‘Very embarrassing’: Supreme Court inadvertently posts document on pending Idaho abortion case
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июн 2024
- Dahlia Lithwick, Senior Editor at Slate, Mini Timmaraju, President of Reproductive Freedom for All and Dr. Kavita Patel, MSNBC Medical Contributor join Nicolle Wallace on Deadline White House with reaction to yet another mistake made by the Supreme Court when it comes to releasing decisions on abortion related cases, this time with a potentially leaked decision involving emergency care to people who are pregnant and what the document which has now been removed from the Supreme Court website could mean for future reproductive healthcare decisions and law. NBC News has not independently verified the document.
» Subscribe to MSNBC: / msnbc
Download our new MSNBC app for the latest breaking news and daily headlines at a glance: www.msnbc.com/information/dow...
Follow MSNBC Show Blogs
MaddowBlog: www.msnbc.com/maddowblog
ReidOut Blog: www.msnbc.com/reidoutblog
MSNBC delivers breaking news, in-depth analysis of politics headlines, as well as commentary and informed perspectives. Find video clips and segments from The Rachel Maddow Show, Morning Joe, The Beat with Ari Melber, Deadline: White House, The ReidOut, All In, Last Word, 11th Hour, and Alex Wagner who brings her breadth of reporting experience to MSNBC primetime. Watch “Alex Wagner Tonight” Tuesday through Friday at 9pm Eastern.
Connect with MSNBC Online
Visit msnbc.com: www.msnbc.com/
Subscribe to the MSNBC Daily Newsletter: link.msnbc.com/join/5ck/msnbc...
Find MSNBC on Facebook: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Twitter: / msnbc
Follow MSNBC on Instagram: / msnbc
#SCOTUS #SupremeCourt #abortion
Imagine needing the Supreme Court to allow doctors to perform life saving procedures. Idaho and the Republican party have lost their way.
Trump world. Where the Hippocratic Oath turns into the Hypocritical Oath and where the Constitution is ignored by the most senior jurists in the land.
They've lost their minds and any compassion or reason they ever had
Waaaaaaaa
@@leonblack2651If you knew any women, this might not be a joke to you. Good luck on meeting one.
While recognizing abortion is fundamentally wrong, the decision must be left to the woman and her doctors. We cannot have nine elitists in Washington ruling on every case. It is not a practical or even possible approach.
This was not an accident
@@ItsNumber84 We the People will only take so much from these treasonous puppets...
The good thing it is coming from within the Supreme Court and not someone frivolously putting it up.
@leekastle8890 - My exact same thoughts. 💙🧘🏼♂️
But who is doing it?
Demand SUPREME COURT REFORM!!!
Why because you don't like it ? No fair play for the other side ? No cope ?
Abort the Supreme Court!
The stupidest post of the day.
Spot On!
@@robertswanson2417 Wrong. 6 right wing devils need to go.
This not a mistake. It is intended to influence the Idaho case. Politicians are dishonest.
Maybe the Supreme Court is dishonest. I mean these guys think money is free speech, so the more money you have, the more free speech you have. It's very egalitarian, don't you think? It's a legitimate court?
always
Transparency is only good when you hide facts. Man being a liberal is hard work, keeping up with the constant changing. I might need to change my party
They reflect us perfectly
@@Saaahdood ya, so hard to up for human rights. You just have to tie yourself knots?
So Alito thinks that a miscarrying woman must die with her fetus/baby.
Get over it
@@leonblack2651 OH yes, the dead woman can just get over it. Tell that to her grieving family. Any previous children can just get over being raised without their mother. You sound like a heartless individual.
Imagine a bill called "In Defense of Life" that allows pregnant women to die? SMH
Don't get pregnant
@@leonblack2651 Don't get someone pregnant
I used to think the Supreme Court was fair but nowadays, I definitely don’t.
Can't believe that a court would rule against a procedure that kills a human bing.
Justice doesn't seem fair when you want everything to go your way and can't stand being told no.
Who cares….it’s Trump’s court, and you can’t deal with it.
No way a 6-3 Christian conservative supermajority can be fair..
@@Skitdora2010kind of like losing an election
Accidental? I think not.
Just like the accidental leak a couple of years ago? What a joke.
Yeah they leaked the Roe v Wade decision a few years ago. Weird that it's always about abortion
Assuming you're referencing the leaked Dobbs decision, it was clearly stated by news sources at the time that it had been intentionally leaked by an anonymous source.
They have plenty to be embarrassed about. 25% approval rating. ALL TIME LOW. Disgraceful.
United States Supreme Court Chief Justice Roger B. Taney, a Dem, had a 75% approval rating
@@wadestanton (I see what you did there! 😜)
@@johnjames5459 most US Citizens can't see portraits of slavers on their US National currency. They are messed up.
The Extreme Court are not legislators. This is not about Pro-Life it's about Pro-control.
Get used to it.
Welcome to Gilead
Incompetent or Unethical?!
Both…
Can't make up your mind eh? Typical
Yes.
Inadvertently, wink wink. Someone just HAPPENED to see it.
Every day we see more corruption
its ironic to say that as we watch MSNBC though
At one point people thought the US had the best democracy in the world. Now both sides believe it’s all fundamentally corrupt.
Dred Scott said that
Either There is a Traitor or An Spy in SC Desk😠👍
It's Alito. Just like when they accidentally leaked the Roe v Wade overturning opinion.
You mean alito who supported insurrection after the fact or Thomas whose with actively urged on the insurrection before and in progress ?
Wonder what bribe will Thomas and Alito will get this time for this ruling:/
More than you'll ever make
'Tip'
@@leonblack2651
I would hope so, I have more integrity in my pinky than that pyg in his entire body and soul.
About as accidental as the leak of the Dobbs case was...
Shhhh the Russians are attacking Ukraine let’s talk about that
Calling the current Supreme Court under Thomas and Alito a complete clusterf#$& is an understatement of epic proportions.
The US government is putting the circus out of business.
This country is FuKd
Grow up.
Don't you have big nuts telling somebody to grow up! I bet your scared of your shadow!!! Keep mouthing Trumper!!?@@Paul-mg8fz
Just figured it out huh?
Dred Scott said that
Yet another "miscarriage" of "justice"......
Wow, Another Trump supporter that thinks justice department is biased
Abso Freaking Lutely Dude !!! Well Put !!!
If Alito had a uterus he might have a different view of things, now he just an uninformed twit!
How exactly is a leaked ruling a miscarriage of Justice?
Lock em up as we democrats say.
Not embarrassing if intentional.
Isn’t this the second time there’s been a leak on the same topic (abortion)?
What about it?
@@leonblack2651 well, it’s kinda odd because Supreme Court leaks are extremely rare, but two recent large abortion cases get leaked? I wouldn’t exactly be confident saying it was an accident.
Should be easy to identify who uploaded it.
KBJ
They still haven't figured out who stole trump's boxes for him. Or have they?
@@TerrenceKane8204 WRONG, ASHOLE. IT WAS ALITO.
Exhibit Z demonstrating what a joke our judicial system is
AN "ACCIDENT", LIKE THE LAST TIME??!!
Assuming you're referencing the leaked Dobbs decision, news outlets at the time stated very clearly that it was not an accident, but an intentional leak on the part of an anonymous source.
With 45 it comes down to "Don't look up"!
Trump hasnt been President for 4 years my dude.
@@Bruce-kx5ku and he will not again!
@@James-to7pi I mean, polling shows him winning all swing states. but anything is possible. overall, Trumps 4 years was quite good compared to these last ones
@@Bruce-kx5ku FOX polling?
@@James-to7pi actually fox polling said joe biden is winning the popular vote and ignored that elections are decided by the votes from state to state. you should think of fox as your ally. its not an ally to Trump.
Why are there people who want to see women die for no reason?
Not pe0ple.
GOP voters.
Or babies.
It's fun lol.
They are so desperate for a "win" that they don't care who they hurt as long as it upsets their targets.
Ask Gen ah side Joe and his supporters
Before the debate? So predictable. Anita Hill and Clarence, Thompson I remember watching the news and her calling him a monster.
Me, too. And they confirmed the SOB.
I believe you Anita.
Anita said he put a pubic hair in her coke. If she had gone to Police and they had kept it, we would today have DNA evidence of who's pube it was.
2024 and you still play into that racially motivated political smear? Call him an uncle tom again to confirm your racism
I remember watching, and I believed every word she said.
"Inadvertently," ooohkay. Is this how SCOTUS is gonna roll now?
The SCOTUS leaks more the The Titannic and for the same reason .
Maybe the SCOTUS needs a drug test..
Joe Biden needs a drug test.
@@Paul-mg8fzeven if he did, the GQP wouldn’t be satisfied. They’d move the goal post further just as they always do. Ya’ll are fools
@@Paul-mg8fz
In January, the Defense Department’s inspector general released a report detailing how the White House Medical Unit during the Trump administration distributed controlled substances with scant oversight and even sloppier record keeping. Investigators repeatedly noted that the unit had ordered thousands and thousands of doses of the stimulant modafinil, which has been used by military pilots for decades to stay alert during long missions.
Trump’s White House Was ‘Awash in Speed’ - and Xanax
It's positive. They're drunk on power.
@@danismithmn
Hahaha
Clowns…no other way to describe it.
Liberals are the clowns….because they’re 🤡 in the Supreme Court’s world.
Highest Law of the Land? Please, spare me😢😮😅
😢
Except it is.
@@user-vx7vi3vq1c It's a joke and this overreach will backfire.
Podunk Idaho, causing all sorts of drama. 😅
Where do you live…..a dirty, grimy., crime infested Democrat city where it’s not even safe to go outside.
13 counties in Oregon have been voting towards succeeding from Oregon because the DNC can't govern a hen house let alone a government. They wouldn't understand why their trans roosters don't lay eggs. 😂
Well bless their tiny little hearts. At least if you are just about to die they found a heartbeat of empathy and a stale crum of sanity to share amongst themselves. And proud we are, of all of them.....😠
Alito is not an MD. He should not make uneducated medical judgements any more than an auto mechanic should adjudicate cases in the Supreme Court. Well, for that matter, the mechanic could arguably do better than Alito, who should not be on the court. Resign now Alito and go sew flags for Frau Alito.
Life / death easy question . Imposed death is illegal . I'm all for saving the mother in life threatening situation determined by a doctor .
3 ghouls on SCOTUS, Thomas, Alito, and Gorsuch, ruled that it's ok for a woman to bleed to death in a hospital parking lot. Fortunately, for the women of Idaho, the other 6 voted against them.
You are very good at copying and pasting.
I feel very bad that a beautiful baby will lose its life over this.
@@sierrahh1 You are OK with mothers dying. Why do you want children to grow up motherless.
@@sierrahh1 Then step up and adopt ANY unwanted child, regardless of race or gender. Put your money where your mouth and (false) morality are.
That’s not what they ruled…and abortion isn’t even fit for animals.
Inadvertently? Yeah right, they need to find out who’s leaking and prosecute them to the fullest extent of the law or it will keep happening.
It's normal now.
I dream of denying Alito the Heimlich maneuver.
Using legal hyperbole to substitute for reality is the mark of subterfuge .... at it's worse!!!!
shame on scotus
The six Republican justices on the Court are nothing more than political hacks.
The Subprime Court
They make the laws….you FOLLOW THEM…or you go to jail.
@@Paul-mg8fz
then tr45h should also go to jail.
@@Paul-mg8fz it’s actually Congress that makes the laws. Courts interpret them.
@@charliebrens3349Came here to say this!
@@Paul-mg8fz No they don't, dummy.
Alito is an embarrassment and should be thrown off the bench.
I'll go one further. He's an evil ghoulish Pope from the 1500's wannabe 🙁
Don't forget the Briber just us Thomas.
You forgot tomas
I'm sure Biden will find a way to charge him with at least 34 felonies
@@winstonsmith8565
If only.
Bless that kind man, Biden 2024!
Stop calling it abortion care and start calling it pregnancy care. Women have a right to pregnancy care. Full stop.
Lying about what to call it doesn't change facts. You just want to call it something it's not.
Women should have autonomy over their own bodies Period. The court of Idaho had the right to make these choices because their mothers made them. It doesn't mean their mothers made the correct choice. These decisions should only be made between a woman and her doctor! Seperation of church and state, all of these infringements upon the civil rights of individuals need to STOP. These are the kind of people (overturning Roe v. Wade) that also could care less about what happens to the babies from the mothers that may not be able to provide proper care or what long term repercussions of how this decision will affect society. What about the women they are supposed to represent from a forced pregnancy? The physical safety, because I believe the existing vessel is more important than a terminable pregnancy because they cannot start anew if their life is quelled. It is like women's lives, physically, emotionally, the mental ramifications that will affect them from such laws and how it will affect them, and society as a whole are of no importance to them! I'm curious about what their agenda really is? We will all be dead someday and I just cannot understand the need to control half of the population, forcing them to breed because they have the power to do so?
"Inadvertantly"
Baloney.
Incompetence is a more accurate description of SCROTUS
They should not be allowed to have phones.
What?
@@leonblack2651 Yes.
VOTE NOW, or NEVER AGAIN!!!💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Solution: stop having children
Not sure if serious... (I mean, isn't that what the bill prevents?)
Exactly.
well technically this is whats happening and here is the problem. some women “protest” and stop having children. but then the women who do have children instil their family values into them, and those women who didnt have children, their ideals die as they die. There is no future for ideas that arent centered around the nuclear family. they will only be trends at best
It's not hard
the people who have children create the next generations culture. family oriented ideology always wins in the end
Women for women! Thank you Nicolle. Thank you to your prestigious panel. Obviously they want to release it after Trump sucks at the debate to draw away from that looming train wreck that is trump.
SUPREMELY corrupt court.
What we have here is a cowardice Supreme Court 🤔 a bunch of cowards.
Cheers 🎉
Pizzas and burritos are also supreme. I don’t listen to their interpretations of law either.
You WILL listen to this Supreme Court, because they make the LAWS.
@@Paul-mg8fz it's just humor... It was funny.
@@Paul-mg8fz
putin owns you
And they don't listen to you cope 😅😅😅
@@Paul-mg8fzthey don't make laws
Ms.Jones, just inadvertently post this for me would you?
It was an intentional leak....
Shameful Supreme Court 👎🏽🇺🇸⚖️
And behold I come quickly as it is written. I have not spoken in secret from the beginning as it is written.
Six traitors in that bunch. Never forget.
😂😂😂🤡
3...I think there is only 3 liberals on there
Translation; Democrats believe that anyone who believes in the original intent of the constitution is a traitor.
@@chadgeary5615 Exactly, 6 traitors 😂
I’m sorry but it was the conservative justices who said they wouldn’t mess with precedent involving Roe v Wade. What did they do? They overturned it.
THEY are the traitors.
Which Justice is responsible for any rulings being released. The whole Supreme Court is a mess…and it is not the whole court. Seems like there is a pattern.
Another leak. Sabotage
Just remember in November.
That's why the dems will never try to legalize abortion everywhere. They need abortion as a wedge issue to get out the vote
Why do people begin sentences with "I mean?" It should be reserved for clarification when one has said something not clearly stated.
Well, judges don't do administrative work. Soooo...is there a questionable clerk? Each judge gets about 4 clerks, I rhink.
Accidentally but just in time.....
weird how these kind of cases get released or leaked by accident.
Like they haven't done this before, recently and devastatingly. 🙄
Recommend all judges be tested for Cannonitis immediately. And, if tested positive, be immediately quarantined indefinitely.
Covid boy is back…but cannot handle the Supreme Court’s power.
don’t be stupid and learn how to spell ugggg😂😢😮😅
"Inadvertently", "a mistake". Haven't we heard that before? Apparently these people aren't very bright.
Hmmmm, allowing the state to decide is bad? I think allowing states to decide is the correct decision. Smaller government is always a positive.
This law prohibited doctors from saving a life. Idahohans would rather two people die.
Not the feds, not the state, not the court, not the clergy, not the politicians, or anyone other than the patient & doctor should make medical decisions or be in the exam room. Decisions concerning a woman's reproductive health care are in the MYOB department.
Embarrassing to whom ?
Why is it Supreme Court's opinions being constantly made public to the media ?
Another accidental release on the same issue in six months, sure
Well, at least you know early
Are they really this incompetent?... But are the highest court in the land! We have to abide by their rules!!.. SAD!!!
It’s “PREGNANT WOMEN” not pregnant people!
Does it disturb your little head to be reminded that women are people? Or can't you deal with the fact that some trans men are still capable and willing to give birth? Why don't you try it out to let people have rights with their own reproduction? What's it to you, and why do you think you have any say over the most personal decision that people make?
Not the place for that "argument."
@@pigs18 I don’t understand?
All people deserve bodily autonomy, privacy and access to appropriate healthcare.
They used the correct term “patients.” Patients are the ones who are receiving medical care from medical providers.
The reason the supreme court’s judges have their hands on their laps it’s to show you that they are not in your pockets at the time of the photo shoot any other time WELL ,
U want access to a "care" but are not acknowledging that the "care" in question is ILLEGAL!!!
Hog wash inadvertently!
Who keeps doing this? Don't they have any control over what is going on over there?
I was shocked to hear there was no exception for the woman’s life.
So I opened the Idaho state website of the bill and the first paragraph under section 2.a explicitly allows abortion “to prevent the death of the pregnant woman”
I smell some horse crap
First Dobbs was leaked and now this. Something’s going down.
Is no one at least happy here that they ruled against what right wing republicans in Idaho had proposed? 🤨
No. We like whining even when we win.
@@leonblack2651 Apparently so,..
They are not “pregnant people,” they are “pregnant woman.”
People who don’t identify as women but have uteruses can still get pregnant. Being inclusive hurts nobody
@@PenelopeHall-vl3gr It hurts the truth, which hurts everyone.
@@johnjames5459 The truth is that some people with uteruses don’t identify as woman. So abortions are for pregnant people. You can say women and be correct or pregnant people and be correct. Inclusivity hurts NOT ONE PERSON.
So y’all just gonna act like we don’t know when a “play” is being ran?? 🤷🏿♂️
I still say the Supreme Court is a Waste of Resources ---- and TIME.
Alito posted the Dobbs decision. I wonder who did this one.
Ladies and Gentlemen, your $upreme Joke! 🤦♂
Once any decicion is made by SCOTUS, that finding should be published. Waiting to tell us sounds cowardly to me.
Ummmm, they tell here
Seems Ole Brett has the court doing jello shots and beer pong. Glad they have spell check.
My throne occupies eternity as well as it is written.
Thank you for the video. Appreciate the coverage.
Did they or was that another leak that will never be discovered
The court that can’t shoot straight.
Softening the blow?...deal with yourself. Human.
Wordpress... man, wordpress. Gotta set those posts to a draft.
Very embarrassing... the press secretary saying deep fake videos on cspan
The press secretary is the biggest fake.
This was no accident. Ridiculous!
If the nations refuse to serve this one Drizzle? Everything burns up and flees away as it is written.
Oglf course something would come out like this right before the debate