@@Kreposi nerves can get anyone, no matter the experience. we don't know what caused it, maybe something in her life, or backstage happened. anyway, most of the time she sounds amazing, so we shouldn't be too harsh on her
@@Kreposihey idt…live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of your favs singing as proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of miyeon singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..
miyeon did good with this live performance... obviously, the only thing was that her voice was shaking due to nervousness. other than that, she still sounded basically the same as the original song, itself.
She just reeks of no confidence. If she’s new to the scene ok I can understand why she would be nervous. But if she’s not then honest it’s kind of sad. She should have more self confidence in her voice then this
@@bennu547shes been an idol for like nearly 6 years but like these shows arent like regular award shows its filled with actors which are like on a higher rank than idols and there were no neverlands here and she was alone obviously she was nervous since actors are treated higher than idols
@@HS-vf9oibruhh…live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of your faves singing as proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of miyeon singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..
@@greyishduckie Yes, as a listener/audience I want to listen to actual live vocals, with no or minimal backtrack. Shaky voice? Hoarse voice? Crack? Breathless when performing? Let it be. I'd rather watch singers try their best to perform, despite the difficulties. I'm not 100% against lip sync bcz it has its own purpose but I would choose live vocals any day.
This is probably the first time I’ve seen someone from this gen sing live LIVE. Not everyone can do this. This may not be perfect for you but you did really well Miyeon!
Although she sounded decent your comparison is unvalid. She was a trainee, she trained for this and made this her job. The people you're calling out most likely didn't.
@@cvyyjgyes, we hearing the tremble, but know why? there is no KPop fan there to cheer her up, just actor, and she performed alone LIVE. Most of idol don't struggling against confidence like she did because they mostly lip sync 😭
The mic definitely matters. Her mic sounds like it kind of creates double voice. She was totally fine without it but I think that was just what she was given. It's not like western artists can always choose their mic that it works for them.
i dont understand why ppl are saying this is bad.. she sounded good plus she was very nervous to be performing this in front of all the actors and with no fans there. and this is how a live performance should sound, with small imperfections rather than just autotune
@@mirajin415 Don't put your own words to other people mouth man. I already said and admitted it's not perfect and i know she can do better. But I can appreciate her determination to finish the song and actually get better throughout the singing. It's still an enjoyable performance for me. 😊
I was expecting a trainwreck from what I had read and I come across a performance of someone who was clearly nervous from head to toe, but GOT IT TOGETHER. As singers, we get nervous and we might not peform at our best when it happens, but she performed a lot better than I would've had I been in her shoes. Besides, it's always delighful to see Miyeon showing why she is (G)I-DLE's main vocalist.
Ladies and gentlemen… now this is a live performance. Better than the fake audios we always get from K-pop concerts. True natural voice that has small imperfections. Miyeon did a great job. Let’s try to get other idols to sing… you might cringe even more. She did amazing once again.
@@AS-ec9llnah….live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of jongho singing as a proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of miyeon singing as well, immortal song what?? even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..and miyeon did fine here, nothing for antis like you to brk abt..
clearly she is nervous cause she knows any drama or movie awards like this dont use autotune. literally singing live vocal even with backup vocals. Better sing live even sounds so nervous, she still sounds just fine. rather than live singing sounds real bad & lipsync most of time but overhyped and win daesang as best singer.
that was really good! It's different from being in front of other idols or her fans, I understand why she was nervous. She probably doesn't even know any of these actors personally
That would include fail. She can do anything, right? She sounds really shaky here. Her voice isn’t clean at all. How long was she preforming for? If it’s a while, she should be more confident than this
@@bennu547nice try….live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of jongho singing as a proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of your faves singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..and miyeon did fine here, nothing for antis like you to brk abt..
listening to this made me emotional (havent even watched my dearest so it’s the song alone and how she sang it). i think thats worth more than getting the pitch perfectly right ❤️ good job miyeon!
i actually think this is a super nice performance... like yes she's obviously nervous, yes you can hear it in her voice, but i feel like it added to the emotion of the song. it's not a technically perfect rendition but it adds like a human-ness to it
And it was pitchy at certain bits, not the whole song. Some people seem to love to hate, right? Miyeon is lovely and deserves all the love she can get. ❤
I can't even hear the "shaking voice" y'all are saying, what ik is that i enjoyed it and wish her the best, i was pleased with what i heard and i think she is magnificient on this stage
Thank you, Miyeon, not just for your wonderfull performance, but for proving, once again, that 99% of kpop fans have no clue about how great live vocals are supposed to sound. The worst you could say about it is is that she wasnt as assured as she would have been were she not nervous, but the way she uses EVERYTHING to bend her sound to what she needs, at every moment... IT is a thing of beauty. This sounds like somebody not doing as well as she wanted, not somebody doing even remotely bad. Her phrasing and emoting are exemplary. Her musicality truly inspiring. She sacrifices some intonation (probably beacuse of nerves) but makes up for it with emotion that feels real. Most of you wouldnt say shit if the internet hadnt told you before. This is a SINGER showing you how its done when things are not in your favor and you are missing the point. Kpop stans are the absolute pit. They have such an inferiority complex about their favourite singers being called fake puppets of big companies instead of artists that they are obsessed with live singing while knowing aboslutely nothing about how the human voice even works. If i never ever hear another dumbass kpop stan mention support, one of the few terms about technique that they think they understand (spoiler allet: they dont), or nonsensical stuff about support range, I will be a happy man.
Miyeon you did great, singing live is not easy for anyone and you were just amazing, I really liked your performance and your outfit. You are so pretty and so kind, thank you for your hard work and good luck for what comes next 🥰
I think Miyeon performs quite good voice control, even the sound on the broadcast live stage is pure real voice (not hear any effect, even reverb), The song structure itself has many parts that are key shifting that are very easy to off the tune for inexperienced vocalists. Miyeon did great! 👏👏👏
Miyeon is a good vocalist, in this performance she lacks a little bit cause she's nervous, it's okay, don't remember that she's not perfect, she's human 😊 love u gidle love u miyeon❤❤
This is live singing y'all. You can get off-pitch at some parts especially if you're nervous. I think this is also the first time she's singing this song live? Correct me if I'm wrong.
Idk if it’s her first time but imo she did really well. This was her first time performing in front of so many actors so I get why she was nervous. I probably have terrible hearing musically bc for me this performance sounded amazing. She was a little shaky at times but other than that she did so well
Oh ..shes been performing with a hundred shows already so people are expecting her to give a great perfirmance besides she is the soundtract singer.. So people expect her that much...
She is just newly this godo at singing tbh. before she had no real expectations but this past year and half she skyrocketd in singing ability. kinda tough for her mental but i get it.@@bennu547
Came to see the performance because of hearing about hate comments. There is certain way the voice shakes when someone is nervous. It's involuntary, a physical response to psychological stress. I can hear it here. There's also the added stress of hearing yourself, knowing it's not right, then that doubles the stress and affects your performance. Being on stage, looking out over the audience and feeling the immensity of all the people focused solely on you is a lot to process. I've experienced it. She did well considering. Bravo. Fighting. All those haters could never.
I didn't even notice what everyone was talking about until I watched it back again after the criticism, she sounds good and it's her real voice, all be it a little shakier and not as on pitch as she usually is, but the drama was uncalled for and blown beyond proportion.
Her voice is so angelic and beautiful, she shouldn't apologise for anything.. I'm so sad :'( miyeon is just an angel singing live with all her love 💖 and I'm proud of her !!
Smooth and real voice Correct technique No sound change in live performance No automatic adjustment There is no difference between the original and live versions of the song Real voice And... So what is your reason for visiting? You are looking for an excuse to hit so much that you will surely take the breath away of an artist (singing live is not for everyone and few people take the risk of live because they
Lmao people criticize her probably don't even know how a real voice without autotune sounds like. She's just a lil nervous, kpop fans need to chill out 😂
I mean there's better performances sure but this isn't awful by any means. She sounds nervous. Everyone is saying it's her job but even professional speakers can get shaken from a bad atmosphere, and Miyeon doesn't perform solo and this isn't her usual venue or style. I think pointing out how she was weak is fine but the hate is crazy.
She was nervous, that's why she was very hesitating, we can hear in her voice. No need "hate" for her performance, I doubt a lot of people can sing in live without being nervous.
I have a music degree there was like 1 note that was a little flat. The rest of this is her just sounding nervous. People are WEIRD. Also look how many idols actually sing a ballad…not many because most of them can’t sing
For the antis…nice try….live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of jongho singing as a proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of your faves singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..and miyeon did fine here, a little nervous yes but nothing for antis to brk about…
Well l, I have heard that this performance was not very good or even got criticised by many people and I didn’t expect much even though I’m a big fan of Gidle. But honestly it was not bad! We can know that she was very nervous throughout her voice with little flaws, however overall it was a good performance
ضَوءُ القمر يَتسلل عبر النَّافذة.... يَمر أمام قَلبي.... في ليلةٍ بلا نوم، وحيدًا.... أنادي باسمكِ.... بصوتٍ حزينٍ.... مع كل نفسٍ منكِ.... يجعلني أشعرُ بالبرد في الريح الباردة.... أصبحتِ بعيدة بشكلٍ مؤلمٍ.... أَفتقدكِ.... مرةً أُخرى، كالدموع التي تتدفق بلا توقف.... أنتِ مَرسومةٌ في ضوء القمر.... يا حُبي الذي لا يُنسى.... فراقٌ جاء بلا تردد.... لم يبقَ خلفكِ غير الشَّوق.... هل ستتحطم عند أطراف أصابعي؟.... أم ستتبدد مع تنهدٍ؟.... ابتسامتك التي أبقتني قريبًا.... مع كلِ ذكرى مفقودةٍ.... أيامكِ تستمرُّ بالانتشار بلا نهايةٍ.... في داخلي.... أنتِ مَرسومةٌ في ضوء القمر.... يا حُبي الذي لا يُنسى.... فراقٌ جاء بلا تَردد.... لم يبقَ خلفكِ غير الشَّوق.... أصبحَتِ لَيلتي.... يا حُبي الذي لا يُنسى.... بلا حتى نجمٍ أو قمرٍ حَزين.... رحلتِ ولمْ تتركي ورائكِ غير الشَّوق....
it shows in her voice that she was very nervous. it's ok and can happen to anyone. fighting Miyeon!
It is not okay since she is not a rookie artist. She has debuted 5 years ago…
@@Kreposi nerves can get anyone, no matter the experience. we don't know what caused it, maybe something in her life, or backstage happened. anyway, most of the time she sounds amazing, so we shouldn't be too harsh on her
@@Kreposihey idt…live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of your favs singing as proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of miyeon singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..
@@Kreposi You do it then. It's always the people with not an ounce of talent to even be able to get on a stage that are the most judgemental.
miyeon did good with this live performance... obviously, the only thing was that her voice was shaking due to nervousness. other than that, she still sounded basically the same as the original song, itself.
Facts👆🏻
Ive seen her live and she can sing. I've seen idols do worse when they can dance but can't sing
Klar kann sie singen. Jeder der das gegenteil behauptet soll es besser machen!
From what I heard from the "hate" comments I was expecting smth horrible, this stage isn't bad like *at all* lmao
She just reeks of no confidence. If she’s new to the scene ok I can understand why she would be nervous. But if she’s not then honest it’s kind of sad. She should have more self confidence in her voice then this
@@bennu547 It's normal for people to be nervous, chill
@@bennu547shes been an idol for like nearly 6 years but like these shows arent like regular award shows its filled with actors which are like on a higher rank than idols and there were no neverlands here and she was alone obviously she was nervous since actors are treated higher than idols
@@bennu547 well most idols dont struggle with confidence bc they just lip sync lol
@bennu547 even actors couldn't give proper acceptance speeches because the atmosphere made them really nervous
Huge Kudos to MiYeon for going live and not lipsynching...she deserves great praise not condemnation...
It’s the least? I mean… she’s a singer right…
@@HS-vf9oi I prefer those who don't Auto-Tune...she is young and will only get better.
@@HS-vf9oibruhh…live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of your faves singing as proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of miyeon singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..
The emotions really came through. Her voice is so beautiful
And everyone was cheering. I have seen actor crowd being really uninterested in Kpop artists' performance
At least she didn't lip sync and actually sang it live
@@greyishduckie Yes, as a listener/audience I want to listen to actual live vocals, with no or minimal backtrack. Shaky voice? Hoarse voice? Crack? Breathless when performing? Let it be. I'd rather watch singers try their best to perform, despite the difficulties. I'm not 100% against lip sync bcz it has its own purpose but I would choose live vocals any day.
This is probably the first time I’ve seen someone from this gen sing live LIVE. Not everyone can do this. This may not be perfect for you but you did really well Miyeon!
Exaggerating lol. Nmixx sings live even in their choreo videos. So many more live singing
All jyp groups do Live performances with little to no backtrack...in every stage ...stop being ignorant
@@HahaHaha-jx4le Well good for them. What I’m saying is that it is rare to see one this gen.
Are you serious ? Stayc ? Nmixx ? Itzy ? Kiss of Life ? Purple kiss ? 💀💀💀
@@nofakehopes6670 I just said this gen. I know SKZ does live well. Good for NMIXX though if they sing raw, would love to see it.
this is the performance y'all are pissed about? she sounds 10x better then any of y'all could do.
Although she sounded decent your comparison is unvalid. She was a trainee, she trained for this and made this her job. The people you're calling out most likely didn't.
@@cvyyjgshe sings better than most kpop idols
@@cvyyjgyes, we hearing the tremble, but know why? there is no KPop fan there to cheer her up, just actor, and she performed alone LIVE. Most of idol don't struggling against confidence like she did because they mostly lip sync 😭
The mic definitely matters. Her mic sounds like it kind of creates double voice. She was totally fine without it but I think that was just what she was given. It's not like western artists can always choose their mic that it works for them.
True
i dont understand why ppl are saying this is bad.. she sounded good plus she was very nervous to be performing this in front of all the actors and with no fans there. and this is how a live performance should sound, with small imperfections rather than just autotune
😢😢😢😢
Right. She sounds amazing 🤩
The “imperfections” were small and normal. The kpop stans just arent used to live singing i guess😭
dude i dont get why ppl r saying her singing is bad
1:01
Her voice was just shaking from nervousness her voice is still beautiful tho
Cause it is
Because she's better than this.
Idk maybe Learn to differentiate between good and bad singing
She sounds soo fine it's such a lullaby to my ear i got it that she was nervous but she did a good job
I think the performance is so beautiful not perfect but pretty. Can feel her emotion pretty well.
@@greyishduckie true
dont has to lie to yourself like that, its far from being perfect performance , its sound flat and robotic go learn to actual singer.
@@mirajin415 Don't put your own words to other people mouth man.
I already said and admitted it's not perfect and i know she can do better.
But I can appreciate her determination to finish the song and actually get better throughout the singing. It's still an enjoyable performance for me. 😊
@@mirajin415lmao did you even read the original comment
I wish kpop performances were also like this or at least similiar... Live singing is what makes a live performance worth watching (and rewatching!)
I was expecting a trainwreck from what I had read and I come across a performance of someone who was clearly nervous from head to toe, but GOT IT TOGETHER. As singers, we get nervous and we might not peform at our best when it happens, but she performed a lot better than I would've had I been in her shoes. Besides, it's always delighful to see Miyeon showing why she is (G)I-DLE's main vocalist.
Ladies and gentlemen… now this is a live performance. Better than the fake audios we always get from K-pop concerts. True natural voice that has small imperfections. Miyeon did a great job. Let’s try to get other idols to sing… you might cringe even more. She did amazing once again.
So many idols sing live, have you seen jongho from ateez on immortal songs? The best vocals you’ll ever hear.
@@AS-ec9llnah….live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of jongho singing as a proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of miyeon singing as well, immortal song what?? even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..and miyeon did fine here, nothing for antis like you to brk abt..
clearly she is nervous cause she knows any drama or movie awards like this dont use autotune. literally singing live vocal even with backup vocals. Better sing live even sounds so nervous, she still sounds just fine. rather than live singing sounds real bad & lipsync most of time but overhyped and win daesang as best singer.
this is actually more heart touching than any so called idol " live" stages. she did a great job
True
Miyeon performed this on lee mujin's service and it was superb. Love youuj miyeoon ❤
that was really good! It's different from being in front of other idols or her fans, I understand why she was nervous. She probably doesn't even know any of these actors personally
Its not even bad.
It is actually Good!
Not only talented, she can also do anything. A whole package
"She can also do anything" wouldn't that also mean she's talented. "A whole package" wouldn't that also mean she can do anything? 🤣
@@JapChae-i2h Maybe they meant some things outside of music. Like drawing or something. I don't know
worst perfomance ever
That would include fail. She can do anything, right? She sounds really shaky here. Her voice isn’t clean at all. How long was she preforming for? If it’s a while, she should be more confident than this
@@bennu547nice try….live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of jongho singing as a proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of your faves singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..and miyeon did fine here, nothing for antis like you to brk abt..
I only see and hear how fabulous she is. The Princess is a star and that is just the beginning. Fighting Cho Miyeon !💗💗
Miyeon's voice was shaking since she was nervous, but she still did well
listening to this made me emotional (havent even watched my dearest so it’s the song alone and how she sang it). i think thats worth more than getting the pitch perfectly right ❤️ good job miyeon!
Miyeon did a great job as a singer 💚💜
I believe she will do better over the time
Singing live already deserves a big like! Not to mention she is really gorgeous
i actually think this is a super nice performance... like yes she's obviously nervous, yes you can hear it in her voice, but i feel like it added to the emotion of the song. it's not a technically perfect rendition but it adds like a human-ness to it
Such a goddess. Princess Miyeon! Love her live singing!
This song was sang again in the second appearance of Miyeon in Leemujin Service! ❤❤❤
This was not as bad as people made it sound. It's not bad but it's not perfect either. It's just okay
The shakiness made it more emotional even if unintentional, the ones who hates are mad! My truth
Yeah, it was pitchy ibut it's a difficult song, and people shouldn't be so cruel that she felt the need to apologize. She sure is beautiful.❤
And it was pitchy at certain bits, not the whole song. Some people seem to love to hate, right? Miyeon is lovely and deserves all the love she can get. ❤
I can't even hear the "shaking voice" y'all are saying, what ik is that i enjoyed it and wish her the best, i was pleased with what i heard and i think she is magnificient on this stage
HOLY SHIT THIS WAS BEAUTIFUL!!! it's sooo live I love it you hear the emotions in the voice so much better
Most Live kpop performance in a while!!! Very good, hearing mistakes makes it more enjoyable
Miyeon is a princess perfect of Kpop
miyeon is a good singer
From the hate comments I was expecting something worse but this is a great performance, just shaky at times, which isn't something to go crazy about
Miyeon you are truly an angel, you are so beautiful and talented, not everyone can sing live as well as you.
You have an amazing voice Miss Cho Miyeon
Thank you, Miyeon, not just for your wonderfull performance, but for proving, once again, that 99% of kpop fans have no clue about how great live vocals are supposed to sound. The worst you could say about it is is that she wasnt as assured as she would have been were she not nervous, but the way she uses EVERYTHING to bend her sound to what she needs, at every moment... IT is a thing of beauty. This sounds like somebody not doing as well as she wanted, not somebody doing even remotely bad. Her phrasing and emoting are exemplary. Her musicality truly inspiring. She sacrifices some intonation (probably beacuse of nerves) but makes up for it with emotion that feels real. Most of you wouldnt say shit if the internet hadnt told you before. This is a SINGER showing you how its done when things are not in your favor and you are missing the point.
Kpop stans are the absolute pit. They have such an inferiority complex about their favourite singers being called fake puppets of big companies instead of artists that they are obsessed with live singing while knowing aboslutely nothing about how the human voice even works. If i never ever hear another dumbass kpop stan mention support, one of the few terms about technique that they think they understand (spoiler allet: they dont), or nonsensical stuff about support range, I will be a happy man.
singing without autotune its show how she is very confident!!! and i find this very good
Miyeon you did great, singing live is not easy for anyone and you were just amazing, I really liked your performance and your outfit. You are so pretty and so kind, thank you for your hard work and good luck for what comes next 🥰
I think Miyeon performs quite good voice control, even the sound on the broadcast live stage is pure real voice (not hear any effect, even reverb), The song structure itself has many parts that are key shifting that are very easy to off the tune for inexperienced vocalists. Miyeon did great! 👏👏👏
When everyone turns to be a good critiques like they know how to sing. Justifying that "they heard the original song", like they don't make mistakes.
I still think her voice is so nice and she sang well for being nervous. Miyeon!! ❤️
Miyeon is a good vocalist, in this performance she lacks a little bit cause she's nervous, it's okay, don't remember that she's not perfect, she's human 😊 love u gidle love u miyeon❤❤
You did a great job cho miyeon!!!
It maybe wasn't perfect but miyeon you still did a very good job, honestly. I hope you won't be too hard on yourself
This is live singing y'all. You can get off-pitch at some parts especially if you're nervous. I think this is also the first time she's singing this song live? Correct me if I'm wrong.
Idk if it’s her first time but imo she did really well. This was her first time performing in front of so many actors so I get why she was nervous. I probably have terrible hearing musically bc for me this performance sounded amazing. She was a little shaky at times but other than that she did so well
Oh ..shes been performing with a hundred shows already so people are expecting her to give a great perfirmance besides she is the soundtract singer.. So people expect her that much...
But you think she’d have more confidence in herself if she is a well seasoned performer. This reeks of no confidence
I Love miyeon but if you're a main vocalist who debuted years ago , she sould've done a little better
She is just newly this godo at singing tbh. before she had no real expectations but this past year and half she skyrocketd in singing ability. kinda tough for her mental but i get it.@@bennu547
Came to see the performance because of hearing about hate comments. There is certain way the voice shakes when someone is nervous. It's involuntary, a physical response to psychological stress. I can hear it here. There's also the added stress of hearing yourself, knowing it's not right, then that doubles the stress and affects your performance. Being on stage, looking out over the audience and feeling the immensity of all the people focused solely on you is a lot to process. I've experienced it. She did well considering. Bravo. Fighting. All those haters could never.
When I first heard the OST in the drama, I thought it was Gummy until I checked later, beautiful voice
This was great. You did great Miyeon!! & I love you and I'm so proud of you always ❤️
Wonderful 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻❣️❣️❣️
She is beautiful ❤
Tbh, it's great
People complaining about her nervousness and here I am being like I would cry just having to stand up there cuz I have stage fright 😩
she has a beautiful voice ❤
I didn't even notice what everyone was talking about until I watched it back again after the criticism, she sounds good and it's her real voice, all be it a little shakier and not as on pitch as she usually is, but the drama was uncalled for and blown beyond proportion.
LOVE MIYEON 🤟🏻💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟💟
a really beautiful performance
You did well Miyeon, stay strong! 💚
Wow
I feel very nostalgic and emotional even without understanding the lyrics🥰
Great job MiYeon👏💯❤️
Great performance ❤
We love you miyeon fighting!!!
I would take a live performance with a few errors over a heavily autotuned lip-synced one any day
She proved she cares about her fans and values them ❤
I knew the hate comments couldn’t have been right. I’d pay to watch this over and over again!
I think sometimes people forget that live vocals aren't sounds like recorded auto tuned songs 😅
AMAZING STAGE 조미연선생님!! Love uuuu
This was beautiful
❤🎉from Ipoh Mali Talak Sombong.
She absolutely ate
It's refreshing to hear live vocals. Been a while
Her voice is so angelic and beautiful, she shouldn't apologise for anything..
I'm so sad :'( miyeon is just an angel singing live with all her love 💖 and I'm proud of her !!
Smooth and real voice
Correct technique
No sound
change in live performance
No automatic adjustment
There is no difference between the original and live versions of the song
Real voice
And...
So what is your reason for visiting? You are looking for an excuse to hit so much that you will surely take the breath away of an artist (singing live is not for everyone and few people take the risk of live because they
Lmao people criticize her probably don't even know how a real voice without autotune sounds like. She's just a lil nervous, kpop fans need to chill out 😂
Her tone is so unique
Am I the only one who sincerely liked this performance? Like, I think she was really good and at least not as ba as haters said
I mean there's better performances sure but this isn't awful by any means. She sounds nervous. Everyone is saying it's her job but even professional speakers can get shaken from a bad atmosphere, and Miyeon doesn't perform solo and this isn't her usual venue or style. I think pointing out how she was weak is fine but the hate is crazy.
My Dearest ❤️❤️❤️
Lee Jang Hyun ❤️ Gil Chae
Princess 👑 miyeon ❤🎉😢😢
Oh my god i expected this to be really bad (because of all the hate), but it actually isn't, she just has a shaky voice cause she's nervous
Miyeon ❤❤❤
Love you miyeon❤😍
Wow ❤
Miyeon, don't be sad if you read bad comments, I'm sure in the future you can do better, this is good
Lovely
Bro so good i saw so much and expected it to be soooo BAD
She was nervous, that's why she was very hesitating, we can hear in her voice.
No need "hate" for her performance, I doubt a lot of people can sing in live without being nervous.
Not α professional nor have i heard of her or the song but she sounds great to me
the best ever
I have a music degree there was like 1 note that was a little flat. The rest of this is her just sounding nervous. People are WEIRD. Also look how many idols actually sing a ballad…not many because most of them can’t sing
For the antis…nice try….live with no backtrack, AR, post process or post edit is different..this is raw, learn the difference..miyeon here first time = alone without team members, without her fans, performing for top actors, last minute preparation and coming back from a hectic schedule…if u wanna show those vids of jongho singing as a proof then dont because i can show u 1000 vids of your faves singing as well…even the best singers can make mistake, even singers of 10 years can get nervous in this situation, she is human not robot…if you wanna discredit her for making mistake once out of 1000 then dont even think abt it..and miyeon did fine here, a little nervous yes but nothing for antis to brk about…
She sounded so goood, wth..!!
Well l, I have heard that this performance was not very good or even got criticised by many people and I didn’t expect much even though I’m a big fan of Gidle. But honestly it was not bad! We can know that she was very nervous throughout her voice with little flaws, however overall it was a good performance
She was singing live so She is the best
ضَوءُ القمر يَتسلل عبر النَّافذة....
يَمر أمام قَلبي....
في ليلةٍ بلا نوم، وحيدًا....
أنادي باسمكِ....
بصوتٍ حزينٍ....
مع كل نفسٍ منكِ....
يجعلني أشعرُ بالبرد في الريح الباردة....
أصبحتِ بعيدة بشكلٍ مؤلمٍ....
أَفتقدكِ....
مرةً أُخرى، كالدموع التي تتدفق بلا توقف....
أنتِ مَرسومةٌ في ضوء القمر....
يا حُبي الذي لا يُنسى....
فراقٌ جاء بلا تردد....
لم يبقَ خلفكِ غير الشَّوق....
هل ستتحطم عند أطراف أصابعي؟....
أم ستتبدد مع تنهدٍ؟....
ابتسامتك التي أبقتني قريبًا....
مع كلِ ذكرى مفقودةٍ....
أيامكِ تستمرُّ بالانتشار بلا نهايةٍ....
في داخلي....
أنتِ مَرسومةٌ في ضوء القمر....
يا حُبي الذي لا يُنسى....
فراقٌ جاء بلا تَردد....
لم يبقَ خلفكِ غير الشَّوق....
أصبحَتِ لَيلتي....
يا حُبي الذي لا يُنسى....
بلا حتى نجمٍ أو قمرٍ حَزين....
رحلتِ ولمْ تتركي ورائكِ غير الشَّوق....
She's soo good ....❤
People real are used to autotune a lot. She singing lovelly and its normal to not sound perfect when singing.