What i really liked about this game story is that nobody is the "bad guy" here. Everyone is in unfortunate and their past were used against them. Forcing them to become who they were today. Joker became the thing he hated the most due to his painful life, Margie refused to face her past, Violetta died before she gets the spotlight she deserves(Shunned by society for her deformeties), Mike going mad once knowing what the circus is really is, and Murro the sole survivor yet I can tell he felt lost due to everyone's tragic fates. That can explain why his Pfp has his eyes open while everyone's eyes were closed. Even though Murro also met his fate in the next game..
I hope I’m not the only one who waits for violetta survivor form.. you know, when I saw this model of her, the first thought of mine was “She has to get an ID switch”. even if she won’t, it was a really good story. can’t wait for next part of AoM and game of group 0
@@yepitisahell1596 actually, many people wants violetta ID switch, and it'd make more sense if NE make it. But the way things are, I doubt it'll come true. For now at least
I don't think Violetta will get survivor form, especially after them saying that they released all characters (and switches) for this story + it would be hard to animate everything specifically for her not to mention that she wouldn't fit on a chair at all.
Yeah honestly i feel bad for everyone EXCEPT SERGEI(we all hate sergei) I felt so bad for joker and margie, joker became the man he hated the most 😭 I knew it wasnt going to go well but still i sobbed
@@Lolfuny yep. I notice that as well. The problem is how would joker (or anyone in game 8) notice the "9 pm" :) Anyway it's just a small interesting stuffs haha
13:58 those have been there since the beginning, since netease release the circus map, i think they only prefer to re-use the original map with some minor changes rater than molding and scalping a whole new map just for this event
Yep, I checked this before with people from the lore department and someone told me that the portrait does not mean anything. I just wanna share them since not everyone knows :)
2:31 I will always hate Mike for this. He told Murro, “see you later” and Murro fully expected them to go and leave together, so he stayed and waited having no idea what Mike would do. Even watching the final ending scene I could just see how fast Murro realized what Mike did to himself and how it would break him. Mike’s letters (I think 4th) also say that him killing himself with the circus was a the closure that he desired while he hurt Murro unintentionally. It’s noted he says “this is only something I can do murro”, which I guess would be true since he was the backbone of the circus. I don’t think Mike realized Murro would wait for him and how, if he saw what Mike would do in the end, just how crushed he’d really be. Murro, although he tried to live in the end couldn’t bear living without his family especially the one he cherished the most. It got to the point he wished someone, anyone or anything, would kill him. Both these situations are sad and both of them deserved to survive together (in my opinion because ik people will disagree).
I don't disagree haha. I mean, well, it's reasonable that Murro would be depressed after Mike did that. Though, I somehow wish for everyone to face their fear rather than escaping it via death and stuffs. That's why, if my theory about game 5 is correct, I'd really want to see it because of Kevin :D
Silmina is one of best idv youtuber i usually agree, he or she doesnt give bias comments on the game, not letting dieahard fans control the perspective about the game. no blind eyes on games obvious flaws.
My only issue with the inconsistency was Joker grabbing the wrong perfume. He grabbed the one with the damp smell but the entire time Margaretha keep referring to the smell on Violetta as "the smell of tree roasting in the sun" which was the the middle perfume... But Joker took the one on the right. I get it if the damp smelling perfume is the drug one but why suddenly the perfumes content got swapped??? Like, come on.... 😅 This is just nitpicking BTW
I really enjoy the story events mostly cause I can hear the characters talk, i'm not one to theorize about every small detail so I just sit there like: "Yesguys!" XD (Im a simple person to please even if there are plotholes) Also I found myself to enjoy Murro and Natalie more just cause they.. talked (edit: yes the music when Violeta was dying really made me sympathise with her more :')
Now that the ehole hullabaloo story is here, we may agree that their portraits are somewhat accurate. Margareta - Dies in cold waters of hullabaloo, A liar she was as Natalie, she stayed a liar as Margareta. Joker - Uhhh, his "hint" of "shackles", I'd suggest he later jumped after Margareta, since their both share "full of water" portrait, he build his shackles binded with Margareta. Violeta - death of hyperthemia, joker played his hand on her too much. Mike - Finally understanding how "Hullabaloo" actually was behind the scenes, although he didn't see it because of how much "joy" he had to be a star on scene, and after joker's screams of pain he finally saw everything for himself, decided to "blow" everything up with this place including himself (even tho, by lore, it's manor owners backyard ig, poor man, rebuilds his backyards for his games each time.). Murro - A man with a partner of his as boar, he coudn't do anything in hullabaloo, saw the death of Mike (Maybe saw rebirth as "Hullabaloo") and yet I doubt he did funeral for Violeta, since, Dementia potion made by manor owner. And so, he survives until mercenary comes out for him.
Hi. I'm not so sure about it, nor am I sure I'm right either since I don't live in the UK. But well, I checked various sources and in the UK, in 1899, there was no anomaly in winter
For the Geisha mask, it’s confirmed in the wiki that she appears in game 6B, so the mask being missing could be intentional? Like Orpheus just added it back in after she died or something
Well, Hullabaloo is game 8 so if Orpheus added it back after geisha's game (which is 6B if according to the wiki), then, shouldn't the mask be in the cabinet in Margie's game?
@@myatlinnko8555 I'm not sure bout that. The manor owner already prepared Margie's room with perfume before she comes, so it's impossible for them to lock it
@@SilminaIDV but I thought that geisha or whoever her ID switch is took the mask and became a hunter(geisha prajna form has the mask) so wouldn’t it make sense for the mask to not be there after the game(the mask was also there during the Emma diaries so idk if it even has a significance anymore)
What i really liked about this game story is that nobody is the "bad guy" here. Everyone is in unfortunate and their past were used against them. Forcing them to become who they were today. Joker became the thing he hated the most due to his painful life, Margie refused to face her past, Violetta died before she gets the spotlight she deserves(Shunned by society for her deformeties), Mike going mad once knowing what the circus is really is, and Murro the sole survivor yet I can tell he felt lost due to everyone's tragic fates. That can explain why his Pfp has his eyes open while everyone's eyes were closed. Even though Murro also met his fate in the next game..
Yeah. Nobody is evil by nature, but by circumstances :')
@@SilminaIDV but...I didn't see hullabaloo hunter...HE'S DEFINITELY DON'T HAVE A REAL STORY DUDE!
@@MANTRIX-1 hmm, judging by design, hullabaloo hunter is Mike wearing Sergi's outfit. Not sure if I'm missing something but yeah
Poor Violetta
Except Freddy, he's evil encarnate
I hope I’m not the only one who waits for violetta survivor form.. you know, when I saw this model of her, the first thought of mine was “She has to get an ID switch”. even if she won’t, it was a really good story. can’t wait for next part of AoM and game of group 0
@@yepitisahell1596 actually, many people wants violetta ID switch, and it'd make more sense if NE make it. But the way things are, I doubt it'll come true. For now at least
I don't think Violetta will get survivor form, especially after them saying that they released all characters (and switches) for this story + it would be hard to animate everything specifically for her not to mention that she wouldn't fit on a chair at all.
Bro I was meaning make concept art for identity switch violetta
Yeah honestly i feel bad for everyone EXCEPT SERGEI(we all hate sergei) I felt so bad for joker and margie, joker became the man he hated the most 😭 I knew it wasnt going to go well but still i sobbed
Well, I dislike Sergi as well given what happened (but I don't dislike him to the point of hating Mike's skin. That'd be too far lol)
In William's diary, he mentions that the clocks are already broken.
So that might explain why the clocks are like that
@@Lolfuny yep. I notice that as well. The problem is how would joker (or anyone in game 8) notice the "9 pm" :)
Anyway it's just a small interesting stuffs haha
Holy shoot the way the AI said Hullabaloo actually jumpscared me so bad cuz it sounded exactly like my accent what the f-
Wahahaha XD
Yeah, the AI said so :D
13:58 those have been there since the beginning, since netease release the circus map, i think they only prefer to re-use the original map with some minor changes rater than molding and scalping a whole new map just for this event
Yep, I checked this before with people from the lore department and someone told me that the portrait does not mean anything. I just wanna share them since not everyone knows :)
2:31 I will always hate Mike for this. He told Murro, “see you later” and Murro fully expected them to go and leave together, so he stayed and waited having no idea what Mike would do. Even watching the final ending scene I could just see how fast Murro realized what Mike did to himself and how it would break him. Mike’s letters (I think 4th) also say that him killing himself with the circus was a the closure that he desired while he hurt Murro unintentionally. It’s noted he says “this is only something I can do murro”, which I guess would be true since he was the backbone of the circus. I don’t think Mike realized Murro would wait for him and how, if he saw what Mike would do in the end, just how crushed he’d really be. Murro, although he tried to live in the end couldn’t bear living without his family especially the one he cherished the most. It got to the point he wished someone, anyone or anything, would kill him. Both these situations are sad and both of them deserved to survive together (in my opinion because ik people will disagree).
I don't disagree haha. I mean, well, it's reasonable that Murro would be depressed after Mike did that.
Though, I somehow wish for everyone to face their fear rather than escaping it via death and stuffs. That's why, if my theory about game 5 is correct, I'd really want to see it because of Kevin :D
Silmina is one of best idv youtuber i usually agree, he or she doesnt give bias comments on the game, not letting dieahard fans control the perspective about the game. no blind eyes on games obvious flaws.
Waah thank you. That means a lot ^^
My only issue with the inconsistency was Joker grabbing the wrong perfume. He grabbed the one with the damp smell but the entire time Margaretha keep referring to the smell on Violetta as "the smell of tree roasting in the sun" which was the the middle perfume... But Joker took the one on the right. I get it if the damp smelling perfume is the drug one but why suddenly the perfumes content got swapped??? Like, come on.... 😅
This is just nitpicking BTW
Oh, that's right! I forgot to mention it haha thanks for the insight :D
Yay, finally another sassy commentary💃🥰. I have'nt (?) finish the story because violleta sad tragic ending😢
No Mike costume for you then 🤷♂️
It's been a while since I made a sassy commentary. Kinda refreshing :D
I feel bad and sad for all of them 😢😢
Fr mate :')
I really enjoy the story events mostly cause I can hear the characters talk, i'm not one to theorize about every small detail so I just sit there like: "Yesguys!" XD (Im a simple person to please even if there are plotholes)
Also I found myself to enjoy Murro and Natalie more just cause they.. talked
(edit: yes the music when Violeta was dying really made me sympathise with her more :')
The VA department did a very good job XD
@@SilminaIDV they were getting a raise for sure
I was waiting for Slimina to make a video about the new event and I am glad it was covered.
@@GinTheCerberus wahaha thank you ^^
THEY STILL HAVE BUTTON EYES
They do :D
Now that the ehole hullabaloo story is here, we may agree that their portraits are somewhat accurate.
Margareta - Dies in cold waters of hullabaloo, A liar she was as Natalie, she stayed a liar as Margareta.
Joker - Uhhh, his "hint" of "shackles", I'd suggest he later jumped after Margareta, since their both share "full of water" portrait, he build his shackles binded with Margareta.
Violeta - death of hyperthemia, joker played his hand on her too much.
Mike - Finally understanding how "Hullabaloo" actually was behind the scenes, although he didn't see it because of how much "joy" he had to be a star on scene, and after joker's screams of pain he finally saw everything for himself, decided to "blow" everything up with this place including himself (even tho, by lore, it's manor owners backyard ig, poor man, rebuilds his backyards for his games each time.).
Murro - A man with a partner of his as boar, he coudn't do anything in hullabaloo, saw the death of Mike (Maybe saw rebirth as "Hullabaloo") and yet I doubt he did funeral for Violeta, since, Dementia potion made by manor owner. And so, he survives until mercenary comes out for him.
Such a nice foreshadowing :)
@SilminaIDV yea :зc
13:50 maybe the manor owner knows who will be the next guest for the game...wait...no...how did he know that morru will die? Ok forget about it
Manor owner already got their plan ahead :o
2:24 you made me cry again ! GIRLY THATS S O SAD 😭😭😭😭😢😢
@@Angelbunny12 haha yeah, quite sad. I've got something more tragic, but it's sad indeed :')
But snow in those ages in October is ok for northern countries like Germany and the UK
Hi. I'm not so sure about it, nor am I sure I'm right either since I don't live in the UK. But well, I checked various sources and in the UK, in 1899, there was no anomaly in winter
For the Geisha mask, it’s confirmed in the wiki that she appears in game 6B, so the mask being missing could be intentional? Like Orpheus just added it back in after she died or something
Well, Hullabaloo is game 8 so if Orpheus added it back after geisha's game (which is 6B if according to the wiki), then, shouldn't the mask be in the cabinet in Margie's game?
@
Dunno! Only time will tell :-)
Great video btw! :D
@@RiceRise thank you ^^
There's a little part of me that's hoping violetta gets main character immunity, like somehow she gets resurrected.
I believe many others think so too :D
Yayy! I kinda missed your sassy commentary. I also loved this side story, but Mike's face always made me laugh 😂 why does he always look angry
@@coelhinho.8356 it's been a while since I made a sassy one XD
OMG i been binging ur vids and it caused me to be early here, i love ur stuff ! :D
Hello, and thank you ^^
Maybe the manor owner locked the door since July's match. Then Dancer flip it to correct date.
@@myatlinnko8555 I'm not sure bout that. The manor owner already prepared Margie's room with perfume before she comes, so it's impossible for them to lock it
Idv mostly takes place in the 1900s and game 8 seems to be around 1920 so most things that are there make sense
@@blackdahlia9494 actually, no. Most canon games happened from 1896 to 1902
Nice video!
@@Potatourmom-kd1dp thank you ^^
0:00 HOOLLLAPALĽOO
@@MANTRIX-1 I'm sorry I'm sorry :')
@@SilminaIDV oh no....v...violleta😔😢😭
My condolences violleta!☹️
I have a question for ya @@SilminaIDV
Why is your voice sometimes that of a nine-year-old girl and sometimes that of an adult?
Also abt the geisha thingy im pretty sure that in the character relations web it shows geisha under game 6b? Its really confusing
@@Go_go_dancerr ikr? If 6B, then the mask should be there in Margie's game
@@SilminaIDV but I thought that geisha or whoever her ID switch is took the mask and became a hunter(geisha prajna form has the mask) so wouldn’t it make sense for the mask to not be there after the game(the mask was also there during the Emma diaries so idk if it even has a significance anymore)
@@Go_go_dancerr well if it is so, then the mask should also be gone in Naib's game, right? But it was there :')
MURRO 😢😢
@@tofu81 howdybii XD
Netease ❌
Netísse ✅
I'm sorry my English is bad and the AI said that instead :')
HULAH! BAH LUUUU! IM LAUGHING SORRY!!!
@@Seven_IDV I'm sorry the AI said that :')
i like joker 👍
@@viscuitts Murro's my favorite :D
HOULAABAWLOO😣
@@Go_go_dancerr the AI said that I'm sorry :')
@ no it was rlly funny