Браво, ПанІ Людмила! Просто чудове, бездоганне виконання! Я пишаюся тим, що така чудова співачка живе та співає в моєму рідному Києві! Вас можна слухати і слухати нескінченно!
I have just seen Liudmyla as Abigaille in London! She simply steels the show!!! She is incredible, she reminds me of Dimitrova...she simply plays with this cruel role! Can not wait to see her again!
Я думаю, что Монастырская обладает не только исключительным по силе и красоте голосом, но и великолепнейшей школой, позволяющей ей с таким блеском петь труднейшие спектакли, где не всегда были безупречны Генка Димитрова, Леони Ризанек, Гулегина с их выдающимися голосами... Невероятное совершенство в партиях Абигайль, леди Макбет!!!
Супер! Талантливая украинская певица с редким драматическим сопрано.Исполнение блестяще! Даже не хочется замечать и говорить об осовремененной постановке,всех этих одеждах -это бич нашего времени, надеюсь скоро пройдет, но Монастырская по-настоящему украсила эту постановку.
Гулегина рядом не стояла, слушать её невозможно. Может возраст уже. У Монастырской редкое по красоте лирико-драматическое сопрано. Одинаково звучать и верха и низы. Настолько сложная партия, а какая лёгкость исполнения.
that voice must be something in person. not feeling the costume, though. Give her white gloves and a pocket book and she's 1962 Caballe going to the market.
I would argue. Dimitrova was a perfect Abigaille with this incredible full throated singing of high notes, superb chest and head register and brilliant pianissimi on high notes too. Monastyrska is a voice of a great value. However she tricked yesterday this killing full throated high notes by singing them with head register. Wisely. I would not recommend her to sing it all. Her Aida and Lady Macbeth were stunning. Neither Abigaille nor Odabella (Attila) are appropriate for her now.
Saioa Hernandez sang this in Dresden. Wow what a complete chest voice in all 3 registers & incredible squillo. Now that's a voice for Abigail. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
I don't believe anyone suggested that this video is supposed to be some sort of exemplar of style; just a pretty fantastic voice singing atrociously difficult music well, occasionally brilliantly (her Lady M is much better) "If I were a dramatic coloratura..." The operative word there being 'If'
Right, it feels that she misses all line endings whose have to sound like parlato with regal accents done through the chest voice (we hear them when Callas, Dimitrova, Gencer are singing). She is much more impressive as Lady Macbeth.
She waited a good long beat between "o fatal" and "sdegno" - enough time to check my email, in fact. She is comment se dire? mi figue, mi raisin! If I were a dramatic coloratura wanting to understand style, this is the last performance I would consider as an inspiration. S'il vous plait de rentrer à Kiev, toute de suite!!
"Comment se dire" lol wtf you mean "comment dire"...if you feel fancy enough to write in French at least know how to. "S'il vous plait de rentrer"??? Omg it's "Veuillez s'il vous plait rentrer" and TOUT DE SUITE without the e...
Браво, ПанІ Людмила! Просто чудове, бездоганне виконання! Я пишаюся тим, що така чудова співачка живе та співає в моєму рідному Києві! Вас можна слухати і слухати нескінченно!
I have just seen Liudmyla as Abigaille in London! She simply steels the show!!! She is incredible, she reminds me of Dimitrova...she simply plays with this cruel role! Can not wait to see her again!
За тиждень послухаю її Абаґаїлу на сцені на Metropolitan Opera в Ню Йорку. Минулого року слухав її Аїду там же. Супер! Монастирська : молодець!
Damn...she's good. Ranks with best I've ever heard!!
Maravillosa soprano luidmila de este siglo de las pocas que no existen
Я думаю, что Монастырская обладает не только исключительным по силе и красоте голосом, но и великолепнейшей школой, позволяющей ей с таким блеском петь труднейшие спектакли, где не всегда были безупречны Генка Димитрова, Леони Ризанек, Гулегина с их выдающимися голосами... Невероятное совершенство в партиях Абигайль, леди Макбет!!!
Супер! Талантливая украинская певица с редким драматическим сопрано.Исполнение блестяще! Даже не хочется замечать и говорить об осовремененной постановке,всех этих одеждах -это бич нашего времени, надеюсь скоро пройдет, но Монастырская по-настоящему украсила эту постановку.
Wow, I love La monastyrska!
A great voice like Ghena Dimitrova !
Goosebumps... Amazing voice!
B R A V A!!! The best soprano in the world!!!
The role of Abigaille is for her !
Bravissima !!!!!!
Absolutely!!!❤🎉❤
Une des meilleures Abigaille.
Гулегина рядом не стояла, слушать её невозможно. Может возраст уже. У Монастырской редкое по красоте лирико-драматическое сопрано. Одинаково звучать и верха и низы. Настолько сложная партия, а какая лёгкость исполнения.
Brava 🎼🌷🌷🌷🌷🎼
Wow! Let's hope she sings like this tonight!
Voice: yes!
Set: no, no, NO! 😂
Хороша, просто потрясающая...
PHENOMENAL !!!!!!!
She is lirico
Such an under developed chest voice for a dramatic soprano!
Fantastica!!!
that voice must be something in person. not feeling the costume, though. Give her white gloves and a pocket book and she's 1962 Caballe going to the market.
I would argue. Dimitrova was a perfect Abigaille with this incredible full throated singing of high notes, superb chest and head register and brilliant pianissimi on high notes too. Monastyrska is a voice of a great value. However she tricked yesterday this killing full throated high notes by singing them with head register. Wisely. I would not recommend her to sing it all. Her Aida and Lady Macbeth were stunning. Neither Abigaille nor Odabella (Attila) are appropriate for her now.
Dimitrova did not have the coloratura that is needed here. The only perfect Abigail was only Callas.
Saioa Hernandez sang this in Dresden. Wow what a complete chest voice in all 3 registers & incredible squillo. Now that's a voice for Abigail. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
Saioa una voz bella y potente. Ludmilla tambien tiene una voz poderosa. Excelentes smbas.
Моя любовь 🎉🎉🎉🎉
Maybe WE'RE wrong!
No chest voice!? Interesting.
What happened to all the written trills? This is disappointing.
I don't believe anyone suggested that this video is supposed to be some sort of exemplar of style; just a pretty fantastic voice singing atrociously difficult music well, occasionally brilliantly (her Lady M is much better)
"If I were a dramatic coloratura..."
The operative word there being 'If'
Does she sing Wagner?
Rusės čia rašo komentarus,jos geriau pažįsta atlikėjas,bet balsas nepaliečia širdies aš tokia subjektyvi!
Tremenda! Terribile.....
HER VOICE SEEMS TO BE ALL OVER THE PLACE. I ENJOYED HER AS SANTUZA BUT ABIGAIL IS NOT FOR HER. ARNOLD BOURBON AMARAL
Right, it feels that she misses all line endings whose have to sound like parlato with regal accents done through the chest voice (we hear them when Callas, Dimitrova, Gencer are singing). She is much more impressive as Lady Macbeth.
Irakli Janashia Yes she's off the Mark.Arnold Bourbon Amaral
хорошая певица, но с великой димитровой ей сравниться не дано. даже темброво.
No....non ci siamo proprio
She waited a good long beat between "o fatal" and "sdegno" - enough time to check my email, in fact. She is comment se dire? mi figue, mi raisin! If I were a dramatic coloratura wanting to understand style, this is the last performance I would consider as an inspiration. S'il vous plait de rentrer à Kiev, toute de suite!!
You are jealous! poor thing...
"Comment se dire" lol wtf you mean "comment dire"...if you feel fancy enough to write in French at least know how to. "S'il vous plait de rentrer"??? Omg it's "Veuillez s'il vous plait rentrer" and TOUT DE SUITE without the e...
Chest a bit light, but very very good
Cómo los cantantes pueden inspirarse con una puesta en escena tan ridícula? Algunos puestas, queriendo ser modernas, son verdaderos mamarrachos.
Plutôt qu'une mise en scène aussi stupide que pitoyable, mieux vaut encore un opéra-concert!!!!