Samaritan Weddings: Signed, Sealed, Delivered | Al Jazeera World Documentary

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
  • The Samaritans are a tiny ethnic-religious community dating back almost 3,000 years - and they are a population in crisis. But perhaps not for long. Marriage agencies in Ukraine have arranged for more than a dozen women to marry into the Samaritan community in Palestine.
    Many Samaritans live in a mountain village near Nablus in the occupied West Bank and face a worrying numbers problem. There are only 800 surviving Samaritans, where once they were counted in their thousands. Men outnumber women by three to one. Their custom is that a young Samaritan man can only marry a woman from within the community if he has a sister who he can offer as a bride in return.
    Faced with a fight for survival, a Samaritan religious leader changed the rules to allow Samaritan men to marry women from abroad. While some traditional Samaritans initially resisted the arrival of several Ukrainian brides into this close-knit community, the women are adapting to their new surroundings and providing a population lifeline to this small community.
    #Documentary #Samaritan #Wedding

Комментарии • 434

  • @judithreyes4664
    @judithreyes4664 2 года назад +36

    What a lovely documentary Thank you for sharing your country and the Samaritan life and struggles with us. You did it beautifully! 💕

    • @sonogabri1
      @sonogabri1 2 года назад

      Let's go find one 🤪

  • @reneeanthony73
    @reneeanthony73 2 года назад +37

    I really loved this documentary getting a look into another culture is something I really love to do, cannot wait to see more of her movies and documentaries!

    • @phabebarcelona863
      @phabebarcelona863 2 года назад +1

      Same gave a Natral intrest in othe people n Cultures

  • @juanitarichards1074
    @juanitarichards1074 2 года назад +42

    The young people should just be able to choose someone they like in their community, marry and raise a family. That will help ease the population crisis and there will be more brides and grooms to choose from in the future. These strict marriage rules often have unintended negative consequences.

    • @sharischoll9411
      @sharischoll9411 2 года назад +9

      Like mental and / or physical health problems from marrying a close relative. Should be a minimum of 3 or 4 steps away from a relative.

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +3

      They do, but mostly look for Jewish ones (because blood related and also because linguistically, ethnically and culturally are the same, beside religious beliefs that are the same), if they can't find one then they look for an Ukrainian

    • @terintiaflavius3349
      @terintiaflavius3349 2 года назад

      There is no population crisis

  • @sonogabri1
    @sonogabri1 2 года назад +36

    Lovely documentary, I wish there were more Samaritan men in the World.Women deserve a husband who's sweet and kind, not the kind some of us end up with....

    • @MoAli-wm4of
      @MoAli-wm4of 2 года назад +7

      A woman is always able to divorce and go back out there to find someone who will value her and fulfil all her rights as a wife … but at the end of the day, good women are made for good men …

    • @evelinholmes6401
      @evelinholmes6401 2 года назад

      @@MoAli-wm4of easier said than done .

    • @sloeberdoet
      @sloeberdoet 2 года назад

      Yes men seem very sweet there.

    • @atsuini
      @atsuini 2 года назад

      Would you have allowed to be married at a younger age to a man/boy without holding demonstrating and calling it evil?

  • @francisfreyre
    @francisfreyre 2 года назад +7

    It has been a very good documentary! Congratulations from my heart! Also, i want to express my admiration for the samaritan people. How nice they are, so spontaneous even with an innocent look and how they are integrated somewhat into arab culture. May God protects them, their marriages too.

  • @aaroniouse
    @aaroniouse 2 года назад +37

    Imagine a Samaritan woman wanting to marry a foreign man. I wonder how that would go?.. Probably not as well.

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад +6

      Probably not. What if a Palestinian or Jewish man wanted to convert and marry? Would they accept?

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +13

      @@2degucitas yes, they'll look first for a Jewish partner (don't need to convert since the culture, tradition and beliefs are the same except for the Mount Gerizim thing), for a Palestinian one the partner needs to abandon their family and everything and embrace the Samaritan faith, culture, etc... Thus being said, the Palestinian can't see again their relatives nor let their kids visit their relatives in order to preserve the identity as Hebrews (or Israelites) with no foreign intervention... But most Samaritans don't want and dont like that idea since they suffered a lot becsuse of them and they see them as invaders of their land

    • @2degucitas
      @2degucitas 2 года назад +3

      @@DD-rv8hi they suffered by Samaritan hands?

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +12

      @@2degucitas Palestinian not Samaritan, they made a lot of massacres and forced conversion process in order to eradicate them

    • @SionTJobbins
      @SionTJobbins 2 года назад +5

      @@DD-rv8hi thanks but your answer isn't clear. Do Samaritan women marry Jewish men? But Samaritan women won't marry Arab Palestinian men because the Arabs took their land and the Muslim Arab won't convert and his family won't speak to him? What if a Samaritan married a Jewish or Muslim woman?

  • @hannah5245
    @hannah5245 2 года назад +5

    The Bible tells the story of the Good Samaritan where a traveler who was stripped of clothing, and left half dead . First a Jewish priest, then a Levite comes by, but both avoid the man. But a Samaritan took pity, bandaged his wounds, put him on his donkey, took him to an inn, gave the innkeeper money to care for him. He even said he would reimburse the innkeeper for any extra expenses. Lu 10:25-37
    Question is - which of these 3 was a neighbor to the man who fell into the hands of robbers? (rhetorical)
    How we all can learn from this community of peace loving and compassionate people ! ❤️

  • @defenderofdecency7218
    @defenderofdecency7218 2 года назад +33

    The young couple are cute and appear to be in love.

  • @NickanM
    @NickanM 2 года назад +33

    I wish them all love, happiness and success! ❤💕

    • @nl.dauhoo
      @nl.dauhoo 2 года назад +4

      😍

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      Amin

    • @yurichtube1162
      @yurichtube1162 Год назад

      Palestenian authorities should support them.

  • @casteretpollux
    @casteretpollux 2 года назад +12

    That sister exchange rule is a sure recipe for population decline.

  • @jacquig7118
    @jacquig7118 2 года назад +23

    Wow, really enjoyed watching this documentary an the picture quality was superb

  • @andratoma9834
    @andratoma9834 2 года назад +3

    Samaritan! They exist? I thought Samaritans exist only in the New Testament! Wow! Thank you for this video!

  • @lekis5975
    @lekis5975 2 года назад +7

    LOL Aunty at 38:05 throwing shade, going on about "men who aren't popular or are a bit overweight..."

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      🤭

    • @SionTJobbins
      @SionTJobbins 2 года назад

      Stupid comment by her. Her community is facing a crisis of incest, if she was serious about the future and happiness of the Samaritans she wouldn't say things which will make a woman think twice about marrying into the Samaritan community. Stupid spiteful woman.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      @@SionTJobbins Come on, man. You're exaggerating. She was just explaining how things are, from her perspective..

  • @csurvivor6774
    @csurvivor6774 2 года назад +16

    These Samaritan's living good. Inside there homes are beautiful

  • @fawziaabdurrahman2251
    @fawziaabdurrahman2251 2 года назад +28

    when men treasure women, they work harder. the samaritan homes all look very lavish. obviously the men know they have to bring their A game if they are to find a wife. that part really impressed me.
    in some parts of the world where the men feel like they are doing women a favor by marrying them, you can see how shoddy their lives are coz women still throw themselves at men regardless. even if they are lazy or drug addicts, or players/adulterous..
    the last couple in the film are very beautiful together i hope they have a lovely life too

    • @sloeberdoet
      @sloeberdoet 2 года назад +1

      Nice comment. Hope you found yourself such a wonderful man too. Like you said if a woman is treasured she is lifted up and do what she can to make her husband happy sadly there are so many dysfunctional people in the world.

    • @alejandrodelgado5829
      @alejandrodelgado5829 2 года назад

      @@sloeberdoet treasure a use up 304

  • @achayootto4221
    @achayootto4221 2 года назад +10

    Samaritans
    Ethnicity
    Description
    Samaritans or Samaritan people are members of an ethnoreligious group originating from the Israelites of historical Israel and Judah. They are native to the Levant and adhere to Samaritanism, an Abrahamic, monotheistic and ethnic religion in the Holy Land.
    Samaritans are mentioned in the Bible and we saw them mentioned as sharing the same lineage of Abraham as the the other Judaic groups..they appeared to be looked down on...but good people.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      Yes, that's true.👍

  • @mariekatherine5238
    @mariekatherine5238 2 года назад +12

    This is still partially arranged. It isn’t left up to chance to “fall in love.”

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад

      Yes, they can... Mostly they look for Jewish brides (for obvious reasons), if they can't find one then they look for s foreigner

  • @beataplaya
    @beataplaya Год назад +3

    Wow. I can't imagine how they withstand uncertainties and uphold their unique culture. I've only read Samaritans from the Bible.

  • @sebresludolf9611
    @sebresludolf9611 2 года назад +9

    *Imagine watching this video as a single 🙂.*

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      I am. 🤷‍♀️

  • @phabebarcelona863
    @phabebarcelona863 2 года назад +5

    Thank you so much for sharing this lovely looking hidden culture. Never ever had seen even a Picture of a Samaritan I've heard thru the bible N when Vhrist use them in a parable. Of how a man had fallen by the rd nd of his country men who passed by stopped n help, But then came s long the What Christ called The Good Samaertian who stopped helped nd paid for his addtional care n gave him food. They appear to be a simplicity n warm n a sense a unity in communtiy

  • @kenfu9334
    @kenfu9334 2 года назад +11

    wow beautiful pictures amazing

  • @diane9247
    @diane9247 2 года назад +3

    Very interesting! I enjoyed this documentary very much and learned a lot of new things.🌺

  • @michaelalando
    @michaelalando 2 года назад +3

    What a delightful documentary.
    I am shocked - but in a good way like the lady Vera Petrak says at 41:37

  • @sheshahayat5117
    @sheshahayat5117 2 года назад +15

    Why can’t they marry fellow Palestinians or whoever they like from their community,,,,
    Why such secret living ,,, I feel sad for them,,,

    • @footballfan5462
      @footballfan5462 2 года назад +7

      Because they are keeping their ancient traditions and their israelite/jewish bloodline.

    • @sheshahayat5117
      @sheshahayat5117 2 года назад +15

      @@footballfan5462 by marrying the girls outside their lineage, from Eastern Europe, who are not even Israelites ?

    • @MrZeev76
      @MrZeev76 2 года назад +2

      In first place Muslim women are not allowed to marry outside of their religion, so very few Muslim Palestinian women will ever be able to marry with a Samaritan man. And if a Samaritan woman marries a Muslim man she will be forced to convert to Islam and will further cause the minority Samaritan community to decline. If more and more Ukrainian women decide to marry with Samaritan men it is a win win for both communities.

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +2

      They don't for many reasons including resentment against them, also they look for Jewish brides in first place (for obvious reasons), if not then they prefer an Ukrainian bride instead a Palestinian one, no matter if she converts to them

    • @yurichtube1162
      @yurichtube1162 2 года назад +1

      Fellow palestenian?

  • @plwn6468
    @plwn6468 2 года назад +4

    To few young women ? This is already terminal decline for such a special community. We will miss the Samaritans in the coming decades.

    • @yurichtube1162
      @yurichtube1162 2 года назад

      If arabs and jews were to provide women, they would survive (with provide I mean set up speed datings). Although, arabs are way too tribal to give away their women.

    • @savagewarrior4384
      @savagewarrior4384 2 года назад

      As a religious community they are not going to disappear but their gene pool will be diminished because of these marriages.

    • @jaialaiwarrior
      @jaialaiwarrior 10 месяцев назад

      Their numbers are still small, but growing.

  • @datolabisi
    @datolabisi 2 года назад +1

    This is very beautiful documentary. Thank you so much

  • @Zero-hl2zy
    @Zero-hl2zy 2 года назад +4

    God bless them all in the life they choose

  • @audryanne6914
    @audryanne6914 2 года назад +3

    So beautiful documentary 😍

  • @sake9305
    @sake9305 2 года назад +7

    Seems to me like there’s a bit of ‘featurism ‘ considered before choosing a foreign bride. Ukraine seems so far away considering there are far closer ethnic groups around them.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      Yes, but:
      《 *_"Ukraine's internet romance industry is booming - despite the unrest._*_ But after chatting online, travelling to Odessa and wooing women on flashy dates, most men fly home alone and far poorer. Are they unlucky in love, or have they been scammed?_
      _These are trying times for Odessa. After the annexation of Crimea,[...] But for all the political and economic chaos that has engulfed Ukraine in the past three months, one industry is still thriving: _*_the internet romance trade._*

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      *_The economies of several Ukrainian cities are boosted by the surreal and disingenuous online bride business, and Odessa is the biggest hub._*_ It does not take long for a visitor to the city to stumble upon an "international date" - _*_there are legions of western men in town meeting with young women they have met online, usually with the conversation facilitated by a translator._*_ At internet cafes and homes across the city, thousands of women spend hours each day chatting to prospective suitors online._

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      _There is nothing like the prospect of economic hardship to facilitate intercontinental liaisons, and so, far from business drying up in recent months, the romance and "bride" trade is booming. If anything, there are now more western men planning trips to Odessa than there were last year, when I accompanied a "romance tour" to Ukraine for a magazine story._
      *_I spent a week in Odessa with 29 men, all of them hoping to find a wife during their trip. They were mainly Americans, but there were also Brits, an Italian and a Saudi on the tour."_* 》

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      This was from a 2014 article from The Guardian, titled: _"The men who go to Ukraine looking for a wife then fly home alone and broke"_
      There seems to be an industry of sorts, for this kind of arranged marriages in Ukraine -which isn't common everywhere. Come to think of it, I think I've vaguely heard of it before. 🤔

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +1

      They look first for Jewish brides, if they can't find one then they look for an Ukrainian, they'll never accept marrying a Palestinian

  • @elizabethalipio2444
    @elizabethalipio2444 2 года назад +7

    Beautiful inspiring story and documentary

  • @ranamansouier1185
    @ranamansouier1185 2 года назад +11

    Ukrainian women are beautiful ❤️♥️

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      Yes, indeed. 🙂♥️

    • @erikamuller4934
      @erikamuller4934 2 года назад +3

      Ukrainian are not only beautiful but also very intelligent and are professionally well qualified. Therefore I don't really think this kind of living will make them happy.

    • @alejandrodelgado5829
      @alejandrodelgado5829 2 года назад

      @@erikamuller4934 you are never happy, you are a 304

  • @toassistindo
    @toassistindo Год назад +2

    So you acknowledge the West Bank is Judaea and Samaria

  • @3hijos5nietos
    @3hijos5nietos 2 года назад +1

    Greetings from Chile, please put subtitles.

  • @liudaboicova6683
    @liudaboicova6683 Год назад +2

    I'm confused here...brothers sister has to find him a bride!? Feel sorry for these people to be forced to marry somebody they don't love😢

  • @tracih5555
    @tracih5555 2 года назад +5

    Question: what’s driving so ma y of these Ukrainian women to seek a partner outside of their country?

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      Well, a certain culture of marrying young & economic hardship, really. This is from a 2014 article from The Guardian, titled: _"The men who go to Ukraine looking for a wife then fly home alone and broke"_ 👇
      Title is a bit sensational, but it brings an interesting insight. I can't post the link or the paragraphs in 1 comment, cause it gets removed. 🙂

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      《 _"Ukraine's internet romance industry is booming - despite the unrest. _*_But after chatting online, travelling to Odessa and wooing women on flashy dates, most men fly home alone and far poorer._*_ Are they unlucky in love, or have they been scammed?_
      _These are trying times for Odessa. After the annexation of Crimea,[...] But for all the political and economic chaos that has engulfed Ukraine in the past three months, one industry is still thriving: _*_the internet romance trade._*

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      *_The economies of several Ukrainian cities are boosted by the surreal and disingenuous online bride business, and Odessa is the biggest hub._*_ It does not take long for a visitor to the city to stumble upon an "international date" - _*_there are legions of western men in town meeting with young women they have met online, usually with the conversation facilitated by a translator._*_ At internet cafes and homes across the city, thousands of women spend hours each day chatting to prospective suitors online._

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      _There is nothing like the prospect of economic hardship to facilitate intercontinental liaisons, and so, far from business drying up in recent months, the romance and "bride" trade is booming. If anything, there are now more western men planning trips to Odessa than there were last year, when I accompanied a "romance tour" to Ukraine for a magazine story._
      *_I spent a week in Odessa with 29 men, all of them hoping to find a wife during their trip. They were mainly Americans, but there were also Brits, an Italian and a Saudi on the tour."_* 》
      It carries on, but you get the point.

    • @NarnianLady
      @NarnianLady 2 года назад +1

      Alcohol problems, economic uncertainties etc among the Ukrainian men. More women than men anyway, so women are forced to look elsewhere

  • @ts7371
    @ts7371 Год назад +1

    What is the significance of the fruit hanging from the ceiling ?

  • @SionTJobbins
    @SionTJobbins 2 года назад +7

    Interesting documentary. Why don't the men find brides from the middle East, Arabic, Kurdish, Turkish etc communities?
    And what of the young Samaritan women, are they allowed to marry put? How do they feel?
    The Jews have succeeded as a people because over the centuries you can see they did marry outside the community. Also, Jewishness is passed on through the mother. Maybe the Samaritan need to give their women more freedom too if they wish to grow as a community.

    • @stevenv6463
      @stevenv6463 2 года назад +3

      Women from those countries don't want to convert and move to another country. Honestly there are some Muslim men in the Arab world that do the same with Russian and Ukrainian women.

    • @yurichtube1162
      @yurichtube1162 2 года назад +2

      Because of islam. Although, because of secularism, it should be possible in the future.

    • @stevenv6463
      @stevenv6463 2 года назад +1

      @@yurichtube1162 Probably not for a while, even for most secular irreligious people they want at least a token conversion.

    • @sloeberdoet
      @sloeberdoet 2 года назад +2

      Because islam doesn't allow to convert to other religions especially women aren't allowed to marry outside the religion and certainly not to convert.

  • @suecollins8199
    @suecollins8199 Год назад +1

    If there is only 1 son & many daughters, who will the daughters marry? Are there enough Samaritan men?

  • @EstherAivinhenyi
    @EstherAivinhenyi 2 года назад +4

    The Western culture needs to be reformed within the context of marriage the DIVORCE RATE is ALARMING . 🙂🙂🙂

  • @srenevanderlugt465
    @srenevanderlugt465 2 года назад +2

    I am a Dutch gay, and I would love to marry a Samaritan 👦

  • @netzel6723
    @netzel6723 2 года назад +2

    Thank you for this Documentary about this Jewish Group. I learnt so much. I must visit this area of our world.

  • @sharonkaczorowski8690
    @sharonkaczorowski8690 2 года назад +2

    What about the girls? What choice do they have?

    • @katharina...
      @katharina... 2 года назад

      They explained it at the beginning, their mothers choose who they are going to marry, all marriages are arranged.

  • @signil
    @signil 2 года назад +2

    But why women from Ukraine? What's the reason?

    • @theb3654
      @theb3654 2 года назад

      Ukraine has or had more women than men by a good amount

  • @avivahbenjamin1103
    @avivahbenjamin1103 2 года назад

    Thank you super interesting

  • @etstarter
    @etstarter 11 месяцев назад

    She forgot to mention why they moved to Mount Gerizim and there used to be about 1 million Samaritans

  • @duaneburd9350
    @duaneburd9350 2 года назад +5

    The Sumars are closer to thier roots than any Ashkenazi or sefardi, they do thier rituals exactly the same way as 3000 years ago nothing has changed except population numbers

  • @cmartin5903
    @cmartin5903 2 года назад +1

    Yes. Saturday is special. I wish the majority of the Christian world did not apostasize.

  • @yehyachalhoub7895
    @yehyachalhoub7895 2 года назад +6

    Yo these Samaritans are balling

  • @salimi.sheriff7608
    @salimi.sheriff7608 10 месяцев назад

    The proverbial Good Samaritans must be preserved! I remember their special relationship with Jesus

  • @questionanswers7278
    @questionanswers7278 2 года назад

    Turkish cap are they using?

  • @shulalavy1698
    @shulalavy1698 2 года назад +2

    There is no any connection between the marriage of woman on condition of solving marriage problame of her brother.
    If the male is wanted he can choose between some women, can his father order him to merry only the woman that she have brother for exchange marriage? Of course not. If his sister will not find groom in the community she can not look for groom outside, may be they will merry her as a second wife like in the Bible or in arabs community. This is crime if doable standard.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      They don't practice polygamy. The social laws in the Bible suferred an *evolution* over the centuries & by the time of Jesus, the population was mainly monogamous.

  • @C-eo1rt
    @C-eo1rt Год назад

    Samaritans have very nice houses.

  • @nyrilly3843
    @nyrilly3843 2 года назад

    Makes you wonder if family members are alll related to each other and id theres and 1st or 2nd cousin marriage.

  • @MrTimetravler
    @MrTimetravler 2 года назад +1

    Wow I love this documentary 👏 😢 😭 ❤️ what are the marrying agencies!? I am a single 43 American man no kids I would love to have a Ukrainian or Russian wife 👰💖

  • @sabrina9492
    @sabrina9492 2 года назад

    Да уж, славянские девушки отважные, ничего не сказать

  • @janesmith9024
    @janesmith9024 2 года назад +4

    Why are there 3 times more men than women or whatever they said? Surely all humans have about 50/50 male and female? If they are short of people have more babies! Mos women can have 10 children ate least if you marry young enough. My great grandmother had 11. I have about 40 great aunts and uncles as every one had about 10 in those days.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      Yeah, that is really strange. Usually, nature regulates itself to about 50/50 distribution, like you said... 🤔 I sense some convenience abortions going on, tbh.
      I don't think they are short of people, just girls. And perhaps it's because women didn't want to have as many children anymore (in this modern age), so perhaps they 'took care' of some of the pregnancies - at times favoring boys over girls..
      This is just speculation, ofc.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      That's a lot of children!

  • @ciaogali
    @ciaogali 2 года назад +1

    Ukrainian women are so beautiful…

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      True.

  • @1czechit1
    @1czechit1 6 месяцев назад

    calling the Judea and Samaria "West Bank" is silly. Its like calling it the trans-Jordan.

  • @jgjalsas1315
    @jgjalsas1315 2 года назад

    A very difficult life

  • @knockknock1246
    @knockknock1246 2 года назад

    I'd be a good Samaritan and hang out with one

  • @jgjalsas1315
    @jgjalsas1315 2 года назад

    Mary Ukrainian women enjoy and take it easy

  • @mosmart4718
    @mosmart4718 2 года назад +2

    Can Samaritan men and girls marry their Jewish and Palestinian neighbours. Just curious. Secondly the men look exactly as Palestinian in their dress and kofia

    • @ايمان-ض2ح
      @ايمان-ض2ح Год назад +1

      no we can't and we will not. we are not palestinian.

  • @jzk2020
    @jzk2020 2 года назад +7

    Seems backwards. -_- sometimes you need to let go of old traditions and customs.

    • @yehyachalhoub7895
      @yehyachalhoub7895 2 года назад +3

      And what walk to your modernity bruv no thanks not interested in women with dicks

    • @ALGERIEECONOMIE
      @ALGERIEECONOMIE 2 года назад +8

      I think it's people like who have no tradition or culture who can be described as backwards.
      Your culture now consists of being told by the corporate world how you should live, what you should eat, buy and even dictate to you what sexuality you should be following...... You live like a zombie and you dare tell others that they are backwards?

    • @devinmcsheehy9608
      @devinmcsheehy9608 2 года назад +4

      We in the modern world have consent

    • @yehyachalhoub7895
      @yehyachalhoub7895 2 года назад +1

      @@devinmcsheehy9608 where was the consent absent here?

    • @tuforu4
      @tuforu4 2 года назад

      @@ALGERIEECONOMIE whaaaaaaassst

  • @thelonemaiden
    @thelonemaiden 9 месяцев назад

    ''girls'' in short supply? WHy / how are girls in short supply?

    • @thelonemaiden
      @thelonemaiden 9 месяцев назад

      Ah! 6 minutes to 7 minutes explains. and, not surprising to learn. So Sad!!!

  • @benoitvadeboncoeur3473
    @benoitvadeboncoeur3473 Год назад

    You notice they went for European women?

  • @sunalineemoore906
    @sunalineemoore906 2 года назад +2

    Reporter this video is made in Israel , some minority of Sammaritans people live in Mt Gerizim and still maintain in Judaism as Jews and they are the part people of Israel till now from 3,600 years ago..please, make this video clear, they are a civic participated of Israel population not Palestine, or Arab please don't make people outsider confused and make Israel wrong from good image !🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 ok , Be Thankful to God of Israel 👍🇮🇱🐋🇮🇱👍🇮🇱

  • @yakigesher-zion7289
    @yakigesher-zion7289 2 года назад +3

    The oldest original people in Palestine are Jews and Samaritans not arabs

  • @samahmud1177
    @samahmud1177 2 года назад

    .

  • @AngelaRodhas
    @AngelaRodhas 2 года назад

    Why so many Ukrainian women looking for husband abroad, what's wrong with Ukrainian men?

    • @theb3654
      @theb3654 2 года назад

      Ukraine has or had a lot more women than men

  • @Rita1984
    @Rita1984 2 года назад +3

    Samaritans are our fellow non “jewish” Israelites ❤️💕

  • @emmaoyongo8610
    @emmaoyongo8610 Год назад

    These Ukrainian women should be highly appreciated for ensuring the continuous propagation of the Samaritan ethnicity that is almost going into extinction.
    I love ❤️❤️❤️ them all.

  • @DJ_A.K_GOLD
    @DJ_A.K_GOLD 2 года назад

    This is the result , that the Jews understood , so they changed it to the mother , meaning you are a jew only if your mother is one ...
    Today 15 million jews vs 1000 Samaritans , and at the time's of Rome , each was 1.5 million..

    • @mariepearl-harbour2335
      @mariepearl-harbour2335 Год назад +1

      The Royal Torah is the word of Elohim. The father is the progenitor. The Real Judahites and Israelites know this.

  • @malhamaulkubra4437
    @malhamaulkubra4437 2 года назад +2

    The group that Jesus called dogs :) in the NT along with the Gentile Western Roman's

    • @oluwafemiadelaja7647
      @oluwafemiadelaja7647 2 года назад +13

      Is either you don't understand what you are saying or you don't know how to comprehends a story

    • @jakeward3986
      @jakeward3986 2 года назад +5

      I don't think you understand the story.

    • @just_juice
      @just_juice 2 года назад +1

      Is that what John chapter 4 says?

    • @dimejiolatunji5232
      @dimejiolatunji5232 2 года назад +2

      @@oluwafemiadelaja7647 God bless you Femi

    • @catherinemorand500
      @catherinemorand500 2 года назад +3

      The Good Samaritan

  • @crystalharris7394
    @crystalharris7394 2 года назад +20

    I enjoyed that so much very interesting thank you

  • @truthtopower48
    @truthtopower48 2 года назад +46

    Sad they have to go all the way to Ukraine to get a wife and they can't marry their own Palestinian brothers and sisters in order to keep them separated and divided

    • @sheelahales4738
      @sheelahales4738 2 года назад +12

      True, I cannot see why they have to go all the way to ULKRAINE. The culture is so totally different, they have nothing in common.

    • @Rita1984
      @Rita1984 2 года назад +15

      I dont see why they can’t marry Jews.I’m sure some jewish women would be Fine with converting. Kosher and Shabbat are basically the same anyway.

    • @aleksandrabissani567
      @aleksandrabissani567 2 года назад +2

      They are not Jew nor Palestinians. Their distinct culture created a barrier difficult to overcome with respect to each other. They don't have to convert just because they are getting merried.

    • @footballfan5462
      @footballfan5462 2 года назад +2

      @@Rita1984 they marry Israeli jews

    • @fawziaabdurrahman2251
      @fawziaabdurrahman2251 2 года назад +3

      but palestinians are muslim and the samaritans follow the towrat mostly which came with nabii Musa (a.s) so the muslim would need to change most aspects of her religion to adapt to the husband's faith. besides, i think palestinian women dont have a problem finding a husband within their own ethnic group. marrying ukranian women is also good coz they are willing to adapt to the new religion. i dont see any problem really. i think what they are doing is good for both parties involved.

  • @YukiTogawa
    @YukiTogawa 2 года назад +50

    Dear Samaritan youth,
    Marry who you wish to marry and live where ever you wish to live.

    • @sheshahayat5117
      @sheshahayat5117 2 года назад +9

      I wish the same to everyone,,,

    • @yurichtube1162
      @yurichtube1162 2 года назад +8

      This will end them tho

    • @lindada1111
      @lindada1111 2 года назад +4

      If it is the end of a culture or belief, there surely were flaws to it...

    • @end-game2030
      @end-game2030 2 года назад

      Yeah and get rid of your culture and become a big Corp sheep.

    • @end-game2030
      @end-game2030 2 года назад

      @@lindada1111 rubbish as the sheep are being manipulated.

  • @monicaenriquez8643
    @monicaenriquez8643 2 года назад +16

    Loved this documentary! I think Ukrainian women & their culture can adapt more easily into the Samaritan culture because the cultural norms & values of both societies are more closely aligned. Many American men have not achieved the same success because many don’t understand the Ukrainian culture. I have a financially successful cousin who twice went to the Ukraine and has not achieve success in marriage. I believe it is because the women whom he chose expected to have a more family values than he could provide simply because he didn’t understand what was important to those women. Thus both marriages didn’t survive. Both marriages ended in divorce and the women returned home to the Ukraine. I felt sorry for my cousin as I know he is a good man of character. Obviously he has insecurities about himself because I didn’t understand how he couldn’t find an American woman . I found that sad for him. I hope that the couples and families highlighted in this documentary are still enjoying the fruit of their marriages! I have always loved the story related in the Bible of The Good Samaritan. And that resonated in listening to the elder Samaritan grandfather sitting with his granddaughter doing lessons together! If it is proper for this 🇺🇸 grandmother I wish you “Shalom”!

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      Very interesting insight & I think you may be right. 🤔

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +2

      Not really, is mostly because they can't find a Jewish bride and because those woman decided to adapt to their husband's culture

    • @sloeberdoet
      @sloeberdoet 2 года назад +1

      @@DD-rv8hi The women seem to fit in well en enjoying their lives. I think they're sometimes better of than with Eastern European men that drink a lot . They're also better treated than most women in other Arabic countries so i don't see the problem.

  • @gailnicholson9094
    @gailnicholson9094 2 года назад +23

    I think marrying outside of their small community is a very healthy and positive way to preserve their heritage.

    • @sheshahayat5117
      @sheshahayat5117 2 года назад +4

      Why don’t we all do that, than ?

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +2

      They don't do it all the time, i mean if they don't marry a Samaritan they can marry a Jewish one (for obvious reasons this is preferred).. what I mean is that they don't look to marry a foreigner precisely to preserve their identity and heritage

    • @sloeberdoet
      @sloeberdoet 2 года назад +1

      @@sheshahayat5117 Because most communities aren't that small as theirs.

  • @mariacawdron2488
    @mariacawdron2488 2 года назад +17

    What a beautiful community!!

  • @tuforu4
    @tuforu4 2 года назад +8

    Did i hear commenters say GENETIC DISORDER..mmm

  • @IamwhoIam333
    @IamwhoIam333 2 года назад +15

    Now that I am as old as dirt and a widow I can truly understand why they still do this. It's a Family commitment for a future line of children. You have to value your tradition's and trust that your religious leaders are honest with you.
    Looks to me it is pretty straight forward with these Sumerians and I respect that.

    • @indrinita
      @indrinita 2 года назад +3

      That's what happens if you believe patriarchy is the only way to structure a society. However the couple at 23:12 seemed genuine.

    • @sheshahayat5117
      @sheshahayat5117 2 года назад +1

      Pretty hypocritical & racist too,,,

    • @debasmitapaul9511
      @debasmitapaul9511 2 года назад +1

      Religion is to expand your consciousness where you cannot distinguish between Communities... It's pure love for all living creatures including human..... Beliefs and varied heritage of culture can be maintained even if you marry outside your group provided there is love and understanding between the couple

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      Samaritans*

  • @eden55272
    @eden55272 11 месяцев назад +3

    Samartian are original indegenoius jeews,not mixed with others

    • @eloffmusk
      @eloffmusk 10 месяцев назад

      Yes, Palestine mixed with Natufian Arab the Jewish one mixed with northwestern European

  • @amoakorichard1
    @amoakorichard1 2 года назад +4

    I don't think it will be difficult for Ukranian women to adjust to life in Samaritan communities, because there are many Jewish families in Ukraine and other Eastern European countries.

  • @achayootto4221
    @achayootto4221 2 года назад +20

    "The Good Samaritan as written in the Bible....lol all we know is that they are good😁💗 Thank you for sharing with us an udate after 2,000 year's

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      😂 Yes, for real. I'm happy they're still around! 😋👍 And doing well, I see.♥️

    • @achayootto4221
      @achayootto4221 2 года назад +2

      @@dyawr me too dear.
      Peace&❤

  • @tsimba7075
    @tsimba7075 2 года назад +41

    These are the good samaritans i need in my life

    • @liveasifthisisyourlastday2345
      @liveasifthisisyourlastday2345 2 года назад +5

      Technology destroys cultures at an alarming rate

    • @tuforu4
      @tuforu4 2 года назад +3

      @@liveasifthisisyourlastday2345 no secrets

    • @shulalavy1698
      @shulalavy1698 2 года назад +1

      Muhammad word's are God word's? Hallo ?! Are you Muslim or what ?

  • @jodrew1845
    @jodrew1845 2 года назад +31

    I'm guessing that this community is where "the good Samaritan on the road, " came from. I am sorry they have such difficulty finding a mate but they have found a brillant way to address their needs. It's a shame they don't look to other ethnic groups but, whatever works. As long as everyone is happy and their unions are successful, that's what matters♥

    • @debasmitapaul9511
      @debasmitapaul9511 2 года назад +7

      Diversity will only profit human race... Lesser chances of genetic disease.... Love should prevail all over the world.... Religion and ethnicity should not be a barrier

    • @pamelajudithrwanyarare8429
      @pamelajudithrwanyarare8429 2 года назад +4

      @@debasmitapaul9511 They are diversifying hence going to Ukraine.

    • @DD-rv8hi
      @DD-rv8hi 2 года назад +5

      @@pamelajudithrwanyarare8429 not really, they first look for a Jewish partner (because blood related), if they can't find it in Israel or elsewhere then they choose to marry an Ukrainian

    • @pamelajudithrwanyarare8429
      @pamelajudithrwanyarare8429 2 года назад +1

      @@DD-rv8hi it's still diversity. Middle Eastern meets European. They are still different races just same faiths what's wrong with that?
      If there culture requires one to marry within the same faith and no one is forced to marry against their will.

  • @cholponkudus8719
    @cholponkudus8719 2 года назад +6

    Before Islam that place used to call Judea and Samaria. They language ancient Hebrew near Aramean

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      I think it's more like, before the Romans...

  • @moraaangeline8713
    @moraaangeline8713 2 года назад +38

    They make marriage look so simple and straight forward

    • @sheshahayat5117
      @sheshahayat5117 2 года назад +2

      Are you serious?

    • @zliu4208
      @zliu4208 2 года назад +6

      The grass is always greener on the other side. If you are actually from a culture in which arranged marriage is still the norm, you will realise how annoying the parents’ and sometimes, the entire extended families’ over-involvement in young people’s love life and marriage can be.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +2

      Yes, I've noticed that as well. But, as someone pointed out - personal life is likely never that easy... 🤔

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      @@zliu4208 Yes, that is true.

  • @sharischoll9411
    @sharischoll9411 2 года назад +7

    Hard to join two entirely different cultures. People are offended by things that are not meant to be offensive but in their culture it means something different. I lived in an area where people were from several different states. Constant problems. When I checked it out and heard both sides, as they were my employees, I discovered it was just a misunderstanding do to different culture meanings.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      Yes, that's true. There seems to be a sort of industry of international marriage arrangements in Ukraine - I think it's a way for women (perhaps along with their families) to aspire to get better lives... you know, more than they'd have just working & marrying in Ukraine..
      So, I think they're the ones primarily putting in the effort to adapt & adopt a new culture.. 🤷‍♀️

    • @elijahcaon8094
      @elijahcaon8094 11 месяцев назад

      ​@dyawr the fact that the Ukrainian women view living in the west bank aa better tells you what you need to know about Ukraine. That being said, the Samaritans have a very unique and somewhat enviable position in that they get preferential treatment from both sides of the conflict.
      If I were to marry someone from the holy land, it would be a Samaritan. Seems like an OK set up, if you can tolerate the religious conversion. And I don't love how it seems a lot of the women weren't told how extreme some of the beliefs are, like them having to live in a separate room once a month while menstruating and that type of thing. If they don't mind it that's one thing, but it's hard to fully be truly consenting to something if you didn't actually get really told was the reality.

  • @kailashbedi3404
    @kailashbedi3404 2 года назад +6

    The good Samaritans. 🌸🙏🌸 Beautiful production. Thank you.

  • @MultiDiane64
    @MultiDiane64 2 года назад +7

    so so sad and controlled

  • @sktgfk9229
    @sktgfk9229 2 года назад +4

    Just imagining what would happen of one of the guys bring home an African,

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      😂 Idk, there's an industry for this kind of international matrimonial agencies, in Ukraine. Maybe that's more the reason they only go there..
      But, I get what you mean. Cause the women being attractive plays a big factor, for sure... and fair skin is probl preferred.. 😕

  • @kelcal6697
    @kelcal6697 2 года назад +8

    I don’t understand the “sister exchange” or why the men are better off getting married if they have a sister?? 🤔 Someone please explain

    • @aleksandrabissani567
      @aleksandrabissani567 2 года назад +7

      basically, there would be a bride exchange. If you don't have a sister for our brother then do not expect our daughter to marry you and our son will be single forever.

    • @kelcal6697
      @kelcal6697 2 года назад +3

      @@aleksandrabissani567 thank you for clarifying

    • @fawziaabdurrahman2251
      @fawziaabdurrahman2251 2 года назад +2

      there is a shortage of women...so its like guaranteeing that the men/boys in the family find a wife. my sister is a special commodity/a treasure so if you want to marry her, bring me a wife first (coz its very difficult to find a wife)
      assume there's a shortage of food and fuel. but you have surplus food in your farm, but no fuel so anyine that wants to buy food must bring you fuel so that you also benefit. like barter trade

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +7

      @@fawziaabdurrahman2251 Yeah, it's exactly like barter, lol. 😄 ....the women should just be allowed to marry 4 husbands. Solves the problem real quick. 🤭

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      @Yo Bo Yeah, it's more of a joke.

  • @fawziaabdurrahman2251
    @fawziaabdurrahman2251 2 года назад +5

    i know someone will go to a dating website now and look specifically for samaritan men lol
    wanting a piece of the cake

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +3

      Good if that happens, their community seems to need it. 🙂 What I'm curious is what led to this shortage of women - usually nature balances itself out & there's about an even number of boys vs girls. 🤔 And they seem to be living well on average, comfortable lives.

  • @sebresludolf9611
    @sebresludolf9611 2 года назад +8

    *I really need to know what is the name of this matrimonial agency. Bro seriously how are they doing this?*

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад +1

      🤭 You can imagine this is just a presentable, general insight into their lives... personal affairs & marriage are usually more complicated than this. And we're not seeing the whole-whole story, just a few min from 3-4 couples.
      What I can tell you is that, from what I know, there is a real culture in Ukraine of marrying young & the girls/women there, see it as a natural progression (early) in life. - like going to school, graduating & then getting a job and marrying. 🤷‍♀️
      So, it's not uncommon in the Slavic world in general, (particularly North-Eastern Slavs I think - like Ukraine, Belarus, Russia, Moldova), to see many women marrying at 20-21-22-23 - around that age. Sometimes even 19.

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      Also:
      《 _"Ukraine's internet romance industry is booming - despite the unrest. _*_But after chatting online, travelling to Odessa and wooing women on flashy dates, most men fly home alone and far poorer._*_ Are they unlucky in love, or have they been scammed?_

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      _These are trying times for Odessa. After the annexation of Crimea,[...] But for all the political and economic chaos that has engulfed Ukraine in the past three months, one industry is still thriving: _*_the internet romance trade._*

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      *_The economies of several Ukrainian cities are boosted by the surreal and disingenuous online bride business, and Odessa is the biggest hub._*_ It does not take long for a visitor to the city to stumble upon an "international date" - _*_there are legions of western men in town meeting with young women they have met online, usually with the conversation facilitated by a translator._*_ At internet cafes and homes across the city, thousands of women spend hours each day chatting to prospective suitors online._

    • @dyawr
      @dyawr 2 года назад

      _There is nothing like the prospect of economic hardship to facilitate intercontinental liaisons, and so, far from business drying up in recent months, the romance and "bride" trade is booming. If anything, there are now more western men planning trips to Odessa than there were last year, when I accompanied a "romance tour" to Ukraine for a magazine story._
      *_I spent a week in Odessa with 29 men, all of them hoping to find a wife during their trip. They were mainly Americans, but there were also Brits, an Italian and a Saudi on the tour."_* 》

  • @jaialaiwarrior
    @jaialaiwarrior 10 месяцев назад +3

    This video gave me a strong sense of peace.
    The way they structure their family is very warm, familiar, beautiful and intimate.
    The most wonderful of communities.

  • @mirmirultra10
    @mirmirultra10 2 года назад +5

    Beautiful beautiful community!

  • @moshe3897
    @moshe3897 10 месяцев назад +1

    The West Bank is not occupied it belongs to Israel always did and always will 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱

  • @stephaniepope4558
    @stephaniepope4558 2 года назад +5

    Thanks for sharing

  • @hassankosar4131
    @hassankosar4131 2 года назад +5

    Waaw