The QI Crop Circle - QI Series 8 Episode 3 Hoaxes Preview - BBC One
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 окт 2024
- Subscribe and 🔔 to the BBC 👉 bit.ly/BBCYouT...
Watch the BBC first on iPlayer 👉 bbc.in/iPlayer... More on this programme: www.bbc.co.uk/p...
A crop circle in the shape of the QI logo has appeared in a field in Wiltshire. Stephen & his guests meet the team responsible, but will they share their trade secrets?
#bbc
All our TV channels and S4C are available to watch live through BBC iPlayer, although some programmes may not be available to stream online due to rights. If you would like to read more on what types of programmes are available to watch live, check the 'Are all programmes that are broadcast available on BBC iPlayer?' FAQ 👉 bbc.in/2m8ks6v.
I love how Sean goes straight for harming horses when he knows they're in the audience 🤣🤣🤣
Before knowing they were in the studio, he said cottaging. Is harming horses worse than cottaging as an insult?
I'd like to see these three guys recreate the giant Milk Hill crop circle formation from 2001, which contained a total of 410 crop circles and appeared suddenly overnight. Do the math; it there are 410 circle in the formation, and there are 480 minutes of nighttime darkness ( 60 minutes times 8 hours ), then that works out to about one circle made every 70 seconds! And that includes time to survey the land and logistical planning, all while working in total darkness.
Well, I liked that
Funny how no one is commenting on this negatively and instead just ignore it
Still it’s better to be sceptical and look at all the “hoax evidence”, despite growing up with knowledge of hidden information so I can do the true research myself and prove it to myself anyway
Do you honestly think they did the planning and logistics on the same night!!! This would have been planned out by a group of at least 10 folk weeks in advance.
It's far easier for a group of humans to enter a field for the night unnoticed than it is for some alien space craft.
@@Coppertunes So they planned it weeks in advance to make it on a night that it was raining? Hmmmm, lol.
the best thing about this crop circle is that a Norwegian "psychic" made a documentary film about it, thinking that it was real.
It the sane thunk with religion or the anti vax movement. People wikl belive ehat they like irrespective of the truth.
I'm Norwegian and I'd never heard of this story. Funny how the one of the leading ladies of the "ooh mystical, fantastical" BS programmes at the time making a total ass of herself in the UK wasn't talked about more. Apparently she's fled to Italy to write a blog these days.
“They were winning the Mr Handsome contest.” Absolutely brilliant 😂😂😂
low hanging fruit if you ask me
How do I know those three guys aren't aliens in disguise? :o
Well, there's a tell tale trick, quite hard to see if you're not experienced ... are you ready for the reveal ----------- it's because they look like 3 normal blokes !!
"No, let's assume we wouldn't invite into the studio people who maimed animals." :D
Well i just searched "most complex crop circles" and ive seen no cc that is too difficult to draw or design for a human. Most are actually quite easy for someone with some artistic talent and understanding of geometry.
Now look up microwave elongated nodes on crop circles
Once people see the analysis of crop circles stalks and subsequent development, there’s no room to doubt advanced technology is at play.
Unfortunate that censorship and ridicule have closed discussion on this phenomenon.
I find it very possible that Aliens exist. I also think it would be very amusing to have Aliens landing in (only) fields, making strange marks, and giggling to them selves as they watch the bewildered, puny humans.
I'm sure that we can't be alone, but I'm also sure that people capable of faster than light speed trouble wouldn't bother to do confusing spirals xD
I like how many people have shown up in support of crop circles.
I think if aliens had anything important to say, they wouldn't tell us by bending bits of grass...
what makes you think so?
@@ilia2000 was 11 years ago pal...prob an old biddie that's been brown bread a few years
@@Another-li2qn What?
na guys everyone be quiet we have a deep genius here.. we must all shut up and listen to this genius of geniuses... He knows the nature of alien life, he knows the behaviour of alien life, he knows how and why alien life from another planet would go about accomplishing their goals.. We must all listen to this massive genius.
@@krixxset2214 ok. the comment to which you are replying is 12 years old now. it may in fact be older than you. do you have something important to say or what?
'Because QI is run by aliens!'
I knew it! xx
What a weak circle. I want to see how they made the "alien face crop circle" from Aug 2002
The same way they made this one - just a different team. Thats a well known hoax anyway, so no prizes for that one
I love how Asiablue answers every request for evidence with a "No, you!"
Cathedral stealing! xD
Whoops! I made the mistake of reading the comments . . . .
The most astonishing thing is how incapable some people are of imagining that human beings are able to accomplish astonishing things. Because we so plainly are. (That sentence is a good example, but I _think_ it came out right.)
One below suggests some hidden/removed commenter said art is beyond people. That statement in itself reveals the true ignorance and misunderstanding.
Omg this! Im watching streaming video on a computer that fits in my pocket yet somehow humans are incabable of making multiple circles in smashed grass.
Hey, that guy in the middle of the first photo is wearing an XKCD t-shirt!
Just love QI, great preview of much mirth ahead ;)
@2012TV actually with just a couple of people and some decent planning you could certainly make that overnight. The prank ones in the eighties certainly were- it added to the "mystery"
They were all "prank ones" - unless there is actual evidence to the contrary that is ... I'm always looking for it - but so far none that stands up has been given.
I love how one of the guys is wearing an xkcd shirt XD
ss74656 missed that, good catch!
excellent programme....can just hear the murmurs ...must be a conspiracy.....lol
crop circles look cool. Stephen keeps his job. All is good!!
NO.. There were woodcuts from the medieval period showing "devils circles' in fields. It's older than just the 1970's.
Great to see Mr Baker back on.
Just remember mocking ones, to have counterfeit money in circulation there had to be real money first.
what u men?
eh?? no comparison
@Asiablue Interesting. Care to share the sources of this evidence - presumably it's been published in peer reviewed scientific journals - or should we just take your word for it?
@Asiablue You can't make a ridiculous claim and then not back it up with anything; that's now how a debate works. Ever heard the phrase "the burden of proof lies with the prosecution"? It's up to the person making the claim to prove what they say, not vice versa.
Preposterous.
QI is not run by aliens.
It is common knowledge that the show is run by elves.
@Heiryz You're not suggesting that Aliens watch QI are you? lol
Yeah true it does only require simple techniques and tools ot make SIMPLE ass crop circles like this one.
This is an old clip, and I'm writing this Comment on the 18th of August, 2020.
It's Quite Interesting that today, an ordinary member of the public can buy and operate an incredibly sophisticated quad-copter ['drone'] equipped with a high-definition video camera and take amazing, perfectly auto-stabilised aerial shots of the landscape for just a few hundred quid.
I wonder what it cost back then to hire a professional helicopter filming outfit for the day?
Please show me one thats so complex a human couldnt even draw it. Id be really interested to see that.
I love David's shiney shirt!!!
lets forget the labour involved shall we? more work involved in making one than harvesting the damn field! and then these designs are like watermark designs you see on banknotes in terms of complexity and drawing even a simple circle requires a teamwork element. no videos of numerous records exist where they show them actually making them?
I own the t-shirt that the middle guy in the photo is wearing!!! :P
excellent programme....
How did they made them in single nights?
with planks and tape measures - and night goggles where necessary
@@stuartanthony6409 Oh wow, yes night goggles , and they pole jumped into the crop so that they did not leave any "footprints" in the field of where they entered and left afterwards, just like Doug Bower and Dave Chorley said they did, and people believed they actually pole jumped into the field ?! well some people, i guess you are one of those who think that is possible.
Wooo! Wiltshire!
@Asiablue
awww bless your simple heart
Is it real or is it man made ?
XD
Can a person walk in a field without leaving footprints ?
Short answer - yes. Down the tramlines - or indeed through the crop if its not wet
when Doug Bower and Dave Chorley left and entered the field for making crop circles . . . they pole jumped, thats what they said when someone asked them how they could manage to not leave any footprints in fields where there was no tramlines, yes POLE JUMPED, no of course that is not possible.
Sorry, but Doug and Dave are not responsible for all crop circles even this gang is unable to create hundreds of circles that have appeared in a particular formation overnight. Do they also go to the trouble of microwaving each and every node in the wheat as well? Damaging crops is an offence so why wasn't this lot arrested.
Interesting Qropcircle.
even 90 square kilometers can be done by a 10 man team over a night, if you can do two square meters per minute, which is extremely easy with a plank.
surely you mean 90 sq meters ?
It's very cool and I'm glad that Alan Davies got the correct answer because he's usually the one who loses points by getting the answer wrong, xxxx
Seems a bit corny
These cereal miscreants must stop!
@Asiablue I'd be more inclined to take your comment seriously if it hadn't taken you three weeks to come up with it. I'll be sure to check back on the 8th of December when you might have a witty response ready.
oh, look, it's David :)
Just like Banksy.......different medium that's all.
OMG Stephen's haircut looks like richard hammond's
Just because some are man-made, doesn't prove they all are.
Ilove David's shiney shirt!!!
Yes youre saying that but i see no proof. Even the most complex ones are easy to design and possible do by a group of people. Some of the known manmade ones (like the ones by the circlemakers) dont have broken stalks, just bent even spiral. There are also examples of the complex ones being done over more than one night. Like this one, often being one of the examples of the "too complex for humans to do" circles. abovetopsecret . com/forum/thread478354/pg1
What are the artists names?
It would be nice if people just considered the the better ones art.
they do
@Asiablue Yes, I probably would.
@nahatsu2 "was"? This is a teaser of next friday's episode. Or are you from the future?
I'm from the future. This was a good episode.
What is it with Sean and animal violence?
that was sweet
@2012TV so was it crop circles that made you crazy, or just the schizophrenia?
i wanna do some oneday
Oh my, the comments are more entertaining than the video..
Oh boy.
nice.
agents of deception
As one of the people who made the QI circle, I can confirm we are all employed by the government and get paid huge amounts of cash to spread disinformation. Theres a girl in this episode who can lick her elbow - shown at the end.
Why did they give it away??
Because it's so simple, and to prove to people who think it's somehow special that it's doable by humans.
i wonder if those norwegian women have seen this episode
who's that then?
@marcmischief I'm scared to ask if you're serious incase it's a joke.
Crub cirkel XD
more like crap cirkel XD
Crab circle *snappysnappy*
Wow...these guys were making them in the 30s and 40s?! OK Fry man...whatever you say! It's on the bbc...must be true
Please... its just a bunch of circles... circlemakers . org/Img/1trip.gif
All. Crop. Circles are all human made
You're so smart...how many times did they jab you? 🤔 I'm gonna guess at least 3
Time for your booster ?
Is it real or manmade? Ayayay.
You'd think that the logo was a hint...
@Asiablue I take it you don't have any proof? And also, do you by any chance happen to be American?
@stonemonkey999 yea ;)
The No.1 important question that was not addressed on this program is: HOW MANY DAYS DID IT TAKE TO MAKE? Anybody know? Stephen Fry tried to make out that is was made over night - which i am guessing is not true.
@whowantsabighug It really happened
@Asiablue Maybe the aliens coming to Earth will force me to when they come. Until then, I'm just fine like this.
Making claims like that without having anything to back up your claims is like me saying that Jim Morrison and Michael Jackson live in my garage. Oh, and Elvis visits them from time to time as well.
I'm missing something. Why would they put so much effort and work to make all those magnificent crop circles that are found. Many them are insanely complex and precise.
I have hard time to believe that they would do them just for the lulz.
To confuse, to deceive, for artful purposes. The ceiling of the Sistine Chapel wasn't done for the lulz... well I don't suppose. But what if it was, wouldn't that be great?
actually do any amount of research on the topic and you'll be surprised what you find out.
Kathie dart replied to 15 comments on this video, yes i'm bored enough to count
and the proof?
@soldatheero Yea great insult pal throw them at me plz.
Truth hurts yea, as so to attack an btw it was ment to be a joke, hint ^^
Nowhere near the complexity or size of other crop circles
Erm ... its the logo the commission required, not some really complex design. Dohh!!!!!
@RoaccVideos That is what they are trying to subliminally putting in peoples head. They are wrong though, there are some genuine crop circles.
@mischellewright69 hmmm-mmmm I see
Disinformation at its best 👏👏👏👏👏
Why?
@@stuartanthony6409 man-made crop circle are some of them not all of them. A particular evidence that isn't mentioned is that the wheat isn't broken but folded, even today in 2021 humanity does not possess this technology. There is a lot more to it I've been studying crop circles for the past 7 years. This guys are just making a TV program for what they are paid for not for what is true
@@nickpillitu9042 mate I can fold wheat with my hands what kinda Stone Age technology do you have access to?
@@garethferguson4434 i would love to see you folding wheat without breaking it.
Implying that every crop circle is a hoax?
I dont think so
If art is a hoax then sure. But it's only a hoax if it's intended to be interpreted as NOT man made, which I'm sure it's not.
it's on the BBC so it has to be true.. :)
Ya this is a lie the first crop circle were spotted when we first flew. And most im sure no man can make what it is are people making fun as they would even make fun of god.
@dragonforks93 no i even think the perfect ones are man made. no one should underestimate the advancement and ingenuity of the human race, especially humans themselves.
@crisisofconsciousnes It's not made by humans. There, dismissed. Now move along, please
Of course it is, they did it.
@WonderlandPirate The proof is being collected by UK scientists and some from other countries. Denial means nothing to me. If you believe the circles are caused by something else then proof it, or at least present something I can google to verify your claims. I'm not going to waste my time on a toy like RUclips and think it to be a serious 'debate.'
@dragonforks93 ya it is possible someone has good tech but it is also quite possible its aliens? i mean why not? they found encrypted messages in some of them but i suspect it is some human activity like graffiti on walls but the smart human version. if its not that then its aliens hahahah
@WonderlandPirate I would not have troubled myself to respond at all if not for responding to a more recent comment on this thread. Proof? Debate? If i bottled ET and mailed him off to you be FED EX you'd demand a DNA check from an independant laboratory. lol
@7j8i9m Noob
vgbn
no real crop circles made by humans
And they want to get 15 minuits of fame
@mattyofWBB haha well the jokes on you.. I'v read through this page before, its a terrible attempt at a debunk. The real circle makers are farrr more sophisticated then these guys.
@Sambolicious Condesending answers reflect badly on you. A simple Google or RUclips search would be fine, too, but clearly too much for you. Let me know if ET gives you a call...lol
This comment section is pure cancer.