Why don't you two work togheter on a piece? Sending it to eachother every single 30mins for example is a great video concept. I really would like to see the end result of that!
i would totally agree but instead of making it 30 min make it 5 or 10 to put some pressure and excite us viewers but u 2 should not be able to communicate let the other try and pick up without knowing where the first stopped
The "action scene" vs "calm landscape" results made me think a lot about the works of John Howe and Alan Lee, the two main illustrators that painted the world of Tolkien and helped make the visuals and artistic direction of the Lord of the Rings movies. Very different way of picturing this gorgeous universe, but also very true to Tolkien's writings.
I love Phase Runner , i've always been a sucker for benny's scenary and realism , n i realized that Phase has got a beautiful sense of fantasy and composition that stands out . Big inspirations from u both!
It's amazing, plus they look like they complement each other, Phaserunner's image gives near vision, while Benny's image gives far vision, it's just amazing work.
I love the sky part from your piece and the action from Phase Runner. A combo from both designs would result in a perfect artwork! I love both of them anyways, thanks for all these edit races between some of the best artists in the world!
The edition race that we were all waiting for, I am so happy. And it's impossible to give a winner, because of the similarity of the colors. The different designs of the two races are their strong points. I think Benny's mountain is perfect in terms of size; it occupies the space well and is really impressive. Thanks for the show and I won't vote because it's impossible, I'm a fan of both.
This is honestly amazing, I love two amazing photoshop artists who are especially personal favorites of mine go head to head to see the differences and ideas of two amazing artists and compare others and add upon each other, both very magnificent.
thank you VERY MUCH for breathing much needed life back into my job Benny. After 20 years of being a designer I was getting bored, you have inspired me again..thanks kid!
There are definitely no losers absolutely great awesome pieces. One thing I do like about Phase Runners piece his mountain is menacing with the angle and distance bringing you into the scene. Benny your piece reminds me of when I watched these movie(s) remembering scenes of seeing the volcano and their hard journey getting to that volcano. again there are no losers here. All I can say is wow
Both looked great, but if I was to have a poster of one of them, I would have to go with Benny's. Frodo and Sam in the shot makes it feel more meaningful to me.
As much as Phase Runner's is epic in telling a story and has action (dragons!), I really loved Benny's work. Benny's vibrant colors and contrast and overall calmer cinematic feel is the kind of art I'd frame and hang on the wall. The volcano and heavy ominous clouds draws the eye and I love the silhouettes of Frodo and Sam in the foreground. It may not have "action" but is just as immersive. I FEEL something when I look at Benny's. PR is a master artist and I love his work, but my vote goes with Benny this time. :)
I can't believe the quality of these episodes. When I saw the first video of you 1.5 years ago, it was an editing race, and at that time I was completely blown out because of this quality. That was the first video I saw from you. Today I wonder/ask myself: “Is it normal to get such quality in RUclips videos” The answer is no, definitely not. This is the special case. 5:25 And as I am in love with these random breaks.
Not sure i can pick which one i like more. You both took it to an amazing result which i expect nothing less from the best photoshop artists on youtube. One of the best battles for sure.
I'm a big fan of your work Benny, but I'm just gonna say it, Phaserunner is on a whole nother level. As much as I love your piece I think Phaserunner definitely won this one.
Hahahahahah you are THE BEST. Edition 10, i love it, 100% creative videos and i love the photoshop art you do. Great series and competitions, i'm never gonna get bored with your amazing videos 😛😆
i watched the video 2 times fully focusing on each side i was mind blown how you guys are so insane in photoshoping but i guess phase has to take the win here
Never dispointed of the pahserunner's artwork result, but benny also strong for the compositing and he place the mount and the people still in the rule of third composition.... both of them are great, my inspirations... thankyou benny for invite phaserunner in this episode 🥰
Both are just so good. Benny's give more broader and clearer atmospheric view to feel, Phase runner guy is on point with everything so action packed as you were pause the epic scene of the movie.
Truly magnificent work. Somehow you made me want to visit Mount Doom, Benny... and PhaseRunner as always with such a dynamic, action filled piece. Love it guys!
Parabéns pelo trabalho, ambos são fantásticos e grandes inspirações. Extremamente difícil escolher qual ficou melhor, mas a forma como PhaseRunner coloca ação na cena é incrível.
Amazing video and amazing concepts!! I'm a graphic designer as well so I appreciate these concept art videos, I loved both illustrations, each one is beautiful in its own way. The PR concept is more epic and think is the winner, the way he made the comp was amazing and how each element it's perfectcly integrated into it, it's a perfect action scene/frame. The Benny concept is beautiful as well, It's just a different mood and story about the same place, it's more about mistery and a journey, if I could bring some critic/suggestion about Benny concept is that it's not framed properly, there is much empty area in the comp, I would crop the final composition to frame the scene in a way the main elements (volcano, tower and the protagonists) are more relevant (that occupy more space in the composition). Again thank you for make these videos, I just found your channel some hours ago and I love it! :D your content is amazing; I think "PS edit Race" and "Editing subs concepts" are simply amazing! Now I met this other PR channel through your video and I subscribed to him too :) Both of you are amazing and have a friendly and kind personality, something key as content creators and something valuable in these times. Congrats and keep going :D Blessings :)
I loved both! It looks like Benny's showing the scene before the battle starts on PhaseRunner's composition. They're both epic! But my favorite is PhaseRunner's. Sorry Benny, but no one can beat PhaseRunner, the man is a legend! 🤩😎❤️
Two legends of the game! One is action-packed while the other one is epicly vast! Can't pick between the two, although I'll say that Benny held his own in the edit race since Epic Fantasy is right down Phaserunner's alley. Incredible compositions, incredible creations!❤
actually both edits are great, but i think i prefer what phaserunner made a bit more maybe the duality between blue and red in yours is a bit too "abrupt", but i absolutely love the cinematic style and vibe it gives off
Both artworks turned out amazing, but I liked Benny's artwork the most because it has a very mysterious and epic atmosphere. And also because Benny's textures are better.
this one goes to you mate .... its like so calm but capturing the strength at the same time...it literally speaks LOTR return of the king...... the composition was like IF BOB ROSS PAINTED A MORDOR LANDSCAPE THATS HOW IT WOULD BE...idk why i just loved the staticness of it.... but yeah some more mist between the mountain and foreground would have made it better...
i think i will vote for PhaseRunner to be honest, his artwork is just fantastic, benny's edit was also cool i liked it, but i think PhaseRunner just absolutely dominated this
In my opinion you are winner benny because some of reasons 1st_Your idea 💡is so good 2nd_Your detailing is really very awesome that force to feel that it is real
Gast, sneeuw op een vulkaan? Supermooie kleurbewerking, maar dat deed echt een beetje pijn XD 2 heel verschillende composities, beiden sterk. Maar Phaserunner wint deze voor mij. Zijn composities zijn altijd zo creatief en out-of-the-box. De dynamiek spreekt me onwijs aan. Op naar de volgende!
Both of you are amazing designers and a massive inspiration to me, I watch both of your content, but I'm handing this one to phaserunner, it was hard to decide, but phaserunner made an epic action scene which turned out great, benny yours was extremely great too, the color style and idea was amazing, I just happened to like the action more, well done both of you
I think Phaserunner is still clear. But if you compare this to the last time these two Guys did a battle together, you can clearly see that Benny has made mad progressie
![I Transformed Minecraft BETTER Than AI | Full Movie [6000+ HOURS]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SzCBweRfhuU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Summer Walker - Heart Of A Woman [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/SFddctbZzw8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Yeat & Summrs - GO2WORK [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NEFEwfPcXRA/mqdefault.jpg)
Thanks again bro for an awesome edit race! Seeing both final results side-by-side❤ Again, great job on your piece, until next time😎👊
awesome artwork man
Hi bro
You are god of photoshop really impressive, 🙏🙏
:)
you are good at making a scene. and benny is good at making so much detailed image. if you both work together then the image will be just amazing.
Why don't you two work togheter on a piece? Sending it to eachother every single 30mins for example is a great video concept. I really would like to see the end result of that!
Would be too messy I think, it’s hard to mix two styles in one like one would change what the other did and so on..
i would totally agree but instead of making it 30 min make it 5 or 10 to put some pressure and excite us viewers but u 2 should not be able to communicate let the other try and pick up without knowing where the first stopped
@@kryptek-channel3725 I think that's the point, it would be funny
You are a genius! That would no doubt be incredibly cool!
very cool idea 💡 👍
It is so wonderful to see you guys together again! 🔥 Keep inspiring as always! 🤘
You should do one photoshop battle as well
Hi encreate, I'll be waiting for you to get in an edit battle with Benny. Would be an intense match up for sure
That feeling when your two most favorite artists fight against each other to teach you something is beyond this world
They're my favorite two! I rewatch those videos a infinite times
Great to see both of you guys in the same video, u r a true inspiration 🔥❤
The "action scene" vs "calm landscape" results made me think a lot about the works of John Howe and Alan Lee, the two main illustrators that painted the world of Tolkien and helped make the visuals and artistic direction of the Lord of the Rings movies. Very different way of picturing this gorgeous universe, but also very true to Tolkien's writings.
I love Phase Runner , i've always been a sucker for benny's scenary and realism , n i realized that Phase has got a beautiful sense of fantasy and composition that stands out . Big inspirations from u both!
It's amazing, plus they look like they complement each other, Phaserunner's image gives near vision, while Benny's image gives far vision, it's just amazing work.
When two photoshop legends Benny and Phase Runner collaborate. Its a blast.
I love the sky part from your piece and the action from Phase Runner. A combo from both designs would result in a perfect artwork! I love both of them anyways, thanks for all these edit races between some of the best artists in the world!
Both are amazing. But I prefer Phaserunner's because of the action, scaling, angle & over all color & contrast.
Me to
The edition race that we were all waiting for, I am so happy.
And it's impossible to give a winner, because of the similarity of the colors. The different designs of the two races are their strong points.
I think Benny's mountain is perfect in terms of size; it occupies the space well and is really impressive.
Thanks for the show and I won't vote because it's impossible, I'm a fan of both.
I’ve been looking for your channel for 2 years now, been watching you since 11th grade. Happy to see this video as a recommendation
This is honestly amazing, I love two amazing photoshop artists who are especially personal favorites of mine go head to head to see the differences and ideas of two amazing artists and compare others and add upon each other, both very magnificent.
Incredible video as always! Your videos never fail to put a smile on my face
Benny's art feels like the setup or beginning of the story & Phase Runners' feels like the the epic ending of the scene. Both GREAT ARTISTS. LOVE.
Hahaha the funny thing is i was just watching your old versus videos of this stuff and hoping you would make a new one and here it is :D
I feel like they both nailed the feel of LOTR. I like how much Bennys feels so huge
My two favorite youtube graphic designers! Can't wait for this one
This is undoubtedly my favourite Edit Race episode!
thank you VERY MUCH for breathing much needed life back into my job Benny. After 20 years of being a designer I was getting bored, you have inspired me again..thanks kid!
There are definitely no losers absolutely great awesome pieces. One thing I do like about Phase Runners piece his mountain is menacing with the angle and distance bringing you into the scene. Benny your piece reminds me of when I watched these movie(s) remembering scenes of seeing the volcano and their hard journey getting to that volcano. again there are no losers here. All I can say is wow
Both looked great, but if I was to have a poster of one of them, I would have to go with Benny's. Frodo and Sam in the shot makes it feel more meaningful to me.
You both are best at what you do! 🙌🏼 Always something to learn from you guys.
Honestly the production value of these episodes are just insane. Well done Benny.
wow you can just do everything with photoshop! You are just insane!
Бенни рисует так как будто это художественная работа...
Рунер рисовал это так как будто это стоп кадр из супер мега игры с офигенной графикой
Really great stuff! These are some of my favorite videos of yours to watch 😄
As much as Phase Runner's is epic in telling a story and has action (dragons!), I really loved Benny's work. Benny's vibrant colors and contrast and overall calmer cinematic feel is the kind of art I'd frame and hang on the wall. The volcano and heavy ominous clouds draws the eye and I love the silhouettes of Frodo and Sam in the foreground. It may not have "action" but is just as immersive. I FEEL something when I look at Benny's. PR is a master artist and I love his work, but my vote goes with Benny this time. :)
I love that LOTR and TheHobbit is still getting attention. And the art you make is absolutely insane!😆
as a concept artist you did fantastic benny. You show cased the feeling and landscape beautifully. Your end piece is an incredible concept art design.
I can't believe the quality of these episodes.
When I saw the first video of you 1.5 years ago, it was an editing race, and at that time I was completely blown out because of this quality.
That was the first video I saw from you.
Today I wonder/ask myself: “Is it normal to get such quality in RUclips videos”
The answer is no, definitely not.
This is the special case.
5:25 And as I am in love with these random breaks.
Not sure i can pick which one i like more. You both took it to an amazing result which i expect nothing less from the best photoshop artists on youtube. One of the best battles for sure.
Wtf, Phase are you crazy? Man, you're incredible, omg.
Benny, you are too awesome!!! Amazing.
highly anticipated and now its finally here. Cant wait to watch this now!
Dude, I'm freaking out! What an amazing visual spectacle to see my 2 favorite RUclips artists doing their art! Thank you very much!
Seeing you two in the same video just gets me so damn hyped. Both incredible artworks! So talented!
-finn
I'm a big fan of your work Benny, but I'm just gonna say it, Phaserunner is on a whole nother level. As much as I love your piece I think Phaserunner definitely won this one.
Hahahahahah you are THE BEST. Edition 10, i love it, 100% creative videos and i love the photoshop art you do. Great series and competitions, i'm never gonna get bored with your amazing videos 😛😆
I'm in love with these new special episodes like realistified pokemons and this edit race
Keep up the amazing work man
PhaseRunner is always on point and his major experience and composition's skills are very clear!
Both r incredible!! Imagine we combine these two masterpieces definitely feel like a epic battle sense!!!
i really loved both of your landscapes, but i liked the explosions of the volcano most
i watched the video 2 times fully focusing on each side i was mind blown how you guys are so insane in photoshoping but i guess phase has to take the win here
Never dispointed of the pahserunner's artwork result, but benny also strong for the compositing and he place the mount and the people still in the rule of third composition.... both of them are great, my inspirations... thankyou benny for invite phaserunner in this episode 🥰
Both are just so good. Benny's give more broader and clearer atmospheric view to feel, Phase runner guy is on point with everything so action packed as you were pause the epic scene of the movie.
Truly magnificent work. Somehow you made me want to visit Mount Doom, Benny... and PhaseRunner as always with such a dynamic, action filled piece. Love it guys!
Parabéns pelo trabalho, ambos são fantásticos e grandes inspirações. Extremamente difícil escolher qual ficou melhor, mas a forma como PhaseRunner coloca ação na cena é incrível.
That intro is sooo epic! And the results is actually awesome. Really cool.
Amazing video and amazing concepts!! I'm a graphic designer as well so I appreciate these concept art videos, I loved both illustrations, each one is beautiful in its own way. The PR concept is more epic and think is the winner, the way he made the comp was amazing and how each element it's perfectcly integrated into it, it's a perfect action scene/frame. The Benny concept is beautiful as well, It's just a different mood and story about the same place, it's more about mistery and a journey, if I could bring some critic/suggestion about Benny concept is that it's not framed properly, there is much empty area in the comp, I would crop the final composition to frame the scene in a way the main elements (volcano, tower and the protagonists) are more relevant (that occupy more space in the composition).
Again thank you for make these videos, I just found your channel some hours ago and I love it! :D your content is amazing; I think "PS edit Race" and "Editing subs concepts" are simply amazing! Now I met this other PR channel through your video and I subscribed to him too :) Both of you are amazing and have a friendly and kind personality, something key as content creators and something valuable in these times. Congrats and keep going :D
Blessings :)
As always clear and concise and ride to the point thank you for not wasting my time I love your videos
Both are "out of this world" 😉🔥 Respect!
Been waiting on this for a while, big fan of PhaseRunner
I enjoy the two pieces but this time I prefer Benny's one , thank you both Legends for this amazing art .
Love watching these battles
I'm 35 years old, I'm learning photos thanks to you, literally thank you...
I loved both! It looks like Benny's showing the scene before the battle starts on PhaseRunner's composition. They're both epic! But my favorite is PhaseRunner's. Sorry Benny, but no one can beat PhaseRunner, the man is a legend! 🤩😎❤️
Two legends of the game! One is action-packed while the other one is epicly vast! Can't pick between the two, although I'll say that Benny held his own in the edit race since Epic Fantasy is right down Phaserunner's alley. Incredible compositions, incredible creations!❤
You both are my favorite artists....😍😍😍😍😍 So much talent in one Video
actually both edits are great, but i think i prefer what phaserunner made a bit more
maybe the duality between blue and red in yours is a bit too "abrupt", but i absolutely love the cinematic style and vibe it gives off
Both artworks turned out amazing, but I liked Benny's artwork the most because it has a very mysterious and epic atmosphere. And also because Benny's textures are better.
after watching manchester united my mood went down but after benny uploaded a video it made my mood go up, thank you benny!
@@jovanka--------6003 REPORTED
you two has god tier photoshop skills
I choose you'r photoshop, It's more beautiful, even though the other one is also insane🤩
this one goes to you mate .... its like so calm but capturing the strength at the same time...it literally speaks LOTR return of the king...... the composition was like IF BOB ROSS PAINTED A MORDOR LANDSCAPE THATS HOW IT WOULD BE...idk why i just loved the staticness of it.... but yeah some more mist between the mountain and foreground would have made it better...
They’re both awesome, it’s truly amazing how two artist can make two completely different pieces of art from the same photos.
Woah this is Awesome! Can you please upload the unedited version of this?
Woow my 2 big favorite artists finally done a speed art challenge 🔥🔥🔥
Two legends. Great match up
I love your overall work Benny 💪🏼 but this time phaserunner win this, scale, color, angle and depth 💪🏼
Amazing results from both! Would love to see an unedited of your version
Simply amazing work. Love both!!!
Benny you did AMAZING you really outdid yourself today
Your editrace are so cool to watch and hope it will soon come a new one
i think i will vote for PhaseRunner to be honest, his artwork is just fantastic, benny's edit was also cool i liked it, but i think PhaseRunner just absolutely dominated this
BRO YOU ARE BEST IN PHOTOSHOP
KEEP IT UP.
In my opinion you are winner benny because some of reasons
1st_Your idea 💡is so good
2nd_Your detailing is really very awesome that force to feel that it is real
Both insane on the own way. Cant decide!
The century’s epic battle.
Benny I think the scale of that mountain is perfect. No need to fret there.
Gast, sneeuw op een vulkaan? Supermooie kleurbewerking, maar dat deed echt een beetje pijn XD
2 heel verschillende composities, beiden sterk. Maar Phaserunner wint deze voor mij. Zijn composities zijn altijd zo creatief en out-of-the-box. De dynamiek spreekt me onwijs aan.
Op naar de volgende!
You can see how bad Benny wanted to win. Mans actually sketched something to start for once😂.
I’ve done that before?😂
It's hard to choose, both are beautiful. This is epicuuuu 😀
*After a long time...it's finally here* 🙏🙏
This was crazy!!! Keep it up Benny!!
I loved Benny's composite more
You are the winner 🥇
You seriously asking which one is my favourite???
HOW AM I SUPPOSED TO CHOOSE ONE..BOTH ARE VERY AMAZING
Bro Two Legends🔥 Don't Have comparison🔥
been waiting for this collab! 😁👊
Lotr- My favourite theme. Yayyy !!!
Your videos are so great and so are the intros man👌👌
Finally..... the battle we have been waiting for🔥🔥
I like both but i swear on my life your picture is awesome and i cant find any words for this one 😍 I love it god damn :O
I dont care who won both are fucking FANTASTIC!!!
Thts what I want so long i sub n watch both for a long time. 😍
my fav collab. Benny and Phaserunner.
Your photoshop skills are Crazy 😍😍
Both of you are amazing designers and a massive inspiration to me, I watch both of your content, but I'm handing this one to phaserunner, it was hard to decide, but phaserunner made an epic action scene which turned out great, benny yours was extremely great too, the color style and idea was amazing, I just happened to like the action more, well done both of you
Both artworks are great! Awesome editing you guys, would love to have those for wallpapers.
I think Phaserunner is still clear. But if you compare this to the last time these two Guys did a battle together, you can clearly see that Benny has made mad progressie