This was kind of an enlightening talk. Not only did Tim Weaver kind of point to non-adaptive kind of changes in the human skull, but kind of also included in his talk phrases that kind of pointed to some kind of strange developments kind of in the way some scientists kind of like to kind of speak these days, or these kind of days. Very kind of enlightening, if you can kind of make it through kind of the way he speaks.
That's an irritating answer, kind of, but it's not the end of the World fella..... his talk wasn't perfect, but I think that he got most things right, he just needs to learn to speak publicly better.
UCTV - I think you missed including a video in the CARTA playlist. There's one from this event uploaded by you a few days ago that isn't in the CARTA playlist.
I bet some day it's discovered that the ability to produce vocalizations are not the key factor for developing language, but rather brain development. And that a certain kind of brain development without the ability to vocalize in certain precise ways would still lead to the development of language. Just not so-called "spoken" language as we experience it... (See beginning around 6:40...)
I have a problem with trying to draw any conclusions based on skull data. We have so many recent finds of small brained hominids that have lived in our very recent past along side other hominin. We have no way of knowing how much interbreeding there was among them so any variation has multiple possible causes. DNA analysis pretty much trumps old school quantification of skull anatomy. You can pretty much throw out judging intelligence based on brain size, as well.
ҳҲ̸Ҳ̸ҳ very interesting I found out the time difference : million years until they knock two rocks together, to metallurgy another million years, then and thousands years until a car was made in my life time to going to space . We are in different time?
ҳҲ̸Ҳ̸ҳ according to scientists we had a extremely slow start an now we are in fast speed mode, like in the beginning time was slower compared with our time, time can compress and expand... but what I know , I am the created, God is the Creator!
The dramatic change in our diets going into the agricultural movement is too recent. Partly explains my non-Celiac severe gluten intolerance. Our guys are not adept to digest so much argicultural product (wheat,corn,rice,.....)
I will never understand where they get the idea that only humans are capable of speech when our speech capabilities is an adaptation to make speech simpler and easier. It didn't just occur one day that a human was born and said momma a few months later, earlier hominids had to be talking up a storm to create the vocal capacity we have today. Albeit their languages wouldn't be anything like ours is but simpler and more complicated. Simpler in the word variety but more complicated in the use of the fewer sounds they could make to say the words. If human intelligences with 100 years experience in speech was given a dogs vocal capabilities they could speak words just not what we would say or how we would say it.
@@Lucas-pe6fg In the west, markers are thought to indicate murderers, serial killers etc., and verdicts are given based on science of genetics, but now seems wrong because many other markers are not considered. A British geneticist/journalist finds. I am not a geneticist.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
The archeologists from Italy is a wonderful and engaging speaker!
Three excellent speakers. Thank you.
Excellent, thank you!
This was kind of an enlightening talk. Not only did Tim Weaver kind of point to non-adaptive kind of changes in the human skull, but kind of also included in his talk phrases that kind of pointed to some kind of strange developments kind of in the way some scientists kind of like to kind of speak these days, or these kind of days. Very kind of enlightening, if you can kind of make it through kind of the way he speaks.
Didn't noticed till reading your comment!
Anyway it doesn't bothers me, but kinda funny instead 😄
What about the “sort of” verbal tick? It’s sort of amazing how sort of smoothly the term is obsessively sort of injected into every third sentence.
That's an irritating answer, kind of, but it's not the end of the World fella..... his talk wasn't perfect, but I think that he got most things right, he just needs to learn to speak publicly better.
UCTV - I think you missed including a video in the CARTA playlist. There's one from this event uploaded by you a few days ago that isn't in the CARTA playlist.
I bet some day it's discovered that the ability to produce vocalizations are not the key factor for developing language, but rather brain development. And that a certain kind of brain development without the ability to vocalize in certain precise ways would still lead to the development of language. Just not so-called "spoken" language as we experience it... (See beginning around 6:40...)
and who spoke which language...
Whatever you do… Don’t listen for how many times the first guy says “kind of”
You’re welcome
36:59 Subs correction: bifacially done.
I have a problem with trying to draw any conclusions based on skull data. We have so many recent finds of small brained hominids that have lived in our very recent past along side other hominin. We have no way of knowing how much interbreeding there was among them so any variation has multiple possible causes. DNA analysis pretty much trumps old school quantification of skull anatomy. You can pretty much throw out judging intelligence based on brain size, as well.
Do we ever get to know any of the juicy stuff? Us peasants only know what they already approved for general knowledge.
@@caradocapcunobelin2875 I concur.
What the hell do I have to do to find someone?
That coughing.
Look at the date, could be a corona case
IKR?! I’m like, someone get that possible corona away from the scientists!
what about those tribes who are still hunter gatherer ? have you chdecked their skulls ? they never had farming diet .
they do eat grass seeds though..
@@vanderdole02 did you read ? i said farming .
ҳҲ̸Ҳ̸ҳ very interesting I found out the time difference : million years until they knock two rocks together, to metallurgy another million years, then and thousands years until a car was made in my life time to going to space . We are in different time?
@@olgaroche4422 what do you mean ?
ҳҲ̸Ҳ̸ҳ according to scientists we had a extremely slow start an now we are in fast speed mode, like in the beginning time was slower compared with our time, time can compress and expand... but what I know , I am the created, God is the Creator!
Eating meat made our brains grow. Cooking meat made our jaws become smaller. Straight and simple.
So glad you have figured it out. Arrogance mixed with limited knowledge.
@@pistonmeyers I have murdered cute squirrels vacuum packed in my fridge. I'm willing to share.
We had large scale migrations into Europe during the neolithic, so perhaps the change in jaw-bones is just a sign of population replacement.
wrong time period.....thousands and thousands of years later
@@SideWalkAstronomyNetherlands At 14:00 He is looking at the transition to agriculture.
It's funny that history repeats itself, eh?
Its cos I have no friends so I go to peices about these things cos I've got nothing else going on.
The dramatic change in our diets going into the agricultural movement is too recent. Partly explains my non-Celiac severe gluten intolerance. Our guys are not adept to digest so much argicultural product (wheat,corn,rice,.....)
I kind of already seen this lecture before, I kind of think..
Why don't you like call my name or tell me where to go or whatever I'm a person you've already broken me what else is there? Yer so mean.
"kind-of" ...............bye
I will never understand where they get the idea that only humans are capable of speech when our speech capabilities is an adaptation to make speech simpler and easier. It didn't just occur one day that a human was born and said momma a few months later, earlier hominids had to be talking up a storm to create the vocal capacity we have today. Albeit their languages wouldn't be anything like ours is but simpler and more complicated. Simpler in the word variety but more complicated in the use of the fewer sounds they could make to say the words. If human intelligences with 100 years experience in speech was given a dogs vocal capabilities they could speak words just not what we would say or how we would say it.
Otzi was murdered.
Interpreting genetic information of modern man is as it is very questionable. Reconstructed genes are even more so.
@@Lucas-pe6fg In the west, markers are thought to indicate murderers, serial killers etc., and verdicts are given based on science of genetics, but now seems wrong because many other markers are not considered. A British geneticist/journalist finds. I am not a geneticist.
there is a thing called epigenetics .
@@Q_QQ_Q I know. The problem is markers do not decide alone, they decide in unison with other markers, we just haven't gone that deep.
it is uh, amazing to uh, me how many uh, speakers say ‘um’ uh, so uh much. Public speaking uh class maybe?
That, and "kind of" and "sort of" in every other sentence.