DACA recipients ponder their future as Trump continues to review the program
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 авг 2024
- The Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program was started by the Obama administration for undocumented immigrants who were brought to the U.S. as children.
Don't know how this country became more about protecting people that are not citizens than not helping its own, I guess the quote "to help others, you must first help yourself" is completely useless, homelessness, drugs, crime, poverty stricken neighborhoods, etc.. I get that they want a better life but so do the legal citizens.
Kevin Button i have mexican heritage, but i was born here. What would you say about 2nd generation immigrants. We call this place home
Yeah but you didn't cross the border illegally, get a fake SSN, work under the table and be a drain on the system. Illegals in all forms, are.
And DACA was ended, so deal with it
DACA has not ended. It's in the hands of Congress. However, Paul Ryan already said Congress should handle it. They support DACA. What happened today was Trump throwing red meat to his base. He has going to use DACA as a bargaining chip for the border wall. Kiss that goodbye. There are several peices of legislations being introduced. I am sure Trump and the neo nazis in his administration will jump at this chance to ask for wall money, but it's fine if Trump doesn't sign a bill that doesn't include wall money. Congress can take over and there you go. Trump can take credit for something he didn't do. Again.
Congress will not approve a new DACA. The can not agree on anything. It is going to congress to die. Every congressman knows if he votes for a new DACA he will not be re-elected.
Ese Poyo I don't have problems with people who believe in progress and assimilating into the country as an American. My problem is the country and politicians not helping its citizens but rather lending more help to those who are not citizens.
In japan we don't have any of this we don't have a lot of immigration we're homogeneous and have great pride in our identity we reject 99% of refugees & immigrants. If we become diverse it'll be the end of our great civilization & culture. Refugees cannot work, don't have health care & cannot leave their prefecture with permission from the government. Japan can deport any of them at any time & we have detention centers with tiny rooms that can house 6-7 people. There is a case going on about a young man who's family fled from religious persecution in India he was born raised speaks Japanese & considers Japan his home but the government does not recognize him the only way he can get citizenship is if his family leaves the country.
minceyjs what's your point
@Red X THAT'S what I'm missing, as an American. Any sort of REAL culture (I hope you take no offense in me saying I learned to eat with chopsticks as sort of a way to assimilate SOME culture). I mean there was the cowboy era, now gone. I can't say that fit me. My generation was the "metalhead" era, 80s/90s. I LOVED it, as it called truth to power, many times. One of my faves (to keep it VERY light) is Dada - Dizz Knee Land. It's not exactly metal, but I wanted to list that song, specifically, because it has DEEP political ramifications, if you really LISTEN to it from our perspective. Back then, we felt freedom of speech WAS A GIFT, and we'd USE it to parody even corporate Juggernauts like Disney (they spelled it Dizz Knee to avoid lawsuits).
And as more and more people flooded in from Mexico, music has turned JUST HIDEOUS, imo. I just don't hear ANY real pattern in it.
I must say, I wish we had YOUR laws. Very wise to protect your culture. Unlike us foolish Americans.
Well said and a perfect example why Japan understands maintain culture, national heritage and borders far better than America.
@Mr. Bushido I wish I could apply for asylum, in Japan. Beautiful culture, they are obviously wise, unlike my country. Oh, I know: I have no chance in hell.
Juan Ortega really bro that's all you had to say now I know why some of you guys are known to violent because you think your entitled to everything btw I am a mix of Japanese Mexican & American decent come here to Japan & I'll show you the reality here do you know what we do to condemned prisoners here We go up to you the day your execution day is & inform your going down to the shallows
When I see people jumping the line at the restaurant I get mad. If you want to come to America, please get in line like everyone else... More propaganda from the msm doesn't cut it with me.
RA, then you need to deport all Mexicans, Guatemalans, Brazilians, Chileans, and every other Central and Southern American too. Those nations were founded by the European nations of Spain and Portugal. Why do you think the people of those lands speak Spanish and Portuguese? So if you're deporting people back to Europe, you need to remove everyone from Canada, America, Mexico, and every other nation of the Americas.
rstone7727 Then look more carefully. If the people that crossed the line had a family with children that were starving I would gladly let them pass in front, and wait! If they didn't have money. I would happily pay for them. The real question is. Would you?
nj13 nj13 My parents happen to be undocumented and the have over 4 jobs to pay for us. Fortunately I'm documented since I was born here. I just don't agree. You speak as if you know what's happened to them. The only law my parents ever broke was coming here for me and my siblings. I agree they shouldn't have done it, and I'm working hard to be a doctor and have them return to their nation. No matter what all you say. They did this for me, their children. Not for them. They are great parents and contribute to this country. When I said "starving". It was metaphoric meaning no money and no where to turn. I would happily help a family with no where to go. Please don't act like you understand all of their situations.
rstone7727 Who cares what cuts with you? 😂
Mr.Bushido Wtf is "America" there is no country of that name. Please tell me you meant to type The United States of America.
America is not a freaking shelter country. This teacher involved politics into her curriculum, not cool.
J ROD
Really? Is that the best you can
He was trying to make point that was well said
DACA needs to be cancelled, your rewarding people for breaking the law period.
Trumpster2020 your mom and your dad are cousins and they had you
Trumpster2020 I know who you are I'm going to set your account on the dark web and expose you, and by the way your dad is Mexican.
Armando J. Martinez 😂 go flip some tortillaz buddy
Armando, Trumpster2020 is just a communist agitator...More likely even a troll bot... It's obviously not a real Trump supporter, probably not even a real person, and just a computer algorithm. It recognized your name as being Hispanic and triggered the programmed insults to make Trump supporters look asinine....Of course DACA needs to be dumped...It's nuts.
flewjewcoop calm down you stupid broad. I'm just fucking around with the lil bean flipper.
American kids first, NOT foreign nationals!!!
Why she gets a job as a teacher, a friend of mine who is a teacher and a master degree did not get a job.
This is so unfair for american people who was born here and not even get a job.
What the hell are the government doing.
It's not right to come here without papers and live off foodstamps and other government assistance that Americans taxpayers money payed into for their children and get education paid for by American taxpayers when that money should help Americans first...no race in this so don't go there...,become a American citizens...pay taxes ...legally..
She lost me when she said she has no respect for President Trump. Its the law of this country that you cannot immigrate illegally. It seems to me that what she really lacks respect for is the law.
She also stated about her humanity but it's not about humanity but about immigration. So she's clearly delusional and arguing with emotion instead of law of the land. Trump should remove DACA this coming Tuesday.
She said she came here at age 10. You really think a 10 year old decided to come here illegally?? She gives hundreds, thousands of dollars to renew her DACA every 2 years. There's 800,000 DACA recipients who also give hundreds and thousands to the U.S. Think of all that money the U.S. will lose.
I have no animosity towards her as a person. Nor is this about money. Its about the laws of this country. Her parents brought her here and made a decision to over stay her vacation visa. How is it fare to let people continue to get away with things like this when there are millions of immigrants waiting and becoming citizens the right and legal way? Why make some follow the law and not others?
Your racism is disgusting. This is about the law, not about race.
BS. Every person who voted for and supports that orange babboon already had well to do jobs before the election. Many still do have them. If all of Trump's bullshit about job growth over the past 8 months is true, then there is no shortage of jobs. Being a teacher isn't like a being a construction worker. She needed something higher than a highschool education to get to be a teacher. How many years do you have to college before you qualify for such a position? DACA recipients don't qualify for any kind of government assistance. Anyways, you wouldn't know one if you saw one. People aren't exactly walking around with "I am a recipient of DACA" stamped on their forehead."
She's making kids left wing 😕
The white population is already defeated LOL
You know the future (;
Achmed Zuzali I KNOW THE ONLY WAY TO DEFEND YOURSELF IS BY OFFENDING PEOPLE, IF YOU TRUMP SUPPORTER ARE SMART SHOW ME A STUDY BY THE CATO INSTITUTE, HERITAGE FOUNDATION, ECT.. WHERE IT SAYS DACA IF BAD FOR THE ECONOMY. Mmm yeaa you can't hahaaa...
Every single person working in education from kindergarten to university is a left winger actively brainwashing kids to be leftwingers, but kids tend to rebel and what the teacher says is never cool, that's why generation Z is more conservative than any generation since 1940 according to pew research. I say let them do it, the brainwashing kids, the SJW stuff, they will kill their own side for us.
Daniel L Anybody with common sense knows Daca is bad for our country! You on the other hand can't even construct a sentence properly.
Why was she allowed to put her ideas on her students? That is very unprofessional.
WTF! EVEN LAWYERS ARE ILLEGAL PRACTICING LAW! WHAT IS WRONG WITH AMERICA?
So are we a nation of laws or a nation of feelings? Following law cannot be optional. With that said, this is the fault of Congress. Congress needs to rectify this problem now. This should not be decided by the executive. CONGRESS RECTIFY THE LAW NOW!!!
Exactly. Majority of the public *run* on emotion.
Jeff Pippins The Left goes by feelings instead of the law and logic.
R A, if you hate white people so much, why do you want to live in the USA?
RA, then you need to deport all Mexicans, Guatemalans, Brazilians, Chileans, and every other Central and Southern American too. Those nations were founded by the European nations of Spain and Portugal.
Why do you think the people of those lands speak Spanish and Portuguese?
So if you're deporting people back to Europe, you need to remove everyone from Canada, America, Mexico, and every other nation of the Americas.
Jeff Pippins no this is Donald Trump and his Republican buddies fault because they can't get anything done so they're being a bunch of little rotten babies and using these people as The Shield's it's disgusting
There should be a law making teachers have to be neutral
Yea...And American teachers should be AMERICAN.
Being a Christian is neutral in the U.S. because the U.S. was built as a Christian nation, even though, the devil has had his way many times. Our founding fathers, in the 1780s, approved of the Holy Bible to be taught in America's schools, and it was that way until about 1960, when Satan's hoards (i.e. ACLU, atheists, etc.) got their way, and kicked God out of the public schools. God has been judging the U.S. ever since, as the swamp has been festering for decades.
Achmed Zuzali um... I think any teacher can express their beliefs. Teachers exist to challenge your ideologies and make you think about topics not condone them. This is a democracy not an authoritarian regime.
flewjewcoop I'd say their every bit of American as the rest of us. They were brought over by their parents, so if you should be blaming anyone it's the parents, and they had to grow up and become productive members of society like everyone else. I don't see the problem in a DACA citizen, who was brought here by no fault of her own teaching kids, and being a productive member of society.
DACA has only been around for 5 years. How is it she was brought here when she looks nearly 30? She couldn't have been a child and brought against her will and the argument of "don't blame the kids", fine but you know what happens in America when parents break the laws? The kids get taken away. So sure, the kids can stay, but the parents get deported.
The parents shouldn't be allowed to flout US law simply because they are trying to use a loophole
People are SO dumb! Obama said "This is a temporary stop gap measure". While signing, he used the word "temporary". If you want to stay, obtain citizenship. It's even the polite thing to do.
If I was invited to spend the weekend in someone's home, I'm not going to overstay my welcome. I DEFINITELY wouldn't start complaining and crying when the ask me to leave. Never would I allow it to escalate to the point of them having to make special arrangements for me to leave. These people are not the kind we need. We need polite, considerate and law-abiding immigrants. You want respect? It works both ways.
Mr Archer They overstayed their welcome and they need to head home and rejoin the other filth.
Oh look at that. She's indoctrinating her students.
Don't forget to tell those deluded religious people!
But, they're illegal though... Why should I care?
Renegade MS they go to the military, they work hard pay taxes and don't receive SSN benefits so they create billions in surpluses while legal citizens mooch off section 8 unemployment food stamps welfare Medicare lol that's why you should care also they pick and plant the food your lazy ass obese family eats
norcal native That's egregiously false.
except the obese part. lol jk.
They were children without choice. The lack of choice is what's important to keep in mind here because it was the last thing these child arrivers had. It's probably easy to look at these adults, disregarding the American life they shared with you and witnessing them defy the negative stereotypes placed on them, and lack empathy. These children, who are raised American by default, will never be the "aliens" you and others so conveniently want them to be. Reality serves us an undeniable truth whether we like it or not. If there's any chaos among humans, it's because we have forgotten that we belong to each other. And breaking up families and blaming innocent children who are now everyday, society/economy contributing adults, for a life that was beyond their control is inhumane. Human to human, I know many of you understand this, at least deep down. And if you're a Christian (disregard this part if you're not), God is welcoming to all His children and left us with no racial or ethnic requirement in the Bible on which one of His children can flourish by His grace and mercy. Shouldn't we aim to be more like the Almighty? Especially over our selfish desires. Hopefully, more hardened hearts will be awaken. Best regards.
Renegade MS it wasn't up to them
so sorry for them but they must apply the law without fail. if they enter other country illegally will they be given special treatment
LS Wong it's not special treatment. These people work extremely hard and DACA is kind of a way to show PITY to these children
Lacedcrazed it's a subversion of our laws by presidential decry, that's why it's not correct, it's in effect like the actions of a king and we're no monarch.
Lacedcrazed I've worked extremely hard for 25 years. Paid for my own education- a BSEE with honors. Never got welfare, unemployment, grants, etc. Why should my tax dollars go to illegal aliens? I give plenty to children's charities and sponsored children in South America. Who the fuck are you to say where my money should be spent? How many illegals aliens are you personally supporting in your home?
@The infinite I live in an area desolate of employment. I currently can't really take care of MYSELF, let alone children. So I never had kids. And yet people like me are expected to pay for THEIR kids. That THEY couldn't take care of.
@Lacedcraze I have no pity. NOT in politics, OR in argument. I rely ON REASON, not "tearjerk boohoos". You know the problem with THOSE...? IT'S ALWAYS UNETHICAL CRETINS WITH AN AGENDA who USE the "boohoo's" to make suckers out of you.
Like those starving children videos showing the kid collaped, and the buzzard waiting to eat it, with the # you call to donate... to a rich shmuck who owns 10 mansions lol.
I may sound cold and heartless... but I can't afford children, in my economy, as it is now. I DIDN'T have kids. It's not MY fault that the parents had kids t they couldn't fucking take care of. So ship 'em out.
Take what you have learned back to your country and make a difference there
Loco two5 like I said squad up and oh don't worry my nigga I got that ratchet for you. you all talk white boy
Why can’t they make a difference here? This is there country just like ours ! They are patriotic and loyal to this country bc this is the only place they know
+Christian Rojo If their parents were able to live in a country they don't know (as illegals) I'm sure she can go back to Peru as LEGAL since her parents are peruvians.
She is peruvians.
THIS IS NOT YOUR COUNTRY AMIGO MEXICO IS YOUR SHIT HOLE, I'M SO SICK & TIRED OF THESE MOTHER FUCKERS THINKING THEY HAVE A RIGHT TO BE HERE, WE DON'T WANT YOU, CAN THEY FIGURE THIS OUT ARE THEY TO DUMB, WITH ONE EXCEPTION I'LL STILL KEEP MY YARD CLEANERI GET A REALLY GOOD PRICE.
Fullmetalnola Theboot YOUR A FUCKING MORON
If you have no respect for the president, how do you expect him to respect you and allow you to stay? It's mind boggling to see these people's attitude and almost demand for rights.
That part!!!!
My step mom is a school teacher she told me they don't know where the kids come from, she says it's really bad. All this illegal immigrants affects the American poor they have little now a ten year old kid just shows up, the school budgets didn't plan for it. Maybe she should pay the neighborhood and schools for just showing up out of thin air and getting all the free services. What about all the poor American kids who got less because you just showed up at five or ten years old.
Robertson Tirado Your step mom is being very rude. It's not the child's fault. They don't have a say in if they come here or not. Your step mom should stop making rude assumptions and maybe realize not all Latinos are immigrants or illegal. And as a teacher she should be disappointed. Teachers are here to teach children and get paid. They are here to prepare them for the world. They are not here to say that kind of stuff behind their backs.
Ernesto He forsure is illegal and so are his parents. He mentioned he lives in a poorer neighborhood and the kid just shows up the next day and wants to be given free public education without the kid's parents paying taxes. How can you support that? America is not some country for anyone to mooch off of.
Robertson Tirado I Gusee you Step Mom don't know what love is.And we should remember that God died for all of us and he is watching over all of us .
Peru just gained an amazing teacher.
Mexico just gained an amazing attorney.
Mexico needs dreamers too, that would make Mexico great, all this young and ambitious minds, with great dreams of success, would be a great asset to their country, they need to protest and demand change to their politicians.
Why are you obsessed with Mexico? I think she came from Peru
South of the Rio Grande is south of the Rio. Who cares after that. They all look the same to me.
@@markarrington3869 hahaha
Amazing, ABC promoting people commiting multiple felonies. Lawsuits inbound!
How is this going to affect trump's Russian Immigrant Trophy wife ?
hasoevo she's legally here, it won't affect her. Plus she is married to a US citizen.
It didn't seem to affect the Kenyan born president
let them go live with obumma!!
If their parents robbed a bank 10 years ago they would worry the same.
Scott Jackson it’s not the same thing you stupid idiot, your comparing a crime to something a kid did not have the choice at that time.
@@jaytheman3681 he's comparing that to robbing a bank lmao 😂 😂
David P I’m telling you man , the level of stupidity in people nowadays.
@@jaytheman3681 it's just a way for them to sound less racist, ever since Trump won, people who speed daily, underage drink, and underage smoke are the first to say daca is "illegal" or say other shit like our buddy in this comment haha. Comparing an illegal entry to the US to robbing a bank? LMAO 😂
If Congress can't fix an easy thing like ILLEGAL immigration, then we need to hire a completely new Congress. They have been useless for too long. And since President Trump is the only POTUS in recent years that seem to be willing to keep his campaign promises and follow the laws, that new Congress should be willing to work with President Trump... and drain the swamp... and put America First.
I HAVE NO RESPECT FOR THE ILLEGAL PARENTS WHO ARE THE PARTIES RESPONSIBLE FOR PUTTING THEIR CHILDREN IN THIS DISPOSITION. IT'S THEIR FAULT NOT PRESIDENT TRUMP'S!
@R Ma You know what? I'll ADMIT I probably had it better than the people fleeing Mexico. You wanna know the difference? EVEN AS "GOOD" AS I HAD IT, my life was STILL bottom of the barrel, because MY voice & dream was given to THEM on a silver platter. And so, KNOWING THIS, I DIDN'T BECOME A PAPA. I used my fucking head, unlike those assholes popping out their babies they should have considered having BEFORE mommy & daddy put a bun in the oven, so to speak. You DON'T accidentally become fucking pregnant.
And NOW, they're EXPECTING ME to pay for their child, when *I* was intelligent enough to not have kids, knowing my situation DIDN'T look good. AND, as I freely admitted, still a better life than theirs.
So I just DON'T have sympathy for those who came here illegally.
SO R MA, are you saying Mexico is a poor country? Because news flash, ITS FUCKING NOT. Mexico is a fine place to live! If you want to talk about a poor country that we should be letting tons of people in from Look at Haiti. The country of witch is almost all black people and Hillary stole over 14 Billion fucking dollars from after a FUCKING earthquake! Mexicans are not fucking poor! GET YOUR FACTS strait DUMB ASS.
R Ma - you're a coward for not responding to any comments.
minceyjs a lot of people have nothing. A lot of people work in camps and they can't do nothing. 74% of the police is run by the cartel, things are dangerous.
Raider Nation101 just stop
How does she get a job as a teacher being undocumented.
fake papers
DACA it gives her the chance to apply it legal not fake papers
123 45 u have no idea wtf you are talking about.... U are American, don't be ignorant.... be better than those DACA that actually go to school.
Doug D wow... I see the ignorance and lack of information is rampant up in here.
Apparently "teaching" is one of those many professions real Americans don't want to do. I am sure there is a teacher who is a real US citizen who trained and educated themselves in college to become a teacher who now didn't get that teaching job filled by a "Dreamer". Becomes even more ironic if the displaced teacher is a black person or other minority. Progressives are so contradictory in their supposed values.
To my Mexican brothers and sisters, please stop this madness come home! America is no longer the beacon of hope and freedom it used to be. Even white european immigrants are now immigranting elsewhere (Germany, UK, Australia). Dont believe the Mass Media, Mexico is beautiful and safe. It's not perfect, but together we can build greatness. You can fight their wars, attend their universities, and live in their communities, but you will never be one of them. Come home, this is your heartland. Viva Mexico!!
goon she's Peruvian
but he is right. they should make their own countries great. running away doesn't do any good for their communities
She is a teacher educated in the USA. Why doesn't she go back to her own country and help her people. She could do so much more in her own country.
I'm glad you say it, I always felt it was an insult to all of those living and struggling down there.
Buddy. Mexico has higher homicide rates as well has domestic abuse rates compare the US.
His heart seems to have a big heart but a huge wallet and massive ego. He will end DACA. He hurts everyone but the 1%.
Teaching kids that it's okay to break the law if they don't agree with it? ... That's just great ... why would you teach kids that it okay to break our laws????? ....That just burns my ass ...What are you people thinking?
they are brown supremacists, above laws. we want the people waiting in line to legally immigrate. this is an invasion force, not immigration. this is a liberal voting block.
Maria Schicklgruber they came here for a better life. Many are struggling... burns your ass? Have a heart
Teaching kids that it's okay to break the law if they don't agree with it? Really just ignore the laws if you don't agree with them? That's what the left stands for?
Hey Mar you'd better watch this from Numbers USA "Immigration, World Poverty and Gumballs - NumbersUSA.com" ruclips.net/video/LPjzfGChGlE/видео.html
Nothing pisses us Americans off more than chanting "undocumented & unafraid" & "here to stay" in our faces.. So please don't ever stop chanting it
Uphold USA laws.
R A won't happen
If my parents robbed a bank when Iwas young, should I be entitled to the ill-gotten money?
Don't break the law, you are not exempt.
Sorry, come in illegal, get booted out. Simple as that, no excuses, no exceptions.
She will be a great teacher in Mexico she has much to offer . These people could change Mexico for the better.
Would someone please answer one question for me. Where are the parents that brought these children to the USA illgally? You here about the DACA kids but not the parents. If they are given legal status does that mean their parents are also?
Trump’s chain migration plan said only the spouse and kids get path to citizenship. This would not include their parents. That’s why they won’t take the deal. Anchor babies would not be able to bring their parents a citizenship later maybe? Not sure how that would work. I really hope that is true though! Maybe there wouldn’t be so many pregnant 13 year old girls going to school.
They can never get help cause they dont have an entry date. Thats the problem. Prove to me u came here legally
I came to the US on a Tourist visa from Mexico at age 17 sponsored by my Brother a legal US citizeresident and his wife a US citizen. After renewing my visa twice, I tried to convert my tourist visa to a student visa. The San Francisco consulate rejected my request ordering me to leave the country and to apply for student visa outside the US. I gathered all my documents I left the country as requested per US consul, I presented myself at the border consulate accompanied by my Sister in law a U S citizen. I had to present proof of financial solvency through my Sister in law and my Brother's tax documents and proof of work. The border US consulate at that time reviewed my documents everything was in order but he gave me a hard time stating no student visa, he told my Sister in law you want her to work for you. My Sister in law was frustrated started to cry and said no, we want to support her to pursue an education because she has good grades which I did. The US consul looked at me very sternly I was very relaxed and quiet, he did not ask me a single question, he then grabbed my documents and signed them. I became a foreign Student under 1-20 form, I renewed my visa every year, I paid for foreign student tuition in college and graduated with a 4.0 GPA and became a Registered Nurse. Because of my profession I then applied for legal residency, I did all the paperwork myself, I was approved, then some years late, I applied for citizenship I again did all the paper work myself through the mail, my interview went with flying colors. I'm glad that I took a brave, chance left the country confronted the consul and was willing to live with a rejection or acceptance. Today I'm a retired, prosperous Registered Nurse. I feel bad for this people. But you are taking a chance when you entered illegally, and are never willing to confront your situation just because a consul might reject you, so you just push your way in. I understand that the US can accept a quota of immigrants, but is unrealistic to accept a mass of uncontrolled, undocumented immigrants, some are going to end up turned away.The whole world wants to come to the US, just pushing your way in always is going to have consequences a lot of people are going to end up disappointed. Thank God that I was courageous to take a chance and I did it the right way, I worked incredibly hard and it paid off. Mexico and its citizens do not support illegal emigration and should not make to pay for a wall that people from all over the world use as a jumping board to the US. Mexico is prepared to accept any returning young Adults and children into their school system. Education is the path to success no matter what country you come from.
Congress should have addressed this problems years ago instead of sweeping it under the rug, yes shame on congress that want to use this situation for political purpose, shame on on the rule and law breAkers that put their children in this position 🙏
Wanna live in America then become a legal citizen
R A you realize there's a difference from illegal immigration and legal immigration right?
TamponMuncher69
I wonder if that's what the Native Americans said when the Europeans got here: "Wanna live in America then become a legal citizen."
RA is a troll so I am just reminding him of history; The Spanish and Portuguese came over before the Engliahs and settled in what is today Central and South America. Everyone in the Americas who basically isn't from Africa, Asia or the Middle East is of European descent, whether they're Canadian, American, Mexican, Brazilian, etc.
TamponMuncher69 then it wouldn't be immigration, it would be migration
That is what daca is to try to become a citizen🤔
Shes been here for this long and did not apply for citizenship she paid cash for collage but not to be a citizen i see no reason to feel bad for them dont be mad at trump be mad at your parents for putting you in this situation
dandude2010 mhmm. The U S needs teachers...she probably would have been allowed in on a visa or possibly as an immigrant. She can't blame the government because in any other country entering illegally is a crime. In Canada it's a federal offence, which means these people wouldn't even be eligible for refugee status even if they were otherwise eligible.
Her parents each worked 3 jobs...illegally...to put her through college.
dandude2010 you misspelled "college" and she became teacher. What have you done?
dandude2010 first of all you should learn how to spell !!!!!!!!!!!! It's college it's not collage!
😂😂😂👉
Maria Nunez you need to learn to sympathize. I bet you would like to kick all white conservatives out of the country, wouldn't you?
I hope by the end of trump we won't see anymore of these illegals on TV saying they deserve to be here. I want all these kids and their parents to get the fuck out. Fuck this teacher fuck MSNBC. Using kids to push your agenda.
anyone to blame , BLAME YOUR PARENT
Gotta follow the law! Of course we want better life here but TOO MANY PEOPLE not enough housing, people working for less than others, how can you stay without a green card???
*T A T I C A L T EA R S A C T I V A T E D*
tactical?
You people are legit sociopaths. Either that or just extremely tribal.
cnn tears
People just don't have a heart anymore
nj13 nj13 oh please. America has been the band aid to other countries because they have chosen that. Time and time again the US GOES INTO OTHER COUNTRIES and puts their soldiers lives on the lines in affairs that only benefit the rich and themselves. You want to know who has literally fucked the Americans, its your own government.
OKAY NO ONE TOOK ANY OF YOUR JOBS, THEY WERE NOT YOUR POSITIONS IN THE FIRST PLACE AND OBVIOUSLY YOU DIDN'T WANT THEM ENOUGH TO GO AND GET THEM DAMMNIT.
OMG... I stopped when I saw the teacher could not even pronounce the word "Important" properly. I wonder where the tax dollar for these special teachers (who know Spanish to help Spanish speakers) get the funds from to do their work, and still no respect for the law, and is teaching no respect from the law from. Any US citizens watching this, remember that these kids, and the need for this type of teacher is paid for by you, and caused by the governments lack of enforcing existing laws. Stop putting out a plate and ringing the dinner bell for these people and they will stop taking away money needed by natives.
There's that keyword for the DACA program. TEMPORARY.
We stand behind u trump!!!
p jay .. And satan stands behind trump
p jay I LOVE YOU TRUMP!!!
Trump must think very carefully whether he is going to let them stay, they were never meant to stay forever, If Trump makes a deal to their advantage, then there wont be a second term for him, Better for him and his admin to know that
p jay Who's we?
Oscar Santana pendejo...you sound like a real gangster, good luck with your future lol. Can only wash cars and flip tacos with attitude like urs lol
Here is a person suppose to uphold the law and then turned around said he if got deported he would turn around and come back because this is his home he said and no one would keep him from his home. Man are you serious? You are supposed to uphold the law not break it. You need to change jobs.
I agree with the comments concerning African Americans. Several African Americans have been living in poverty in the United States. Instead of a war on poverty their is a war on drugs that only makes private prison investors richer. Why spend money on illegal citizens when it can go to improving the lives of legal citizens?
And the Teacher is illegal too? Well, she'll be an asset to her native country! The same goes for the rest of them!
John Wierzbicki uh, she was born here.. she's an American but her parents are not..
I'm guessing the people who see the program as some form of government assistance are the result of years of poor education. Well, it's not the burden those poorly educated have made it out to be. In fact, there is not a single person yet that fully understands the program has said how DACA has negatively effected or could effect them. How does a person whose abiding by the rules of a program that allow people to go to school and work lawfully interupt the life of someone else? I by no means support illegal immigration. I'm guessing the parents had good reasons, but they went about things the wrong way. It's difficult to sympathize there. As for the children, no little kid asked to be brought along for the ride. Children should not be punished for the sins of their parents.
Uh, not based upon American law they're not. If they're born on this country's real estate, they're natural citizens.. Whether their parents are legal or illegal..
Higher Soul - Then blame the parents, not our Government! We as citizens have to follow rules so why shouldn't they! They could've came here legally! There's an old saying-- Everybody likes Sausage but nobody likes to watch how it's made! You get my Point!
Higher Soul nice! Now they can come in legally and show their hard work by becoming citizens!
She cant teach in Peru?
Maybe she can improve Peru.
eze how is that her job
She looks like a nice teacher, and I wouldn't be surprised if the policy they put in place will let her stay. Regardless, it's entirely fair and within the rights of the actual citizens such as myself to decide exactly who gets to be here for any reason. If she doesn't respect that, she doesn't respect the people of the United States.
While they're pondering their future... heading to the back of the line and coming into the U.S. legally would be a move that would improve their lives, if they're really wanting to be U.S. citizens.
undocumented immigrants or burglars ? I still don't understand the difference ?
Not really one. "Undocumented Immigrant" is just just political mumbo jumbo FOR burglar.
Just to clarify :) I'm feeling optimistic for tye first time in years I'll have a better life, I may have to change my name, soon :)
Rob C i'm sorry what did they steal jobs? I really don't think so if anything most immigrants, take the shit jobs most Americans don't want to do. Some even go to high school, get degree, and become teachers like herself, so I think she rightfully earned that position.
it'sKate teaching jobs are not easy to come by honey. Obviously you know nothing.
it'sKate yes agree.
bendietrees there are millions of jobs that people can get but they are to lazy to if you want to work you will work but people like you want everything handed to you stupid thinking we steal jobs come to Northern California and see how many Americans want to work in the fields they don't even last one day because they're fucken lazy...
Shame on her parents for not applying for citizenship fist..her parents broke the law and should be prosecuted for illegally crossing the border. You can practice in your native country. I have no respect for you for being a cheater, you have no integrity..
it sucks that the parents broke our laws and brought these people to the country. They now must face the consequences of there parents actions. I think that teacher has a great future in Peru. She is bilingual and she has a US education. She will def do very well in Peru.
Have heart as nothing to do with it. I am British and probably Britain is the best ally America will ever have. when i was younger I would have loved to live in America and worked but it was never possible too expensive for me to do it legally and would never do it it illegally. So why the hell should a two bit country like Mexico which is not even a good ally be allowed to cross over illegally and bring up a family there and prosper.
Lol a status. U mean breaking the law?
and?
@Silky Johnson Well, "CRIMINAL" is a status. And I think it applies to them :)
Laws should be revised when it's a morality issue.
It's not a morality issue and if that's the case, then abortion should still be illegal since that's a moral issue for Jews, Christians and Muslims.
I just believe there's a moral high-ground here we should be taking for hundreds and thousands of kids. How would any empathetic person disagree?
THIS "DREAMERS' ARE A NIGHT MARE
julio iglesias the ones who blocked Disneyland were screamers not dreamers.
How about safe spaces for robbers,thieves,thugs,pushers,rapist,killers
How could Ms. Luna be Undocumented, if she is clearly in this documentary ?!?! What her status is called is ILLEGAL.
Lol. Your right she is a documented illegal 👽.
she should go back to peru to teach
the epic fail gamer right? What about her family back there? Trump is trying to keep these families together by sending them home..
zinov3 you disgust me.
Lacedcrazed
..so, you are all for splitting up these families? i, personally, would like to see them reunited.. family should stick together..
@norwegianguy Who's heartless? I care A LOT for people who are LEGAL, and don't turn MY country into trash people's paradise of apartments. Work hard, but at the end of the day, REAL Americans are stuck living in fucking BOXES.
Then THEY come, and HAVE HOMES.
Yeah, FUCK YOU, lefties!
the epic fail gamer wow that was my teacher fucking disrespectful fuck
Telling children this age "Your voice matters, you have a voice" that's the parent job. Her job is Reading, Writing & Math, Science & History........
In her defense there are a lot of unqualified parents out there...
Sometimes you don’t get that from your parents. So, you would rather have a teacher who says ok that’s we’re my job stops, teaching your kids?? Mmh.. interesting.
Why does shutting down DACA have to be played out to be such a negative move? I can actually see a positive outlook to this decision to abide by the law of the land, regarding immigration.
How about If those so called "dreamers" who are well educated & very skilled in their professions, who get sent back to the country of their parents origins, take those skills and use them for positive purposes and make their original countries better by the fact that those young people bring back their skills to improve and benefit those cultures by what the "western" culture taught them. Be positive and benefit others by the skills they have gained.
NO RESPECT????
WELL NO RESPECT FOR DACA.
Tables have turned now son I'm daca and about to reach my first half a mil America is my playground and now my home.
100 % support PRESIDENT TRUMP
Chicago Unity I'm sorry to hear that.
Fernando Olivo
Sorry to hear an opinion that differs from yours.
What's sad is useful idiots refusing to lay blame where it belongs, upon uniparty politicians fronting for corporate gubmint seeking to overthrow America.
What's sad is that dreamers were utilized as political cannon fodder.
The left failed to take over America and now dreamers are in limbo.
We can't legalize them because the leftists would weaponize them against America, a violent distraction while they reorganize.
We have to deport them all, perhaps after a few years allow some highly vetted dreamers to pursue legal immigration.
She was so liberal and I couldn't say my conservative values in her class
Julio Correa Stay Strong if your legal stand Strong!
Yes there voices are important.......but, the Laws protect law abiding society. If you site and do nothing, you then are braking the law. I'm sorry you don't have a right to be here, only citizens do....... Get the ball rolling and become a citizen. If your not then I'm sorry. DACA doesn't mean you have the right.....
TOURIST VISA=GET OUT
Byebye daca
It's sad really. I'm reading these comments and so many people are saying that illegals are taking jobs.Im born and raised in the US but my family is from Mexico .Many of my family members migrated to the US because it was hard to support their family back in Mexico.The only reason why they came over here was to live a better life not to "take jobs" or "take people's dream" .I really believe that we should be more supportive of each other and understand that life isn't easy. We work as hard as we can and do whatever it takes to support are family but sometimes it just isn't enough.Many people are against immigrants because their either racist or just don't understand their struggles .if the people who are against immigrants saw what it's like to really struggle I really I think their opinions about ending DACA would change.Immigrants are a big part of the US and their what keeps our economy together. Their willing to do whatever it takes just to support their family and live a better life to create a future for themselves. Many people may still disagree with me or have something bad to say about my opinion but I could care less because I believe that immigrants are what makes America great.
Hey, don't feel too bad. We Americans have been dumping our trash into the ocean, poisoning it with microplastics. They discovered a patch of our garbage blanketing an area the size of Texas. It's not like ANY of this retarded species will be around for long, after we bury the world in shitty diapers.
So not only did we NOT do anything about climate change, NOW we're ALSO fucking up our oceans!
Cheers! :)
echosixnoble yeah I get it's illegal but but some people deserve to live a better life. there's more opportunities in the US . We all have different opinions on this situation but I mean the people that are doing good to are community or aren't commiting any crimes deserve to stay
Maybe God is saving our people from the calamities to come upon this nation by allowing the goverment to send mexicans back. People freely abort babies here and parade sin...its coming and God spare us when it comes. I dont think its much about illegal immigration but more on the historical sin of America " Racism"
The problem is the children who went with the parents who crossed illegally, trying to improve both their lives and their children's lives. I can see why they have to cross illegally as they might be better economic opportunity to support their family in the US. (Though I don't know how the job situation is where they come from) This is where the problem I stayed above comes in with the children. See, they've spent basically their whole lives (If not most) within the US. They know nothing else save for living in America. Now, deporting them will cause massive problems both for the US and for the dreamers as a whole. For the dreamers, they might be poverty stricken because they might know how to act in their country of origin and they might not even know the native language of the country depending on how old they were when they came to this country. Now for the US. Apparently, the US could lose billions in job revenue if they deport said dreamers, resulting in economic issues. Though, I primarily argue about this issue for the morality issue. Think if you were in their shoes. You've lived in the US your whole entire life, knowing nothing else. Then, the president of the country you are living in proposes a plan to possibly deport you from the only home you've ever known. You would be devastated emotionally and angry at the unfair government taking away the only place you've called home.
Sorry for ranting on some, just wanted to give my honest opinion. :P
So if it's hard for people in one country, it's cool to come over to another and take work away?
You do know that there are Americans who struggle too, right? They need help, not immigrants. The citizens who can't feed their families, who have to work two jobs just to stay where they live rather than on the street.
President Trump has no choice but to send the illegals home because their parents broke the law and obeying the law is and has always been the American way. If I were a DACA person, I would be moving to Canada now, I would not wait until March 2018.
Exactly what we need. A whole Generation of children whom stand against US Laws & for Illegal Immigration.
All children in the world are important. Not just Mexican children. America can no longer uplift all the Nations of the World & children through Trade when the US is aimed against itself, US Laws & it's own existence.
No I dont want to hear & listen to the voice for Illegal Immigrant parents through their children. Mexican children are not dying from starvation & diseases in Mexico. We are not a Mexican Homeless Shelter nor Illegal Immigrant Orphanage for Mexico. We are a Nation of Laws. A Nation where ppl from all over the World have come Legally.
Everyone else arrives Legally. Mexicans need to do the same w/ or w/o Children. No excuses. No sympathy.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Obey the laws
The why isn't Steve Mnuchin in prison for illegal foreclosures on grannies?
Joe Smith Finally, a man who would not buy any food picked or processed by an undocumented immigrant or eat in any restaurant that employs undocumented immigrants. You sir are a hero.
All countries started from immigrants. You cannot just let people in. Dreamers who are here already should stay.
Like you haven't smoked weed or drank underage. You obey the laws.
Why should the dreamers that are already here get to stay? Their parents broke the law by bringing them here. why should they get to break the law and we have to obey the law? I feel sorry for the children. But if they stay then others will bring their children over here and say well they will get to stay regardless. and we can break the law regardless.
This teacher seems to think just by way of being a person, she's entitled to be a U.S. citizen. Also, she's openly dumping on the president she wants to help her. I'm less in favour of DACA after watching this.....
This teacher solidifies my decision to home school or provide private schooling for my future children.
The parents who brought the kids in need to be deported and put in jail. BUT LEAVE THE KIDS ALONE IT WASNT THEIR FAULT.
Right there 7:55 when she has no respect for the president then why in the hell should she be a US citizen if she can't even respect the US President deport deport
im an american citizen and i have no respect for the president should i also be deported Allen?
How can ANYONE RESPECT DONALD TRUMP -- HE IS SO VERY DANGEROUS IF IRAN DECIDES TO TAKE HIM SERIOUSLY --- AND ALL THE ARAB COUNTRIES THAT DONALD TRUMP BRAGS ABOUT TELL THE WORLD HOW THEY REALLY FEEL ABOUT TRUMP NORTH AMERICA DOESN'T STAND A CHANCE. TRUMP IS VERY DANGEROUS
the us constitution protects your opinions and decisions, so no, you shouldn't be deported just spanked in the as* both cheeks for not liking your president.
Agreed!! Agreed!!
As soon as she mentions the words (SAFE SPACE) I knew she was under qualify to teach.On top of that she added not to RESPECT PRESIDENT TRUMP and still wants for him to do this for them, nah i dont think so .
LEO music ,english is not my first language its my third.......Also she oughta be teaching this kids how they will deal with reality once they move on to other grades and getting them ready for the world,not to create a safe space for them to become snowflakes in a near future like your self .
I love how lefties with no argument always resort to the whole grammar Nazi thing.
Maikel Parra he's not doing nothing it was already done 😅😅😅
Maikel Parra WTF is safe space? Safe space to me means staying out of punching distance in a fight. Seriously though what the he'll is safe space?
As a taxpayer I should have a voice about the $2,000 a year I pay for resources for somebody who has illegally entered my country. I would rather spend that money on MY FAMILY! I welcome ANY immigrant who comes here LEGALLY. Why do Central Americans get a free pass? Wrong is wrong, they are breaking the law and we reward them for it. There are many sympathetic stories about people from ALL COUNTRIES.
WE CAN NOT REWARD LAW BREAKERS WHO HAVE BROKEN OUR NATION'S LAWS FOR 22 YEARS AND THEN GIVE THEM CITIZENSHIP, THAT CAN NOT HAPPEN !!!!!!!
A communist teacher
TRUMP ❤️❤️❤️
You are racist!
You're a racist @durece100
You know people who support Trump want to get rid of you...
So heartless
BLAME YOUR PARENTS AND LIBERALS FOR PUTTING YOU IN THIS SITUATION! STAND IN LINE LIKE MY ANCESTORS AND BECOME A CITIZEN!
She needs to be sent back immediately. She has no respect for our people or our President or our country and its laws...its all about HER AND HER NEEDS
That room needs more white people! Diversity is a strength right?
lol! exactly! look at her classroom... not a single white kid in it! it's the perfect environment to cultivate hatred towards whites and the tearing down of america. in other words, a liberal's dream class room!
FashTheStampede it’s not like white people even care about diversity they want a white America
sorry, but AMERICANS first
Any loyal citizen is obligated to turn any criminal immigrant over to ICE
I am fine with letting the current DACA immigrants stay but DACA needs to be scrapped right now.
If a DACA student is capable more than you, as a citizen, it says more about your work ethnic than it does about them.
peekayboo atleast they know how to get a job 🙄
People like Ms Luna is ILLEGAL in the US and also unpatriotic towards a country that has only showed her kindness. Please leave and make a difference in your OWN country. Yes Ms Luna - be afraid, be very afraid & GO!
I was her student last year
Just shut up lol
ms luna had a chance to appeal to the president, instead she said 'I have no respect for the president'. pack your bags lady go teach elsewhere, our kids deserve better.
DACA ppl were supposed to be the most sympathetic group of all them illegals (children dragged into the US through no ‘fault’ of their own) instead they grew up to be a bunch of entitled, insolent brats who will register as Democrats the moment they’re awarded citizenship. I say deport their brown asses.
Let's make a deal. The government throws your parents in federal prison for illegally entering this country and you can have your citizenship.
i am currently trying to get my family members immigrated into the US, they have to wait YEARS, we have paid thousands in legal and processing fees, its not an easy process, but that is how a civil society works.
america is the greatest county in the WORLD, that is why so many people want to come to the UNITED STATES, i have visited many countries and i can say, while america is not perfect, it is better than most.
Everyone in the video pisses me off. Stop the self pity please, and stop being selfish. Many more people paid and waited years to get into this country legally, why are you so special that you can just come across and get citizen benefits, especially when you don't learn English, and protest for us to change our laws to help you.
TheyTake MyCalls then why don't we help them get citizenship the right way instead of kicking them out. You're only hurting the economy. Let's make citizenship easier, so that more people can make America greater.
Nah no thanks, they hate America and have no intention of becoming Americans. Fuckem all and build a wall featuring multi defenses.
TheyTake MyCalls they have no other home... I'm not at all agreeing with what their parents did, I obviously don't support illegal immigrants but these people were children, they couldn't force their parents to do anything. They have no other home.
+Sophie N - That's not our problem. Tell that to our American Homeless and stop being such an aider and abettor. That's what these illegal mexicans rely on people like you who sponsor and/or support law breakers.
TheyTake MyCalls "Stop being selfish" I was living in a country that was becoming so corrupt that our president was robbing the people millions and millions of dollars and the people were becoming desperate that they started robbing and becoming violent I remember my brother being held with a knife to his neck for a stupid phone... so my family decided to escape and we came to America and we tried to become legal, didn't work out, so my parents went to Mexico to try and work while my brother and I stayed with my sister to finish school and guess what helped us... DACA🎉 not everybody has the luxury of time to figure out their future when their life is at risk
She should go and make mexico great again.
Instead of being thankful for the opportunities and benefits this country offered her, she thinks the country is taking "everything away from her"? If you give $100 gift to a person everyday and suddenly stop, does that person have the right to say that you are taking things away from him or her?
There are many legal immigrants who had worked extremely hard to find an employer willing to sponsor them to get legal status. Please follow the same procedure as others in accordance with the laws.
"This is a temporary stop gap measure" said Obama'