Mr. Giant Reacts to Proto-Indo-European Origins | DNA

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 49

  • @binxbolling
    @binxbolling Год назад +3

    Fun fact: Avocados are theorized to have evolved alongside giant ground sloths, the only nearby animal big enough to pass the enormous seeds through their digestive system.

  • @jonathonfrazier6622
    @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад +11

    They have done Africa. You are right, it starts with the Bantu people. Initially a small iron capable culture who were agriculturalists. They quickly expanded some 6000 years ago to dominate much of Sub-Saharan Africa. Roughly during the same time period the Proto Indo Europeans were moving in on Europe.

    • @jonathonfrazier6622
      @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад

      @FIGHTFAN777 As I recall from Jared Diamond's Guns, Germs and Steel, it was 6000 years ago.

    • @ario2264
      @ario2264 5 месяцев назад

      The Indo-European migrations were 2-3 thousand years earlier.

  • @S.J.L
    @S.J.L Год назад +5

    The Bantu and Indo Europeans are certainly parallel cultures in their vast constinental spread due to technology, geography and culture. Seeing these parralels can build bridges now and beyond.

  • @nahumhabte6210
    @nahumhabte6210 Год назад +8

    genteics is uncovering the ancient past. Its going to be interesting to see what more we can learn in the future

  • @LastEuropaKiss
    @LastEuropaKiss 5 месяцев назад +1

    For the spread of Indo-European languages being after Yamnaya expansion west I think is explained by it being Corded Ware who spread their language east. So the Yamnaya moved further into Europe and became Corded Ware, some of whom moved back to the east and into Asia becoming Sintashta and Andronovo etc, who then went into India.
    They were a violent people and very warlike, so it wasn't so much a migration, as an invasion wherever they went. For example, the Bell Beakers of the Netherlands, who were descendants of the Indo-Europeans, replaced ~95% of the former population of Britain within a few generations of when they arrived. Modern Britons are the descendants of these Bell Beakers. (Though the English have Anglo-Saxon genetics too [who are the descendants of the Bell Beakers who stayed in the Netherlands]). There may have been trade involved sometimes, and they did take local women, but the men were replaced. They did introduce caste systems in many places they settled. The "Ary*ns" are in fact descendants of Indo-Europeans who had moved into Central Asia (Around Northern Iran region). Likely descendants of the SIntashta culture, who's ancestors had moved from Europe and into Central Asia.

  • @Akdemx
    @Akdemx Год назад +6

    The Cucuteni-Trypillia culture, also known as the Cucuteni culture or the Tripolye culture, is a Neolithic-Chalcolithic archaeological culture (c. 5500 to 2750 BCE) of Eastern Europe. It extended from the Carpathian Mountains to the Dniester and Dnieper regions, centered on modern-day Moldova and covering substantial parts of western Ukraine and northeastern Romania, encompassing an area of 350,000 km2 (140,000 sq mi), with a diameter of 500 km (300 mi; roughly from Kyiv in the northeast to Brașov in the southwest).[1][2]
    The majority of Cucuteni-Trypillia settlements were of small size, high density (spaced 3 to 4 kilometres apart), concentrated mainly in the Siret, Prut and Dniester river valleys.[3] During its middle phase (c. 4000 to 3500 BCE), populations belonging to the Cucuteni-Trypillia culture built the largest settlements in Neolithic Europe, some of which contained as many as three thousand structures and were possibly inhabited by 20,000 to 46,000 people.[4][5][6]
    One of the most notable aspects of this culture was the periodic destruction of settlements, with each single-habitation site having a lifetime of roughly 60 to 80 years.[7] The purpose of burning these settlements is a subject of debate among scholars; some of the settlements were reconstructed several times on top of earlier habitational levels, preserving the shape and the orientation of the older buildings. One location, the Poduri site in Romania, revealed thirteen habitation levels that were constructed on top of each other over many years.[7]

    • @KaiHansen-sf1lq
      @KaiHansen-sf1lq Год назад

      This same culture resides also in Bulgaria and (at least) all the Eastern Balkans, is connected to the culture of the oldest gold treasure in the world of the Varna necropolis in Bulgaria.

  • @robertdavis100
    @robertdavis100 9 месяцев назад +1

    riding on horseback elevates obviously , aristocrats are still obsessed with equestrianism

  • @jonathonfrazier6622
    @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад +3

    What most people call an avocado, I call an alligator pear.

  • @andreamuller9009
    @andreamuller9009 11 месяцев назад +2

    The thing with the gold diggers can also happen the other way around... we have evidence that in many parts of Europe there was a more matriachal society, so the male warriors of the Yamnaya could also have kept an eye on the rich female landowners. If we look at the old Greek legends.... didn't anyone notice that Menelaus became the king of Sparta through marriage? Sparta is Helena's inheritance, not Menelaus's... no wonder he wanted her back so badly.😅... Priam's is exactly the same... Troy is Hecuba's inheritance.
    These were Achaeans who married into Mycenaean families.

  • @jonathonfrazier6622
    @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад +9

    Great video. I wish they touched on the Indo European language family. I recommend a video centered in on that. Did you know for instance that English, Greek, Iranian and many languages if India ( only to name a few) were far back in time a single language? This Proto Indo European you just heard about. Or that most of the great religions of antiquity were, being Indo European, also once one religion. The Viking God Tyr ( although Odin grabbed all his attributes and position at some point), Zeus of the Greeks and many others were once one god in the mind of the P.I.Es further back in time. If you read the Greek myth about Zeus ordering the world and ascending into kingship and then read the Norse account of Odin doing likewise you will be shocked, it's the same exact stories. Sometimes down to the minute details.

    • @MrGiant
      @MrGiant  Год назад +4

      Thank you for this information, I will have to do some reading up on this.

    • @jonathonfrazier6622
      @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад +2

      ​@@MrGiant Yeah. For instance here's a neat little fact you wouldn't expect : Irish and Sanskrit of India are both Indo European. And both are " conservative" languages. Meaning they both evolve and change at a slower pace than most other languages. Therefore both languages are remarkably similar. Even some words are the same or near so. And these similarities are evidently traits of the original P.I.E language. And that's how we reconstruct P.I.E. . W compare the different modern I.E. languages to find the similarities, to oversimplify it abit.

    • @LightLoveLaugh
      @LightLoveLaugh Год назад

      @@jonathonfrazier6622 check videos of : Jeffrey Armstrong to know more about this language. Also : abhijit chavda to know more about how ancient india is and ancient indian cultire and language influenced europe actually

  • @colinowen7730
    @colinowen7730 Год назад +2

    Nice one 👍

  • @binxbolling
    @binxbolling Год назад

    Individual family graves does not necessarily mean a caste system. That's a non-sequitur.

  • @jonathonfrazier6622
    @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад

    Hey its here! Great!

  • @pitch1691
    @pitch1691 Год назад +2

    React to the battle of Stalingrad 1942/1943 dramatic world war 2 combat footage by HCT

    • @MrGiant
      @MrGiant  Год назад +2

      Thank you I will

  • @jonathonfrazier6622
    @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад +7

    It's pretty widely accepted that the Kurgan hypothesis is the correct one. The Anatolian Farmer hypothesis is practically fringe now.

    • @KaiHansen-sf1lq
      @KaiHansen-sf1lq Год назад

      Actualy the combination of them, which leads us to the Black Sea-Balkan origins of ALL European civilization at least.

    • @KaiHansen-sf1lq
      @KaiHansen-sf1lq Год назад +1

      I meant...the combination is the most probable and logical acording to the evidence.

    • @jonathonfrazier6622
      @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад

      @@KaiHansen-sf1lq The unrelated farmers from Anatolia brought agriculture to Europe. But they are not part of the IndoEuropean world. Genetically or culturally. Which is the question.

    • @KaiHansen-sf1lq
      @KaiHansen-sf1lq Год назад +1

      I can tell you much more, but as a start just think about the Varna civ. and most ancient gold, the Deluge, the thracian mounds, the Thracian Horsman, the wheelchairs found in Thrace...

    • @KaiHansen-sf1lq
      @KaiHansen-sf1lq Год назад +1

      And all, as little as they are there, DNA traces show stable continuity...

  • @lindasteel4502
    @lindasteel4502 Год назад +3

    I always marvel at the British peoples when it comes to language. You can go a few miles up or down the road, and the accents are completely different, including words that don't exist in the way you might speak. I lived on the border of Birmingham and West Bromwich, and just those few miles felt as though you were entering a foreign land.

  • @Vladan.m
    @Vladan.m 4 месяца назад

    What lies so that it would not be known that the Balkans (HELM) was the place where the white race was born, which later spread first to the south and east, and then to the rest of Europe. Migrations were two-way, first from Zaoad to Isrik, and later the opposite.

  • @ioanmaftei6587
    @ioanmaftei6587 Год назад +1

    🙌🙌🙌🙌❤❤❤❤

  • @Declan_Moriarty
    @Declan_Moriarty Год назад +1

    appreciate the sentiment, but unfortunately saying "everyone is human" repeatedly doesn't mean or change anything, let alone any one person's mind. genetics are genetics are genetics

    • @MrGiant
      @MrGiant  Год назад

      ait can work, just like people saying over and over they are one religion or the next works.

  • @kevinprzy4539
    @kevinprzy4539 Год назад

    Nah, gold digging isn't a matter of survival it's the specific aim of marrying a rich man to be rich yourself that isn't survival it's indulgence imo and do you ever think of or study the indigenous people of the Caribbeans because I know Africans aren't native to the Caribbeans

    • @-_YouMayFind_-
      @-_YouMayFind_- 11 месяцев назад

      They don't know for certain why the woman did it. Maybe the first idea was to mix with men they didn't mix with yet. Woman tried to make sure to not inbreed.

  • @lindasteel4502
    @lindasteel4502 Год назад

    We are all mongrels!

  • @Dashuyan88
    @Dashuyan88 11 месяцев назад

    Proto indo european people or yamnaya people are not original europeans. Original europeans were western hunter gatherers who had dark skin and blue eyes. These were the first people to have blue eyes. Yamnaya LATER came and KILLED the males of these people and took the females and mixed. Yamnaya were not blond but they had the blond gene in them as yamnaya themselves were a mixed population of two groups, one of these groups had the gene for blond hair from which yamnaya got it. Later when yamnaya took over europe and took the females of original europeans who had dark skin and blue eyes, their phenotype started to change and you got blue eyed blond hair people
    If somebody today has both blue eyes and blond hair then he is a mixed race person as both of these traits come from two different populations

  • @saumensingh9482
    @saumensingh9482 Год назад +1

    👉All European, Mediterranean, C.Asian, G.steppe nations are founded by race of Bharath (Vedic/Arya). Kings, warriors of West, C.Asia, G.steppe are R1a1a/R1a1Y {Vedic warrior caste (Shatriyas)}, this marker didn't exist in steppe to Europe before 1k BCs. They've descended from CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas who've conquered G.steppe then Europe, China in the 1k BCs from India-Iran region when Vedics from India already conquered upto Anatolia (Mittani-Hatti-Hari) in 2k BCs. Greco-Roman descended from M-H-H Aryas, only Aryas can bring IE language, chariot, Mitra, thunder/sky God, astronomy, astrology, funerary cremation in Greece-Italy. Aryas in west have turned blonde/white breeding with white women (Celts R1bY Yamnyan, Veneds R1aY Sintashtan) like brown Jews have turned blonde. Aryas are brown skinned, dark haired/eyed (Check G-R, Irani, Saka, TochaArya, Kushan frescoes). Europe's Monarchies came 1300 years after Sakas monarchy of 700 BC., literature after 7th c CE. Greece-Italy Monarchies came 1000 years after M-H-H.
    Proven conquest of west by Aryas.👉In 2k BCs Mittani-Hatti-Hari conquered upto Anatolia.
    👉In 800 BCs CimmeArya, Saka conquered Balkan, Ukraine, Russia.
    👉In 500 BCs Parsha conquered Greece, Balkan.
    👉In 400 BCs. Sauromata, Alani conquered upto Ukraine, then to British Irish Isles, remember RgVedic Goddess Danu.
    👉 In 400 CEs one Alani branch conquered Spain raiding Greece, Italy.
    👉In 4th c. Hun conquered half of Europe descending from Tocha-Arya, Wushun."
    ++++++++
    👉Since 800 BCs white (Celts, Veneds) & C.Asian trib@ls are en$laved by Aryas (CimmeArya, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Roxolani, TochaArya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan).
    👉Whites are next en$laved by Roman descending from Mittani-Hatti-Hari Aryas.
    👉Next en$laved by Hun descending from Tocha-Arya, Wushun Aryas.
    👉Next en$laved by moors for 700 years, moor leaders are Irani Aryas.
    👉Again en$laved by Turk, Mongol. L0rds of Turk, Mongol tribals are Tocha-Arya, Xiangno, Wushun Aryas.
    👉Lords of Turk, Mongol, Avar, Khazar, Tatar trb@ls are Tocha-Arya, Kushan, Wushun, Xiangno, Khotan Aryas. Xiangno, Wushun, Kushan conquered China, Tibet. Shatriyas of eastern India conquered SE Asia, possibly China bringing chariot & great flood mythology (ref. GE Gerini). R1a1a/R1a1Y are in Chinese, Tibetan, Turk, Mongol, SE Asian, Jews, Arab. Nations' kings don't share common race with $laves, commoners. Trib@ls don't give birth to conquerors. Shatriya Arya, Ezyptian, Mesopotamian are only martial races.
    ++++++++
    Whites trib@ls (Celt, Vened or old Slavic) aren't IE/Aryas or warrior race, no evidence of native language. Let alone riding chariot, didnt even ride horse. Roman labelled them subhum@n. IBN Fadlan described yellow haired are f!lthiest of God's creation. Till 10th c. r@ping, hum@n s@crifice were their custom. Stark contrast of people in a continent confirms different races. Whites aren't martial race but they @nnihilate weakers, they've @nnihilated native Euros. Roman, Saka, Sauromata, Alani, Hun Aryas could do the same with whites but didn't. In last 1k years Aryas in west assimilating with whites commited gen0cides of American, African, Asian, Australian. Hiroshima nuking, WW1/2. British rulers who are Arya R1a1a/R1a1Y l00ted $45 tril. alone from India & feeding white p@rasites leaving over 10 mil. starved to death. Vedic civilization is destroyed by her own long lost children.
    ++++++++
    West isn't one race. Stark difference in civiliation confirms different races. There are Aryas, Celts, Veneds, Phonecian-Etruscan from Middle East, Negroids from sub Sahara, some C.Asian, some native Euros, Gypsies, Mongoloids.
    ++++++++
    Shatriyas are founder of Buddhism, Jainism, Sikhism. Shatriya Buddha, Mahavira, Ashoka TG, Kurus TG are the greats no race on earth could give birth. Abrahamic religions are existing because Kurus TG saved Judaism from extinction, he's the only non-Jews regarded "messiah" in Judaism. Literature of all civiliations combined can't reach half of Vedic. RgVeda is the oldest IE literature. 40% Earth's population speak Arya languages. Aryas who surpass even great Mesopotamian, Ezyptian can't originate from civilizationless Steppe. Oldest chariot found in "Sinauli" India. None ever rode Chariot in Steppe. Vedics=Aryas=IE.
    +++++++
    Will Durant, American historian.
    "India was the motherland of our race, and Sanskrit the mother of Europe's languages: she was the mother of our philosophy; mother, through the Arabs, of much of our mathematics; mother, through the Buddha, of the ideals embodied in Christianity; mother, through the village community, of self-government and democracy. Mother India is in many ways the mother of us all."
    William James, American Author "From the Vedas, we learn a practical art of surgery, medicine, music, house building under which mechanized art is included. They are encyclopedia of every aspect of life, culture, religion, science, ethics, law,
    cosmology and meteorology."

    • @MrGiant
      @MrGiant  Год назад +1

      Thank you for sharing.

    • @saumensingh9482
      @saumensingh9482 Год назад

      @@MrGiant you're welcome Sir. I'll share more within my capacity.

    • @jonathonfrazier6622
      @jonathonfrazier6622 Год назад

      Not accepted by the international scholarly community. This is actually just a piece of propaganda from India where they don't want to accept that the Hindus being Indo European invaded during the Bronze Age. And wish to create an India-centric view of history. Surely there are many pieces of data that you may show in defence of this stance, not one single academic in the Western world would agree with it. And they would easily explain the problem with it.

    • @KaiHansen-sf1lq
      @KaiHansen-sf1lq Год назад

      (Proto)Thracians on Balkans rode horses and had chariots many thousands of years before CE.

    • @greaterbharat4175
      @greaterbharat4175 Год назад +1

      ​​@@jonathonfrazier6622their is no archeological evidence of invasions
      And indo Iranians were first people who documented their things and their is no document of invasions in India ( read Vedas or even Iranian avesta )