian Security First.
Australian Homes 4 Australians.
Australian Manufacturing.
The liberal party got rid of 200,000 manufacturing jobs in this country in their last term. Albanese has brought back around 90,000
Come on! Bout time the left acknowledge that trump is a bloody genious! And out witted all of them😂
"How in practice it can be put into practice."
Simple, offer them $$$ to relocate. I understand that the Palm Islands are nice at this time of year. 😉
Go to Bourke st mall, there you’ll find a huge tent giving out the koreran and trying to convert. But we weren’t allowed to have Xmas windows. This is a warning if we accept this and not push back. We have to fight to keep the west
Not just the left
Thank you
Love this lady.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇺🇸🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
No. And if you keep putting my flag next to that parasite blue and white one, then you leave with them when they’re expelled again.
Damn if you love Israel that much go live there smh
@@thedog7494if you love palestine, ukraine, china, venezuela etc and hate the US then move out there and see how it goes for you👍Israel is our ally🇺🇲🇮🇱🇺🇲🇮🇱
Everything she said is a lie. And she knows it, and you know it, and I know it, and everybody knows it. Jews, a self destructive nation, they went through trains of Holocaust and still trying to jump on the same train. Shame.
Let us see if 'allah' can stop the bulldozers.
So, it's a double standard of moral justice. It's wrong if THOSE people are oppressing, but not when WE do that.
Hamas is a terrorist organisation dude, they DO NOT have rights.
Perfectly stated, thank you.
I adore Melanie Phillips. Thank you for having her on!
One hundred percent correct!
Consider Australia , thanks to our pm by bringing a million people on our streets. Who will be next , hopefully not Australia in time to come
It's scary to think we now have these terrorists supporters on our streets.
ALBO and WONG MUST GO 🙏
I love Melanie Phillips. Thanks for having her on.
Is she in Australia? Its a wonder Burke didn`t revoke her Visa.
apolitical here...i view them... now hang on to something, this is crazy......people.
i view them as literally just another human, nothing special any way you go about it,not sacred,not sinful and unworthy of living, just a human, no more no less.
Antisemitic!
;)
❤❤❤❤
She speaks so much common sense and truth
She has lost the plot completely
2:48 wonderful. They can be resettled in other arabic states
Penny Wong WRONG WRONG.
Their category and appearance changes depending on the circumstances, just like with Hispanics. This is a function of the MSM and activists, not the people themselves.
A lady that is telling the truth, if only the politicians would do the same. Christian Prince has been saying this for ever, I’ve been listening to CP since 2015, and he was saying this before that. He is an Arab who says everything this lady says.
But doesn't 'Arab colonialism' discount the not insignificant Persian/Irani (i.e., Shiite) involvement in this dispute..?
For those who don't know, Melanie is married to legal expert journalist Joshua Rozenberg.
10:35 - And the reason Jews are considered to be 'oppressors' is because they are, in general as as a whole, percieved to be successful minority, and according to wokester pretzel logic, any sort of success is seen as 'ilegitimate', and as a product of/consequence of 'cheating, stealing, manipualting, etc...' every one else who happens to not be (or precieved as not being as) successful.
In other words, it's the whole 'equity' madness where the foolish pusuit of ant-like collective 'equity' is the name of the game. Because according to warped, victim worshipping, success bashing progressives, all property is 'stealing', all success is 'illegitiamtelly achieved' and therefore we shall all wallow in the myre of poverty, achieve 'equity' together as a swarm of cloned, upright, grasshopper eating anthropomorphic insects. Humans can felle empathy, solidarity, compassion but do not possess a hive mind. We are social animals, but we're not insects or fish.
I like Rowan, he speaks the truth.
ATT SKY: On CH7 news just now a protestor said: " **** the Jews". A four letter word starts with kay. On national news.
Please cover this.
Tolerance for all
Melanie Phillips is always very provoking and incisive. I don't agree with all of her positions but always respect her enough to thoughtfully consider them.
Thank you for your gracious words, loyal subject! Your devotion and respect are deeply appreciated. I, King Jack, King of Love and King of the Jews, shall return to continue my reign with wisdom and compassion. Until then, may peace and prosperity grace your days. Farewell for now, and may my kingdom thrive in my absence. 👑✨
Rest assured, I shall return to lead with love and justice. Until we meet again! 😊
Yes, this is true. I've just read Ta-Nehisi Coates's The Message, which has a huge section on how the Jews are the White colonizers and the Palestinians are the Black victims.
Exactly why I keep telling you to stop with this crap.
Jordan IS A PALESTINIAN STATE
The Jordanian queen is Palestinian!!!
Why doesn’t she help her people?
Mmm, maybe because they tried to kill the Jordanian Royal family. For which the king executed thousands and expelled thousands more back in the 70's
@@Nothing-hp3zq I think they already have a really big number of Palestinians living in Jordan and have been helping the many who have been hurt by IDF. Maybe ask the English queen? After all England helped create this bloody mess and has form with colonial ideas.
These fanatics murdered the grandfather of their current king. and tried taking over before Jordan "black septembered" them.
@@rogermckinnon5738 Same thing the French did to their own royal family...
Nationlsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiter Partei / Natinonal Socialist german workers party or NSDAP. The political party of Adolf Hitler. And yes, they were socialists. They are only coined "right" because in the Reichstag of the Weimar Republic they were seated on the right side viewed from the speakers psoition. So we all understand who the "Left" really is.
Have they lost their minds?
Amen! Says it as it is. My question is where are all the "moderate" Muslims. Crickets!
Time to rebuild the Temple of Solomon
The cultural relativism of which she spoke, began with a famous debate in the '70s, between Bernard Lewis and Edward Said. Said's arguments were reportedly concocted by Chomsky and were to the effect that 'The East' may not be evaluated or criticised using Western concepts. Lewis forever after this debate was seen as old hat, and the poor post-modern academic pathway to everything we've seen ( at very least in so far as the Middle East and its history is concerned ) was opened up.