Listening to Marillion: Brave, Part 4
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 фев 2023
- If you enjoy what you're watching and would like to contribute, then I'd be massively grateful for a cup of coffee! www.buymeacoffee.com/jimnewstead
There are also membership options available if you feel super generous!
If you want to fast track a reaction, click here: www.buymeacoffee.com/jimnewst...
Mail me: Jim Newstead, PO Box 6487, Milton Keynes, MK10 1RE, United Kingdom
www.discogs.com/user/beatswor...
Part Four of BRAVE by Marillion
This is the 2018 Steven Wilson Remix of the 1994 original.
All rights and music: Marillion, Parlophone Records
Apple Music here: / brave-2018-steven-wils...
Amazon - amzn.to/3YlZZZq
_________________________________________________________________________________
Spotify playlist of music used on this channel: tinyurl.com/jf3fdxfy
www.mixcloud.com/jimnewstead/
Stream and buy Jim's music on Bandcamp - www.jimnewstead.bandcamp.com
'A mountain isn't far to fall
When you've fallen
When you've fallen from the moon...'
It cracks me up, again and again ❤
Those lines are on the back of the t-shirt that I am currently wearing ❤
Absolutely agree.
You ain't crying. I am. ❤❤❤Huuuge band. Greetings Dirk Belgium
There's nothing more beautiful than the end of Great Escape/Falling From The Moon. Those lyrics (ending the story) and moving into that gut wrenching guitar solo is, I feel, one of the greatest moments in the history of music. There isn't a time I've ever listened to that where I haven't choked up, in 30 years.
How anyone can listen to The Great Escape - whether for the first time or the thousandth - and not be moved, especially at the Falling from the Moon part, is beyond me. I still turn into a blubbering mess every time I listen to it.
Yes!❤
This album has completely changed my way to listen the music. I must have listened to the whole album 10-15 times before i could get into it! because the music was so different and every song is so incredible intense and deep, this music caught me completely. After that i listened to it every day for over 2 years. A tipp for everyone: put on headphones and listen in the dark, then the music works even better...
An absolute masterpiece - the album holds up so well and, as you pointed out, it was so different from what was being burped out at the time. Thanks to Marillion and thanks you Jim.
Something about side 4 from the ‘94 released vinyl:
The double-LP vinyl release of Brave features a double groove on the final side of the album, providing two endings to the story of this concept album. The first groove plays "The Great Escape" as heard on the CD, followed by "Made Again", providing the happy ending; the second groove plays "The Great Escape (Spiral Remake)" and 7 minutes of water noise, providing the downer ending.
Masterpiece. My favourite one from Marillion. Remembering so well when I bought it in Berlin in 94, during my military duties. Was feeling miserable being so far from my family in France and just passing through a sentimental break I didn't expect. This album save me from desperation. Gorgeous sad and extraordinary music.
I was 17 when Brave came out and I loved it. Absolutely loved it...right in the middle of Britpop as you say (which I also loved!).
30 years later (can't believe it's that long) and I still love it...but parenthood has changed me. I can't listen to this album without full-on crying.
The whole of Side 4 (Brave, Great Escape & Made Again) is just a blub-fest. Context + parenthood.
Haven't listened to this album in its entirety for probably 10 years or so, but watched it with you here and ive no tears left.
Well done Marillion.
This album was released when we lost a son to miscarriage..couldn't listen to it for ages after the event..listening to it Live and indeed studio...tears my heart apart...such an emotional album
Thank you for listening to this record with us. It’s a pleasure to share this listening. Hope « Marbles » will follow one day 😊
Ditto !! Marbles is one of their best!!
As a preferred "Fish" guy when it comes to Marillion, this was the album that reconnected me to this incredible band after struggling (outside of "Easter") with the earlier Hogarth stuff. A return back to their progressive and conceptual excellence.
Un album sombre, mais tellement magnifique, incroyablement brillant ! Il fait partie de mon top 5 parmi tout ce que j'ai pu écouter à ce jour...
Great reaction to a great album all we have to do now is get you to listen to "Afraid of Sunlight"
Love that title track "brave" it's stunning.
I'm enjoying your channel Jim.
You are totally reliving me back in 1993 or so. I used to travel for work. I had loved Marillion since A Script For A Jesters Tear In the 80s. Anyway, I was driving up in Edinburgh listening to Brave. My favourite album of all time. The last 3 tracks are unbelievable and mean so much to me. Your reaction was priceless. Like me in the car going, "this is outrageously awesome"
You need to review This Strange Engine next.
I haven't listened to the album in its entirety for a long time. Great stuff. Thanks for sharing.
When Steve Rothery comes in on Falling From the Moon I think it may be the most beautiful thing I've ever hear. It's also good to know it's not just me who squeaks on their guitar strings, although it sounds a lot less musical when I do it.
Jim - think about the album from 1995 Afraid of Sunlight...
Such a wonderful album that brings back so many memories. When I first bought Brave back in the 90s, I played it to death, and the music is still so haunting when I hear it again today. Next album would be Afraid Of Sunlight, which explores the destructive power of fame. Trust me Jim, it's another masterpiece!
Why did l not listen to Marillion years ago. It's nice to have good music in these tragic time's.
Afraid Of Sunlight next, young man! 😀
Thanks for this Jim, as someone very familiar with this album it was a pleasure to watch you explore its contents through fresh eyes and ears!
The album actually ended after The Great Escape, but the record company didn't want a sad ending. So the song Made Again was recorded and added as the last track.
Clutching at Straws is also a must listen, the best album with Fish.
And if you're planning to do a Valentine song, check out Cliche by Fish. A great song about how to express yourself to your lover ❣️
Absolutely agree, essential listening.
Yes indeed. Cliché is THE song to dedicate to the woman you love.
This album has its jewels among the rock(s) songs; like Brave.
"Brave" is a wonderful album, and "Marbles" pushes further
great !!.... Lets go for "FEAR" (Marillion)😊
There is also a video Brave. Well worth a watch.
Look at Made Again live 2013... it's great fun!!
Dear Jim - thank you very much for such an extraordinary journey with Brave :)
Hey Jim great reaction as always. Always loved this album, I might have to shell out for the vinyl now.
Album ends...and breathe...
As good an album as I have ever heard and has there ever been a more perfect ending to an album? After the doom and gloom of the previous songs and the anger and sadness of the awesome 'The Great Escape', 'Made Again' just uplifts and, for me, redeems the entire album.
As someone who recovered many years ago from severe depression, I can truly relate to 'Made Again' and attest to how accurate a portrayal of emerging from the deepest dark into the light this is. I remember the world being 'made again,' fresh and new as if seeing it for the first time - such a special song.
Just listened to this all the way through after not picking it up for a while. It’s simply awesome!
Great to see your experiences with Holidays and Brave, two stunningly brilliant albums from the high point of their classic period. But, just wait, as you haven't heard their best work yet- Season's End, Afraid of Sunlight and Clutching at Straws (if you haven't heard that)!
Bless you, Jim. I have enjoyed many of your albums on your channel in the time I have been coming here, but this is one of my favorites. So far.
It does not happen often, sadly, but on those rare occasions where a group & their music syncs with my spirit, it is instantaneous. I can tell in a minute that this is going to be something special that starts a whole new rabbit hole for me to explore.
The last time that happened to me was over a year ago when I tripped over a reaction to Devin Townsend's "Kingdom" EMG video. Blew my head clear off and I haven't found it since! Now he is my favorite artist of all time. I have seen most of your reactions to his stuff.
(quick plug in for a "Stormbending (Live in Plovdiv or video)" or "Spirits Will Collide (Video)" reaction pleeeeeassse!)
Thanks again, man. You rock.
I used to repeat listen to the fallin from the moon section on its release. I did it again this morning. Transported back to my 23yr old self. Then ended up all watery eyed. Great reaction..
I’m always reminded of the wonderful Belfast Child when hearing the title track Brave !
Old Irish folk tune I believe, Simple Minds overhauled it, as they say. However, check Cara Dillon, She Moved Through the Fayre - same song, stunning.
This album brought me back to Marillion. I'd been on a musical walkabout for a bit ,so you can imagine my surprise to find this out of place gem in the mid 90s. Absolute classic. Can't say more. It just is.....
Made again ❤️🔥
Falling From The Moon….short but amazing. It was so lyrically powerful on my first listen that I was dumbfounded. And I always thought Made Again deserved more attention than it got.
Bless you, Jim, for the great content.
Wow, I am very impressed with your emotions, Jim!! I never, ever keep it dry when I listen to the song Brave. Not to mention The Great Escape... Two powerful and emotional songs that I cherish for almost 30 years.
Awesome album
Love this!! Thanks Jim!
My first concert of Marillion, was Brave, they played it in Ahoy Rotterdam. I just love it❤️
Happy for you Jim!
Really enjoyed the journey with you Jim. Side 4 did not disappoint at all✅✅
I love this album and i found it funny that you said exactly the same thoughts as me during the album, the singles that came with this album also had spin offs from this making it a bigger picture. brilliant thanks for sharing
Superb; thank you Jim :)
Thank you Jim for doing this
Marillion are the best
Greetings from Germany
Jim, that squeaky sound on the classical guitar in Made Again is actually Steve’s fingers on his left hand scraping on the thickest 3 strings when he changes chords. He’s also fingerpicking with his right hand without a pick. In the 1960’s when I started that squeak was generally frowned upon. But in the last 4 decades it’s become quite common and appreciated.
Masterplan? 5 world class musicians jamming. And Head Chef Dave Meegan mixing the ingredients into a pot of Gold
Next: "Marbles" (2004), "Sounds that can't be Made" (2012)
Great content as always, Jim. Subscribed. Cheers from Argentina.
What a wonderful album this is! :)
Most of us die-hard Marillo-heads don't think much of "Made Again" since it feels so tacked on, but honestly, it's a great song. I forget how much I like it. Anyway, love that you've gotten around to experiencing "Brave" finally, Jim, it's always great to see someone enjoy it for the first time. This album is still a masterpiece.
“prog masterpiece” 💯
The happy ending bit wasn’t guaranteed in first release - the double vinyl release had a double groove. When you played it, you didn’t know if you would end with Made Again or with 7 minutes of water noise… stunning concept
Quite true. They were initially going to do an extended version of The Great Escape, which didn’t contain the Falling From the Moon section, but when they listened they thought it was too depressing. Rothers had written the acoustic intro to Made Again for his daughter, and they took that and crafted the song and tacked it on the end. I like both concepts, and I like that the vinyl had the double groove (I never owned it, however). I do wish they’d put both editions in the cd set so you could have the option for whichever floated your boat, though I guess you could always cobble your own together via the extra tracks, but it would have been nice to just have the proper flow.
Well that's something I never knew ! I was going to relate the time I took the vinyl back to the record shop two or three times, saying that it wasn't playing right. The guy at the shop was completely unaware of the double groove.....as I was, until this day !
Didn’t the cd end in water but if you persevered it got to Made Again? Perhaps I’m wrong.
@@Ifyoudonttakeitucantfakeit No, you’re sort of right. As FFTM fades away it is replaced by the sound of lapping water and some birds. It even exists in the Wilson Remix as well. Plays for 20-30 seconds before Made Again begins.
@@NmDPlm31 I don't have the OG Vinyl or the Remastered either but I know both of these had the second grove with Spiral Remake and 6 minutes plus of water. They had a different hidden track on the CD I believe (if Wikipedia are to be believed). Spiral Remake was shorter than the usual Great Escape and is on the CD/BluRay as a BluRay bonus track.
Hey Jim! Late start today. Body is not working today. Thank you for this reaction. Prog at its best. Til next time my friend.😎
My favourite side by far, although I really liked the tour through all four sides. Three great songs here. Great album.
I have a memory of hearing the news report on the radio that inspired this seminal album.
Great stuff Jim.
Brave is my absolute favourite but you must try Marbles... another masterpiece.
Ive never left a gig where nobody could say anything on the way out, before or since. I’m obviously a cry baby as I always get emotional listening to Brave. I don’t care though.Glad you enjoyed the album Jim.
For some reason I still consider this a relatively ‘new’ album.. Was kinda shocked when you said it was 30 yo. Where has the time gone? Still, great, great album and I enjoyed your reaction to it very much.
Jim, you say you knew The Great Escape previously. How does it compare now you've heard it within the context of the album?
This is the stand out song for me. I lost my father in 1994, 6 months after Brave was released. "They shower you with flowers when they bury you" is exactly what happened, when we said goodbye to him, and I take comfort from it every time I hear it.
I hated this when it came out. I was looking for a Fish like concept album. It took me a good while but man what a masterpiece. ❤
😎
GREAT ESCAPE..Fait partie de mon Marillion Top 5..Entourée par CARE GAZA, THIS STRANGE ENGINE ET NEVERLAND..MERVEILLEUX ROTHERY..
And back into timelessness... agree a smidgeon of Simple Minds....but wow the serenity is akin to Clannad meets Pink Floyd .....with something entirely new age meets likes of Crowded House later. Like you say magical composing here.....🌠🎸✨ 🧙♂️
I've loved Marillion since around 1983 or '84. Would love to see you reacting to Fates Warning "A Pleasant Shade of Gray" album.
This is a very different experience, listening to the four sides, as opposed to the CD where there is no clear break from one album side to the next.
To answer your question about how they did it. This, I think, was the first time Marillion started to work with recording everything they did jamming in the studio then piecing it together later. I remember an article about it but can't seem to locate it anymore. I think it is the process they continue to use.
Fucking great reaction to my fave H album Jim...I'm now going to rewatch your reaction to the TODNOBILE/JON ANDERSON version of AWAKEN...for the 20th time!
If you’re going to listen to Marbles I personally love the four short Marbles interludes that run through the double album; they are the thread that’s locks it all together :)
This might interest you: Marillion’s current resident producer Mike Hunter was at this time their keyboard tech and created an electronic soundscape that was played before every show. It used bits or Brave and from their backcatalogue and slowly built an atmosphere that would lead into the lapping waves and foghorn at the beginning of the album.
Another one: the original LP had a double groove which either made you hear the full version of Great Escape followed by Made Again or you got the shorter (movie version) of Great Escape ending with the sound of lapping waves for minutes. You never knew which version the needle had caught.
'River' was an amazing piece of music. It was available on CD through Racket records. Its very zen.
I always thought that made again was when the girl actually had fallen from the bridge and was dead.... Not sure if it was meant that way but that is what I got out of it. I think it is the best album ever made. Even after 29 years it still graphs me and I get goesebums.
I understand that you've chosen to run through Marillion's studio albums, but the truth remains that Marillion's live performance of these songs is much greater than the album versions, mainly due to a much stronger vocal performance by Steve Hogarth, not to mention how he augments his singing with his visage and hand gestures. My favorite live performance by far was taken down several years ago. It was the b-light TV version that contained the backdrop showing the precisous little girl with lots of curls, in a pretty pinafore dress, swinging back and forth on the back drop, smiling and laughing. Meanwhile, The Great Escape is being performed, and it hits you like a boulder that people, and life, were so very hard on that girl that she chose to throw herself off the bridge and fall from the moon, when her life really had just begun. I raised a daughter, and this total mulit-media event wrecked me emotionally each time played the video. Maybe it is a good thing it is no longer on YT.
In one of your earlier reactions to Marillion, I kidded (maybe) you about once you've reacted to Marillion, why react to any other band? You responded with something like "there is lots of great music out there". Have you changed your mind yet?
marbles, fear, this strange engine, all great albums from H also
You liked Holidays in Eden, An Hour Before It's Dark where you thought they had outdone themselves and now Brave. Desert Isand Discs time - What is your fav now?
Jim, I can't speak for the present day (and unlike you I don't possess a turntable) but when the original LP was released, depending on which groove you began Side 4 on, there was an alternate ending for 'The Great Escape'. Perhaps you can try locating the stylus again to see if you can locate the alternate groove? I won't spoil the ending just in case....Great reaction as ever, Kindest, Kevin (you did my Gaza request for me a while ago)
He'll need to source an original pressing for the double groove, but I'd love to see/hear it too...
@@actorJSB I am sure you are probably right Joseph. The track is available as 'The Great Escape (Spiral Remix)' which was included on the re-mastered series a few years ago. Here is the link for you ruclips.net/video/yo7UXKKy4m0/видео.html Cheers Kevin
🎸🔊🔉🔈🕺💃🎸
How many Grammys (Grammies??) have Marillion won? Now, is that because Marillion are not that good or is it because the Grammys are pretty useless in determining musical excellence? (Also true for the Brits) I'll let you decide. I think you'll be right.
Marillion are the epic in music than comes pink floyd
Go for Afraid of Sunlight better I think all albums of the fantastic five
"Brave" is such an emotional sucker punch, maybe the most emotionally powerful thing the band ever committed to tape, but yeah -- when connected to "The Great Escape" and "Made Again" it's pretty devastating. It's actually very cool, considering they just rocked your ass off with the "Lap of Luxury"/"Paper Lies" combo. And then they reduce the listner to a puddle with this crushing, dramatic ending. And I'd guess that's why the album didn't do better in the UK charts. All those Brit Pop bands were about posing and nihilistic whinging, instead of confronting a really tough topic and laying their emotions bare. Plus I'd imagine Steve Hogarth's voice wasn't considered "cool" by the hipster tastemakers. BTW, also credited on Brave is Darryl Way for the arrangement for "Fallin' From the Moon". I assume this is the same Darryl Way who had been in Curved Air. There's a relatively obscure early 70's prog band for you to check out some day, Jim.
FEAR next for you Jim
Try IQ you will love this band!
Cracking album isn't it Jim. Now from one classic Prog concept album you really must get on to doing The lamb lies down on Broadway by Genesis, but don't drop it 🤣
Oh wow...
I didn't realize that Jim hasn't heard Lamb yet. That is definitely one I would suggest reading the lyrics and studying the packaging first. Or, while I love the vinyl, as a first time listen perhaps reacting to the Illustrated version here on RUclips. I do believe one of the sides is subject to blockage though, from what other reactors have experienced.
@Illume Eltanin so I take it you haven't heard the story of Jim's originally copy of the lamb.
@@kevingreen3429
Oh, I remember seeing that now! But for some reason I still thought he had listened to it after that. 😳
Horrible day? Listen to The great Escape and all your worries and concerns just miraculously float away! Marbles should be your next Marillion listen.
Pretty sure Jim does them in release order, so Afraid of Sunlight is probably up next.
Edit: Marbles is their masterpiece though. And if/when Jim gets there, I hope he's going for the extended/deluxe edition.
@@SerHenkan Marbles is, indeed incredible. And it doesn’t hurt that it contains my favorite Marillion track - Neverland.
I just hear Marillion , not any other band is it a bit biast??? Maybe.
This was the first truly h album that was him and John Helmer who wrote Made again, my husbands favourites.
I think when h came along I think Marillion became a band not Fish and the Marillion. I think h gelled well... 34 I think that time has shown that Fish was a better solo artist just MY opinion. If you want to see them singing this to help us getting through the pandemic look up made again lock down.
Also get some tickets!!! Their conventions in Leicester !
Am I first again ??
Look up "Made Again (2020" Lockdown version ruclips.net/video/v-WqMgD_NFE/видео.html . There's also a great version from a Marillion Weekend from Port Zeelande in 2013 ruclips.net/video/eavi-IRzt6M/видео.html .
The original had a version of The Great Escape called Spiral Remake which is the downer version of the track. It was hidden in a second groove and the CD version had a 26 minute gap and then some random studio stuff. ruclips.net/video/yo7UXKKy4m0/видео.html
I want a reaction of this Album wenn you listen it about 20 times. Maybe a nice idea
Me second? 🙂
Can I pester you again about Big big train ? You won’t regret it
And get tickets for the tour in August. You won't regret it!
I concur
Rothery. Better than Gilmour.