The mysterious atmosphere in the instrumental, the strings in the second verse adding drama to the song, the 80's synths in the bridge, all alongside their flawless vocals... I know a lot of people didn't get this song, but this is seriously one of their bests
So true! Yeri mentioned their focus is to make music for fans instead of what trending or would make them popular, that is why the members discuss and have a lot of meetings together before an album release. What did I do to deserve them🥲
Dude, I agree. Maybe I'm just drifting from K/J pop but I really can't get into some of the newer groups from the last three years. They all sound the same and it's all the same choreography. Blackpink is really the only big group I enjoy and even then a lot of their music has fallen off. Some sad times.
U know that unfortunately this is not that true. They just found a vibe that match them, their ages and the people's aproval. In the start they were going to promote RED and VELVET songs, wich means velvet songs were the classical red velvet's ballads, but after their 1st velvet single "one of these nights" ended up with not that impact caused by the others concepts, they promoted a LOT of time in a really "RED" vibe, starting from Roussian Roulette and almost till Psycho they were sutck in some weird concept songs, in my opinion. I still love the girls and the songs and concepts at all, don't misunderstand me, but don't forget the concept idea of them. It's like when time passed, they put some ''DARK" in the concepts too xD
omg fr… this is literally one of the most red velvet sounding songs and people hate it sadly :( it’s because they don’t get it. rv has been making quirky and weird music since debut and they still want them to make those repetitive basic commercial songs that are too easy to listen to. rv’s sound is MADE to be not easily digested by the public because of its special uniqueness and we love rv for that!! we should not let locals take rv’s originality away.
It's because all the newer songs are short and clearly a way to be easily digestable so when new songs that bring back a proper song structure, they think it's outdated unfortunately@@Lady_bugg9316
when they said this will be a red velvet concept they really meant it, the whole song has that velvet side and then the chorus feels more brighter more red…this is really amazing red velvet will never disappoint with their work
This ain't a music video, this is a music movie. Red Velvet comebacks are so mysterious and tells stories so deep in their MVs. The creativity and talent is overflowing
Lol no. It’s just the fact that SM is known for having groups that are vocally strong, which isn’t a lie and there’s nothing wrong/ incorrect in mentioning that. Do other SM groups have the same vibe as RV? No. But like RV, do they do exceptionally well with vocals? Yes. And that’s what @miniya is pointing out; that of course RV is going to have strong vocals because majority of SM groups do. Basically applauding the company for valuing the importance of singing WELL. @bestest5346
The way you just know it’s a Red Velvet song when u hear one, there is something special in this group that sets them apart from others I love them sm!
The MV feels like short movie, all the storyline and cinematography are superb. It's always Red Velvet styles that gives different vibe between the song colour and the MV... For me, it feels like they set them free from toxic relationships ❤
I adore how Irene takes on the final vocals. Her portrayal as the familial guardian fairy resonates deeply, with her soothing tone seemingly signaling the end of all bad things they've endured.
I just came back to watch this MV and it made me cry. The story about them finally escaping the shadow of their abuser and still sticking together as sisters really hit home. Even though they get caught they are still happy and hold hands like their signature style of them holding hands in a circle. The feeling of happiness while still having that under the surface feeling of doom and horror is what red velvet does best and they're so real for that. There is no other group quite like red velvet.
Omg really that’s the meaning I did think the song was about something kinda like that cause of the stuff they were doing in the mv but omg I’m so sad now that’s such a sad story redvelvet always has a dark or sad meaning to there bright and colorful songs
Red Velvet is always known for their duality concept. Red is their girly, happy, summer vibe (Red Flavor, Queendom, Zimzalabim) while their Velvet is the more mature and darker theme (Peek-A-Boo, Bad Boy, Psycho). But THIS, this one is finally the one where i can see their two concepts merging. This is probably their first Red Velvet song.
you're genuinely one of the greatest kpop groups ever. we will never have another one like you, queens. thank you so much for existing, for the music, for everything.
Too many people found the instrumentation to be “weird”/complex. You’d think that more people would know that SME artists are always going to deliver innovate songs that stand out from the rest of the industry.
Too many people found the instrumentation to be “weird”/complex. You’d think that more people would know that SME artists are always going to deliver innovate songs that stand out from the rest of the industry.
i think one of the reasons why RV is still popular today is bc they dont follow trends (in terms of music) most kpop nowadays feels catered to the west with a lot of pop but RV always changes it up!!🥰
Exactly! Red Velvet is true to their music, to what they want to do, be experimental not always the same concept because it was "popular". They are a 10 year group and even sm most successful group in america, with not us label for album distribution, promoted there like the new groups do now.
@oopsweareonaride Totally. SM isn't going to have RV abandon their musical identity 10 years later just so they appeal to drooling Billie Eilish and Doja Cat fans.
@@MillerJeykYG and JYP lean towards western pop and they’re part of the Big3. I don’t think there’s a correlation between them being from a big company to their genre of music.
Red Velvet continue to break the mould and raise their ceiling by releasing incredibly cinematic, alluring and mystifying MVs, there was so much to unpack from this. I really loved all of the members getting to act their heart out especially Joy and Yeri.
You're here because you have a unique taste in music. And I praise you for that. Being a luvie is remarkable because the girls always drop "hit or miss" music, yet you are still a fan of them.
I can’t with these whole comeback!Just what are they?Why so good?!I’m having goosebumps all over while listening to the whole album.Just how incredible the whole team RV is and the team behind them? This is why every single release of theirs is anticipated.
Red Velvet really been winning shows every year since 2015, the only 3rd gen girl group to win Music Core this year too, talk about longevity, loyal fandom, general public wanting to give this recongnition to Red Velvet. ChillK win is even more wholesome cause everything was so against just a win and the members knew it, that is why their shock face, all those posts, ahhhh so proud, happy for them, Reveluv, you are the best!
@@seully_4 Red Velvet never used ads not even in 3rd generation, the most follow Girl Group in Korea, named the best kpop group alive by Billboard, sm most successful group in US, still no US label or promoted in america lol yeah, already have their place.
The thing about RV is they are always original. Always make you think. No one of their songs ever sounds the same. They are perfection in terms of quality and quantity. I love them so much!
This indeed gave me the CHILLS!!! Wow, great song, great video! RED VELVET never disappoints. The most original group and the darkness is still there. Triumph!!
only red velvet can pull a concept like this, sounds sweet and kinda innocent but lowkey weird, like there's some disturbing secret hidden in something cute, it's a playful concept, so unique, so red, so velvet and i LOVE MY QUEENS FOR THAT!!! 💗💛💙💚💜 let's enjoy this album my fellow luvies!
@@feea-pe8uq 본인은 드라마 랩 좋다고 하셨으면서 뻔한 랩 추가라니... 그렇게치면 에스파도 자기네가 낸 노래에 랩 추가한거 아닌가요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그리고 다른사람 개인적인 감상인데 거기다 대고 왜 전문가마냥 똥폼잡고 진지처빨고 대댓달고 그러시는...😅 댓글은 원래 감상이랑 자기 생각 다는 곳이에요 객관적인 평가만 쳐쓰라고있는게 아니라요
This is seriously one of my faves from them. I just love the storyline and the realistic atmosphere, rather than an obvious set. It just shocks me that their talents just keep getting more ore fine-tuned as time goes on. Great job girls!
@@Nothereforit174Tbh, red velvets songs kind of have this certain feel to them that remain even when the concept changes, but they are still some of the most flexible groups in the kpop industry
This is actually a masterpiece, SM should promote their best artists much more, Red Velvet is unmatched. This MV mixes one of my favorite movies with my favorite music group, I couldn't be happier, but I would love for SM to promote Red Velvet more...
Red Velvet never a disappointment, WOW i really got chill watching the MV, the song was so great. Cant wait for my Red Velvet album in the mail... RED VELVET FIGHTING!!!
oh I looooove the song and the music video representing something sinister’s going on but it’s under a disguise of false joy, switching up from a really mysterious sound to something super cheerful and reckless ……. Another red velvet slay
@@urhypeboy You can fall in love more even if you like a song already. And just because it's not your cup of tea doesn't mean no one genuinely likes the song - I personally loved it at first listen. And yet it still made me fall in love more the more I listened to it.
@@urhypeboy I loved it at first listen, then loved it more and more the more I listen to it. If it’s not your cup of tea then fine, it’s not my responsibility to force it on you. Not your place as well to come on here and complain about someone’s music preference 😊
Wow. Red Velvet always comeback with unique and different concept. I love it. The MV and the vocals. Thank you. Reveluvs, we are so lucky to have Red Velvet. Let's watch this together and support them to the fullest
I’ve been a red velvet fan for 5 years and this is the only group i REALLY respect for sticking to their beautiful art direction and distinctive music. In a way, red velvet is one of those groups with a cult following (joke totally intended haha) that is sooo well deserved. Red velvet is timeless. LONG LIVE RED VELVET!!!
at first i used to believe their album was low key boring, except for 3 or 4 songs, but after i checking the lyrics it makes so much sense, it's such a beautiful album for a cold season!
This song came out 10 days before my dad died... a year later I'm reflecting on how listening to this song during that time brought me so much comfort and hope. I'll always be so thankful to Red Velvet for releasing such a beautiful song, I wish it had gotten promoted more 💕
it feels crazy that I've gotten into red velvet this year cause it feels like I've been listening to them for years the way this song made me feel nostalgia
I have no words, I am mind blown. This is a concept red velvet pulls off so well istg. The vocals, the dance, EVERYTHING gave me LIETRAL CHILLS. props to them for this amazing comeback
RV ALWAYS slays the horror concepts. they gave us a whole movie this time. love this girls, ive followed their careers since debut and they just get better and better
@@riffgroove fr tho idk why i be hatin it on my first listen i wasn't rlly having it and didn't even thought of listening again til a month later lmfao DEFINITELY A ME PROBLEM
The mysterious atmosphere in the instrumental, the strings in the second verse adding drama to the song, the 80's synths in the bridge, all alongside their flawless vocals... I know a lot of people didn't get this song, but this is seriously one of their bests
Agreed. 👍
That's RV. It's all for us, the fans. Those who appreciate them.
I LOVE THE INSTRUMENTAL BROOO
the "don't think about tomorrow" part is like warm hugs🧸 it has the same feelings as psycho's "hey now we'll be okay"
exactly
YES
And yet people are still complaining about wanting “Psycho 2.0” when that’s exactly what ChiII KiII was.
추워져서 다시 생각나는노래
El grupo más elegante del kpop ❤
ця пісня дуже осіння
헐 그래서 방금 왓는데
they really do do it for the arts not the charts
Yes, they’re like the true artists of kpop
@@Crystalcloudzz Realest comment!
And i really love it
This song is basically the definition of "Red Velvet".
hauntingly beautiful, Dark mv, Crazy vocals. Story telling...This song is so Red Velvet!
True
cmt like cmt
BTS BETTER STAN BTS
@@Sismsjsi I like bts; But this isnt bts video, it comes across as rude to say this.
@@Sismsjsi go to promote bts somewhere else
One thing I really like about Red Velvet is that they never betray their vibe for popularity. They've stayed true to their root.
always changing their concepts!! queens
So true! Yeri mentioned their focus is to make music for fans instead of what trending or would make them popular, that is why the members discuss and have a lot of meetings together before an album release. What did I do to deserve them🥲
Dude, I agree. Maybe I'm just drifting from K/J pop but I really can't get into some of the newer groups from the last three years. They all sound the same and it's all the same choreography. Blackpink is really the only big group I enjoy and even then a lot of their music has fallen off. Some sad times.
Omg I was just thinking just that!
U know that unfortunately this is not that true. They just found a vibe that match them, their ages and the people's aproval. In the start they were going to promote RED and VELVET songs, wich means velvet songs were the classical red velvet's ballads, but after their 1st velvet single "one of these nights" ended up with not that impact caused by the others concepts, they promoted a LOT of time in a really "RED" vibe, starting from Roussian Roulette and almost till Psycho they were sutck in some weird concept songs, in my opinion. I still love the girls and the songs and concepts at all, don't misunderstand me, but don't forget the concept idea of them. It's like when time passed, they put some ''DARK" in the concepts too xD
can we appreciate how they've been making music for 10 years
it is A must
also the way they make ACTUAL MUSIC
fr they made so many music genres, i really really like RV music
Its been a remarkable 10 years that went by fast.
I suppose all things must pass. It was a fantastic journey.
still can’t believe that the public does not like this song like this is the most balanced red and velvet concept that we’re all looking for
omg fr… this is literally one of the most red velvet sounding songs and people hate it sadly :( it’s because they don’t get it. rv has been making quirky and weird music since debut and they still want them to make those repetitive basic commercial songs that are too easy to listen to. rv’s sound is MADE to be not easily digested by the public because of its special uniqueness and we love rv for that!! we should not let locals take rv’s originality away.
But for sm this style suitable with aespa more.
it's all because this mv is too long, we have 20 empty seconds in the beginning and at the end before the bridge too
MV: 🩸🔪💀🪦🔥🚔
The chorus: 🌈⭐️🌸🌞🍀🦋
But i love it
@ey1ubwhy's everyone always saying that can u tell me please
pretty sure it only a myth that it freezes views@@dogyuru
@@dogyuruthey think it freezes views but it doesn't
lyrics: 🥶💧🖤🪦
M..😮❤😮😮😅😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😅😊😅 0:36 😅😊😅😅😅😅😊😅😊😊😊😊😊😊😅😅😮😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😊😊❤❤😅😊😊😊😊
This MV deserves so much more. People slept on this song!
fr
The mv literally has 22M views 😂
@@silvervixen007 not enough for a big 3 gg after 4 months
@@silvervixen007 22M for a 10 yr old group from the Big4? Sounds underappreciated for me
@@silvervixen007for redvelvet Korean releases that’s low… not to mention the fact they’re under Sme.
i’m obsessed. the concept is so creepy and the song is so fun. this is cinema.
Who's here after Cosmic ?
Me
Me
Me
mee
Me
the concept is really unique, it's creepy but at the same time calming. their album is really a no skip album!! so inlove!!
thats a lot of their music videos! you should check out more red velvet if you like this concept :)
@@giovanabanana-8why all of their comebacks sounds like a song for Old people now LOL
@@simpayshenaidesin what way is this an "old people" song?
@@simpayshenaidesstick to kids bop and cocomelon then, you big baby.
It's because all the newer songs are short and clearly a way to be easily digestable so when new songs that bring back a proper song structure, they think it's outdated unfortunately@@Lady_bugg9316
when they said this will be a red velvet concept they really meant it, the whole song has that velvet side and then the chorus feels more brighter more red…this is really amazing red velvet will never disappoint with their work
This ain't a music video, this is a music movie. Red Velvet comebacks are so mysterious and tells stories so deep in their MVs. The creativity and talent is overflowing
What's the story of the music video?
Dreamcatcher copy
@@sept4799It's a secret 😂.
@@prokol_ne_v_prikol what did they copy from dreamcatcher
@@prokol_ne_v_prikolwho ?
레드벨벳만의 음악성과 독창성은 아무도 따라가지 못함 트레일러 티져 뮤비 모두 단편 영화같음 앨범 자체도 전곡으로 듣다보면 온몸에 소름이 끼침
뮤비 본지 이틀차인데 볼 수록 왜 이렇게 여운 가득한 영화를 보는 것 처럽 맘이 아려오는지..... 특히 아이린 표정 볼 때마다 조용하고 무표정인데 그 흔들리고 텅빈 것 같은 눈이 맘을 아프게 한다.
2틀차 아니고 이틀차
Dizi ile ne alakası var bunun normal bir klip çekimi
Red velvet never disappoint us when it comes vocals.... Bridges are crazy...
they're an sm group after all... sm ent really knows how to make vocally strong groups and how to use their potential. love this comeback
@bestest5346 girl what
Lol no. It’s just the fact that SM is known for having groups that are vocally strong, which isn’t a lie and there’s nothing wrong/ incorrect in mentioning that. Do other SM groups have the same vibe as RV? No. But like RV, do they do exceptionally well with vocals? Yes. And that’s what @miniya is pointing out; that of course RV is going to have strong vocals because majority of SM groups do. Basically applauding the company for valuing the importance of singing WELL. @bestest5346
The way you just know it’s a Red Velvet song when u hear one, there is something special in this group that sets them apart from others I love them sm!
4th gen fans love to call Red Velvet flops but their groups always go back to RV’s concepts😂
This is one of their MVs that i keep rewatching, not just listening, but WATCHING. The storyline is just something i LIVE for.
there's something in RED VELVET that nothing kpop group can't copy, that's why it's worth stanning them.
정말 스엠 냄새의 정석.. 레드벨벳은 항상 자신들의 아이덴디티가 확실해서 노래 듣는 맛이 있음 하나같이 찰떡으로 소화하고 멤버마다 능력치도 뛰어나고 무엇보다 합이 너무 잘맞음..
평생 노래해주라..
please red velvet never stop making music, kpop is so boring without you
The MV feels like short movie, all the storyline and cinematography are superb. It's always Red Velvet styles that gives different vibe between the song colour and the MV... For me, it feels like they set them free from toxic relationships ❤
I adore how Irene takes on the final vocals. Her portrayal as the familial guardian fairy resonates deeply, with her soothing tone seemingly signaling the end of all bad things they've endured.
I just came back to watch this MV and it made me cry. The story about them finally escaping the shadow of their abuser and still sticking together as sisters really hit home. Even though they get caught they are still happy and hold hands like their signature style of them holding hands in a circle. The feeling of happiness while still having that under the surface feeling of doom and horror is what red velvet does best and they're so real for that. There is no other group quite like red velvet.
Omg really that’s the meaning I did think the song was about something kinda like that cause of the stuff they were doing in the mv but omg I’m so sad now that’s such a sad story redvelvet always has a dark or sad meaning to there bright and colorful songs
Watching Redvelvet's mv's are like watching a movie ......
How many likes?!?!?! Puku puku paw paw
FRRRRR
Red Velvet is always known for their duality concept. Red is their girly, happy, summer vibe (Red Flavor, Queendom, Zimzalabim) while their Velvet is the more mature and darker theme (Peek-A-Boo, Bad Boy, Psycho). But THIS, this one is finally the one where i can see their two concepts merging. This is probably their first Red Velvet song.
And their last as well ༎ຶ‿༎ຶ
😂 The last you say.... fat chance... keep dreaming lol 😆 🤡
I think Icc and birthday are red but winterish 😂❤ I love red velvet duality
@@EpiCODM i better not dream as well, it's just cause i read in an article that this might be their last release that im anxious
@@sourrrr8 where is that article? send link if it's legit
you're genuinely one of the greatest kpop groups ever. we will never have another one like you, queens. thank you so much for existing, for the music, for everything.
truly The Best Idol Group Alive!
I’ve never seen any other kpop group do a new different concept for every comeback, and that’s why they stand out for me I love my girls sm
i 100% agree.
@@vulever521*female, yes
@@miac5843They’re not the only ones who do that, among women only if
Don't understand why this song is so underrated. Definitely one of their best songs
Too many people found the instrumentation to be “weird”/complex. You’d think that more people would know that SME artists are always going to deliver innovate songs that stand out from the rest of the industry.
Too many people found the instrumentation to be “weird”/complex. You’d think that more people would know that SME artists are always going to deliver innovate songs that stand out from the rest of the industry.
the audio has much more love than just the MV, they made the MV way too long for a 3 minute song...
i think one of the reasons why RV is still popular today is bc they dont follow trends (in terms of music) most kpop nowadays feels catered to the west with a lot of pop but RV always changes it up!!🥰
Exactly! Red Velvet is true to their music, to what they want to do, be experimental not always the same concept because it was "popular". They are a 10 year group and even sm most successful group in america, with not us label for album distribution, promoted there like the new groups do now.
@oopsweareonaride Totally.
SM isn't going to have RV abandon their musical identity 10 years later just so they appeal to drooling Billie Eilish and Doja Cat fans.
and their fans is very loyal too
@@MillerJeykYG and JYP lean towards western pop and they’re part of the Big3. I don’t think there’s a correlation between them being from a big company to their genre of music.
They're kinda fallen off tho, just like twice.
10M without ads with an experimental song. I am proud honestly.
with no promotional push for this title track from the company, they’re famous famous indeed. The countless reaction videos proves it
It's so satisfying watching it rise naturally.
its 24M now
Red Velvet continue to break the mould and raise their ceiling by releasing incredibly cinematic, alluring and mystifying MVs, there was so much to unpack from this. I really loved all of the members getting to act their heart out especially Joy and Yeri.
이 뮤비 뭔가 계속 보게됨.... 사리곰탕처럼 자극적이지않고 담백한 맛이 있어
아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 뭔지 알것 같음 ㅋㅋㅋ
저는 진라면 먹용 시드니 ❤
진짜요... 가끔씩 생각나서 찾아와서 뮤비 보고 갑니다! 노래도 안 질리고 계속 듣고 있는데, 뮤비도 가끔가다 생각나는 마력이...
@@seok.e_48 최근 cosmic도 좋아요!!
곰탕처럼 아닙니꺼,, 사리곰탕은 세상 짠데..?
No one can pull this kind of concept, but RED VELVET DOES ! QUEEN OF CONCEPT !
So true #slayredvelvet
Exactly. Red Velvet has the best concept!
What a great comeback! Red Velvet never let us down.
레드벨벳 특유의 그 분위기와 곡들 너무 애정해... 오래오래 활동해줘...
You're here because you have a unique taste in music. And I praise you for that. Being a luvie is remarkable because the girls always drop "hit or miss" music, yet you are still a fan of them.
I can’t with these whole comeback!Just what are they?Why so good?!I’m having goosebumps all over while listening to the whole album.Just how incredible the whole team RV is and the team behind them? This is why every single release of theirs is anticipated.
💖💖💖
What I love about RV is they're staying true to their sound instead of following trends
Almost ten years, Red Velvet is still proving they are the most music interesting group and charting on top!
oh Red Velvet the trend setter that you are 💅💅
Red Velvet really been winning shows every year since 2015, the only 3rd gen girl group to win Music Core this year too, talk about longevity, loyal fandom, general public wanting to give this recongnition to Red Velvet. ChillK win is even more wholesome cause everything was so against just a win and the members knew it, that is why their shock face, all those posts, ahhhh so proud, happy for them, Reveluv, you are the best!
This group proves that no views or popularity can rival the talent this group has.
@@seully_4 Red Velvet never used ads not even in 3rd generation, the most follow Girl Group in Korea, named the best kpop group alive by Billboard, sm most successful group in US, still no US label or promoted in america lol yeah, already have their place.
The cinematography, the story, the acting, the dancing, the song! JUST PERFECT ❤
Dont use emogi please let's support our queens.. emogi freeze views
no se si me entiendas pero porfa no uses emojis pq eso arruina el stream que le hacemos a nuestras patronas ^¡^
thats a lie, stop spreading misinformation on the internet, let people use emojis @@anabestreveluv
@@raianejoy4624 thats fake do you really believe that?
The thing about RV is they are always original. Always make you think. No one of their songs ever sounds the same. They are perfection in terms of quality and quantity. I love them so much!
oh red velvet you will always be famous
Newer groups can’t help but watch rv for ideas
I love rv’s concept it’s so fire they don’t just stick to one, they go over a course of different concepts.
Cool😊! I think you often listen to Red Velvet with your girlfriend☺🏳🌈👩❤👩🤗! Who is your bias from RV🤔?
@@beabinside8190 🤣 oh my pfp is not me it’s from enhypen I’m a girl lmaoooo my bias is seulgi and yeri
@@Kuromiiiiiiiiiiii-n7s Cool☺! Yes I knew you were a girl!🤗
They remind me of F(x), I love it ❤
@@beabinside8190lmaooo
This indeed gave me the CHILLS!!! Wow, great song, great video! RED VELVET never disappoints. The most original group and the darkness is still there. Triumph!!
only red velvet can pull a concept like this, sounds sweet and kinda innocent but lowkey weird, like there's some disturbing secret hidden in something cute, it's a playful concept, so unique, so red, so velvet and i LOVE MY QUEENS FOR THAT!!! 💗💛💙💚💜 let's enjoy this album my fellow luvies!
Red Velvet always got the most underrated comeback in kpop
Red Velvet's concept is always fresh and new! This looks like a movie!!! Vocals, dance and acting skills -100%
periodt
요즘 유행인 이지리스닝 계열의 뻔하지 않은 음악이라 신선하게 느껴지네요. 레드벨벳 노래는 유행을 그저 따라가거나 전작이 인기 끌었다고 재탕삼탕하지 않고 늘 새로운 시도로 질리지 않는 부분이 롱런하는 이유가 아닌가 싶네요.
Agree, they always come with different interesting concept and genre every comeback ✨
진짜 공감합니다...
이지리스닝으로 유행가가 될 수 없고 그렇다고 신선하지도 않고 늘 하던 뻔한 음악에 허접한 랩을 더한 노래라 전작에 이어 이번에도 잘 안 될 것 같습니다 노래 좋으면 그냥 좋다고 하지 이렇게 쓸데없이 말 안 길어지죠
드라마 랩 좋다고 난리치는 애가 할 말은 아닌듯?
@@feea-pe8uq 본인은 드라마 랩 좋다고 하셨으면서 뻔한 랩 추가라니... 그렇게치면 에스파도 자기네가 낸 노래에 랩 추가한거 아닌가요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그리고 다른사람 개인적인 감상인데 거기다 대고 왜 전문가마냥 똥폼잡고 진지처빨고 대댓달고 그러시는...😅 댓글은 원래 감상이랑 자기 생각 다는 곳이에요 객관적인 평가만 쳐쓰라고있는게 아니라요
This is seriously one of my faves from them. I just love the storyline and the realistic atmosphere, rather than an obvious set. It just shocks me that their talents just keep getting more ore fine-tuned as time goes on. Great job girls!
This comeback deserved so much more.... the whole album is a masterpiece!
im losing count at how many times i repeat the entire album. thank you red velvet for your presence in my life.
Same
@@HwangJiwonOfficial ikr?? Like the entire album has no skip song
오래오래 활동했으면 하는 그룹.. 수록곡까지 싹 다 듣는 그룹.. 레드벨벳.. 행복해주세요
@rukassoyou are not smart
@rukassonope sulli's death anniversary was one month ago😂
Red velvet never disappoint with cheerful but dark concept, respect
Their concepts change constantly and it’s fine lol
@@Nothereforit174Tbh, red velvets songs kind of have this certain feel to them that remain even when the concept changes, but they are still some of the most flexible groups in the kpop industry
돌고돌아 결국 레드벨벳임... 다같이 화음들어갈때 듣는 귀가 풍부해지는 느낌이라 너무 좋아 ㅠㅠ
I really love Red Velvet's lore, it never fails to pique my interest i swearrr
어떻게 이렇게 매번 새롭고 레드벨벳 같은 벅찬노래를 들고 올 수 있는거지.. 멤버들은 말모고 레벨담당팀 일 너무 잘하는듯
제발 음방 트로피도 신경썼으면 합니다 ㅜㅜ Feel my rhythm 1관왕 Birthday 2관왕보다더요 정규인데 뮤비 조회수도 팍팍오르고 초동도 100만장 가길 ㅜㅜ
"Don't think about tomorrow, forget about your sorrow"got me teary eyed
Me too
This is living in my head for days
Me too
It's the new "Hey now we'll be okay"😢
It hits hard 😭
Coming back here to support the OG concept flourished and only made sense by Red Velvet! Thank you for giving us your best, always! 🎉❤
Teen Vogue named Red Velvet as one of the best girl group.
We already knew that. 😉
@@riffgroove it's nice to get another achievement 🎉
‘Cause they are!☺️
And it's true they r legendary
AS.👏THEY.👏SHOULD.👏
from their acting to their dancing, to their visuals, vocals and message. red velvet is perfection ❤
The "Cosmic" teaser photos look amazing.
RV always come up with something new. 👍
they were poor 🤩
make sure to stream and vote cosmic!
This is actually a masterpiece, SM should promote their best artists much more, Red Velvet is unmatched. This MV mixes one of my favorite movies with my favorite music group, I couldn't be happier, but I would love for SM to promote Red Velvet more...
Also the story was given justice because the gurls did amazing on their acting! Let's go Red Velvet drama, we need one now SM
Red Velvet never a disappointment, WOW i really got chill watching the MV, the song was so great. Cant wait for my Red Velvet album in the mail... RED VELVET FIGHTING!!!
oh I looooove the song and the music video representing something sinister’s going on but it’s under a disguise of false joy, switching up from a really mysterious sound to something super cheerful and reckless ……. Another red velvet slay
red velvet is the most unique group in the world
Red velvet deserves more views!
fr not even 20M is low key sad, but at least are 20M with raw views
The more I listen to it the more I fall in love. Thank you Red Velvet for always giving us the best music. 💗💛💙💚💜
"Best music" My butt. Imagine having to force yourself to like a song by listening to it a hundred times 😂😂 Sad
@@urhypeboy You can fall in love more even if you like a song already. And just because it's not your cup of tea doesn't mean no one genuinely likes the song - I personally loved it at first listen. And yet it still made me fall in love more the more I listened to it.
@@urhypeboy I loved it at first listen, then loved it more and more the more I listen to it. If it’s not your cup of tea then fine, it’s not my responsibility to force it on you. Not your place as well to come on here and complain about someone’s music preference 😊
Imagine hating on someone for having an opinion, that is sad@@urhypeboy
Wow. Red Velvet always comeback with unique and different concept. I love it. The MV and the vocals. Thank you. Reveluvs, we are so lucky to have Red Velvet. Let's watch this together and support them to the fullest
I can't believe it's been a year since the most beautiful song in the galaxy came out 💔
the best idol group alive
y lo sabes
Faxx
nah that's Twice
no@@einsleyharriot1294
@@einsleyharriot1294ew have ever watched their live performing? Their vocal skill is terrible
The harmony is crazyy... Love it. Only Red velvet can do it....
fr there's something special about RV
I’ve been a red velvet fan for 5 years and this is the only group i REALLY respect for sticking to their beautiful art direction and distinctive music. In a way, red velvet is one of those groups with a cult following (joke totally intended haha) that is sooo well deserved. Red velvet is timeless. LONG LIVE RED VELVET!!!
Anyone who don't acknowledge Red Velvet is such a disgrace bruh
@@sherwinpatrickalcantara5207Bruh, kpop doesn't just revolve around them be serious.
red velvet music videos and songs are just pure art
I really love it when Red Velvet kept on making music that they haven't tried yet. They are truly a versatile group!
And us fan are even more luckier 🫠
Wonderful Red Velvet! Yet another mesmerizing music video, concept, and song! Truly amazing!
Kenzie and Moonshine are amazing music producers for Red Velvet.
I keep returning to this album. It's amazing
I haven't stopped.
at first i used to believe their album was low key boring, except for 3 or 4 songs, but after i checking the lyrics it makes so much sense, it's such a beautiful album for a cold season!
This song came out 10 days before my dad died... a year later I'm reflecting on how listening to this song during that time brought me so much comfort and hope. I'll always be so thankful to Red Velvet for releasing such a beautiful song, I wish it had gotten promoted more 💕
it feels crazy that I've gotten into red velvet this year cause it feels like I've been listening to them for years the way this song made me feel nostalgia
they just have that effect hehe
I reallly love this song. It's the perfe3ct combination of red & velvet. I'm so proud of them working so hard for us. I love them sm!
I have no words, I am mind blown. This is a concept red velvet pulls off so well istg. The vocals, the dance, EVERYTHING gave me LIETRAL CHILLS. props to them for this amazing comeback
"don't think about tomorrow, forget about your sorrow" something i should listen to rn
Everyone talking about cosmic but they never gave love to this masterpiece
FR
RV ALWAYS slays the horror concepts. they gave us a whole movie this time. love this girls, ive followed their careers since debut and they just get better and better
Ugh their harmony is so heavenly. Their individual contribution to the song makes the drill-type beat even more fitting. Oh its giving alright!❤
Their voices are so magical ..
Reminder to watch the mv once a day!
Please exactly
yes!!!
Yup
yess i'll be doing this!!
this is arguably Red Velvet's most layered MV to date. absolute masterpiece.
thisssssss ❤❤❤❤
and i thought they couldn´t surpass Peek a Boo´s MV, they really worked for this one
fact
SORRY RED VELVET FOR UNDERSTIMATING THIS SONG, I'VE NOW COME TO MY SENSES AND THIS IS AN ABSOLUTE MASTERPIECE
You NEVER judge a Red Velvet song after one listen.
@@riffgroove fr tho idk why i be hatin it on my first listen i wasn't rlly having it and didn't even thought of listening again til a month later lmfao DEFINITELY A ME PROBLEM
average stan twt
@@riffgroovefor real😂
@@riffgrooveYEAHH when I first listened to Dumb Dumb and Rookie I was NOT feeling them, but now they're some of my faves
HAPPY 1 YEAR TO THIS UNDERRATED MASTERPIECE!! will never forgive how ppl treated this song tbh ☹️
밝은 멜로디 부분이 오히려 역으로 섬뜩한 느낌들게 하네요 들으면 들을수록 안질리고 좋은노래같아요
THE TRANSITION FROM THE FIRST VERSE TO THE CHORUS WAS INSANE!! WAS NOT EXPECTING THAT!
첫 번째 절에서 코러스로의 전환이 정말 미쳤어요!! 그럴 줄은 몰랐어!
Yep, I was surprised the first time with the sudden change in the mood... But after the 2nd listen, the song really clicked for me 😍
@@Lyf4rMusic SAME!!
이 앨범은 ㄹㅇ 아이돌 앨범이 아니고 아티스트 앨범이다
Halloween= Red Velvet
I'm not joking when I say they're kpop royalty!