It really annoys me that no one can see past the sexy look, choreography and video to actually appreciate the song. You won't watch the MV or see the dance on your phone while on the bus to work or school, you're going to be listening to the song. That's what matters most and what should be recognized the most! The song is a complete jam and should be so much higher on the charts! I don't understand the mindset of most K-fans -_- ALSO! Cheer for every group! In a country that prides itself on being polite - they surely don't know how to respect idols.
Me too, I liked so much what he said, I only have Kpop in mp3, my fav kpop group is Secret :V, Madonna, Love is Move, Magic, Poison, Shy Boy, Yoohoo, etc, etc.
I agree but they weren't super comfortable with the song, they just needed to eat :/ So I wish they could've done the song with different choreography cause what they ended up with was purely exploitative. But the song is a fucking JAM and if they were managed by a better company I think this could've been the real comeback if it had toned it down a little bit (I think the backwards butt movement is cute, and it's all iconic now, but if we could go back in time? I'd want it changed, for their sake).
Rawan ah It had nothing to do with that. The audience was basically one fan club that only reacted to their fav group. Almost all of the other groups that day got the same treatment.
@@hunnibunnii7782 For any TWINKLES Out there, we have a discord server that you all can Join to talk and chat with. The server is dedicated to the Group Stellar with Pictures information and updates!! Come have fun with our community!!! Respond do this comment if u want the link!
Knetz fans are the worst.Can't you just enjoy everybody performances and show supports. It's so rude.I'm not even Stellar's fan, but that's a good live.
@i love you say it back please watch miss back!! gayoung is a cast member and she shared her experience while they were promoting this. it will really make you angry to their management
Maybe it's an American thing idk, but Americans will usually cheer for ANY artists that come on stage, even those they don't know. It's awfully rude I'd say to just stand there and not acknowledged an act right before them..
All I can say is... if I was there I'd be screaming at the top of my lungs for this group and this perf. This song is amazing. Wish there was better camera work doe...
I really dont understand why the audience isnt applause or scream.. this is ont fair. Stellar it's really a good Girlgroup. Same if its sexy concept or each other. ♡
I usually hate girl groups that go over the top with sexy concepts but stellar is the only girl group that does the sexy thing with that spark and you can clearly see how they actually dont mind even though they expose themselves to hate because of the ir concept. I LOVE THESE GIRLS!! ^^ now i need a fancam that will make them skyrocket thwir status into stardom ^^
There is a fancam of Minhee that has almost 14 million views (on Facebook)... Sad that they aren't more popular than they deserve... ;-; I'm still waiting haha their songs are great, really, and their vocals aren't half bad... :/
oberdamujigae Exactly! It's got more than 4 times the views the Mask MV has (the fancam is Minhee during their Mask promotions)... I'm seriously surprised that they aren't more known given the views on that fancam...
yea, that song should've changed the kpop game and put stellar on the map as one of the hottest girl groups. instead, people dismissed it and ignored them. What a shame. By far one of the most underappreciated groups in kpop.
The girls were amazing and the song is a jam but I think the crowd shouldn't be quiet...it was awkward. I'm very happy because the girls performed amazingly even if the crowd was quiet. #rude :(
this is why some kpop fans annoy me. ok, i get it, u dont really listen to this group and you're not familiar with them. ok! just try to have some respect and support them! these girls seem really cute and talented, they could make it big if they had better choreography and a catchier song... but srsly tho im not pointing fingers but just cause a particular group has visuals u like or a couple of hit songs, doesnt mean they deserve any more respect than others. put urself in their shoes and see what its like to train like crazy to end up with this... like how snsd first started and received hate, i hope this group shows us what they can really do in the future... cased closed xD
cddlyxx julie I have a feeling korean fans are really rude to groups they don't stan, especially during music shows. If this were in the states, I think everybody would be singing along if we knew the song
cddlyxx julie Seriously I'm not familiar with this group but the song itself is really cathchy and really really good. If you don't pay so much attention to the sexy concept and stuff you can clearly hear that the song is really really good, better than some of big group's hit summer song
I read something about it. The Tickets for music shows will be bought by the companies. The companies will give it to their Fanclubs. You are in a Fanclub. It will be chosen, if you can go to music shows. Than you are a lucky one. Rule of the Fanclub: Cheer for your Band! If you suddenly cheer for other artists or sing along, it will be a bad reputation. Simple rule: Cheer only for the Band of your Fanclub! If not or you cheer for somebody else: It can happen, you are not in the Fanclub anymore. And The consequence: You can't go to shows anymore.
In this group, you won't be able to pick a bias. They're all visually amazing, vocally talented, and wonderful in dancing. They're so underrated tho :(
Luna Xo i think they are talking about fame wise, Exid blew up after a fancam of hani, but stellar didn't get much fame... 2 members left and I think their disbanding
It's actually true. If you read the Allkpop post that they posted recently about Stellar, it actually talks about them getting interviewed and their responses to the sexy concepts. They would get look down by another famous girl group even though they've debuted and stuff. I feel extremely sorry for them.
Omg, I'm REALLY in love with this song, the beat, the choreography, the girls, I think everything is perfect, hope they have more attention 'cause they deserve it.
You can't blame the audience for being dead. If Stellar isn't their bias group then why would they force themselves to cheer for someone they don't know or not fan of? Even tho Stellar needs recognition for their hardwork, you can't just force someone to like them.
I know Mnet is a cable TV channel but I am still surprised that Stellar didn't have to change their choreo...esp. the humping part. honestly, I think this is a great song but their marketing strategy just taints the whole group.
It's a shame that their sexiness kinda overshadows their song/performance. This is one of my favorite summer comebacks this year, and they all seem to be really talented.
I just realized that Stellar experienced the Black Ocean and it saddens me because they did their best but didnt get the recognition or the awards that they deserve, gosh i've watched this a multiple times but I dang. Korean fans are the worst
Just so everyone knows...the audience was not dead and they did applaud. The video ends a bit too early so we dont get the applaud but you can hear some people beginning to scream at the very end lol
Its usually impolite to cheer loudly during performances in asia, unless fanchants of course, and sometimes if its an outside arena. They were just waiting for the song to finish before cheering :)
At least the song is actually good. The dance is not my favorite but they are trying. Mask was my favorite song and dance of this girl group. Good work!! fighting!
lets be honest, dead crowd is better than loud and rude crowd. At least when the crowd is quiet , they can actually learn to listen and focus on them :>
Para todos los que critican, sepan que una de las integrantes confesó que a ellas las obligaron a enseñar y bailar así, ya que su concepto desde el principio era lindo y las obligaron por medio de su contrato a cambiarlo a sexy
This is why I hate the audience in shows like this, even if they dislike the group they should at least show a little bit of respect. Stellar puts as much effort in their presentation as Girls Generation.
![스텔라 (Stellar) - 떨려요 (Vibrato) 교차편집 / Stage_Mix [2K/60fps]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pwoAc9pmAlo/mqdefault.jpg)
![스텔라 (Stellar) - 떨려요 (Vibrato) 교차편집 / Stage_Mix [2K/60fps]](/img/tr.png)
![[SISTAR - I Like That] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 160623 EP.480](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/g_etUUuipAs/mqdefault.jpg)
even if you don't like their dance or outfits, you gotta admit the song is pretty damn good
pretty damn good is an understatement. This song is iconic.
yeah the song is great
+Andrew Kordyban Ikr the song is very catchy and nice to listen to...it should bring fame some how?
so true.. their song very good... best3!!
nobuko if they put some effort in their dance instead being in a porn site, they would be awesome
I'm really surprised that MCountdown let them dance the original choreography. Kudos Mnet!
That isn't the original choreo, I don't see certain parts from the MV Which is good
Uhm... M!Countdown always let the original dance to be done, it's a program that goes to the world audience... Liberalists
KBS is the strict one.
***** but they also banned choreo, which is what I'm talking about.
Arren Hidalgo If Jay Park can performance in the Mnet Show called "Show me the money", then Stellar can performance this without problems...
I expected screams and fan chants but instead the audience area is dead silent like as though they were not there.
It sounded like they muted the audience
it's like they were singing for the cameras, not the audiences. that's so sad, for sure.
they`re lipsyncing
@@sanhamori4619 It's called singing with backtrack definitely different from lipsync
Choi Yena Is Talented haha za tiim bh
It really annoys me that no one can see past the sexy look, choreography and video to actually appreciate the song. You won't watch the MV or see the dance on your phone while on the bus to work or school, you're going to be listening to the song. That's what matters most and what should be recognized the most! The song is a complete jam and should be so much higher on the charts! I don't understand the mindset of most K-fans -_- ALSO! Cheer for every group! In a country that prides itself on being polite - they surely don't know how to respect idols.
Omg I wanna like this comment 100 times.
Me too, I liked so much what he said, I only have Kpop in mp3, my fav kpop group is Secret :V, Madonna, Love is Move, Magic, Poison, Shy Boy, Yoohoo, etc, etc.
+IfIWereABoyWhichIAm Yes!! The song is so good! it is the first song ever in my playlist that was repeated (i listened to it like 5 times in a row)
IfIWereABoyWhichIAm i actually like the lyrics and its catchy af.
plus the choreo and the outfits are not that sexual.
I agree but they weren't super comfortable with the song, they just needed to eat :/ So I wish they could've done the song with different choreography cause what they ended up with was purely exploitative.
But the song is a fucking JAM and if they were managed by a better company I think this could've been the real comeback if it had toned it down a little bit (I think the backwards butt movement is cute, and it's all iconic now, but if we could go back in time? I'd want it changed, for their sake).
Stellar is a masterpiece! Hope the members are now free and step up on stage again as who they want to be now 😊
The crowd should scream for every other artist not only their bias group. I dont understand its so annoying.
***** they do
but they didnt like their dance
Rawan ah It had nothing to do with that. The audience was basically one fan club that only reacted to their fav group. Almost all of the other groups that day got the same treatment.
+Binjuice77 I have seen some concerts usually on the groups from big company would have scream but nothing with other groups like Stellar
Depend on if ppl is kind or not, but Yh sones almost took over the audience
i think they did in the end of performance but it was cutted
does this crowd realise they are watching the song of the year performed by the godesses stellar, wtf are they doing
i thought they didn't know how amazin this song is, really really hate K-nets, they underestimated about stellar,
Sexy concepts for mostly girl groups were frowned upon and seen as a bad thing back then😔
@@hunnibunnii7782 For any TWINKLES Out there, we have a discord server that you all can Join to talk and chat with. The server is dedicated to the Group Stellar with Pictures information and updates!! Come have fun with our community!!! Respond do this comment if u want the link!
@@sanasshoebox7962 Would you please send me the link?
Fr the black ocean is real
That stage looks so grand. Look at the size of the auditorium!
I thought there is a hair on my screen...
GillianandCharlene Lmao same
i hate you lmao i thought there was a hair on my screen
I thought there was a hair on my screen
I scrached my screen! thinking there was a hair... lol
This song is actually good
Knetz fans are the worst.Can't you just enjoy everybody performances and show supports. It's so rude.I'm not even Stellar's fan, but that's a good live.
Stellar unfortunately ran out, and was one of the best bands I've ever seen. Throwing the truth in the face of Korea !! Kiss's
@i love you say it back please watch miss back!! gayoung is a cast member and she shared her experience while they were promoting this. it will really make you angry to their management
the crowd shouldn't be so quiet. at least have some reaction please.
Dead crowd. So disrespectful
Noam G i'm guessing they're busy wiping their noses ... man if i were i think i'd be like that to .. i love these ladies
Noam G On the Show that got much love. Mnet is all fan girls. Seems like they only cheer for boy groups or top 5 groups
Korean audience is always like this.So sad
Emily Muzi LOL >_< dear keyboard master.. have you been with korea audience before? NO
+the lovm♡nsta they cut the part where the fanchant was watch it in other kpop channels
damn i want to be in that crowd screaming even if i'm on my own,, this seems mean :( or rude
posumy I would scream with you too bruh
Same
Same like at least clap
same, i'd scream and clap, even if i'd be a little bit shameless
though the crowd seems like they're all poker-faced, you can't deny that Stellar's freakin' gorgeous and amazing here
Stellar performs sexy concept: ...
Nine Muses performs sexy concept: Uh...
SNSD/AOA performs sexy concept: *screams*
#SaveStellarVagina
😂😂😂
So true
Aoa yes. Snsd never
Snsd? You are crazy
snsd dont have many sexy concept
Maybe it's an American thing idk, but Americans will usually cheer for ANY artists that come on stage, even those they don't know. It's awfully rude I'd say to just stand there and not acknowledged an act right before them..
Culture does things differently everywhere so why do Americans think what they do is the only right way lol make me laugh
@@tripper9642 Well, in the world of live entertainment, the American way is how it SHOULD be done.
OMG I WANNA CRY ITS SO QUIET THAT IT FEELS SO DISHEARTENING :(... I WANT TO BE THERE SCREAMING FOR STELLAR!!
they suffered a lot but this song is so good damn they are so talented
They deserved better than that trash company 😭😭💔💔💔
The bridge is so good.
I hate this crowd
I love this song.. and i miss stellar😢❤
All I can say is... if I was there I'd be screaming at the top of my lungs for this group and this perf. This song is amazing. Wish there was better camera work doe...
I really dont understand why the audience isnt applause or scream.. this is ont fair. Stellar it's really a good Girlgroup. Same if its sexy concept or each other. ♡
Jeonyul didn’t look uncomfortable at all. She owned this era with her confidence.
I love these live performances better than the videos.
What a pleasant crowd… .
I usually hate girl groups that go over the top with sexy concepts but stellar is the only girl group that does the sexy thing with that spark and you can clearly see how they actually dont mind even though they expose themselves to hate because of the ir concept. I LOVE THESE GIRLS!! ^^ now i need a fancam that will make them skyrocket thwir status into stardom ^^
There is a fancam of Minhee that has almost 14 million views (on Facebook)... Sad that they aren't more popular than they deserve... ;-; I'm still waiting haha their songs are great, really, and their vocals aren't half bad... :/
DarkTemplar8952 holy that's a lot 0.0 really wishing they get the boom like EXID they totally deserves the fame :'(
oberdamujigae Exactly! It's got more than 4 times the views the Mask MV has (the fancam is Minhee during their Mask promotions)... I'm seriously surprised that they aren't more known given the views on that fancam...
Same af
So... no one is gonna address the fact that this trashcan hates girls only because of sexy concepts, or...?
They actually cheered in the end... There was this other video (same video but longer where it got to the mc part) where they cheered for stellar 👏🏻
yea, that song should've changed the kpop game and put stellar on the map as one of the hottest girl groups. instead, people dismissed it and ignored them. What a shame. By far one of the most underappreciated groups in kpop.
The girl with orange hair reminds me kf Nayoung from i.o.i.
If a group is not from a large-scale agency, it's hard to gain attention even if the song and concept are great.
THIS WAS THE STELLAR'S STAGE I WAS WAITING FOR ♥
STELLAR FIGHTING!
The girls were amazing and the song is a jam but I think the crowd shouldn't be quiet...it was awkward. I'm very happy because the girls performed amazingly even if the crowd was quiet. #rude :(
That amazing instrumental, amazing voices... I love this song
this is why some kpop fans annoy me. ok, i get it, u dont really listen to this group and you're not familiar with them. ok! just try to have some respect and support them! these girls seem really cute and talented, they could make it big if they had better choreography and a catchier song... but srsly tho im not pointing fingers but just cause a particular group has visuals u like or a couple of hit songs, doesnt mean they deserve any more respect than others. put urself in their shoes and see what its like to train like crazy to end up with this... like how snsd first started and received hate, i hope this group shows us what they can really do in the future... cased closed xD
cddlyxx julie I have a feeling korean fans are really rude to groups they don't stan, especially during music shows. If this were in the states, I think everybody would be singing along if we knew the song
Well nobody said kpop fans don't respect them.
cddlyxx julie Seriously I'm not familiar with this group but the song itself is really cathchy and really really good. If you don't pay so much attention to the sexy concept and stuff you can clearly hear that the song is really really good, better than some of big group's hit summer song
Preach
I read something about it. The Tickets for music shows will be bought by the companies. The companies will give it to their Fanclubs. You are in a Fanclub. It will be chosen, if you can go to music shows. Than you are a lucky one. Rule of the Fanclub: Cheer for your Band! If you suddenly cheer for other artists or sing along, it will be a bad reputation. Simple rule: Cheer only for the Band of your Fanclub! If not or you cheer for somebody else: It can happen, you are not in the Fanclub anymore. And The consequence: You can't go to shows anymore.
2024, anyone?
In this group, you won't be able to pick a bias. They're all visually amazing, vocally talented, and wonderful in dancing. They're so underrated tho :(
The Main vocalist should get on Immortal song or Masked Singer
Came backhere after i watched Gayoung in "Miss Back". I reslly want tohug these girls.
i hope they ended like AOA or EXID 😭😢
Me too😭😭😭
Eros Hyun watching them yeah i do feel kinda AOA vibe
1 year update they didn't two members left and they replaced them lmao
I don't think EXID disbanded? Solji has a disease and can't perform or sing in their songs I think.
Luna Xo i think they are talking about fame wise, Exid blew up after a fancam of hani, but stellar didn't get much fame... 2 members left and I think their disbanding
if any other agency could bring back stellar..it would be good...they really are talented...but they stuck in the wrong agency before...i love stellar
Not me tipping "vibrato kpop" waiting for vocal analysis and I ended up here LOL🗣️
They sing so beautifully . If they were given proper chances they would've been so successful
Stellar's songs are so catchy everything of it but the choreography (naaahhhhh) they are not toys
I hope they will comback like Brave Girls
THEY so talents (Vocals, good physical appearance, dance ...)
Why they are not famous
I don't think,many members were traumatized…If you don't know about their story, find it.
poor stellar... they deserved a much better company
i miss stellar so much
I'm REALLY surprised that they all get pretty much the same amount of lines each! I'm shocked!
Sad to see such a talented group disappear from the industry. Screw the haters
Vibrato was one of the best song of that year.
Indeed，they don't want to have a sexy concept. They said they even never went to a club before. But sexy concept is the only way they gain attention.
It's actually true. If you read the Allkpop post that they posted recently about Stellar, it actually talks about them getting interviewed and their responses to the sexy concepts. They would get look down by another famous girl group even though they've debuted and stuff. I feel extremely sorry for them.
Omg, I'm REALLY in love with this song, the beat, the choreography, the girls, I think everything is perfect, hope they have more attention 'cause they deserve it.
In 2019, having this kind of outfits and dance are fine with Knetz.
Yesss I felt bad for stella , they're in a wrong generation :((
song goes hard
You can't blame the audience for being dead. If Stellar isn't their bias group then why would they force themselves to cheer for someone they don't know or not fan of?
Even tho Stellar needs recognition for their hardwork, you can't just force someone to like them.
By respect even if you don't like a group you cheer them for their hardwork
Stellar is a group of talented fearless sexy bad ass women!
People who hates on them are hypocrites!
Rock on girls!
I know Mnet is a cable TV channel but I am still surprised that Stellar didn't have to change their choreo...esp. the humping part.
honestly, I think this is a great song but their marketing strategy just taints the whole group.
They had a few innocent comebacks but nobody took notice of them, that's why they keep going back to sexy concepts
I think they should do a really emotional song to display their vocals. They sing better than many other groups, and harmonize well together...
... WHERE ARE THE FELLOW TWINKLES THAT WERE IN MTV THE SHOW!? D:
IKR THE CROWD IS SOO DEAD HERE
I love stellar
This is definitely one of those good but underrated songs
I miss them ♥️
I am back after watching Miss Back! POOR STELLAR...FUCKING DAMN AGENCY
their proportion was amazing
They said they were embarrased to perform sexy concepts, because their company forced them to chose sexy concepts.
Officially a new fan with this song, Hyoeun has become my bias!
I rarely ever become fans of the new generation groups. I like the older groups.
I miss them...they can give good entertainment and new trends in dancing.... how i wish their agency just treated them right...STELLAR FIGHTING!!!
It's a shame that their sexiness kinda overshadows their song/performance. This is one of my favorite summer comebacks this year, and they all seem to be really talented.
They r getting better & better every comeback. Stellar fighting!!!!!
We need a comeback we miss you even if it’s 0t3
I just realized that Stellar experienced the Black Ocean and it saddens me because they did their best but didnt get the recognition or the awards that they deserve, gosh i've watched this a multiple times but I dang. Korean fans are the worst
iconic stage
i feel like the screams were muted cuz at times u can hear them but they’re very faint
hey the song is pretty good
I really like this song...I hope Stellar gets more love at music program performances.
That’s exactly five years ago today
Oh! So perfect. Stellar is one of the groups that I really support.
it's okay stellar! you're more fabulous and hotter than those dead rude crowd!
Such a large crowd! Hopefully they become interested in STELLAR
I must admit, Stellar is a visual group. MinHee is a killer.
Just so everyone knows...the audience was not dead and they did applaud. The video ends a bit too early so we dont get the applaud but you can hear some people beginning to scream at the very end lol
Its usually impolite to cheer loudly during performances in asia, unless fanchants of course, and sometimes if its an outside arena. They were just waiting for the song to finish before cheering :)
stellar is a great girlgroup but all of you keep hating the girls bc the concept!! grow up please
i love stellar. girls deserve much more recognition. fangirl is here))))))))they cheer up!
At least the song is actually good. The dance is not my favorite but they are trying. Mask was my favorite song and dance of this girl group. Good work!! fighting!
some of those kpop fans are really annoying. sexy is their concept, they are just doing it.
hyoeun is the prettiest ♥️
lets be honest, dead crowd is better than loud and rude crowd. At least when the crowd is quiet , they can actually learn to listen and focus on them :>
This song is such a fucking jam it's an absolute shame how exploited these girls were :( I like the dance but i'm sad the girls didn't.
Para todos los que critican, sepan que una de las integrantes confesó que a ellas las obligaron a enseñar y bailar así, ya que su concepto desde el principio era lindo y las obligaron por medio de su contrato a cambiarlo a sexy
Talent has nothing to do with years of experience 😪😌 Keep doing you Stellar
Miss stellar 😭😭
Stellar 's new song vibrato.
I bet i’m the only one coming in 2024
if only i was there i'd scream more than i could to cheer them up...
U SLAY IT WITH UR HAIR FLIP GIRL
こんなにかっこいいサウンドでも１位になれないんですか？ ちゃんと音楽を聴きましょう。 この曲の１小節目の１拍目はどこですか？
This is why I hate the audience in shows like this, even if they dislike the group they should at least show a little bit of respect. Stellar puts as much effort in their presentation as Girls Generation.
GREAT Song, get it together fans
I guess everyone is stunning so they are quite.