This is what it looks like when artists take in critisism and actually change for the better. All 4 of them seems to be very confident, their vocals are eating & their facial expressions are never boring to look at. I'm especially proud of Giselle, considering that she was/is considered the weakest yet objectively (imo) she is keeping up with the other members and serving so hard lately. Love my girlies ౨ৎ
dude is this their "change for the better"? i'm sorry don't mistake me for a hater...recently i've been listening to their songs like supernova etc.. so i decided to give it a try to their live performance and i'm really not impressed with this live. i seriously think they still have to improve much more. I've seen some of karina's solos stage reels on insta and she was incredible and that drove me here. i don't think this is any better...i was expecting more from them. i was not aware of their critisism until i read your comment.
@@mahamuthafathima12b19like any idol out there, of course they still have room for improvement. if you were to compare their earlier eras like ‘savage’/‘girls’ to ‘drama’, you will see a big difference in their stage presence. also, aespa debuted during the pandemic, so they barely had any opportunities to perform in front of an audience. and coachella ended up being their first ever performance in front of a live audience.
@@mahamuthafathima12b19 my guess is that it’s probably their choreo that’s giving you that impression, plus maybe energy- karina never sang live for her solo and could dance more difficult choreo, which adds to her presence in that performance. It’s why you def felt connected to it more. They’ve all rlly improved in aura the most imo, plus their voices have gotten better and better
@@emicals. I feel like their improvement stage is already over because it's been 4 years since pandemic. And being a singer/musician and a performer, both are different. Not every singer out there knows how to perform and not every performer knows how to sing. and aespa just comes under the first category. They are incredible singers, but their company SM lacked to give training for their performing skills.
![[#2024MAMA] aespa - Whiplash (MAMA ver.) | Mnet 241123](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QB7eaAAIZAU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[aespa] Trick or Trick/ Set The Tone/ Next Level/ Armageddon (ROCK) - #aespa_SYNK_PARALLELLINE_inBKK](/img/1.gif)
Stylist ate with this one fr 😭
this hair is sooo pretty on giselle omg a doll
how crazy Giselle's aura !!
Doesn’t match Karina’s aura but Giselle also looks phenomenal. She was feeling herself. But Karina as usual is just 🤌
@@mknwycome on bro.. you can’t appreciate Giselle without comparing her to the other members? What a MY…
@@mknwy what a party pooper
Seeing her live is next level, she is out of this world
@@mknwy jesus i hope u don’t downplay compliments to others like that irl cause damn, u’re asking to get side eyed by the ppl around u lol
this just proves that giselle has improved her dancing so much that she stands out the most!!
2:24 Giselle was feeling herself damn
Sweetest girl in ma heart
She needs that Dopamine 😁
defenitly gotta be the most replayed part because why did i purr
and ningning at 2:48
What a monumental slay by Giselle!!
giselle is so perfect omg
Winter eats illusion every damn time. Also she a yassified cinderella 💅
Ningnings stand and walk is ICONIC ALSO JUST HER OVERALL EYES ONLY ON HER SHES SPECTACULAR!!!! GO NINGNING !!!!her gaze and vibe unmatched!!!!
Giselle being Giselle
they are honestly one of if not the most prettiest girl group ever 😭
2:22 omg Giselle..so fine
The part prior to this 1:34 but especially this very part is so satisfying, their harmony ❤❤❤❤
why the hell is gigi so damn hot. OMGGG
Stylist did what was needed to be done! Loveeee!!! ❤❤❤
Winter looks dazzling
Giselle is mothering as alwayssss
Karina looks like a fairy ❤❤
Giselle is crazy georgerus 😮❤
GISELLE, my bias❤❤❤ slays it every time❤❤❤
ningning in that yellow dress just WOW QUEEN SLAYYYEDDD!!!!
blue dress looks beautiful!
Winter
I love winters dress!!
This song and the choreo is so addictive, it's my fav song from aespa for sure ❤
This is what it looks like when artists take in critisism and actually change for the better. All 4 of them seems to be very confident, their vocals are eating & their facial expressions are never boring to look at. I'm especially proud of Giselle, considering that she was/is considered the weakest yet objectively (imo) she is keeping up with the other members and serving so hard lately.
Love my girlies ౨ৎ
dude is this their "change for the better"? i'm sorry don't mistake me for a hater...recently i've been listening to their songs like supernova etc.. so i decided to give it a try to their live performance and i'm really not impressed with this live. i seriously think they still have to improve much more. I've seen some of karina's solos stage reels on insta and she was incredible and that drove me here. i don't think this is any better...i was expecting more from them. i was not aware of their critisism until i read your comment.
@@mahamuthafathima12b19like any idol out there, of course they still have room for improvement. if you were to compare their earlier eras like ‘savage’/‘girls’ to ‘drama’, you will see a big difference in their stage presence. also, aespa debuted during the pandemic, so they barely had any opportunities to perform in front of an audience. and coachella ended up being their first ever performance in front of a live audience.
@@mahamuthafathima12b19 my guess is that it’s probably their choreo that’s giving you that impression, plus maybe energy- karina never sang live for her solo and could dance more difficult choreo, which adds to her presence in that performance. It’s why you def felt connected to it more. They’ve all rlly improved in aura the most imo, plus their voices have gotten better and better
Girl...they are not singing here.
@@emicals. I feel like their improvement stage is already over because it's been 4 years since pandemic. And being a singer/musician and a performer, both are different. Not every singer out there knows how to perform and not every performer knows how to sing. and aespa just comes under the first category. They are incredible singers, but their company SM lacked to give training for their performing skills.
The only performance I’ll think abt for days on end
it is time to shine giselle❤❤
Can’t take my eyes off of winter❤❤❤
they’re unbelievable beautiful
Damn Aeri - chan!
they are such. magnetic performers damn... and winter with this coral hair remains iconic
the dance,the voices ,the outfits OMGGG they are so perfect😍🤩
These outfits are giving So Cool by Sistar and I am LIVING for it👏🏻☝🏻🧎🏻♀️
Omg yes!
how can all of them be so pretty?
애리 너무 예쁘다
The outfits!!!! ❤❤❤
0:11 who was MOANING??? 😭😭😭
OMG LMAO
😭😭😭😭
Cupcakke was in the crowd 😂😂
OMG they were probably 'too happy' to see Aespa 😂
Wow Gigi
Omg so gorgeous and talented I'm obsessed
couldnt stop staring at giselle
Giselle is really shining and rocking this era.
YESSSS THEY LOOK SO AMAZING
Giselle aura is UNMATCHED. holy crap ‼️
I can’t take my eyes off giselle
THEY'RE SOOO STUNNING!
omg giselle damnn🔥🔥🔥🔥
WHAT I WOULD GIVE TO SEE THIS LIVE😭😭
No need for high energy choreo, just subtle precise moves will do the job. Just Incredible.
Winter is so over this song lmaooooo
Omg winter 😻
The are just GLOWING OMG 💗💗💗💗
Their outfits are so gooddddd. RAHHH.
3:11 GISELLE MOTHER😩
NingNing ate
All black mamba songs are giselle's 💯🖤💥💫
Goddesses
2:30 winter noticed giselle was feeling herself here 😂 so cute
Wow, Giselle looks like a vintage barbie! She looks amazing with that hair and fit
OUU AESPA ATE ❤
Thank you .
Giselleeeee❤😮
와 닝닝
Thumbnail so insane I had to watch
그저 GOAT
Giselle❤
썸네일에 진짜 홀려서 들어옴
Karina my angel 😇
that’s hot 🥵😮💨
Damn they look hot
Winter❤
지젤 너무이쁘네요
Gigi😍
I NEED TO NOW FROM WHERE ARE THESE DRESSES OMG
Wow Giselle is so beautiful
😍😍😍😍😍😍
At last!!stylist gave Giselle the outfit she deserves!I see an idol and not a "back dancer"
GISSELLLEEE IM YOURSSSSSSSS
Giselle😭
지젤 ㅈㄴ이쁘다
Ning in this yellow dress tho..😍
las amooo
0:40 WINTER VISUAL?? 🤭🤭💗
성형 이빠이데스
karina
❤
Karina and Winter🛐🩷
Its time to make some giselle edits ig
They look so goooood I was who’s this 😂😂😂
They all look so pretty that I want to die god
I dont know why my eyes is at Giselle all the time❤
Hermosas
ommgg everyone is so stunning and Giselle-so gorgeous and crazy!! shes like where are u looking? Dont get your eyes off me!
Giselle slays
2:33 this is so iconic mann
I can tell their bias is Karina
their body and face is just so effin unreal.......
NingNing is so hot
언니 ; 와이리 예쁘노 ; 얼굴 재밌네 거참 ;
HERMOSAS ES DECIR POCO
Giselle такая любовь. Как же она хороша!
지젤 미챴다ㅏㅏ