Maoist cult follower: “I think he’s being framed”

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
  • Josephine Herivel is the woman who shouted out Balakrishnan's innocence in court. Surprising - because she was the one who blew the lid on the whole case, helping his daughter to leave in 2013. She speaks exclusively to Channel 4 News.
    Subscribe for more like this, every day: bit.ly/1epe41j
    Dangerous world: bit.ly/1JCsSYb
    The news explained: bit.ly/1epgay4
    Music: bit.ly/1RVTRNy
    Technology: bit.ly/1LI1K9y
    Like us on Facebook: on. 1wQ1Gty
    Follow us on Twitter: bit.ly/1mFUjBD

Комментарии • 87

  • @11oilrig
    @11oilrig 8 лет назад +47

    This lady showed courage and realism in arranging for the other cult members, including Balakrishna's daughter, to escape the collective. She realised that the daughter needed treatment which Balakrishna was denying her, and made contact with the outer world without his knowledge. Those are the actions of a well-meaning, responsible person who must have been aware of Balakrishna's faults.
    Instead of giving pat judgments, people should realise that our lack of understanding of the psychology of why young people can be entrapped into cults is a life and death contemporary issue! And also that there are 'cults' and beliefs which are not so obviously damaging, but which attract and control in similar ways.
    This woman is hardly weak-willed, as some commentators have described her, and hardly stupid. Before joining the collective she was a brilliant violinist by all accounts, and the daughter of a brilliant mathematician and codebreaker.
    But it would not be easy for her to admit to herself that for 40 years of her life she was living a terrible mistake.

    • @petepimpernel5507
      @petepimpernel5507 6 лет назад +4

      Hi! Katy herself agrees with all that, as quoted here:
      "I totally agree with this comment on Josie, in fact I’ve said as much in my book. She is just indoctrinated beyond belief. I hope she can become enlightened one day, as she doesn’t deserve to live in Bala’s mental cage!!"

    • @stonethecrows25
      @stonethecrows25 5 лет назад

      thank you for your perceptive comments

    • @youparejo
      @youparejo 4 года назад +1

      Thank you for your empathy. I think you dodged the bullet she's actually the one who tried save the others (but it's highly possible she was involved in brutalising others as well), including Katie the daughter, but she could not save herself.

    • @stover14
      @stover14 2 года назад +1

      How is she hardly weak willed? She lived in a cult for 30 years, pretty weak willed isn't it? Like, the definition of weak willed

    • @stover14
      @stover14 2 года назад +1

      A strong willed person does not let someone have complete control over their lives. Seriously, what do you even mean?

  • @1park813
    @1park813 3 года назад +22

    she's irreversibly brain washed, incredible and sad

  • @veganostra7388
    @veganostra7388 Год назад +8

    I feel so sorry for her, she helped them escape but now she cannot escape it in her own mind.

  • @annwaine2881
    @annwaine2881 6 лет назад +9

    Totally brainwashed. He could at least have let visit a dentist.

    • @youparejo
      @youparejo 4 года назад +4

      In the documentary, one of the woman said that he told them teeth must fall naturally and they would grow back when they reach 100 yo

  • @55tranquility
    @55tranquility Год назад +5

    Poor woman, her life has been literally wasted and thrown away. At least 30 years in prison she would have had access and contact with other people and the world outside and come out with a sane relationship with the world. What she has been through is so much worse - she has lost any form of rational thought. I wonder if somewhere deep inside she knows its all nonsense but that admitting this to herself would mean the complete crumbling of her entire identity so maintaining the lie is the only way she can function?

    • @jan.plays.guitar
      @jan.plays.guitar Год назад

      Probably, yeah. Very empathic of you, that’s what psychology would basically say in my opinion.

  • @rosepetal34
    @rosepetal34 7 лет назад +17

    so sad, look in her eyes you can see the pain

  • @Finallylefttomyowndevices
    @Finallylefttomyowndevices Год назад +4

    Perhaps a desperate urge, and compelled to go back to the only existence she knew for so long even if it wasn't great but could function and control her fear.

  • @TheFakeyCakeMaker
    @TheFakeyCakeMaker 2 года назад +5

    They all talk with that weird accent so strange, it's a really fascinating case. One of the things I find interesting is that to me when you actually watch these women you can see that deep down they don't really believe in all this stuff only they don't have anything else after 40 years of being force fed this bull.

  • @quietprofessional9928
    @quietprofessional9928 2 года назад +3

    Eyes says it all

  • @budekins542
    @budekins542 7 лет назад +10

    I spoke to her a few days ago and she Still thinks her cult leader was innocent.

  • @Mother_Earth777
    @Mother_Earth777 2 года назад +2

    I think admitting the truth will make her collapse, she want to believe in something. I feel sorry her, I don't think she will ever change.... Currently reading Katy boook

  • @PorkyLikesDonuts
    @PorkyLikesDonuts 19 дней назад

    I knew her two sisters - Susan and Mary - back in the seventies. Strange family but all brilliantly talented. I feel so sorry for Josie.

  • @VyGee3311
    @VyGee3311 3 года назад +2

    The “you know”s are a dead giveaway

  • @klaussperger
    @klaussperger 8 лет назад +4

    the teeth don't lie !!!

  • @WasabiDreams
    @WasabiDreams Год назад +1

    These are the words of somebody brainwashed to the core. I feel for her because she is that deluded, she can not see past his warped lies

  • @nirmaladrieskens4338
    @nirmaladrieskens4338 3 месяца назад

    She don’t want accept the truth! She’s blind for the truth! Mybe is it mind escaping to survive that kind of that she lived for 40 years! She put him on a pedestal and he can’t do anything wrong in her brain washed mind!!! She is not clear in her mind! She needs help till the end of her life!💔💔💔

  • @HooknCookbyDespinaTrina
    @HooknCookbyDespinaTrina 2 года назад +1

    I believe she helped the girl but then she was warned by him that something bad would happen to her if she didn't claim he is innocent he probably said his special so called powers would kill her and she really does believe all that he says she's clearly conditioned and scared of him

  • @raskltube
    @raskltube 6 лет назад +9

    this has got to be one the most fascinating stories of our time. im very pleased at the questions asked by the interviewer to expose this truly evil man

  • @jon123xyz
    @jon123xyz Год назад

    Her blinking is bizarre.

  • @puggzymalone5824
    @puggzymalone5824 3 года назад +3

    If he cared so much about people why wouldn't he want his own daughter to get medical help? And why did that poor deluded woman have to escape in order for her to get treatment. Thats the question he should have put to her because that proves that he didn't want her to get medical help and she obviously knew this. Plus when she lies she does the double blink tell. I think she can't except what happened because it means everything you believed in is false. She's clearly a very damaged person but doesn't seem to realise it.

  • @SK47ER
    @SK47ER Год назад

    She is literally correct.

  • @MarxistStaffy
    @MarxistStaffy 6 месяцев назад

    This is what happens when an Opportunist decides to go to the next level on using Maoism as a tool for his own fairytale (religion) nonsense.

  • @3ooth
    @3ooth 3 года назад +1

    this so sad 😞💔

  • @cellgraph
    @cellgraph 6 лет назад +1

    something is wrong about her logic

  • @mspremalatha5721
    @mspremalatha5721 2 года назад

    Its so horrible 😠😠😠

  • @martinea199
    @martinea199 2 года назад

    The relevant question is how could it be such a surprise when he literally fathered a child before your eyes

  • @TheRobstargames
    @TheRobstargames 7 лет назад +1

    Is she native to Britain?

    • @wibblyboo5229
      @wibblyboo5229 6 лет назад +9

      shes irish but been in captivity for so long shes has a weird accent, all the women in that house talk like that, so bloody strange what 40 years can do

    • @noellegunning3301
      @noellegunning3301 2 года назад +3

      Northern Ireland. Her father was later an lecturer at Queen's university Belfast. She developed an Indian accent from being in the collective.

    • @dxtura
      @dxtura 2 года назад +3

      @@noellegunning3301 it sounds more singaporean than indian imo.

    • @jonny_sparks
      @jonny_sparks 2 года назад +2

      @@dxtura "Comrade Bala" grew up in Singapore so it makes sense. I guess he did most of the talking in the commune - so his female followers ended up talking like him.