Hi Shane, My comment isn't about your model (which I think you have done a cracking good job on by the way and Can not fault at all) but about the first pic you posted of a Sherbrooke Sherman III. It's actually a Sherman V of a Canadian Artillery regiment. It's a Sherman V OP. A few identifiers are the undercuts in the cast hoods, the radio pot on the front glacis, T62 tracks (Most commonly used on Sherman V's but not exclusively), Some could also argue the early 3 piece transmission but some III's did have them. Also, the 3 antenna's. This is actually a very well known picture in Canadian Armour circles. Keep up the great work mate!!!
Thanks mate! Thanks so much for explaining and sharing this great information with me! I never even noticed the cut outs on the hoods! I have a question regarding the antennas as you seem more knowledgeable about British/Canadian Shermans than I. Would a Squadron command vehicle have a similar three antenna array ?
Nice model shane ! You added lots of nice details. Soon starting my Asuka Firefly. I don't know my shermans like you but I like anything with a 17 pdr. You are a very helpful source for me. Thanks for taking the time and effort
@johncrimmins1540 cheers mate! The Firefly is pretty nice looking Sherman for sure! Are you building the VC ? If you run into issues or need information on the build let me know
Hi Shane, another great kit build from a master of this great hobby,looking forward to the painting episode, best regards from a Kiwi living in Australia 👌👍👌👍👌👍
That's a lovely bit of work there - and I hope you don't take me for an A-hole rivet counter, but I can't help noticing the positioning of the blanket box. In every picture I've seen, the box lines up with the bottom of the bustle, rather than hanging below it. You can see on that photo of the 13th/18th Hussars tank you showed.
Hi Shane, great build as always and so much useful information on the little details. I’ve just bought this kit, so this video was really useful. Love all the scratch built items along the way. Looking forward to seeing the painting video.
Thanks mate! Super glad my project could have helped you out a little. Your gonna love this kit its such a gem to work on. Hopefully we will be getting the painting and weathering early 2024
Very nice and to the point mate! You keep teaching us about Shermans and their peculiar minor detail variations, which is really handy. That particular Sherman version is one i never noticed before, so i think my horizon has widened a bit in that field thanks to you. Of course all you did here turned the model into a gem. It looks lovely, one might consider to not paint it, since it illustrates nicely what you did to the kit to achieve this result.
Thanks Michi! Super glad you enjoy my Sherman ramblings lol Oh mate I've descended down the Sherman rabbit hole of late, and keep finding new details to try to add at the risk of my sanity lol I am considering leaving one of my builds unpainted but I am such a messy builder to get away with it lol Now I'm off to watch your 250 video as I have the same kit!
Cheers mate, i certainly did enjoy it since generic things bore me, but special stuff gets my attention :) Right now i am in the process of building up momentum to start the M7 Priest by Dragon in the next few weeks, or at least i plan something along those lines. I need some Allied stuff for the Alsace liberation project i want to take part in. I could also build two Shermans but i don´t have a vision for the scene i want to build, the Priest is a bit clearer in that regard. That 250 is nice but also a pig in some aspects, i hope you find our review helpful and not too discouraging :D
@@HamilkarBarkasScaleModelling Glad to have stirred your curiosity to the dark side of the Sherman :P Oh I remember you saying you a M7 in the stash. I am pretty sure I tired to order one not too long ago but never showed up lol The M7 would make an interesting subject to do for a Alsace themed project!
@@longlance67 I know it is proper heresy for me, but i don´t build US armor very often at all, so i might be forgiven a small detour into that topic. Also, that model show next year about the liberation of Alsace is giving me a reason to do so. I just want to be there and in order to do so i have to suffer a bit it seems :D
I think all the details are beautiful and spot on. With the interest in getting everything perfect, why do modelers not do anything with the lights? Or did they get damaged early on and never work? I picked up the 1/16 jeep kit, and that is one point I'm looking forward to addressing. Thanks for a great video.
The sherman looks fantastic with all the small details and after market bits you added. I'm looking forward to the painting & weathering part. Also, just wanted to point it out, but for me at least, the audio of this video is really quiet and i had to have my audio turned all they way up just to hear you.
Beautiful! I wish tamiya would re-release their firefly. Another sherman I would like to build, if a company would make it is Oddballs sherman from Kelly's Heros!
The Firefly in question is an Asuka Model rebox by Tamiya which is still readily on the market if you are hunting one still. Doing Oddball's Sherman would be so cool. Speaking of movie Shermans I currently working on my rendition of FURY. Which is such a good looking tank in my opinion lol
Hi Shane your sherman looks really cool buddy you have done a fantastic job love all the updates you have used regarding the archer set you have used where did you buy the set from as i can't find the archer resin set any where. looking forward to the paint job mate. Cheers Gary 🇬🇧
One wiki page for the Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment has a story of the CO receiving a squadron's worth of new tanks. He had B and C squadron commanders flip a coin, and B Sqn won the toss. "Rad" was in C squadron, and Caribou was his third mount. I would disagree with piling so many stores on the engine deck. In the Normandy battles, the echelon was not far behind and was able to meet the tanks at hides and harbours. Too much gear would have been an encumbrance, especially when the tankers often evacuated wounded or lifted infantry on the engine decks. Tank Bomb had a shell hit the turret .50-cal and it injured two crewmembers - if the tank is big, that would give the enemy more to sight on and impacts could start fires or direct splinters into the engine.
Very nice build and appreciate the explanations. I have one of these Asuka Shermans in my stash to build. Specifically the Jumbo with some sandbag armor. I am looking forward to the build as I hear these are unique kits. I am curious what you thought of the rubber tracks that came in the kit vs the replacements you added. The Jumbo has the duckbill tracks and I'm on the fence as the rubber tracks in the kit are actually quite nice in comparison to those old school Tamiya rubber tracks. Considering the Fruilmodel replacement but not sure yet.
Thanks mate! super happy with how it turned out! I don't think I will be doing a dio for this Sherman as such but maybe a small vignette base. It will be part of a larger display with Ekins' Firefly and Wittmann's final Tiger
Great video as always mate, I have a question for you, are you able to clean the brush after using mr surfacer or is it a case of use once and bin the brush,?? I've never used it before and wamt to order some and I want to get the correct cleaning solution or cheap brushes for when it arrives, Cheers mate
Thanks mate! As for the Mr.Surfacer and using brushes. I have some old brushes that are frayed that are my primary brushes for applying it. To clean the brushes I use a dedicated bottle of lacquer thinner (in my case a bottle of Mr.Color self levelling thinner) which easily removes the Mr.Surfacer from the brush. hope that helps mate!
I’m looking to get a Sherman kit that my grandfather might have driven. He was in North Africa from late 1941 and the Italy. Drove crusaders and shermans. Any recommendations? Which kits do people rate as the best? A bonus would be a kit that has decals for 10th royal hussars (the 10th royal hussars had no camo paint schemes it would seem and just had a blue circle for each side and on front and back there was a ‘67’ on a red square and a white rhino on a black pill shaped background to signify 1st armoured div). I have decals I recently bought for the hussars so I guess I could just use those, though they were for a crusader so couldn’t use the vehicle ID number. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated. Wish my grandad was still here to advise me!! RIP Daniel Murphy 10th Royal hussars, 2nd arm bgde, 1st arm div.
@danhat69 Hey Dan, what a great project and a lovely tribute to your grandfather. So off the top of my head, North African Sherman being deployed with the British in 1941. That would be some of the very first deliveries of early production M4A1 (Sherman I) and M4A2 (Sherman III), respectively. Both of these variants would have the direct vision ports for the drive/co drivers. Early bogies for the M4A1 and possibly for the M4A2, though I've seen A2s with the later return roller on the bogies issued, too. I'll double-check my references when I get home from work. As for kits, ASUKA has both of those types in their range. And i would highly recommend them. I'll get back to you with more information later this evening. Hope this helps as a starting point
@ thanks lance. Asuka m4a1 it is then. I was looking at dragon El Alamein Sherman kit but if I find an Asuka with correct markings I think I’ll go for that. Never done a dragon or asuka to be honest (I have a couple of Miniart kits and a Border models crusader so I’m really branching out. I’ve got lots of kits to hone my skills on b4 I attempt the tribute diorama to my grandfather. I’m very much a novice at the moment. It’ll prob be at least 18-24 months before I have completed all my ‘practice’ kits (I have over 35!!)
I can't wait for the paint video.
thanks mate! I hope to get around to painting this M4 up in the next week or so!
Hi Shane, My comment isn't about your model (which I think you have done a cracking good job on by the way and Can not fault at all) but about the first pic you posted of a Sherbrooke Sherman III. It's actually a Sherman V of a Canadian Artillery regiment. It's a Sherman V OP. A few identifiers are the undercuts in the cast hoods, the radio pot on the front glacis, T62 tracks (Most commonly used on Sherman V's but not exclusively), Some could also argue the early 3 piece transmission but some III's did have them. Also, the 3 antenna's. This is actually a very well known picture in Canadian Armour circles. Keep up the great work mate!!!
Thanks mate! Thanks so much for explaining and sharing this great information with me! I never even noticed the cut outs on the hoods! I have a question regarding the antennas as you seem more knowledgeable about British/Canadian Shermans than I. Would a Squadron command vehicle have a similar three antenna array ?
*Wonderful result, the scratch work gives so muche realism to your model, the "basic" Sherman!*
Thanks mate! I really love adding those extra little details! It really bring your own project to life!
Nice model shane ! You added lots of nice details. Soon starting my Asuka Firefly. I don't know my shermans like you but I like anything with
a 17 pdr. You are a very helpful source for me. Thanks for taking the time and effort
@johncrimmins1540 cheers mate! The Firefly is pretty nice looking Sherman for sure! Are you building the VC ? If you run into issues or need information on the build let me know
Thanks a lot ! Yes , the VC. Did you have good luck with the tracks? Been awhile since I have done that type.
Hi Shane, another great kit build from a master of this great hobby,looking forward to the painting episode, best regards from a Kiwi living in Australia 👌👍👌👍👌👍
Greetings from rainy Ireland!
That is super kind of you to say, I hope my efforts live up to your praise!
thanks mate!
Amazing detail mate..You’ve built a right beauty there..All the best👍
Thanks very much mate! It has to be my favorite Sherman I've built this last year!
That's a lovely bit of work there - and I hope you don't take me for an A-hole rivet counter, but I can't help noticing the positioning of the blanket box. In every picture I've seen, the box lines up with the bottom of the bustle, rather than hanging below it. You can see on that photo of the 13th/18th Hussars tank you showed.
Thanks mate! You know I never realized how low I placed the stowage box. I will be sure to fix that before I get to painting it up! Thanks again!
Well Done Shane!! Lots of great attention to detail.👍🏽👍🏽
Glad you liked it!
Hi Shane, great build as always and so much useful information on the little details. I’ve just bought this kit, so this video was really useful. Love all the scratch built items along the way. Looking forward to seeing the painting video.
Thanks mate! Super glad my project could have helped you out a little. Your gonna love this kit its such a gem to work on. Hopefully we will be getting the painting and weathering early 2024
Very nice and to the point mate! You keep teaching us about Shermans and their peculiar minor detail variations, which is really handy. That particular Sherman version is one i never noticed before, so i think my horizon has widened a bit in that field thanks to you.
Of course all you did here turned the model into a gem. It looks lovely, one might consider to not paint it, since it illustrates nicely what you did to the kit to achieve this result.
Thanks Michi! Super glad you enjoy my Sherman ramblings lol
Oh mate I've descended down the Sherman rabbit hole of late, and keep finding new details to try to add at the risk of my sanity lol
I am considering leaving one of my builds unpainted but I am such a messy builder to get away with it lol Now I'm off to watch your 250 video as I have the same kit!
Cheers mate, i certainly did enjoy it since generic things bore me, but special stuff gets my attention :)
Right now i am in the process of building up momentum to start the M7 Priest by Dragon in the next few weeks, or at least i plan something along those lines. I need some Allied stuff for the Alsace liberation project i want to take part in. I could also build two Shermans but i don´t have a vision for the scene i want to build, the Priest is a bit clearer in that regard.
That 250 is nice but also a pig in some aspects, i hope you find our review helpful and not too discouraging :D
@@HamilkarBarkasScaleModelling Glad to have stirred your curiosity to the dark side of the Sherman :P Oh I remember you saying you a M7 in the stash. I am pretty sure I tired to order one not too long ago but never showed up lol
The M7 would make an interesting subject to do for a Alsace themed project!
@@longlance67 I know it is proper heresy for me, but i don´t build US armor very often at all, so i might be forgiven a small detour into that topic. Also, that model show next year about the liberation of Alsace is giving me a reason to do so. I just want to be there and in order to do so i have to suffer a bit it seems :D
lovely work Shane all that lovely detail cant wait to see her with some paint on 👌👌👌👌
thanks Greg! I'm really looking forward to painting and weathering her up!
I love your videos! Thanks Shane!
Thanks mate! I really appreciate it!
Awesome stuff mate and I love the history behind the it. I can't wait to see it painted.
Thanks mate! I have Firefly to complete the Sherman aspect of the battle. Which I will build up over the next few weeks!
@@longlance67 I can't wait to see it mate.
Great build, Shane!
thanks mate!
Very interesting, thanks
Glad you enjoyed it
Thanks Shane, Always great to see your videos and excellent work.
My pleasure!
I think all the details are beautiful and spot on.
With the interest in getting everything perfect, why do modelers not do anything with the lights? Or did they get damaged early on and never work?
I picked up the 1/16 jeep kit, and that is one point I'm looking forward to addressing.
Thanks for a great video.
The sherman looks fantastic with all the small details and after market bits you added.
I'm looking forward to the painting & weathering part.
Also, just wanted to point it out, but for me at least, the audio of this video is really quiet and i had to have my audio turned all they way up just to hear you.
Thanks mate! Glad you enjoyed it! I will try to fix the audio going forward!
Beautiful! I wish tamiya would re-release their firefly. Another sherman I would like to build, if a company would make it is Oddballs sherman from Kelly's Heros!
The Firefly in question is an Asuka Model rebox by Tamiya which is still readily on the market if you are hunting one still.
Doing Oddball's Sherman would be so cool. Speaking of movie Shermans I currently working on my rendition of FURY. Which is such a good looking tank in my opinion lol
Very good Job 👍🏻🤘🏻Shane
cheers mate!
Hi Shane your sherman looks really cool buddy you have done a fantastic job love all the updates you have used regarding the archer set you have used where did you buy the set from as i can't find the archer resin set any where. looking forward to the paint job mate. Cheers Gary 🇬🇧
Thanks mate! As for the Archer Transfers. They are near impossible to find these days as Archer is now out of business now
One wiki page for the Sherbrooke Fusilier Regiment has a story of the CO receiving a squadron's worth of new tanks. He had B and C squadron commanders flip a coin, and B Sqn won the toss. "Rad" was in C squadron, and Caribou was his third mount. I would disagree with piling so many stores on the engine deck. In the Normandy battles, the echelon was not far behind and was able to meet the tanks at hides and harbours. Too much gear would have been an encumbrance, especially when the tankers often evacuated wounded or lifted infantry on the engine decks. Tank Bomb had a shell hit the turret .50-cal and it injured two crewmembers - if the tank is big, that would give the enemy more to sight on and impacts could start fires or direct splinters into the engine.
Very nice build and appreciate the explanations. I have one of these Asuka Shermans in my stash to build. Specifically the Jumbo with some sandbag armor. I am looking forward to the build as I hear these are unique kits. I am curious what you thought of the rubber tracks that came in the kit vs the replacements you added. The Jumbo has the duckbill tracks and I'm on the fence as the rubber tracks in the kit are actually quite nice in comparison to those old school Tamiya rubber tracks. Considering the Fruilmodel replacement but not sure yet.
Looks cool.
cheers!
Great Video. I just found you and subd. Great site!
Thanks for the sub! Just returned the favor with a sub too :)
Hi Shane
Great work as per your usual standards!
Are you going to do a diorama?
Thanks for sharing your cool video mate ❤😊
Thanks mate! super happy with how it turned out! I don't think I will be doing a dio for this Sherman as such but maybe a small vignette base. It will be part of a larger display with Ekins' Firefly and Wittmann's final Tiger
Great video as always mate, I have a question for you, are you able to clean the brush after using mr surfacer or is it a case of use once and bin the brush,??
I've never used it before and wamt to order some and I want to get the correct cleaning solution or cheap brushes for when it arrives,
Cheers mate
Thanks mate! As for the Mr.Surfacer and using brushes. I have some old brushes that are frayed that are my primary brushes for applying it. To clean the brushes I use a dedicated bottle of lacquer thinner (in my case a bottle of Mr.Color self levelling thinner) which easily removes the Mr.Surfacer from the brush.
hope that helps mate!
@@longlance67 cheers mate, much appreciated
I’m looking to get a Sherman kit that my grandfather might have driven. He was in North Africa from late 1941 and the Italy. Drove crusaders and shermans. Any recommendations? Which kits do people rate as the best?
A bonus would be a kit that has decals for 10th royal hussars (the 10th royal hussars had no camo paint schemes it would seem and just had a blue circle for each side and on front and back there was a ‘67’ on a red square and a white rhino on a black pill shaped background to signify 1st armoured div).
I have decals I recently bought for the hussars so I guess I could just use those, though they were for a crusader so couldn’t use the vehicle ID number.
Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
Wish my grandad was still here to advise me!!
RIP
Daniel Murphy 10th Royal hussars, 2nd arm bgde, 1st arm div.
@danhat69 Hey Dan, what a great project and a lovely tribute to your grandfather.
So off the top of my head, North African Sherman being deployed with the British in 1941. That would be some of the very first deliveries of early production M4A1 (Sherman I) and M4A2 (Sherman III), respectively. Both of these variants would have the direct vision ports for the drive/co drivers. Early bogies for the M4A1 and possibly for the M4A2, though I've seen A2s with the later return roller on the bogies issued, too. I'll double-check my references when I get home from work.
As for kits, ASUKA has both of those types in their range. And i would highly recommend them.
I'll get back to you with more information later this evening.
Hope this helps as a starting point
@ thanks lance. Asuka m4a1 it is then. I was looking at dragon El Alamein Sherman kit but if I find an Asuka with correct markings I think I’ll go for that. Never done a dragon or asuka to be honest (I have a couple of Miniart kits and a Border models crusader so I’m really branching out. I’ve got lots of kits to hone my skills on b4 I attempt the tribute diorama to my grandfather. I’m very much a novice at the moment. It’ll prob be at least 18-24 months before I have completed all my ‘practice’ kits (I have over 35!!)
what asuka kit is this ?
Sherman III mid production (w/cast driver's hood) Kit No. 35-018
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bomb_(tank)# Bomb was repatriated to Canada, and is on display.
That is awesome!