A little correction: I’m pretty sure Mario only promised to let Boyfriend go if he beat 3 songs, because right after he says that Girlfriend is gonna pay for what her father did, he turns to boyfriend and says “You, on the other hand” and only then he makes the deal. He also doesn’t say “Beat me and I’ll let you guys go”, no instead he says “Beat me and I’ll let you go”, only referring to one person. That might also be the reason why Boyfriend fled the scene after Starman Slaughter, because he wanted to leave with Girlfriend, but Horror Mario wouldn’t allow that.
Quick thing about Act 4, Horror Mario isn't actually just singing parts of other songs, but also mimicking their voices. It's hard to hear but they are there.
Corrections 22:49 Actually From Mario Party 8 25:32 It’s Actually Confirmed That Gf Doesn’t die here. Mr v has the power To do this because it’s his V Boy. 32:09 His Name is Costume not Custom.
Fun fact: at the end credits the song "a mad world without you" play while Ultra M is singing, in the lyrics M is saying how he regrets killing bf and saying why isn't he satisfied, it's because M was Trapped in the game for very long time and was lonely. The characters we fought don't count because as he said "they all are apart of his game" in typical way "Revenge is not the way"
9:21 To be more specific, every song still canonically takes place in the story of the game. But most of the songs created by M are based on various different Mario related things, that has no relation to one another outside of Mario’s Madness. Beta Mario is a different character from Horror Mario, for example.
I admire ur bravery for actually giving ur opinion instead of buying into hype. Some of these ratings are gonna piss ppl off lol. Also I believe that paranoia, somari, and no party are bangers.
I can’t explain what happens in the classified series since my brain can’t comprehend the amount of lore and forgot a lot about it but here is explanation of the song “Promotion” that I can remember. In the cutscene, Mario is shown hosting a show. This is supposed to be an episode of a show called Nintendo Mania. (if that was name) The show was supposed to be a show that show the hottest game releases and the first game shown was Super Mario 64. As what he said in the video, the second part of the song is taken over by a character named “Stanley”. Stanley is AI in the game of Super Mario 64. The series shows how every copy of SM64 is personalized. (Tho I can’t remember what else). Luigi is shown on TV next to Mario. In the promotional video from the series, Mario is hosting the show (obviously) and since he can’t show SM64, he asks Luigi to do a tour (or something like that) of the game. While Luigi keeps exploring the castle, he finds himself in an underwater section of the castle. He finds coins to regain Power. Though, he slowly gets lost and eventually runs out of coins, thus leading to his demise. This is also what “Thalassophobia” is based on and the coin notes in the song. In the second part of the song, Mario is then taken over by Stanley, the Ai. I don’t remember if he mimics the form of Mario but do know that Stanley is appeared as a deformed Mario with missing textures (hat logo, button on overalls, etc.). If it’s true that Stanley mimics Mario’s form, this is because he is an Ai that (I think) can only talk through text towards the player. That’s I can remember from the series. I know I missed a lot of things and got things incorrect so if you remember the series, please tell me. Though, for anyone reading this right now, if you never watched the series (which I think most of you did), go check out the series. It’s honestly good and there’s still questions left unanswered in the series. Anyways this was written at 3:54 AM currently. Thanks for reading if you did Edit: Fixed the song name with the coin notes. Corrected by a reply. Thanks for correcting me!
Thanks for the explanation! One small mistake however, the coin notes are from Thalassophobia, the song based on L is Real. Classified Luigi’s Abandoned has those switch notes that lower the water level.
Thank you, I’ll pin this comment so people can see it. That is, hoping that this video even gets enough comments that pinning this one would make a difference 💀
I am of the belief this is the only mod (that I know of and/or recall) that has no misses. You can name any song from the mod and you can vibe to any one of them, not to mention the story. It's not a novel concept, Trollge Files years before did some lore when Trollge was booming, but it's like the team pulled from that, put Mario on it, and decided to make only bangers. To make a great song based off evil mario of all things AND able to make a pretty concrete story out of it is peak having the cake and eating it too.
I really liked this video. My only real issue with it is that I feel like you could've been more specific on why you like each song music-wise. Even if you don't know music terminology just saying stuff like "I really liked this songs vibe/energy" or "the melodies in this song are verh catchy/memorable" would've made your analysis of each song more interesting in my opinion. This is a still a great video with good editing and writing, but if you ever do make another FNF mod review like this one, I think you should try to doing this. Regardless, I'm definitely subbing and I'm interested to see what you do next!
34:02 One thing I think you should’ve mentioned was the credits music. As it gives us an insight into Ultra M’s character. And how he regrets what he did to BF and GF, and describes his world being an empty tomb that he’s alone in.
14:43 One of the best songs in the game. 16:48 I really love this song. 18:43 Opinions, I know. But decent!? This is some amazing music right here. 23:40 “Okay”? I’m shocked that you said it’s okay. Because this song is amazing and is really fun to listen to. 31:44 This and Grand Dad are two other songs I say are also great, and yet he thinks are okay. It’s fine tho, lol.
though i didn’t agree with most takes, you did go in depth and the video was very entertaining! you earned a new subscriber (justice for apparition and the end)
Extra information: At 36:20 the souls Ultra M consumed starts to sing together. It is hard to hear but for people asking for lyrics "See in the star, Move on lost way all that we are, living to stay, part of it all, take of all face, beckoning call, JOIN US" They repeat this for 2 times after either Mario or Mario with GF's voice tries to trick BF with another lyrics "Say its true me and you! Make it through, what we have to do. Let's be free can't you see? It's-a me!" In my theory since Mario didn’t wanted to kill BF he tried to trick him to get his soul aswell or his companion in his hell. Maybe with an amount of soul Mario can escape from the game or like i said Mario could've wanted BF's companion. If you would ask why would he want BF's company? It is because in outro Mario starts to sing if we need to describe song in short because of with BF he remembered his humanity filled the loneliness inside him after many years. He wanted to defeat him but not with cheating with an fair way. But in end he ended up with losing to his anger and killed him unfairly
I already commented but I noticed smthn else lol: in the IHY creepypasta, before the romhack there was an EXE game based off of it that was very similar to the romhack with some differences. One difference is that in the EXE build, the mushroom jumpscares you with popular creepypasta images instead of killing you. This is why it jumpscares you in Oh God No.
When you say that this is one of the longest mods that isn’t quite true, Vs Imposter V4 and DDTO plus clock in at 3+ hours. I do agree tho that it is pretty long. Crazy you didn’t bring up the mod cameos in the first cutscene. Seeing your ratings, you seem to hate swing rhythm, which kinda sucks to hear considering how rare it is a song to be written in swing. Will say Hex devs literally had experience in NotITG so they thought modcharting was the ideal challenge but didn’t realize how difficult that modcharting was to handle.
@@benny_by6344 Swing Rhythm is commonly in jazz music but the notes sort of are divided unequally so notes have jumps but the tempo and instrumentals help for a basis to keep a toe tapping.
How I interpreted the lore was the same as the one you said, but Daddy Dearest trapped M in the game during the 2020s. And as M created his world, he used many Mario related things he knew about at the time and liked or thought was funny. Leading to why the songs are all based on pre-existing things.
I wholeheartedly agree All Stars is a phenomenal last song! The ending of Act 4 in particular genuinely shocked me first time I saw it. All the notes in the final section felt like it was building to something and I thought it would end on a final note from Boyfriend. But then he was killed before anything like that could happen! At first it was a very abrupt end to the song and lacking a satisfying endnote, but now that I think about it maybe it was intentional? BF being denied a way to victory at the very end cemented how hopeless it was to defeat Ultra M. That is the kind of ending that sticks with you and makes a song like this memorable.
My thoughts exactly, it did something that no other mod had done before so I can understand why some people didn’t like the ending, but personally I loved it
this video is so well made and edited, i don't see why the view count is so low. excellent video! i agree with everything you said, except for a few things [everyone has their own opinion, of course]. the only things i disagree with you on are: 1.) race traitors -> personally, i thought this song was pretty good in the original V1 of the mod, but i don't really like the new chromatic they used on mario for this song in the V2 update. 2.) demise -> i love this song as well, and i can see why you rated the charting so low. personally, i love the challenge of the charting, but i do agree that it uses chord notes [double notes as you say] too often compared to anything else in the mod. i would have rated the charting two or three, probably two though. 3.) dark forest -> i personally loved this song and the chromatic / voice of corrupted peach [and the screaming]. obviously, these are my opinions and that doesn't mean your video is bad. again, your video was really fun to watch and it was really well made!! [i dont really know why i even wrote my opinions because nobody will read it, but whatever. and sorry this is such a long comment!!!!!!!!!! i dont write comments often because i feel so stupid writing them] this isn't related to the video itself, but has anybody else realized that in "bad day" against "bad mario", he will change your maximum framerate to 69? i haven't seen anybody else talk about it and i thought it was pretty cool.
Thank you so much for leaving this comment, that’s part of the reason I made this video is so people can give their opinions and we can debate about this kind of thing. I agree that I probably should’ve given Demise a slightly higher charting rating, and I loved dark forest as well!
Gonna be honest i never really understood why people prefered race traitors v1 over v2. Other than nostalgia. I remeber when i first heared the song i thought "they acctually gave him a chormatic?!" but i respect your opinion. The other 2 things you said i totally agree with. Demise at first was a song i really didn't like and just thought it was too hard, but with time it has really grown on me and the diffculty isn't that big of a problem. And acctually the same story with dark forest. The screaming in the song really wasn't my cup of tea at first, but what can i say i found the screaming to acctually fit very well with the song after listening to it multiple times.
@@Pagun47 i would try and explain the part i dont like about the chromatic for race traitors, but i cant figure out how to word it. other than my issue with the chromatic, the song itself is pretty good with all the new changes, such as one or two duet sections and the extended song. i may be stupid, but whenever i played the mod for the first time, i was really excited to hear how they were going to create a V2 race traitors. whenever i got to the song, i felt it was good up until mario starting singing, which is like five seconds in. the chromatic was really a problem for me and the song became one of my least favorites, down there with "so cool". i dont hate the song nearly as much as i used to, but i still find the chromatic to be a bit annoying. sorry for a long comment again!!!!!
This is honestly my favorite mod, I'm happy that Nintendo did nothing against it for now Also future update will have bald Mario LET'S FUNKIN' GOOOOO!!
Ik this is gonna sound like a lot of other comments, but MY GOODNESS YOU ARE UNDERRATED! This video seems like its from someone with 100K+ subs, but LESS THAN 1K?!?!?!? YT, start recommending this guy, *NOW!* ⚡⚡⚡
Yooo, the effort on this video is incredible! It's always great to see high quality stuff from underground channels! You plan on doing more stuff like this in the future? :0
Thank you so much! As a matter of fact, I am currently working on another video essay as we speak! It should hopefully be done within the next week or so (no promises though 💀). However, I will be leaving on a mission for two years in about three weeks so I will have to step away for a little bit, but I plan on doing more once I return!
The worst thing about this mod is probably writing. Bf running away from Mario while being unfazed by Much, MUCH more intimidating and scary characters doesnt make sense and is forced
Admit it when you see a half melted enraged mario staring at you like he’s about to brutally murder you’re more terrified than when you see mario with a katana
@@FireCo0kie-0fficial BF was smiling at MX, GB, Mr. V, IHY Luigi, Ultra M, Coronation Peach, Turmoil, and many more that are scarier and more intimidating then melted Horror Mario
@@Happy06853 He wasn't smiling at mx When facing gb he was habitued to the horror marios He was smiling at mr virtual UNTIL HE REALIZED GF DIED IHY luigi is just luigi but almost dead Ultra M same reason as gb, bf came prepared Coronation peach is just a floating dead body (but he got a bit scared for a second) To avoid turmoil, he can just hide in the bushes (in the mushroom kingdom there was nothing but platforms)
Correction about beta luigi’s mansion: it isn’t from a beta. It’s from some kind of commercial for the game, though I don’t remember. Incredible video!
Nourishing blood is more of a reference to vinesauce joel and memes than 7 grand dad I feel like you should have mentioned the hidden lyrics in oh god no In day out mario and luigi are actually adults and the voicelines are from the original video The design of DJ Hallyboo is from Juno songs' lyric video of host hoedown. Juno also made the chromatic for the song and he was in the anti piracy finale Tbh these are really minor things in such a good and well researched video
ONE THING YOU DID NOT MENTION IS THE DANM CHARTING SYSTEM THIS MOD IS HELD TOGETHER BY DUCT TAPE OOHH BUT IT GETS WORSE NOBODY TALKS ABOUT IT AND BECAUSE OF IT I AM STARTING TO GO INSANE AND SOMETHIING EVEN WORSE THIER WAS A 2 YEAR WAIT AND A NEW VERSION OF THE PSYCH ENGINE THEY HAD LIKE A YEAR TO FIX THAT BECAUSE THIS WAS IN V1 AS WELL also sorry if this comes off as aggressive or something like that i've been trying to fc this and this thing gives me a headache
12:00 This specific version of the mushroom is actually a reference to the EXE game of I HATE YOU. In the EXE game, touching the mushroom would result in an annoyingly loud jumpscare. The EXE game had many problems with it, such as the jumpscares and poor gameplay. But still, a reference is a reference either way.
12:20 Ngl, I think Oh Gosh No, is very eh. Some parts are fun to listen to, but a lot of the song just feels messy with the two of them singing at the same time. Typically for many mods, it takes me a while to get used to the voices as instruments and what the notes are in the songs’ music sheet usually for said vocals, and it took me a while to really appreciate the OST. This song however, I still have the same opinions as I did when I first heard it. 29:10 This song is also something I never cared for. Even if I like so many others I once felt more negatively about. It just feels messy or not that interesting I guess.
19:00 The video seemed to be more about non-Nintendo characters being on the track. Not Link or Animal Crossing, especially that they make no appearances in the video.
Yeah I’ll admit it’s a little weird… but I saw the overall category as not just a combination of the three other categories but a culmination of everything about the song, and because the song was so unique and creative I gave it a 5 overall.
I always wondered why Classified Mario has the TV show Mario voice, but in the song, he has a more traditional voice. Another thing that I thought about, wouldn’t it ruin GF’s death in All*Stars if we see her dead a few times already?
Classified Mario is like that because the cutscene was made after the song was made so they just made his voice in the cutscene sounds more like a tv show Mario just because the could. And for the gf thing you may be right, but there are 2 differences here. First of gf doesn't come back after the song. Which is obious cuz it's the last song but still. Secondly Ultra M using gf as a puppet and making her fight gf shows that there really isn't anything he can do now. Gf wont get another 1up. So yeah those 2 things make the death in All stars feel may more impactful.
29:29 Bro did NOT just rate Demise higher than Bad Day 💀 Imo Demise is in a really weird spot for me. It's not BAD per say, but it's not GOOD either. It's mostly due to Demise mostly being nonsensical notespam, in both the song and the charting, leaving it feeling like your average Dave and Bambi spamtrack. There's also MX's HORRIBLE sounding atonals in the Underground part. BF and MX are also almost CONSTANTLY singing together, and in some cases doesn't sound great, because it sounds like they're fighting over control of the song, and not in a GOOD way either. What keeps me from saying "Song bad, worst in the mod lmao" is the instrumental, it goes so hard. Especially the piano at the beginning. The first couple turns also aren't as bad as the rest of the song, Still too overcharted, but not AS bad as everything else.
Yeah, like I said, this video is very opinionated, but I felt that Demise captured the mood very well, and in the final section where MX holds the song timer at 3 seconds it really feels like you are having a final showdown which is what made me like the song so much despite the note spam.
@@benny_by6344 Yeah the timer being held at 3 seconds is a really cool concept, along with the general idea for an underground section, it's just I'm not the biggest fan of MX's atonals (Because they just sound horrible lmao) but it's not like Demise is *terrible* or anything, just a bit disappointing and overall a bit of a missed opportunity.
Respectfully, skill issue. I only came across one small bug that didn’t cause much of an issue, and I thought the charting overall was excellent. Probably the best FNF mod to exist.
@@benny_by6344 i know what you mean, but for us that we're working on mods (and with good quality too) play Mario Madness wasn't that experience that we thought it was going to be. My reaction was exaggerated, i don't hate this mod, i just don't think is the "BEST" fnf mario creepypasta mod, when there are literally other mods that are better in some other aspects. I hope this explains it all, and have a good day
![[FULL] RETROSPECTIVE : Final Fantasy Tactics](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/RUBmYqs1jZ0/mqdefault.jpg)
A little correction: I’m pretty sure Mario only promised to let Boyfriend go if he beat 3 songs, because right after he says that Girlfriend is gonna pay for what her father did, he turns to boyfriend and says “You, on the other hand” and only then he makes the deal. He also doesn’t say “Beat me and I’ll let you guys go”, no instead he says “Beat me and I’ll let you go”, only referring to one person. That might also be the reason why Boyfriend fled the scene after Starman Slaughter, because he wanted to leave with Girlfriend, but Horror Mario wouldn’t allow that.
Now that I think about it that totally makes sense
Quick thing about Act 4, Horror Mario isn't actually just singing parts of other songs, but also mimicking their voices. It's hard to hear but they are there.
Also just adding onto that if you look at act 4 Mario’s icon when he mimics the characters the character he is imitating right next to his icon
i think more of them use just voice than voice in reference, i think the only references were omega, costume and virtual but don't quote me on that
Corrections
22:49 Actually From Mario Party 8
25:32 It’s Actually Confirmed That Gf Doesn’t die here. Mr v has the power To do this because it’s his V Boy.
32:09 His Name is Costume not Custom.
Fun fact: at the end credits the song "a mad world without you" play while Ultra M is singing, in the lyrics M is saying how he regrets killing bf and saying why isn't he satisfied, it's because M was Trapped in the game for very long time and was lonely. The characters we fought don't count because as he said "they all are apart of his game" in typical way "Revenge is not the way"
I have no clue how this isnt more popular, its well made and edited. Great video, well made review, keep it up
Thank you so much, a lot of effort went into this video so I’m glad it paid off!
Broke my heart with the Mario game and rhythm review 🥲
9:21
To be more specific, every song still canonically takes place in the story of the game. But most of the songs created by M are based on various different Mario related things, that has no relation to one another outside of Mario’s Madness.
Beta Mario is a different character from Horror Mario, for example.
This mod is probably the best fnf mod to ever exist
I absolutely agree
*hit single real walks in*
@@migloverMario Madness:Welp guess you can stay here
@@PapyrusTheGreatestRoyalGuardRUclips poop invasion : death stareing in the cornor
step right up adventure isle: *breaks down the wall and prances in*
I love how everyone treats this mod likes it's a completely different game from FNF, it's so good.
I admire ur bravery for actually giving ur opinion instead of buying into hype. Some of these ratings are gonna piss ppl off lol. Also I believe that paranoia, somari, and no party are bangers.
I can’t explain what happens in the classified series since my brain can’t comprehend the amount of lore and forgot a lot about it but here is explanation of the song “Promotion” that I can remember.
In the cutscene, Mario is shown hosting a show. This is supposed to be an episode of a show called Nintendo Mania. (if that was name) The show was supposed to be a show that show the hottest game releases and the first game shown was Super Mario 64. As what he said in the video, the second part of the song is taken over by a character named “Stanley”. Stanley is AI in the game of Super Mario 64. The series shows how every copy of SM64 is personalized. (Tho I can’t remember what else). Luigi is shown on TV next to Mario. In the promotional video from the series, Mario is hosting the show (obviously) and since he can’t show SM64, he asks Luigi to do a tour (or something like that) of the game. While Luigi keeps exploring the castle, he finds himself in an underwater section of the castle. He finds coins to regain Power. Though, he slowly gets lost and eventually runs out of coins, thus leading to his demise. This is also what “Thalassophobia” is based on and the coin notes in the song. In the second part of the song, Mario is then taken over by Stanley, the Ai. I don’t remember if he mimics the form of Mario but do know that Stanley is appeared as a deformed Mario with missing textures (hat logo, button on overalls, etc.). If it’s true that Stanley mimics Mario’s form, this is because he is an Ai that (I think) can only talk through text towards the player.
That’s I can remember from the series. I know I missed a lot of things and got things incorrect so if you remember the series, please tell me. Though, for anyone reading this right now, if you never watched the series (which I think most of you did), go check out the series. It’s honestly good and there’s still questions left unanswered in the series. Anyways this was written at 3:54 AM currently. Thanks for reading if you did
Edit: Fixed the song name with the coin notes. Corrected by a reply. Thanks for correcting me!
Thanks for the explanation! One small mistake however, the coin notes are from Thalassophobia, the song based on L is Real. Classified Luigi’s Abandoned has those switch notes that lower the water level.
@@CocoaChris917 oh thanks for correcting me. I was tired while I was writing it
@@ggeeoo yeah no problem! Happy to help
the fact you said day out was an "ok" song is "Criminal"
UST reference1!1!11!!1
Minor Correction:
21:27 Hellish Heights actually does have a theme; it's home for characters from Mario horror games and ARGs.
7:41 - 7:50: I think it’s specifically primarily based on the subsequent 7 grand dad meme
Thank you, I’ll pin this comment so people can see it. That is, hoping that this video even gets enough comments that pinning this one would make a difference 💀
@@SaddieMoon yeah. I was right then.
Society if Nourishing Blood was based off was based off SiIvagunner and not Vinesauce: 📈📈📈
@@CinnaBox isnt the song majorly based on both
I am of the belief this is the only mod (that I know of and/or recall) that has no misses. You can name any song from the mod and you can vibe to any one of them, not to mention the story.
It's not a novel concept, Trollge Files years before did some lore when Trollge was booming, but it's like the team pulled from that, put Mario on it, and decided to make only bangers.
To make a great song based off evil mario of all things AND able to make a pretty concrete story out of it is peak having the cake and eating it too.
@@DriverNeku My thoughts exactly
I really liked this video. My only real issue with it is that I feel like you could've been more specific on why you like each song music-wise. Even if you don't know music terminology just saying stuff like "I really liked this songs vibe/energy" or "the melodies in this song are verh catchy/memorable" would've made your analysis of each song more interesting in my opinion. This is a still a great video with good editing and writing, but if you ever do make another FNF mod review like this one, I think you should try to doing this. Regardless, I'm definitely subbing and I'm interested to see what you do next!
Thank you so much! I’ll keep that in mind for future videos!
How the hell do you not have 10K subs or more. This video is so well made, so good, you’re a very underrated creator. Keep it up.
Thank you so much! Comments like these mean the world to me!
I thought Sys was short for System, as he mentions in the commercial "We are Nintendo. Ultimate Game System."
34:02
One thing I think you should’ve mentioned was the credits music. As it gives us an insight into Ultra M’s character. And how he regrets what he did to BF and GF, and describes his world being an empty tomb that he’s alone in.
14:43
One of the best songs in the game.
16:48
I really love this song.
18:43
Opinions, I know. But decent!? This is some amazing music right here.
23:40
“Okay”? I’m shocked that you said it’s okay. Because this song is amazing and is really fun to listen to.
31:44
This and Grand Dad are two other songs I say are also great, and yet he thinks are okay. It’s fine tho, lol.
though i didn’t agree with most takes, you did go in depth and the video was very entertaining! you earned a new subscriber (justice for apparition and the end)
Thank you very much!
wait this is epic. i’m going to watch this entire thing even though i’m on vacation
Sounds like a great way to spend your vacation to me 😏
I find it cool that Unbeatable was treading on Twitter for 3 or 4 days.
Extra information:
At 36:20 the souls Ultra M consumed starts to sing together. It is hard to hear but for people asking for lyrics
"See in the star, Move on lost way all that we are, living to stay, part of it all, take of all face, beckoning call, JOIN US" They repeat this for 2 times after either Mario or Mario with GF's voice tries to trick BF with another lyrics "Say its true me and you! Make it through, what we have to do. Let's be free can't you see? It's-a me!" In my theory since Mario didn’t wanted to kill BF he tried to trick him to get his soul aswell or his companion in his hell. Maybe with an amount of soul Mario can escape from the game or like i said Mario could've wanted BF's companion. If you would ask why would he want BF's company? It is because in outro Mario starts to sing if we need to describe song in short because of with BF he remembered his humanity filled the loneliness inside him after many years. He wanted to defeat him but not with cheating with an fair way. But in end he ended up with losing to his anger and killed him unfairly
Top 3 biggest mods in 2023 Mario madness, indie cross, and impostor v4
I already commented but I noticed smthn else lol: in the IHY creepypasta, before the romhack there was an EXE game based off of it that was very similar to the romhack with some differences. One difference is that in the EXE build, the mushroom jumpscares you with popular creepypasta images instead of killing you. This is why it jumpscares you in Oh God No.
When you say that this is one of the longest mods that isn’t quite true, Vs Imposter V4 and DDTO plus clock in at 3+ hours. I do agree tho that it is pretty long. Crazy you didn’t bring up the mod cameos in the first cutscene. Seeing your ratings, you seem to hate swing rhythm, which kinda sucks to hear considering how rare it is a song to be written in swing. Will say Hex devs literally had experience in NotITG so they thought modcharting was the ideal challenge but didn’t realize how difficult that modcharting was to handle.
@@monkeyb0is4276 I’m not even sure what swing rhythm is 💀 as far as my ratings go, monkey like song, monkey rate song high 💀
@@benny_by6344 Swing Rhythm is commonly in jazz music but the notes sort of are divided unequally so notes have jumps but the tempo and instrumentals help for a basis to keep a toe tapping.
@@monkeyb0is4276 Gotcha, good to know!
How I interpreted the lore was the same as the one you said, but Daddy Dearest trapped M in the game during the 2020s. And as M created his world, he used many Mario related things he knew about at the time and liked or thought was funny. Leading to why the songs are all based on pre-existing things.
Underrated and great review and you gained my sub my g
Thank you so much!
I wholeheartedly agree All Stars is a phenomenal last song! The ending of Act 4 in particular genuinely shocked me first time I saw it. All the notes in the final section felt like it was building to something and I thought it would end on a final note from Boyfriend. But then he was killed before anything like that could happen! At first it was a very abrupt end to the song and lacking a satisfying endnote, but now that I think about it maybe it was intentional? BF being denied a way to victory at the very end cemented how hopeless it was to defeat Ultra M. That is the kind of ending that sticks with you and makes a song like this memorable.
My thoughts exactly, it did something that no other mod had done before so I can understand why some people didn’t like the ending, but personally I loved it
Do u think I you’ll do this for Deluxe and V3 when they come out? (And maybe some UST idk)
this video is so well made and edited, i don't see why the view count is so low. excellent video! i agree with everything you said, except for a few things [everyone has their own opinion, of course].
the only things i disagree with you on are:
1.) race traitors -> personally, i thought this song was pretty good in the original V1 of the mod, but i don't really like the new chromatic they used on mario for this song in the V2 update.
2.) demise -> i love this song as well, and i can see why you rated the charting so low. personally, i love the challenge of the charting, but i do agree that it uses chord notes [double notes as you say] too often compared to anything else in the mod. i would have rated the charting two or three, probably two though.
3.) dark forest -> i personally loved this song and the chromatic / voice of corrupted peach [and the screaming].
obviously, these are my opinions and that doesn't mean your video is bad. again, your video was really fun to watch and it was really well made!!
[i dont really know why i even wrote my opinions because nobody will read it, but whatever. and sorry this is such a long comment!!!!!!!!!! i dont write comments often because i feel so stupid writing them]
this isn't related to the video itself, but has anybody else realized that in "bad day" against "bad mario", he will change your maximum framerate to 69? i haven't seen anybody else talk about it and i thought it was pretty cool.
Thank you so much for leaving this comment, that’s part of the reason I made this video is so people can give their opinions and we can debate about this kind of thing. I agree that I probably should’ve given Demise a slightly higher charting rating, and I loved dark forest as well!
Gonna be honest i never really understood why people prefered race traitors v1 over v2. Other than nostalgia. I remeber when i first heared the song i thought "they acctually gave him a chormatic?!" but i respect your opinion. The other 2 things you said i totally agree with. Demise at first was a song i really didn't like and just thought it was too hard, but with time it has really grown on me and the diffculty isn't that big of a problem. And acctually the same story with dark forest. The screaming in the song really wasn't my cup of tea at first, but what can i say i found the screaming to acctually fit very well with the song after listening to it multiple times.
@@Pagun47 i would try and explain the part i dont like about the chromatic for race traitors, but i cant figure out how to word it. other than my issue with the chromatic, the song itself is pretty good with all the new changes, such as one or two duet sections and the extended song.
i may be stupid, but whenever i played the mod for the first time, i was really excited to hear how they were going to create a V2 race traitors. whenever i got to the song, i felt it was good up until mario starting singing, which is like five seconds in. the chromatic was really a problem for me and the song became one of my least favorites, down there with "so cool". i dont hate the song nearly as much as i used to, but i still find the chromatic to be a bit annoying.
sorry for a long comment again!!!!!
34:36
Fun fact:
Ultra M is an entity that horror mario needs to fuse all overworld and secret characters besides legacy and extras songs
This is honestly my favorite mod, I'm happy that Nintendo did nothing against it for now
Also future update will have bald Mario LET'S FUNKIN' GOOOOO!!
Ik this is gonna sound like a lot of other comments, but MY GOODNESS YOU ARE UNDERRATED! This video seems like its from someone with 100K+ subs, but LESS THAN 1K?!?!?!? YT, start recommending this guy, *NOW!* ⚡⚡⚡
@@EgPerson Thank you so much, this means the world!
very good video and very good script and very good editing and very good review
Even though I alr made 2 comments, this video is very well edited but some of the songs reviews hurt my soul 😔
I also don’t get how people like demise, I personally find it the second shittiest song in the mod
Yooo, the effort on this video is incredible!
It's always great to see high quality stuff from underground channels! You plan on doing more stuff like this in the future? :0
Thank you so much! As a matter of fact, I am currently working on another video essay as we speak! It should hopefully be done within the next week or so (no promises though 💀). However, I will be leaving on a mission for two years in about three weeks so I will have to step away for a little bit, but I plan on doing more once I return!
@@benny_by6344 If it means we get more stuff like this, I can wait for it. :)
Sad bro only 1k also the video is very well edited
This feels like a ign review 💀💀💀
(Great video btw)
@@mrbananathebananaman were my takes that bad? 😭😭😭
@@benny_by6344 you did apparition dirty 😭😭😭😭😭😭 but most were good and fine
@@mrbananathebananaman my fault bro 😭 apparition was just the least memorable song for me 💀
@@benny_by6344 I get it, it's opinions my man
The worst thing about this mod is probably writing. Bf running away from Mario while being unfazed by Much, MUCH more intimidating and scary characters doesnt make sense and is forced
Admit it when you see a half melted enraged mario staring at you like he’s about to brutally murder you’re more terrified than when you see mario with a katana
Finally someone said it. This mods amazing on everything EXCEPT the writing.
@@FireCo0kie-0fficialBF has arguably seen worse.
@@FireCo0kie-0fficial BF was smiling at MX, GB, Mr. V, IHY Luigi, Ultra M, Coronation Peach, Turmoil, and many more that are scarier and more intimidating then melted Horror Mario
@@Happy06853
He wasn't smiling at mx
When facing gb he was habitued to the horror marios
He was smiling at mr virtual UNTIL HE REALIZED GF DIED
IHY luigi is just luigi but almost dead
Ultra M same reason as gb, bf came prepared
Coronation peach is just a floating dead body (but he got a bit scared for a second)
To avoid turmoil, he can just hide in the bushes (in the mushroom kingdom there was nothing but platforms)
Correction about beta luigi’s mansion: it isn’t from a beta. It’s from some kind of commercial for the game, though I don’t remember. Incredible video!
Nourishing blood is more of a reference to vinesauce joel and memes than 7 grand dad
I feel like you should have mentioned the hidden lyrics in oh god no
In day out mario and luigi are actually adults and the voicelines are from the original video
The design of DJ Hallyboo is from Juno songs' lyric video of host hoedown. Juno also made the chromatic for the song and he was in the anti piracy finale
Tbh these are really minor things in such a good and well researched video
ONE THING YOU DID NOT MENTION IS THE DANM CHARTING SYSTEM THIS MOD IS HELD TOGETHER BY DUCT TAPE OOHH BUT IT GETS WORSE NOBODY TALKS ABOUT IT AND BECAUSE OF IT I AM STARTING TO GO INSANE AND SOMETHIING EVEN WORSE THIER WAS A 2 YEAR WAIT AND A NEW VERSION OF THE PSYCH ENGINE THEY HAD LIKE A YEAR TO FIX THAT BECAUSE THIS WAS IN V1 AS WELL also sorry if this comes off as aggressive or something like that i've been trying to fc this and this thing gives me a headache
12:00 This specific version of the mushroom is actually a reference to the EXE game of I HATE YOU. In the EXE game, touching the mushroom would result in an annoyingly loud jumpscare. The EXE game had many problems with it, such as the jumpscares and poor gameplay. But still, a reference is a reference either way.
Keep it up love the videos brotha
Thanks bro, I really appreciate it
12:20
Ngl, I think Oh Gosh No, is very eh. Some parts are fun to listen to, but a lot of the song just feels messy with the two of them singing at the same time. Typically for many mods, it takes me a while to get used to the voices as instruments and what the notes are in the songs’ music sheet usually for said vocals, and it took me a while to really appreciate the OST. This song however, I still have the same opinions as I did when I first heard it.
29:10
This song is also something I never cared for. Even if I like so many others I once felt more negatively about. It just feels messy or not that interesting I guess.
oh gosh no💀
Day out as an ok song is insane but ok
Underrated W video
19:00
The video seemed to be more about non-Nintendo characters being on the track. Not Link or Animal Crossing, especially that they make no appearances in the video.
Pretty sure that was just an example he used for showing what that video was about.
17:03 You've got balls if you're rating Day Out that low. Still great video though!
Day Out just wasn’t as good as the other songs in my opinion, but that is just my opinion.
Well, remember he seems to be rating on the other songs. Like, yeah, Day out is not in the area of starman slaughter or All- Stars.
Hello Anthony Fantano I didn't know you reviewed FNF too
Fun fact: comes 2nd place in luigikid exe challenge
man even ai's telling me my song is ass XD
It is a fantastic fnf mod, i love it.
Im offended by no party
30:34 His name is has always been Stanley. And bro seriously said The End was mediocre…bruh
Paranoia ranking is so strange -_-
Like, 4 stars, 3 stars, 3 stars and overall... 5 stars?!
Yeah I’ll admit it’s a little weird… but I saw the overall category as not just a combination of the three other categories but a culmination of everything about the song, and because the song was so unique and creative I gave it a 5 overall.
@@benny_by6344 k
Continue, hero
Makes me wish they made a sequel to the mod (or a full D sides version)
@@sonicexe66613 I betcha there’s somebody out there who’ll make a d sides version or something like that
@@benny_by6344 yeah, there's some hope
You did no hope justice
Shame song 3 of Irregularity Isle only got a 3 i love the song but others are better honestly but its top 5 for me.
I always wondered why Classified Mario has the TV show Mario voice, but in the song, he has a more traditional voice.
Another thing that I thought about, wouldn’t it ruin GF’s death in All*Stars if we see her dead a few times already?
Classified Mario is like that because the cutscene was made after the song was made so they just made his voice in the cutscene sounds more like a tv show Mario just because the could.
And for the gf thing you may be right, but there are 2 differences here. First of gf doesn't come back after the song. Which is obious cuz it's the last song but still. Secondly Ultra M using gf as a puppet and making her fight gf shows that there really isn't anything he can do now. Gf wont get another 1up. So yeah those 2 things make the death in All stars feel may more impactful.
whats the background music for the “part 1: Intro”?
1:14
It’s from Donkey Kong Country I believe, don’t quote me on that. I’ll check when I get the chance.
How is No hope is higher than paranoia?? 💀💀
I ranked No Hope higher in charting and music, but Paranoia was a higher rating overall.
@@benny_by6344 Ik I just thought paranoias song sounded way better 😔
@@Scaylypie well that’s a classic case of opinion vs opinion 🤷♂️
@@benny_by6344true true true. I like chicken
You accidentally said custom but his name is costume
My top 3 fnf mods 1st mario madness 2nd Wednesday infidelity 3rd indie cross
who dies on 1-1??
Can you do Step Right Up Adventure Isle pls
29:29
Bro did NOT just rate Demise higher than Bad Day 💀
Imo Demise is in a really weird spot for me. It's not BAD per say, but it's not GOOD either.
It's mostly due to Demise mostly being nonsensical notespam, in both the song and the charting, leaving it feeling like your average Dave and Bambi spamtrack. There's also MX's HORRIBLE sounding atonals in the Underground part. BF and MX are also almost CONSTANTLY singing together, and in some cases doesn't sound great, because it sounds like they're fighting over control of the song, and not in a GOOD way either.
What keeps me from saying "Song bad, worst in the mod lmao" is the instrumental, it goes so hard. Especially the piano at the beginning. The first couple turns also aren't as bad as the rest of the song, Still too overcharted, but not AS bad as everything else.
Yeah, like I said, this video is very opinionated, but I felt that Demise captured the mood very well, and in the final section where MX holds the song timer at 3 seconds it really feels like you are having a final showdown which is what made me like the song so much despite the note spam.
@@benny_by6344 Yeah the timer being held at 3 seconds is a really cool concept, along with the general idea for an underground section, it's just I'm not the biggest fan of MX's atonals (Because they just sound horrible lmao) but it's not like Demise is *terrible* or anything, just a bit disappointing and overall a bit of a missed opportunity.
Well, I’d like to be an oddball and say *No Hope sucks*
I literally have no beef with all the other songs besides No Hope and So Cool, those are the 2 songs I dislike
Oh yeah your difficulty rankings are also really weird
The difficulty for each song will vary from person to person is what I’ve found, this is just how hard I found each song in comparison to one another
Youre wrong on the part where you didnt give every song a 5
I wanted to 😭 but I was comparing each song to the rest of the mod, not just FNF songs in general
What the skibbidy sigma is this video I’m unsubscribing for the fun of it
I agree
You are talking to yourself.
Don't mind him, he is a brainrot
That’s my brother 💀 so yeah don’t mind him
didnt ask lol
okay, you didn’t have to watch the video
Fuck mario madness, literally, this mad was full of bugs and some of the charting was hard
Respectfully, skill issue. I only came across one small bug that didn’t cause much of an issue, and I thought the charting overall was excellent. Probably the best FNF mod to exist.
@@benny_by6344 i know what you mean, but for us that we're working on mods (and with good quality too) play Mario Madness wasn't that experience that we thought it was going to be.
My reaction was exaggerated, i don't hate this mod, i just don't think is the "BEST" fnf mario creepypasta mod, when there are literally other mods that are better in some other aspects. I hope this explains it all, and have a good day
@@Bragbigfoot_2 out of curiosity, what mod do you think is better than this one? I’d love to check it out and see for myself
@@benny_by6344 classified
I didn’t experience any bugs and the only hard song is no party, I think you just have a skill issue
Dude
Bro