Brayshaw was on borrowed time with his long concussion history. Any game could've been his last. It was a freak incident. Maynard's been suspended once or twice in his career for very minor incidents, so he deserves the benefit of the doubt that he was only going for a spoil and not trying to bump. Say what you will about him being a "wannabe tough guy" as people like to call him, but he's never been a sniper. He's always been a hard but fair player.
As a Dees supporter, I agree. I don't and didn't think there was any malice in the Brayshaw/Maynard collision. Personally I'm not a fan of booing (i know others disagree, and that's okay) but for the Dees, it's time to move on and I think the players were trying to do that. They just lacked any hunger and drive, plus the skill level was so poor. But lets not take anything away from the Pies, they were playing some good footy.
A spoil you say, haha. How that guy was not suspended absolutely beggars belief, and you know it. Brayshaw forced retirement, Petracca out for the season, both against Collingwood. Karma’s coming…you can’t hide.
@@TheBeddaMan Karma's coming? When? It's not like the Dees are making finals this year. Guess it'll have to be another KB clash that we usually win. Just let it go man. Dees players let it go and shook Maynard's hand after the game. Only nuffie supporters still care.
"More and more irrelevant", but thousands of people like you keep watching her shows and going onto SM to make comments about her. A bit of a contradiction, wouldn't you say?
Yeah I didn't mind her opinions a while back but I'm starting to see a real nasty anti Collingwood theme with her so as far as I'm concerned she can rot in hell. Maynard did not hit Brayshaw, Brayshaw ran into Maynard. Caroline never played the game, I played for Collingwood's U17's in 1984, she knows nothing about jumping up to block a kick, its quite a legitimate part of the game.
@@timjames9963 Rubbish. Footy Classified isn't "Her" show. Garry Lyon and Matthew Lloyd were the best hosts of it. Caroline has a grudge against Collingwood so if you can't be objective don't appear on a sports program.
@@trep17mag Ok, focus on the completely insignificant part to my earlier comment. The point is that people continue to talk about her opinions and stories stemming from whatever outlet she appears on, whether it be radio, TV, or print media, and then when they disagree with her, take the “she’s irrelevant” angle. Better?
@@timjames9963it is obvious she has to say the outrageous thing to get reactions because she has no valid opinions. You can not deny her takes are wrong, click bait at best and her anti collingwood gets old. Sick of her taking cheap shots at others but then playing victim when she gets called out. It is so bad she has to be scripted to play the hated pannel member for views surely
Considering that Petracca was the one to shake Maynard’s hand, I think it’s alright. Or are we saying Petracca is too nice? Dude is a competitive beast who literally tried to play through probable broken ribs.
The media are just mad they missed out on a spicy story If Maynard and Pretracca are friends off field, apparently they are, and they've sorted out their issues regarding Brayshaw it's gonna be obviously fake bravado if he starts pushing Maynard before the game starts
100% correct and not a word by caro about how he,s career was cut so short and murphy knew he wasn,t right , so why didn,t Brayshaw and melbourne FC do the same thing and say enough mate
@paulmatters2641 an attempted spoil is a dog act? 🤔 So what Charlie Cameron did in the granny wasn't (break Howe's ribs) because he's a great bloke? The victim mentality permeates throughout that club and its supporters, coming straight from the coach.
Correction, Kane and Caro - Maynard did not END Brayshaw’s career 🙄 what about the other concussions the bloke suffered prior to that? Jeeez! Hope one day, you get sued for slander and misinformation
Anyone continuing to say maynard ended brayshaws carrer is nothing short of character degrading. Yeh if the guy didnt have an entire history of concussions from juniors to seniors you could. Or if he didnt wear a helemt due to that. Seriously. The opposing club had a guy retire from concussion as well and look how its being handled. Melbourne have had the bihhest fall from grace and it came from their ego. Stop trying to cover it up with old stories.
I am so proud and pleased with Collingwood NOT going after Petracca’s ribs. Most other teams Carl, Syd, Bris would’ve tested him. No cheap shots for Collingwood 🫡
Yeah because Collingwood play within the rules and to the integrity and spirit of the game. That's why we're the best. We have the best club attitude and culture.
@@martinbox6110 the fact he got off and you still whinge just proves you have no idea. Should Pickett be getting 6-8 weeks each time he lines blokes up? He’s a proper grub.
@@martinbox6110 genius, it was Collingwood players that showed most concern, telling him he didn’t look well and should leave the ground seek further medical advice.
It is unfortunate that Angus Brayshaw had to retire. As well as Nathan Murphy. It would be great if the media focused on the attitudes surrounding the retirement between the two of them. One looking at being a constructive pillar to assist in awareness of how to manage the effects of concussion moving forward. The other playing the outright victim. How would you like your son to act in this predicament. As a proud Melbournian, I find the woke/victim mentality has permeated the city and state to the point of destroying the courageous/tough attitude of the battling Aussie. If you play a physical contact sport and suffer concussion these days, as unfortunate as it is, you made that choice, we have known for almost a generation the lasting effects that can happen. Brayshaw has an opportunity to be a better man, stop playing the victim and find how he can use his situation to help others. Life is tough but heroes find a way to turn the biggest challenges into their greatest strengths.
isnt that just called respect? every team ive ever watched has shook hands with their opponent before the game, during the game they get stuick into eachother and want their team to win, and after the game they all shake hands in respect. yes melbourne didn't lay enough tackles and didnt play that well but im sorry tyo say but EVERY team has down weeks and they get out of form. lets show these players more respect and step up.
Bradshaw had a history of injury so it's no one's fault his career was cut short. It's a contact sport and sometimes bad things happen. This shouldn't effect sportsmanship. Kane thinks football is war, it's sport, it's a game.
Considering his dad played and works for Melbourne, his brother played for Melbourne, and his sister in law is captain of the Melbourne women’s team.. and they still claim he deliberately took out Brayshaw, a bloke who Maynard played junior footy with. It’s insane isn’t it 😂
Kane Cornes is correct. Caroline, the fact is Maynard did NOT hit Brayshaw. Maynard is entitled to jump up in order to block an opposition players kick. Its been happening for several decades. And the fact is Brwyshaw ran into Maynard, at no point did Brayshaw attempt to swerve to avoid Maynard and the fact that Brayshaw was wearing padded head protection tells us he had prior head injuries. Caroline, cease the Collingwood hating and be objective as journalists should be.
Honestly, what would caro know about 'making a statement ' on the footy field. She isn't an ex-player and really has no place in saying what should or shouldn't happen on the field. Nothing anoys me more than journos who aren't ex-players talking as if they played the game.
@@dilloncoleman144 the videos i found weren't flattering hahahaha we are all armchair critics, we are all allowed an opinion. she gets paid for hers right or wrong. haha an opinion is an opinion not gospel.
Dog act by Collingwood on two Dee players an Sun's player. Remember that "what goes around comes around," - Bombers won and Suns won and there will be more.
Maynard was in the air and not in a moving state when Brayshaw ran into him. Brayshaw should have side stepped Maynard while he was in the air because Maynard can't move side to side or backwards and forwards but no Brayshaw run's directly into him. These channel 9 football shows all go for the headline because they don't have any credibility and are not closely associated with the game, that's channel 7 and Fox.
Correct. I cringed every time I saw that incident (so it was a lot of cringing!). He could have easily side stepped a player running straight at him, especially when he was airborne. Don’t have to be The Chad to do that. Full respect to Brayshaw, but he ran into Maynard …
Maynard targeted Angus, not the other way around. There is absolutely nothing to blame Angus for it's all on Maynard the thug. He blatantly tries to hurt players and ruin their careers, and doesn't give a damn.
His outlook is circa 1970. I don't want the AFL to revert to bone heads like Mal Brown knocking out opponents with cheap shots. Run them out of the game. Certainly compete hard on the field. But if you want to fight, get into the boxing ring so everyone knows what's expected.
Nope he’s right as per usual. If I was a Melbourne fan I’d be fuming with another poor display in the ever closing premiership window for that list. Show the fans it’s more than just a big paycheque for you. Clearly they don’t care win lose or draw. As long as the moneys green they’re all smiles
@@lukemate2783 Imagine being so easily manipulated lol. Was he right when he trashed Melbourne and the coach for going after Maynard over the exact same incident 🤣🤣🤣. He said they let emotions get the better of them, it was poor, that Maynard shouldn't be suspended and that it was a footy act lololol
Avid Pies hater here (like ~85% of the nation) still, I can't sing anything but praises for Maynardand the way he took it up to a poor and complicit Mellb but the hit on Frisky @ 2:34 was clearly with a raised elbow as he made above chest high contact. No word from umpires or review panel? The black and white eyes are dominating the Vic media...
I think the AFL should allow clubs to write off the salary cap hit to incentivise them not to play players with brain injuries. You still have to pay them, so it's not without penalty, but it shouldn't be in the cap.
Matthew Lloyd "melbourne cant win a flag playing the way they do" Also Matthew Lloyd last week "i have essendon in my group of 6 teams that can win the flag". Essendon's record against top 8 teams in 2024 = 1 win 3 losses 1 draw Essendon's record against bottom 8 teams in 2024 = 7 wins 1 loss (and that loss was against current 9th placed team gold coast. In 4 wins against teams 14-17th, 3 were by a goal or less and the tigers win was by 2 goals..... Total flag contenders right Matt?
@@ma3stro681 carlton look more settled than pies and lions to me. Thing is every "flag favourite" has slipped. Brisbane were flag favourites at the start of the year along with pies, both aren't now. Early on it was also Melbourne and GWS.... not anymore. Port are always slightly off, Cats were 7-0....and now 8-5... Essendons easy draw gave false hype and they've been brought back to reality. Everyone stumbling except Sydney....
@@HeywoodJablowme7but the Syd ducks will stumble eventually and don't forget the grand final is played at the GEE. Remember the last time the ducks made a grand final.
@paulkyriakopoulos3444 hey I never said it was Sydney's flag guaranteed. A million things can happen between now and then. Sydney get injuries, another team goes on a hot streak of form, the weather on grand final day wreaks havoc, a couple of players get hurt early in the GF, Sydney could do a Richmond of 2018 and have just 1 bad game cost them a gf spot, a lucky bounce of the ball etc. It's just as of right now they are in the box seat but not guaranteed at all.
Melbourne showed no heart, and in fact Collingwood and Maynard used the incident as a motivator to stoke the competitive flames. Embarrassing by the Dees.
how do you know this as "fact"....... let me guess its an assumption you want to bolster by using strong language to insinuate a false truth? Embarrassing by you espically when you spell the key word wrong. God you are stupid, what makes it better it you "edited" the comment and still stuffed it. Let me guess, your IQ is below 90?
If Melbourne did all that and lost, he’d be trashing their fake macho, saying their heads were stuck in the past, and that they should’ve brought the energy where it mattered. He’s so boring. Compare it with Lloyd, who actually gives substantive analysis. There are bigger issues with Melbourne than performative theatrics.
I completely agree with you on this one. They always have double standards and want it both ways. They know they can get away with consistently doing it aswell.
@@aussieintexas61Hutchy's got a lot blame in this. He loves this type of punditry. It's shocking that Kane is part of official AFL media and on All Australian selection. They can find a better candidate to represent Adelaide.
Imagine if he did that dog act to a Carlton player, he would be attacked at every opportunity for the next few games. Everyone who has played footy and is being honest with themselves knows he lined Brayshaw up from about 20mtrs away. People who back up Maynard are exactly the same as those 'benefit of the doubt' people that say Milne couldn't have stopped that ball and kicked the winning goal. You're lying to yourselves. Oliver and Gawn hugged Maynard after the game, I was gobsmacked. The guy has priors, he is a thug.
I swear just cause someones career ended because of another player doesnt mean what they did was wrong. Maynard got off at the time and the rules were changed accordingly. Mccarthy practically ended nathan murphys career but does that mean he did anything wrong? Of course not!
Maynard incident was way worse than Murphys. Both unfortunate incidents but in the grannie Murphy put his head down going for the ball and was unlucky. Brawshaw was also unlucky that Maynard went for the smother and executed it horribly. Don’t compare the two incidents.
@barrytalks3531 not comparing the incident itself mate. I'm saying that just because Brayshaw's career ended doesn't mean what maynard did was wrong, he got off which the rule let him at the time. It may be a suspension now but back then it wasn't. Ending someone's career doesn't necessarily make the action wrong. It's About the action itself which is what I'm trying to say
That was a dog act by Moore, who knew exactly what he was doing. And it wasn't "brave" for Petracca to continue playing; it was foolish for him to be allowed to continue.
Hmm Best?…..if by best you mean having an opinion based on no nothing and then never conceding he got it wrong….then yep I’d say he’s the best.. To be fair Kane’s does his best work when he’s analysing the game… When he scrutinises player contracts and pointed agendas against coaches who have clearly out preformed Ken Hinkley it’s hard to take the rest of what he says seriously..
He always backs up and supports his opinion. Not always right but who is? He has certainly acknowledged when he has got it wrong. Also he has called out Port plenty of times. I like him and I like Lloyd.
@@denisfinn6681 mate I like him too… but you have to concede he twist his story’s & opinions to suit his agenda… Like He’ll Go hard on Hipwood but not on Dixon, Hard on Simpson but not on Hinkley.. it’s just that type of stuff…
the players at Melbourne look broken theres no joy in the way they play footy this year they've transitioned from being a team to a bunch of individuals
That Brayshaw brother was the lesser brother of the two. Melbourne FC's and media-spin's angry and sad reaction has been so over the top - He wasn't even that good a player anyway! The Freo Brayshaw is a much better player.
There’s actually three brothers, a dud one in Perth. He said Maynard was a thug for what he did but gaffs a good guy despite breaking his little brothers jaw 😂
Kane’s obsession with handshakes and chair-offs is bottom of the barrel, low hanging clickbait punditry. He talks like someone who knows he’s losing relevance.
Kane Corn’s is spot on about his comments, but I am glad the Dees are better than that. They play football to win not the man. Bogan’s is the words I described for some of the Pies players. We are playing football not the man and Collingwood constantly player the man and not the Ball. ‘Break their spirit’ Darcy Moore’s tactics to his team worked. Watch Moore’s flight to hit Christian Petracca in taking him out of the game. That was no coincidnec. Moore new what he was doing. There were two other Collingwood plays infight and he ensure he hit Petracca. He other Colingwood’ HITTER is Maynard. He does that game after game to injured players to break their spirits. Just remember what goes around comes around,
If there’s one thing the AFL can take from the NRL is that any disrespect/attack toward a player their teammates take it personally and go after them. Shaking hands with the bloke that ended your mates career is soft as sh, which is how they play.
Can't believe Moore has no responsibility re kneeing petraca like that disgraceful . Are Collingwood that protected by the afl .it seems so. No character from Melbourne. If Campbell Brown was on the dee's list he would have made Moore pay In the world we would call that an assault
It’s called spoiling the mark, it has been in the game for 150 years and is perfectly legal and encouraged but it seems like you missed it. I’d shut up now if I were you as you’ve embarrassed yourself.
Is this the first game you have watched. How else do you think you get up over the shoulders to take a mark or create a contest. You must be new or just a fool or both. If you dont know about human physics yet I suggest you take a course. You use your knees to jump in the air.
He looks done, mentally and physically. His skills are sub par for AFL. Looks more like a bush footballer now, though he always did with the way he just dump kicks it …
@ma3stro681 Those first 3 games for collingwood were so pathetic, the change since then has been pretty huge so dare I say keep an eye out for that Collingwood Sydney game at the scg later this year when the pies get most of their players back 👀
We need another Barry Hall to play on Maynard and teach him that footy is, well, footy and not thuggery. Wait, maybe he will get Toby Green as an opponent. Dirty play is not sportsmanship. I think Maynard might be happier as cage fighter.
I have supported the Dees since 1955 because over the years I have generally found they are men of honour polished and refined. The Dees will comeback they are good side. Wouldn't want to stoop to the Pies HIT the man's tactics to win.
So polished and refined that they punch on with each other in French restaurants and tell their team mates they would have lost a grand final if they played
You’re conveniently forgetting you have the biggest sniping thug running around for you in number 36. Picks off players continuously, been suspended and all of them head knocks.
Goes to show that Alan Richardson, Christian Petracca, Caroline WIlson and even Matthew Lloyd don't buy into the hype that Kane Cornes is always seduced by. Going after players is childish bravado.
Lloyd ur kidding ur self he was one of the tough players giving it before the game , Kane spitting facts. Caro a useless cat lady as usual she’s gotta be single
Maynard never should have played in the Grand Final last year, it was late, it was high and it should have been a minimum of two weeks. The AFL judiciary is a joke.
@@Nathan-gd7xq Nah, he's the guy who ended a players career then went to his house with flowers just so he could tell the media he did it. You know, the scumbag one.
@@Sulufy Oh and by the way what sort of witch doctor allows a player with 4 broken ribs and a punctured lung return to the field ? the same sort that allows a player with a history of neurological injuries continue to take risks.
korn korn korn, always showing your true colours. dont shake opponent's hand. show your opposite number no respect, said like a true tagger / scragger who needed limited skills to hold his position.
Brayshaw was on borrowed time with his long concussion history. Any game could've been his last. It was a freak incident. Maynard's been suspended once or twice in his career for very minor incidents, so he deserves the benefit of the doubt that he was only going for a spoil and not trying to bump.
Say what you will about him being a "wannabe tough guy" as people like to call him, but he's never been a sniper. He's always been a hard but fair player.
As a Dees supporter, I agree. I don't and didn't think there was any malice in the Brayshaw/Maynard collision.
Personally I'm not a fan of booing (i know others disagree, and that's okay) but for the Dees, it's time to move on and I think the players were trying to do that. They just lacked any hunger and drive, plus the skill level was so poor.
But lets not take anything away from the Pies, they were playing some good footy.
A spoil you say, haha. How that guy was not suspended absolutely beggars belief, and you know it.
Brayshaw forced retirement, Petracca out for the season, both against Collingwood.
Karma’s coming…you can’t hide.
@@TheBeddaMan Karma's coming? When? It's not like the Dees are making finals this year. Guess it'll have to be another KB clash that we usually win. Just let it go man. Dees players let it go and shook Maynard's hand after the game. Only nuffie supporters still care.
Maynard going and giving Brayshaw flowers is a great gesture. Caroline is becoming more and more irrelevant in footy. Can't wait for her to retire
"More and more irrelevant", but thousands of people like you keep watching her shows and going onto SM to make comments about her. A bit of a contradiction, wouldn't you say?
Yeah I didn't mind her opinions a while back but I'm starting to see a real nasty anti Collingwood theme with her so as far as I'm concerned she can rot in hell. Maynard did not hit Brayshaw, Brayshaw ran into Maynard. Caroline never played the game, I played for Collingwood's U17's in 1984, she knows nothing about jumping up to block a kick, its quite a legitimate part of the game.
@@timjames9963 Rubbish. Footy Classified isn't "Her" show. Garry Lyon and Matthew Lloyd were the best hosts of it.
Caroline has a grudge against Collingwood so if you can't be objective don't appear on a sports program.
@@trep17mag Ok, focus on the completely insignificant part to my earlier comment. The point is that people continue to talk about her opinions and stories stemming from whatever outlet she appears on, whether it be radio, TV, or print media, and then when they disagree with her, take the “she’s irrelevant” angle. Better?
@@timjames9963it is obvious she has to say the outrageous thing to get reactions because she has no valid opinions.
You can not deny her takes are wrong, click bait at best and her anti collingwood gets old.
Sick of her taking cheap shots at others but then playing victim when she gets called out.
It is so bad she has to be scripted to play the hated pannel member for views surely
Considering that Petracca was the one to shake Maynard’s hand, I think it’s alright. Or are we saying Petracca is too nice? Dude is a competitive beast who literally tried to play through probable broken ribs.
Petracca is a gun footballer. He's look bloody good in black and white he's that good
The media are just mad they missed out on a spicy story
If Maynard and Pretracca are friends off field, apparently they are, and they've sorted out their issues regarding Brayshaw it's gonna be obviously fake bravado if he starts pushing Maynard before the game starts
Melbourne soft af 😂
Caro still beating this Maynard going to Brayshaw's house non-story 8 months on.
Caro is correct about Maynards dog acts
Caro is right for once about that
Nathan Murphy same deal. Career over because of a concussion on field. Pies aren't crying. Murphy isn't crying
100% correct and not a word by caro about how he,s career was cut so short and murphy knew he wasn,t right , so why didn,t Brayshaw and melbourne FC do the same thing and say enough mate
@@ronlibbis7160 because they're a soft cultured bunch of sooks
On the flip side look at how Collingwood has dealt with the forced retirement of Nathan Murphy who was a key pillar last year.
Just shows you the difference between the two clubs.
Murphy was knocked unconscious for two minutes by a dog act? Dont recall that champ.
@@paulmatters2641Murphy was knocked unconscious about 3 or 4 times last season champ. Got literally punched in the head against st kilda and Adelaide.
@paulmatters2641 an attempted spoil is a dog act? 🤔
So what Charlie Cameron did in the granny wasn't (break Howe's ribs) because he's a great bloke?
The victim mentality permeates throughout that club and its supporters, coming straight from the coach.
poorly... ?
Really Kane, every single team shakes hands with their opponents before the game. It’s called sportsmanship chief
What an unbeleiveable game from maynard. Would be up there with his better performances for sure. He was deadly with his kicking
Dees are comfortable being comfortable. Like port
Both Clubs are weak and woke … 😂🤡😵
@@ma3stro681 What's woke mean?
Correction, Kane and Caro - Maynard did not END Brayshaw’s career 🙄 what about the other concussions the bloke suffered prior to that? Jeeez! Hope one day, you get sued for slander and misinformation
Couldn’t agree with you more!
Anyone continuing to say maynard ended brayshaws carrer is nothing short of character degrading.
Yeh if the guy didnt have an entire history of concussions from juniors to seniors you could. Or if he didnt wear a helemt due to that.
Seriously.
The opposing club had a guy retire from concussion as well and look how its being handled.
Melbourne have had the bihhest fall from grace and it came from their ego.
Stop trying to cover it up with old stories.
Brayshaw also had a head knock earlier on in that same game, so he could have gone off then, but apparently his past wasnt such a big factor that time
Maynard doesn't have any form of character. He doesn't give a damn who he hurts or what career he ends, it's about him. I would never shake his hand.
If Maynard didn't plough his shoulder into Brayshaw's head he'd still be playing
@@stevelozevski8151maynard best on ground
@@SV0747 when?
How did May have a good game? He was cooked by every opponent he was on
Murphy had to retire way to early too. Says a lot about both clubs when you compare them…
Maynards been my favourite pies player since he debuted, just a great footballer, in the mould of Roy Keane of Man U back in the day
I am so proud and pleased with Collingwood NOT going after Petracca’s ribs. Most other teams Carl, Syd, Bris would’ve tested him. No cheap shots for Collingwood 🫡
Yeah because Collingwood play within the rules and to the integrity and spirit of the game. That's why we're the best. We have the best club attitude and culture.
Yep, like Maynard last year? Should have got 6-8 weeks.
@@martinbox6110 the fact he got off and you still whinge just proves you have no idea. Should Pickett be getting 6-8 weeks each time he lines blokes up? He’s a proper grub.
@@martinbox6110 genius, it was Collingwood players that showed most concern, telling him he didn’t look well and should leave the ground seek further medical advice.
Absolute Bollocks………Spoken like a true Colliwobble Supporter………Overrated.
It is unfortunate that Angus Brayshaw had to retire. As well as Nathan Murphy. It would be great if the media focused on the attitudes surrounding the retirement between the two of them. One looking at being a constructive pillar to assist in awareness of how to manage the effects of concussion moving forward. The other playing the outright victim. How would you like your son to act in this predicament. As a proud Melbournian, I find the woke/victim mentality has permeated the city and state to the point of destroying the courageous/tough attitude of the battling Aussie. If you play a physical contact sport and suffer concussion these days, as unfortunate as it is, you made that choice, we have known for almost a generation the lasting effects that can happen. Brayshaw has an opportunity to be a better man, stop playing the victim and find how he can use his situation to help others. Life is tough but heroes find a way to turn the biggest challenges into their greatest strengths.
Only Kane Cornes could have an issue with shaking someone's hand before a game.
isnt that just called respect? every team ive ever watched has shook hands with their opponent before the game, during the game they get stuick into eachother and want their team to win, and after the game they all shake hands in respect. yes melbourne didn't lay enough tackles and didnt play that well but im sorry tyo say but EVERY team has down weeks and they get out of form. lets show these players more respect and step up.
Is there a connection between Melbourne falling from their premiership window and running out of coke?
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Kane, what do you ask your barber 👀
Isn't it interesting to note that it was Collingwood players offering the shake, not the other wau round.
Bradshaw had a history of injury so it's no one's fault his career was cut short. It's a contact sport and sometimes bad things happen.
This shouldn't effect sportsmanship. Kane thinks football is war, it's sport, it's a game.
Maynard is actually friends with many of the Melbourne players, fake bravado wasn't gonna help them
Considering his dad played and works for Melbourne, his brother played for Melbourne, and his sister in law is captain of the Melbourne women’s team.. and they still claim he deliberately took out Brayshaw, a bloke who Maynard played junior footy with. It’s insane isn’t it 😂
Kane Cornes is correct.
Caroline, the fact is Maynard did NOT hit Brayshaw. Maynard is entitled to jump up in order to block an opposition players kick.
Its been happening for several decades.
And the fact is Brwyshaw ran into Maynard, at no point did Brayshaw attempt to swerve to avoid Maynard and the fact that Brayshaw was wearing padded head protection tells us he had prior head injuries.
Caroline, cease the Collingwood hating and be objective as journalists should be.
Honestly, what would caro know about 'making a statement ' on the footy field. She isn't an ex-player and really has no place in saying what should or shouldn't happen on the field.
Nothing anoys me more than journos who aren't ex-players talking as if they played the game.
which afl club did you play for google couldnt find you. your words mean nothing according to your theory. haha
@@aussieintexas61 you googled my name?? Gosh I'm flattered, thank you 🙏
@@dilloncoleman144 the videos i found weren't flattering hahahaha
we are all armchair critics, we are all allowed an opinion. she gets paid for hers right or wrong. haha an opinion is an opinion not gospel.
Caro always bringing up the flowers, runs with it more than her obsession with Dane Swan or James Hird.
Footy on Nine, nice video dude
Dog act by Collingwood on two Dee players an Sun's player. Remember that "what goes around comes around," - Bombers won and Suns won and there will be more.
Maynard was in the air and not in a moving state when Brayshaw ran into him.
Brayshaw should have side stepped Maynard while he was in the air because Maynard can't move side to side or backwards and forwards but no Brayshaw run's directly into him.
These channel 9 football shows all go for the headline because they don't have any credibility and are not closely associated with the game, that's channel 7 and Fox.
Correct. I cringed every time I saw that incident (so it was a lot of cringing!). He could have easily side stepped a player running straight at him, especially when he was airborne. Don’t have to be The Chad to do that. Full respect to Brayshaw, but he ran into Maynard …
I don't know if he could have side stepped but not much Maynard could do once in the air
didnt the afl make a new rule , because of brayshaws ineptability to dodge a clumbsy spoil.
Maynard targeted Angus, not the other way around. There is absolutely nothing to blame Angus for it's all on Maynard the thug. He blatantly tries to hurt players and ruin their careers, and doesn't give a damn.
That's the whole problem with your comment. Maynard was off the ground.
The Melbourne players didn’t go after Maynard coz they know that what happened to Bradshaw was a football act - nothing more than an accident
Cornes celebrates bad sportsmanship and has no respect for sportsmanship. Says a lot.
His outlook is circa 1970. I don't want the AFL to revert to bone heads like Mal Brown knocking out opponents with cheap shots. Run them out of the game. Certainly compete hard on the field. But if you want to fight, get into the boxing ring so everyone knows what's expected.
I think that he doesn't really understand the value and purpose of sportsmanship. It's almost a sociopathic approach.
Kane is wrong, despite what he thinks you can still shakes hands pre and post match.
Nope he’s right as per usual. If I was a Melbourne fan I’d be fuming with another poor display in the ever closing premiership window for that list. Show the fans it’s more than just a big paycheque for you. Clearly they don’t care win lose or draw. As long as the moneys green they’re all smiles
@@lukemate2783 Imagine being so easily manipulated lol. Was he right when he trashed Melbourne and the coach for going after Maynard over the exact same incident 🤣🤣🤣. He said they let emotions get the better of them, it was poor, that Maynard shouldn't be suspended and that it was a footy act lololol
@@imalwaysright not reading anything from someone who writes out “lol”. Cope harder
@@lukemate2783but “cope harder” is better lmao 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Avid Pies hater here (like ~85% of the nation) still, I can't sing anything but praises for Maynardand the way he took it up to a poor and complicit Mellb but the hit on Frisky @ 2:34 was clearly with a raised elbow as he made above chest high contact. No word from umpires or review panel? The black and white eyes are dominating the Vic media...
Raised elbow 😂 open your eyes ya lemon
lol are they back to pretending Brayshaw didn’t wear a helmet for a reason and had a history of of concussion prior to Maynard’s attempted smother?
"he's been knocked in the head before, so one more is actually his fault not my thug's"
It was late, it was high, its two weeks end of story... oh wait, its Collingwood, nothing to see here, play on!!
@@PeterM1-qx1tzwith that logic every marking contest that doesn't result in a mark but the knees/legs ECT are high is a automatic suspension 😂
I think the AFL should allow clubs to write off the salary cap hit to incentivise them not to play players with brain injuries. You still have to pay them, so it's not without penalty, but it shouldn't be in the cap.
@@joshuasadler9243no Joshua. Just don't plough your shoulder into an opposition players head because that's illegal in footy
Matthew Lloyd "melbourne cant win a flag playing the way they do"
Also Matthew Lloyd last week "i have essendon in my group of 6 teams that can win the flag".
Essendon's record against top 8 teams in 2024 = 1 win 3 losses 1 draw
Essendon's record against bottom 8 teams in 2024 = 7 wins 1 loss (and that loss was against current 9th placed team gold coast.
In 4 wins against teams 14-17th, 3 were by a goal or less and the tigers win was by 2 goals.....
Total flag contenders right Matt?
Sydney only have 3 legitimate challengers: Collingwood, Carlton and Brisbane, but none are even close at this stage …
@@ma3stro681 carlton look more settled than pies and lions to me.
Thing is every "flag favourite" has slipped. Brisbane were flag favourites at the start of the year along with pies, both aren't now. Early on it was also Melbourne and GWS.... not anymore. Port are always slightly off, Cats were 7-0....and now 8-5... Essendons easy draw gave false hype and they've been brought back to reality.
Everyone stumbling except Sydney....
@@HeywoodJablowme7but the Syd ducks will stumble eventually and don't forget the grand final is played at the GEE. Remember the last time the ducks made a grand final.
@paulkyriakopoulos3444 hey I never said it was Sydney's flag guaranteed. A million things can happen between now and then.
Sydney get injuries, another team goes on a hot streak of form, the weather on grand final day wreaks havoc, a couple of players get hurt early in the GF, Sydney could do a Richmond of 2018 and have just 1 bad game cost them a gf spot, a lucky bounce of the ball etc.
It's just as of right now they are in the box seat but not guaranteed at all.
@@HeywoodJablowme7 agree dude 100% correct
Melbourne showed no heart, and in fact Collingwood and Maynard used the incident as a motivator to stoke the competitive flames.
Embarrassing by the Dees.
how do you know this as "fact"....... let me guess its an assumption you want to bolster by using strong language to insinuate a false truth? Embarrassing by you espically when you spell the key word wrong. God you are stupid, what makes it better it you "edited" the comment and still stuffed it. Let me guess, your IQ is below 90?
If Melbourne did all that and lost, he’d be trashing their fake macho, saying their heads were stuck in the past, and that they should’ve brought the energy where it mattered. He’s so boring. Compare it with Lloyd, who actually gives substantive analysis. There are bigger issues with Melbourne than performative theatrics.
I completely agree with you on this one. They always have double standards and want it both ways. They know they can get away with consistently doing it aswell.
lloydy has had to pull him up a few times this season. korn just says dumb things to create talk amongst his fellow media heads, who laugh at him.
@@aussieintexas61Hutchy's got a lot blame in this. He loves this type of punditry. It's shocking that Kane is part of official AFL media and on All Australian selection. They can find a better candidate to represent Adelaide.
Spot on and I think Goodwin has to go
@imalwaysright I hate to say it, but I think you're right..
Imagine if he did that dog act to a Carlton player, he would be attacked at every opportunity for the next few games. Everyone who has played footy and is being honest with themselves knows he lined Brayshaw up from about 20mtrs away. People who back up Maynard are exactly the same as those 'benefit of the doubt' people that say Milne couldn't have stopped that ball and kicked the winning goal. You're lying to yourselves.
Oliver and Gawn hugged Maynard after the game, I was gobsmacked. The guy has priors, he is a thug.
Caro I did see a smile on his face.
I swear just cause someones career ended because of another player doesnt mean what they did was wrong. Maynard got off at the time and the rules were changed accordingly. Mccarthy practically ended nathan murphys career but does that mean he did anything wrong? Of course not!
Actually the incident that ended Murphy's career was a sling tackle from Daicos in training. That was the last straw.
Maynard incident was way worse than Murphys. Both unfortunate incidents but in the grannie Murphy put his head down going for the ball and was unlucky. Brawshaw was also unlucky that Maynard went for the smother and executed it horribly. Don’t compare the two incidents.
@barrytalks3531 not comparing the incident itself mate. I'm saying that just because Brayshaw's career ended doesn't mean what maynard did was wrong, he got off which the rule let him at the time. It may be a suspension now but back then it wasn't. Ending someone's career doesn't necessarily make the action wrong. It's About the action itself which is what I'm trying to say
Maynard is a guy you would have in the trenches with you....... But he aint no sniper "lloydy"😂
he’s a thug
@@osvnisaneek8254 only thug that out on the field on kings birthday was Pickett.
He is a drop kick
Surprised Melbourne didn’t really come out breathing fire, they missed a few shots early and after that Collingwood controlled things.
That was a dog act by Moore, who knew exactly what he was doing.
And it wasn't "brave" for Petracca to continue playing; it was foolish for him to be allowed to continue.
What a pathetic comment. All players jump and put knees in the back. Go back to kinder.
Cornes is the best commentator in the game. Calls his opinion and backs it up.
Hmm Best?…..if by best you mean having an opinion based on no nothing and then never conceding he got it wrong….then yep I’d say he’s the best..
To be fair Kane’s does his best work when he’s analysing the game… When he scrutinises player contracts and pointed agendas against coaches who have clearly out preformed Ken Hinkley it’s hard to take the rest of what he says seriously..
Except when it comes to port
He always backs up and supports his opinion. Not always right but who is? He has certainly acknowledged when he has got it wrong. Also he has called out Port plenty of times. I like him and I like Lloyd.
@@denisfinn6681 mate I like him too… but you have to concede he twist his story’s & opinions to suit his agenda…
Like He’ll Go hard on Hipwood but not on Dixon, Hard on Simpson but not on Hinkley.. it’s just that type of stuff…
@scottbrushett152 I agree 100% re Dixon. Not sure about Hinkley. As I said not always correct . Have a great day mate.
Can’t stand Maynard but he did nothing malicious to Brayshaw. Grow up
the players at Melbourne look broken theres no joy in the way they play footy this year they've transitioned from being a team to a bunch of individuals
Send the Dees chocolates & flowers
Because he brought Brayshaw flowers
Oliver has had NO pre season....ALL IT IS
That Brayshaw brother was the lesser brother of the two. Melbourne FC's and media-spin's angry and sad reaction has been so over the top - He wasn't even that good a player anyway! The Freo Brayshaw is a much better player.
Irrelevant comment
There’s actually three brothers, a dud one in Perth. He said Maynard was a thug for what he did but gaffs a good guy despite breaking his little brothers jaw 😂
Kane’s obsession with handshakes and chair-offs is bottom of the barrel, low hanging clickbait punditry. He talks like someone who knows he’s losing relevance.
maybe his teammates didnt give him as good enough send off when hinkley let him limp to 300 games and retire.
Disagree, do you understand the point(s) he's making?
@@Jaezon you cant spell "embarrassing" so do you get the points when you cant do a basic spell check on a system which does it for you?
@@Jaezon the point he is making? You mean when last year he slammed Goodwin and Melbourne for going after Maynard?
@@liamcallery2833 Whoa, dude! Check out the grammatical errors in your comment to me. 🤣
COLLLINGWOOOOOOOOOD
Season over for Melbourne no doubt 👍
Kane spot in here, Melbourne playing like their trust fund supporter base at div 12 ressies
Kane Corn’s is spot on about his comments, but I am glad the Dees are better than that. They play football to win not the man.
Bogan’s is the words I described for some of the Pies players. We are playing football not the man and Collingwood constantly player the man and not the Ball.
‘Break their spirit’
Darcy Moore’s tactics to his team worked. Watch Moore’s flight to hit Christian Petracca in taking him out of the game. That was no coincidnec. Moore new what he was doing. There were two other Collingwood plays infight and he ensure he hit Petracca.
He other Colingwood’ HITTER is Maynard. He does that game after game to injured players to break
their spirits.
Just remember what goes around comes around,
go and watch soccer mate as you know bugger all about AFL
@@ronlibbis7160 know more than you
@@ronlibbis7160 You go and throw boomerangs - skip
@@ronlibbis7160 I was playing football when they call you are drop kick. Leave it at that you are a fruit cake
Wilson needs to retire. "Im offended I'm offended she says ". Yes because she knows nothing about the game..
If there’s one thing the AFL can take from the NRL is that any disrespect/attack toward a player their teammates take it personally and go after them. Shaking hands with the bloke that ended your mates career is soft as sh, which is how they play.
Well, this is one example and why they’re criticising it. In most cases players and teams would go after that player and make a statement.
@@jsequine927 Getting the hard ball is making a statement, not pushing players around, that's juvenile.
@@jsequine927 in country footy maybe.
Stupid take, Maynard didn't intentionally end his career. He went for a spoil. You sound like a child not being able to shake hands
Can't believe Moore has no responsibility re kneeing petraca like that disgraceful . Are Collingwood that protected by the afl .it seems so. No character from Melbourne. If Campbell Brown was on the dee's list he would have made Moore pay
In the world we would call that an assault
It’s called spoiling the mark, it has been in the game for 150 years and is perfectly legal and encouraged but it seems like you missed it. I’d shut up now if I were you as you’ve embarrassed yourself.
Get a box of sorbet 224 wipe your tears away go pies
Is this the first game you have watched. How else do you think you get up over the shoulders to take a mark or create a contest. You must be new or just a fool or both.
If you dont know about human physics yet I suggest you take a course. You use your knees to jump in the air.
Melbourne supporters are hilarious. Biggest d!ckheads in the league 😂
if Coll miss a few more shots and Dees made a few more shots, as expected this game and the narrative are completely different, typical overreactions.
Keyboard warriors are gnashing at the bit on this one
Kane has a problem with sportsmanship
Surprise surprise Carro way off the mark again
Should have traded Oliver lol.
Could you imagine Adelaide with Petty and Oliver?
...
They'd be even more 💩
He looks done, mentally and physically. His skills are sub par for AFL. Looks more like a bush footballer now, though he always did with the way he just dump kicks it …
@@ma3stro681 he's a ginger Treloar, minus the work rate.
Jesus , with of those players to still come back for Collingwood.... its a scary thought.
Not for Sydney, though Collingwood are probably the only team that can challenge them. Carlton for a half, maybe …
@@ma3stro681 Sydney aren't exactly unbeatable...they lost to richmond who are one of the worst teams in the league.
Yeah, yeah. Couldn't beat the doggies last week. Beat a pathetic Melbourne and think they are world beaters
@ma3stro681 Those first 3 games for collingwood were so pathetic, the change since then has been pretty huge so dare I say keep an eye out for that Collingwood Sydney game at the scg later this year when the pies get most of their players back 👀
@@mark8860 settle down Mark
Hugs and kisses next time
Melbourne are as tough as a half full cup of wee. Maynard is a beast , it's amusing to be honest.
By showing a lack of brains, he's a beast? OK ...
Makes a great first impression before slacking off- Clarry must have ADHD
Nah, just a coke addiction
We need another Barry Hall to play on Maynard and teach him that footy is, well, footy and not thuggery. Wait, maybe he will get Toby Green as an opponent. Dirty play is not sportsmanship. I think Maynard might be happier as cage fighter.
I have supported the Dees since 1955 because over the years I have generally found they are men of honour polished and refined. The Dees will comeback they are good side. Wouldn't want to stoop to the Pies HIT the man's tactics to win.
So polished and refined that they punch on with each other in French restaurants and tell their team mates they would have lost a grand final if they played
You’re conveniently forgetting you have the biggest sniping thug running around for you in number 36. Picks off players continuously, been suspended and all of them head knocks.
Melbourne fans are the biggest grubs in the league. Just sooky entitled flogs
@@TeamSethRules he didnt hurt them
Goes to show that Alan Richardson, Christian Petracca, Caroline WIlson and even Matthew Lloyd don't buy into the hype that Kane Cornes is always seduced by. Going after players is childish bravado.
Lloyd ur kidding ur self he was one of the tough players giving it before the game , Kane spitting facts. Caro a useless cat lady as usual she’s gotta be single
yeah nice wig corn
Her pure hatred for anything Collingwood is always a good laugh
Its not Maynards fault Brayshaw is soft.
Caro is losing the plot
Maynard never should have played in the Grand Final last year, it was late, it was high and it should have been a minimum of two weeks. The AFL judiciary is a joke.
Hahaha still crying 9 months after oh how sweet it is carn the pies!
Totally agree and I am a Swans fan.
Lol u got no idea
@@timspencer4324hey swans fan, how many games should Barry Hall have missed in '05?
Four weeks
Key stone cops are back in force
Kane, hunting the controversial headline yet again….yawn
Maynard has a peeing problem as reported in Age today.
Cornes is right. Soft
Alan Richardson failed coach and pretty boring person. Should be gone
I agree with Kane. Maynard is an absolute dog of a bloke and the Dees just rolled over for him.
Was Maynard the guy who knocked out his teammate and pulled windscreen wipers off random cars?
@@Nathan-gd7xq Nah, he's the guy who ended a players career then went to his house with flowers just so he could tell the media he did it. You know, the scumbag one.
@@Sulufy not his fault Angus Glassjaw wasn't tough enough for a man's game. Maybe he'd be more suited to netball.
@@Nathan-gd7xq watch out everyone, we got a toughguy badass collingwood supporter over here.
@@Sulufy Oh and by the way what sort of witch doctor allows a player with 4 broken ribs and a punctured lung return to the field ? the same sort that allows a player with a history of neurological injuries continue to take risks.
Goodwin out!
People that disagree with Kane Cornes definitely still wear masks when there outside
They are called the walking dead.
But did you take the Jew jabs?
👍
Yes, Melbourne were disappointing!
Kane Cornes makes my skin crawl.
He was never as great as he makes himself out to be.
korn korn korn, always showing your true colours. dont shake opponent's hand. show your opposite number no respect, said like a true tagger / scragger who needed limited skills to hold his position.
What's up with Lloyd's hair ???????? looks terrible
this brayshway crap is nothing but a load of rubbish. soft soft soft. Anyone crying about Murphy?
You are 100%correct mate 😊