Some people (including a girl which was involved in a lot of rumors and lawsuits earlier this year and literally ever) have brought up some things, wonho was allegedly involved in, that happened yeaaars ago (some of them where right some of them their entertainment ‘starship’ denied)so he left the group out of his own will not thinking about himself but more of the image he would leave on the group as a whole if he stayed
@@damnitaintright I will give you chill... He is "gone" from the group because of false allegations some stupid idiot made cuz she was mad YG dropped her...
@@tessagrey1656 they need to stop giving her attention then she will make a louder noise but eventually leave bbecause thats the only reason she doing this, her parents didnt give her attention so she getting it somewhere else
Music and movies(theater) are made to entertain us ✌️ whatever they do or whatever drama they bring I'm just gonna enjoy their "work" ☺️ IT'S 👏 NOT 👏 THAT 👏 DEEP 👏
보면 개빡치는 영상 1위 한쳐먹게 되는 영상 1위임 새벽까지 녹음하고 동선 맞춰서 흠잡을거 하나 없는데 여기가 아쉽다 저기가 아쉽다 평가절하했던 그 팬들 절대 못 잊음ㅋㅋㅋ 6명 전부다 너무 잘해줘서 고마워 우리야 보는 입장이니까 마음 아프고 말지만 본인들이 무대에 서겠다고 마음먹기까지 무슨 생각이였는지 아무도 가늠 못할거야 무대 서줘서 고마워
Same and you can tell the boys felt it too they weren't even trying to put on the best show which is completely understandable I wouldn't want to perform if one of my members/bestfriend/brother is going through such a tough time but you can tell especially with jooheon and I.M . My poor babys man... im pissed
I can't believe starship actually made them perform without Wonho, I mean it's been just one day after the news, at least let them process what is going on :(
can we just erase october 2019 and start over. edit: They say 2014 was a bad year for kpop BUT 2019 WAS THAT YEAR apart from all the successful comebacks and debuts we had many losses. How about we delete the while 2019 and try one more time
Just bc 2 ppl left a group in a WHOLE year doesnt mean it's the worst year.. and this year was rookies' year so for me 2019 is the best yea for kpop rookies
Your comment has most like plz can you edit this is urgent, kmonbebe posted that if you guys being pressured by starship bcz of leaving of wonho, plz hold mic on your left hand, except IM, and jooheon whole time holding mic in his left hand, where others members don't have mic on their hands. Can you see kihyun's swelling eyes?
Mine too. I feel you. This situation is so sad and hard. On top of that Wonho was my bias. I chose him after thinking so hard. And now... He's gone. I hope he comes back.
the song symbolizes a devastating time for the group and Monbebes.. even though the contract is terminated I feel as though we all should keep fighting to get Wonho back. This whole situation is uncalled for and unfair.
he was fully prepared to pay back the debt and everything she wanted. in the texts released his lawyer wanted to meet up and to negotiate. but instead of doing that, they decided to spread rumors about him and his bandmates. please get your information right and check the sources. as for whatever crime he committed, he served his time. i'm not saying he was right, i'm saying he might have changed. this was almost a decade ago and he has since not been charged for any offences whatsoever. i'm not a monbebe and thus not as clear on the situation, but i know enough to not dismiss him as a criminal. why are they releasing all thus information now? why didn't they just settle things with him and his lawyer instead of publicizing it? it's clearly a ploy to drag monsta x and wonho knows it, which is why he left.
This actually hurt me to watch them perform without WonHo. This comeback is so powerful and overall amazing but with this whole situation it just ruins everything for the fans and Monsta X.
This is for those saying to respect Wonho's decision/ Starship's decision. We won't and will never let Wonho leave Monsta X just like that because we, Monbebes, know better than anyone else that Wonho really don't want to leave. For someone who keeps on saying that MX x MBB to be together for so many years, suddenly saying he will no longer be part of Monsta X... no... I will not accept it. And see the eyes of the members? It shows how much they want to protect him, each one of them. They don't want Monsta X to be just a group, they want it to remain as a family and we will make it happen.
Even if you're a Monbebe since the beginning, you're not there when Wonho did something like this. Nobody's perfect and we don't know if he really didn't do it or did he? One thing is for sure, we have to pay all the things we do, whether it's good or bad.
@@blakeblock9376 there is actually a post the came out this morning talkon about how someone heard hiz voice and smelt weed in a living room. When hw haunt out wit.
My baby sister: "Why are you crying because of that video?" Me: "Because they are sad but they can't show it"😢 I'm just glad that my family doesn't think that i'm weird because i've been watching MX performances while crying the whole day :(
Stay strong 💪 I am an army.....but I can understand your feelings..... Monbebes you have to be STRONG! Don't give up! Monsta X needs you! P.S Take care of your health ♥️
I’m so disappointed in Starship: terminating Wonho’s contract and still sending Monsta X to shows after all that? Wonho belongs with Monsta X. Sending lots of love to all of Monsta X 💙 Update: Guys I read the news on Soompi, I know it’s probably Wonho’s decision but still I do think Starship could have handled this better
I don't understand how they could drop him so easily without sending him into a hiatus first and why they're immediately making them promote as 6... it's like they didn't value wonho at all:( plus how hard must it be for the other six to act like everything's okay..
aslireyni as far as I know, it’s not Starship that terminates Wonho’s contract. It’s his decision regarding many issues about him lately. I guess if it’s Starship decision, it wouldn’t happen around their comeback like this. Let’s just hope the best for Monsta X and Wonho :”)
I know you feel sad about what happen to wonho but the show must go on and thats one of the rule in kpop. They already experience this situation. And plus wonho is the one who decide to leave so he cannot affect his other member
You can tell they've been crying and they're eyes are swollen. They all look upset and angry. You cant just have them dance without their brother on stage! Monsta X is 7 not 6!!!
@@rrkivexx wonho left because of a really bad person who spread rumors (true or false that's not the question) about him without proof just to ruin his carrer. People are mad because this person also do that to other idols and want to be an idol herself + she has also a bad past.
1. I want 2019 to be over 2. Jooheon looks PISSED 3. Starship broke a family, our boys are brothers....starship is gonna get repercussions Edit: I'm just pissed off, and saying that whether it's starships fault or not..I feel like they could have done more to protect Wonho. So no one get butt hurt over an opinion, please and thank you
Choong Kai thank you for actually being intelligent. He wanted to leave to protect his members. Starship has released a few statements about the situation but nothing changed so wonho decided to leave. It’s not starships fault
the not so talented makeup artist don’t blame starship. Try blaming Han Seo Hee and Jung Daeun they are the ones who caused him to leave not anyone else. So sad that people always blame the wrong party.
Right!!!! It seems to me that they always try to solve the problem by removing the member. That's not right, they are not disposable for crying out loud.
When you can see their swollen eyes, the anger in their dance, and the pain of losing a brother on stage. Shownu lost so much weight his cheeks are gone too. I can’t watch this anymore.
@@msuarz6666 The guys literally spent the past four years close together after a harsh time in a survival show. It really IS that deep. They basically lost a brother.
나는 그일 있고나서 애들 막 돌리길래 주헌이가 웃는게 정말 좋아서 웃는게 아니라고 생각이 들고나서부터 뭔일 나겠구나 했더니 아니나 다를까 주헌이 활동중단.. 다른 멤버들도 멘탈적으로 체력적으로 다 함들었을텐데 오히려 본인들이 활동하겠다고 한게 더 멋있고 마음이 아프다..그래도 지금 괜찮아진거같아서 다행이지만 힘들땐 쉬어가자..사랑한다 몬스타엑스❤️
Jooheon 🥺😭 he looks like he’s been crying.
Shownu looks like he hasnt slept or stopped crying
kbaby boo he probably couldn’t. Especially after that bish HSH said he made someone cheat on her husband
All of them... Poor guys
Like when they did Hyungwon's entrance all I could see was how shaky and heartbroken he looked
they look so sad
It feels so wrong watching them as just 6 cant imagine how they feel
I really wanna cry :(
This broke my heart in many many pieces
Even in the beginning I was kind of waiting for Wonho to show up
And it's because of this girl. Ughh I want to see her burn in hell
Ikr :(
*googles* how to delete 2019 out of world history
Aa türk mdksnďkdndnkdns
I mean not the comebacks, just the bad memories
Yes!!!! 2019 has not been kind to the kpop world
🇹🇷💜
이때 재녹음하랴 동선 바꾸랴 정신적으로 육체적으로 정말 정상일 수가 없었을텐데 이 악물고 무대해줘서 정말 고맙단 말밖에... 넘어져도 꼭 다시 일어나겠단 말처럼 다시 일어나서 달려와서 결국 커하 찍었고 정말 멋져 앞으로 더더 행복하자
앞으로 점점 더 커하 찍을거임 꼭 그렇게 될거야
혹시 커하가 뭔가요??
@@hamm_28 커리어 하이 줄인거에용! 앨범을 지금까지 판거중에 제일 많이 팔았거나 음원순위 높을때 커하찍었다고 해여
정말 웃긴게 이슈로 이 노래 오히려 뜸 ㅋㅋ 남잔데 이때부터 입덕함
하나도 안 웃기고 애틋한 활동 팔로우.. 진짜 명곡.. 정말 '이 악물고'.. 이 말 공감.정말 앞으로도! 더더 높이 넓이 오래오래~ ㅎㅎ함께 해줬으면 좋겠다 멋진 사람들
Anger and sadness, that’s what I see in their eyes.
I know right...
No smiles. You can see that they are in pain and are clearly not okay
They don’t have the same energy as they did before. Even though it’s a serious concept they look so unhappy to be there
You can see how hurt they are when you look them in the eyes ...it’s just so sad, upsetting and unfair that all of this had to happen like this
Yes it was an absolute soulless performance
Norhane M. Salah completely agree
What happened to wonho i'm so dizzy
@@user-oq1dr2pe1e he left the group 😞
Some people (including a girl which was involved in a lot of rumors and lawsuits earlier this year and literally ever) have brought up some things, wonho was allegedly involved in, that happened yeaaars ago (some of them where right some of them their entertainment ‘starship’ denied)so he left the group out of his own will not thinking about himself but more of the image he would leave on the group as a whole if he stayed
바로 전날 엠카에선 7명으로 무대 서놓고 다음날 6명으로 다시 녹음하고 동선바꿔 무대 선 몬스타엑스....
늦베베라 이때 당시 팬들 멤버들 심정 모르지만 진짜 어떻게 하루만에 그걸... 그때 녹음하고 동선 연습하면서 무슨 생각 했을지 감히 상상도 안됨
STARSHIP, YOU LET THEM PERFORM AMIDST THIS CHAOS THAT'S HAPPENING??!! COULDN'T YOU SEE THAT THEY ARE SAD ABOUT WONHO'S DEPARTURE?!
It was prerecorded
@@lindamarie5425 but wonho is still missing...
@@lindamarie5425 wth are u saying it's not pre-recorded. if it's pre-recorded, wonho still there duh
@@lindamarie5425 it's still after Wonho left and that's not ok
@ggotee pre-recorded or not, they still perform today isn't it? so it's after wonho departure
Is it only me who thinks that they r mad and sad at the same time?
Of course they are...they lost a precious member/friend😔
Wonho Lee hes not dead lmao chill, they can still be friends
@@damnitaintright I will give you chill... He is "gone" from the group because of false allegations some stupid idiot made cuz she was mad YG dropped her...
@@damnitaintright I know he is not dead,i meant that they lost him cus he left,you can chill too and of course they are mad
@@tessagrey1656 they need to stop giving her attention then she will make a louder noise but eventually leave bbecause thats the only reason she doing this, her parents didnt give her attention so she getting it somewhere else
I can't believe that a song like this makes me cry.
I can feel u
유기현 독기 진짜,,, 무너지지마 절대
Remember when I.M said 2019 is gonna be Monsta X year?
...
True...
It's not cause they are so sad and it's the worst year ever for them cause they have lost a brother and a member wonho so ....😭
Oh...yes
2019 was so close to being their year 😭 they only had 2 months left to call it their year. 😭😭
they all look so frustrated and done, the way starship handled this situation was awful at least give the members some time to recover.
No man. I’m honestly crying. 2019 doesn’t count as a year in my life
Chaela Dance it's just music chill
@@emmafrostnr.1fan662 it has nothing to do with song but a misfortune within the group.
@@emmafrostnr.1fan662 It's not when you stan a group you stan people not just the music
Music and movies(theater) are made to entertain us ✌️ whatever they do or whatever drama they bring I'm just gonna enjoy their "work" ☺️ IT'S 👏 NOT 👏 THAT 👏 DEEP 👏
well ok snow flake
보면 개빡치는 영상 1위 한쳐먹게 되는 영상 1위임 새벽까지 녹음하고 동선 맞춰서 흠잡을거 하나 없는데 여기가 아쉽다 저기가 아쉽다 평가절하했던 그 팬들 절대 못 잊음ㅋㅋㅋ 6명 전부다 너무 잘해줘서 고마워 우리야 보는 입장이니까 마음 아프고 말지만 본인들이 무대에 서겠다고 마음먹기까지 무슨 생각이였는지 아무도 가늠 못할거야 무대 서줘서 고마워
대체 누가 그랬어요? 아니 팬이란 사람들이 대체 무슨...
ㅇㅈ… 그때 진짜 환멸났었음.. 다 기억함..
ㅠㅠㅠㅠ늦베베는 정말 얘기만 들어도 가슴이 철렁..... 하루만에 그걸 다해따고요...? 하
Jooheon’s face at the end says it all 😔
kris10manuel yeah :c they all look so unhappy...
Given what has happened they still have a good performance. Gotta give them a round of applause for holding it together.
kihyun looks M A D mad tho
Kelley Thompson they danced it to the Tee i agree but their facial expressions just hurt me... pretty sure they’ve been crying too
I want to still be here to support them it’s just so hard without WH there
I cried when wonho left imagine how hurt they are right now
can we rewind back in time? 😔
Why did he left? Did I miss something
Zkash Beauty yeah he left Monsta x yesterday :(
@@zkashbeauty if you search up his statement you can find it and it broke my heart
@@zkashbeauty but I think theres some stuff now happening to do with shownu as well
Just read!!! Its heartbreaking. Stay strong monobies. Love from EXO-L
As soon as kihyun started singing wonhos bit I started crying 😭😭😭
와....엠카 컴백무대 보고 이거 다시보니까 원호 파트를 전부 기현이가 했네......유기현 진짜 독기 장난아니다
This was one of the most heartbreaking videos of 2019.....
BTSVTSKZ TXTATEEZBP I agree
Ik. Non of the other groups with departed members have made a comeback. There’s just came out on Monday
I agree
It literally is. Like I cried in the intro.
it's just like... they're carrying a ruin in their eyes...
2019 really is a joke, this just hurts
yeah,it's hurt so much
hurts so much
Yeah.... all my favorite groups are just falling apart and I can't do anything but stand on the side lines and watch it happen.
@クリームCream both them as well
몬엑이들이 살벌한 돌판에서 커하 찍을 수 있었던 건 저 독함...진짜 본받고 싶음 내돌이라서가 아니라 한 인간으로써 진짜 본받고싶다...우리애들보면 인생 열심히 살고 싶게 만듬....진짜 사랑을 넘어선 동경이야
다시한번 깨닫는다 아이돌은 극한직업이다
Literally the first time I can’t feel their energy through the screen TT
Exactly.
Yeah 💔💔💔
They just look sad and angry- and the intro they clearly had just finished crying. 💔
There faces show that they have been crying and their eyes are swollen, I couldn't be more devastated
어떻게.. 이날 무대를 세웠냐 진짜
다들 낯빛이 잿빛이네
MONSTAX OT7 FOREVER ❤❤❤❤
Am I the only one who has like an empty feeling watching this? 😔
i feel the same bruh . . neomu apa
I keep seeing the empty spot 😭😭
Same and you can tell the boys felt it too they weren't even trying to put on the best show which is completely understandable I wouldn't want to perform if one of my members/bestfriend/brother is going through such a tough time but you can tell especially with jooheon and I.M . My poor babys man... im pissed
The intro at the beginning breaks my heart . Like the saying goes “Eyes are the window to the soul”. 💔🥺
살은 다들 쭉 빠져버렸는데 눈은 부어서... 마음 아프다
Shownu looks too thin, Joohoney looks so angry, and Changkyunnie looks so depressed. I’m really hurting for these boys right now.
And minhyuk looks so minhyuk like always...
I mean to be honest, this is heartbreaking. Joohoneyy looks like he has cried to much and he eyes was clearly red.
don’t forget to notice kihyun’s eyes..
in the face he looks thin, but on his body it’s the black. black tends to make people look skinnier
I can't believe starship actually made them perform without Wonho, I mean it's been just one day after the news, at least let them process what is going on :(
exactly
Ikrr I was shocked when I saw a performance that came out today
True!! They look so sad here 😔
Istg for a second i thought this was done earlier WITH wonho bcs i never thought they'd ACTUALLY fo it without him and TOO SOON
i agree:'(
You can see the sadness in their eyes. This is wrong
Trueee 😭😭😭
I can tell all of them have been crying.. my heart hurts
I have seen two performances of follow and this performance is for me false😭
I'm crying, it's not even a joke, I'm really sitting here crying.
I can't imagine how difficult it must've been to perform.
I think is because about Wonho left? Or am I wrong?
이건 진짜 대단하다는 말 밖엔..다들 보통 멘탈이 아니다..몬엑을 깊게 안지 얼마 안됐지만 인트로 표정만 봐도 평소랑 너무 달라서 흠칫함ㅠㅠ 실시간으로 모든걸 겪었을 저 순간의 몬엑과 몬베베들 너무 고생많았어...
I can tell that everyone has been crying. Look at their eyes.......
Yup
Yeah. Eyes don't lie~
Their eyes were all at least somewhat puffy and I cant blame them cause I've been bawling my eyes out too
Yeah it seemed to me the same
I agree with you 😔
this is the saddest comeback live I've ever watched
Same
rt
😭
Same :( there is no enthusiasm
Same
Their faces literally shows how devastated and heartbroken they are it is as if they had cried day and night (might have sadly..)
몬엑을 얼굴밖에 모르던 시절 이때 사건 뉴스에 뜬거보고 ‘아 또 한그룹 난리났구만’하고 그냥 넘겼는데 이젠 애들 표정만 보고도 독기를 한가득 품고 무대 끝마치기위해서 노력했다는게 보여서 마음이…미어진다 미어져…
can we just erase october 2019 and start over.
edit: They say 2014 was a bad year for kpop BUT 2019 WAS THAT YEAR apart from all the successful comebacks and debuts we had many losses. How about we delete the while 2019 and try one more time
same.
last couple of days of it the rest were good :)
I feel as useful as the p in raspberry
eye-
we just gonna ignore sulli ?
Same
it exactly the whole October need to go
I just don’t see that energy, starship u r so cruel
Exactly...my heart is broken💔💔
It's not starship fault
it's not starship
Starship didn't do anything
Fyi wonho didn’t even discuss with starship and the members so it’s none of their fault. It’s wonhos choice
i started crying as soon as kihyun started singing wonho's part
몬베베들 없이 비공개 사녹...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ많이 힘들었을텐데 무대 너무 잘해줘서 고맙고 진짜 사랑한다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
아그래요ㅠ다들참아픈시갼이 저안에있네ㅜ
Kihyun’s eyes really look like he just had a tough cry
Joong Shin he probably did........😭
Yeah I can see that I’m soo sad 😞
I really that girl for ruining their life and also STARSHIP for not able to handle it properly
They all look (the most at the beginning) really tired... and sad, I guess..
Jooheon sounds so dead on the inside-they all seem so distraught :(
The most i hate is when i see jooheon angry face... i'm scared.. that means this really hurt them all...
He looks throughly pissed off. Like he could set fire with that face.
2014: i‘m the worst year of Kpop, it will get better.
2019: let me just quickly join you
What happened at 2014
Sasori well, krislutao left exo, jessica left snsd, the whole sewol ferry thing and then EunB and RiSe died in a car accident. Terrible year.
@@Nymphchannie just search for some videos on youtube. There are a lot. Search 2014 kpop worst year
Also 2017
Just bc 2 ppl left a group in a WHOLE year doesnt mean it's the worst year.. and this year was rookies' year so for me 2019 is the best yea for kpop rookies
늦베베 되어서 이제 보니까 진짜 기현이 눈빛에 독기 장난 아니네.
잘 버텨줘서 고맙다
I'm crying when kihyun singing wonho part 😭
Me too😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 cuz he my bias
They got swollen eyes, there's not a smile, its clearly that they're hurt like us
I never knew a Monsta X performance would hurt me this much.
Why did 2019 happen 😭
fr tho
Same😭
입덕하고 보니 맴아픈 무대...
2222
Kihyun covering Wonhos part is heartbreaking :(
Its the most hesrtbreaking part of the song hmmm feels like crying
I cant even watch this without crying i miss wonho 💔💔
This is not even a sad song but I'm crying so hard 😭
😭😭😭
X2
I cannot even watch this
I feel you bud.
Your comment has most like plz can you edit this is urgent, kmonbebe posted that if you guys being pressured by starship bcz of leaving of wonho, plz hold mic on your left hand, except IM, and jooheon whole time holding mic in his left hand, where others members don't have mic on their hands. Can you see kihyun's swelling eyes?
I'm crying a lot, i don't even think 2019 will be like this. It is so sad
Worst year ever... And october 2019 was the worst month ever too...
다들 평소에 비해 어두워보여 마음이 아프다ㅜㅜㅜ 하지만서두 다들 너무 프로라서 딱 봤을 때 무대가 거의 완벽함 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ follow는 특히 안무가 대박인듯 ...
안무 너무 멋있음
Kihyun singing Wonho’s part totally broke my heart. I can’t imagine how they are getting through this.
I cried when not hearing WonHo's voice at the first part. I am even thinking They are all sad but tried so hard for Monbebes to be Ok😭😭😭
Mine too. I feel you. This situation is so sad and hard. On top of that Wonho was my bias. I chose him after thinking so hard. And now... He's gone. I hope he comes back.
when you can just feel this isn’t Monsta X these are just boys dancing a song because of how soulless they look
That's what I felt
same.
who else cried their eyes out after this
edit: i feel so empty what about yall i hope monbebe gets better
I cried even before just hoping to see him one last time, hoping that all of this was a dream
I had this slight hope that he would be there and then my heart broke when I saw just six of them and I started sobbing
ikram genereux me too 😭 I hope you feel better baby stay strong
*crying before clicking, watching and left still crying*
Meeee im so sad😭😭😭😭😭
와…전날 엠카는 7명서 하고 바로 다음날 다 수정해서 무대 선거구나.. 진짜 대박
다들 마음 진짜 안좋을텐데 무대 하는거 보니까 내 기분이 묘하네
There's no smile , there's no enjoying there's no fanchant that was really hurt.... that wa really quiet 😭
Deviana Dka the reason there were no fan chants is because they didn’t allow Monbebe’s in the building.
I'm crying right now T_T
not even shocked i wouldn't have been able to chant either
IM I THE ONLY ONE THAT' CANT FEEL THE ENERGY OF THIS SONG ANYMORE
I agree
You're not alone
the song symbolizes a devastating time for the group and Monbebes.. even though the contract is terminated I feel as though we all should keep fighting to get Wonho back. This whole situation is uncalled for and unfair.
yoongi's shootdance same
Yes, not only you because I can’t either. It’s not Monsta X’s stage presence. 💔
You can see the anger, sadness in their eyes. Starship this is wrong.
Being human is normal, being perfect is toxic~
mUlTi fAnDoM he was accused of stealing stuff, though. If it's true, it's not just "being human" it's a crime.
monbebe i beg yall to not reply to this troll^^^ and yeah it's heartbreaking seeing the boys like this as if they just got done crying.
It's not "being normal human" by refusing to pay debt and stealing stuff lmfao.
he was fully prepared to pay back the debt and everything she wanted. in the texts released his lawyer wanted to meet up and to negotiate. but instead of doing that, they decided to spread rumors about him and his bandmates. please get your information right and check the sources. as for whatever crime he committed, he served his time. i'm not saying he was right, i'm saying he might have changed. this was almost a decade ago and he has since not been charged for any offences whatsoever. i'm not a monbebe and thus not as clear on the situation, but i know enough to not dismiss him as a criminal. why are they releasing all thus information now? why didn't they just settle things with him and his lawyer instead of publicizing it? it's clearly a ploy to drag monsta x and wonho knows it, which is why he left.
It wasn’t just starship it was so wonhos choice
늦베베라 그 일 때는 몬엑에 관심 아예 없었고 그 사건에도 전혀 신경안쓰고 넘겼음 근디 입덕하고 나서 이 영상, 이 날짜 보니까 아 괜히 싱숭생숭하고 다른 영상들처럼 헤헤 거리면서 볼수가 없네
I've never seen them perform without an actual smile in their face, this hurts
and its sad it probably won't be the first
They look so sad and angry, I can't believe this has happened, 2019 is the worst year, so much has happened not just this year but this October
The boys look so broken, no amount of makeup can disguise their hearts.
아제발 몬스타엑스 분들 30대에도 활동 해주세요 이렇게만 쭉 갑시다
현 30대 이렇게 활동중임미다 히히
This actually hurt me to watch them perform without WonHo. This comeback is so powerful and overall amazing but with this whole situation it just ruins everything for the fans and Monsta X.
This is for those saying to respect Wonho's decision/ Starship's decision.
We won't and will never let Wonho leave Monsta X just like that because we, Monbebes, know better than anyone else that Wonho really don't want to leave. For someone who keeps on saying that MX x MBB to be together for so many years, suddenly saying he will no longer be part of Monsta X... no... I will not accept it. And see the eyes of the members? It shows how much they want to protect him, each one of them. They don't want Monsta X to be just a group, they want it to remain as a family and we will make it happen.
Exactly... Leaving wasn't his decision
Even if you're a Monbebe since the beginning, you're not there when Wonho did something like this. Nobody's perfect and we don't know if he really didn't do it or did he? One thing is for sure, we have to pay all the things we do, whether it's good or bad.
@@blakeblock9376 I know. But what I'm saying is the way he loves MX and MBB. And the investigation is not yet over.
@@blakeblock9376 there is actually a post the came out this morning talkon about how someone heard hiz voice and smelt weed in a living room. When hw haunt out wit.
ZtoA TV finally someone realizes that he didn’t choose to leave starship. Starship told him he had to leave
When Kihyun started singing Wonho's part I felt that 😢😢😢
😭😭😭
입덕 전에는 팔로우 무대보면 아따 신난다 다들 실력 대박이네 정도로만 생각했는데 입덕하고 이무대 보니까 심장이 미어터져....ㅠㅠㅠ
there is absolutely no emotion in this, there's empty pissed off eyes glaring at a camera.
My baby sister: "Why are you crying because of that video?"
Me: "Because they are sad but they can't show it"😢
I'm just glad that my family doesn't think that i'm weird because i've been watching MX performances while crying the whole day :(
Samee😢
@@atirahkamal7653 Let's stay strong together Monbebe😢 It's the best thing we can do for now.
@@wish3559 yess😌
Same 😭
Stay strong 💪
I am an army.....but I can understand your feelings.....
Monbebes you have to be STRONG! Don't give up! Monsta X needs you!
P.S Take care of your health ♥️
I’m so disappointed in Starship: terminating Wonho’s contract and still sending Monsta X to shows after all that? Wonho belongs with Monsta X. Sending lots of love to all of Monsta X 💙
Update: Guys I read the news on Soompi, I know it’s probably Wonho’s decision but still I do think Starship could have handled this better
I don't understand how they could drop him so easily without sending him into a hiatus first and why they're immediately making them promote as 6... it's like they didn't value wonho at all:( plus how hard must it be for the other six to act like everything's okay..
Starship didn't terminate anything. Wonho decided to leave.
they terminated his contract ??? i thought he still had it and he just left monsta x but was still under starship
aslireyni as far as I know, it’s not Starship that terminates Wonho’s contract. It’s his decision regarding many issues about him lately. I guess if it’s Starship decision, it wouldn’t happen around their comeback like this. Let’s just hope the best for Monsta X and Wonho :”)
I know you feel sad about what happen to wonho but the show must go on and thats one of the rule in kpop. They already experience this situation. And plus wonho is the one who decide to leave so he cannot affect his other member
그래도 무대 서겠다고했을때 그 마음이 어땠을까 진짜...
You can tell that they're upset about the whole situation.
Why..just why wonho have to leave..
they look absolutely broken
JUST BY THE THUMBNAIL
@@musabunny as broken as the system
@@catalinamaria4014 yeah, esp our Joo-honey
You can tell they've been crying and they're eyes are swollen. They all look upset and angry. You cant just have them dance without their brother on stage! Monsta X is 7 not 6!!!
Actually started to cry when I see their faces with no energy and no smiles...
me too
진짜 이 악물고 한게 보여ㅠㅠㅠ 보면볼수록 프로답다 너무 멋있어 힘냈구나ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
hyungwon looked like he was about to cry when he first appeared
They all look emotionally exhausted
It's different seeing a member missing when he/she's sick or sth. Even then, it doesn't feel right. But this, this downright hurts
The vibe is off because Wonho ain’t there anymore 😭
That's mean to say to them thi
Unknown what happened? please explain, i didn't understand what happened
@@nevenapetrovic1508 wonho left monsta x
@@rrkivexx wonho left because of a really bad person who spread rumors (true or false that's not the question) about him without proof just to ruin his carrer. People are mad because this person also do that to other idols and want to be an idol herself + she has also a bad past.
@@mmmhno ik and when u go to her ig , her comments are MADD
최근 입덕하고 거슬러올라가는 중인데 당시에 팬들 마음이 어땠을지 댓글만봐도 알겠다
never seen them perform while looking so sad
breaks my heart
1. I want 2019 to be over
2. Jooheon looks PISSED
3. Starship broke a family, our boys are brothers....starship is gonna get repercussions
Edit: I'm just pissed off, and saying that whether it's starships fault or not..I feel like they could have done more to protect Wonho. So no one get butt hurt over an opinion, please and thank you
Plz dont ruin it for the other artists in SS that's all I'm asking.
It wasn't starship's decision. It was Wonho's and they have to respect his decision
Choong Kai thank you for actually being intelligent. He wanted to leave to protect his members. Starship has released a few statements about the situation but nothing changed so wonho decided to leave. It’s not starships fault
the not so talented makeup artist don’t blame starship. Try blaming Han Seo Hee and Jung Daeun they are the ones who caused him to leave not anyone else. So sad that people always blame the wrong party.
@@cams9865 starship terminated wonho's contract actually, it wasnt his decision
they should have just made Wonho hiatus for a while then comeback after the issue has faded
Right!!!! It seems to me that they always try to solve the problem by removing the member. That's not right, they are not disposable for crying out loud.
I agree, he should then come back cause we miss him so badly.
It's out of the group's control, unfortunately. Their company should be handling it better
AJB Can someone explain what happened? What's the issue? I want Wonho my birthday twin back! This feels so odd
Ikr...😭😭😭😭
너무 좋아하는 노래고 앨범 수록곡들도 다 너무 좋아하는데 듣기만 해도 그때가 생각나서 들으려면 진짜 작정하고 들어야하는… 듣기만해도 목매이는 노래… ㅠ 이제보니 진짜 악으로 버텼구나 얘들아 ㅠㅠ
I can sense the pain through their eyes and the stage has never felt this empty
When you can see their swollen eyes, the anger in their dance, and the pain of losing a brother on stage. Shownu lost so much weight his cheeks are gone too. I can’t watch this anymore.
The sadness in their eyes
When I first saw them arrive, I saw how sad they were, I.M looked so sad..
It ain't that deep
@@msuarz6666 The guys literally spent the past four years close together after a harsh time in a survival show. It really IS that deep. They basically lost a brother.
920921 it literally is though
kihyun and jooheon look like they're shaking with anger honestly.
and maknae I.M looks depressed...
@@ilikeshippingwaytoomuch8368 i can't imagine how hard he's taking this, changkyun loves his hyung. we'll make things right though, it'll be okay.
What part?
*True*
No they not
진짜 눈에 독기 가득이다 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이 힘든걸 어떻게 하고 어떻게 견뎠을까ㅠㅠㅠ
They are so strong, I hope for the best in this situation!
They're trying to be so strong. But you can see the heartbreak on their faces 💔😭
i feel so incomplete right after i watched this :((
Same Wonho brings another level of energy onto the stage.
Hayley Ballis this just feels different ;(
나는 그일 있고나서 애들 막 돌리길래 주헌이가 웃는게 정말 좋아서 웃는게 아니라고 생각이 들고나서부터 뭔일 나겠구나 했더니 아니나 다를까 주헌이 활동중단..
다른 멤버들도 멘탈적으로 체력적으로 다 함들었을텐데 오히려 본인들이 활동하겠다고 한게 더 멋있고 마음이 아프다..그래도 지금 괜찮아진거같아서 다행이지만 힘들땐 쉬어가자..사랑한다 몬스타엑스❤️
주허니 활동중단해써요?ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@monsomi 예전에요 ㅎㅎ
it feels they are performing without a soul their faces shows how painful this is for them
Right
Lily Shinki looks like you can tell they were crying beforehand in the beginning
their eyes tell everything.
Their faces look puffy like they have been crying... They also look angry
Their eyes show how sad they are. But they're trying to hide it.
Well... It isn't working...
Ok please if you want get mad at me but...
I don’t know what is happening.
Why are they so sad?
@@moonie6698 wonho is not more a part of the group
You can tell all of them have been crying ... Those bitches really got away with what they did and that's what has me livid
Alpacasaurio dominará el mundo Oh... Why is the kpop community going down like this. So many people are leaving. October can go die in a hole
The only thing I see is how broken they are and this makes me cry
Jimin’s Bae yes, same
same 😔
In JESUS name everything will be ok 😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏
2:00 랩 미쳤다 ..남자아이돌 무대는 젝키랑 HOT 후로 끊었는데..ㅎㅎ이친구들은 대단하네 다들 실력파인 듯. 랩과 보컬이 아주 훌륭.. 노래좋고 춤 멋지네. 더 승승장구하길 바랍니다