The OLDEST, Shortest & Weirdest Border In The World - SPAIN
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 сен 2024
- Spain has the worlds most interesting borders; including
The Oldest Border in the world
The Shortest Border in the world
& The most accidental border??
Here's a run down on all of them
/ toycat - Discuss this video
flattr.com/@ibx... - Support Every Channel You Watch
If you want to see a specific type of video (travel, a particular lets play or the geography stuff) check here:
/ ibx2cat
Free month of Amazon prime (faster shipping) and Amazon video (one of the best and cheapest TV/movie streaming services):
US - amzn.to/1heDFe8
UK - amzn.to/1rhGoYm
Want to know what I use for my recording/gaming setup? www.amazon.com...
Check out my main channel at / ibxtoycat
Also on twitter @ibxtoycat
also just to mention this video has nothing to do with the Spanish (Rajoy) government being struck down a few hours before it went live!
Brilliant video. Just one correction. I believe that border controls were done until 1992 when they introduced the Schengen treaty in Spain. I'm not 100% sure tbh but I think so.
You're right! It even seems it wasn't fully implemented until 1995, although border controls were lax before that. Will pin your comment as a correction - my bad.
ibx2cat just one more correction (though its more of an expansion) Portugal has the oldest alliance in the world with Britain which was formed in 1373 and then ratified in 1386 in the treaty of Windsor. They specifically formed it to stop Spain and/or any other nations threatening Portugal due to its smaller size
ibx2cat Thank you, no problem mate :)
Yes, also not all members of the EU are members of the schengen-area.
Max Bräutigam ibx2cat Ceuta and Melilla have controls when you are going out from those cities to the rest of Spain or other Schengen countries. This is due a previous agreement between Spain and Morocco that allows Ceuta people cross the border to Tetouan and Melilla people to Nador and viceversa without visas or passport. So they have to do outbound control from this two cities. You might find this interesting.
Freedom units were meant as a joke but the funny thing is they gave me a better idea of the island’s size than the metric units lmao.
They speak at American speeds and are angry at themselves that they can't keep up, lol.
Lmafo the gun shows help with that 🤣🤣🤣
you can show me how long a MM or a CM or a KM is and being from America I will still attempt to make peace with it by trying to figure out In my head how many inches feet or miles that is! Honestly our measurements make less sense but not to us Americans. Metric just throws us off!
Although he speaks fast to some people, he does enunciate well. right ? I'd rather have him speak that way than have to watch four times longer video. There are people that speak this fast or faster and you can't understand. He was clearly speaking I think.
Condominium?
@@user-oj7en8xx3g you ?
Gabble.
Interesting subject, though.
Must learn about it sometime.
I completely agree. As a Spaniard myself can say that his fast but articulating way of speaking makes him easy to understand, which is really nice bc it helps at practicing my english
awesome!! Loved this. I did a documentary on Melilla last year for mY Vox Borders series. Really interesting stuff!
came here from Andrew
Spain and France fighting over Isla de los Faisanes: "It's ours!" "No, ours!"
Spain and France fighting over nearby Hamburger Restaurant: "It's yours!" "No, yours!"
It’s more like that with Egypt and Sudan
😂😂
Not sure why everyone are complaining about the speed, I watched the video in 1.25x speed and understood everything perfectly lol
Also a great and informative video, keep it up 👍🏻
I think the speed is just perfect but he rambles a bit which makes it a bit incoherent. I thought it was fine although he does need to refine his craft but he will go on to make excellent videos one day if he chooses.
I watched it in 1.50x speed still understandable
4:15
I am watching on August 1, so that means France have just today regained control of the island
I love how you are so excited! You keep speaking how you speak and doing your thing! Awesome job!
As a spanish speaker i can confirm that we can understand portuguese well but as you said portuguese speakers can understand spanish even easier for some reason, it is pretty cool
9:25 "One of Europes only exclaves"
Germany with its 6 exclaves and Italy with its exclave in Switzerland: "Helo?"
Netherlands and Belgium with its border mess: "ayyo bruh"
Exactly what I thought
russia with kaliningrad: 😀👍
bosnia also in serbia
I am originally from Spain and have to say that you did a great job with your research. Keep these vids coming. They're very informative. Cheers!
I thought everyone knew about Gibraltar.
I thnk at least is more prominent than Andorra
I've been to the Rock, but not to Portugal or Andorra. Caught the Euskotren from Hendaye, that's a Spanish station in France. One can get a bus from Barcelona to Andorra
In Europe, I'm positive we all know about it.
Citation needed Jimmy (Kimmel).
Mark Norville dear Europe, without looking it up, name the 4 states that make up 4 corners.
Search : Belgium and Nederlands borders... it's just amazing, some house/doors are between both countries ! no joke.
I know it is hilarious. I used to live in Holland and did not know about it. I saw a video on it years after. LOL
I assume you mean the issue of the village Baarle-Nassau?
It has many random patches of land in the middle of the village that are Belgian territory called Baarle-Hertog.
@@QoraxAudio Yup. If you think that there are only a few enclaves in Europe, well, there are 23(!) already right there between Belgium and the Netherlands.
@@AndreSomers yeah I know about it, but the 'Baarle-Nassau region' is a very extreme/extraordinary case haha
Canada and the U.S.A. share a library. You can come and go as you please from the Canadian side, but the American side requires customs.
There is a zip line between Spain and Portugal which I found an amazing experience and a way of crossing a border (and a time zone) between two countries :) Tom Scott did a great video on it .
I'm Portuguese (my first language is English though) and I was actually warned not to take Spanish in school because I was told it would mess up my Portuguese. I didn't listen, took Spanish anyway and yep it messed up my Portuguese so now I can speak Spaortuguese lol I mix the languages up because I often forget which words and pronunications belong to which language.
WoW! That is a fascinating geography briefing on Spain's 5 borders! You also saved the most interesting for last....the 18 meter border.
80 eighty not eighteen
The Spanish king Phillip II of Spain actually took the Portuguese crown after King Sebastian of Portugal died without an heir, it was called the Iberian Union and happened between 1580 and 1640 (whole 80 years!).
Lots of fun happened in this period, like Brazilian explorers roaming around and settling beyond the previous border between the Spanish and Portuguese Americas, so Brazil got a lot bigger than before the union.
Also, the Dutch were somehow pissed and invaded many Portuguese colonies in this period, like the Brazilian northeast, Sri Lanka and their trading posts in Africa and Japan.
Eduardo Ganança 60 years
:o
Interesting
1369-1385 the kingdoms of Portugal and Castilla fought several (succession) wars. 1762-63 French-Spanish army invaded due to the Seven Year's War.
It's amazing the border is that old, considering how many times Spain and Portugal chose different sides on multinational wars.
Correction: Phillip II of Habsburg wasn't king "of Spain", that's just fictional Spanish nationalist propaganda (unless you also want to count the kings of Portugal as kings of Spain). At that time there were no Kingdom of Spain, which wasn't created until the early 18th century, while Philip of Anjou, Philip V of Bourbon was in the throne. Phillip II was (among others) king of the Crown of Castile and king of the Crown of Aragon.
On the other hand, you failed to mention that Portugal was actually invaded and occupied by the troops of Phillip II of Habsburg. They fought a battle and there were sacks. It wasn't a voluntary and peaceful dynastic union, what also helps explain why didn't last much.
People in comments have said about him talking too fast, I recommend playing it at 75% speed.
Does the island that changes every 6 months change on Google maps when the border changes?
Let's find out on August 1st :)
No it didn't, I just checked the exact same thing!
Yea he made a video on it, it actually doesn't lol
wow! that was a very productive geography lesson in only 25 minutes! I learned a lot of interesting stuff here, very well done!
My good fellow, you could be a horse-race commentator or a horse auctioneer with that rate of speech. It's like you don't even have to pause for breath. Very impressive.
I'm always been fascinated by Spain
AI AC LOL I’m Spanish living in UK and I believe it depends of the person you’re speaking with... some English people speak like Busta Rhymes , specially here in Bristol with some of them speaking slang... ffs. Anyway I think spanish people speak louder, but not that fast as polish, French or Australians, for example. And I’m recepcionist 😂
JP, same here! I am of Spanish descent and never been to Spain. I hear about it in videos like these. I'm a bit angry at the Spanish government for my brother tried to become Spanish
citizen but he was denied because he was an American citizen first, thus they look at it from this perspective. They didn't want to hear that he was a child and had nothing to do with it...but so is the case.
Juan Romero Garcia you should hear how fast Mexicanos speak down here in South Texas. I’m of Mexican heritage and I can’t even keep up. Not to mention South Texas Spanish has it’s own specific slang which can be even harder to follow! 25 and still trying to learn haha
@@ddskimmer anyone can become a Spanish citizen but you have to renounce your other citizenship because they don’t allow dual nationality
10:35 many of the villages of that region, and even more as you go to the west, have these "odd" names (-arre, ar-, -ui, -an, ur-) because etymologically they're of Basque origin. According to some scholars, Basque was spoken in that region until the eleventh century
1:53 There is a french city named Condom. It had to be said.
Lmfao
well they do say french is the most romantic culture
Grow up
After the huge success of "Fun with Flags" enjoy "Blazed by Borders".
Big bang theory?
@@avoughtf4u-4corsair19 small bang theory
I don’t think Llivía is European’s only example of an enclave/exclave situation. In the Netherlands we have a village called “Baarle-Nassau” which shares some interesting enclaves/exclaves with the Belgian village of Baarle-Hertog. There are even subenclaves (enclaves within enclaves). You should really make a video on that subject!
"one of the only" does not equal " the only"
You're right. I must have misheard it. Sorry! Still the Baarle-Nassau story should be an interesting one, too
Campione d'Italia, Italian city on Lake Lugano located entirely in Switzerland. You can go there for all-night pizza and casino.
Aro actually "one of the only" does not exist, so that's no fault of Jan V. It is either "the only" or "one of the few".
+Jan V I was in Llívia and Andorra in early May and the two Baarles in September 2016. I got some stroopwafels on the market.
Great video, clicked on it because I happen to be born and raised in Melilla, one of the North African enclaves. You might find insteresting how our borders were formed, although Melilla existed since 1497, the official land delimitation was carried away centuries later by firing 14 cannonballs that would ultimately define the Spanish territory. Ceuta on the other hand was a Portuguese city that chose to become Spanish after the Iberian Union was disbanded, and thus his "jironada" Portuguese-style flag
Pedro del Pino Whats life like in Melilla?
Joe Sammon Amazing hash
LjFJDhs, Spain in 711??? AHAHHAHAHAHAHHA Spain is a fake state forged in the 19th century by the losing Castile and is not a nation, not even today. Spain is doomed to break off at some pint in the near future. Spain is an outright historic fraud. Even the name was stolen from a Roman province ahahha LOSERS
Don't be jealous about Spain please.
@@alvaropuerta5283 LOL Historical reality.
Freedom units 😂 amazing
He is in favor of metric units.
An AR 15 won't give you freedom. Americans used their ballots to throw their freedom away. They lost it even though they had hundreds of thousands of automatic weapons.
Dave Soucy Americans don't have hundreds of thousands of automatic weapons. The military and some police do. But regular citizens owning one is very rare and incredibly expensive.
CoachVaz24 Coach. Fake news. I know several people who have one or more automatic weapons. Not sure where your research comes there are 3 gun shops near me that are stocked with AR 15s
In plumbum nos fides AR15s are SEMI-automatic.
"Why didn't Spain just invade Portugal?"
Well, they tried :^)
I wouldn't say Livia is Europe's only exclave. Italy and Germany both have tiny pieces inside Switzerland. Kaliningrad is an exclave of Russia, though not surrounded by another state. And there are a huge peppering of pieces of Belgium inside Netherlands, including, if I recall correctly, one piece of Belgium inside a piece of the Netherlands inside a piece of Belgium that's inside the Netherlands.
Yeah, I saw that part of the video and checked the comments for this!
Yeah, check out Baarle-Hertog/Baarle-Nassau in hm, well, Netherlands, sort of ;)
Thank you, was going to comment on the Belgian exclave in a Dutch exclave inside a Belgian exclave in the Netherlands, but you nailed it!
I thought he said “one of the only exclaves . . .” but need to listen at a still slower speed to be sure.
Exclave and enclave , BOTH have 2 'E' s in it .
Love your enthusiasm! Always cheers me up 🙂 The strange thing about the man detained at Tokyo Airport is that he claimed to be from Taured, a country slightly larger and older than Andorra, but in its approximate location. The weirdest thing is he produced a Tauredian passport with valid visa stamps, some Tauredian currency, and Tauredian stamped travel documents...
PS. Spain has also never had any real desire to annex Portugal because 1) The Spanish and Portugese monarchies were intermarried for hundreds of years, and 2) Britain has the world's oldest mutual protection pact with Portugal against Spanish aggression... and we love having lots of little nooks and crannies around Spanish territory to keep our eyes on them.
The reason why Portugal wants Olivença back is because the spaniards took it from Portugal when allied with the napoleonic filth :P Also, Ceuta was portuguese from 1415 until 1668.
LOL...please do try... again...
I like how fast you talk it means I get to lisen to more stuff in less time
i'm from the usa and i didnt realize how long the island that switches countries was until he brought up 19 AR-15's long
Very interesting video.. and i'm american :)
I see a lot of comments on you talking too fast but I didn't mind at all. You seemed excited and passionate about this, kept it going at a good pace without any slow boring parts. Well done!
As for Andorra. The leaders/princes are President of France and a Bishop of Diocese of Urgell in Spain whom currently is Joan-Enric Vives i Sicilia. So he's just a Catholic Bishop and not Prince. For the Japanese dude it is called a Man from Taureed and when he was asked to point where his country is he was surprised that there was different country called Andorra. He was taken to hotel to get things straighten out next day but dissipated next day without trace or explanation.
But a nice video and all ;)
The Bishop of Urgell is also Co-Prince of Andorra, likewise, the current president of the French Republic is also the other Co-Prince.
Sadly, Andorra is really pretty boring. It's dedicated to duty free, there's one main road that passes from the low Spanish side to high on the French side, but with nothing very special to look at, then when you get close to the French border, you have to sit in a traffic jam because of all the French people crossing, buying, then returning. Best to avoid, frankly.
*tony bennett,* dude, in the Principate of Andorra (there are more than one Andorra) there are more things than "duty free" stores/stores. There are ski resorts, a large thermal spa resort, Romanic churches, alpine mountains, lakes, natural preserves, hiking trails, 4x4 trails, rafting in white waters, etc. In that sense it's much better equipped than the Principate of Monaco.
I agree with your assessment of Monaco, Marujita, pretty on the surface but how many unsavoury international wheeler dealers are in residence there? I've travelled much of the Pyrenees (mainly in summer), seen ski resorts, spas, churches, been on fantastic hiking trails and gone white water rafting. However, I have never felt so enclosed as on that central road through Andorra, nor trapped in a duty free traffic jam, so my recommendation still stands : visit the fabulous Pyrenees by all means, but you'll have an easier time of it if you avoid Andorra. Sorry, any Andorrans out there.
Ceuta and Melilla have always been Spanish cities, they were funded by Spain even before the existence of Morocco. So no, they cant ask back what they never had.
But just like Gibraltar nowadays they don't make much sense. Useless problematic cities full of people desperate to continue being Spanish or British but with no real nacional identity.
ceuta and melilla were not founded by spain neither they were always spanish
If you wish, yes they were Berber villages I think, then Romain..., but Melilla became Spanish in 1497 and Morocco became Morocco with the Alaouite Dynastie in 1631. So, never been Moroccan
and Ceuta was Portuguese then became Spanish. Never been moroccan neither
filipedk no ceuta was founded by Portugal
And no you give Cueta to the Moroccans and we might talk about Gibraltar.
This popped up in my recommended videos and glad it did. First video I've seen of yours and an easy subscribe. Love your passion for the topic. Was quite surprised to see the negative comments here, loved the pace. Really enjoyed the video, cheers!
Just when I thought Sheldon Coopers “Fun with flags” was a hoot, now we have Ibx2cat “Fun with Borders” 🤠🙀
19 AR-15s long! As a Texan I proudly say you just earned my sub! Also if you're not a history prof at a uni you should be!
as a texan i second this
Spain and Portugal were unified in the Iberian Union from 1580-1640.
Except that was a personal union, they were separate countries with a single king
*sundhaug92,* those weren't "separate countries" because Spain wasn't even one single "separate country" at that time. To be more specific, the Kingdom of Spain didn't even exist back in 1580.
Ultimately the were no countries as we know it today because the treaty of westphalia which established modern nationstates did not exist until 8 years after the disolution of the Iberian Union.
Marujita Díaz the kingdom of Spain exists since Carlos I entered the throne in 1516
The kingdom of Spain was only created in the 19th century and its first king was French (José Bonaparte) as is the current one.
19 AR-15's long, freedom units😂
There's a town in France in between gap and valance called Die
Holy shit, these were some of the most random 25 minutes I've ever spent on RUclips. Never thought I'd spend a Monday night listening to a Brit talk about the borders of my own country, so thank you for squeezing in sooo much info (your speech pace helped there, lol) and making it so oddly entertaining! Visit us again soon, un abrazo :)
Great job. I'm surprised that you kept my interest up for 24 minutes. I never imagined that borders could be that interesting.
You were talking so fast my clock started running backwards.
Regards from Spain, Barcelona. To all who may read my comment 👋
Saludos desde Sevilla! :D
Hello from athens
Im spanish
!Suerte con obtener vuestra Libertad!
Hello from Las Vegas Nevada USA 🇺🇸
Spain doesn't border the UK because Gibraltar is not a part of the UK but a non self-governing territory under British rule, which is very different.
You're quite right that Gibraltar is not a part of the UK (it's a British Overseas Territory) -- but it IS self-governing in all areas except defence and foreign policy. One weird thing, though, is that Gibraltar remains on the United Nations' list of "non-self-governing territories" despite the fact that the UK government declared in 2008 that Gibraltar's continued inclusion in the list was "an anachronism".
Sorry to correct you! Gibraltar is not part of England, Northern Ireland, Scotland or Wales, and so for that reason and legally speaking Gibraltar does not belong to any country. But in fact, as any british overseas territories, does not belong to any country but does belong to the union of the countries, called United Kingdom, despite the economic autonomy.
That's the reason they are considered British, and so Spain has land border with UK.
Im Gibraltarian born and bread in Gibraltar and we have been British since 1704 and British we stay forever 🇬🇮🇬🇧🇬🇮🇬🇧🇬🇮
Sorry, but gibraltar never belong to spain, as spain was created in 1784, so never had spanish rulers in gibraltar
It is UK wheather you like or not. Deal with it. :)
Thank you for taking the time for making this video, man. Very interesting. And I mean it. I am from Catalonia, and pretty many facts you pointed out about Spain I was not aware of. Well done. Plus, you have one of the most understandable accents from brits that I've heard of. Speed is ok, time is the most valuable asset both for you and us. That said, the time invested in watching your video has been profitable to me thanks to your research. So thank you.
I'm glad you liked the video, it means a lot to me. This is part of a border series on the channel, so at the risk to self promoting perhaps you'd like to see some other videos in the same series too? Would be interested in your feedback
I lived in Spain and this is a great deep dive into the weird boundaries of Spain. Love it!
Brilliantly eccentric presentation! Love It!
At 0.75x playback speed, I can just about keep up.
I put 1.25 on every video, saves time.
2:20 if you look where it says arrantzale auzoa there is a French excalve on the Spanish side!
Melilla is a great name for a city when pronounced in Spanish (Meliya) but the English way to say it (Melila) makes me wanna cry.
It's kinda incredible to me that people think you're too fast. For a video like this, the speed is perfect.
Great video, especially set at 0.75x speed!
DON'T Slow down. I watch most You tube videos on 1.25 or 1.5 speed because they are tooooooo slow.
I think it's interesting to mention they have right-hand traffic in Gibraltar
???? What's all _that_ got to do with the price of fish?
Anyway, just to make things clear: Gibraltar drives on the right and England (like the rest of the UK) drives on the left.
@Trofknarf Alias;
Yes I understand your logic and you make a reasonable argument, but alas it is flawed. The rules of the sea and those on land are different for good reason.
My understanding is that horse traffic originally passed on the left hand side of each other because the majority of people were right handed and friendly greeting was carried out by a right handed wave, salute or handshake. But probably more importantly if it was an enemy you encountered or the meeting situation quickly deteriorated to violence you were able to draw your sword [usually hung on your left hand side] or lower your lance more easily to attack or defend yourself. Making the placing of your opponent to your right advantageous.
If we are to believe what I have read, It was Napoleon who decreed that all French citizenry, and those under French control, should travel forward on the right hand side of the roadway in an effort to create confusion and upset the "invading" British army when they encountered them coming in the opposite direction. bringing chaos to the traditional passing rules.
Oh and importantly I should mention that road or foot traffic [read horse mounted or drawn] was far more common and in earlier use than water borne traffic to the majority of travelers.
I think you will find there were already road rules long in place [though possibly unwritten?] centuries before the invention of the automobile. How else could traffic have functioned in cities the size of London?
Thank you toycat, you’re gonna help me with my AP human geo exam
Toycat: The border between Cueta, Spain and Morocco is the heaviest militarized border in the world.
Kashmir: Hello
The Great Amida north South Korea border HELLO
@@caolanfeely4317 the DMZ is not more dangerous than Kashmir
The Great Amida well imma just say I wanna stay a god distance from the two of em
Another fact: The region of Spain just north of Portugal is called Galicia and has its own regional language. It's a mix of portuguese and spanish and it's not considered a dialect of any of them but a separate language. That's curious because Galicia was never part of Portugal not even after the roman empire.
But the North of Portugal was part of the Galician Kingdom down to Coimbra.
@MaxCarponera, @levxzpzx, so many wrong things. Galiza (this is the original name in Portuguese) was part of Portugal more than once, NEVER the other way around. In the 14th century, Galicians voluntarily (and in a very emphatic fashion) acclaimed Portuguese king D. Fernando I in Galicia. There was no such thing called Galicia or Galicians in pre-Roman Lusitania. Galicians are originally Lusitanian and lusophone, as the biggest authority on pre-roman Iberian Peninsula (Estrabão) clarifies. Galicia is a piece of Portugal under Spanish rule and Galicians (as they themselves claim) are Portuguese forced to be Spaniards.
you're wrong... Gallaecia is Roman Province(capital Bracara Augusta and Lucus augusti), south border in Douro river with Lusitanian Province. Next in time to roman province was Suevi Kingdom same borders. North Portugal is part of old Gallaecia. North Portugal is autentical Portugal, It got independence of Leon (Galicia remains) and it expand to south.
Galicias are close to portuguese, but north-portuguese. I have own language, close but not portuguese and sorry definitely not Lisbon-portuguese.
Note: Lusitania capital was Emerita Augusta today Merida in Spain.
Bilbo hob I'm sorry to disappoint you and to put an end to your myth but what you said just doesn't correspond to the historical truth. There was no Galecia nor galegos prior to Rome (as big authority on pre-Roman Iberian Peninsula, Estrabão, points out). The calaicos were, as Estrabão said in his book "Geography", the Lusitanians living north of Douro. Even during early stages of Roman colonization on Iberian Peninsula, Galicia was the northern part of Lusitania province (read "Toward an understanding of Europe" by American teacher Alan W. Ertl), which says it all. The kingdom of Galicia is not relevant because it was created by Suebi, who were nothing but foreigners (the true name of the kingdom was "Regnum Suevorum" and the kings were Suebian!!!). It was Galicia who was part of Portugal more than once (14th century) and never the other way around, and it goes without saying that Portugal (in 12th century) gives national expression to the Lusitanian identity. Galiza is originally Lusitanian and lusophone. If it weren't for the Castilian meddling, Galiza would be the northernmost province of Portugal and galegos would speak Portuguese in this day and age.
+Rui Azevedo
which Portuguese? Lisboa Portuguese? No thanks...you distort too much the language.
Very interesting video! However, I have one point of disagreement: Llivia is not the only exclave in Europe. Take a look at Campione D'Italia, which is an Italian exclave surrounded by Switzerland, located on the Lago di Lugano.
There are many exclaves in Europe. The border of Belgium and Netherlands has about 30 exclaves. It's in the area of Baarle-Hertog(Belgium) and Baarle-Nassau (Netherlands). There's even counter-exclaces.
The borders are marked with pins in the cobbles.
Clemens Reinke , there's also Kleinwalsertal which is Austrian territory in the Alps and can be accessed only from Germany. They are served by the German postal service and, before the Euro, had the Deutsche Mark as currency.
Maghouin Beg;
Ha haa. I can't comment on the Belgian character, having met only a handful in my lifetime, but that marking of the border with pins in the cobbles seems such a Dutch thing to do! : )
Can u make a video about the youngest million cities and there groth?
Nerdiest guy on the internet. Thanks man, I learned a lot
THIS WAS ACTUALLY VERY INTERESTING ! Thank you !
Lots of criticism here about the presentation style, I understood him perfectly, although I am English, so maybe that helps! However, that doesn't take away from the fact that this is a very interesting and well researched video.
@essell548: Not to be argumentative, but you notice that few other presentations are done at such a pace. There's a reason for this. It's nice that you can hear it well. But such presentations are intended for a wide audience with variable dialects and differing ages and levels or hearing and levels of comprehension, etc. There is little point in sending out a video that makes people strain to understand it. Unless, of course, this person intended to for you alone to enjoy the video. If that's the case, enjoy.
Thomas O'Keefe , Yeah but as usual it's only yanks complaining and they are legendarily thick among the rest of us, so I don't take their little exceptionalist meltdowns very seriously, after all, they are scared of basic words like autumn or criticism and use other words instead.
@@will k : Ah, another British voice in the mix. Given the general theme of most of the commentary here, it is a brave soul that goes against the mainstream of opinion and, rather than remain silent and risk being thought a fool, chooses instead to comment and, in doing so, removes all doubt.
Indeed it must be fascinating to learn that an english speaking country might consider english to be their first language while lesser spoken languages are thought of as secondary languages. A concept clearly not considered in some of the once thought of as "advanced" societies of the western world. The rest of us are going to have to start inventing things about which some such nations are no longer competent, since that nation has all but extinguished rational thought from its ranks.
@Oscuros: I see your point about Americans being thick, particularly when compared to the many advances offered by Great Britain's intellectual elite. For example, they invented ... that is to say they created ... um ... you know, ahhhh ... well I'm sure they'll think of something. Perhaps it will be akin to coming up with a definition for words that don't exist, like: "exceptionalist". While you ponder that against the backdrop of your exceptional intellect I'll muster what little courage an Americans can, as so often demonstrated beating and saving your country, as we so often must, and tell you that it is the pace of his speech, borne, I suspect, from his youth and inexperience rather than his nationality. But if a rue is what you prefer, I will clearly oblige.
Thomas O'Keefe: Just struggling to think of things invented in Great Britain, uhhm, let me think, ahh I know: internet, television, telephone, computer, refrigerator, antibiotics, the telegraph (leading to cell phones), ATMs, jet engine, electric motor, steam engine, pneumatic tyre, light bulb, vacuum cleaner, public railways, spoked wheel, kettle, cement, stainless steel, toothbrush, torpedo, telescope, syringe, lawnmower, road catseyes, disc brake, tin can, matches, carbon fibre, thermos flask, photography, toaster, hovercraft. Hmmm, seems you're right, there's literally nothing useful invented by the British!
Video about all city states of the world. Please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Singapure.
Done. xD
It's "Singapore" my dear, although "pure" sounds better :P
There is also Vatican City and a few others.
Just another 90s kid
Djibouti
San Marino
Singapore
Vatican City
and I think that's it unless you count Mexico City, Panama City, Guatemala City and Kuwait City.
Edit: crap, also Monaco and Luxembourg (and maybe Andorra La Vella?)
Edit 2: already 2 likes and posted 7 minutes ago...
I loved your video . One correction pls . People of Morocco Don't cross the border up on the walls . The rule of claiming we are on Europe doesn't apply on Moroccan people . Just for the rest of the southern countries of africa . Mostly the ones with civil wars exc... infact Iam from Tetouan city on morocco and we have the privilege to enter ceuta city without visa . Just passports . That rule apply only on tetouan city . We go to shop from ceuta Everytime we want man . Anyway thanxs for your video 👍
Yeah moroccans are weird. They cross trough the doors.
Great video! I never even thought about people being interested in studying the borders, you have so much information very awesome stuff. Thumbs up!
Spain also has the only cross border zip line in Sanlúcar de Guadiana. I did this a few years back; you go to the bar in the village and ask a guy to drive you to the nearby hill on the Spanish side of the river and that takes you to the Portuguese side of the river.
Interesting video but God, CALM DOWN, please!
😂
@H B I have no problem with his passion, on the contrary, I applaud him for it. The problem is that he talks so quickly - and I'm not the only person to notice and remark on it.
Just want to point out that Gibraltar is not part of the UK. It's a British Overseas Territory of the UK. Meaning it is under the sovereignty of the UK but is not part of it itself.
Never stop making Geography videos!!!!! AMAZING WORK
I loved this video, thank you!
One interesting Spanish-French border fact is that it follows the high point of the Pyrenees except for the Vall d'Aran, which is in Spain but lies on the French side of the Pyrenees. It's the only place where the Occitan language, which traditionally was spoken across all southern France, is legally recognized.
Good Lord, Son, slow down. You're not on a race! Slow down so we can enjoy your information, which is excellent. The suggestion to set the speed at .75 is a good one because if you do, he sounds completely normal.
Dude don't listen to these slow minded people. I understood perfectly. I hate when people drag shit out. You can't help talking fast when your passionate about the subject. I get the same way when I talked history to people.
Does make me laugh the amount of people having problems with the "fast paced talking" sounded perfectly fine to me, Americans just talk way too slow haha, but then I am from England and by the sounds of his accent from around the same kind of area so probably made it easier for me.
I will say I do agree with what I saw someone else say in another comment, maybe not going as far and having it as regimented as they said but having a script or at least a something written down to give you a rough idea of what you want to say to lessen stuttering, repeating yourself or using the same words over and over.
Aside from that great video, very informative, I had no idea Spain had all those random bits of territory along the coast of Morocco.
Then you almost have to be a young person (under age 25), because back before electricity (lol) when I was young and even in my 30s, most English people I heard, such as the Monty Python troupe in most skits, and especially Vincent Price, L Olivier, Roger Moore, ad infinitum .... spoke SLOWER than most Americans.
@@douggriggs1499 I'm 30, also are you having a giggle? The Monty Python lot spoke very fast compared to Americans. I dunno about the others really but have you actually heard Americans speaking? Apart from certain states most talk about as slow as a racist person trying to "make" someone in another country understand English by speaking it slower and louder.
Never the less where I'm from (the South East of England) this is not fast at all, it's just normal. Not just for me, my 50+ year old parents speak just as fast and my now dead 80+ year old grandparents spoke just as fast, apart from one of my nans who was Northern.
I enjoyed the fast talk, he is getting the point across. I cant stand long drawn out videos. Im from Australia
@@soniarose1983 Same, also from Australia. (via Spain and England.) Most youtubers speak way too slowly, and I lose interest quickly.
Fun fact: Ceuta was initially a Portuguese exclave, conquested during the Reconquista. But, long history short, in 1580 the Portuguese King died withou heirs and the closest relative was the Spanish King, thus creating the so-called "Iberian Union", which last for 60 years, and then there was an independency war in Portugal, the Portuguese won and become an independent country again, but they had to give Ceuta to the Spaniards
"A lot of people think I'm American somehow..."
The only people who would think ibx2cat are American are people who have learned JUST enough English to understand most of it, but not enough to distinguish accents. Trust me, most Americans would IMMEDIATELY recognize him as British.
I'm dizzy with all those hands movements.
Yes!!! TONS OF PEOPLE (I am not implying anything like a majority of people) have that problem, but very few in TV or movies. I knew a friend who went into TV ultimately. Saw him years later, and he related how the VERY FIRST THING they told him was that he HAD TO SLOW DOWN HIS SPEECH RATE. Which he did.
Wow. You are a fast talker. Did you actually take a breath when you recorded the video?
I think Gibraltar has a similar status to Jersey. Jersey is not part of the UK nor is it part of the EU but it has a special arrangement with the EU where it's treated as if it is a member for trade purposes. As an interesting aside. Brazil actually borders the EU. French Guiana in South America is a fully fledged region of France and is in the EU. Their currency is the Euro. And not a lot of people know that. :-)
I believe Jersey is classified as a 'state', whereas Gibraltar is a 'territory', so they are different.
The Channel Islands (Jersey, Guernsey, Alderney and Sark) are not UK Overseas Territories like Gibraltar, they are sovereign states within Great Britain (nb. NOT the UK). They have no representation in the UK Parliament but have their own "States", their own laws, their own stamps and their own currencies linked to Sterling. They recognize the current U.K. monarch as being their Sovereign. This all because they are the last surviving remnants of the Duchy of Normandy. When William the Conqueror (or, more correctly, Guillaume le Batard, Duc de Normandie) beat the anglo-saxon King Harold at Senlac Hill (aka, the Battle of Hastings) in 1066 England became a vassal state of the Duchy of Normandy. The English recognised William as their Sovereign, crowned as King William I. When King John lost the last English possessions in France to the French King in the 13th Century, the Channel Islands opted to stay with the English Crown rather than to submit to the French king and to this day the English (and U.K.) monarch officially is the Sovereign in the islands because she is also still the Duke of Normandy, irrespective of her gender. Thus in the Channel Islands, Queen Elizabeth II is still toasted as "Elizabeth, Duke of Normandy".
What this all means is that England, together with Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland (which England "collected" along the way) belong to the Channel Islands by right of conquest and have done so since 1066!
The Channel Islands are not in the E.U., they have "associate membership" with the EU, a status negotiated by the UK Government when the UK joined the EEC.
Incidentally, not being UK Overseas Territories, the Channel Islands had no right to vote in the Brexit Referendum, unlike Gibraltar which voted overwhelmingly to remain in the EU. However, since the referendum voted to leave the EU Gibraltar now has to abide by the decision to leave.
Yes, and similarly, the island of Reunion, which is region and department of France and shares the Euro, but is in the Indian Ocean off Madagascar. I love these oddities!
@@docleetoo and the Isle of Man? That seems weird.
amazing video so nice and well done actually I did learn been spanish, very well done and very respectful for all sides.
10 seconds in. i'm going OF ALL THE THINGS A RUclipsR CAN BE FASCINATED OVER!? his enthusiasm in nauseating . lets continue w/ the video!!!
Olivença was portuguese for centuries before Spain took it, so of course we'd want it back...
yes and before portuguese it was for centuries part of Castile ! Olivenza is now at home where it belongs !
@@EstrellaPolux Olivença has never been part of Castile. It was captured from the Moors by the Kingdom of Portugal. You obviously have a problem with the Historical truth and no one can take you seriously. You deliberately doctor History to spread your fake message. You are nothing but a troll and everyone has already picked up on that.
Who cares? Myself, living in Galicia, Spain, in a beautiful coastal town quite close to the Portuguese border, I go to beautiful Portugal quite often to enjoy their woderful food, their beautifully upkept historical towns....
Many small enterprises trade all sorts of goods routinely as if there wasn't in fact a border at all.
Saramago, the portuguese writer awarded the Nobel Literature prize, who was married to an intellectual born in Granada, Spain, and resided in the Spanish Canary Islands towards the end of his life, was of the idea that THE TWO OLDEST AND WESTERNMOST NATIONS OF EUROPE should one day become part of a United Iberian Federation, after having been on friendly terms since the early middle ages.
I would only add that it would be awesome if such Iberian Federation, in the form of a Republic most likely (although... who knows? Iberia could be original once again, BEING AMONGST THE TRULY OLDEST WESTERN NATIONS, and have a federation of a Parlamentary Monarchy and a Republic, with a rotating capital in Lisbon and Madrid, for example, both stunning European cities, both friendly world capitals with that Olde World flavour, a key part within a United States of Europe (led by a reformed, efficient, non-bureaucratic European Government ELECTED BY EUROPEAN VOTERS, with headquarters in Strasbourg (let Brussels become a BUREAUCRATIC WASTE museum to shock and awe future appaled world citizens!!)
[NOTE: NO need to build huge structures at horrid costs to taxpayers such as the horrible monsters wasted in awful Brussels!!! Plenty of beautiful buildings in Strasbourg to house a small assembly of a few representatives gathering "a la mode Suisse": An inexpensive body of government, higly efficient due to e-administration practices. PERIOD!!]
In fact, Internet makes it possible (vía e-administration) to rotate the capital of this potentially AWESOME historical originality, based on the seniority and age of these 2 great nations, shifting the capital of the federation periodically amongst Lisbon and Madrid and Porto and Barcelona and Guimaraes and Seville and Coimbra and Valencia and Braga and Bilbao and et , etc, etc,...
...forever solving the petty narcissistic tiny remaining issues, exemplified here by the otherwise friendly and civilised comments debating over Olivenza....
... and giving value once and for all, to the once worldly, always interestingly full of history (PACKED WITH WESTERN HISTORY TO THE VERY BRIM), stunning historical landmarks of a part of the world that has been basically itself SINCE THE ROMAN EMPIRE, well over two thousand years ago!!
Saramago's idea was brilliant and we should not let it go to waste. He truly loved Portugal and Spain EQUALLY, as he was aware of their outstanding historical and human wealth and value.
(...alas, it might take a Nobel Prize winner to be able to see that far... Portugal and Spain, finally united within a United Europe.... within a United Nations of Planet Earth. I have a Dream.....)
Hehehehe not gonna happen
@@EstrellaPolux you are wrong!!!!! we got ot from the moors!!!!
8:04 "One of them is a Spanish OR catalan" WTF, dude? Catalonia is a region of Spain. So all catalonians are, in fact, spanish.
BTW frenchs are boring, we keep all the fun in Spain :P
Blimey mate, do you ever stop to breath?
Love your intensity and excellent articulation
Intzura handia is the original name of the île des Faisans.. in Euskera, our language..
It is super great that you are making videos of the thing that you love! Small piece of advice from an actual master instructor. Notes! Instead of shooting from the hip and blathering on and repeating yourself numerous times ........ write some notes, practice the presentation and then after you make your video, edit, edit, edit. Still, very informative video.
I understand what you are saying, but as he can shoot from the hip so well, I'd say go ahead.
Stay off the uppers or stimulants man
Hi ibx2cat! I love your geography videos as I JUST LOVE geography! This may be irrelevant to the video but I would think this might help you, I will tell you the Welsh alphabet. You will be be a pro! Here we go.
A as in cat
B as in bat
C as in cat
Ch as in Loch and Bach.
D as in do.
Dd as in this or then.
E as in pen.
F as in as in of, similar to an English 'v'.
Ff as in off.
G as in go.
Ng as in long.
H as in hat.
I as in teeth or see.
L as in lamp.
Ll - place your tounge flag on the roof of your mouth and blow - you'll hear a hissing from one side of your mouth!
M - as in man.
N - as in nod.
O as in dog.
P as in pet.
Ph as in graph.
R as in rat, but with a distinct roll of 'rrrrr'! But don't don't the r like this " RRRRRRRRRRAT!!!"
Rh - an aspirated 'r', roll your 'r' and blow / cough. The difference 'rh' and 'r' is similar to when and went.
S as in sand.
T as in top.
Th as in thin.
U as in sit (the 'i' is the pronounciation)
W as in cool (oo is the pronounciation
Y as in fun or sometimes it is pronounced the same as sit, like "u".
Welsh has also added "J", so J as in jam.
Alright! I hope you'll read this and hope this will help you too. Hopefully, it will help others too!
Loved the video, I get why he talks fast, he is passionate about the subject and I personally enjoyed that.
Yes, .75 speed is definitely recommended.
I enjoyed the video, however, slow down the talking...you talk way to fast for some of us to understand...
Very interesting thank you. I am American and travel often to Europe. Spain is my favorite country in Europe, however I never knew any facts about its borders. Salutations from, USA.
You're a Russian spy.
@arseymcspmething, pssss Yes, but do NOT tell anyone. Salutations from, USA!
Salutations from Spain, Alexei!! :=)
Actually Olivença was always Portuguese and the original border treaty of 1297 said exactly that. It was only in 1801 that the Spanish took it and even with the later treaty as talked in the video, they never gave it back.
As stated in the article of the Portuguese constitution that defines borders, Olivença is Portuguese territory. Might I add, de facto since the 12th century to 1801 and under Spanish occupation since 1801
And?
@@alvaropuerta5283 and what? What's your question?
There are a lot of exclaves in Europe: Büsingen am Hochrhein, Jungholz in Tirol, Mützenich, Roetgen, Gibraltar, Dubrovnik... And when we talk about Baarle, it gets really confusing.
I think one interesting border is between Egypt and Sudan. They disagree on the shape of the border, which causes a territory claimed by both countries but, conversely, there's another piece of land that's not claimed by either country. Which technically speaking means that there's a piece of land there that belongs to no country (because neither country is claiming it as part of its official territory).