AoA and ChoA fans please read this! This is not a idol solo debut. This is a project of ChoA's. She is turning popular rap songs into BALLADS! Please stop listening as if it is a pop song. There is not going to be a catchy chorus. There aren't going to be catchy singing styles. This song showcases lyrics, emotion, and feeling. Please take some time to explore ballad artists before you comment on the style of song. The song is slow, eerie, and melancholy. Just how it should be.
I'm just going down liking all the positive comments about this song and choa that aren't mean or about BTS Let Choa have her moment guys. She worked hard on this.... If she read any of these comments she would be sad...
I really think the song is good. A song doesn't have to have high notes all the time to be good, and ChoA doesn't have to sing high notes every single time to be captivating
Choa pulls off ANOTHER look, she has had so many, a serious and troubled look...completely the opposite of the cute aegyo and sexy AOA looks...I love the song....Choa is a true artist...she explores different areas and tries to convey feelings and thoughts ..... I hope she continues doing new and challenging roles/songs....she is like a painter conveying a fictional characters thoughts ...she isn't trying to make a popular song but a character for you to explore
I am not even kidding when I say this is one of my favorite song ever, from any singer/group. The emotion ChoA showed through her voice is irreplaceable
Love how this song made use of Choa's most comfortable vocal range for the most part. The fact that she's more of an alto with a singing voice slightly on the deep side makes her really suitable for intense ballads like these. This concept fits her so well, it's actually hard to believe that the cute Choa Song exists lol petition for a full studio version of it as well please~
눈을 뜨는 순간부터 시작되는 아픔 너를 떠올리는 시간마다 시린 가슴 그 동안의 이별은 이별 아니었나 봐 이게 바로 이별이란 걸 너로 배워 가 내 방에 너와 있던 일이 모두 영화가 돼 그 영화 속의 넌 내 사랑의 주인공인데 끝나가는 사랑의 끝을 보기 싫어 난 처음으로 다시 되감아 너를 꺼내 봐 저 하늘에 달빛이 나의 눈물에 가릴 때 하나만 하나만 나의 사랑도 끝나고 다 잊으려 지우려 내 맘 속에 널 태워도 불꽃처럼 나를 감싸는 지독한 내 못난 사랑아 한 편의 시가 되어버린 나의 슬픈 사랑 한 번의 실수로 날 버린 너란 나쁜 사람 한 방울의 눈물로 잊을 수만 있다면 일년 삼백 육십 오일을 울 수 있는 걸 저 하늘에 달빛이 나의 눈물에 가릴 때 하나만 하다만 나의 사랑도 끝나고 다 잊으려 지우려 내 맘 속에 널 태워도 불꽃처럼 나를 감싸는 지독한 내 못난 사랑아 가라 가라 너라는 사람아 한 때는 내 사랑아 저 바다에 별빛이 거센 한숨에 잠길 때 서러워 서둘러 억센 내 숨도 끝내고 내 마지막 혼잣말 부는 바람에 날리고 네가 없어 내가 떠난다 머나먼 곳으로 저 하늘에 달빛이 나의 눈물에 가릴 때 하나만 하나만 나의 사랑도 끝나고 다 잊으려 지우려 내 맘 속에 널 태워도 불꽃처럼 나를 감싸는 지독한 내 못난 사랑아
Well, here I am, a year and a bit onward. Listening to this on repeat to soothe my sadness and send my well wishes to ChoA. I hope she has a speedy recovery.
I can't believe people think the chorus is underwhelming. Its not just about singing loud the chorus shows how much emotion choa can put in her voice. Plus she does a high note at the end anyway so how are you not satisfied.
How is this a song that lacked impact?! The chorus is beautiful, sad, soulful and PERFECT! I thought it was really impactful until I read the comments O.O
One of the best K-pop vocalist is here!!!!!!! The way she presents the song and anything is just perfect. Is it ChoA fits the song or the song fits her?
hey, I've seen that hardly none here know what conect the MV to the lyrics, so here's my only way to explain it a bit, so first, into, the death person I think it's the person she's crying about (she killed beeing blood thirsty), as we can see clearly she's a vampire (sun burns her skin.... obvious), then the person she had closed in, I think it's like a splitted personality, she's out and the "beast" or "hungry vampire" of her who killed him is closed inside, may that explain a bit the part of "Thought I burn you in my heart to ferget & erase My poor love wrapping around me like a flame" , so for the open air scenes I still without explanation. so pleae if I'm totally wrong or just useless ppl help! We all love her so don't hate each other :)
This is good, you know.. Minus the creepy part where the girl kept captive another girl for the reason as to drink her blood when the moon turns red (..?)
+Iris wonderland i didn't find it scary in particular so i think you can watch it but i don't know what triggers you so idk but i don't think that it was scary, not at all
I like AOA... but this sounds nothing like AOA o_o ...I LOVE IT It is seriously giving me the chills, seems made for a movie drama, so mature-sounding and such harrowing ambience musically.
Saw some negative comments, and I don't understand it. People say that the chorus wasn't strong enough and it didn't impact them... It's a really good song, and a singer doesn't have to scream at you until their pipes are about to burst to be deemed good. ChoA's voice is beautifully unique and she is skilled at what she does. I'm satisfied with this. Great job ChoA~
They filmed the abandoned pool scene in the same place where BTS' prologue was filmed too. Take a look at 1:40, that drawing at the wall was Taehyung's drawing in the prologue.
![T-ARA[티아라] "완전 미쳤네 [So Crazy]" M/V](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/maSoUetHock/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#2024MAMA] BIGBANG (빅뱅) - 뱅뱅뱅 (BANG BANG BANG) + FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EQsYfiPR9uM/mqdefault.jpg)
2024 초아화이팅
Choa's voice is so impressive like the candle's light
+Prince Rawa ★ LoveKPopKurdishSubs ★ wish i could sing like dat
+0vershade this song has more of s classic vibe, I thought it picked up in the second half especially towards by the end...great vocals
+Kx7pl 5 a*
Yah,my heart is melting!
emotional
My first kpop bias... from my first kpop groupe... I miss U ChoA, you still in my heart
이게 ㄹㅇ띵곡인데
전에 비행기에서 들었을때 감성에 취해서 뛰어내리고 싶었다
감성에 취해서 뛰어 내리고 싶었다 ㅇㅈㄹ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 개 웃기네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋㅋㄱㅋㄱㄱㅋㅋㄱㄱㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ감성에취하기만하세요 뛰어내리지마세요ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㄱㄱㄲㄱㄱㄱㄱㄱㄱㅋㄱㄱ 미친다
오랜만에 들으러왔어요 초아언니 목소리 너무 좋아요 😍
AoA and ChoA fans please read this!
This is not a idol solo debut. This is a project of ChoA's. She is turning popular rap songs into BALLADS! Please stop listening as if it is a pop song. There is not going to be a catchy chorus. There aren't going to be catchy singing styles. This song showcases lyrics, emotion, and feeling. Please take some time to explore ballad artists before you comment on the style of song. The song is slow, eerie, and melancholy. Just how it should be.
What’s the meaning and storyline of the song btw ? I’m curious
초아 컴백기원 솔로곡 정주행!
컴백준비중 유튜브 나옴
2020 anyone? miss choa so much
So do I. What happened to her
@@Ryo517s she left AOA (her girl group) due to depression and insomnia.. we don't hear much from her
Denise i was once a huge fan, so sad to see her go
True, we hope she will say something in the future
so much T T
이게진짜 가수지... 어떻게 뮤비를 찍을때도 프로정신을 보여줄까 정말 가창력 더불어 얼굴에서도 죽지않는데.. 와 이노래듣고 눈물나왔다ㅠ
정말 마약같은가창력,가사&멜로디..하루에도 수십번을듣는다..
I miss choa!!😢
ChoA is one of the best vocalist in Kpop
She is coming back soon
가수초어 반가워요
I'm just going down liking all the positive comments about this song and choa that aren't mean or about BTS
Let Choa have her moment guys. She worked hard on this.... If she read any of these comments she would be sad...
Why are you including BTS in it?
I only love 4 members of bts 1.V 2.j-hope 3.suga 4.jungkook
because people are including bts in their comments
진짜.. 눈물날뻔했어..초아언니 사랑해요ㅜㅠ
I really think the song is good. A song doesn't have to have high notes all the time to be good, and ChoA doesn't have to sing high notes every single time to be captivating
and yet its beautiful.. what an unique voice she has
Its a cover song
high notes is easy for her but she is a rare female singer with an amazing low pitch.
Choa pulls off ANOTHER look, she has had so many, a serious and troubled look...completely the opposite of the cute aegyo and sexy AOA looks...I love the song....Choa is a true artist...she explores different areas and tries to convey feelings and thoughts ..... I hope she continues doing new and challenging roles/songs....she is like a painter conveying a fictional characters thoughts ...she isn't trying to make a popular song but a character for you to explore
Although you are not the member of AOA now ,I will support you until the end of world . My love ,Choa.
초아언니 음색 너무좋음 ㅜㅜ
초아목소리 너무 좋아
ちょあが一番好きだった
I Love Choa…❤️
초아님 고생 많이 했다 스트레스 많이 봤고 마음 고생 많이 했을 거 같다..ㅠ 웃으면서 유튜브 한 거 봤는데 마음 아프당 ㅠㅠ 초아 응원해요
초아 보고 싶어요 ㅠㅠ....
아 정말 초아 음색 좋다♡
진짜최고다..어떻게저렇게 숨이꺼지듯.심장이조이듯처절하게외치듯, 감정을저렇게실을까..최고다~진짜!
0:33 와 너무 이뻐서 헉함
Would be cool if they had Seoulhyun as the vampire girl it would really bring back some Orange Marmalade feels
+TransFormersAddict11 true ^^
+TransFormersAddict11 true
Im sure that was the whole point not to use her, everyone would get those feels again of how bad the show was and seolhyuns bad acting haha
no she needs to take a break we dont want AOA that means "always one absent" we want ace of angels
+ItsSunnyHere still Seolhyun won award from that show.....
와 목소리 진짜좋다... 빠져든다빠져들어
omg I'm really loving the song and music video
Listen to choa don't be shy it's a amazing
+jeon jungkook i came here just to check out v's drawing but then im glad i didnt missed such a beautiful song and voice ;3
+abram garibay hahahahaha jungkook?
+jeon jungkook can you see the girl walk in the ground ? It was appeared on BTS prologue ~ =)))))))) Remember ?
HopeMin My yeah hhhhh i already commented on that 💕
노래완전조하 초아완전사랑이야 진짜 ㅠㅠㅜㅜㅜ사랑스럽다 완벽해 😍😍😍😍
I am not even kidding when I say this is one of my favorite song ever, from any singer/group. The emotion ChoA showed through her voice is irreplaceable
Oh she's the girl from She Was Pretty! I knew I saw her somewhere before...
THANK YOU !! fot this comment!!
i was squeezing my brain to remember!! lol
Nope its not her. xD They just look very similar :)
True! Hahaha. Kim Hae Jin when she's a teenager and second character is Kim Hae Jin's younger sister. Ngeee.
+MiggyMac it's her. Jung Da Bin a young actress born in 2000
+Linh Đặng OHHH her. I knew. I thought she was talking about Choa xD She looked liked Ha Ri xD
Choa warms this winter with ''Flame''. Slay!
Choa has a very impressive vocal range, I love this song :) Love AOA.
퀸덤보고 aoa 노래 찾아보는데 이거 숨겨진띵곡이었네요ㅜㅜ좋다...초아그립네
초아 졸예...❤❤❤
솔로곡을 이거밖에 안내고 가다니.... 아쉽다진짜ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 음색과 목소리가 아까워
이건 리메이크곡이라 솔로곡이라 하긴 좀 그렇고 아끼지마, 무슨말이 더 필요해, 아직하지 못한 말 있어요
초아 복귀했어요..
ㅎㅎ소식들었어요 너무 행복하네요ㅜㅜ
이건 진짜 죄임
박초아 사랑해 너무 오랜만에 돌아와봤다
omg this song is awesome..Chao you are the Best!!
2019 and I'm still missing Choa. I hope she is doing fine
초1,2학년때 뮤비 보고 좀 무섭다고 생각한 노래, 노래 너무 좋음 ㅋㅋ
Love how this song made use of Choa's most comfortable vocal range for the most part. The fact that she's more of an alto with a singing voice slightly on the deep side makes her really suitable for intense ballads like these. This concept fits her so well, it's actually hard to believe that the cute Choa Song exists lol petition for a full studio version of it as well please~
God this song is so so so *underrated* ChoA's voice is simply stunning and this music video is shot beautifully.
New year's day 2020 0002. Thinking of you Choa. Fighting!
만날엉덩이살랑대는 걸그룹인줄만알았는데 목소리들으니 진짜 애절한목소리를 가진 가수네요
Omg I can't believe I forgot about this song... I'm having so many flashbacks, my happy days
눈을 뜨는 순간부터 시작되는 아픔
너를 떠올리는 시간마다 시린 가슴
그 동안의 이별은 이별 아니었나 봐
이게 바로 이별이란 걸 너로 배워 가
내 방에 너와 있던 일이 모두 영화가 돼
그 영화 속의 넌 내 사랑의 주인공인데
끝나가는 사랑의 끝을 보기 싫어 난
처음으로 다시 되감아 너를 꺼내 봐
저 하늘에 달빛이 나의 눈물에 가릴 때
하나만 하나만 나의 사랑도 끝나고
다 잊으려 지우려 내 맘 속에 널 태워도
불꽃처럼 나를 감싸는 지독한 내 못난 사랑아
한 편의 시가 되어버린 나의 슬픈 사랑
한 번의 실수로 날 버린 너란 나쁜 사람
한 방울의 눈물로 잊을 수만 있다면
일년 삼백 육십 오일을 울 수 있는 걸
저 하늘에 달빛이 나의 눈물에 가릴 때
하나만 하다만 나의 사랑도 끝나고
다 잊으려 지우려 내 맘 속에 널 태워도
불꽃처럼 나를 감싸는 지독한 내 못난 사랑아
가라 가라 너라는 사람아
한 때는 내 사랑아
저 바다에 별빛이 거센 한숨에 잠길 때
서러워 서둘러 억센 내 숨도 끝내고
내 마지막 혼잣말 부는 바람에 날리고
네가 없어 내가 떠난다 머나먼 곳으로
저 하늘에 달빛이 나의 눈물에 가릴 때
하나만 하나만 나의 사랑도 끝나고
다 잊으려 지우려 내 맘 속에 널 태워도
불꽃처럼 나를 감싸는 지독한 내 못난 사랑아
원본으로 불러도 좋았을거같다
Well, here I am, a year and a bit onward. Listening to this on repeat to soothe my sadness and send my well wishes to ChoA.
I hope she has a speedy recovery.
i hope this m/v will receive a million views.. she deserve it...
I can't believe people think the chorus is underwhelming. Its not just about singing loud the chorus shows how much emotion choa can put in her voice. Plus she does a high note at the end anyway so how are you not satisfied.
원곡도 진짜 좋아하는곡인데 절제하면서도 내뱉듯 부르는게 오히려 더 애절하게 와닿네... 완전 빠져들음;; 뮤비컨셉은 살짝깨지만 초아 음색만큼은 진짜 웬만한 여타가수 쌈싸먹겠네요
How is this a song that lacked impact?! The chorus is beautiful, sad, soulful and PERFECT! I thought it was really impactful until I read the comments O.O
Yeah, right?!
Choa demonstrating herself here as a wonderfully subtle and effective singer. Beautiful, sorrowful song ...
Cho a please comeback with a "real album" or i can't cry anymore
초아 돌아와줘
Choa's vocals were quite impressive. Way to go Choa~
choa has a magical voice. I loved this single
I am in love with Choa!
와 진짜 초아누나 완전 여신인듯
노래도잘부르고 성격도좋고
이뿌고ㅎㅎ
목소리 대박이다ㅠㅠ촤 화이팅!!
Is Choa going to perform this song on stage ? I hope she perform it..I love it ♡♡
I'm glad i found this MV. Choa's voice is impressive.
One of the best K-pop vocalist is here!!!!!!! The way she presents the song and anything is just perfect. Is it ChoA fits the song or the song fits her?
이거 ㄹㅇ 레전드
초아 이 노래 진짜 좋다. 계속 듣게 되네
초아조아요
Unnie this song make me cry (이 노래는 나를 울게 만들)
This would make a good soundtrack for a movie! Choa is beautiful and the song is nice.
촤누나 눈빛 대게 몽환적이네..♥ 화장땜에 그런가? 촤누나 예뻐요♥
i was soooo attracted when Choa did the Notes....i just love that part so much...Choa Voice is vvv sweet & Nice like the person itself
ChoA is coming back to the industry! My queen ❤
this its an amazing song, i hope more people discover it. Cho ah voice it shines here.
hey, I've seen that hardly none here know what conect the MV to the lyrics, so here's my only way to explain it a bit, so first, into, the death person I think it's the person she's crying about (she killed beeing blood thirsty), as we can see clearly she's a vampire (sun burns her skin.... obvious), then the person she had closed in, I think it's like a splitted personality, she's out and the "beast" or "hungry vampire" of her who killed him is closed inside, may that explain a bit the part of
"Thought I burn you in my heart to ferget & erase
My poor love wrapping around me like a flame"
, so for the open air scenes I still without explanation.
so pleae if I'm totally wrong or just useless ppl help! We all love her so don't hate each other :)
Park Choa = Goddess of the Voice, as same as her face, even the mv actress is cute, but Choaya is still much much more attractive.
음색 진짜 좋아
Her voice is incredible, splendid and perfect music , very talented choa
초아님 노래 잘불러요~^^♥
This is good, you know.. Minus the creepy part where the girl kept captive another girl for the reason as to drink her blood when the moon turns red (..?)
+Iris wonderland i didn't find it scary in particular so i think you can watch it but i don't know what triggers you so idk but i don't think that it was scary, not at all
Out of context that sounds really weird I'm sorry
Can we talk about Choa looking PERFECT like an angel like a doll in this MV !!!!!😮😮😮😮😮😮
와 헐 뮤비 중간중간에 나오는 곳 방탄 화양연화 프롤로그 그 장소 아니야ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 이렇게 보니까 반갑다ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
I actually liked the song alot ... her voice delivered emotion to me
I went here today because I miss Choaya, I wish she's doing well today 😩❤
it was sudden that she gave up her dream. I wonder what really happened between her and her company.
@@kuroneko3206 or maybe btw Choa and Jimin ?
Choa just perfect to creepy concept.
非常"棒"的聲音,在我聽過的韓國女歌手中我很喜歡 !(太妍.潔西卡.白智英.許率智)
給草娥 Cho A ,希望妳能有更好的作品 ....加油!
오늘 첨들었는데 노래듣기 넘좋다.
I like AOA... but this sounds nothing like AOA o_o
...I LOVE IT
It is seriously giving me the chills, seems made for a movie drama, so mature-sounding and such harrowing ambience musically.
+bloodberrybellamy Agree :) Love it too.
+bloodberrybellamy thats because this isnt aoa, this is choa, she's her own person and has her own sound (:
+bloodberrybellamy AOA Black more likely has sounds like this, search for AOA Black Without You
AOA's b tracks sounds like this
Forever my favorite vocalist, Happy birthday i hope you're happy wherever you are
2020
Legend is back...
오랜만에 들으니 좋다 ㅠㅡㅠ초아 이런 노래 잘어울려,,
I think Choa is the princess of ost. It's song same as ost series Korean drama.
ChoA My Princess.👑👑👑
this is a really nice song it has a mysterious thriller era which is my favourite
ikr, i feel like if there's a mystery and thriller based drama, it would be a great OST. i love the lyric too
+cikmiza93 so agree
stalker
Lina Akhtar you found me.... that's makes you a stalker
+blei stift is thegirl in this video suppsed to be a vampire?😜
2019 anyone?? 😭 I miss Choa !
Here. And now, Mina is gone too...
Choa 넘좋아 돌아올거야
됼아욜거야 이먈읁 너늕 벉엮하지 몼핡꺼약 ㅋㅋ
@@oficina27-official7 really?
@@TakkySweetgirl Yes, they "AOA" released a new song without Mina
Saw some negative comments, and I don't understand it. People say that the chorus wasn't strong enough and it didn't impact them... It's a really good song, and a singer doesn't have to scream at you until their pipes are about to burst to be deemed good. ChoA's voice is beautifully unique and she is skilled at what she does. I'm satisfied with this. Great job ChoA~
This is a very good ballad.
My sad song
This is so good... its hard not to get emotional~ 😢
The music video and the song go so well together
HAPPY BIRTHDAY!! CHOA!!! ❤️🎉🎂🎁🎈🎊
They filmed the abandoned pool scene in the same place where BTS' prologue was filmed too. Take a look at 1:40, that drawing at the wall was Taehyung's drawing in the prologue.
I still listen to this song every now and then even though 6 years have passed by.
Good
.
CHOA FIGHTING 👊
omg love the close up shots on choa's expression 😍😍
노래는 좋은데 너무 잔잔하게 해석한듯...초아도 고음 잘하는데ㅠ