Also I think this is the last song using the old formula for lines distribution of them TaenSic dominating The vocal line having verses Dance line few prechorus And Yuri the bridge Think songs like Gee, The Boys album, Debut etc
Goodbye Verse 1: Tif, Seo, Soo Chorus 1: Tae Verse 2: Sun, Hyo, Yoo Chorus 2: Jes Bridge: Yur, Tae Outro: Seo, Sica, Sun, Tif, Tae I gave Tae/Sica MVL credit for carrying the whole Chorus. Felt deserved. Tae 3 lines, 1 adlib, MVL, high note, main high note Jes 2 lines 1 adlib, MVL, 2 high note Tif 2 lines, 1 adlib Sun 2 lines Seo 2 lines Yur 1 line Soo 1 line Hyo 1 line Yoo 1 line Main Tae 7 points Sica 6 points Lead Tif 3 points Vocalist Sun 2 points Seo 2 points Subvocalist Yur 1 point Soo 1 point Hyo 1 point Yoo 1 point
[LINE DISTRIBUTION] Girls Generation at [TAEYEON KIM] (NEW VERSION) OT9 UNTIL : Goodbye 😔 TAEYEON_3057.3 JESSICA_2660.8 TIFFANY_1986.0 SEOHYUN_1784.3 SUNNY_1496.9 YURI_1017.6 SOOYOUNG_988.2 YOONA_897.9 HYO_791.2 Last Jessica's Korean Album 😔 // 💗
prettyyy bad i think...then again i think it makes sense based on their positions. the main vocals getting whole choruses and adlibs, the lead vocals with one line each and a couple adlibs, and the dancers with one line each...technically fair? (based on positions lol its still a bad line distribution imo)
I'm pretty sure the chorus could be divided in two by two people and make the distribution more fair instead of a TaeJess duet feat. the rest of them but what do I know
@@user-ep6kj6do5iIn Europa, catch me if you can, chain reaction and Divine Jessica's same position with lead vocal Tiffany so I don't count them. In these songs there're like 3 main vocals When Tiff's actually a lead.
Would be TaengSic main TiffSunSeo lead Dance line Vocal. Ot8 Would be main Tae Lead SunSeo Vocal Tiff Sub Vocal dance line. I dont think Tiff got any lines from Jess and the chorus have more impact.
- Tiff first adlib - How weak the vocals on the 3rd chorus sound compared to TaengSic's choruses - The outro - EVERYTHING lol live version >>>>>> studio version
This should’ve been the TaengSic duet we all deserved 😭
TaengSic chorus😢😢😢
Also I think this is the last song using the old formula for lines distribution of them
TaenSic dominating
The vocal line having verses
Dance line few prechorus
And Yuri the bridge
Think songs like Gee, The Boys album, Debut etc
Vocal line ad-libs too.
Mr.Mr (at the moment):
1) Taeyeon: 69.7
2) Jessica: 67.6
3) Tiffany: 40
4) Seohyun: 26.6
5) Sunny: 23.1
6) Sooyoung: 18.5
7) Yuri: 18.4
8) Yoona: 16
9) Hyoyeon: 15.3
In a way this song is proof SM still considered taejess the main vocal line its just sad the rest of the album/3rd japan album doesnt reflect that
Love this song
Here they remembered Sica is a main vocal
The only track in mr mr ep that respects her
everyone loves Goodbye
This is song so fit so much for Tiff+Hyo's deep voice and TaengSic
This song is so good. But imagine if Taengsic sang the last chorus together
like the last chorus bein taengsic would’ve been so good
It's Most likely them.
Maybe with Tiff or SEO or Sun inside.
@@nighthunter3372 it’s sunny and Seohyun with taengsic backing up
@@shrugemoji7476Ok
@@nighthunter3372It’s not though. It’s Seohyun and Sunny with TaeJeTi or just TaeJes backing them up
Goodbye
Verse 1: Tif, Seo, Soo
Chorus 1: Tae
Verse 2: Sun, Hyo, Yoo
Chorus 2: Jes
Bridge: Yur, Tae
Outro: Seo, Sica, Sun, Tif, Tae
I gave Tae/Sica MVL credit for carrying the whole Chorus. Felt deserved.
Tae 3 lines, 1 adlib, MVL, high note, main high note
Jes 2 lines 1 adlib, MVL, 2 high note
Tif 2 lines, 1 adlib
Sun 2 lines
Seo 2 lines
Yur 1 line
Soo 1 line
Hyo 1 line
Yoo 1 line
Main
Tae 7 points
Sica 6 points
Lead
Tif 3 points
Vocalist
Sun 2 points
Seo 2 points
Subvocalist
Yur 1 point
Soo 1 point
Hyo 1 point
Yoo 1 point
If using the alt system pretty sure Jess would be a Lead.
Tae 3 lines 1 adlib MVL HN MHN= 12.5
Jess 2 lines 1 adlib MVL 2 HN= 8.5
[LINE DISTRIBUTION] Girls Generation at [TAEYEON KIM]
(NEW VERSION) OT9
UNTIL : Goodbye 😔
TAEYEON_3057.3
JESSICA_2660.8
TIFFANY_1986.0
SEOHYUN_1784.3
SUNNY_1496.9
YURI_1017.6
SOOYOUNG_988.2
YOONA_897.9
HYO_791.2
Last Jessica's Korean Album 😔
// 💗
Looking at this Sun won't pass 2000 and HyoYoon maybe pass 1000
No songs in Mr Mr album plus Lion Heart were dominated by her
Maybe It's you from Holiday Night might help her. SunHyoYoon
are you counting only the solo lines?
prettyyy bad i think...then again i think it makes sense based on their positions. the main vocals getting whole choruses and adlibs, the lead vocals with one line each and a couple adlibs, and the dancers with one line each...technically fair? (based on positions lol its still a bad line distribution imo)
I'm pretty sure the chorus could be divided in two by two people and make the distribution more fair instead of a TaeJess duet feat. the rest of them but what do I know
agree
Taengsic and friends 😅
One of my favs. ❤
This is how i would've distributed:
[Tiff] Dwie museun daesareul haljji aneun geujeo geureon drama-cheoreom
[Seo] Oneul niga naege eotteon mareul haljjido neomu algesseo
[Soo] Chungbunhi yesangdwen jinbuhan story-ya
[Tae] Oh bamsae nanun yaegiwa jeojeun geu nunppit seotuldeon neoye gobaekdo ijen
[Tae] bukkeureoun ilgicheoreom sumgyeojigo Maeil
[Seo] dulmane baegya sok nege mutteon Buranhan miraekkaji jeonbu
[Seo] Annyeong really really good goodbye
[Sun] Hanttaeneun naega neo eopshin sum shwigido himdeun jul arasseo
[Hyo] Geuttaeneun niga nareul jonjaehage mandeun shinin jul arasseo
[Yoo] Jogeum ashwipjiman minmanghan iyagi
[Jess] Oh bamsae nanun yaegiwa jeojeun geu nunppit seotuldeon neoye gobaekdo ijen
[Jess] bukkeureoun ilgicheoreom sumgyeojigo Maeil
[Sun] dulmane baegya sok nege mutteon Buranhan miraekkaji jeonbu
[Sun] Annyeong really really good goodbye
[Yu] Manyak naega maedallyeo ni mameul dollyeodo
[Soo/Yoo] Geu daeume
[Hyo/Yu] Geu daeumen
[Jess] banbokdwel ppunijanni
[Tae] Oh yeah
Sueopshi ipsul kkaemulmyeo beotyeotteon maeumi ijen jichin geolkka anim naega?
Neomu keun gidael haetteon geolkka? Moreugesseo ([Tiff] Gidaehaenneunjido molla na)
Waenji naeireun biga ol kkeonman gata
Memareun naege ppuryeo jweoyo
Annyeong Really really good goodbye
[Seo] Yeah oh yeah
Eoryeotteon shigan Really really good goodbye ([Tiff] Goodbye)
Eojeye naneun ([Tiff] Really really good goodbye ([Tae] ooh)
Ijeneun annyeong Really really good goodbye ([Jess] Really really good goodbye)
[Tiff] Oh yeah
[Sun] Oh yeah yeah
Good good really really good goodbye
[Tiff] Hmm hmm hmm
Main vocalists - 1st part of the choruses + 1 part at the bridge + 1 adlib
Lead vocalists - 1 verse + 2nd parts of the choruses + 1 Adlib (As there are no more choruses i gave Tiffany all the other adlibs)
And then i gave the Sub-vocalists duo parts in the bridge and i think it would be pretty cool
Line distribution:
1. Jessica - 23.1
2. Taeyeon - 23.0
3. Seohyun - 19.7
4. Sunny - 19.6
5. Tiffany - 18.2
6. Yoona - 8.2
7. Sooyoung - 8.1
8. Hyo - 8.0
9. Yuri - 6.8
not fair line dist. but one of the best songs :D
Jessica's last main vocal moment I guess.
Europa too
@@user-ep6kj6do5iIn Europa, catch me if you can, chain reaction and Divine Jessica's same position with lead vocal Tiffany so I don't count them. In these songs there're like 3 main vocals When Tiff's actually a lead.
Can you make this as an AI with taengsic duet
Would be TaengSic main
TiffSunSeo lead
Dance line Vocal.
Ot8
Would be main Tae
Lead SunSeo
Vocal Tiff
Sub Vocal dance line.
I dont think Tiff got any lines from Jess and the chorus have more impact.
everything after Taeyeon's bridge sucks so bad compared to the live version imo
- Tiff first adlib
- How weak the vocals on the 3rd chorus sound compared to TaengSic's choruses
- The outro
- EVERYTHING lol
live version >>>>>> studio version
@@tubatubatu My only thing is that Tiff's first ad lib wasn't audible on sketchbook because her mic was still turned down
@@SMAnthonyW oh i HATE that adlib jajajjajj i'm glad we can't hear it cuz i prefer the melody of the chorus