French parliament spontaneously breaks into national anthem in honour of attack victims
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 янв 2015
- In a parliamentary session dedicated to last week's violence, members of the French Parliament stood in silence for one minute on Tuesday (January 13).
...
Watch the Euronews live news channel here: / euronews
Find us on:
Website: www.euronews.com/nocomment
Twitter: / nocomment
Facebook: / euronews.nocomment
Instagram: / nocomment_euronews
Tiktok: / nocomment_euronews
Flipboard: flipboard.com/@euronews/no-co...
Newsletter: www.euronews.com/follow-us#ne...
No Comment is brought to you by euronews, the most watched news channel in Europe.
#Nocomment
Le haut-parleur: "Une minute de silence"
Le Parlement français: Non.
@Darth Nihilus Indeed it was not complicated to understand
@Darth Nihilus it’s... almost like almost all of those French words look like English words 😳
Remarque tellement stupide ! La représentation nationale chantant l’hymne national à une bien plus grand portée. Réfléchissez ...
@@voyagevoyage8966 Je pense qu'il le sait. C'était surtout pour la blague.
Haha haut-parleur means a speaker as for listening music, not the man who talks
Imagine how cringe this would be if nobody else went along with it
Epic
Alone, but still standing
Oddly enough, we haven't yet reached the point of decay where this could happen..
Lmaooooo
It's June 6th 2005. (The evening of D Day 1944 anniversary ) Im in the bar of a formula One truck stop at Cherbourg Normandie . all at once A chorus of voices strike up with a german marching song "Watch am Rhein " Who are these people,? They are (French re-enactors playing as German Wheremcht ) I say to my buddy what are we going to do, He replies "Careful Age, Don't start anything, there is a lot of em "- And then I remembered the film I've seen a dozen times , Casablanca. I raise myself up on the barstool and begin to sing " Allons enfants de la Patria" Instantly 40 truck drivers took up the stirring strains of the French National Anthem and drowned out the Cardboard Vichy collaborators. The honour of France was maintained.
@@jeandupont8501 you could value the minute of silence over the need to sing the anthem at that moment. I think it's crass to disrespect the silence even though it's the national anthem
*Napoleon Bonaparte himself marches in shortly after*
as always :D
La marseillaise took place way after Napoleon. It was le chant du depart at that time
Ironically, Napoleon had banned the Marsaillaise.
He just nukes Iraq
*SHORTLY* after
One minute of silence.
One random guy: nope, not doing that
Everyone else: yeah we neither
Nice 69 likes
France in a nutshell
I think they cut the video so people didn't have to wait a minute before hearing what the came for from the title
Oui neither
One guy this is boring I need some spice
Funny how this gets recommended as Americans are storming the capitol.
French revolution 2
@@makutas-v261 Wonky riot
Napolean wasn't singing when the capitol was stormed in 1814
I was thinking the same thing.
Corious
A very underrated historic moment in this century.
No
@@br4054 yes
It was very intensely lived in France and Belgium. Being a foreigner there at the time, it felt like you were part of history at that moment.
@@vaggs75 Netherlands to
fr
The only thing everybody seemed to miss is the fact that the congressman called for a minute of silence, yet they all broke the silence less than 10 seconds after... Beatiful anthem tho
I think it is more respectfull to sing the national anthem, those who died would have want soo
The french can’t do anything without breaking something or burning it
Because it was better than silence. That was the point.
Silence was replaced with something far greater
@@alexvonrom7942 Do you have a source to say that they would "want to". That just seems like your subjective opinion.
Beautiful. Room full of people that disagree, probably vehemently so on certain issues, coming together to sing the anthem of the nation that brought them all together.
I wish we had more moments like this in the states. This kind of nationalism, of virtuous patriotism, is what made those men and women set aside their differences to honor and respect their country and countrymen. And it was beautiful and inspiring.
@@robertstaples3256 Very well said, and so true. We need to get back to where we can have a discussion about our issues, otherwise none of them get fixed, we're just fighting with no purpose or solutions.
@@delzerui4975 there's a communist party in the French Government?
@Wind Rose indeed
@Wind Rose Of healthy fake democracy you wanted to say?
The only national anthem that is way way better than a moment of silence
svenskt namn
@@roskcity jajamen
Well not enr
Tirely true
Deutschlandlied?
All verses of the deutschlandlied
This is so patriotic!
Gabriel Miranda You don't know eritreans or somalis, sudan people etc. horrible! in western european countries
Racism is horrible. But what is more horrible is islam
This hymn as about fighting tyranny . Racism is obviously tyrany. Fuck racism.
The ideology of those right wing barbarics is quiet similar to the ideology of islam.
Toni Schumacher islam is also tyranny
My cat listened to this. He’s still a cat but he’s wearing a beret, eating cheese and a baguette and criticising my cooking
Hon hon hon and a oui oui oui.
I'd love to like your comment, but a magic number is holding back my finger
@@yohan9641 ah yes, the 69
C‘est Nestor
When I read "beret" I somehow thought you then were gonna say he'd be outfitted in lizard camo, smoking a cigarette and grumbling about needing to take back Tien Bien Phu.
The youtube algorithm definitely knows what’s up. Welcome to 2021 my friends.
Greetings back!
As a french guy, dont think it was disrespectful, it wasnt at all it is even more respectful and im really glad they did that.
Who on this Earth could think , French or not, that this could be disrespectful? Nuts ..
The only disrespect i feel in this scene is that all of them are politicians and well, we dont respect the people who screw us all and dip with the money.
The act in itself however? All good
French parliament : *Patriotic choral*
American capitol : *ARMA 3*
Ptdr
Vive Le Québec - 🇫🇷
Classic quebecers
@@lightzpy8049 vive la francophonie canadienne 🇨🇦!
@@lightzpy8049 on a beau se moquer de votre accent, on vous admire !
The truly sad thing about watching this now is that I wouldnt remember which terrorist attack against France this was mourning, if it wasn’t for the news banner. There’s been way too many.
... Sadly yes
F
"Lest water our fields with their blood"
Pretty badass French Anthem
I C BAJ forsen1
Not “their” blood but that of the people, actually, this has to do with the origins of the anthem: a revolution of the people against the elites, it’s a way of saying that the people is ready to commit sacrifice for the sake of the community (feed the soil to fertilize it).
More precisely: "Let an impure blood water our furrows". BTW: Nobles were supposed to be of pure blood, unlike the vast majority of the people who had to fight 8 countries right after the Revolution started - hence the reference to the 'impure' when speaking of the very French citizens going to war.
Respect from The Netherlands. It keeps inspiring to see the french has kept his identity stilll fresh from the revolution it started once. Respect!
yeah, I seriously doubt even half the Dutch parliament and cabinet know the Wilhelmus...
But the EU themesong they can all sing along to of course, the traitors.
@@jwenting 17th of March those traitors will be removed.
@@Elliott2001 ik hoop het, maar denk het niet. Niet door de verkiezingen.
@@Elliott2001 why? Is there a movement of "dutchexit"?
@@jwenting yeah and then there is Germany....
J’ai toujours des frissons quand j’entends cet hymne.
(Je suis Québécois.)
Les Québécois ❤️ Les Français
For me a french Guy the things that blow my mind it's that actually all our député are here in the same room that's just unbelievable XD
Oui d'habitude ils sont pas plus d'une dizaine et la ils sont full mdr
@@-erebor-2361 oui oui baguette
@@user-fz3ip3ke8p yeah yeah hamburger
@@-erebor-2361 based
@@user-fz3ip3ke8p ?
Le Marseillaise is one of the most powerful anthems. They were singing so somberly, and it sounds reverential. When its sung heartily, it sounds triumphant.
tears, vive la france
From the USA and Kyiv Ukraine, Vive le France, France had a Ukrainian Queen Anne of Kyiv....
I cried a little even though I'm not French. Wish our country could act like this...
@@Junr-lc7no sadly, this is really rare. Far left actually hate his own country, just like in America. France is no exception
@@hugebeebop2955 Far left doesn't have any significant following in France nor in the US.
@@danorott not in the power instances, but they have a huge power on the culture and education of the youth. I can observe my generation, and it's easy to notice it
This is the kind of nationalism we need more of!
@@niklas5923 just semantics
Amen brother.....since when did Patriotism and Nationalism become "evil" words?
That's the truth!
@Gulf Relay I take your point, but bear in mind that you are listening to the singing of a more than 200 year old anthem (the product of its times) by a democratically-elected group of representatives. Perhaps your 1933 parallel is not so parallel.
@Gulf Relay Stupidity never fails. How dare you accuse one of the greatest democracies on earth of harbouring midevil sentiments like revenge? Vive la France.
This gives me chills and I'm not French
french anthem is beautiful (first time i hear it), got goosebumps. very symbolic and emotional moment.
love from germany to our french friends 🤝🇫🇷
The french anthem is actually pretty special. It was never composed to be an anthem. But a war song. It bears a heavy History and symbolism. That is why one of the top song for supporters during World Cups is... the national anthem, which ehoes all throughout the stadium during games.
Germany is our model somewhere. France has so many respect for you ! we just don't understand why Germany always choose US for their defense and partnership.
Because us buy their cars
I‘ve done it 🤩 made the 69 everything achived in my life
Sus🤨
I was always amazed about french patriotism. Best wishes from Czechia!
🇨🇿🇫🇷
Czech Republic *
@@ing.hemoroid9938 OFCOURSE :D
France is such a wonderful country. May it prosper and be kept safe. Vive la France !
Walter Joosten lol no
Paul Goodier if you acually knew something about france you would know that they have more backbone than any other country in the world.
@@Theuselessguitarist They are the laughing stock of the world. A testament to what happens when you lose your own identity and bow to foreign elements and influence. France hasnt been France for a very long time.
@@tacticalgaming4765 you mean Islam?
@@tacticalgaming4765 Well they shouldn't have brought all the foreign "elements" to build their roads and buildings while stealing the resources from the same foreign countries .
From an Englishman.. Vive La France!
De la part d'un Français... Long live Great Britain!
It gives dept, when you know that the french anthem is basicly a death threat to its enemies.
Our Anthem is a war anthem created when the coalized Europe attacked our newly proclaimed republic. This is more a song about war, sacrifice, solidarity, patriotism and, about fighting those who betray the people (nobility amongst them). By the way, they won.
Shocked us in Scotland 🏴 as well.
France 🇫🇷 is like a brother to us.
Like Scotland 🏴 France 🇫🇷 is brave
thanks bro !! scotland and france forever brother !!!
France brave?? FUNNY
hdhdj hdhd France has the greatest military history, fucking dumbass go to school.
thx. We don't forget our Auld Alliance :)
@hdhdj: Read about La Légion étrangère and The Battle of Camarón. 63 french légionaires have stood up to 3000 Mexican soldiers for the covetheir they were responsible to arrive safely.
And now compare it with "braves" US boys how drone civilans.
Sorry Scotland.France is like a brother to us.France and Spain neighbors and brothers.
That was really moving.
Spontaneous, honest, restrained, respectful. A wonderful demonstration.
The way you can tell that they sing it in a not patriotic way, but a more solum tone was touching.
This is more touching than a minute's silence.
very powerful, your pain is our pain France love from Turkey
ismini değiştir istersen Erdoğani pek sevmezler.
gta 5 one day france will return as a christian country and we kick terrorist islam out and kick every secular bastard
The roots of france is christianity
BOXING BOXING wow, christianity
Tufan Öcal thanks
Red Eye turk
Vive la France, et vive notre Europe!
Colin McDonald vive la France mais pas l’Union européenne
Not the Union
Just Europe
Meme Man Ahhh you have your own opinion
Meme Man ZA DOM !
Now that is patriotism
The best part is they don’t applaud themselves for being so patriotic and clever at the end. Not like America.
Very under rated comment.
(I think we both know why.)
I agree
Yes because it was sung for a good reason. Very noble indeed
I've only seen applaud after an Anthem in the US and it's so weird to me honestly.
@@avocadosareweird5172 I'm not sure why we do. Personally, I think it's a respect thing, applauding the singer and the anthem.
Vive la liberté!! xx
Support you France 🇫🇷 freedom forever
Upon hearing this in the UK, my hand shook so much that my tea spilled all over my trousers.
The French are Coming.
"Not for you this time" X)
I wouldn't worry mate, if their track record is anything to go by they won't be able to cross the channel. The only 'French' people to manage that were actually Vikings pretending to be French.
Respects from Louisiana
You mean the US? Louisiana is not a country
Its a state so its fine
@@thylaggyone4513 Wtf? Its not a separate country you liberals always wanting to succeed from the union smh
@@tripleastacz372 I never meant to say that. Hell, I never even implied it. So what the hell are you going on about?
@@tripleastacz372 Respects from the US. I say Louisiana because how important France is to the history of Louisiana. Also stop going around calling people liberal, it’s cringe.
The youtube algorithm is extremely wise.
From where I come from our parliament once spontaneously broke into a drunk brawl.
Haven’t all parelmients had that happen at some point
Lemme guess, Uganda.
Ireland?
Ah yes, my type of parliament. True democracy!
Ukraine?
Legend says Napoleon himself was resurrected in the centre
L'Empereur est immortel.
😂
Funny you say that, Napoleon actually banned La Marseilles because he thought of it as a reminder of the terror of the French Revolution but okay.
@@anti-loganpaul7827 He didn't say he was resurrected for good
@@Chorophilax What?
God bless the man who started singing the national anthem.
France when people talk about them surrendering once when they've won more battles than any other nation
Random Stuff.Merci beaucoup!De tout notre cœur!
Vous nous rendez justice.
Parfois,les anglo-saxons oublient que la France était la seule grande puissance à posséder des frontières terrestres avec l'Allemagne en oubliant qu'il est plus facile de juger quand une mer ou un océan vous séparent de l'ennemi.
Ils oublient qu'en 14/18 notre pays a perdu plus d'1 million 300000 hommes au combat.
Ils oublient qu'en 1940,60000 allemands ont été tués pendant la campagne de France qui ne fut certes pas pour eux"une partie de plaisir!"
Ils oublient de préciser que les officiers allemands craignaient et admiraient les soldats français.Merci encore!
Their great victories do not change the fact that the single most devastating loss of all time was the French campaign in 1940.
@@teutonic_crusader1175 Tu représentes parfaitement l'anglo-saxon bien stupide dont je parle plus haut en réponse à "Random Stuff!"
Tu ne sais rien de cette campagne mais tu en parles comme si tu l'avais vécue alors que tu ignores tout de celle-ci.
Je ne vais pas te demander de réfléchir ça te prendrait trop de temps et ça userait tes trois derniers neurones.Pour ma part je ne vais même plus te répondre tu n'es pas assez intelligent pour ça!
@@teutonic_crusader1175 Well, there are two ways of seeing this fact :
The first one being that France was weak and ill prepared for WWII
The second one being that France spent the whole 30s to develop a completely pacific politics, creating mandatory holidays (15 days, still higher than the average US worker in 2021) for all French workers, social aids, lowered the working hours to 40h/week (all of this, a western world first) ... Basically, took care of its own people without wanted to cause any trouble abroad.
So, what/who's to blame ? Should France had not done all of this but built a huge army with aggressive behaviours instead ?
Truly speaking, the 1940 defeat if nothing proves France was one of the few country in Europe that had the right values and politics. If more countries had done the same, the world would have been a better place to live today.
@@jean-luchochart6960 la défaite française de 1940 et surtout les années de soumission qui ont suivies sont une 0art honteuse de notre histoire. Cela n'efface en rien les autres victoires glorieuses. Mais c'est un fait.
As an American, I am proud to be able to sing the first two stanzas of La Marseillaise en francais!
Oh wouahw bravo, it is very complicated to sing with that melody for the French but then for foreigners I guess not even, you're right to be proud 😊😊
Impressive.
@Waldeinsamkeit , My pleasure mon frere and likewise!!
Patriotism at it’s finest. 🇫🇷
This is even better when you know that they actually all hate each other here
Love from the US. We will always stand by you, you fought for our freedom alongside us all those years ago. We haven't forgotten.
Neither do we have.
We stand with you, in this difficult times.
The past is the past. I would argue that you don't owe us anything, nor do we owe you anything. Best terms ever.
oh dear! read some history. the French fought as a cynical way to get revenge on the British because we had crushed them in Canada and India. however the stupid French bankrupted themselves in so doing which led in the end to the evil French revolution where thousands of innocents were murdered. - out of interest; after American independence the US actually decided to trade with Britain rather than France.
Un de ces rares moments où nos parlementaires représentent le peuple et servent la Nation...
Came back from champagne tasting in Reims yesterday, France is a wonderful country. Unfortunatly see more and more American influence.
American influence? In what way
@@georgeskanderbeg3242 You mean that rotten thing, democracy? lol
@@johnrobinson4445 I think he means culture not government
@@johnrobinson4445 contrary to 30 years ago most youths in France can now speak english, so they to tend to consume more american media, hollywood films , american music etc..and the mindsets change with it. so I think what he meant is that he missed losing a bit of that french uniqueness to american global influence when he was on holidays in France
@@NPJGlobal rubbish amerikaaa
France has the best anthem
We stand united 🇫🇷🇬🇧🏴
This is so patriotic, my scone just morphed into a croissant
Respect from Russia.
The only moment in French history where the parlement was full 🥲
So true 😂
I nearly cry...
It's not often mankind gets a moment they should be well and truly proud of, but this is absolutely beautiful.
Time to save Europe
That is so much more moving and inspiring than a minute silence.
Apart from all the memes, does no one else realise how beautiful and patriotic that was, it was so much nicer than a minute of silence and especially those who understand what the lyrics say know what im talking about
Прекрасные люди в плане своего патриотизма к стране.
P.S.
Представляете, чтобы Госдума РФ так сделала?
Вот и я не представляю...
“Une minute de silence”
One absolute legend in the French parliament: *non, ne fait pas.*
the video cut the minute of silence since there was nothing to show. they DID respect it, and started to sing after it ended.
I find more strength in a National Anthem and not one minute of silence.... 🇬🇧🇫🇷
they did both, video was just cut
What a beautiful moment this was. Glory to France from Hungary!
Thank you. Glory to Hungary from France too! :)
@@roigrisouille1625 nn là c'est gênant.. 😅
Why does this song always hit me in the feels? I'm not even French.
Because it's their anthem. It's meant to motivate people to fight for their country.
La première fois que je vois autant de personnes dans l’hémicycle !
Why am I only hearing this for the first time today? Beautiful!
0:43 left corner : Jason Statham 2.0
I honestly strongly dislike minutes of silence. I can’t help but be very uncomfortable. The anthem is a much better way. Memories have sounds attached to them, not silence.
This is oddly wholesome , but also eerie at the same time.
RUclips: hmmmm, yes, would you like to watch this six year old video that you can’t even understand
You wont see that in germany. The patriotism of france is so beautifull.
Germany needs more diversity
No, france has a great lack of patriotism, maybe not as much as germany, but still compared to the us for exemple its very low
Let's say it's a strange patriotism. It's invisible most of the time. It only appears in the time of crisis. The opposite of the US I would say, who are so patriotic most of the time but divide and fight themselves so much when they need union.
@@chiefrabbischlomosteinberg4953 No
@@gauthierloustaunau5396 thats... actually true ive never thought of that
Every government should be this respectful
If this happened in The House of Commons, a good three-quarters of MPs wouldn't even know HOW to sing the UK National Anthem! Throughly embarrassing! 🇬🇧🤯🇬🇧🤯🇬🇧🤯
In fairness, yer national anthem is embarrassing.
It should so clearly be rule Britannia
What's really interesting is that for once they were almost all present that day.
Some guy: *sings *
Practically everyone: haha lookit dis dood
Claude Bartolone: *sings *
_You have unlocked the French Parliament Choir_
March on to greatness, respect and condolences from the USA
We English have always held great admiration for the French in times of adversity, they are so stoic in their convictions.
Anyone else getting this recommended to them 6 years later?
Youtoube 🤷♂️
Some weren’t singing. That one must be scary for politicians !
France's national anthem is.... a bit bloodthirsty for the modern era.
@@hagamapama Boohohoo, blood bad, war bad.
@Michael Arnold I don't even really like the Marseillaise, I essentially associate it to regicide and the horrors the french revolution inflicted upon it's own people. But the mention of "modern era" in the comment upset me lol it's like french should change the anthem because "omg it's violent"
those who weren't singing are from left wing "communist" anti patriotic !
@@roms4154 depends if you see nationalism as patriotic, communists think their way is the best way for france so in a way they are trying to help france and so they are patriotic
We can all agree that this is the kind of European "Nationalism" all of us like
Edit: I want you to notice how i put "Nationalism" instead of just Nationalism
Yeah, i see you name fits with your ideas
That's not nationalism. That's patriotism. It's important to make the difference.
@RED RED I think the whole world can guess what your favorite color is man, by looking at ur previous comments
@RED RED ah yes, because destroying my country with socialist policies is the best nationalism.
This is not nationalism, this is just "patriotism". Nothing beats true Nationalism, where you truly love your nation and defend it to the end, not for superiority sake but for the right to be. This "patriotism" is weak and useless, a sign of weakness. In the face of danger and hardship you need to be assertive. This is just kumbaya patriotism... 5 years ago, plenty attacks in France since... nothing has been done about it.
2015 is now 6 years ago 😔
Viva la France 🇫🇷
I really like how they unite , so patriotic
In Germany that would not be possible. I guess 80% of our parliament, didn't know the text of our Anthem 😂
Die linken und grünen wurden pfeiffen
@TheWeeaboo - if France leads Europe then Europe is finished.
The only time they went on patriotic mode...
Imagine how proud the guy that started to sing the song
Beautiful. Long live the people of Europe!
Feel envious of the passion our french neighbours put in singing their anthem 💯
Spain is 1,000,000 better than France
@@marcokite Agree with that, my friend ♥️🏆
@@marcokite I don't think so 🗼🗼🗼🗼🗼🗼
The French could teach us something about patriotism and love of country. Cannot imagine our Congress breaking into our national anthem !!
what is stoping you from electing patrootic congressmen
Just because they sing the national anthem does not mean they care about the country lmao why is everyone making this a big deal
I love the French anthem so much.
Reminds me of the time when the West German parliament sang their National Anthem after they found out that the Berlin Wall had fallen in the same moment...
France and Europe. You can't have one without the other. Hard to imagine a civilised Europe without France
No
*meanwhile france being stormed by islam*
@@bootsyuos8234 no
@@mxmlnlcdcdffmnt2232 What did he say wrong?
@@Pajdas610 its not only wrong but its also a dumb racist
God bless the great people of France.
This is one of the most powerful things I have ever seen....
This would never, and I mean NEVER happen in the german parlament..... sadly..
Indeed.. It would perhaps would be considered a controversy.. Especially if the MPs from AFD started it and someone joined them. Germany needs to stop with the pointless self hate...
But but... they are proud of their country! *They are literal nazis* :(
@@garp9269 i might have misunderstood your comment but if a german should be able to love his nation and be patriotic without being called a nazi. This is a big problem not only for Germany but for Europe in general. I’m swiss and i can tell you, almost no one knows the national anthem. There is barely any patriotism. Swiss are most patriotic in the football world championship. Its really sad
Yes, certain ethno-religious group would cry out in desperation to UN if it happens, twitter would become crazy and attempt to cancel a whole country.
Oh, Germany, how far you have fallen, how the true evil of the world has destroyed your understanding of your own history.
@@motivationlessaxolotl8266 I think he/she joked but yeah agree.
I am German and think it is sad, like I never sang the national anthem ever, and just heard it before football game.
But I also think that the anthem should have been replaced after WWII because it's kind of weird to have national anthem with banned verses
For those who think that this was “Breaking” the minute of silence. First of all by the time the anthem started there were maybe only seconds left of silence as the minute is never a full minute. Second the person who started it is actually doing something in line with what happens in military ceremonies were the minute of silence or the specific tune played for the dead in the French army is always ended by the national anthem (maybe as a note of hope, looking at the future).
Much better than a moment of silence.
Beautiful and very moving, in the face of adversity - it doesn't matter if you believe in nations, kingdoms, good or bad - this was very uplifting.