Tata Zest vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Hyundai Xcent | Comparison Test | Autocar India
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Tata’s new compact sedan, the Zest faces off against the heavyweights of the sub-four-metre sedan segment, the Maruti Suzuki Dzire, the Honda Amaze and the Hyundai Xcent.
Find out who comes on top in this comparison test
I own a 2015 Xcent with around 15k kms done....no problem faced...and will easily do 140-150kmph on an open stretch...and i frequently get around 18-20kmpl when driving lightly.... excellent choice i must say
Zest is the best package... a perfect mix of all the plus points of it's rivals...
***** boss look whose talking with 1.1 ltr engine
that is diesel. petrol is 1.2
zest is very very good car for indian roads and all
Tata zest is good and far ahead of all...if you find hard to drive,buy AMT...good looking one
ZEST is the best. I went to 300KM's in my friend's Excent.
It'snot at all good car. I m not able to sit comfortably in passenger seat. Just going on brand image...
Zest top model xt (petrol)
Is best best best and now I'm completely satisfied with service of this company
Now tata is changed believe me.
you have zest? am planning for diesel. some are saying to consider dzire.
help me bro
Armaan girdhar pls don't buy dzire bcoz it's so bumpy , buying car for comfortable but maruti Suzuki won't gives you that
Zest is best car in segment and safest car with 4 star ncap safety rating and uses same engine which is dizire uses so no reliability issues..
After seeing the video in 2015 I bought the xcent car and I must say it was a good decision the car is still working good and it's awesome
Nice comparison. Zest seems to be a good come back car for Tata motors. It stands up to the hype that was given.
Go for xcent u will feel the difference in high speed
Happy to see the Zest being promoted to no.2 by AUTOCAR from its former no.3 position..
True.. just as a car the Xcent comes out tops coz of its all round ability.. however if we factor in the prices.. esp considering the Xcent SX(O) is on par on features with Zest XMS! It is the Zest which comes out top with its great value for money..
The Zest XMS costs 6.6 lacs on road for the petrol.. while the Xcent SX(O) costs 7.9 lacs!! All on road Bangalore..
Ignoring 1.3 lacs in favour of Xcent is really really tough..
Amaze- it doesn't have much space at the rear as the video shows. In fact when compared to dzire and xcent(I have no idea about zest), one will feel cramped when 3 people sit at the rear. On the whole when comparing to the 4 cars looking at the video and from my personal experience, my pick would be on xcent; reason: it has good space, good mileage, better infotainment and looks better than the rest.
Test driven all these cars nd I'm gonna buy zest. ..
you have zest? am planning for diesel .
Bro dont do that mistake
Zest is good
@@armaangirdhar1175 Go for Petrol, never go for Diesel cars.
In this comparison Zest is the best car..Its hav 15 inch alloy wheel,navigation,100000km warranty..and good in thigh support..Comfortably site 3 adults in back seat. All the best team TATA...
Tata seems to be improving a great lot. I am worried that might go unnoticed with the kind of mentality most of us have. Start to believe in our home grown company, they are bound to turn the tables for their competitors that is now ruling our minds...
Hyundai Xcent is indeed the best midsize car of the segment. It clearly beats the Zest, Amaze and Dzire in the following fronts performance, handling and looks. Xcent does look like a proper 3 box sedan and not an add on job(after thought) like the rest..
Zest has certainly packed a huge huge punch !!! way to go tata !!
Zest is best against the Rest.
Are you kidding me ? Zest is the winner not xcent. Overall Zest is the one which is good among all. Xcent Kappa engine isn't as powerful as Revotron. Feature wise its slightly up from zest but not whole lot more. Zest is feature packed with power. I want diesel review of same cars if you can. I will wait for diesel review. Zest with manual transmission not AMT as its not the smoothest gearbox.
excellent car !! Zest
I liked about zest is big space inside, silent cabin, good ground clearance and comfort. I think that is enough for me to go for zest
Have been using zest for the 28000+ kilometeres milege in highway is 18 and at city is 15 ... finest interior and good steering control👌 recommend to buy.
xcent is the best car good job hyundai
Zest XMS Petrol is the best ever in compact sedan, drive 750 km non stop from indore (MP) to sarata(MH) with comfort in all respect
Can't find a full comparison across sub 4 meter segment with both petrol & diesel variants.
Agree- Xcent IS d best car. I own a Amaze Diesel and my last 2 cars were Indica vista and Indica v2.. TATA CAN make an excellent product .. BUT POST SALES OH BOY..... Ask anyone who has used a TATA car for personal use..SERVICE IS A HORROR SHOW!!! TRUST ME I TRIED 7 YES SEVEN Tata service centers in Delhi
Dezire sold 18185 units in September 2014. This is the second most selling car in india right now, second only to Maruthi's alto. The other three cars in comparison here sold 11660, put together. Means the dezire sold 6525 more units than the other three cars put together in the last month.
This shows the fact that there is something more to the feeling of the indian market that what is discussed here.
+rakhi narayanan it is the unbeatable after sales service and the better resale value. you can expect that with every Maruti car. Keeping those two things in mind, the only car worth being discussed against the Dzire in this segment should be the Xcent.
Zest is much better drivable car. One has to learn using its various modes smartly as per the situation. Its ride is farm more comfortable for back seat passengers due to its heavy body running aligned to road and excellent suspension. It is a robust car among all compared.
whatever I knew xcent is the best car in the comparison
biased, zest will be the car of the year and no way xcent is better than zest.
zest is the best
Right bro
Zest is safe car and best than excent
Having taken the test drive of all 4, my take is on Hyundai xcent and that is why I went for it. The reason being it is the best in fuel efficiency, good interiors, big boot space, smooth ride, low maintenance cost and last but not the least it has a good resale value as well. So all in all a very good bargain as compared to Amaze, Zest or Dzire.
Its between Zest and Xcent for me
Zest
ZEST is Good Car but Still there is questions about Tata Dealers/Service Centres. There are three challenges in front of Tata & that is 1.After sales service, (need to learn from Maruti-Suzuki)
2.Keep Zest as a Car not a ''Cab or Taxi like Premier''(Remember Premier history-What peoples mindset fixes that time...& what is condition today)
3.Most important peoples mindset about Tata Motors ..''Tata Motors is not only a Transport Vehicle Mfg. but also its best Car Manufacturer''
I hope Tata will keep Zest as a Premium Car & try to improve further....to win the Race.
All the Best
Vinayak Wawge Not any more. TATA has drastically improved the quality of its vehicles and can now boost of competing its foreign rivals. Things are only going to improve further in the future. I am a happy and proud owner of Zest for six months now. I didn't face any problems in my car and the service guy gives me door to door service which even maruti may not give. The game is now definitely changing for TATA. Zest has changed that perception. It is too strong a product to be ignored. Hope TATA gets its due credit in the coming times. TATA has already announced that bolts and zests will not be sold as taxis unlike its rivals including dzires and xcents. This is the major reason zest sales are still lower than the rest.
Tata Zest is the best of all!!
Zest is all feature in very best
Xcent is ULTIMATE
zest is best
I'll still wait for Ford Aspire to go about purchasing !
Ankur Kumar Even I am waiting for the Aspire. Ford says that the car will be launched in August 2015
Xcent Last man standing wohoo ....now i am proud owner of this car
Zest is the best
Zest is the best car I have bolt And zest
You're expecting a bmw sports mode at 7-8 lakhs price mark.. funny
Amaze is best
I cannot understand which to take the zest or the xcent but I have heard that tata is not a good company
Ahsanul Haque Tata is a good company but they are not as flashy and vocal about it like other brands. Zest and Aria are two very underrated Tata products in India compared to the products from foreign car makers like Hyundai , Honda and Toyota .Tata got a bad reputation because they did not have a segregated business for Passenger and Commercial vehicles and hence perceived as Truck , Taxi ( Indica / Indigo) manufacturers. The visit to a Tata Service Centre was not liked by general public as they didnt like these Indica , Indigo cab drivers sitting alongside - but that doesnt mean that Tatas were not taking care of your car any less than a Maruti / Hyundai Service centre ! And believe me Hyundai / Maruti Service stations may have all those people paying attention to you with smiling faces BUT that is a sweet trap to squeeze the money out of you which the Tatas are not doing .
seriously, xcent?? I was driven away from this car by the showroom sales guy himself!!
hey, Can you also suggest on the Chevy Sail which was recently been updated. I know its not in same category but its cost is somewhere in same range. So If you can suggest considering that too, it would be helpfull for us.
It cant quite manage to be as good as the competition above..
It neither can match the sheer all round ability of the sub 4 meter class.. nor can it be compared with the premium C segment offerings..
Too expensive for its features.
Same review for Diesel models please ..
+Samrat Roy go for Dzire vdi or zdi. However if by chance you feel like buying a petrol I would suggest the Xcent because it is on par with the Dzire in performance, it is better looking than the Dzire, feels excellent on the road and has much better interiors and features. Only benefit of the dzire petrol over the xcent is that being a Maruti you can expect lesser maintaining costs and a slightly better resale value.
+Sarthak Gulati
am planning for diesel zest. peopl are saying me to consider dzire but i think zest is better in all ways..
buddy if you are in the market for a compact sedan i would suggest you to look beyond the dzire, xcent and zest and have a look at the new Amaze, Aspire or even the VW Ameo. The new Amaze interiors give it a refreshing luxury sedan look and it has excellent performance. Aspire is a very under rated car just like every other Ford vehicle in India. VW Ameo looks interesting as well, especially because its VW priced very competitively for this segment. Do a bit of research for Amaze, Aspire and Ameo in my opinion according to your budget.
I am in a big confusion, please help me and say which is better to buy.
oleti subrahmanyam Zest but diesel one is much better than the petrol one
+Vimal Negi u hav zest
naah , but I have driven exhaustively
Could you please update the comparison of all Sub4 meter sedans by adding VW Ameo and Ford Figo Aspire . Tata Kite andChevrolet Essentia are to be launched .
its already there
I could not find 'Tata Zest vs Maruti Dzire vs Honda Amaze vs Hyundai Xcent vs Figo aspire vs VW Ameo'
Aspire wins hands down.
my have got zest and zest is very comfortable car and this is tata company
Zest is comparatively cheaper than all and giving the best
As always nicely done by Ms Kirplani.
So tell me which is better to buy
+oleti subrahmanyam In Petrol- if you want a complete package i.e. looks, performance, features, interiors, go for the Xcent. There is no difference between Xcent and Dzire in terms of performance, Xcent infact feels more confident on the road. However if you are not really bothered how your car looks on the outside, Dzire is a slightly better option because of its better resale value and slightly better after sale service being a Maruti. In Diesel- Dzire again is the safest best bet. However if you want a better looking diesel car, you can go for the Zest but when you are talking about diesel engines, they need more maintenance so I would personally suggest Dzire over Zest to anyone on any day.
xcent vs figo aspire vs tata zest? which one shld I buy?
Xcentt
Dezire
Zest
One of the ugliest Honda they have ever made
***** don't forget jazz and mobile...equally ugly...not sure what the honda india designers are on...
+Akhilesh Mohan Jazz is sold as Fit in USA and I find it a good looking car but yes, mobilio is ugly as well as amaze/brio...
Akhilesh Mohan 2015 Honda jazz looks good... Remaining Honda cars are ugly!
+shantanu0512 The European Honda Jazz isn t bad looking for a city car
naveen kumar crv?
Why the vxi for the dzire?
Best comparison
nice presentation thank you
Swift dzire is best
tata zest that's it
One n only swift ....
Maruti suzuki swift Dzire is the best all rounder of all
zest is superb
Why we need touch screen n all... The cars r all about driving pleassure...
& that included convenience & good futuristic accessories!
Zest and excent are the best
I have Tata zest xms revetron
Swift is a best product that we want to buy a car for convenience
Zest best build quality
Maruti belono
But still the dezire scoring on sales chart....
Abhijith Abhijith
you will know truth once you buy and drive in rainy season
@156314
pradeep srivastava why which car handles rainy season best
+wreckedpc Toyota Fortuner lol.
hyundai good job !
whatever be your observations , only maruti sells in India , u can't do anything about it 👍
Maruti = value for every penny that you pay..
🌹
but interior is not much better.....and mostly same interior in all maruti cars + swift is not a safe car(i have swift vdi)
I have swift VXI in my family. I know it's bit light. But unsafe means what? If u go n bang at 80kmph. Normally we hit on brakes. N by the time of collision speed reduces to 40 or so. For that matter if Scorpio n creta not safe
marutis are certified tin can coffins
Even if you R not going 80kmph, the other car/lorry could be going that speed. And since force = mass x acceleration, your speed really doesn't matter, the speed does not even matter if a lorry is hitting you even at 10, ok?
Tata zest is nice car
Well actually Toyota etios is better
I don't know from where the Etios comes to your mind, but I also think the same way. Superb car. Only thing which refrained from buying Etios is its built quality. Inverse to the engine quality. Why Toyota is doing this?
Almost 90 percent Etios (in Mumbai city) I saw are with at least one dent. Unhappy.
+Abhijeet n Kavita Honestly nothing beats a Toyota. Owned a Corolla and it was an absolute beast. I agree Etios doesnt have a great built quality but that is something one has to compromise with when you are getting a Toyota for just 6 or 7lacs.
I prefer the jetta , its more comfortable and built better . still though i respect your opinion !
Oh and there is no difference between the Octavia and the jetta ( except for the design ) turns out they make them both in the same factory .
yeah i know
Best car is dzire
Amaze is the best.
swift dzire is better to buy
+Sai karthik I'd love to see a BMW 1, 2 or 3 series in the same review. It would be like comparing the space shuttle to rickshaws. Personally, I prefer cars that look and drive like they're from the 21st century.
Zest is the best
zest is best
Zest is the best
zest is the best
Zest is best