Andre Fratto played all instruments except for the drums and he is also a classical film composer. If you are up for some classic music, check out his latest original symphony right here: andrefratto.bandcamp.com/album/corona-symphony-2
When a drummer waits for almost half the video on a drumming channel to showcase her skill you know she is generous. I also enjoyed the prominence of the snare roll at about 5:18. Sina is not simply pounding out beats (though she is immaculately capable of that) she is a very skilled and collaborative musician!
I’m 67 years old and a Floyd fan from day 1. If your going to cover Floyd then it needs to be good. This is an amazing production. Absolutely loved it.
It was really really good. I was a bit confused at first why she didn’t change the gender of the song’s protagonist to female. It really works either way,. Listening again. Wow that’s very good.
Sina can be anyone she wants, Ian Paice, Phil Collins, Ringo Starr, Nick Mason … she is a real drum impersonator. It’s incredible how many different styles she can do.
Who in the world are these people? Every talented person who has a part in this video, from the musical aspect to the video production - I am blown away. I have been coming across some extremely talented musicians lately on RUclips. Covers or not - it doesn't matter. It is all top notch. The covers are simply fantastic. I respect anyone who has talent in any field of endeavor. Music has been a big part of my life since I was a kid in the 60's. The 70's can't be beat for all-around great music in many genres. And the production values took off in this decade, as well. With the state of today's popular music being so poor, a classic rock guy wonders if there are any musicians out there who can play quality music. I knew there had to be good music out there. I would hear some occasionally. But I am hearing it more and more. Like the people on this video. Again - much respect. Keep it coming.
Tommy, Sina has been the most viewed drummer on RUclips over the past 4 years by over 100 million views over #2. She has posted almost 500 videos, the vast majority Classic Rock covers or collaborations with other young artist from all over the World, most of them as good or better than the original. She has released 3 original albums and produced other music. She is also touring Europe as the drummer for "Rock The Opera", attending music college, and still keeping up her RUclips channel. There's more, but Sina is the real deal.
@@gregbr100 Thank you. I appreciate all of the info you provided. You want to see these talented and driven people succeed in the field that they are passionate about. Plus it sort of guarantees us hungry listeners that we will continue to be fed their delicious entrées. And appetizers and dessert, as well. With some thirst-quenching drinks thrown in there for good measure.
There are very, very few artists that can make a cover of an iconic Pink Floyd song and match the original's quality, intensity and feeling. Vienna, Andre, Sina and Mike have done it here flawlessly! 💯
Ok so I admit, I am lost. I am lost in the sheer brilliance of the performance, I am lost in the graphics and visuals....I like what is done here...extremely tastefully...and then I always lose myself in those drums... So I am hearing this for the 2nd time in 24 hrs...just letting the music cascade over me. Thank You Sina and your merry band for these musical blessings
Just found Sina Drums today and these are the best covers I've ever heard. This was one of my brother's favorite songs, he died 7 months ago, he would have loved this. You guys are AMAZING 👏 ❤ 👏
War in Dortmund, Anfartsweg 700km Ich kann und will nun auch nicht nach 30 Jahren versuchen mich daran zu erinnern, wie die einzelnen Songs rüberkamen, aber eins weiß ich mit Gewissheit: Es war und ist das gigantischste, sowie beeindruckendste Konzert, das ich bis zum heutigen Tag erleben durfte. Was ich damals Komisch fand; eine Durchsage: nehmt keine Drogen, ihr erlebt den totalen Kick. Nicht zuviel versprochen.
Of all the songs I have heard in my 65 years this one song is most important to me due to a deep caring experience with my Mom when she became terminally ill. Your production was so beautiful that I was brought to tears..... Thank you for that. I am eternally grateful to you for making this one song so poignantly beautiful.
I watched this video 10 times and plan to view it many more times. Pink Floyd should be envious of your collective talent. Get a good agent and make something beautiful happen.
Mike, it is a video produced with mastery and artistry, Vienna a voice that embraces and penetrates, beautiful interpretation, André, musical arrangements and sound quality that one appreciates, and Sina, every time I see you on the drums I delight, you are air, water, earth, fire, and spirit, I congratulate you. Art in essence.
What can I say, I was blown away by this Pink Floyd cover, what an impressive voice, what a masterfully played guitar, perfect arrangement, Sina as an integral part of this extraordinary performance and, last but not least, her father's professional video composition. But one thing struck me in particular: the sound quality, especially the voice of Vienna D’Amato Hall, rarely heard so prominently, great!
Well done Sina, I am impressed. The story goes that Nick Mason of Pink Floyd could not drum this because of the difficult time signature changes and they got Jeff Porcaro to do this track. It was another tense brick in the situation when PF recorded The Wall album.
I lost an good friend / brother a couple years ago. We loved this song. What you guys have done here, is perfect Sina. If James were with us, he would have an tear in his eye. God knows i do.
Floyd is one of my favorite bands. Comfortably Numb is my favorite song, followed by Mother. This was awesome. Andre did a great job. Really liked Vienna's voice. Great job on the drums. Thanks Sina
Einen riesen Respekt für dieses Video. Ich bin ein Pink Floyd-Fan mit meinen 63 Jahren, habe viele Cover- und Tributes-Bands gesehen, aber was Du in Deinem Video so kreativ gestaltet hast, ist unglaublich.
Sina, you continually demonstrate your innate ability to drum accurately and with such passion to some of the most challenging songs and favorites to so many fans. I always look forward to your next video! I love how you pay tribute to the rock legends, like John Bonham, Keith Moon, Ringo Starr, et al. And I like how you collaborate with some very talented musicians, such as on this video. Thanks for all of your performances! Some I watch several times with and without headphones. Simply put: you got natural talent.
Nur sehr selten gefällt mir eine Cover Version von Pink Floyd genauso gut, wie das Original. Es ist fantastisch, dass du es gewagt hast diese Band zu covern und es ist dir ausgezeichnet gelungen. Ein perfektes Zusammenspiel von Gesang, Instrumental und Video. Deinen Kanal habe ich natürlich schon seit Längerem abonniert und habe sehr viele musikalische Highlights entdecken dürfen. Besonders gefällt mir auch das Cover Child in Time von Deep Purple und Black Dog von Led Zeppelin in dem du gemeinsam mit Alyona und Andrei musizierst. Einfach ganz große Kunst. Danke und weiterhin viele schöne Erfolge. Ralf
I relive my drum playing youth that was taken away from me, simply by watching and listening to Sina. Her music transcends so many good things, there probably in not enough room in the world to hear how she talks through her drums. I love her performances, and hope she continues to grow in her profession. Buddy
Thanks Sina and company! This is my absolute favorite album! This is the best rock opera/musical composition. Roger did a tremendous job on this. Sina and crew you did a great rendition, thank you for sharing.
Wow!! Stunning video mix and a totally moving performance by some really talented musicians. Vienna's vocals were spot on and Andre owned the melody. Drumming was not too shabby also! 🧡
Sina! Guten Abend! Tolles Lied!!! Pink Floyd!!! Sina! Dein Spiel ist toll!!! Toller Drumkit-Sound !!! Sina! Alles super geworden!!! Vielen Dank!!! 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹♥️♥️♥️💘💘💘🥁🥁🥁🎶🎶
Thank you! Thank you!! Thank you!!! Sina, Mike, Vienna, Andre, this is so incredibly beautiful!!! Sina Drums absolutely the best music channel on RUclips!
I must say perfection is a standard found in few 'things'. In this video and most all other Sina THINGS I see perfection from all aspects. Keep it coming young lady, others would do well to follow your lead in pursuit of happiness. Your talent is such a decorum of your being. God Bless All
Wow such a powerful piece and again Sina you did such a great job your drumming skills are so precise and powerful you nail it every time love your playing💖👌
Frohe Weihnacahten! .... Frohes Fest! ......Schone Feiertage! ...Ein gesegnetes Weihnachtsfest! ... Gesegnete Weihnachten! .... Merry Christmas to you Sina and your Dad and entire family
Im not really a Pink Floyd fan at all i have Dark side of the Moon but i dont have The Wall. . I didn't enjoy the Pink Floyd concert that i attended at the NJ Meadowlands/Giants Stadium decades ago......But i have to tell you Ms. Doering, ms. Hall and Mr. Fratto everything in this video is just pure pleasure and perfection..bravo.! And thank you! 🎼🎶🎶🎶🎵🎶🎵🎙🎸🥁🎹😊❤
Sina, Großartig! Die Musikauswahl, dieser Titel. Eine wunderbare Interpretation. Ich wünsche Ihnen, dass Sie von Roger Waters ebenso "Credits" bekommen, wie von Ian Paice. Sie haben es verdient. Und, JA! Sie sind gut genug. Sina, Great! The choice of music, this title. A wonderful interpretation. I wish you get "credits" from Roger Waters as much as from Ian Paice. You deserve it. And, YES! You are good enough.
Sina when The Wall Album came out I had to buy it I knew this album was gonna be great still have it this day mother was one of my favorite hits your drumming is always on Time never miss a beat I can watch you play all day you are truly great I loved the video to the song the cover of the wall the video was great you’re such a Talent keep up those great beat you’re fan TCB Take care of business 👍⭐️🥁🎶❤️
I'm not sure if I already commented on this (or maybe I just thought about it and didn't write anything yet). But if so, it bears commenting again... I only recently discovered this beautiful recording within the last 2 months, and I am still "new" to Sina's world... But I have listened to this track multiple times, and I can't stop going back. Pink Floyd is one of my all-time favorite bands, and this is one of favorite songs (from the Wall). I have heard multiple versions of this song (original studio album, The Wall movie version, live concert version , etc.); and this... wow... this is one of the best... right up there with Pink Floyd's recordings and in some ways (dare I say), better... Sorry Roger and David!!! I love the sweeping extended guitar solo (like the live version)!!! And the imagery is similar to the movie. I have just done some "critical listening" and Sina's drumming is so spot on, it's almost unbelievable... even the subtle ride cymbal and bell when the drums first come in. This is so magnificent, I can't say enough... I was inspired and I just posted an amateur vocal version of "Mother" on "Indaband" (which I learned about from Sina)... Obviously, my version is not to the level of this professional recording, but I just wanted to share how inspiring this music is, and how these recordings are actually making a difference in our lives. Myself and all of Sina's patreons and subscribers and fans absolutely adore the drum covers (with backing tracks), but this type of musical collaboration with othr brilliant musicians is just the best... Please make more of these for us!! I realize that these masterful productions cost money and time (which also equals money, as they say)... but we can find or raise the funds, as this is worth it!! Thank you! Muchas gracias... Gracie, Merci, Obrigado, Vielen Dank!!
Remaking such an iconic piece of music is very risky, but with fantastic musicians as you are the result is something unique and great, congratulations to all !!.
Give me a brake. These fake musicians are playing it safe. Diminishing themselves by trying to mimic another soul's success. You guys suck. If you want to truly shine, sing your own Goddamn song. Sina needs to grow up and stop being a little girl.
@@joejones8810 Sorry but I don't agree, there is nothing wrong with playing covers, all great artists do it, reinterpreting the songs of others according to their experience and ability, but you have to be capable of it. It is important to put effort and originality into it. Make a cover of a famous song does not mean winning easy, because if done badly, the comparison with the original would be merciless. The skill in making this cover is precisely being able to make a song full of originality that you listen to with interest without making you regret the original version. This is what only experienced and talented musicians can do.
@@joejones8810 much of Led Zeppelin's repertoire were covers of Mississippi delta blues. It is good that they are getting inspired by all creeds of musical genre, and letting this process build their own image. I am sure Nick Mason was inspired by influences of fellow drummers.
Miss sina , if at sometime you could you maybe cover silver paper by mountain, or to defy the laws of tradition by primus ? Been watching you keep my musical interests alive for a while and appreciate the fact you not only play but play with enthusiasm, it's inspirational, and I actually have my daughter intrigued by you , she's 13 and plays a flute in her school band for 3 years now , we enjoy your work and just wanted to say thank you for what you do ,
Yes, it was Porcaro on this track. This was the only track on the album where Mason wasn't on drums. The story goes that Mason found the constantly shifting time signatures difficult to learn within the tight recording schedule, so they called on Jeff.
@@Prof_Jeff No shame in that. Jeff Porcaro was one of the greatest and most iconic session drummers of all time. The man could play on any song and make it look easy.
Wow, what an amazing production. Next to the Who, Pink Floyd is my favorite group and this video displayed the intensity of the original in spades; brought tears to my eyes.
Andre Fratto played all instruments except for the drums and he is also a classical film composer. If you are up for some classic music, check out his latest original symphony right here:
andrefratto.bandcamp.com/album/corona-symphony-2
😊😊😊🎶🎹🎸🎤😎🖖
Aw, shucks. Thank you guys for your brilliant work! Vienna too! Wow! And thank you, Sina fans! I'm so glad you're enjoying this! :)
@@sonia_kl99, thank you so much! 🎸
@@NorbertTristan, that’s so kind! Thank you, thank you, thank you! I hope you enjoy. ❤️❤️❤️❤️🎶
Du wagst dich da an ein grosses Thema an liebe Sina. Aber du liebst die Musik, ich bewundere dich sehr. Du bist so gut, mach immer weiter
I am 62 years old .... Pink Floyd I have been listening since 1975. After Sinina's first blow, tears welled up ...
When a drummer waits for almost half the video on a drumming channel to showcase her skill you know she is generous.
I also enjoyed the prominence of the snare roll at about 5:18. Sina is not simply pounding out beats (though she is immaculately capable of that) she is a very skilled and collaborative musician!
Praises for playing the extended guitar solo. Great song..
I’m 67 years old and a Floyd fan from day 1. If your going to cover Floyd then it needs to be good. This is an amazing production. Absolutely loved it.
64 and ditto.
I 100% subscribe to that.
It was really really good. I was a bit confused at first why she didn’t change the gender of the song’s protagonist to female. It really works either way,. Listening again. Wow that’s very good.
55 years young and totally blown away by this excellent rendition of a Floyd favourite 😻
I’m 105 and guess what…WTF cares about how old I am
Best version of this song I ever heard.
Thank you Sina and friends ❤️
THANKYOU. Both Sina and Vienna. Excellent.
Welcome, to our Circle Of Light. Thankyou for joining us.
Sina can be anyone she wants, Ian Paice, Phil Collins, Ringo Starr, Nick Mason … she is a real drum impersonator. It’s incredible how many different styles she can do.
Who in the world are these people?
Every talented person who has a part in this video, from the musical aspect to the video production - I am blown away. I have been coming across some extremely talented musicians lately on RUclips.
Covers or not - it doesn't matter. It is all top notch.
The covers are simply fantastic. I respect anyone who has talent in any field of endeavor. Music has been a big part of my life since I was a kid in the 60's. The 70's can't be beat for all-around great music in many genres. And the production values took off in this decade, as well. With the state of today's popular music being so poor, a classic rock guy wonders if there are any musicians out there who can play quality music. I knew there had to be good music out there. I would hear some occasionally. But I am hearing it more and more.
Like the people on this video. Again - much respect. Keep it coming.
Tommy, Sina has been the most viewed drummer on RUclips over the past 4 years by over 100 million views over #2. She has posted almost 500 videos, the vast majority Classic Rock covers or collaborations with other young artist from all over the World, most of them as good or better than the original. She has released 3 original albums and produced other music. She is also touring Europe as the drummer for "Rock The Opera", attending music college, and still keeping up her RUclips channel. There's more, but Sina is the real deal.
@@gregbr100 Thank you. I appreciate all of the info you provided. You want to see these talented and driven people succeed in the field that they are passionate about. Plus it sort of guarantees us hungry listeners that we will continue to be fed their delicious entrées. And appetizers and dessert, as well. With some thirst-quenching drinks thrown in there for good measure.
There are very, very few artists that can make a cover of an iconic Pink Floyd song and match the original's quality, intensity and feeling. Vienna, Andre, Sina and Mike have done it here flawlessly! 💯
Emotional … Congratulations to all, 7 minutes of pure pleasure.
I can listen to that, Adorable Sina, on the drums all-day. Pink Floyd should pay her for bringing these songs back.
God Bless Sina Friday Thank you 🙏❤️😎much Love from Detroit
Bravo everyone, May your stars continue to shine bright.
a blast from the past!
SINA-DRUMS, IT'S ALWAYS GOOD TO HEAR FROM YOU SINA !!!!!!!!! SINA YOU AREA TALENTED , BEAUTIFUL YOUNG WOMAN !!!!!!!!!!
Ok so I admit, I am lost. I am lost in the sheer brilliance of the performance, I am lost in the graphics and visuals....I like what is done here...extremely tastefully...and then I always lose myself in those drums...
So I am hearing this for the 2nd time in 24 hrs...just letting the music cascade over me.
Thank You Sina and your merry band for these musical blessings
Nothing to say but Simply Awesome
Just found Sina Drums today and these are the best covers I've ever heard. This was one of my brother's favorite songs, he died 7 months ago, he would have loved this. You guys are AMAZING 👏 ❤ 👏
Yesterday, for me! How did I not know about Sina earlier? Glad I found her
War in Dortmund, Anfartsweg 700km Ich kann und will nun auch nicht nach 30 Jahren versuchen mich daran zu erinnern, wie die einzelnen Songs rüberkamen, aber eins weiß ich mit Gewissheit: Es war und ist das gigantischste, sowie beeindruckendste Konzert, das ich bis zum heutigen Tag erleben durfte. Was ich damals Komisch fand; eine Durchsage: nehmt keine Drogen, ihr erlebt den totalen Kick. Nicht zuviel versprochen.
Among your best covers ever. Amazing.
Sina you're the very very best keep it up.
What talent!
Congratulations!
PLEASE run for president ... this world needs someone like you
Of all the songs I have heard in my 65 years this one song is most important to me due to a deep caring experience with my Mom when she became terminally ill. Your production was so beautiful that I was brought to tears..... Thank you for that. I am eternally grateful to you for making this one song so poignantly beautiful.
Goosebumps.
Fantastic version.
I watched this video 10 times and plan to view it many more times. Pink Floyd should be envious of your collective talent. Get a good agent and make something beautiful happen.
Amazing beautiful, well done
Mike, it is a video produced with mastery and artistry, Vienna a voice that embraces and penetrates, beautiful interpretation, André, musical arrangements and sound quality that one appreciates, and Sina, every time I see you on the drums I delight, you are air, water, earth, fire, and spirit, I congratulate you. Art in essence.
The ride/hi-hat work in this is just so very tasteful!
One day this young lady will by the highlight of the big stage. She must now master the art of big solo and let her inner self free...
What can I say, I was blown away by this Pink Floyd cover, what an impressive voice, what a masterfully played guitar, perfect arrangement, Sina as an integral part of this extraordinary performance and, last but not least, her father's professional video composition. But one thing struck me in particular: the sound quality, especially the voice of Vienna D’Amato Hall, rarely heard so prominently, great!
Sina’s talent is matched by her charisma and class. I am a big Pink Floyd fan and I give this cover a perfect 10. 🙏
what a production🔥
Well done Sina, I am impressed. The story goes that Nick Mason of Pink Floyd could not drum this because of the difficult time signature changes and they got Jeff Porcaro to do this track. It was another tense brick in the situation when PF recorded The Wall album.
Wow - so ein tolles Lied. Pink Floyd wären begeistert.
What was in the minds of Sina and her fanciful friends? Embracing a thought-provoking classic, with skill and heart.
Really beautiful SINA, a big thank you to you. Lots of big kisses from France. 💕💕💕
Not too many women can sing the classic rock songs. Vienna did a fantastic job on this one. Awesome job Sina thank you.
OMG Sina...I have never heard that with so much emotion.....wonderful...thank you.
Outstanding performance
I lost an good friend / brother a couple years ago. We loved this song. What you guys have done here, is perfect Sina. If James were with us, he would have an tear in his eye. God knows i do.
Floyd is one of my favorite bands. Comfortably Numb is my favorite song, followed by Mother. This was awesome. Andre did a great job. Really liked Vienna's voice. Great job on the drums. Thanks Sina
Awesome! 🥰
Nice performance Sina.
Einen riesen Respekt für dieses Video. Ich bin ein Pink Floyd-Fan mit meinen 63 Jahren, habe viele Cover- und Tributes-Bands gesehen, aber was Du in Deinem Video so kreativ gestaltet hast, ist unglaublich.
Nice Video. Almost an honor to Another Brick in the Wall. Relaxing vocals.
Sina, you continually demonstrate your innate ability to drum accurately and with such passion to some of the most challenging songs and favorites to so many fans. I always look forward to your next video! I love how you pay tribute to the rock legends, like John Bonham, Keith Moon, Ringo Starr, et al. And I like how you collaborate with some very talented musicians, such as on this video. Thanks for all of your performances! Some I watch several times with and without headphones. Simply put: you got natural talent.
Mother is my favorite Pink Floyd song. This tribute was phenomenal
Wundervoll. Das hat mich voll abgeholt
Nur sehr selten gefällt mir eine Cover Version von Pink Floyd genauso gut, wie das Original. Es ist fantastisch, dass du es gewagt hast diese Band zu covern und es ist dir ausgezeichnet gelungen. Ein perfektes Zusammenspiel von Gesang, Instrumental und Video. Deinen Kanal habe ich natürlich schon seit Längerem abonniert und habe sehr viele musikalische Highlights entdecken dürfen. Besonders gefällt mir auch das Cover Child in Time von Deep Purple und Black Dog von Led Zeppelin in dem du gemeinsam mit Alyona und Andrei musizierst.
Einfach ganz große Kunst. Danke und weiterhin viele schöne Erfolge. Ralf
The original loses a lot the drums.
Amazing arrangement Sina with Vienna. I really enjoyed it. Love watching you play the drums.
A nice piece of work this. I'm lovin it. I got my calendar in the mail today. Thank you. Do good, be safe.
I got mine today also. I think it's better than the 2021 calendar and it came 3 months sooner.
I relive my drum playing youth that was taken away from me, simply by watching and listening to Sina. Her music transcends so many good things, there probably in not enough room in the world to hear how she talks through her drums. I love her performances, and hope she continues to grow in her profession. Buddy
Glad U reminisce, sad about what was taken.
oh sina what a great talant you are truely amazing thank you for the music
Thanks Sina and company! This is my absolute favorite album! This is the best rock opera/musical composition. Roger did a tremendous job on this. Sina and crew you did a great rendition, thank you for sharing.
you guys are awesome, i fell in love with her drumming since the light my fire cover back in 2016
Amazing. Perfect. Pink Floyd. Sina.
Truly fantastic. Well done!!!! Thank you.....
Just the perfect cover of this magical song and music.Thank you Sina
👍👏🌹🌹🌹💕
Hi Sina, fantastic job well done to all of you, welcome home safe and sound have a great weekend thank you for another great cover...
Wow!! Stunning video mix and a totally moving performance by some really talented musicians. Vienna's vocals were spot on and Andre owned the melody. Drumming was not too shabby also! 🧡
Thanks Sina for keeping a true classic song alive. This song from WW2 needs to be remembered in this day and age! Great job Sina.!!
Sina! Guten Abend! Tolles Lied!!! Pink Floyd!!! Sina! Dein Spiel ist toll!!! Toller Drumkit-Sound !!! Sina! Alles super geworden!!! Vielen Dank!!! 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹♥️♥️♥️💘💘💘🥁🥁🥁🎶🎶
Thank you! Thank you!! Thank you!!! Sina, Mike, Vienna, Andre, this is so incredibly beautiful!!! Sina Drums absolutely the best music channel on RUclips!
Couldn't help but notice that you dropped the conventional grip for this cover. The execution was, as always, top notch.
Good catch, but it was noted in comments / confirmed by Sina to be recorded about a year ago... agree:top notch🌴
Perfection in the production the playing and the song
The medium is the message and Sina you have mastered the medium. This is perfection- What an accomplishment by you and your team.
Absolut killer… god is this a good attempt on this timeless tune.
I'm Really Speachless
The magical music of Pink Floyd in a wonderful performance by Sina. 👍
I must say perfection is a standard found in few 'things'. In this video and most all other Sina THINGS I see perfection from all aspects. Keep it coming young lady, others would do well to follow your lead in pursuit of happiness. Your talent is such a decorum of your being. God Bless All
567 comments b4 me. this piece touches to the bone. tears in my eyes of joy and sadness at the same time. thank you 4 ur work.
Wow such a powerful piece and again Sina you did such a great job your drumming skills are so precise and powerful you nail it every time love your playing💖👌
Frohe Weihnacahten! .... Frohes Fest! ......Schone Feiertage! ...Ein gesegnetes Weihnachtsfest! ... Gesegnete Weihnachten! .... Merry Christmas to you Sina and your Dad and entire family
Im not really a Pink Floyd fan at all i have Dark side of the Moon but i dont have The Wall. . I didn't enjoy the Pink Floyd concert that i attended at the NJ Meadowlands/Giants Stadium decades ago......But i have to tell you Ms. Doering, ms. Hall and Mr. Fratto everything in this video is just pure pleasure and perfection..bravo.! And thank you! 🎼🎶🎶🎶🎵🎶🎵🎙🎸🥁🎹😊❤
Just made my day better
Sina, everything is just right in this video ... The song, the drums, the partners and the video production. Simply perfect and great !! 🌹🌹🌹
Someone sounds like a lap dog lol
Thank you Sina, you are a dream made of the matter of music!!
Sina , great as ever , but we couldn't hear you , music was too loud , drowning your drums , love ya !
You are an amazing girl. Thank you so much for keeping Pink Floyd alive. You are really great.
Sina, Großartig!
Die Musikauswahl, dieser Titel. Eine wunderbare Interpretation.
Ich wünsche Ihnen, dass Sie von Roger Waters ebenso "Credits" bekommen, wie von Ian Paice.
Sie haben es verdient. Und, JA! Sie sind gut genug.
Sina, Great!
The choice of music, this title. A wonderful interpretation.
I wish you get "credits" from Roger Waters as much as from Ian Paice.
You deserve it. And, YES! You are good enough.
Soooooooooooooo beautiful song version!! Congrats to Sina and the composer and all the crew who did this possible!!!
This is outstanding all around.
Sina when The Wall Album came out I had to buy it I knew this album was gonna be great still have it this day mother was one of my favorite hits your drumming is always on Time never miss a beat I can watch you play all day you are truly great I loved the video to the song the cover of the wall the video was great you’re such a Talent keep up those great beat you’re fan TCB Take care of business 👍⭐️🥁🎶❤️
Hi Sina! "Mother" is one of my favorite songs from "The Wall". Awesome Cover and video. Great job by your dad putting this together.
bravo un grand talent vraiment magnifique
I'm not sure if I already commented on this (or maybe I just thought about it and didn't write anything yet). But if so, it bears commenting again...
I only recently discovered this beautiful recording within the last 2 months, and I am still "new" to Sina's world... But I have listened to this track multiple times, and I can't stop going back. Pink Floyd is one of my all-time favorite bands, and this is one of favorite songs (from the Wall). I have heard multiple versions of this song (original studio album, The Wall movie version, live concert version , etc.); and this... wow... this is one of the best... right up there with Pink Floyd's recordings and in some ways (dare I say), better... Sorry Roger and David!!! I love the sweeping extended guitar solo (like the live version)!!! And the imagery is similar to the movie. I have just done some "critical listening" and Sina's drumming is so spot on, it's almost unbelievable... even the subtle ride cymbal and bell when the drums first come in. This is so magnificent, I can't say enough...
I was inspired and I just posted an amateur vocal version of "Mother" on "Indaband" (which I learned about from Sina)... Obviously, my version is not to the level of this professional recording, but I just wanted to share how inspiring this music is, and how these recordings are actually making a difference in our lives.
Myself and all of Sina's patreons and subscribers and fans absolutely adore the drum covers (with backing tracks), but this type of musical collaboration with othr brilliant musicians is just the best... Please make more of these for us!! I realize that these masterful productions cost money and time (which also equals money, as they say)... but we can find or raise the funds, as this is worth it!!
Thank you! Muchas gracias... Gracie, Merci, Obrigado, Vielen Dank!!
Just down right Damn great. Thank you!
Excellent work, Sina!! Kudos to you all for this tribute.
Remaking such an iconic piece of music is very risky, but with fantastic musicians as you are the result is something unique and great, congratulations to all !!.
Give me a brake. These fake musicians are playing it safe. Diminishing themselves by trying to mimic another soul's success. You guys suck. If you want to truly shine, sing your own Goddamn song. Sina needs to grow up and stop being a little girl.
@@joejones8810 Sina has made three albums of entirely original material. Please do your research before spouting off.
@@joejones8810 Sorry but I don't agree, there is nothing wrong with playing covers, all great artists do it, reinterpreting the songs of others according to their experience and ability, but you have to be capable of it. It is important to put effort and originality into it.
Make a cover of a famous song does not mean winning easy, because if done badly, the comparison with the original would be merciless. The skill in making this cover is precisely being able to make a song full of originality that you listen to with interest without making you regret the original version. This is what only experienced and talented musicians can do.
@@joejones8810 much of Led Zeppelin's repertoire were covers of Mississippi delta blues.
It is good that they are getting inspired by all creeds of musical genre, and letting this process build their own image.
I am sure Nick Mason was inspired by influences of fellow drummers.
@JoeJones, you’re a knob !
Miss sina , if at sometime you could you maybe cover silver paper by mountain, or to defy the laws of tradition by primus ? Been watching you keep my musical interests alive for a while and appreciate the fact you not only play but play with enthusiasm, it's inspirational, and I actually have my daughter intrigued by you , she's 13 and plays a flute in her school band for 3 years now , we enjoy your work and just wanted to say thank you for what you do ,
Awesome - just awesome! Vocals, guitar solo, drumming, it's all so amazingly good.
This was first class! Very entertaining and chilling.
On an average day I would say that the Beatles are my favorite group. But then. nothing moves me like Pink Floyd. Thank you for this perfect cover! 👍
That left hand grip-Whatever it takes to sound fantastic.
Wonderful job, Sina, played with passion and finesse as always. R.I.P. Jeff Porcaro, drummer extraordinare
Jeff? Nick Mason is the drummer for Floyd
@@billkaldem5099 Jeff Porcaro, not Nick Mason, played the drums on Mother
Yes, it was Porcaro on this track. This was the only track on the album where Mason wasn't on drums. The story goes that Mason found the constantly shifting time signatures difficult to learn within the tight recording schedule, so they called on Jeff.
@@Prof_Jeff No shame in that. Jeff Porcaro was one of the greatest and most iconic session drummers of all time. The man could play on any song and make it look easy.
With this and Rosanna (and perhaps others I’ve missed) you have done Jeff Porcaro proud! Excellent cover!
What an amazing video! Pink Floyd, great work one of the best songs
Sina you are brilliant, talented, the best ever!!!
I got your beautiful calendar!
Wow, what an amazing production. Next to the Who, Pink Floyd is my favorite group and this video displayed the intensity of the original in spades; brought tears to my eyes.
With this and Rosanna (and perhaps others I’ve missed) you have undoubtedly done Jeff Porcaro proud! Excellent technique, excellent covers.
Sina drums keep doing what you love because we love what you do