Fun fact: Gaimon is in one of the paintings on the dining room walls of the Baratie. It could mean that in 11 years we get the pun conclusion and best girl: Gaimon and Sarfunkel
Hey nice vid! I don't agree with you on the Garp part tho. Yes Garp has been rough with Luffy his entire life, punching him with his fist of "Love". But in MarineFord it was different because of the context of what was going down, It wasn't only "hitting my Grandson" it was more like getting in his way of saving his other grandson, deep down he wanted to let luffy save ace, it was a conflicting position to be in. I don't think their interaction in the live action would make a potential marine ford arc less impactful
Yeah, I can understand that side of the argument. There's definitely an element of Garp wanting to protect Luffy AND Ace in that situation, that being the reason he TRULY holds back. I feel you dude!
It's interesting seeing people reactions to the series, especially the criticisms, because my first viewing of the series had me somewhat uncomfortable with the execution, that uncanniness of seeing the cartoonish translated to live-action. After letting it sit and viewing it a second time, despite being a little rough around the edges, I no longer get that discomfort telling me that something's wrong. I've accepted the world of Netflix's One Piece on its own terms.
@@BillyCabinsYT Because it's a joke-- well two in one really-- that I have been waiting for just the right context to tell it in, and your video is perfect.
Oh stop it I'm blushing!!! Jokes aside though, it's incredibly kind of you to give the video a chance and comment something so nice! You've made my day dude!
He definitely was holding back but at the same time... he still punched him through a few houses, ya know? Maybe I'm looking too far into it? What do you think?
I think in Paramount War though, its different because of the situation and what Luffy is trying to achieve there. For the first time he's fighting for something other than his dream with everything he has, and Garp is having to stop him. Given whose life is on the line, his hesitation makes a lot of sense. @@BillyCabinsYT
There's certainly an element of that to be sure! Garp not only wanted to avoid confrontation with Luffy, but also wanted to make sure that Ace wasn't hurt@@LaurArt_UK
@@BillyCabinsYT I think it's mostly the context of Marineford people have already commented about that makes the scene consistent (if the series continues to Marineford), but to the specific point of punching him through houses, Garp knows Luffy can take some punishment, having raised/trained him, so one can assume he could do far worse if he were fighting someone else. Garp is a very contradictory character; in the manga, his values being similar to Luffy's while serving in the Marines is kind of left up in the air until Marineford really dives into it with his relationship to Roger and Ace. I imagine there's even more yet to be revealed with Dragon's backstory and the mystery of D. still untouched. In this series they've altered the dynamic between him and Luffy so that his internal conflicts are portrayed up front, setting up a future Marineford to build on them (or, Oda forbid, to have them in there at all if the series can't make it that far). I feel that a lot of animanga fans are missing this because the original narrative portrays Garp as somewhat invincible until he finally fails at Marineford, and the contrast from that feels stronger to them than showing Garp as flawed from the start. It still feels the same to me, because Garp's failure here is meaningful to his character but trivial to the rest of the world. All of that will change in Marineford.
When I clicked on this video.... I thought It would be a stupid negative video about the live action. But I was wrong. I never watched lazy town, yet...somehow I agreed with everything you said
Small issue with the wigs sections. While I wholeheartedly agree with the sentiment, it can fall flat at times. In Cocoyashi Village, *every* unnammed character from the village is extremely desaturated and realistic. This does help Nojiko, and to a lesser extent Genzo, stand out in the crowd, but I felt during those scenes specifically that it was a bit too fake. Idk, ig it's b/c the fishman rarely interact with the villagers so the normalization is a bit off ig.
Now that's a clickbait and a half, considering the adaption was made to appeal to a more non-weebish audience =]
that's fair... I just wanted a silly title tho haha
This is the perfect opporunity for me to mention that captain Kuro looks like the villain from lazy town
TRUE
well the anime is straight up Looney Toons its just right the live action should be LazyTown
Fun fact: Gaimon is in one of the paintings on the dining room walls of the Baratie. It could mean that in 11 years we get the pun conclusion and best girl: Gaimon and Sarfunkel
I really enjoy the way that your brain works haha 😂
No one has compared the live action of One Piece to Lazy Town before but hou are absolutely right
haha thanks man!
Hey nice vid! I don't agree with you on the Garp part tho. Yes Garp has been rough with Luffy his entire life, punching him with his fist of "Love". But in MarineFord it was different because of the context of what was going down, It wasn't only "hitting my Grandson" it was more like getting in his way of saving his other grandson, deep down he wanted to let luffy save ace, it was a conflicting position to be in. I don't think their interaction in the live action would make a potential marine ford arc less impactful
Yeah, I can understand that side of the argument. There's definitely an element of Garp wanting to protect Luffy AND Ace in that situation, that being the reason he TRULY holds back. I feel you dude!
2:58 when will jumper get its faithful adaptation
0:48 I liked that one
It's interesting seeing people reactions to the series, especially the criticisms, because my first viewing of the series had me somewhat uncomfortable with the execution, that uncanniness of seeing the cartoonish translated to live-action. After letting it sit and viewing it a second time, despite being a little rough around the edges, I no longer get that discomfort telling me that something's wrong. I've accepted the world of Netflix's One Piece on its own terms.
Bro, ghost in the shell was great
Actually.....you're right.
And I never figured it: Sportacus is the greatest Chad ever.
and that's on god dude
Can't wait till it gets to the "WE ARE number one" arc.
BANGER comment wtf why is that so funny
@@BillyCabinsYT Because it's a joke-- well two in one really-- that I have been waiting for just the right context to tell it in, and your video is perfect.
the amount of stars that had to align for that to work... @@Evdafawth
Comment for the algorithm. Editing is really good for a small channel and people should give this vid a chance...
Oh stop it I'm blushing!!! Jokes aside though, it's incredibly kind of you to give the video a chance and comment something so nice! You've made my day dude!
They should ham it up even more in Season 2 lol
oh absolutely!
I think Live Action Garp was holding back too.
He definitely was holding back but at the same time... he still punched him through a few houses, ya know? Maybe I'm looking too far into it? What do you think?
I think in Paramount War though, its different because of the situation and what Luffy is trying to achieve there. For the first time he's fighting for something other than his dream with everything he has, and Garp is having to stop him. Given whose life is on the line, his hesitation makes a lot of sense. @@BillyCabinsYT
There's certainly an element of that to be sure! Garp not only wanted to avoid confrontation with Luffy, but also wanted to make sure that Ace wasn't hurt@@LaurArt_UK
@@BillyCabinsYTGarp was definitely holding back
@@BillyCabinsYT I think it's mostly the context of Marineford people have already commented about that makes the scene consistent (if the series continues to Marineford), but to the specific point of punching him through houses, Garp knows Luffy can take some punishment, having raised/trained him, so one can assume he could do far worse if he were fighting someone else.
Garp is a very contradictory character; in the manga, his values being similar to Luffy's while serving in the Marines is kind of left up in the air until Marineford really dives into it with his relationship to Roger and Ace. I imagine there's even more yet to be revealed with Dragon's backstory and the mystery of D. still untouched. In this series they've altered the dynamic between him and Luffy so that his internal conflicts are portrayed up front, setting up a future Marineford to build on them (or, Oda forbid, to have them in there at all if the series can't make it that far). I feel that a lot of animanga fans are missing this because the original narrative portrays Garp as somewhat invincible until he finally fails at Marineford, and the contrast from that feels stronger to them than showing Garp as flawed from the start. It still feels the same to me, because Garp's failure here is meaningful to his character but trivial to the rest of the world. All of that will change in Marineford.
5:07 Us manga readers caught up know their names lol
fair enough haha
heck yeah greg bob n billy
DUDE!! Remember when bob did that one thing and then Billy said that thing to greg? Sh*t was goated! @@IceCream-fm4oc
When I clicked on this video....
I thought It would be a stupid negative video about the live action. But I was wrong.
I never watched lazy town, yet...somehow I agreed with everything you said
haha I'm glad you enjoyed dude thanks for giving it a chance!
0:38 Alita is good, and the Japanese live action
That’s a dub for us one piece stans
LET"S F-ING GO GAMERS! 🎊🥳💯
f*ckin underated channel
omg that means so much to me... thanks dude!
I like the one piece live action ^w^
dude... I LOVE IT so much! It was such a surprise
damn this is a pretty entertaining video bro
That is so kind of you to say dude omg thanks for watching!
Wait what?
hmmm... idk
Small issue with the wigs sections. While I wholeheartedly agree with the sentiment, it can fall flat at times.
In Cocoyashi Village, *every* unnammed character from the village is extremely desaturated and realistic. This does help Nojiko, and to a lesser extent Genzo, stand out in the crowd, but I felt during those scenes specifically that it was a bit too fake. Idk, ig it's b/c the fishman rarely interact with the villagers so the normalization is a bit off ig.
I felt the same way, but in rewatch because Luffy said that lady with the cool hair, compare to everyone else there. It kinda help a bit.
Ya know what, I can agree with this idea. I still think he overall execution of wigs in Netflix's One Piece is great overall tho.
First