Sorry about that 😂 it’s not gonna happen every time, she’s a hard person to eliminate cause all her real eliminations (except All-Stars) have weird circumstances to work with
To be fair, that’s pretty much because Lindsay has the unique distinction of being a very competent competitor while also being universally liked and underestimated by everyone else. She’s almost never going to get targeted until she’s the only option left.
@WrongPlant The Kiss happened because of the tension Gwen had from Duncan being about so if Duncan stays, no kiss. So no love triangle. If he quits and comes back. The kiss. So yes love triangle.
Here are some ideas: What if Ezekiel didn’t lose the stick? What if Beth didn’t find the idol? What if Cody didn’t get mauled by the bear? What if Noah participated in Dodgeball? What if Trent wasn’t obsessed with the number 9? What if Duncan didn’t return in I see London? What if Tyler conquered his fear? What if The screaming gophers lost in the first episode? What if Eva was in Action? What if Dawn stayed longer?
I really like the Duncan one. Would've been so much better. Noah would've made merge, Gwen and Courtney stay friends, and no love triangle. Sadly I think this means that they vote out Heather here.
Tyler technically conquered his fear though as Chris only said to go *in the pen with the chickens* and was not told specifically to pet or interact with them. However I still support this idea.
Its funny, in both this and the last video on if Alejandro was on Team Victory, both times it replaced one of the already existing finalists with Lindsay.
@@adammartinez8061 She probably would still be in World Tour. I don’t see why Courtney not competing in TDA suddenly makes her go off with Geoff to find help instead of staying put as she did in Canon.
I would want to see: What if Duncan never returned in World Tour? Could be interesting to see how the latter half of the premerge turns out, as well as the merge with no love triangle mess. I see Courtney and Gwen's strong friendship continuing late into the game.
Well atleast Bridgette doesn't leave with a skunk spray and maybe she then cursed at heather, and she would've left on dignity and probably kissed Geoff before leaving
@@kleesbomb1034 I disagree with season 1, yes she was cheated out but she kinda needed luck to get where she got anyway(Ezekiel’s sexist comments straight up spared her from being the first boot, and Tyler not getting a point which he should have got spared her from being out there) and I also don’t think that she would get much farther anyway, nobody at the elimination place really felt that she was cheated out, Lindsay straight up said to her face that nobody liked her and she would’ve been kicked off relatively soon anyways. I do wish Courtney had won All-Stars though.
@@kleesbomb1034 I don't think she deserved to win either season she basically just floated to the final 5 in All Stars and she got insanely lucky in Total Drama Island
It would take a lot more guessing, but I would love to see a "What if Trent acted normal" or something like that I would just a love a video similar to this about how Total Drama action would change if Trent didn't became weirdly obsessed with Gwen and the number 9
Trent would be pretty good in Action if he just kept it together First of all he’d win 4, deservedly with his dance moves, then he’d rally the Grips to win 5 after roping Gwen Gwen wouldn’t have to throw 7 so they might even win normally or lose someone like Beth. DJ would still quit in 9, Izzy wasn’t going to make it through 11 Honestly Trent had real potential just as a normal competitive man on a team of losers and Justin
i was JUST thinking earlier today “i wonder what total drama would be like if harold didnt rig the vote and turn courtney insane” i loved it btw i really like this style of video and i like your reasoning and explanations, i cant wait to see more vids from you
That’s Off the Chain: If Geoff fell off his bike. She would stop but if Duncan fell Courtney would keep riding. Also Geoff the only reason why his bike fell apart was because the Guys Alliance just voted off Bridgette. He was too depressed to remember how to make a bike. So Geoff may make it to the second part and Geoff falls and Bridgette cares so much that she would get off her bike and run to Geoff so I think Courtney would go.
Ugh this part hurt me as a kid I was always a big fan of her and for some reason I thought she was going to win this season so I was like no not like this 😢
For the episode with the psycho killer you could've eliminated Owen, because he was so scared that he sacrificed Izzy to the killer. The way you could've eliminated was to got the most scared I guess
Lindsay is given loads of credit for her td gameplay(more than she deserves honestly) There are a lot of weird circumstances that get Lindsay eliminated but similarly there are weird circumstances that get her far in her merged seasons(Almost going home in episode 4 of island and saved by Noah doing… you know. And in action she almost gets the fifth boot but DJ quits directly sparing her
Haven't watched this video yet but I love these what ifs you're putting out! I don't know if this will be impactful but maybe a what if Izzy and Katie didn't switch teams?
No no that's really good. It means they never have a reason to vote Katie out so she probably makes it way further but I imagine Sadies placement stays the same
If Heather wasn't the antagonist anymore, would've expected it to be Izzy, but then she got 6th, so I'm thinking Courtney would've been the antagonist then
This video make me so satisfied dam. And dam, Courtney stays sane!! I like how she’s isn’t a winner actually and its fair even. Somebody wrote this here, but I will add some of mine: What if Courtney was in TDA from the beginning? For addition, she would be in Trent’s team and when sees he’s loosing she forms an alliance with him to make Gwen and Duncan jealous
The Screaming Gophers would've probably still voted Noah out. He's incredibly weak and very unathletic, he has God awful reflexes and he's known to be cowardly on occasion. Even if Noah did play, he would play so horribly that it would've ended up in a Screaming Gopher defeat thus leading them to kicking him out. He could potentially come up with some sort of strategy to win but then again, even though Noah is book smart, he has no interest in sports or physical activity in general so it's unlikely he'd be able to come up with a decent strategy or any strategy at all to win the dodgeball game. Overall, this game is bad for Noah, no matter what happens, he's completely screwed, if the doesn't play, than his entire team would despise him and vote him out, if he did participate in the game, they wouldn't hate him, but they would see him as a weak link and a potential force dragging them back from victory. It's just doom for Noah in a game all about athleticism. The only way I can see Noah making it through is either the Killer Bass being unable to wake up Duncan so he wouldn't be able to lead his team to victory and eventually Harold coming in and saving the day at the end, or the Screaming Gophers would instead target Lindsay because of how terrible she played in the game and because she flirted with Tyler who's a member of the Killer Bass. Now both of these possibilities would be extremely unlikely to happen since for 1: even if the Bass lost, Noah probably wouldn't last much longer, and if the rare chance they did win without Duncan, they'd still vote Noah out, and for 2: Lindsay is significantly more popular are well liked on her team than Noah is and she's also in the one and only alliance in the first half of season 1. There are just too many things bringing Noah back from actually being able to win the dodgeball game.
@@sarahconway2382 if he did play he could have played similar to how cody did - cody isn’t very athletic but was able to do stuff such as make the dodgeball have static electricity so it followed katie around, i think noah would play similarly to that. noah might still get voted out anyways for generally being not as well liked as cody though - he becomes friends with owen and izzy later on in the show but i’m not sure if they were friends at that point
@@sarahconway2382 I think Lindsay probably goes because she made out with someone on the other team, she only didn’t because of Noah being that bad. If he at least tried her probs survives
What if Mal never resurfaced in All Stars? I think this would be interesting because Mike would be able to use his other personalities while people like Alejandro and Cameron wouldn't be manipulated and tricked through the game
Do you think she would have had her villain arc still? Because originally, she was able to use the "getting voted off unfairly" to her advantage because of Harold, but she doesn't have that any more. Personally, I feel like she would have found something else but it's an interesting thought as that would significantly change the 2nd half of TDA.
If she hadn’t been cheated out of Island then her lawyers wouldn’t have got her into Action in the first place, so if that hadn’t happened she might have been stuck on the sidelines the whole season. The only way she might get in is if the changes to the season had an impact on her during the Special, which for me I don’t think it would. If that’s the case I suppose they would have had to try to make Justin more threatening to fill the villain criteria. Duncan is a possibility but I don’t get a main antagonist aura from him.
No, her lawyers wouldn’t even get her into TDA Which would change quite a bit, Owen would still go home in 13 (he fucked the challenge so bad) and Heather in 15 Where it really changes is Duncan is without allies and probably loses out in 17, Justin never “falls” for her and probably makes it much farther.
My suggestions : What if Duncan won the Big sleep challenge against Gwen ? What if Lindsay was actually very smart and was playing dumb as a strategy to avoid being targetted ? What if Deejay didn't get cursed in TDWT ? What if the teams were chosen by the first three people to complete the pyramid challenge in TDWT ?
Hello good video, what about this, What if... -Gwen wasn't eliminate in the jail episode -Scott didn't make the toxic rats lose -In all stars participate Justin,Trent,Leshawna,Eva,Dawn,Brick,B,Anne Maria -The toxic rats didn't lose the first challenge(they deserved to win) -All the original cast was in total drama action -The cowboy episode waw a reward challege
As a Courtney fan, I would like to ask: In TDI, what if Harold did not tamper the votes against her? Do you think she would make it farther at least in the top 10? In TDA, what if she learned to be more patient with Duncan and not control him? In TDWT, what if Courtney told Duncan about how she feels about him being close to Gwen? Considering it's important to communicate with your partner In TDAS, what if she did not create the chart and instead just not think about winning too much?
Katie would actually make it quite far. The gophers win 2 and 3, Noah was definitely going home in 4 as he did fuck all. Heather rigged the vote against Justin in 5, the team wins 6 and 7 She’d probably be eliminated in 8 as Izzy is no longer on the Gophers to take the fall. If she somehow survives that elimination she literally makes the merge lmao
What if Geoff and Bridgette didn't snog so much at the beginning of TDA? What if Courtney didn't file any lawsuits? What if Chef didn't start the alliance with DJ in TDA? What if Lindsay recognized Tyler right away in TDWT? What if Gwen and Trent weren't pitted against each other in TDA? What if Sierra wasn't obsessed with Cody? What if nobody came back in any of the seasons? (Like how Izzy and Eva came back in TDI) What if Heather didn't have plot armor in TDI? What if Beth didn't pick up the statue in TDI? What if Ezekiel didn't go feral? What if Heather didn't steal Eva's MP3 player in TDI? (I'm just gonna edit this comment if I come up with any others.)
Some of my suggestions: What if the love triangle in world tour didn’t exist? What if Mal didn’t exist in Total drama all stars? What if Heather didn’t have plot armor in island? What if Courtney didn’t return in Action? What if Trent didn’t have his 9 obsession in action? What if Sierra didn’t exist to help Cody in World Tour?
i have an idea: TDI but the teams are randomized(aka using a wheel to pick the teams) and would still have the major events like izzy and katie swapping teams
I could actually see it being Duncan or Bridgette that gets voted out in the X-Treme episode. Neither really liked the other, and Courtney and Geoff would side with their love interest, with DJ being the swing vote. Or if the Bass won, it’d either be Heather (who ironically cared more about the shower reward) or Lindsay just for costing their team so many challenges before then and being a general liability.
It would 100% be Heather if the gophers lost. Also I think Geoff and DJ would vote for Courtney and Bridgette would side with her love interest, Geoff, especially considering that it was her or Courtney going home, it was basically vote for Courtney or get eliminated for Bridgette. Geoff and DJ never really seemed to like Courtney and I think that they only really kept her around in basic straining because they liked Duncan.
@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110 yeah idk, we’d probably be saying it’d be 100% Heather at either of Izzy’s boots or the following couple rounds after, yet she always finds a way to survive. Gwen and Leshawna definitely vote her, but Trent may not even vote, and apparently he hadn’t voted Heather over Beth last time. Owen’s vote would be completely up in the air, and Lindsay definitely sides with Heather. Regarding the Bass, I still think Bridgette’s dislike of Duncan is stronger than Geoff’s and DJ’s aversion to Courtney. Not to mention, Bridgette and Courtney were pretty tight.
@@ryandennison8754 true, but Geoff and DJ were both tight with Duncan and Bridgette but they weren’t with Courtney. And ok, Bridgette and Courtney did get along well. But Geoff and DJ would definitely not vote Duncan over Courtney even if that’s what Bridgette wanted. Courtney might vote Geoff because he failed his challenge(DJ won his) but if she sided with Duncan to vote out Bridgette and Bridgette knew, she would vote Courtney. Courtney is either eliminated by a vote of 2-1-1-1, 3-2 or 3-1-1, or her and Bridgette tie 2-2-1. And if the gophers lost, well the writers created a ton of plot armour to keep Heather around(Beth’s cursed idol, Cody being mauled, Cody throwing his vote away onto Trent preventing a Heather-Justin tiebreaker, Eva coming back, her random immunity) If Trent didn’t vote(he would vote Heather if he could) and Owen sides with Heather and Lindsay, maybe Heather could survive but the most likely scenario is: Heather goes home. I’m thinking her and Lindsay would vote Trent, so I do see your point.
@@Кайф-в5я uh, Owen didn’t even compete this episode, neither did Gwen. Trent failed the first challenge while DJ won, Leshawna won the second challenge while Geoff lost, Heather unfairly won the third challenge while Harold unfairly lost, and Lindsay won the final challenge while Duncan lost. Owen, Gwen and Bridgette didn’t get to compete at all.
Here's a good idea; what if everyone that didn't join Total Drama Action (Katie, Sadie, Noah, Tyler, Cody, Ezekiel, Eva, Courtney from the start) joined Action. There is a lot of reward challanges where they could be eliminated on.
this is one i thought about before i would have thought duncan would take out bridgette dj was loyal to him and theres also his comment at the start of the season where he said he likes the teams odds with dj if they ever have to lift a truck
I agree with you about Heather & Trent. A lot of people seem to forget that Heather and Trent had a lot of scenes prior to their kiss. So it makes sense why she would still target him and Gwen.
I love these videos so much there so cool and interesting to watch! My suggestion is to do a 'what if Courtney never met Duncan.' as Duncan is a reason why Courtney isn't a 'suck up' after season. Another one could be 'what if Izzy wasn't crazy in season 1?'
This is really cool! In my opinion, I think with Lindsay still in the game, Sadie (and therefore Katie) would probably actually say Lindsay instead? And with Heather being eliminated before Lindsay, they might not have that big break (a shame for Lindsay's character) meaning Heather could realistically think she could manipulate Lindsay still if she won, causing Heather to play the role of Courtney from the original. And then Tyler could fill the Lindsay spot from the original (which is funny since he loves her).
One thing to note Episode 24 isn't a vote but Chef decides who to eliminate. And between Owen and Geoff, I think Chef would eliminate Owen (assuming he still eats the cinnamon rolls).
I did rewatch this because I thought the same thing while writing the video, I checked and the actual episode is quite vague about this point. So I interpreted it as more being Chef taking pleasure in the fact Duncan had been voted off than actually choosing him. Thanks for watching.
Can you please do what if total drama island was fair? So no rigging votes, no dumb rules in the ‘that’s of the chain’ episode, no dumb rules in the episodes where Leshawna gets eliminated, no dumb rules in the episode where dj gets eliminated etc etc etc I love these videos!
16:23 I think duncan might be able to convince Owen though, Owen likes Duncan more than Leshawna. And I’m Action when Lindsay asked Owen to vote Duncan, Owen threw his vote away. Overall I don’t think that’s happening tbh
What if Harold was a Screaming Gopher and NOT a Killer Bass? Because Harold really only gets eliminated due to Duncan, Geoff & DJ being friends. What if Courtney was eliminated instead of Tyler in Phobia Factor? Honestly Courtney made it further than she had any right to, people seemed to forget how poorly she performed, she was bossy, mean and a hypocrite, wouldn't jump off the cliff, wouldn't face her fear, constantly putting others down, she was essentially the Killer Basses Heather, but less cunning, and had no real skills aside from leading.
I agree with you, her elimination is so recognised as unfair but the way Tyler was rigged out to save Courtney isnt(Tyler actually completing his challenge but Chris not counting it for some reason and Courtney definitely goes home otherwise. She’s also the first boot no doubt if Ezekiel just keeps his mouth shut. If tdi was not rigged at all Courtney goes home at 17th place in Phobia Factor. And even though she was cheated out I don’t think she would’ve survived very much longer anyway.
I feel like if Heather told Duncan that Courtney said she hated him, he'd actually believe her, but just flat out wouldn't care because their relationship is just like that.
Great what if video! Tbh I never liked how Harold got away with rigging the vote against Courtney, and producers didn’t even care to do anything about it. I always thought Courtney could go to top 5 If she wasn’t cheated out of the show
stuff i’d KILL to see! What if Alejandro and Jose, Katie and Sadie raced in the Ridonculous Race? What if Harold never left his crusty underwear in the cabin? What if Noah returned instead of Blanieley? (S3) What if Leshawna was never eliminated in S1?
(I'm not telling you to do this or anyone to but i love this idea i had so i thought I'd share) I can't do this cause i have no talent or internet essay skills but i thought of a all stars season but in reverse, meaning that instead of the most famous and loved characters its the most underdeveloped and underwhelming Og cast: Dj - him and dawn can have connection with animals and i feel dj would meditate with dawn Noah - imagine him trash talking staci, or telling b to speak up, he'd be there for eva to calm her down when she's getting angry Tyler - he goes on runs with brick, they would be bros in no time Harold - him and sam would be the best nerd buddys, i can just imagine "wow is that a kaiju?" "No that's my girlfriend dakota" "awesome" Eva - noah wouod help her with her anger she coild also try meditating with dawn, and she also goes on runs with tyler and brick, also she does sparing with Dakota since dakota after being radiated decides to box, so that would be a fun dynamic Leshawna - more leshawna and harold, also her telling staci to shut up, also her and annw maria would either be best friends or enemies, they'll either get their hair and nails done together, or talk shit about each others taste, and I'm here for it Trent - i feel like trent can make friends with eva through songs, cause they both have a thing for music Revenge: B - more b and dawn dynamic is always good, also i feel like dj could help him come out of his shell a bit Dawn - it's just she's to good, she could have something with everyone, imagine dawn bringing up trents 9 thing or him having paranoia and abandonment issues, tell me that's not the best thing you've heard Dakotazoid - again, sparing with eva, more sam and dakota, harold being amazed by a kaiju women, also noah could dish on her too Brick - runs with tyler and eva, i see eva and brick maybe getting together cause remember brick "has a need to be dominated" and eva would be perfect for it Sam - sam and Dakota (yes he was in all stars but i feel people still over hate him) he's a good boy, also noah would still dish out dirt "my girlfriend is a monster" and harolds just like "mines scarier" Anne maria - again the dynamic with leshawna, also i feel like there should be a joke about how she's as orange as dakota 💀 Staci (still first off don't worry, new gen Zeke) i just want her here so leshawna and noah can tell her to shut up first episode, plus i needed a slot filled I have no idea how teams will be split up but please go ahead and share more dynamics and teams if you want cause i feel like this is a good idea, I won't do it but someone should
I think Chef would eliminate Owen because he ate his sticky buns. Yeah he gave the marshmallow to Owen in that episode but he only did that because he HATED Duncan, so with him not being there, he would boot Owen since he wouldn’t really have a solid reason to boot Geoff.
It would be cool to see, "TDI If The Winners Were Reversed" (Original Episodes where the Screaming Golphers win are won by the Killer Bass and vice versa, including the Boys vs Girls challenges, etc.)
I don't think DJ would've been voted off. Specially when he was the only one to complete the challenge (Duncan failed in the driving, Geoff on riding the bull and Courtney/Bridgette with Heather). Here's my theory, like you said, the couples would never vote for themselves, but the guys are also really close. I think their friendship should also count. I see two scenarios happening: 1 They vote based on their relationship, no strategy. The voting would go like this: Duncan: Bridgette (she was the first target of his alliance and is the least close to him) Bridgette: Duncan (said some episodes later she didn't like him cause he's mean, so of course she is voting him off) Geoff: Courtney (too close to the guys and has a relationship with Bridgette, only leaves Courtney as an option) DJ: Courtney (too close to the guys and he likes Bridgette more than Courtney, his vote could also change depending on who lost the challenge to Heather) Courtney: Geoff (has a relation with Duncan, is friends with Bridgette and DJ won the challenge, that only leaves Geoff) Here, Courtney goes home and nothing changes. The only major change is that maybe Duncan could be pissed at the guys for voting her off, but he seemed pretty rational and I think he would be kinda understandable. 2 Courtney uses strategy to not go home. If Courtney sees she is in trouble, since the guys are all friends and she is not well liked, that puts a target on her. Specially if she was the one that lost the challenge in the end. So she convinces Duncan and maybe DJ (since he is the only one not in a relationship, using the same argument she used to get Harold to vote Leshawna off) to vote with her. Then the votes would be: Courtney: Geoff (she picks Geoff cause he was the only one that lost the challenge besides Duncan and her or Bridgette) Duncan: Geoff DJ: Geoff Bridgette: Duncan Geoff: Courtney Geoff goes home and Courtney makes it to the merge.
I agree that Duncan would vote Bridgette. And I don’t think Courtney would really consider the chance that she was in danger. Even so I disagree with DJ voting with Courtney as he did not really appear to like her and only really kept her previously because he liked Duncan. I think DJ liked Bridgette. Courtney might vote with Duncan so I think she votes Bridgette. And lastly, if Bridgette knows it’s either her or Courtney going home she probably does betray her friend. So Courtney is eliminated 3-2. But the bass most likely don’t even lose anyway so this doesn’t matter. But Geoff would not vote DJ for sure
Fantastic. I’ve always wondered what would happen if Trent and Gwen remained a normal / healthy couple. I’ve heard rumors ( and read it was confirmed ) that the creators never wanted to break them up, so I wonder what things would have been like if Trent never felt like he was losing touch with Gwen or got super obsessed with the number 9 ( or if it were incorporated differently ).
Again it's all let's talk to each other to who's gonna get voted off like Courtney would not go to her and say hey let's vote off this person every episode 😂
Duncan is definitely "stupid" enough to mess around with Heather in that he would and did mess around on Courtney and was attracted to Heather and even got played by her later in this season leading to him being eliminated.
While I do appreciate a fleshed out version of Courtney making it far, I actually think she get eliminated next episode, or Chris exposes Harold to only highlight/laugh at that Courtney was eliminated anyway. The only way I see Courtney going further and into the merge is that DJ gets voted out over Harold and her, and since he is clued in that they are voting out each other, Harold doesn’t tamper the vote. Argument that Harold’s tampering was unnecessary: While Duncan is correct about 3 people not voting for Courtney, those 3 campers don’t vote together while the other 3 did. Also, Duncan later realizes, and what Duncan was actually referring about a “long memory” that Geoff lied to him about voting off Courtney (to spare his bro, DJ (for recent poor performances) and even Harold’s periodic ability to clutches challenges), which provides more context on Duncan wanting Bridgette out and eventually eliminating when he is able to gather the votes to oust him later on. If Harold gets eliminated via vote out or vote tampering, then I actually see Courtney going out next over DJ. Essentially, Courtney replaced Harold in the next challenge, where Heather dirty gameplay turned indecent accident caused Courtney to crash. Upon losing, the Bass team is unsure on who to vote. Duncan pitches Bridgette (possibly again) while Geoff pitches Courtney, with Geoff or DJ mentioning how many times Courtney has cost their team the win. Courtney convinces Duncan to vote out DJ, leaving Bridgette as the swing vote. In addition to not wanting to vote out DJ, Bridgette strikes a deal with DJ and Geoff to, in exchange to voting Courtney off, to vote out Duncan should the Bass lose again. Argument for DJ leaving over Courtney and DJ. While Harold is clearly on the outs, the Killer Bass don’t want him yet because the guys are still too amused at bullying him while the girls noted his ability to clutch comps. Thus, Courtney convinces Bridgette, Duncan and Harold to vote out DJ (in light losing the prior challenge for the team as well getting eliminated first in the current challenge)
I feel like in Hide & Be Sneaky, Lindsay would go home, since Duncan & Courtney are smart they would know Heather is a bit of a villain, and need to target her, so how would they do that? By voting Lindsay, which it now means Heather is along an episode earlier, and that's really it. I feel like Gwen being voted for an episode after Trent feels odd personally. In That's Off The Chain, I feel like its a toss up between Lindsay & Bridgette (since Lindsay survives Hide and Be Sneaky here) since even though Lindsay crossed the line, she did get stuck in the pond for a second, and I don't think Bridgette would be too far behind Lindsay since as you say, she's good at sports and Lindsay really isn't, also since Lindsay helped Heather get through, if Bridgette does complete it, it's easy for Bridgette to get through since the there is a clean path through the oil slicks, and since Bridgette is good in water, she could have gotten out of the pond *before* Lindsay, doubtful but possible. That's really it and I agree with essentially the rest of this alternate reality.
Thanks for watching, feel free to leave any suggestions or opinions here
Can you do what if Duncan never quit
What if Trent and Gwen never break up (total drama action)
what if duncan never quit in world tour
can you do a what if Anna Maria never quit?
@@bossome77777 that’s literally what I just said 🫤
Homie takes justice for Lindsey to a whole new level, she wins every time 😭😭
Sorry about that 😂 it’s not gonna happen every time, she’s a hard person to eliminate cause all her real eliminations (except All-Stars) have weird circumstances to work with
@@VyseNodge one of the winners is always Lindsay or Tyler
To be fair, that’s pretty much because Lindsay has the unique distinction of being a very competent competitor while also being universally liked and underestimated by everyone else. She’s almost never going to get targeted until she’s the only option left.
I would love to see, “What if Duncan never quit in World Tour?”
And “What if DJ didn’t quit in Total Drama Action?”
No love triangle
@@LuKAz_Gamez64-69 world tour just became way better
@WrongPlant The Kiss happened because of the tension Gwen had from Duncan being about so if Duncan stays, no kiss. So no love triangle. If he quits and comes back. The kiss. So yes love triangle.
@@LuKAz_Gamez64-69 the best thing I've seen all day
Here are some ideas:
What if Ezekiel didn’t lose the stick?
What if Beth didn’t find the idol?
What if Cody didn’t get mauled by the bear?
What if Noah participated in Dodgeball?
What if Trent wasn’t obsessed with the number 9?
What if Duncan didn’t return in I see London?
What if Tyler conquered his fear?
What if The screaming gophers lost in the first episode?
What if Eva was in Action?
What if Dawn stayed longer?
I really like the Duncan one. Would've been so much better. Noah would've made merge, Gwen and Courtney stay friends, and no love triangle. Sadly I think this means that they vote out Heather here.
Either no Aleheather or no Coderra.
Screw Coderra
Tyler technically conquered his fear though as Chris only said to go *in the pen with the chickens* and was not told specifically to pet or interact with them. However I still support this idea.
Also What if Lindsay didn't accidentally Vote herself off in TDA.
@@caellumwoodward
Lindsay would probably win,
Her voting herself on accident in tda was what lost her chances of winning-
Its funny, in both this and the last video on if Alejandro was on Team Victory, both times it replaced one of the already existing finalists with Lindsay.
She's just that good
Fun fact: this also leads to a butterfly effect of Courtney not competing in Action since she no longer has a case.
And she never competes in World tour…..or all stars and Duncney never happens.
Fun fact: Ezekiel being sexist caused Duncney if you think about it
@@adammartinez8061 No, i'm sure Duncney still happens. And we see who gets chosen for WT from the celebrity manhunt
@@adammartinez8061 why wouldnt she compete in world tour
@@adammartinez8061 She probably would still be in World Tour. I don’t see why Courtney not competing in TDA suddenly makes her go off with Geoff to find help instead of staying put as she did in Canon.
I would want to see: What if Duncan never returned in World Tour?
Could be interesting to see how the latter half of the premerge turns out, as well as the merge with no love triangle mess. I see Courtney and Gwen's strong friendship continuing late into the game.
Y
Well atleast Bridgette doesn't leave with a skunk spray and maybe she then cursed at heather, and she would've left on dignity and probably kissed Geoff before leaving
this hurts me as a courtney stan knowing how much more of her we couldve seen
I feel like Courtney deserved to/deserves to win at least one season.
@@loganmcdonald568 I feel like she deserved to win the first season tbh or all stars because she was kinda close
@@kleesbomb1034 I disagree with season 1, yes she was cheated out but she kinda needed luck to get where she got anyway(Ezekiel’s sexist comments straight up spared her from being the first boot, and Tyler not getting a point which he should have got spared her from being out there) and I also don’t think that she would get much farther anyway, nobody at the elimination place really felt that she was cheated out, Lindsay straight up said to her face that nobody liked her and she would’ve been kicked off relatively soon anyways. I do wish Courtney had won All-Stars though.
@@kleesbomb1034 I don't think she deserved to win either season she basically just floated to the final 5 in All Stars and she got insanely lucky in Total Drama Island
@@TotalDramaOwenandNoah agree with your point on season 1 but I think Court deserved to win All-Stars imo
"No one really encountered with the killer, so he's just lurking around"
... **Me procceeding to have dark imagines of IOS**
It would take a lot more guessing, but I would love to see a "What if Trent acted normal" or something like that
I would just a love a video similar to this about how Total Drama action would change if Trent didn't became weirdly obsessed with Gwen and the number 9
Trent would be pretty good in Action if he just kept it together
First of all he’d win 4, deservedly with his dance moves, then he’d rally the Grips to win 5 after roping Gwen
Gwen wouldn’t have to throw 7 so they might even win normally or lose someone like Beth. DJ would still quit in 9, Izzy wasn’t going to make it through 11
Honestly Trent had real potential just as a normal competitive man on a team of losers and Justin
i was JUST thinking earlier today “i wonder what total drama would be like if harold didnt rig the vote and turn courtney insane”
i loved it btw i really like this style of video and i like your reasoning and explanations, i cant wait to see more vids from you
That’s Off the Chain:
If Geoff fell off his bike. She would stop but if Duncan fell Courtney would keep riding. Also Geoff the only reason why his bike fell apart was because the Guys Alliance just voted off Bridgette. He was too depressed to remember how to make a bike. So Geoff may make it to the second part and Geoff falls and Bridgette cares so much that she would get off her bike and run to Geoff so I think Courtney would go.
I think Courtney would be out at final 10
I don’t think so, Geoff was smiling about his use of “top of the line bolts”
He’s just an idiot
I love how non-bias this was. After reading the title, I thought you wouldve put Courtney in the finals
What if lindsay didn't accidentally vote for herself in tda
Ugh this part hurt me as a kid I was always a big fan of her and for some reason I thought she was going to win this season so I was like no not like this 😢
Duncan the goat tho
Like it was supossed to be originily
@@buffyglimmersI was happy but I was also sad like I wanted Duncan to be in the game but I also wanted Lindsay to be in the game so..
@@Origoldklang no this was always planned to happen
For the episode with the psycho killer you could've eliminated Owen, because he was so scared that he sacrificed Izzy to the killer. The way you could've eliminated was to got the most scared I guess
That is something I considered for that challenge, but considering it was an encounter with the killer I decided against it.
@@VyseNodge Maybe What if Mal was arrested instead of Duncan?
biggest takeaway from both this and the previous video: lindsay is a much better player than people give her credit for
Lindsay is given loads of credit for her td gameplay(more than she deserves honestly)
There are a lot of weird circumstances that get Lindsay eliminated but similarly there are weird circumstances that get her far in her merged seasons(Almost going home in episode 4 of island and saved by Noah doing… you know. And in action she almost gets the fifth boot but DJ quits directly sparing her
Harold: oops I got busted
Tbf for 19, you could eliminate Geoff as Chris says “by far, the worst blunder yet”
So he was definitely 2nd-to-last just ahead of DJ
Haven't watched this video yet but I love these what ifs you're putting out! I don't know if this will be impactful but maybe a what if Izzy and Katie didn't switch teams?
No no that's really good. It means they never have a reason to vote Katie out so she probably makes it way further but I imagine Sadies placement stays the same
This would probably mean that Katie or Sadie get voted out earlier because they probably wouldn’t stop complaining about being on different teams
If Heather wasn't the antagonist anymore, would've expected it to be Izzy, but then she got 6th, so I'm thinking Courtney would've been the antagonist then
I'm satisfied courtney actually got far she deserves that screen time in my opinion
This video make me so satisfied dam. And dam, Courtney stays sane!! I like how she’s isn’t a winner actually and its fair even.
Somebody wrote this here, but I will add some of mine: What if Courtney was in TDA from the beginning? For addition, she would be in Trent’s team and when sees he’s loosing she forms an alliance with him to make Gwen and Duncan jealous
2:30 bros before hoes, that was their first mistake
I have an idea; what if Noah participated in the dodgeball challenge?
The Screaming Gophers would've probably still voted Noah out. He's incredibly weak and very unathletic, he has God awful reflexes and he's known to be cowardly on occasion. Even if Noah did play, he would play so horribly that it would've ended up in a Screaming Gopher defeat thus leading them to kicking him out. He could potentially come up with some sort of strategy to win but then again, even though Noah is book smart, he has no interest in sports or physical activity in general so it's unlikely he'd be able to come up with a decent strategy or any strategy at all to win the dodgeball game. Overall, this game is bad for Noah, no matter what happens, he's completely screwed, if the doesn't play, than his entire team would despise him and vote him out, if he did participate in the game, they wouldn't hate him, but they would see him as a weak link and a potential force dragging them back from victory. It's just doom for Noah in a game all about athleticism. The only way I can see Noah making it through is either the Killer Bass being unable to wake up Duncan so he wouldn't be able to lead his team to victory and eventually Harold coming in and saving the day at the end, or the Screaming Gophers would instead target Lindsay because of how terrible she played in the game and because she flirted with Tyler who's a member of the Killer Bass. Now both of these possibilities would be extremely unlikely to happen since for 1: even if the Bass lost, Noah probably wouldn't last much longer, and if the rare chance they did win without Duncan, they'd still vote Noah out, and for 2: Lindsay is significantly more popular are well liked on her team than Noah is and she's also in the one and only alliance in the first half of season 1. There are just too many things bringing Noah back from actually being able to win the dodgeball game.
@@sarahconway2382 yea that might be true but i still wanna see a scenario where he doesn't get voted off and see how the Total Drama course would go.
@@sarahconway2382 if he did play he could have played similar to how cody did - cody isn’t very athletic but was able to do stuff such as make the dodgeball have static electricity so it followed katie around, i think noah would play similarly to that. noah might still get voted out anyways for generally being not as well liked as cody though - he becomes friends with owen and izzy later on in the show but i’m not sure if they were friends at that point
What if he didn’t actively ruin his position on the team?
Lindsay would be gone 20th
@@sarahconway2382 I think Lindsay probably goes because she made out with someone on the other team, she only didn’t because of Noah being that bad. If he at least tried her probs survives
What if Mal never resurfaced in All Stars?
I think this would be interesting because Mike would be able to use his other personalities while people like Alejandro and Cameron wouldn't be manipulated and tricked through the game
Do you think she would have had her villain arc still? Because originally, she was able to use the "getting voted off unfairly" to her advantage because of Harold, but she doesn't have that any more. Personally, I feel like she would have found something else but it's an interesting thought as that would significantly change the 2nd half of TDA.
If she hadn’t been cheated out of Island then her lawyers wouldn’t have got her into Action in the first place, so if that hadn’t happened she might have been stuck on the sidelines the whole season.
The only way she might get in is if the changes to the season had an impact on her during the Special, which for me I don’t think it would.
If that’s the case I suppose they would have had to try to make Justin more threatening to fill the villain criteria. Duncan is a possibility but I don’t get a main antagonist aura from him.
No, her lawyers wouldn’t even get her into TDA
Which would change quite a bit, Owen would still go home in 13 (he fucked the challenge so bad) and Heather in 15
Where it really changes is Duncan is without allies and probably loses out in 17, Justin never “falls” for her and probably makes it much farther.
My suggestions :
What if Duncan won the Big sleep challenge against Gwen ?
What if Lindsay was actually very smart and was playing dumb as a strategy to avoid being targetted ?
What if Deejay didn't get cursed in TDWT ?
What if the teams were chosen by the first three people to complete the pyramid challenge in TDWT ?
Hello good video, what about this, What if...
-Gwen wasn't eliminate in the jail episode
-Scott didn't make the toxic rats lose
-In all stars participate Justin,Trent,Leshawna,Eva,Dawn,Brick,B,Anne Maria
-The toxic rats didn't lose the first challenge(they deserved to win)
-All the original cast was in total drama action
-The cowboy episode waw a reward challege
As a Courtney fan, I would like to ask:
In TDI, what if Harold did not tamper the votes against her? Do you think she would make it farther at least in the top 10?
In TDA, what if she learned to be more patient with Duncan and not control him?
In TDWT, what if Courtney told Duncan about how she feels about him being close to Gwen? Considering it's important to communicate with your partner
In TDAS, what if she did not create the chart and instead just not think about winning too much?
it would be cool to see a "What If All Eliminations Were by Vote"
Here's one:
What if Harold managed to win the challenge for the Bass in X-Treme Torture and the Gophers had to vote someone out instead?
Now I’m wondering a bunch of what if scenarios.. like “What if Katie stayed on the gophers” or what others suggest!
If Katie and Sadie were on separate teams they’d be cut loose almost immediately, their incessant whining at Chris would be unbearable
Katie would actually make it quite far. The gophers win 2 and 3, Noah was definitely going home in 4 as he did fuck all. Heather rigged the vote against Justin in 5, the team wins 6 and 7
She’d probably be eliminated in 8 as Izzy is no longer on the Gophers to take the fall. If she somehow survives that elimination she literally makes the merge lmao
What if Geoff and Bridgette didn't snog so much at the beginning of TDA?
What if Courtney didn't file any lawsuits?
What if Chef didn't start the alliance with DJ in TDA?
What if Lindsay recognized Tyler right away in TDWT?
What if Gwen and Trent weren't pitted against each other in TDA?
What if Sierra wasn't obsessed with Cody?
What if nobody came back in any of the seasons? (Like how Izzy and Eva came back in TDI)
What if Heather didn't have plot armor in TDI?
What if Beth didn't pick up the statue in TDI?
What if Ezekiel didn't go feral?
What if Heather didn't steal Eva's MP3 player in TDI?
(I'm just gonna edit this comment if I come up with any others.)
Some of my suggestions:
What if the love triangle in world tour didn’t exist?
What if Mal didn’t exist in Total drama all stars?
What if Heather didn’t have plot armor in island?
What if Courtney didn’t return in Action?
What if Trent didn’t have his 9 obsession in action?
What if Sierra didn’t exist to help Cody in World Tour?
With the killer nit being found that means in revenge in this universe then... Idk its scary
Tbh i forgot this video was abt Harold
Omg this is wayyyy better than how it actually played out
For the horror challenge, Owen’s reaction probably would’ve gotten him eliminated.
“I’ve never seen them interact with Leshawna” 😂
I think comparing TDI'07 to the later seasons would cause some headaches, because there are inconsitencies galore
i have an idea: TDI but the teams are randomized(aka using a wheel to pick the teams) and would still have the major events like izzy and katie swapping teams
Here’s random TDI
Gophers
1. Heather
2. Katie
3. Leshawna
4. Geoff
5. Lindsay
6. Izzy
7. DJ
8. Sadie
9. Noah
10. Justin
11. Eva
Bass
1. Ezekiel
2. Tyler
3. Cody
4. Beth
5. Courtney
6. Harold
7. Trent
8. Bridgette
9. Duncan
10. Gwen
11. Owen
It's kind of interesting that Courtney is antagonistic to Lindsay in the same way as Heather is to Gwen
I could actually see it being Duncan or Bridgette that gets voted out in the X-Treme episode. Neither really liked the other, and Courtney and Geoff would side with their love interest, with DJ being the swing vote.
Or if the Bass won, it’d either be Heather (who ironically cared more about the shower reward) or Lindsay just for costing their team so many challenges before then and being a general liability.
It would 100% be Heather if the gophers lost.
Also I think Geoff and DJ would vote for Courtney and Bridgette would side with her love interest, Geoff, especially considering that it was her or Courtney going home, it was basically vote for Courtney or get eliminated for Bridgette. Geoff and DJ never really seemed to like Courtney and I think that they only really kept her around in basic straining because they liked Duncan.
@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110 yeah idk, we’d probably be saying it’d be 100% Heather at either of Izzy’s boots or the following couple rounds after, yet she always finds a way to survive. Gwen and Leshawna definitely vote her, but Trent may not even vote, and apparently he hadn’t voted Heather over Beth last time. Owen’s vote would be completely up in the air, and Lindsay definitely sides with Heather.
Regarding the Bass, I still think Bridgette’s dislike of Duncan is stronger than Geoff’s and DJ’s aversion to Courtney. Not to mention, Bridgette and Courtney were pretty tight.
@@ryandennison8754 true, but Geoff and DJ were both tight with Duncan and Bridgette but they weren’t with Courtney. And ok, Bridgette and Courtney did get along well. But Geoff and DJ would definitely not vote Duncan over Courtney even if that’s what Bridgette wanted. Courtney might vote Geoff because he failed his challenge(DJ won his) but if she sided with Duncan to vote out Bridgette and Bridgette knew, she would vote Courtney. Courtney is either eliminated by a vote of 2-1-1-1, 3-2 or 3-1-1, or her and Bridgette tie 2-2-1.
And if the gophers lost, well the writers created a ton of plot armour to keep Heather around(Beth’s cursed idol, Cody being mauled, Cody throwing his vote away onto Trent preventing a Heather-Justin tiebreaker, Eva coming back, her random immunity)
If Trent didn’t vote(he would vote Heather if he could) and Owen sides with Heather and Lindsay, maybe Heather could survive but the most likely scenario is: Heather goes home. I’m thinking her and Lindsay would vote Trent, so I do see your point.
@@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110 if Gopher lose, they vote owen , because he fail first challenge
@@Кайф-в5я uh, Owen didn’t even compete this episode, neither did Gwen. Trent failed the first challenge while DJ won, Leshawna won the second challenge while Geoff lost, Heather unfairly won the third challenge while Harold unfairly lost, and Lindsay won the final challenge while Duncan lost. Owen, Gwen and Bridgette didn’t get to compete at all.
I just realized Chris always just ignores vote rigs…when he can always see them.
In my idea total drama island my way, I think Owen and Lindsay would be the perfect final 2, and action you can have Gwen and Duncan.
Here's a good idea; what if everyone that didn't join Total Drama Action (Katie, Sadie, Noah, Tyler, Cody, Ezekiel, Eva, Courtney from the start) joined Action. There is a lot of reward challanges where they could be eliminated on.
I would love to see a video where not only dose Harold rig the vote but leshwana does not get unfairly eliminated
I know lots of people have been requesting this, but I would love to see what would happen if Duncan didn’t quit World Tour
Great video man!
this is one i thought about before
i would have thought duncan would take out bridgette
dj was loyal to him and theres also his comment at the start of the season where he said he likes the teams odds with dj if they ever have to lift a truck
What if Katie and Sadie were swap into the Screaming Gopher instead and Izzy remain on the Killer Bass
I LOVE VIDEOS LIKE THIS!! subscribed :)
I agree with you about Heather & Trent. A lot of people seem to forget that Heather and Trent had a lot of scenes prior to their kiss. So it makes sense why she would still target him and Gwen.
I love these videos so much there so cool and interesting to watch! My suggestion is to do a 'what if Courtney never met Duncan.' as Duncan is a reason why Courtney isn't a 'suck up' after season. Another one could be 'what if Izzy wasn't crazy in season 1?'
"What If DJ never threw the challenge in Paris where Lindsay got eliminated"
Total drama but if scarlett didn't wanted to bomb the island
This is really cool!
In my opinion, I think with Lindsay still in the game, Sadie (and therefore Katie) would probably actually say Lindsay instead? And with Heather being eliminated before Lindsay, they might not have that big break (a shame for Lindsay's character) meaning Heather could realistically think she could manipulate Lindsay still if she won, causing Heather to play the role of Courtney from the original. And then Tyler could fill the Lindsay spot from the original (which is funny since he loves her).
One thing to note Episode 24 isn't a vote but Chef decides who to eliminate. And between Owen and Geoff, I think Chef would eliminate Owen (assuming he still eats the cinnamon rolls).
I did rewatch this because I thought the same thing while writing the video, I checked and the actual episode is quite vague about this point. So I interpreted it as more being Chef taking pleasure in the fact Duncan had been voted off than actually choosing him. Thanks for watching.
@@VyseNodge Fair enough thanks for the response
Can you please do what if total drama island was fair? So no rigging votes, no dumb rules in the ‘that’s of the chain’ episode, no dumb rules in the episodes where Leshawna gets eliminated, no dumb rules in the episode where dj gets eliminated etc etc etc
I love these videos!
22nd Ezekiel
21st Eva
20th Noah
19th Justin
18th Katie
17th Courtney
16th Izzy
15th Cody
14th Beth
13th Tyler
12th Sadie
11th Heather
Merge(no returns)
10th Duncan
9th Owen
8th DJ
7th Geoff
6th Trent
5th Harold
4th Lindsay
3rd Bridgette
2nd/1st Leshawna and Gwen
16:23 I think duncan might be able to convince Owen though, Owen likes Duncan more than Leshawna. And I’m Action when Lindsay asked Owen to vote Duncan, Owen threw his vote away. Overall I don’t think that’s happening tbh
She got scared by Beth in Action remember
For some reason I think this is a superior version to TDI.
You know it would be more interesting to find out what would have happened if Harold rigged the vote against duncan instead of courtney.
What if Cody listened to Courtney in Tdwt Greece’s Pieces and threw the challenge to get Gwen eliminated?
It was a reward challenge anyway though so it doesn’t make a difference really
What if Harold was a Screaming Gopher and NOT a Killer Bass? Because Harold really only gets eliminated due to Duncan, Geoff & DJ being friends.
What if Courtney was eliminated instead of Tyler in Phobia Factor? Honestly Courtney made it further than she had any right to, people seemed to forget how poorly she performed, she was bossy, mean and a hypocrite, wouldn't jump off the cliff, wouldn't face her fear, constantly putting others down, she was essentially the Killer Basses Heather, but less cunning, and had no real skills aside from leading.
I agree with you, her elimination is so recognised as unfair but the way Tyler was rigged out to save Courtney isnt(Tyler actually completing his challenge but Chris not counting it for some reason and Courtney definitely goes home otherwise. She’s also the first boot no doubt if Ezekiel just keeps his mouth shut. If tdi was not rigged at all Courtney goes home at 17th place in Phobia Factor. And even though she was cheated out I don’t think she would’ve survived very much longer anyway.
I feel like if Heather told Duncan that Courtney said she hated him, he'd actually believe her, but just flat out wouldn't care because their relationship is just like that.
Great what if video! Tbh I never liked how Harold got away with rigging the vote against Courtney, and producers didn’t even care to do anything about it. I always thought Courtney could go to top 5 If she wasn’t cheated out of the show
stuff i’d KILL to see!
What if Alejandro and Jose, Katie and Sadie raced in the Ridonculous Race?
What if Harold never left his crusty underwear in the cabin?
What if Noah returned instead of Blanieley? (S3)
What if Leshawna was never eliminated in S1?
What if mr coconut won
18:16 at that point they weren’t a couple Izzy was mad at Owen
I have two ideas for world tour. 1. What if Duncan got the boot instead of Tyler. 2. What if Dj never sang in sea shanty
I love it when you do these what if’s your channel is really underrated
well this is a suprise I just found this channel and I apperently see you here
I really love how you removed the plot armor of the main characters 😭
What if the screaming gophers lost the challenges they originally won, as well as the killer bass
You forgot that in Episode 24, Chef chooses who goes out. There wasn't a vote
What if they voted off Sadie instead of Katie?
(I'm not telling you to do this or anyone to but i love this idea i had so i thought I'd share) I can't do this cause i have no talent or internet essay skills but i thought of a all stars season but in reverse, meaning that instead of the most famous and loved characters its the most underdeveloped and underwhelming
Og cast:
Dj - him and dawn can have connection with animals and i feel dj would meditate with dawn
Noah - imagine him trash talking staci, or telling b to speak up, he'd be there for eva to calm her down when she's getting angry
Tyler - he goes on runs with brick, they would be bros in no time
Harold - him and sam would be the best nerd buddys, i can just imagine "wow is that a kaiju?" "No that's my girlfriend dakota" "awesome"
Eva - noah wouod help her with her anger she coild also try meditating with dawn, and she also goes on runs with tyler and brick, also she does sparing with Dakota since dakota after being radiated decides to box, so that would be a fun dynamic
Leshawna - more leshawna and harold, also her telling staci to shut up, also her and annw maria would either be best friends or enemies, they'll either get their hair and nails done together, or talk shit about each others taste, and I'm here for it
Trent - i feel like trent can make friends with eva through songs, cause they both have a thing for music
Revenge:
B - more b and dawn dynamic is always good, also i feel like dj could help him come out of his shell a bit
Dawn - it's just she's to good, she could have something with everyone, imagine dawn bringing up trents 9 thing or him having paranoia and abandonment issues, tell me that's not the best thing you've heard
Dakotazoid - again, sparing with eva, more sam and dakota, harold being amazed by a kaiju women, also noah could dish on her too
Brick - runs with tyler and eva, i see eva and brick maybe getting together cause remember brick "has a need to be dominated" and eva would be perfect for it
Sam - sam and Dakota (yes he was in all stars but i feel people still over hate him) he's a good boy, also noah would still dish out dirt "my girlfriend is a monster" and harolds just like "mines scarier"
Anne maria - again the dynamic with leshawna, also i feel like there should be a joke about how she's as orange as dakota 💀
Staci (still first off don't worry, new gen Zeke) i just want her here so leshawna and noah can tell her to shut up first episode, plus i needed a slot filled
I have no idea how teams will be split up but please go ahead and share more dynamics and teams if you want cause i feel like this is a good idea, I won't do it but someone should
Another amazing video
Lindsay: You would've been *voted* out in another episode, nobody liked you that much.
Courtney did not get voted out in another episode.
She probably would though
Harold Did Save himself only for one more Episode, Then Karma Struck, If this was the case, then good-bye Harold
I think Chef would eliminate Owen because he ate his sticky buns. Yeah he gave the marshmallow to Owen in that episode but he only did that because he HATED Duncan, so with him not being there, he would boot Owen since he wouldn’t really have a solid reason to boot Geoff.
It would be cool to see, "TDI If The Winners Were Reversed" (Original Episodes where the Screaming Golphers win are won by the Killer Bass and vice versa, including the Boys vs Girls challenges, etc.)
Really interesting idea!
Harold was supposed to be eliminated in Basic Straining but he had to eliminated Courtney so he can get back at Duncan for torching him
Yes! Another upload
Bridgette def would’ve crashed she was known for being clumsy
I don't think DJ would've been voted off. Specially when he was the only one to complete the challenge (Duncan failed in the driving, Geoff on riding the bull and Courtney/Bridgette with Heather). Here's my theory, like you said, the couples would never vote for themselves, but the guys are also really close. I think their friendship should also count. I see two scenarios happening:
1 They vote based on their relationship, no strategy. The voting would go like this:
Duncan: Bridgette (she was the first target of his alliance and is the least close to him)
Bridgette: Duncan (said some episodes later she didn't like him cause he's mean, so of course she is voting him off)
Geoff: Courtney (too close to the guys and has a relationship with Bridgette, only leaves Courtney as an option)
DJ: Courtney (too close to the guys and he likes Bridgette more than Courtney, his vote could also change depending on who lost the challenge to Heather)
Courtney: Geoff (has a relation with Duncan, is friends with Bridgette and DJ won the challenge, that only leaves Geoff)
Here, Courtney goes home and nothing changes. The only major change is that maybe Duncan could be pissed at the guys for voting her off, but he seemed pretty rational and I think he would be kinda understandable.
2 Courtney uses strategy to not go home. If Courtney sees she is in trouble, since the guys are all friends and she is not well liked, that puts a target on her. Specially if she was the one that lost the challenge in the end. So she convinces Duncan and maybe DJ (since he is the only one not in a relationship, using the same argument she used to get Harold to vote Leshawna off) to vote with her. Then the votes would be:
Courtney: Geoff (she picks Geoff cause he was the only one that lost the challenge besides Duncan and her or Bridgette)
Duncan: Geoff
DJ: Geoff
Bridgette: Duncan
Geoff: Courtney
Geoff goes home and Courtney makes it to the merge.
I agree that Duncan would vote Bridgette. And I don’t think Courtney would really consider the chance that she was in danger. Even so I disagree with DJ voting with Courtney as he did not really appear to like her and only really kept her previously because he liked Duncan. I think DJ liked Bridgette. Courtney might vote with Duncan so I think she votes Bridgette. And lastly, if Bridgette knows it’s either her or Courtney going home she probably does betray her friend. So Courtney is eliminated 3-2.
But the bass most likely don’t even lose anyway so this doesn’t matter. But Geoff would not vote DJ for sure
Thanks for using my suggestion!
Fantastic.
I’ve always wondered what would happen if Trent and Gwen remained a normal / healthy couple. I’ve heard rumors ( and read it was confirmed ) that the creators never wanted to break them up, so I wonder what things would have been like if Trent never felt like he was losing touch with Gwen or got super obsessed with the number 9 ( or if it were incorporated differently ).
I like to see if Harold did not boot himself in world tour
Courtney is the 3rd best imo
And her elimination in island was the most unfair
Again it's all let's talk to each other to who's gonna get voted off like Courtney would not go to her and say hey let's vote off this person every episode 😂
My Opinions!
[Ep. 1] ...
[Ep. 2] Ezekiel (7-4)
[Ep. 3] Eva (8-2)
[Ep. 4] Noah (10-1)
[Ep. 5] Justin (5-4-1)
[Ep. 6] Katie (4-3-2)
[Ep. 7] Tyler (5-2-1)
[Ep. 8] Izzy (N/A)
[Ep. 9] Cody (5-2-1)
[Ep. 10] Beth (4-3)
[Ep. 11] Sadie (3-2-2)
[Ep. 12] Harold (4-2)
[Ep. 13] Courtney (2-1-1-1)
*MERGE*
[Ep. 14] ...
(Courtney & Eva return. Even tho Izzy originally returned, as I wanna change things up, Courtney returns instead.)
[Ep. 15] DJ (7-5)
(Leshawna was immune.)
[Ep. 16] Courtney (7-4)
(Eva was immune.)
[Ep. 17] Gwen (5-4-0)
(Heather, Leshawna, & Eva were immune.)
[Ep. 18] Eva (Auto-Elim)
[Ep. 19] Owen (Auto-Elim)
[Ep. 20] Lindsay (4-3)
(Duncan was immune.)
[Ep. 21] Geoff (3-3)*
(Duncan & Leshawna were immune.)
[Ep. 22] ...
(The eliminated campers were able to vote someone to be immune. They accidentally choose Heather.)
[Ep. 23] Leshawna (3-2)
(Bridgette & Heather were immune.)
[Ep. 24] Duncan (2-0)
(Bridgette & Heather were immune.)
[Ep. 25] Heather (Auto-Elim)
[Ep. 26] *Bridgette VS Trent*
*Bridgette wins!*
The thing is that the drivers team wins if they crash heather loses if he crosses the finish line
Duncan is definitely "stupid" enough to mess around with Heather in that he would and did mess around on Courtney and was attracted to Heather and even got played by her later in this season leading to him being eliminated.
While I do appreciate a fleshed out version of Courtney making it far, I actually think she get eliminated next episode, or Chris exposes Harold to only highlight/laugh at that Courtney was eliminated anyway. The only way I see Courtney going further and into the merge is that DJ gets voted out over Harold and her, and since he is clued in that they are voting out each other, Harold doesn’t tamper the vote.
Argument that Harold’s tampering was unnecessary: While Duncan is correct about 3 people not voting for Courtney, those 3 campers don’t vote together while the other 3 did. Also, Duncan later realizes, and what Duncan was actually referring about a “long memory” that Geoff lied to him about voting off Courtney (to spare his bro, DJ (for recent poor performances) and even Harold’s periodic ability to clutches challenges), which provides more context on Duncan wanting Bridgette out and eventually eliminating when he is able to gather the votes to oust him later on.
If Harold gets eliminated via vote out or vote tampering, then I actually see Courtney going out next over DJ. Essentially, Courtney replaced Harold in the next challenge, where Heather dirty gameplay turned indecent accident caused Courtney to crash. Upon losing, the Bass team is unsure on who to vote. Duncan pitches Bridgette (possibly again) while Geoff pitches Courtney, with Geoff or DJ mentioning how many times Courtney has cost their team the win. Courtney convinces Duncan to vote out DJ, leaving Bridgette as the swing vote. In addition to not wanting to vote out DJ, Bridgette strikes a deal with DJ and Geoff to, in exchange to voting Courtney off, to vote out Duncan should the Bass lose again.
Argument for DJ leaving over Courtney and DJ. While Harold is clearly on the outs, the Killer Bass don’t want him yet because the guys are still too amused at bullying him while the girls noted his ability to clutch comps. Thus, Courtney convinces Bridgette, Duncan and Harold to vote out DJ (in light losing the prior challenge for the team as well getting eliminated first in the current challenge)
In Are We There Yeti? there isn't a vote to kick someone out. Chef just picks one member of the losing team to go home.
That's not confirmed, though. It's never stated that Chef gets to vote (To my memory).
I feel like in Hide & Be Sneaky, Lindsay would go home, since Duncan & Courtney are smart they would know Heather is a bit of a villain, and need to target her, so how would they do that? By voting Lindsay, which it now means Heather is along an episode earlier, and that's really it. I feel like Gwen being voted for an episode after Trent feels odd personally.
In That's Off The Chain, I feel like its a toss up between Lindsay & Bridgette (since Lindsay survives Hide and Be Sneaky here) since even though Lindsay crossed the line, she did get stuck in the pond for a second, and I don't think Bridgette would be too far behind Lindsay since as you say, she's good at sports and Lindsay really isn't, also since Lindsay helped Heather get through, if Bridgette does complete it, it's easy for Bridgette to get through since the there is a clean path through the oil slicks, and since Bridgette is good in water, she could have gotten out of the pond *before* Lindsay, doubtful but possible. That's really it and I agree with essentially the rest of this alternate reality.
What if the non elims in tdwt were eliminations
Im love one vote changes everything