MY TRANS DAUGHTER (Answering your questions)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 сен 2024
- When Edie was 6 years old she socially transitioned into identifying as a girl. That was almost 3 years ago and now my daughter has fully integrated into home life and school life as a girl. So we thought it might be helpful for other families who might be having a similar experience. for us to share a Q and A.
If you have any other questions please leave them below in the comments and next time we might answer your question.
#sacconejolys #trans #lgbtq
Watch our RUclips short videos here
Anna - @AnnaSaccone
Jonathan - @jonathanjoly
Does it concern anyone else that Edie only equates being a girl with having long hair and wearing girly things? Because that's not all a female or woman is. She is still too young to truly understand all it really entails in the future and the impact it will have on her life at a later stage.
No. Not really. She knows who she is. You can tell that in this video. I do wonder if shes under a gender therapist yet, because she should be of she isnt.
Riley you are right
This
@@Sam-zu5mr there’s no way an 8 year old could “know who she is.” At 8 I thought I had super powers. I’m not even exaggerating. She’s way to young to transition. That’s coming from a trans male. You have to have life experience and have pretty bad gender dysphoria to transition. Edie has only lived as a boy for like 6 years, that’s nothing. Half of that she was just a baby and has no memory. They better hope to god they made the right choice or Edie is gonna be going through an existential crisis at 13
@@AidenAndSaturn yup
I grew up with a boy who LOVED wearing dresses and playing with dolls. He is now married with kids.
My son used to ask me to paint his nails and wanted to wear purses when he was younger because that’s what me and his sister used to do. He is a pre teen now and is just an average boy. My issue is that they are putting this on the internet, their child should have privacy.
As a child I’d kick and scream when my mom put me in a dress and combed my hair. Lol . I was a complete tom boy with holes in my knees, played with my brothers trucks over my dolls etc. I detested picture day at school because I knew it meant my mom putting me in a dress and making me look pretty. Same with going to weddings and parties. My 2 sisters on the other hand were opposite of me. By grade 8 I loved dresses etc had interest in boys . I’ve been happily married to my husband for 23 years with a son. You just never know I guess.
I have a story about my son. He is now her age. Seven years old.
When my son was about four years old, we went back to school Outfit shopping. He picked out a sparkly blue top and plain denim shorts. He picked it out. He always loved sparkly dresses. His sister (2yrs older than him) always let him play princesses with him. We never tried to enforce it, we just let him pick. He wore a dress and a hair bow to school one day, no one cared. He didn’t want to wear one again because he said he didn’t think dresses suited him. He is now seven and he doesn’t like sparkly things anymore but I’m glad that we let HIM decide what he likes instead of telling him he’s transgender He chose a dress and a sparkly top ONCE in a store. That never made him a girl or have gender dysmorphia, it just gave him the opportunity to wear what caught his eye, what HE wanted to wear. We encourage our kids to express themselves as much as THEY want to, whether that be a lot or not at all. I personally believe that the kid in this video probably said he wanted to wear something that his sister wore and his parents immediately said you’re trans buddy.
Anyway, I agree that this child in the video does not deserve those cruel parents , but I wanted to share my personal experience with a child that loves sparkly things. My son no longer loves sparkly things, and it was just a phase he went through as he was growing up, which is completely normal! What isn’t normal is for a young child being forced on camera and being forced to be transgender. This is abuse. Thank you.
I’m glad that I didn’t force my son to do anything, and I treat all my kids equally. Even when he wanted to wear what his sister was wearing, we didn’t treat him any differently and I’m glad we didn’t. We said he could wear whatever HE wanted to wear, and we wouldn’t force him to wear anything. We said it’s okay if he doesn’t want to wear dresses or shorts one day because he can CHOOSE what he wears. We explained that he might not want to wear things that his sister wears as he grows older but if he does, that’s perfectly fine and he can just tell us. He is now her age and I am thanking myself for not forcing him to be a girl because it was just a phase that literally lasted like five months. This is ridiculous, they are putting their child all over the internet and saying that they are transgender just because they liked wearing ‘girl clothes’ when they were like five years old! I think it’s abusive and wrong.
@@Phoebebridgersslays you’re amazing 👏
Also valid. But some kids actually express not wanting to be a boy/girl. Wanting to wear dresses does not equal a gender. I assume they spoke with their child about more then just wearing dresses.
As a doctor I find this so concerning. Boys are allowed to be feminine and have long hair. Don’t ruin your sons life for views and fame.
Agreed if he has feminine interests or wants to dress up let him but do not start a transition journey for a literal child
@@starfiresreign automatic karen
I agree that boys can have long hair and are allowed to be feminine but that doesn’t dispute the fact that gender dysphoria is still a real thing. They do mention that she often gravitated towards feminine things and did feel like they were a boy. This is common for people with gender dysphoria. Imo they need to be referred to a gender specialist because she likely does have gender dysphoria. Ruining someone’s life and letting them express themselves are two different things. If it turns out that she doesn’t actually have gender dysphoria then she can just socially transition back to a boy. It also doesn’t seem to be for views and fame as they genuinely seem happy as they are, a lot happier than if they were forced to live their life as a boy. Gender dysphoria id much more than being feminine, it’s feeling a mismatch on a bigger scale.
I totally agree. I think gender is a crock of bs and people can dress and act however they want. People take it way too seriously and think melodramatic thoughts like they're born in the wrong body. When really, it's just gender expression. Which is a man-made societal concept. Lots of people don't fit in the box and that's totally fine. Doesn't mean they're trans. If you want to transition as an adult that's totally fine, freedom is awesome. But you should try to teach your kids to love who they are instead of have them become a new person. That's how Edie made it sound, like that was a different life as a boy. It wasn't, that's her and always will be and that's okay.
I agree with the doctor
I thought these stopped exploiting their child for money. This is so wrong.
They will never stop exploiting their children for money. They are disgusting parents.
@@nataliec5883 completely agree, after seeing the apology and saying they realise what they are doing and then they leave it a few months and appear again, they must have ran out of money. It will be when these kids hit adulthood that the impact of what they are doing will show with these kids, I hope they speak out and make money from sharing their parents abuse and how much it effects them as grown ups. Not that I want these kids to suffer but so many are coming forward now having been exploited like this as children and its not nice to see.
you haven’t hit puberty yet kid, once you do then come back with the answer. Praying for you.
Same this kid literally has no idea who he is or what he wants and he certainly won't know for a while. He'll only know what his parents tell him
@@starfiresreign children are capable of making decisions for themselves. None of this is permanent and you should treat children with more respect, they are capable of more than you think. I knew that I wanted to play piano as a child and I'm thankful that my parents allowed me to make the decision to get lessons as I still enjoy playing piano today. She may not entirely know exactly what she wants in life, but she is able to change her mind at any time, it's not permanent. So the least you could do is respect her wishes at this current time and respect her decision to be considered a girl. Forcing her to be a boy right now isn't really going to help her in any way, it's only going to cause even more distress.
What’s scary is many of these kids at the beginning of puberty get further entrenched in this. Puberty blockers at Tanner Stage 2, a mere year later estrogen may begin. When these kids are left alone, by adulthood, 85-98% of boys desist. Will he be spared of medical intervention? Well, these ideologues are allergic to the data, so I fear not.
@@laurab1105 “children are capable of making decisions for themselves”
Do you know how idiotic you sound right now? Making a decision requires knowledge on a matter, and where does a CHILD get to have all the knowledge on such a complex topic?
@@laurab1105 puberty blockers are permanent and that’s where they are headed next. Watch videos of detransitioners. It’s heartbreaking
Knowing that the kid cant remember how she knew she was a "girl" speaks volumes.
Do you remember how you knew you were a girl?
That’s your opinion and belief thank god not everyone thinks like you. Grow up let the kid be what she wants to be and not what society or older adults what them to be. Great job for them to be there for this child . I have a friend who has a kid the same age and they disowned there kid and gave them away to someone else in the family cause they don’t belief and want the child anymore which is wrong but it’s not my problem cause it doesn’t effect me.
@@iretb73 when I saw what was between my legs
@@sandawise79 👏🏽 right there.... All living things are either male or female. Even plants. Period. It is what it is... But I do understand that our mental can have an effect on how we FEEL and decisions we make. Still, science is science and we are what we are.
@@peachy_reina we are what we are…. True statement . Unfortunately you appear to be someone who is not very considerate of the fact that perhaps you’re just not smart enough to understand DNA. If you speak for science, maybe you should do more scientific research before you claim to have all the answers.
But let’s assume for a second you’re entirely right and what this mom is doing is incredibly wrong . Why exactly do you care ? If you think this is anti (whichever of the many gods’ ) word you believe in, then still ... Why is it better to promote hatred on this earth and let those “sinners” commit their sins ? I honestly would love to know why judging makes things better ? If a god is out there not liking what this mom is doing let them deal with that in the afterlife then. We’re here and now . Let’s choose love for the time being. It’s the only thing we know for sure exists ..sadly enough not coming from people like you …
This kid isn't Trans, just being a kid and exploring and enjoys feminine things.
I don’t think a child who likes dolls is the same as someone who believes deep down that they are female.
They are still a child. Children deep down want to be astronauts and superheroes for a job. It is irresponsible to do this without proper informed consent at a mature age. In many cases doctors encourage parents to do this. They end up de transitioning as adults and the process is painful.
@@user-sw2wv1zx1t actually there is a lot of research into how a lot of transgender people were and are very aware of themselves, often more so than heteronormative children. All Edie has done is change her clothes, her name and her hair. Nothing else happens at this age. Why is everyone so offended by this?
@@danamoore5118 No one said that dummy account. Please quote or stop making things up to strengthen your already dead argument. You are educating no one and are quite sick. Leave children alone.
@@BLane-xr1ic you’re going to be more specific. Did they mention hormone replacement, no. Did they mention surgical gender reassignment, no.
I can give you plenty of link to medical research on gender identity and transgender identity if you would like to read it.
I'm so happy that people are calling these attention seeking parents out! this child isn't old enough to decide to live as a girl.
I know of many adult trans people who knew they were trans from this age and even younger. She knows that this doesn't have to be permanent, but it's what she is most comfortable identifying as now. May as well respect your child's wishes as there is nothing wrong with wanting to idenfiy as a girl, especially if she finds it dysphoric and distressing to be identified as a boy.
@@laurab1105 except 90% of transgender people, if left alone, are just gay. He’s forming his self esteem and identity off of a change in gender, which statistically, is unlikely to stick. Then comes the rebuilding of self once he realizes which should not be taken lightly.
💯
@@laurab1105 this isn’t the kid’s fucking wishes, it’s his MOM’s wishes!
I'm a trans woman and while yes I knew I was trans when I was younger, the vast majority of children experiencing dysphoria out grow it by the time the reach adulthood. Letting children transition is playing with fire and if they're not in the 20% they will grow into being disgusted and deeply depressed about their bodies. This is not okay and shouldn't be allowed unless the child was self harming over it or making S attempts. Only reason why I support that is because I'd rather someone be alive and regret it than the world lose a child in tragedy. This isn't okay.
I'm not transphobic in any way but it just feels wrong, it seems the way the parents think the world works is boys like blue and have short hair and girls like pink and have long hair, thats completely wrong! I'm male and I'm in the middle of growing my hair long and my favourite colour is green! Boys CAN wear dresses, boys CAN have long hair vice versa. The child (I won't refer to them as any gender) also said "if I want to be a boy again I'll get a haircut" like WHAT!? I feel these parents have made it clear to the child that girls can only have long hair and boys can only have short hair. If the child wants long hair and their a boy thats completely fine! You don't need to change gender just because of a hairstyle. I wouldn't suggest the child undergoing physical changes to a girl as theres a pretty good chance the child will want to remain male. Just my opinion, not meaning to be transphobic at all! I just think it's wrong changing everything so early in life.
this isn't transphobia it's just facts i wanna be feminine and wear skirts and paint my nails doesn't mean i'm trans
There are many straight men with long hair. There are many straight women with short hair.
Hair length does not define gender or sexuality.
The fact that this child thinks that long hair makes him a girl is ridiculous and proves that he doesnt know what gender means.
This poor kid, they should have had this conversation after they were 18. I don’t know how they havnt taken the kid away, they should be ashamed. Gods kids are not for sale or to be experimented on.
so what you're saying is that you're transphobic
@@victoryluck In all fairness he was only 5. But I completely agree
My daughter dressed in boy clothes, wore her hair like a boy till the age of 12 when she started dressing girly wearing makeup. Kids go through phases doesn't mean they're automatically trans smh
did you daughter display distress and dysphoria when going by their assigned gender? This child is clearly not comfortable being considered a boy, it would be cruel to force her to continue being a boy if she clearly doesn't want to at this moment.
@@laurab1105My father worked for CPS for 10 years. The fact that people like you have kids is insane. He’s dealt with people like you for 10 years and he knows how you all think. Everything is about yourselves.
@@laurab1105 ah yes of course, I bet if your child was somehow feeling comfortable being seduced by a pedophile you would just let the child get used and abused for your child's temporary comfort. Please do not reproduce.
These people are deluded and monetizing his illness is Wrong!!!
Same
This is a little kid 😢 heartbreaking
more like heartwarming
@@pankoza2 literally child exploitation
The thing that worries me is that he says he doesn't remember and that he only started feeling like a girl when he was given dresses. This shows it was encouraged
She, the human identifies as "She". Give the kid respect. Right or wrong. This child will make the final decision as an adult.
Mother started all this bloody rubbish needs sorting
@@Musicsports that’s a boy
Of course it was.
@@Musicsports god already decided for us all and people like you are the ones who like to even question Gods decision and be ungrateful for who you really are
Do your job as a mother and let your child have a childhood without this life damaging madness!
She is doing her job exactly. To listen to her child, understand them, support them and encourage them to be themselves.
@@gamepads wrong
@@gamepads sorry do you know the definition of pedophilia. Obviously not.
By your definition having a transgender child someone makes you a pedophile.
Reported for being an ignorant, discriminatory, transphobe.
Finnaly a comment talking facts
@@danamoore5118 where does a young child learn this from, it's indoctrination, mental torture,brainwashing! Kids that age only think about their next playdate!
"Sacrificing your kid for the glorification of your own compassion". - Jordan Peterson
Spot on.
I wonder if they have listened to the detransitioning podcasts Jordan Peterson has been putting out lately.
@@JH-nb4nn What are you talking about? Like what are you trying to say?
@@bazbulick hahaha I can’t figure it out myself
dont worry LOL.
This is child abuse. They don't know about almost anything, we have to decide for them ,and they can decide their gender?, they don't even know what that is, this is unacceptable
This poor kid, they should have had this conversation after they were 18. I don’t know how they havnt taken the kid away, they should be ashamed. Gods kids are not for sale or to be experimented on.
this child, edie, is a girl. you dont "decide" your gender. gender and sex are different.
I consider this to be a type of abuse by persuasion. Makes me sick these ppl shouldn't be parents🤮
This should never be normalized
It OK to be trans however saying you can only be a girl if you like pink is what shouldn't be normalised
Edie thinks being a girl is just the stereotypes
Or maybe radical feminism has removed women so far from what they are, that anything traditional or normal looks like a stereotype from that vantage point.
@@ReferenceMA no, I just mean that the only thing Edie actually associates with being a girl is liking dresses and pink and not liking football and wanting to be friends with girls
@@charlotte726 true, but at age ten I'm not sure it's fair to expect anything particularly profound.
@@ReferenceMA maybe not but if she’s going to change which gender she identifies as then a better understanding would be best
@@charlotte726 I'm sure that will come with age.
I'm a mother of a 6 year old , you can not let your child make life changing decisions just because they feel a certain way, if they say mommy I feel like a cat , then are u going to entertain that and treat the child like a cat? They do not know what they want , our job as parents is to guide our children to be the best they can be as a person and the foundation is god, please do not ruin this kids life and stop entertaining the idea thats his a girl when you as a grown adult know that u gave birth to a baby boy not a girl,
Then you're a bad parent. I made a decision to become a vegetarian when I was 8, which my parents respected. I have been a vegetarian ever since, I am now a vegan and work in the animal welfare sector. I am glad my parents allowed me to make decisions because I am my own human being with my own mind.
1000% agree
not everyone is a christian or cares about "god". None of this is permanent at this moment either. As a parent you should respect your child's wishes. If they are clearly displaying distress when considered being a boy, it would be cruel to force them. They can change their mind if they want to at any point. She is just having a healthy and open conversation with her child.
@@user-yt9ge3ry1f exactly. We are capable of making decisions for ourselves regarding how we want to identify as children. Gender expression is complex and forcing your child to identify as something they are uncomfortable with is cruel. She is always capable of changing her mind, nothing is permanent.
None of this is permanent tho. The kid can change her mind and get a haircut and go back to her birth name any time she wants to. It’s not like she’s doing something irreversible
I saw a video with the dad and 3 of the kids including Edie and they together discussed if they "feel like a boy or a girl" and it is clear from that video that they literally think if you like pink and dresses you are a girl and if you like blue and sports you are a boy... The truth is being a girl and a boy is biological, not a stereotypical description of what in general society expects you to be
Incorrect. Read a book.
It’s so sad they won’t let a boy wear a dress! Why do they go straight to this
@@Chelseabee55 I agree
@@asiagarcia5403 I see you don't have any logical argument, just trying to seem smart
@@asiagarcia5403 How is that incorrect?! That's literally a biological truth that no "gender norms" nonsense can change !!! It's just extremely sad that so many people are so deeply brainwashed into thinking otherwise. There are so many different ways to be a man or a woman...
Don't expose your child!!
What the heck does that mean? This is an honest discussion.
@@KM-ws4kf don’t tell me a child can have an “honest discussion” about their “identity” 😂😂 it’s a CHILD
Yeah, no privacy
I think you mean exploit
@@KC-bc2tb both
So much guided communication going on here from this woman.
Literally endless leading questions.
You're looking at the definition of munchausen by proxy, and Edwardo will pay the price for corrupt doctors who instead of treating the parents will destroy the young boys life.
Yes!!!!
Typical of trans parents. It's disturbing.
This poor kid, they should have had this conversation after they were 18. I don’t know how they havnt taken the kid away, they should be ashamed. Gods kids are not for sale or to be experimented on.
Child exploitation. Honestly take a step back and put the camera away.
Thank you we need more ppl like u
Fr tho
I honestly felt like I just watched two completely delusional human beings. And I’m not wrong.
Bullseye 🎯
At least one of them has an excuse.
I honestly feel like I just read a completely delusional comment. But, hey! Go off 😒
@@MsSpktrout Yea don't worry about it. Didn't expect you to understand it.
How can a woman who gave birth be an expert on transgender? Not saying it’s not something a lot of people go through but this isn’t a life hack kinda thing.
Being a woman is nothing to do with your hair, clothes, makeup. This whole trans thing is insulting.
This!! No one cares your son wears dresses and has a nickname. He is not a female.
Yes
The child is 8!!!!! Do you really expect them to wax philosophic about everything being a woman is?
She feels like a girl, what is the harm in letting her live female for now (no surgery) and just support her while she figures things out?
I don’t understand why conservatives are so twisted on this. Did you even watch the video? Even if she ends up deciding to live as male later, she is glad to be living as female right now.
No harm no foul
Shhhh
@@Puglover130 there's nothing for the child to " figure out".
The child was born male, and will always be.
If mama had a brain she would explain that to the child.
Just because he likes dresses and long hair doesn't mean he is a girl. Why is this so confusing people 😢
*she *
Exactly. But why is his parents already deciding he is going to be a Transgender???
@@lynm.8787 it's all for views and $
@@Plsdonategoal1m You think that feminine boys don't exist?
@@lynm.8787I believe she (edie) made the decision herself her parents are supporting
Lord have mercy on this child and his family.
The Lord should take mercy on the poor child but not the abusive parents !
Bro what.... she's comfortable with this... and in no way is this abuse, this child is not in distress...
Pure evil
her*
@@heartstopper.is.myLIFE no...his
How uncomfortable this child looks. These parents pushed and pushed this narrative and this is the result. I used to watch during Amelia baby days…but I stopped because Jonathan strikes me as a predator…I’m not saying he is, but there’s always a vibe with those kinds of people and Jonathan is one of them. Feel sorry for these children.
Same, When I look at this family I just am so happy that I have parents that care about me
It’s telling that the dislikes are turned off. I have a feeling more people disagree with this. At least I hope so…
People who deny sex differences are always predators or have some agenda.
So happy my parents never made me make decisions when I was basically a baby. This kid is going through a phase.
I made a decision to become a vegetarian when I was 8, which my parents respected. I have been a vegetarian ever since, I am now a vegan and work in the animal welfare sector. I am glad my parents allowed me to make decisions.
They never said anything about this decision being permanent or life-changing and she is free to change her mind at any time. 8 years old is not a baby and children are capable of making decisions regarding how they identify. Again, nothing is permanent.
@@user-yt9ge3ry1f deciding to or to not eat meat is not the equivalent of changing your name, and having the desire to alter your body and taking hormone blockers and such. this is a stupid comparison. gender identity is a serious thing and can be something so overwhelming for adults to figure out, let alone a child. i believe boys should be allowed to wear "feminine" things if that's what they want, but starting a full transition as a literal child is odd to me.
And that’s fine, Edie can go back to living as male is she decides to. It’s not like she’s had bottom surgery!! You guys need to chill out.
She’s so lucky she’s grown up w an open minded family who will support her regardless
@@user-yt9ge3ry1f that’s a decision about food not your life.
I will never forget when Anna made a comment in a video once that she hoped she would have a gay son someday, which I thought was an extremely weird thing to say. She seems drawn to men with feminine characteristics.
Leave the children alone you freaks!
That would make so much sense. Her husband himself looks super gay. It’s ok to be gay, but weird to marry a guy that acts so feminine. I hate what she and he are doing psychologically and physically to this poor little boy!
Or want whyte people gone, genno side-al behavior? 🤔
@@Amabadam Her husband is obviously just projecting himself onto this poor little boy.
Would love to see that video
Dang this is crazy that some people can fail this hard as a parent
wtf !!!! they are not failing ! they are very understanding, supportive and very loving !
@@vickyvicky-qp1fzshe’s 8 and trans. you would usually think this at around 13-14+
@@vickyvicky-qp1fz what if he changes his mind when hes 14 and says mommy I'm a boy after all?? You think he's body is going to return to normal after all that hormone therapy. Seek help youre just as bad as his child abusing mother.
wait till the puberty…
@@NikaPix STOP 💀💀
I feel so sorry for this child to have parents like this!! 😢
👏👏👏👏👏👏
👏🏻 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Transphobic
Yh, I feel soo sorry for this little boy
@@officialkide6557 how is that transphobic?
Boys can like makeup and dolls and dressing up too when their young, alot of them grow out of it. What if Edie does too. Shouldn't you wait until Edie is atleast 18. My brother was super girly because he grew up around women. My father wasn't in the picture back then. But grew out of it. That being said you also need to help Edie understand growing your hair and wearing a dress doesn't make you a girl. Have you discussed what a girl is? And what future changes that will entail. Taking hormones etc
exactly, kdis make up their mind all the time!! He or she might change mind as he or she gets older.
Nothing Edie is doing right now is permanent. If for whatever reason she decides she is not trans, which she made very clear in the video that she doesn't think that would ever happen, she has only socially transitioned as of now. There are a ton of steps you need to go through before any medical interventions are done. Also, no good doctors are out there willy nilly putting kids on blockers and performing life altering surgeries. I speak from the experience of having a trans son.
@@iretb73 Edie isn't doing anything permanent but I still feel if a child can not understand what this will lead too, then don't encourage it at such a tender age. They may later feel like they now have to be someone they wanted to be as a child. It's very confusing for people. You should actually see those that transitioned and then regretted their decision. It's heart breaking to see how much damage they did to their bodies and minds. This child is too young.
I played with Legos and g.i. joes and wore baggy clothes. I didn't like girly things because girls bullied me. I grew out of it. It never made a guy, that's ridiculous
I think they answered this in the video. She knew, and know, that boys can like girls stuff. And they also talked about what if she "changes her mind".
This is so scary. Kids don’t know what they want to eat for breakfast, let alone to become a different gender. Insanity.
My god, Anna, you’ve grown to be SUCH a disappointment. I’m not a “hater”, I’ve been following you since you were just The Style Diet. The way you and Jon push Edie to be the face of the Trans movement is criminal. I have zero issues with her being transgendered and EVERY issue with her story being exploited day after day. Like I said, you’ve become an epic disappointment and I’m heartbroken for Edie.
I have also been a long-time viewer & fan of Anna, but how they have handled this has been incredibly disappointing.
They haven't prioritized their children, especially Edie, who is going through something so sensitive. Instead, they have actuvely dragged her into the popular trans spotlight. Their own child is more important than being an ally to any movement & it is possible to do a lot of good alllyship in private, without exploiting your own child.
Anna has always said that Edie was always very sensitive, I don't see how she can't realize this exposure & focus is going to negatively affect her.
I am not trans but I am gay, I am so glad I was able to figure it out in private & wasn't encouraged to have conversations for the benefit of others before I was emotionally or mentally ready to. Also, just because someone comes out doesn't mean they are 100% comfortable or happy discussing their whole journey & that's for a fully gown adult, not a young child.
Agree with u, saw this lady in my recommendations and while information on trans kids is good it’s also a lot of exposure for the child and idt it’s really fair on her
the son is not a her. stop encouraging this bullshit
I used to dress like a boy, played with my boy cousins toys, relate better to men, but I AM A WOMAN!!!! You are ruining Eduardo’s life! I pray y’all stop pushing this on him and that God opens your eyes and mind. This is so heartbreaking!!!
I couldn’t even begin to imagine what would have happened if my parents did this to me… I was a tomboy growing up.. loved “boys” toys and all the typical “boy” things to do. If my parents told me I was trans because of all that.. man.
this child, edie, is a girl
Parental grooming to the enth degree.. unfortunately this is a western/ cultural sickness that is blighting our society.
So sad what some parents do to their kids. This isn’t normal
This Mom needs to be in prison.
Have a day off will you
@@alannahcoleman7 have some basic morals and stay the fuck away from children, will you? Predator.
Surely this is child abuse, why is this disgusting mother enabling this and making money from it!, I hope they are on social services radar!
This generation will go down as one of THE most bizarre/sad generations for the crimes committed against children for genital mutilations.
Let kids be kids. If they still want sex change, they can do it when they turned 18.
Children under 18 can’t drink, drive, vote, smoke yet they can make decisions for sex change 😭🤯:
Where have you found actual information about gender affirming surgery being done on children?
@@fridasoderstrom7116 Look up Chloe Cole on RUclips
@@fridasoderstrom7116jesus Christ, open your eyes
Went through male puberty as a trans-person, was absolutely horrible. Lost my female voice and now I have to mourn the loss of the potential to develop a female bone structure for the rest of my life.
Hope this kid gets the healthcare she needs to go through the female puberty she needs to thrive like I wish I could've. Don't wish what I went through on my worst enemy let alone this child
What it sounds like is that Edie doesn't like to answer the questions "how did she know she was a girl?" because there is no true answer she can give, because the way "she" feels is the way a boy with his "feminine" personality feels like, he doesn't know what it feels like to be a girl because he is a boy. Whenever he describes being a girl is about stereotypical and surface level things like dresses and not liking sports. Also, he said it happened gradually that he knew he was a girl which just clarifies that its because his parents encouraged this an told him that he might be a girl and so over time they caused him to think this.
Exactly.. so terrible
Yeh I’m also beginning to see a bit of picture here they already have two that are girls but I think they wanted all girls and what he said isn’t even close to what he should be feeling if he felt like a girl trapped in a boys body.
This is insanity! This is abusive as a parent!
Or just bc he does not like to be filmed and used for views🤦♀️ he’s uncomfortable in front of the camera clearly
this child, edie, is a girl
I remember her mentioning she was so scared when she found out she was having a boy. Also her husband has his own issues. The mom battles with mental health issues. If they want to help themselves and children they will get off all socal influences. Find work. And ways to get help with mental instabilities
I wish this little boy the best. Very sad
He* it is ok
I am sure they made enough money for a lifetime. they don't need jobs out of the public eye.
BRO, GIRL. WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU GUYS.
yeah... it's a family with lots of issues. This child didn't have any escape.
oh really ?? WOW -why was she scared , did they say ?
God honestly help us all. Let children be children. They don't know enough to determine such a thing. God creates us all so perfectly, male and female and I pray we all embrace this
Exactly. I used to be very thin and I wanted to become 300 Lbs. to experience being "Fat". My mother refused to let me alter my body for the sake of my health. My parents knew I was just making childish decisions.
I’m sorry, but there’s nothing about this child that isn’t perfect. Period. I’m guessing that you knew you were a girl at 8. Should someone have told you that you weren’t allowed to be a girl because you didn’t know enough to determine such a thing? I am truly, truly baffled by the magnitude of ignorance in these comments.
@@MsSpktrout With reasoning like that, you are likely to be baffled often. Try reversing that lobotomy maybe.
@@MsSpktrout Respectfully, her physical girl parts would of let her know she was a girl, this isn't the same.
this child, edie, is a girl, no need to pray for her.
Clearly identity issues that are within the father are being transferred to the kids. Kids have no idea who they actually are unless a parent instills it to them
Ahhh we aren’t who are parent tell us to be. It comes from within.
@@danamoore5118 She's a child!!!!!
@@aimeek1236 he
And the parents are exploiting the hell out if it. So wrong.
I can see the headline in a month or three from now..
Child k ll their parent or father molest tranxxx kid or even ch ld takes own life, so scary!
I wanted to be a damn transformer at that age. This is rediculous.
I wanted to be able to stand to pee, but I’m 100% happy to be a woman as an adult. Kids want weird things. This mom is fucked up
Not exploiting would be a good start
I’m sorry but this kid is too young to make this type of decision
The amount of therapy this kid is going to need is astounding. I’m so sorry your parents failed you, Eduardo. You deserve better.
Yes yes yes yes. Couldn’t have said it better myself
Your so right it's sad
this child, EDIE, is a GIRL. she is not eduardo.
Exactly! Thankfully there is Hope Walt Heyer was groomed by his grandmother and he helps people with trans regret or questions on all things the media and the world are not saying.
@@-Syrus- eduardo.
This boy has been pushed into this because his dad is trans
Dad is not trans.
How did they have so many children if the dad is trans. It is possible but not that easy as two biologically females
@@SimayB_ He is still a he, drugs dont change that..
@@nikitasrivastava974 huh?
@@SimayB_ a person can identify with another gender without medically transitioning btw. The father could feel female and internally identify as a woman. hell, he could be intersex and we just don't know (he may not even know). Medically transitioning isn't necessary to be trans.
I truly believe a child of this age should not be encouraged to change their name and identity due to wanting to wear a dress and liking girly things … perhaps when asked the question “how did you first know?” Is uncomfortable to the child as they still don’t know ……beucase they are way too young to possible understand!
My son used to beeline to the girls section, loved all the sparkly, colourful things. He would tell me he was jealous that girls clothes were cooler. He always loved costume jewelry section pouring over all the baubles.
Now he’s 14, pure ‘boy’ into sports and girls.
Let the kids be themselves but at this age why label these preferences and make them feel so permanent?
this child, edie, is a girl
How is this allowed to happen, it's abuse
It’s relieving to see that people are not condoning this. Grooming at its worst. Bless this kid, who knows what he’ll be in for.
she'll *
this child, edie, is a girl, her parents are not grooming HER
@ManiacHERE-td2pj it’s not it’s just what uneducated people call it and it’s wrong hurtful and annoying
This is pure evil
Poor child. He is already traumatized and it's just the beginning of his life. Parents need to sort their heads really.
Something in your soul has to tell you this is wrong Anna 😢 this poor child!!
It seems like his parents are grooming him to be a transgender. Sheesh
this child, edie, is a girl
This is hugely concerning. This has undoubtedly been encouraged most likely to ensure the family appear more relevant.
Shame on the money grabbing parents.
They’ve been on RUclips for over a decade…
@@danamoore5118 And?
The sad part is this "mother" has it all on the internet for the world to see. He is a child and doesn't understand what that means until he is older and realizes how foolish his parents are. Truly heartbreaking.
Let your child hit 18 to make a life changing decisions.
In my opinion,the 'change' here happened when Eduardo/Edie received so much more attention from around once he/she started wearing dresses. He was lacking attention and found a way to get it.
I think the exact same thing.
Sadly not just lacking attention at school and at home. Dad is non binary and the children that are girls are favored. So it is happening at home.
@@hjcip3934 I think the fact the dad is nonbinary kind of proves my theory of him believing in strict gender stereotypes
this child, edie, is a girl
Went through male puberty as a trans-person, was absolutely horrible. Lost my female voice and now I have to mourn the loss of the potential to develop a female bone structure for the rest of my life.
Hope this kid gets the healthcare she needs to go through the female puberty she needs to thrive like I wish I could've. Don't wish what I went through on my worst enemy let alone this child
This child is too young to even know
I knew this was coming. I don't think a 6 year old has the capacity to understand sexuality.
Your mind doesn't fully develop until 25 and yourself personality isnt fully established until 18, some slightly later. So a 6 year old in my eyes, can't make such a huge life changing decision. And if they can and are allowed, they should be able to choose to drink, go to the club, or buy cigarettes at that age too.
This is gender, as in male or female (& some people think none binary.) Sexuality is straight, gay, lesbian, bisexual (&some people think pansexual.)
@@NotAnotherKuromi Yeah there is only 2 genders. Nonbinary was created off gender stereotypes for example if someone likes both masc and fem things or if they like neither
The frontal lobe of the brain which dictates good decision making and good judgement happens after the age of 21, these questions you are asking Eddie is for a more mature person and adult
25
25 and even longer in many boys
Omg I couldn’t agree more with this comment! X
25 in boys
The correct word is "are".
"..questions you are asking Edie ARE for a blahblah. Question- when does the frontal lobe understand run on sentences and basic grammar?
Been watching you guys for almost a decade. I’ve stayed silent on this every time I’ve seen content posted about it. God doesn’t make mistakes. This is down to the parents. Let your child grow up. Then when he is old enough, let him figure it out. Chances are years from now, you will all live with a lot of regret.
I don't believe in God. But let's say God is real...how do you justify the line that "God doesn't make mistakes" when children are born with horrible genetic abnormalities, develop childhood leukemia, are born with damaged hearts and die as infants, are born with osteogenesis imperfecta and have their bones break into shards when birthed and enter this world in horrible pain, and on and on and on?
Given the number of suffering children, many born with horrible conditions...I would assert that if there is a God, it is a sadistic, evil asshole. There is absolutely nothing remotely good about God of God is real.
This poor kid, they should have had this conversation after they were 18. I don’t know how they havnt taken the kid away, they should be ashamed. Gods kids are not for sale or to be experimented on.
*By the time society does nothing about this sickness, our children are exposed to this sickness.*
this child, edie, is a girl
When I was a child, I grew up with mostly boys. I liked their toys, wore baggy clothes and watched sci Fi movies. I didn't like girly things because girls were mean to me. I was a girl who liked guy things but that never made me a guy. That's so stupid. As I got older, I enjoyed makeup, dresses and overcame things. But this needs to stop.
This is my daughter now! She’s 7 . She loves all “boy things” not once did I question her identity . She enjoys playing with trucks , wearing super hero clothes BUT still knows she’s a girl because I did not manipulate her.
I feel so sad for this poor innocent child. When he goes thru puberty he is going to be so confused . I know this isn’t my child BUT as a mother I cannot imagine putting my own child thru this . Children are curious and innocent.
when we were children (I am assuming based on your comment you're not a child still) being trans was NOT safe. unpack it. this is this Childs way of expressing themselves right now. the parents are LISTENING to their child. this is OK.
@@lemonita347 That still doesn't make it ok. They shouldn't be taught this while their brains are still developing. It causes confusion. Men identifying as women are also causing other problems all together. Anyone can say it now, and not be questioned. They can still impregnate women in jails and beat them in sports because they're built stronger. Some things need their own space and a limit to how far they should go. People like Dylan Mulvany are becoming the face of Ulta Beauty and Tampax and we are resorting to being called "chest feeders" and "birthing people" all because of men wanting to be us. It's not ok.
@@lemonita347 Also.. them expressing themselves that way doesn't make them the opposite gender. What if my mother told me I was a boy because I liked Legos and I grew up chopping off my boobs and taking testosterone? I can't imagine.
There was this thing when I was growing up, being a "tomboy" that was/ me. I hate girly things and am born a girl. But I am still going to be a female. Why isn't that still ok?
This exposing and explosion of your child is so disgusting! These people should be in jail!
Yes, thank you 💯💔
Narcissistic parenting at its finest
I’m so glad these comments aren’t supportive. I’m sick of people supporting this. It’s so sad..
Prayers for this family. There is a heavy judgment on adults who willfully lead kids astray.
Dear future, adult Edie. I'm so sorry you had to live this childhood, and that you were finally able to escape the abuse. Best of luck to you in the future, Sir.
Her shirt should say PROTECT MY WALLET.
Disgusting, vile people. This is child abuse.
i feel sooo sooo sorry for this boy.. why are parents pushing this just for fame and clicks... very very sad to see.. just let him have his childhood and when hes grown he can understand and decide byhimself!!!!
this child, edie, is a girl
What on earth will they do when puberty hits?? This is a disaster 😢
At her age I would look up how to fly and spend half my day trying to figure out how
They use this poor child just for fame! Shame on you parents! I don’t understand why RUclips proposes me that channel. I’m not agree with all that F… stuff !!!!
Trans person speaking here. I'm pretty sure that liking "girly" things and not liking sports that doesn't necssicarily mean their trans or a girl they just don't like sports and want to wear dresses and play with dolls and in my opinion I think its best to wait until Edie is a bit older cause some kids grow out of it some kids dont. And I'm not saying Edie isn't truly trans I'm just saying maybe give Edie some time for her to figure out if she just likes girly things or is trans before saying she's actually trans.
If your kid ever comes to you saying he's a lamp, would you change his name to Ikea ?
I mean… my three year old tells me multiple times a day she IS a boy…she just wants to do the things her brother does and in her little mind that’s what that means…. Transitioning children so young is the parent’s decision not the child’s. That’s scary for these kids
Right??!! Same with my daughter. These people are sickening!
I used to tell my mom I wished I was a boy & refused everything girly. What she didn't know is that my brother, who is 5 years older than me, used to bully me & tell me I should have been a boy. He used to make me play football in the yard & he was weirdly into shadowboxing in the mirror with me. It just made me feel bad about being a girl. I was only trying to make my brother happy. That's all.
@@inactiveaccount6106 first and foremost I’m sorry your older brother made you feel like you weren’t good enough just as you are. Secondly I totally understand… there are SO many factors that make little girls or boys wish to be more “girly or boyish”! In my opinion this little boy is a lot like my daughter he has an older sister that he’s pretty close to in age and in his juvenile brain he just wanted to be just like his big sister ( just like my daughter wanting to be the same as her big brother) it’s normal for younger siblings. These parents took something completely innocent most kids do and took it to a harmful extreme…. I only pray his own parents haven’t destroyed his mental health and don’t take it any further to destroy his physical health as well 💔
I totally agree! My almost 3yo barely understands the proper use of "her" and "him". He refers to his sister as him, and his Papa as a her, and then switches it the next time. And the dog is both pronouns to a toddler! If she's saying this child knew from when he was a baby??? There's something wrong there.
Ooooh whee I’m glad I wasn’t raised by narcissistic people. I could’ve been a man by now the number of fights with boys I got into 😂
Thank God the people in the comments have some sense
Let the child be a child. If he wants to transition as an adult, fine. But this is a child. I told people to call me Max as a child. I don't know why I did it. But I grew out of it.
Attention seekers using their children in this way is horrible!!!
I’m sorry but this child abuse to me!!! To each their own but this is a LEGIT CHILD & this whole lgbtq stuff has gotten WAY out of hand….I don’t ever want this page to show up to me again
This is so wrong in so many ways. His mom is treating him like an adult and not like he's her child. This boy is a boy and he doesn't even know how to talk how much more to know his gender and whether he wants to be a girl. He doesn't even remember doing the things his mom says about him wearing dresses and drawings and things like that. That scares me. God help us
if Edie doesn't like answering certain questions ehy are you still pushing for her to answer them and/or answering them for her. Edie's opinion about herself and her life and choices deserves to be respected by everyone ESPECIALLY her parents.
I remember watching you guys when you were pregnant with your first child. It’s so sad what’s happened to you, this is sick! Child sacrifice 💔😭
Yep!! Satanic demonic sacrifice of their first born SON for fame!!!! HOW SICK!!!👿🤮
So true.
I used to watch this family when Emilia was born... I watched Emilia learn to crawl and walk and talk...
I can't stand to see what they have become ... Now Jonathan thinks that he is a non-binary non-gendered thing, and they encourage their little boy to be a girl.
I dont watch them anymore, unless a video like this pops up on my youtube's home page.
Children can’t even begin to fathom the complexity of this. Any GOOD therapist would have said leave him alone. Most children with gender dysphoria will end up simply being gay or gender non-conforming. Y’all are going to really go out on that limb and sacrifice this child for views.
I am so angry that you're confusing the F out of this poor child. It is so *clear* this kid has no idea WTF he wants bc his _parents_ are confusing the f out of him.. he doesn't even understand any of this and it is your job as a parent to guide them and not let them take the lead because they have no idea WTF to do without guidance
You can’t tell me that there wasn’t influence involved. Kids are literally sponges 🧽. If your boy wants to wear dresses, let them but a kid at that age has absolutely no ability to truly understand what trans means, and I’m so tired of people labeling themselves trans without actually transitioning. I’m also fucking tired of parents exposing their kids for money and fame online, just gross.
This is absolutely disgraceful. I’m not sure if the family wants attention and to feel like they are “bringing awareness” BUT this is wayyyyy tooo young! Almost as bad as parents letting their child shit in a litter box and identify as an animal! You are grooming your child. Sorry…NOT sorry.
I hope this kid gets out of this phase before y’all chemically castrate them and there’s irreversible damage
So sad and very disgusting what is wrong with this mother this child doesn’t know what it wants Omai gosh what are we doing to this younger generation I blame the mother she’s a very terrible parent
That’s disgusting! He’s not even sure if he’s going to change at adult age. You are just ruining and already ruined his life. Sad .. very very sad
i’m always curious how a baby knows they are trans? My nephew is 2 and he has no idea about his gender
They don't
They don't know... until they grow up as disturbed people who have a hard time accepting their gender because of some kind of trauma...
The parents pushed it on him
Wtf is happening in the west??? How is this seen as acceptable and allowed / normalised and celebrated? ? This is peak degradation of society.
Because they dont know, theyre being indoctrinated and taught these things, and the adults are teaching this stuff for their own gain and benefit, all they want is clout and attention
This is child exploitation...so disturbing watching this
Child isn't mature enough to understand these questions fully. He equates being s girl with long hair and dresses and doesn't understand
My 7 year old daughter likes superheroes and short hair but that doesn't mean she's a boy. Child has been fed this narrative and lie
Yip
@@Maceymayjunejuly yup
I'm so happy to see people in the comments section are not condoning this.
It’s insane to me that parents are actually thinking they are doing the kids a favor and being supportive when in reality your completely failing them. You need to be his clear thinking because he’s so young and doesn’t understand. I don’t see how your proud of yourself
wow this is messed up. This is what happens when you follow trends and lack education.