Q&A: If you could pick any British admiral from the time period the channel covers to command the Battle of Trafalgar besides Nelson, who would you pick? And do you think it would it turn out as it did under a different Admiral?
To some people this may sound like a ridiculous question, but as somebody who does not understand, and I have a 13-year-old son who is also interested knowing I'm going to ask. My question is why round cannonballs? Could they not have produced Square Cannon and therefore Square Cannon shot so that there was a lease chance of it rolling around in bad weather or during action?
-Dolphins are returning to Italy -Japanese torpedo boats are being sighted on Europe once again -Drach uploads part 3 of the Admiral Nelson series Nature is finally healing
Just to be that guy, but one is a training vessel (JS Kashima (TV-3508)) and the other is a guided missile destroyer (JS Shimakaze (DDG-172)). But they do both have torpedoes and that is probably enough for the Kamchatka. :)
Seeing the Trafalgar Gun Company in action was super cool, and answered a lot of my questions about age of sail gunnery in ways that written or spoken descriptions never have been able to. Seeing it happen just makes everything clearer. Thank you for giving me this opportunity.
Yes! Even the reason for him being mad are similar. For one it was a supply ship sighting imaginary torpedo boats. For the other one it was an Admiral seeing imaginary Nelson's chasing him around. You can just imagine him panically signaling to the captains under his command: "You see Nelson's boats?!"
Just to note that the Victory has now been repainted in the colour scheme historians believe to be closer to the time of Trafalgar rather than the deeper yellow previously seen . Great video
You know you’re good when the most replayed section is the start of the video, people (myself included) are starting over and listening again because there’s so much info and it’s so interesting
I really enjoyed the section with Matt Easton because it got Drach answering the kind of questions I have and really explaining things to a lay audience.
A pleasure to work with you! For anyone who is interested in exploring more about the gunnery we have a video on the subject: ruclips.net/video/wTN7UErLVkQ/видео.html
I was wondering about the sub-calibering of the 32 pounder. is there some regulation that prevents firing a gun as large or is it pure economics that the powder expended would be prohibitively expensive?
This has been a most excellent video, despite me taking two days to enjoy its full goodness. Good to see Matt and his expertise, love the Trafalgar Gun lads too. Thank you Drach - it was worth the wait. One more day to Trafalgar Day - we always celebrated it at my school in Newcastle as one of its old boys was a certain Cuthbert Collingwood.
The description of Villeneuve's Nelson fixation reminds me of the Japanese before the Battle of Leyte Gulf. They set out with faith in Divine Providence, or, as another officer phrased it, with faith in total annihilation. (Paraphrased from Hastings' "Retribution".)
I had never heard of the HMS St. Lawrence. I have learned more about history from following RUclips channels such as yours than any history school books, thank you.
Even 2 years ago when this series started i wouldn't have imagined that Drach would be filming his material ON HMS Victory. its amazing the access a dedicated educator can get these days, and the things they can show us from halfway across the planet. thanks for all your hard work Drach.
Lmao your profile pic. You do realize that gayness was outlawed in the USSR and pretty much all the communist leaders of the 20th century were extremely racist, right?
Confidence in a close in fight during the age of sail is utterly key, when everything is being done by muscle power a good crew is more than a good crew, its almost equivalent to a steel and steam warship with clean boilers, quality coal/bunker oil, a state of the art comms suite, top end hydraulics and more since all this in a sail ship is done by your ratings and their officers French timidity and defeatism, infuriating to the captains of the French ships certainly trickled down to lower ranked officers and men. When you have no faith in your leadership you’re much more likely to strike your colours when your broadside to broadside Compare that to Nelson who at this point was a living legend of the RN, when he said “I’m going to defy naval tradition and just run right at them” his captains were hanging off his every word, both parties had total confidence in each other. Thats leadership
Good god, this should be on the big screen, Drach, it's long enough. Not complaining, HELL NO, you're doing great work. I feel so much more educated about the great admiral Nelson, TYVM good ser
Just finished watching this three part documentary. Absolutely fantastic thoroughly enjoyed it. Also as a video suggestion for HMS Manchester or HMS Liverpool. Thank you for these videos great stuff keep it up
Terrific vid Drach and thank you so much for the chat with Matt of the Trafalgar gun crew. Its the first time Ive heard anything about real world gunnery tactics and considerations of that time from someone who clearly knows his stuff . An absolute eye opener and documentary gold
Victory is still available for thorough tours including below decks. She is in dry dock at Portsmouth naval base. I have been on board several times and never tire of these visits. I have a good sized lump of Victory’s inner hull, my father was industrial nurse at the dockyard in the 1960s when repair work was being done and my piece had been thrown in the rubbish skip.
2 года назад
Very interesting Video jam packed with great colabs ! :)
Regarding the comment about the gun crew's entire focus being on gun drill, a more modern example of this would be the Boy (1st Class) Jack Cornwell at Jutland though mortally wounded his default reaction was to pick himself up and return to his position to continue serving his gun.
The small battery of sixteen guns, which in another video they said was used for performances of Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture, reminds me of another performance using real guns. Usually during Labor Day weekend, the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, during their summer residency at Ravinia Park, will also perform that piece. There is somebody who provides a battery of Lyle Guns, which are short-barreled muzzle-loading guns, 2.5 inch smooth bore, developed by the United States Life-Saving Service (now part of the Coast Guard) to fire rescue lines. I've been to one of those performances and it's a lot of fun.
HMS Victory! Real gunnery! Matt Easton! Plus not one, but two inconspicuous carriers in the background! This really shows what the battle of Trafalgar is to the British. Tell us more!
Do my eyes deceive me? Or is it really? Oh boi. Part 1 was one of the first videos I got in my recommended from you Drach. This feels downright nostalgic
Admiral Nelson is indeed both human and Superman. He had a younger woman who apparently loved and care for; they got to spend a mere 25 days at a wonderful mansion he owned, before he left for the last battle of his life. He is very fortunate to have found a woman that doted on him! I wish my wife of 48 years had loved me that much. Admiral Nelson was also blessed to get such useful insights to insure the British victory at Trafalgar! It would have been easier to follow SOP.
Nice, I was just casually watching the first two episodes. Wondering where the 3rd part would be and discovered through the comments, it had just been published.
Many years ago I enjoyed going to and participating in living history events that took place in the northeast part of the united states. The time period that those events depicted was 1730 to 1840 I primarily did the revolutionary war era. At those events I met and became friendly with a couple guys that owned two different muzzle loading black powder field guns. One was a 4lb cannon and the other was a 2lb short barrel howitzer. I was fortunate enough on two different occasions to help load and fire both guns. It was a fun and educational experience.
He was no less fallible than any other man, however, he was one of the greatest combat leaders in Naval history. Greatly admired for his physical courage, patriotism and humanity...
![Noob To Max With DRAGON REWORK In Blox Fruits [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LnBMOinoOvA/mqdefault.jpg)
Pinned post for Q&A :)
Q&A: If you could pick any British admiral from the time period the channel covers to command the Battle of Trafalgar besides Nelson, who would you pick? And do you think it would it turn out as it did under a different Admiral?
Who would you say is one of the better non British age of sail commanders? Any particular stand outs?
Finally part 1 is what made me find the channel 🎉
To some people this may sound like a ridiculous question, but as somebody who does not understand, and I have a 13-year-old son who is also interested knowing I'm going to ask. My question is why round cannonballs? Could they not have produced Square Cannon and therefore Square Cannon shot so that there was a lease chance of it rolling around in bad weather or during action?
@@Cbabilon675 a delicious question. Children truly are wonderful, glad yours is so inquisitive :)
-Dolphins are returning to Italy
-Japanese torpedo boats are being sighted on Europe once again
-Drach uploads part 3 of the Admiral Nelson series
Nature is finally healing
Lol 😂
i love it i just cant tell u a man or woman i dont care ima turk both work for me
Lmao at the second one
Green Abrahms are sprouting in Eastern Europe again - nature is healing.
Just to be that guy, but one is a training vessel (JS Kashima (TV-3508)) and the other is a guided missile destroyer (JS Shimakaze (DDG-172)). But they do both have torpedoes and that is probably enough for the Kamchatka. :)
At last, we conclude the saga of Nelson, the greatest frigate in the history of the British Navy.
That would be the Lydia, under Hornblower.
The best frigate of his time, so.e mught say
And how he transcended his physical form and became a naval victory.
Wait, frigate? Thought a BB
@@alanwilliams4443 its a joke based on the name of episode 1 "From Boy to Frigate"
It's been 84 years and Part 3 is finally here!
*Now... I just gotta go back and rewatch the other two for context again.*
HMS Victory has had two refits in between the episodes ......... RUclips is hell.
@@mENTALdRIFTER Her 32 pounders had never been fired.
I love how Villneuve's plan went from "complex" to "labyrinthian".
It was awesome to see both carriers in the background when Drach and Matt were on the deck
H.M.S. Malta, “I’m not trapped in the fog with you lot, you’re all trapped in here with me, lads!
They should have renamed her H.M.S Mad Lad
"Guess we should have let him go duel the Admiral." - some French officer in October 1805
"Hurled his spyglass at the flagship..." Somewhere in the afterworld, the man's drinking with Rozhestvensky. :)
@@richmcgee434 But I bet the Russian didn't have a wig to throw as well!
@@jonathanhill4892 No, he was just tearing his actual hair out. :)
@@richmcgee434 Could well be:)
@@jonathanhill4892 The Kamchatka alone was enough to leave any commander bald as an eggshell.
Seeing the Trafalgar Gun Company in action was super cool, and answered a lot of my questions about age of sail gunnery in ways that written or spoken descriptions never have been able to. Seeing it happen just makes everything clearer. Thank you for giving me this opportunity.
Finally, I've watched the other episodes atleast a dozen times by now.
Thank you Drach
“Hurled his telescope, and then his wig….”
Tell me, did he have any family in the Russian navy?
That was my first thought as well. :)
@@richmcgee434 me too
Yes! Even the reason for him being mad are similar. For one it was a supply ship sighting imaginary torpedo boats. For the other one it was an Admiral seeing imaginary Nelson's chasing him around. You can just imagine him panically signaling to the captains under his command: "You see Nelson's boats?!"
@der Sägefisch [Sees one ship]
"IT'S NELSON, THE WHOLE FLEET IS CLOSING ON US! WE'RE SURROUNDED!!!"
@@JonatasAdoM proceeds to shoot up a bunch of Spanish fishing boats.
Or at least try to.
Just to note that the Victory has now been repainted in the colour scheme historians believe to be closer to the time of Trafalgar rather than the deeper yellow previously seen . Great video
*Drach uploads part 3 of Nelson's Saga*
Finally my collection is complete
You know you’re good when the most replayed section is the start of the video, people (myself included) are starting over and listening again because there’s so much info and it’s so interesting
Whoever asked for a video on Nelson deserves a plaque.
So much information and knowledge. We often only hear about the big battles.
I really enjoyed the section with Matt Easton because it got Drach answering the kind of questions I have and really explaining things to a lay audience.
A pleasure to work with you! For anyone who is interested in exploring more about the gunnery we have a video on the subject:
ruclips.net/video/wTN7UErLVkQ/видео.html
Subscribed chaps - if you weren't 6 hours drive away I'd sign up as an unpaid volunteer. Love what you do!
I was wondering about the sub-calibering of the 32 pounder. is there some regulation that prevents firing a gun as large or is it pure economics that the powder expended would be prohibitively expensive?
Given that the wadding etc is still expelled from the gun, it's probably to do with safety distances?
Good morning all. Been looking forward to this👍
I've actually been waiting 2 years for this, let's go
You know... I've always blasted the IJN for their "Napoleon at Sea" tactics but I didn't realize even Napoleon used "Napoleon at Sea" tactics.
You mean the "extremely complicated plan with lots of split-up forces that requires split-second timing and inhuman dedication"?
@@gregorywright4918 I'm more talking about "splitting up forces to transit to the battle area and combining them when battle starts".
@@Eboreg2You've gotta admit, the other definition works just as well.
The prophesied day has come, the great speaker of Nelson’s saga has returned.
Wind noise on a sailing ship??!?!??!!!? Outrageous!!
Great video 👍👍🇺🇲🤝🇬🇧
Awesome to see Matt Easton pop up in another video!
This has been a most excellent video, despite me taking two days to enjoy its full goodness. Good to see Matt and his expertise, love the Trafalgar Gun lads too. Thank you Drach - it was worth the wait. One more day to Trafalgar Day - we always celebrated it at my school in Newcastle as one of its old boys was a certain Cuthbert Collingwood.
The description of Villeneuve's Nelson fixation reminds me of the Japanese before the Battle of Leyte Gulf. They set out with faith in Divine Providence, or, as another officer phrased it, with faith in total annihilation. (Paraphrased from Hastings' "Retribution".)
Thanks Drac.
The final chapter of the story of The Norfolk Hero.
I had never heard of the HMS St. Lawrence. I have learned more about history from following RUclips channels such as yours than any history school
books, thank you.
Was refreshing yt to look for something to watch, very delighted to see this pop up.
".....is underselling it considerably." Love it.
Even 2 years ago when this series started i wouldn't have imagined that Drach would be filming his material ON HMS Victory. its amazing the access a dedicated educator can get these days, and the things they can show us from halfway across the planet. thanks for all your hard work Drach.
Lmao your profile pic. You do realize that gayness was outlawed in the USSR and pretty much all the communist leaders of the 20th century were extremely racist, right?
Nice work getting both new carriers AND Victory in the same shot. Good work sir.
This is my first post on youtube and I can't say how excited I was to see part three this morning, Thank you!
Drachinifel, thank you for the work you put into the channel. Your audience appreciates you.
Having HMS Queen Elizabeth and Prince of Wales in the background is a nice touch.
I watched the Nelson video yesterday and spent like 4 hours looking for the third part
I cant wait for a video on Trafalgar. It'll be great.
Drinking a Lambs Navy 1:4 with water, watching part 3 of the Nelson series, and thoroughly enjoying both.
Finally! I have been waiting for this for so long!
I do hope you make a playlist for this series, I had missed the first two and had some issues finding the other. Great work as always.
Confidence in a close in fight during the age of sail is utterly key, when everything is being done by muscle power a good crew is more than a good crew, its almost equivalent to a steel and steam warship with clean boilers, quality coal/bunker oil, a state of the art comms suite, top end hydraulics and more since all this in a sail ship is done by your ratings and their officers
French timidity and defeatism, infuriating to the captains of the French ships certainly trickled down to lower ranked officers and men. When you have no faith in your leadership you’re much more likely to strike your colours when your broadside to broadside
Compare that to Nelson who at this point was a living legend of the RN, when he said “I’m going to defy naval tradition and just run right at them” his captains were hanging off his every word, both parties had total confidence in each other. Thats leadership
It may have taken two years, but blessed be the day it arrived
Finally part 3, I waited ages for this ^^
Fantastic! Made my morning, on to coffee!
I would love to watch more content about the anglo- Dutch wars!
good thinking!
Good god, this should be on the big screen, Drach, it's long enough. Not complaining, HELL NO, you're doing great work.
I feel so much more educated about the great admiral Nelson, TYVM good ser
I’ve been waiting for this! Thank you!
Drach, I thoroughly enjoyed this vid. The Trafalgar Gun Company segment brought back fond memories of crewing a 3# field piece.
Holy shit I just rewatched 1 and 2 last night to refresh hoping this would come out soon.. can't wait but I must I'm at work.
That was most illuminating, thanks very much.
Just finished watching this three part documentary. Absolutely fantastic
thoroughly enjoyed it.
Also as a video suggestion for HMS Manchester or HMS Liverpool.
Thank you for these videos great stuff keep it up
Fantastic work, can't wait for the next part
great lighting in that ship can see really clearly
Whoaaa.. nice... Finally another long video... Thanx Drach
Nice footage on the business end of the guns. Real bruv moment.
I’ve been waiting for this! I feel like a kid on Christmas morning lol
Can't belive Drach finished the Nelson series haha
Not quite...
52:32 A wild Drach appears, attracted by the blast and gunsmoke produced by the cannon... :)
Thank you, Drachinifel.
Terrific vid Drach and thank you so much for the chat with Matt of the Trafalgar gun crew. Its the first time Ive heard anything about real world gunnery tactics and considerations of that time from someone who clearly knows his stuff . An absolute eye opener and documentary gold
Outstanding video, Drach!
Thank you, kind sir. I am now complete.
Enjoyed this series. Would love to see one on Thomas Cochrane.
What a great day, part three is here after a long long wait!
Great video keep up the work.
While I have enjoyed every program, this is my immediate favorite.
Horatio, Horatio... wherefore art thou dear Horatio?? wonderful to see the this return of my fav British Captain come Admiral.
Everyone has been waiting for this video.
Thank you for your great quality videos. They bring pleasure to many peoples life, Like fentanyl, only milder and less deadly.
"MAKE ME MASTER OF THE CHANNEL FOR 6 HOURS AND ILL BE MASTER OF EUROPE" - Napoleon
"Not today short man" - Some British admiral
I can hear Rod Steiger shouting that. Now I need to go and re-watch Waterloo.
Captain Pellew no doubt
I initially read this and assumed "the channel" referred to Drach's RUclips channel 😅
"I do not say they cannot come, I only say they cannot come by sea", Lord St Vincent
1940 - "Not today short man with tache"
I was just thinking about when we were getting part 3. I guess today!
Very informative. Thank you for making this video.
I impatiently await the battle Drach. Get on it!
Victory is still available for thorough tours including below decks. She is in dry dock at Portsmouth naval base. I have been on board several times and never tire of these visits. I have a good sized lump of Victory’s inner hull, my father was industrial nurse at the dockyard in the 1960s when repair work was being done and my piece had been thrown in the rubbish skip.
Very interesting Video jam packed with great colabs ! :)
I love history , So I love your passion for history
Yay I’m so happy! I was just rewatched part one and two last night. What luck to have part 3 out today!
Regarding the comment about the gun crew's entire focus being on gun drill, a more modern example of this would be the Boy (1st Class) Jack Cornwell at Jutland though mortally wounded his default reaction was to pick himself up and return to his position to continue serving his gun.
IVE WAITED SO LONG FOR THIS
oh man I've been waiting a while to see this episode I was beginning to think you've completely forgotten it!
Ty I thought I missed it or you named it something else but this makes sense thank you
Sweet, the new audio book version of Hornblower is out!
The small battery of sixteen guns, which in another video they said was used for performances of Tchaikovsky's 1812 Overture, reminds me of another performance using real guns. Usually during Labor Day weekend, the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, during their summer residency at Ravinia Park, will also perform that piece. There is somebody who provides a battery of Lyle Guns, which are short-barreled muzzle-loading guns, 2.5 inch smooth bore, developed by the United States Life-Saving Service (now part of the Coast Guard) to fire rescue lines. I've been to one of those performances and it's a lot of fun.
Pre dreadnought and the age of sail are my two fave eras.
Good video. Looking forward to Part 4... many years from now.
HMS Victory! Real gunnery! Matt Easton! Plus not one, but two inconspicuous carriers in the background! This really shows what the battle of Trafalgar is to the British. Tell us more!
Do my eyes deceive me? Or is it really? Oh boi. Part 1 was one of the first videos I got in my recommended from you Drach. This feels downright nostalgic
Admiral Nelson is indeed both human and Superman. He had a younger woman who apparently loved and care for; they got to spend a mere 25 days at a wonderful mansion he owned, before he left for the last battle of his life. He is very fortunate to have found a woman that doted on him! I wish my wife of 48 years had loved me that much. Admiral Nelson was also blessed to get such useful insights to insure the British victory at Trafalgar! It would have been easier to follow SOP.
Excited for part 4!
Nice, I was just casually watching the first two episodes. Wondering where the 3rd part would be and discovered through the comments, it had just been published.
I thought this would never come, amazing! 🥳
Wow i went to school with Matt easton, small world
It’s here!
I got to this vid only now, but it is awesome!
Just finished, thanks Drach! I very much enjoyed the finale and it was worth the wait! Take care brother Drach, catch ya soon!
Enjoyable and informative as usual
That's pretty awesome! Great video
Loved the Monty python photo clip discussing Spain (“Nobody survives the Spanish Inquisition”)…
EXCELLENT - THANK YOU SO MUCH ! ! !
🙂😎👍
Many years ago I enjoyed going to and participating in living history events that took place in the northeast part of the united states. The time period that those events depicted was 1730 to 1840 I primarily did the revolutionary war era. At those events I met and became friendly with a couple guys that owned two different muzzle loading black powder field guns. One was a 4lb cannon and the other was a 2lb short barrel howitzer. I was fortunate enough on two different occasions to help load and fire both guns. It was a fun and educational experience.
2 year wait is over!!
He was no less fallible than any other man, however, he was one of the greatest combat leaders in Naval history. Greatly admired for his physical courage, patriotism and humanity...
Yay the trio are done :)