I'm a white Aussie male and I have visited China and USA. I felt absolutely free in China. I could go anywhere, leave my things on a restaurant table and go to the counter, come back, and my things were there. The Police in China are Civic Police and carry no guns. One Chinese Police office even escorted me to the nearest toilet when I needed to go. The people were friendly, and they went out of the way to help me when I struggled with Mandarin. I went out in the Cities of China at 3am in the morning and there were thousands of people shopping (the night shifters) and many were young women walking around freely. I felt absolutely nervous in USA. There are over 40,000 gun related deaths in USA every year (virtually ZERO in every other developed country in the world because they do not have Citizen Gun Rights) and I was told that USA citizens carry guns to "protect themselves". If that is the case, then how do Tourists protect themselves? Some of my USA relatives and friends warned me not to go to certain suburbs in the cities, and I would not go out in a city after midnight. I got pick-pocketed in USA and I saw many people living in the streets. The Police in USA are militia police, they walk around with a utility belt full or arsenals (guns, batons, phasers, cuffs, pepper sprays, etc). It was clear to me that citizens in China are FAR MORE FREER than the citizens in USA. Too many angry citizens in USA due to their government not taking care of their citizens. USA has one of the worst Civic Infrastructures I have seen in a developed country, and their Civic Services are ridiculously expensive, out of the reach of millions of USA citizens.
The. Reality of life based on OBSERVATION based on using common sense & ability to critically think past the propaganda we are subject to in the West ..we are constantly deceived about life outside North America.
Thanks for sharing. I hope more people understand that to make the world a better and happier place requires all hands on deck and it’s not supposed to just be “ME” but “US”. Thank you
People say that the United States (US) is the land of the free and the home of the brave. However, the US government accuses the People’s Republic of China of being a dictatorship. A black man who has lived in China for 6 years compares the freedom in the US, and the freedom in China, to determine which citizens are happier. Freedom means nothing, if you are unhappy! Today, 38 million Americans live in poverty. Only 33% of Americans are satisfied with our government. Conversely, China has eradicated her poverty since 2020, despite having 4 times the US’ population. 90% of Chinese are satisfied with their government! The US has consistently refused to comply with 42 United Nations’ resolutions demanding that it immediately return Puerto Rico’s sovereignty to the Puerto Ricans. Therefore, the US does not want freedom for the Puerto Ricans! China does not support the artificial colonial settler state of Israel in its genocidal campaign against the indigenous people of Palestine in their own homeland. The US, however, and despite most of its citizens being against it, is unconditionally supporting Israel’s genocide! That makes the whole world very unhappy! US freedom is just an illusion!
Freedom in western world is the freedom for international bankers and super rich families, while freedom in China is the freedom for everyone regardless of his/her economic status. That's the difference I concluded in past decades.
Bro. Willene, Your idea for freedom is right Thank you for your nice videos. I my last 20 years living in Cina, find Chiese society to be a very harmonious happy and most hospitable, civilized and safe society, beautiful people.
Well said. Glad you feel the same. I just hope the world can realise that these videos we make are not to fight against everyone or other countries but just to try and make the world a better and peaceful place for all. Glad you’re enjoying your stay in China too. Grateful for your support. 🙏🏾😊💙
Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
Here are some examples of areas where the United States is generally considered to offer more freedom compared to China: Freedom of Speech: In the United States, individuals have the right to express their opinions and viewpoints freely without fear of government reprisal, whereas in China, there are strict limits on freedom of speech, with censorship and government control over media and online content. Freedom of Religion: The United States guarantees freedom of religion, allowing individuals to practice their faiths without interference from the government, whereas in China, religious practices are tightly regulated, and minority religious groups often face persecution and restrictions. Political Freedom: The United States has a democratic political system where citizens have the right to vote and participate in the political process, whereas China is governed by a single-party authoritarian regime with limited political freedoms and no competitive elections. Personal Privacy: In the United States, individuals have a right to privacy protected by law, including limitations on government surveillance and data collection, whereas in China, government surveillance and monitoring of citizens' activities, both online and offline, are widespread and extensive. Rule of Law: The United States operates under the rule of law, with an independent judiciary and legal system that protects individual rights and ensures due process, whereas in China, the rule of law is often subordinated to the interests of the ruling Communist Party, leading to arbitrary detention, lack of transparency, and unfair judicial proceedings.
I have lived in China for over 13 years. I have lived all over the world, and to be honest I have never felt this safe anywhere in the world. Nobody carry guns because it is not necessary. Every government in the world are doing things that not everybody agree with. The same is here in China, a woman can walk by herself day or night in China and nobody will harm or steel from you. No comparison when it comes to safety between the west and China.
You can walk safely in Taiwan too. The difference is that you can call out Government leaders on Social Media or even protest without fear of the police. The freedom in Taiwan to be as you are & shape change as a citizen is uncomfortable to China. Look how China has controlled HK. - Don't forget that the HK Police shot 3 protestors. One protestor ( who was an organiser) mysteriously dropped to his death from a car park 2nd floor. It is no wonder that the majority of people in Taiwan; citizens and others FO NOT WANT CHINA to take over. China is a neighbour but not family.
@@morejoy5188 does Taiwan government respond to what citizens need? you can protest all you want the most important thing is does the government respond to the citizens?
China you are completely free. Walk anytime in 24 hours completely safe hardly any police on the streets and if there is no guns just walking around. China is the safest Country in the world
@@i-eat-you You saw what happened in USA, didn't you? They forced their citizens to go to work during Covid-19 for $7.50 an hour, helping USA Corporations making more PROFITS than ever before, during the Covid pandemic. As a result, USA had 1.4 MILLION citizens die from Covid, more than any other country in the world. China, with 5 times the population of USA, had under 6,000 Citizens die from Covid during the same period. The difference, China cares for all of its Citizens. In Corporate USA, they only cared about their profits, regardless of whether they were sending their citizens to their death. USA always idolises money of citizens (including their OWN citizens). So called USA freedom to their DEATHS!
In China, I don't need to worry about my child being exposed to drugs, guns, violence and other crimes. The only thing I need to worry about is his academic performance.
@@leoholy9818well how do you know that? Rate of entry to a Uni? How smart they are(compare with our kids)? Doesn’t make any sense about what you’ve been mentioned.
@@leoholy9818 It is hard so say, on the one hand their is a large population to be educated, the resources is indeed lacking, but the internet somehow release a part. But kids do study hard for more resources. That is same in USA, once you settle a goal you have to bring more effort
@@leoholy9818 Education in China is the most equitable form of education. In the nine-year compulsory education, all students receive elite education from the same starting line, rather than just like the happy education of ordinary people in Western countries. Only those who have money and power receive elite education! In China, unless students are particularly disinterested in learning, they are only allowed to attend vocational and technical colleges for technical training in high school after completing nine years of compulsory education to become useful individuals in entering society. Those who enjoy learning will be admitted to high school and have the opportunity to pursue higher education in college
It has come to the attention of many that certain RUclipsrs have seared their conscience and have no guilt to make money hating China simply for profit. Stay away from these wicked people, there is no joy or peace with them !
China is actually freer and safer than US. Standard of living for Chinese in China is higher and better in China too.....better living conditions....better affordable healthcare for Chinese in China.
I can't refuse what you say, that is fact. Freedom for Amrc is like free to do anything(more to immorality) there is no place is safe from stalker/ psych/ weird fetishes/ pervrt and looter
@@i-eat-youWhen you think someone is lying, it should be up to you to prove that they are lying, rather than biased to make someone prove that they are not lying
Some yes, other nope. Is depending on the states, country or any places that you go to. Is quite depending on it. That why, you need to research it before you go anywhere on it.
@marinaliu7213 Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
@@impopquiz Some like @peanutbrain will talk rubbish of China and even claim that they live in China but when you challenge them to prove the veracity of their claims, will shut up and slink away like the curs that they are.
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
I’m initially from Massachusetts but moved to NYC when was in my late 20s and both States are dangerous and there’s no difference in any other part of the United States Of America. I have seen mice & rats before but in NYC, the rats are the same as house cats in the Metro System in NYC and the entire NYC is filthy and unsafe! I moved back to Massachusetts in 2004 but it’s not much better than New York City. Who say that we here in America is free or freedom? That’s a fallacy and it doesn’t exist! Official Law Enforcement Servicemen here in America actually killed people and it’s all over the News all the times so, I stopped watching the News completely! There’s so much Racism and Hypocrisy throughout the entire Nation of America but this is all that I know about America so, I just with it the best that I am able to get through life here in the United States of America!🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Speaking about racism, the Chinese are more racist among themselves than foreigners. Like where you live, how much you make, what kind of car you drive, what's even better is where your kid attends school.
I am a Malaysian who travel a lot to Europe and Asia, 48 countries so far. No contest, countries like China, Japan, Singapore, Malaysia are much safer than countries in Europe. China was not very safe 30 years ago, but the safety level is now world topping.
Here are some examples of areas where the United States is generally considered to offer more freedom compared to China: Freedom of Speech: In the United States, individuals have the right to express their opinions and viewpoints freely without fear of government reprisal, whereas in China, there are strict limits on freedom of speech, with censorship and government control over media and online content. Freedom of Religion: The United States guarantees freedom of religion, allowing individuals to practice their faiths without interference from the government, whereas in China, religious practices are tightly regulated, and minority religious groups often face persecution and restrictions. Political Freedom: The United States has a democratic political system where citizens have the right to vote and participate in the political process, whereas China is governed by a single-party authoritarian regime with limited political freedoms and no competitive elections. Personal Privacy: In the United States, individuals have a right to privacy protected by law, including limitations on government surveillance and data collection, whereas in China, government surveillance and monitoring of citizens' activities, both online and offline, are widespread and extensive. Rule of Law: The United States operates under the rule of law, with an independent judiciary and legal system that protects individual rights and ensures due process, whereas in China, the rule of law is often subordinated to the interests of the ruling Communist Party, leading to arbitrary detention, lack of transparency, and unfair judicial proceedings.
I am a Chinese citizen. When the Chinese government handles public incidents, it adheres to the principle of seeking truth from facts. This means that before establishing the true facts, it is necessary to prevent the spread of rumors, which can harm the families of victims and cause social panic. Most people are unable to immediately discern right from wrong. But to be honest, sometimes the judgment may not be well-balanced. However, at least our government is making sincere efforts to progress. If I were to rate the CCP, I would give it a score of 9 out of 10.
I 've lived in both Canada and the United States for many years, and currently I am at my home in Xi'an, China, basking in the sun and enjoying delicious Chinese cuisine while watching this program. I can't help but reflect on the freedom I experience here. A woman can go for a night run or a morning jog at any time she pleases. The subway is clean, affordable, and the people are peaceful and courteous. Incidentally, I have lived in Calgary for 7 years, which is normally considered a very peaceful city in North America. However, I once had a terrifying experience where a mentally ill drug addict pushed me off the subway platform. Unfortunately, such individuals are becoming increasingly common in Canada. Canada, please give this some serious thought.
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
I am a Chinese person who were born and raised in Taiwan, and I feel much more freedom of freedom of speech and freedom of thinking in Mainland China than in Taiwan, it’s not only about safety, but everything, the true principles of freedom are all better in China
Lmao freedom of speech in China? The place where you can’t even talk about the historical event 64 Tiananmen Square publicly ? You call that freedom of speech 😂
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
Thank you very much for sharing. One thing I must clarify is that in China, Chinese citizens over 18 years old can vote as long as they register. However, they vote to elect their own local officials, and continue at each level. Elect people's representatives until the highest-level People's Congress finally elects the highest national leader, instead of every citizen who can vote directly choosing one between two national candidates. Because China has a large population, hundreds of millions of people Choosing one of the two is not the best choice for China. On the contrary, local citizens are familiar with their local officials and choose people they recognize to represent their own interests. People's representatives in each locality will then elect people to represent them layer by layer. Representing local interests is the most suitable method for China at present.
OK, I'll speak as a person who grew up in China. Firstly, having millions of cameras might feel repressive to Western citizens, to us Chinese citizens, we feel like it is a commitment by our government that they always have our back, even if our two eyes fail us. The cameras have helped us solve many crime cases and act as a deterrent for criminal activity, and that's why we support it. Secondly, most people do not know this, but protests are actually allowed in China. It is in our constitution that people are allowed to voice our opinions (or at least, when Deng Xiaoping came around, and most people agree that Mao was a dick during the central period of his rule). The only reason the police will ever get involved is if the protest is a really big one (such as the Hong Kong ones) or it is done in front of a government facility, or the protests get violent. In fact, the police were created due to the Tiananmen Incident, because the government thought that the PLA should only focus on the defence of the nation, and not managing protests, and the PLA back then did most of the policing too. Thirdly, Xinjiang and Tibet are pretty thankful that the CCP decided to exert some control over them. not a lot of people know this too, but Tibet and Xinjiang were very violent regions before the CCP stepped in. After our government got there, they upheld peace for the people by eliminating all the destabilising factions that were inside these two provinces. They also upheld human rights there. One example: The Dalai Lama(in the past) would sacrifice virgin girls for some inhumane ritual every month or so. When the CCP stepped in, they abolished this practice and cracked down on such inhumane rituals and gave everyone in Tibet freedom from the totalitarianism of the Tibetian monastery. From what I learned, it seems that China has a much stellar record of human rights, liberation, freedom and safety compared to the West
You can right about china. But you can be wrong about west as well. Is depends on which of country that are corrupt or not corrupt. Most state and country are not that bad. Some can be awful and other are not. The most funny part that no one ever not even talking about the state the most. They only talk about country like the usa and china. No offense. But they mostly talk about new york, California, Texas, and Florida of how bad was or whatnot. But most never talk about kentucky, tennessee, Ohio and other places. They only talk about most popular place right there. From their hometown. Hell, they not talk about the people who live in unpopular state that live and have no crime rates or what so ever. Hell, even china and russia are the samething even eu or whatnot. People, never talk about the less or good state or whatnot. They only talk the most of popular state most of their home town. Which is just haliorus of horse crap or whatnot. I can see you point. But don't get to attach from your own country. Sometimes they can do nice thing. But other time, they are looking themselves out. Samething in usa. That I not getting to attach. Which I saying is more a trust issue of which person say the truth the most but other tell the lies. Or can be both.
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
As an ordinary Chinese, I truely hope there is no violence in the world. Let peace spread and stay in every corner of the world. In spite of all the diferences, we can be trading partners, coworkers, friends, neighbours, even competitors, but not enemies. Now passing 40s, with all these conflicts in the world, I truely understand the words of Mao in Tiananmen, "世界人民大团结万事"
@@user-lv9jk7zj7kIf the crime rate is low, people won't even need to ban guns because no one uses guns to begin with. Look at Iceland or (please excuse me for that) Japan Both Japan and Iceland have very low crime rates. Compared to the US or Israel that's almost 55 percent absent. The US has a crime rate of almost 77.0 percent. China, Iceland, Japan, and Korea have only 3 percent. Even less in China due to the cameras.
What’s funny is that the U.S. Congress believes that Huawei affects U.S. national security, but U.S. President Biden and many U.S. congressmen actively use TikTok
My Uncle and Dada told us in the late 80;s and 90's there were alot of bad crimes in China especially Shenzhen close to Hong Kong, we as the people wanted our Chinese government to have cameras everywhere and police in the police in the streets. Freedom in China where my niece and nephew can play in the evening with no worries and freedom in China where we as girls can wear sexy clothes at night with our smart phones in the open, you 'Willene Business & Lifesty' youre very lucky to be in China, best of luck brother 兄弟
In China, you can do almost everything a normal citizen wants. If you dress sexy, you probably won't get harassed, but you WILL draw a lot of attention. Just make sure you have you phone on all the time... You'll have to pay for everything from it.
It’s their democratic right to commit crime and freedom from prosecution in America - no photographic not video evidence. Photographic or video evidence without prior expressed consent, is not permitted nor permissible in court.
Always bashing the US. Amazing how touchy and sensitive Chinese get when dealing with criticism. US criticism on a different level. You guys are turning into the worst type o online US right winger spewing shite.
You put all these crucial arguments in a small package. You discussed almost everything. Very clear! Well done!!! I think everyone should see this video. I saw your previous videos. This is the best one!!! Thank you!!!
In china , it’s freedom from drugs and homelessness . In america, it’s freedom of speech and a ban on tik tok( how’s that for freedom of speech? ) and homelessness can be cured by billions of $$$ spent on ukraine wars and israeli wars against the Palestinians 😂😅😂
One thing I'd like to add some nuance to is the "freedom to loot" that was brought up around 11:15. In the US at least, when looting does occur it's almost never portrayed as a freedom to do so. It's almost unanimously an act of either retaliation or desperation for disenfranchised American people who feel they are left with no other option. And it goes hand in hand with riots that happen for similar reasons. We have a saying here that "riots are the voices of the unheard". This is especially true for black Americans who are routinely and violently ignored and subjugated by the ruling class in the US. When every nonviolent option is exhausted and ignored, the only option left is destructive action. Even the rioting and looting that happened on January 6th, while done so for much more malicious reasons and was not at all justified, still has its root cause in an oppressive government that ignores the will of its people in order to further enrich the privileged few. (For Jan. 6th the perpetrators weren't the ones being killed in the streets, they were deranged white supremacists who felt they'd been wronged.) I really hope this adds some much needed context to the topic, and shows just how little freedoms those in the US have (if they're not the ruling capitalist class) and the desperation that causes compared to countries like China.
The Chinese government will try its best to balance and control the unlimited expansion of the interests of the privileged few. This is why some wealthy Chinese choose to immigrate, because these wealthy people have discovered that money is not everything in China. If you have money in the United States, you can find the best lawyers without going to jail. However, if you have money in China, you cannot avoid jail.
The "soul of freedom" is "safety", so that one can move around day or night on will with "no death threats from crimes". And, the "partner of freedom" is "respects and understandings in-between people" .
Depends on from what angle you see freedom. In the West, freedom is seen from individual interests or individual liberty. In the East, including China, freedom is seen as society's liberty. In the East, the common good is held above individual liberty.
China is not part of the west or USA. So it doesn’t have to abide by USA’s standard of freedom. Freedom in China is freedom to education, safety, drinking, leisure etc. While freedom in USA is speech and vote.
Are you kidding me? Does the United States have freedom of speech? So why is Trump’s freedom of speech restricted? China has never advocated absolute freedom like USA. China’s freedom of speech means that what you say must be based on facts. You cannot create lies out of thin air to incite emotions and create chaos, which will bring serious and huge negative impacts to society. As long as you do not cause serious Social harm, your speech is still very free
Free speech in USA? I don't think so. Why do you think Julian Assange is jailed. So many of the channels that don't parrot the mainstream narrative are either shut down or demonetized. Comments being sensored or deleted. Tiktoc is about to get banned. Where's the speech freedom you're talking about?
I learned, March 28 is the date of Tibet slavery emancipation, done in 1955. And the emancipated slaves (no more Dali Lama and his cohorts) have been Chinese citizens and celebrated this date, since. And they call their home, Xizang (not Tibet). Ours emancipation proclamation was January 1, 1863 and we’ve been fighting for freedom all the way till August 28, 1963, Dr King’s “dream” speech. The process have taken a whole 100 years! I have no idea why all these celebrities wanted to shake hands with Dali Lama?
Because they want to help the Dalai Lama split China, not just the Dalai Lama, but also many people who want to subvert the Chinese regime. These people just want to become dictators themselves, not really for the benefit of ordinary people, but the Communist Party of China Uniting 1.4 billion people and helping everyone eventually become rich is not what the United States and Western forces want to see. If China is turned into a dozen or so small countries, China will no longer be able to threaten the United States.
Because those people just want to break the peace. Just like in the Middle East. Support those terrorists. Most people actually prefer peace, but profit will drive many to become mercenary. They are actually the same as those Dalai speakers. Treating people like pigs or sheep to create value for them. There is also a possibility that things come together, I am curious about free speech why no one Falun Gong? It seems to have disappeared.
Those Tibetans in Western countries who hold the snow-capped lion flag and shout "Free Tibet" are not even willing to admit that their grandfathers or fathers were serfs or slaves before 1955. Ridiculous.
As a Chinese, I want to say our lives are free. What foreigners perceive as our lack of freedom is actually our morality and responsibility. Do you think people don't need morality and responsibility?
About 150 million Chinese people traveled abroad, and 99.99% of them voluntarily returned to China because they knew they would enjoy life better in China. Even many Chinese people living overseas did not change their nationality because they eventually Will still go back to China to spend their remaining years in peace
I have never been to the United States, so I do not know and am not qualified to evaluate the freedom of the United States.The price of freedom in China is not to do illegal things, and not to publicly promote and spread divisive rhetoric and ideas on the Internet.(No one cares if people do this in private.My friends and I often talk about or insult the government and the Communist Party when we meet in restaurants, and the police will not rush into my house to arrest me).If you don't do the above two things, you can do whatever you want at any time and place.Any foreigner who has lived in China for a long time understands what I am talking about.Chinese people never worry about offending anyone because of their race, color, religious beliefs, and sexual orientation.I won't worry about being robbed or shot when I go out to buy a pack of cigarettes at night.I won't worry about a lunatic with a gun rushing into my child's school.(But I envy American citizens the right to own guns because I like guns very much)😂
exactly , my city in malaysia is known as mat rempit (mid night rider robber) , while i am in china i felt extremely safe when going out in midnight for food.
this is the first i happen to find the channel and the video, actually the point is so much neutral, and Willene is really what the freedom is, and how to lead the people's idea to the right path. thanks, Willene.
China is not perfect, but as you said it is trying to improve! It’s sad to see so many people with racist stereotypes despite all the evidence available. Anyways, I love how you always stress the idea of world peace, because ultimately - that is my dream too! But it’s is sad to see so much conflict between humans whether it is war or politics etc.. It’s hard to stay positive when I people see purposely spreading misinformation or just people being haters without trying to research and educate themselves. World peace may be close to impossible but it’s definitely my dream one day, progress can be possible when we appreciate each others culture and understand at the end of the day.. we are all human🌎❤️
We have everything written in the middle school textbook 30 years ago in China to explain what freedom is which many westerners have not figured out even now.
Hello, I know you are speaking for true of what your experienced. However, your comment may ONLY caused U.S. politician who wants to criticize more about China. The worst part is ---- majority American rather believe their politician than someone speak for truth.
Thanks brother! Glad you enjoyed the details of the video. I think many people misunderstand this concept so I just thought I should share my personal experiences for more people to understand that cultures are different. Thanks for your support. 🙏🏾😊💙🎉
The very fundamental of "Freedom" is Personal Safety, everything else comes after the fact. Without Personal Safety, the fear and stress levels are high, and your "freedom" diminishes significantly.
Hello! As someone from China, I truly appreciate your efforts in introducing China to your RUclips audience. To be honest, for many Chinese people, the sound of gunshots might be mistaken for the sound of fireworks or firecrackers cause we may we may have never heard the sound of gunfire actually. Thank you for sharing the rich and diverse aspects of Chinese culture with the world! Wish the world will be freedome and peaceful in totally! ！
As a Chinese, I don’t want to compare which country is freer or better with the United States. We just strive to become better than ourselves. Many people who indulge in language attacks and laugh at us say that China is a dictatorship. They flaunt freedom by saying that they can freely criticize their government. What I want to ask is what happens next? Has your situation improved? Has your government really improved after listening to your criticism? Or do you just need a channel to vent your dissatisfaction and don't care about the results? In China, we have our own channels to contact the government. The mayor’s hotline is a good example. It can effectively and quickly solve various problems in your life. As for higher-level problems, the government will solve them. Because the government has gained our trust. We don't think we can handle it better than the government.
For me, the most dangerous thing about going out at 1am in China is that I may be tempted to buy high-calorie gourmet food, which will cause my body fat to increase. It's so tempting!😮
Amen, brother. But sadly that not going to happened samething with russia and eu the world always fight each other with their own greed and bloodlust for war. That's just not right.
Compared freedom China vs US. It's so easy to answer this. China freedom from violence. US freedom for violence. This the big different between China & US ok.
thx 4 ur clarification.I copied some comments on Chinese video sites: We respect the American concept of freedom, and we ask the United States to respect China's concept of freedom. We don't want a drug epidemic, we don't want gun violence, and we don't want labeled groups that cause social division and discrimination. One more thing: we'd better not put too much emphasis on the concept of freedom and forget the purpose of the struggle for freedom.
Thank you ,man. Africans are rising to show the world that their sense of justice, equality,human rights ,compassion , civility and peace is world class. I have great respect for Africans especially their women folks. Thank you.
The difference is the culture. Americans treasure individual freedom, whilst others treasure collective freedom. It is a me me me culture in America whilst others seek the common good. Remember you can't protect yourself when you only want to protect yourself, it takes everyone who wants to protect everyone else to have safety. To give you an analogy, if I think that everyone is not littering, I should litter to create jobs for the cleaners, then if everyone else think like me, there won't be enough cleaners to clean the streets.
Thank you for the amazing video! To me, it's simply about differences. Both countries are far from perfect, and the world isn't black and white.From the perspective of personal freedom and power distribution, the United States and China hold different views on wealth and authority. In the United States, individual wealth often symbolizes personal freedom, while in China, wealth brings additional responsibilities and regulations. This contrast reflects differing ideologies and practices in social governance, individual rights, and governmental oversight between the two nations.Having lived in both the United States and China for considerable periods, I've firsthand observed the contrasting attitudes towards wealth and its implications. In the United States, affluent individuals enjoy the liberty to pursue their desires without restraint. With increasing wealth comes the realization of the ability to explore desires beyond the confines of ordinary life. However, this disparity in personal freedom can be seen as a form of inequality in human rights, as there are fewer constraints.Conversely, in China, wealth entails a heightened level of caution and responsibility. As one ascends to a certain level of affluence capable of influencing significant matters, they also bear greater accountability. The Chinese government scrutinizes whether individuals are willing to shoulder this responsibility. Furthermore, if exceptionally wealthy individuals in China exceed the boundaries of ordinary rights or societal norms, they face more severe repercussions.This discrepancy prompts many affluent Chinese to choose immigration to the United States, where they perceive fewer constraints on their actions.
Are you suggesting that I am a liar? The truth is, I was born and raised in China, pursued my undergraduate and graduate studies in the United States, and spent some time working there before returning to China to embark on my entrepreneurial journey. Before responding, please take a moment to read carefully; I did not assert that China is flawless, but rather, I was conveying my personal perspective. In the United States, the privileged class typically comprises the affluent, who undeniably hold significant sway, resulting in numerous injustices. In China, the privileged class is often associated with the Communist Party, which also grapples with issues of corruption and inequity; for instance, the progeny of influential figures often enjoy preferential access to resources. I firmly believe that there is no utopia nor inferno on this earth. The majority of individuals worldwide belong to the non-privileged class, endeavoring to lead meaningful lives, yearning for security, love, and liberty. Before responding, I encourage you to reflect, or at the very least, read my message in its entirety. 或者？你是看不懂英文？需要我给你翻译一下吗兄弟？还是你觉得我会中文也是装的？
Wow, thank you for this detailed analysis of both sides. Your unbiased opinion is definitely something everyone needs to understand. I’m glad I can learn from you too 🙏🏾😊
As a Chinese, I basically agree with what the up owner said. China may really be safer. But freedom does not equal security. If it were, North Korea would be safer. It is obvious that North Korea is not free. Life is very difficult for ordinary people in China. Many people work non-stop throughout the year and can barely maintain food and clothing for their families. But it is extremely difficult to have a quality life, so many people want to immigrate to the United States. You may want guns to be controlled, but you definitely don’t like “North Korea-style” security and freedom
And thats a problem - they think that life is easier on the other side. Its not. Hell, in majority of cases immigration leads to actually lowering standards, as you end up doing job that is below your skill level. And if you had low level job in your county, dont expect to suddenly get better job abroad. You may end up doing better finacially after some time, but you would be doing worse socialy. So unless you migrate from some really bad country, you arent going end up in better place. And China isnt that far when it comes to living standards anymore - unless you live in some rural village. And if you live there, then you know why you doing bad and its not because of country, rural live is equally bad in majority of places, there is a reason why everybody around the world goes to cities.
It can be concluded that freedom of expression in Asian countries such as China, Korea, Japan, Indonesia and the Arab world is a basic right that is protected, but still has limitations, namely that it does not violate religious values, morality, order, public interests and the integrity of the state.
True freedom is when there is all freedom to BE LOVE and no freedom at all to be EVIL...! Worldly freedom in its highest possibility is what comes most near to the above...! 🙏❤❤🙏 TRUE GOD, YOU ARE LOVE - AND WE, WHO WE ARE OUR SOULS, DO LOVE YOU ABOVE ALL AND IN ALL OUR LOVING - FOR WE ARE BORN FROM YOU TO BE WHO WE ARE, BEING LOVE....!
All freedom is superficial or relative freedom. Westerns value more on individual freedom rather than collective freedom (asians). When come to safety, education, happiness, etc, its will come to different matter.
In South Asia country, freedom depend on which caste you are born to. The upper castes definitely have more freedom than the lower caste communities like the Dalits.
首先一點即，你拿全民自由和政府集權對比就是一個天大的笑話！ 舉一個不是特別恰當的例子“你在監獄裡，獄警手裡有槍，允許犯人在他認為合理的情況下做所謂的任何事！犯人沒有權利不做！不做就是錯！獄警就可以採取任何措施進行無限制懲罰！你覺得如果你是那個因為跨出牢房時先邁出左腳而被獄警槍擊的囚犯，你是自由的嗎？”當然，像美國一樣極度自由也是存在很多問題的，正如全世界都知道的槍擊案頻發！可槍擊事件不是自由導致的，而是人，是一個心懷惡意的人導致的！你不能說因為有了自由，所以才有槍擊，恰恰相反，正是因為有自由，所以在受到槍擊的時候，受到侵害的人有能力和權利選擇反擊，而在你所認為自由的國家裡，民眾沒有這種自由裁定權和防衛權，尤其是受到公權力或權貴階層和黑惡勢力侵害時，只能忍氣吞聲默默享受你所謂的自由帶來的結果！ 同時，一些自詡在中國所謂生活過一段時間的人，你們不是中國本土人，是享受特權的，只是你們不知道而已！ 當然有一說一，如果你們因為受到自由的庇護而認為槍擊案件或者說治安問題是困擾你們感受自由的核心關鍵，那確實中國確實如你們所謂的“自由”！因為武器在中國絕對不允許除了黨以外的任何勢力染指，觸及即死！ 對了，你可以了解一下近代的8964事件、文化大革命運動、上山下鄉知青運動等等不勝枚舉，現代的就太多了，只是你們不可能從一個“自由的”國家裡傳播出來，比如唐山打人、鐵鏈女、蘇丹紅、三鹿奶粉、地溝油、疫情期間的政府對人民做出的恐怖行為等等……正如全世界可以通過互聯網聽到你們抱怨美國歷史上的印第安人種族滅絕、黑奴等等不光彩的歷史，而我們的聲音卻在中共建政之後幾乎不太可能被外界聽到，因為我們有屬於你們無法理解的所謂“自由”！政府官員可以上B(X)，民眾不允許否則就是違法！政府官員的資產可以存在你們認為不自由的美國，民眾不允許否則就是違法！政府可以強行拆除你家的房子，但是你不能反抗，否則就是違法！如果遇到了不公平的政府行為，不准上訪(可能你們都不懂這個詞的意思，意思是由於受到當地政府的不公平違法行為，無法投訴起訴只有奢求向更高一級政府部門尋求解決方法)，否則就是違法要被拘役或監控！你們認為不自由的國家可以在網上發表對政府的不滿，可在你們認為自由的國家，這樣就是違法會被公安抓捕拘役判刑！並且你的孩子和親屬也會連帶受到政治審查！ 其實我有一個一勞永逸的辦法，能夠解決你們這些受到不自由美國、不自由加拿大、不自由澳洲等國家民眾的困擾！如果你們，以自己身在“不自由”的國家而感到困惑和煩惱，想獲得中國式“自由”以享受餘生，請與我聯繫，我們盡一切可能達成雙方的利益互換！我成為你，生活在你那個“不自由”的國家，而你成為我，沐浴在“自由”的陽光裡，溫馨的提醒你，不是以一個“外國人”的身份，而是一個地地道道的“中國人”或者說“韭菜”的身份。正如中國現在流行的一句話“不要看那個人說什麼，而要看他做什麼！說的再好看，行動總不會騙人！”引申到現在就是“不要看嘴巴說什麼，而要看錢放在哪裡？”為什麼在你們認為自由的中國，官員和富豪們都把資產或公開或隱蔽的偷偷配置到你們深惡痛絕的不自由的美國、加拿大、澳洲、歐洲呢？ I don't intend to translate it into English, because the RUclipsr marked the subtitles in Chinese and English, and even talked about the so-called "freedom" of the CCP. So I will use the freedom I enjoy to express my opinions. you want to know more? you can be translated by yourself!
i m a Chinese.i ve saw so many people said that live in the USA is better than in China.but i don't think so,i think if u want to live in a good place in the USA,u need so much money and power to make sure u can live peacefully.
I'm a white Aussie male and I have visited China and USA. I felt absolutely free in China. I could go anywhere, leave my things on a restaurant table and go to the counter, come back, and my things were there. The Police in China are Civic Police and carry no guns. One Chinese Police office even escorted me to the nearest toilet when I needed to go. The people were friendly, and they went out of the way to help me when I struggled with Mandarin. I went out in the Cities of China at 3am in the morning and there were thousands of people shopping (the night shifters) and many were young women walking around freely.
I felt absolutely nervous in USA. There are over 40,000 gun related deaths in USA every year (virtually ZERO in every other developed country in the world because they do not have Citizen Gun Rights) and I was told that USA citizens carry guns to "protect themselves". If that is the case, then how do Tourists protect themselves? Some of my USA relatives and friends warned me not to go to certain suburbs in the cities, and I would not go out in a city after midnight. I got pick-pocketed in USA and I saw many people living in the streets. The Police in USA are militia police, they walk around with a utility belt full or arsenals (guns, batons, phasers, cuffs, pepper sprays, etc).
It was clear to me that citizens in China are FAR MORE FREER than the citizens in USA. Too many angry citizens in USA due to their government not taking care of their citizens. USA has one of the worst Civic Infrastructures I have seen in a developed country, and their Civic Services are ridiculously expensive, out of the reach of millions of USA citizens.
You've already told us that 20,000 times. We're starting to know it.
The. Reality of life based on OBSERVATION based on using common sense & ability to critically think past the propaganda we are subject to in the West ..we are constantly deceived about life outside North America.
Thanks for sharing. I hope more people understand that to make the world a better and happier place requires all hands on deck and it’s not supposed to just be “ME” but “US”. Thank you
WELL SAID!!!
@@VerkaterterStiefel
You should be glad because if he/she was living in USA he/she may not be alive today to tell us about how safe China is.
People say that the United States (US) is the land of the free and the home of the brave. However, the US government accuses the People’s Republic of China of being a dictatorship. A black man who has lived in China for 6 years compares the freedom in the US, and the freedom in China, to determine which citizens are happier. Freedom means nothing, if you are unhappy! Today, 38 million Americans live in poverty. Only 33% of Americans are satisfied with our government. Conversely, China has eradicated her poverty since 2020, despite having 4 times the US’ population. 90% of Chinese are satisfied with their government! The US has consistently refused to comply with 42 United Nations’ resolutions demanding that it immediately return Puerto Rico’s sovereignty to the Puerto Ricans. Therefore, the US does not want freedom for the Puerto Ricans! China does not support the artificial colonial settler state of Israel in its genocidal campaign against the indigenous people of Palestine in their own homeland. The US, however, and despite most of its citizens being against it, is unconditionally supporting Israel’s genocide! That makes the whole world very unhappy! US freedom is just an illusion!
well said
Spot on
Land of the fees and home of the caged.
Freedom in western world is the freedom for international bankers and super rich families, while freedom in China is the freedom for everyone regardless of his/her economic status. That's the difference I concluded in past decades.
Western countries, especially in USA, ban TikTok in order to make their people live in the information prison of Western authoritarian media.😡
Bro. Willene, Your idea for freedom is right Thank you for your nice videos.
I my last 20 years living in Cina, find Chiese society to be a very harmonious happy and most hospitable, civilized and safe society, beautiful people.
Well said. Glad you feel the same. I just hope the world can realise that these videos we make are not to fight against everyone or other countries but just to try and make the world a better and peaceful place for all. Glad you’re enjoying your stay in China too. Grateful for your support. 🙏🏾😊💙
Glad you enjoyed the time in China, Ur always welcome to China ：）
Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
Here are some examples of areas where the United States is generally considered to offer more freedom compared to China:
Freedom of Speech: In the United States, individuals have the right to express their opinions and viewpoints freely without fear of government reprisal, whereas in China, there are strict limits on freedom of speech, with censorship and government control over media and online content.
Freedom of Religion: The United States guarantees freedom of religion, allowing individuals to practice their faiths without interference from the government, whereas in China, religious practices are tightly regulated, and minority religious groups often face persecution and restrictions.
Political Freedom: The United States has a democratic political system where citizens have the right to vote and participate in the political process, whereas China is governed by a single-party authoritarian regime with limited political freedoms and no competitive elections.
Personal Privacy: In the United States, individuals have a right to privacy protected by law, including limitations on government surveillance and data collection, whereas in China, government surveillance and monitoring of citizens' activities, both online and offline, are widespread and extensive.
Rule of Law: The United States operates under the rule of law, with an independent judiciary and legal system that protects individual rights and ensures due process, whereas in China, the rule of law is often subordinated to the interests of the ruling Communist Party, leading to arbitrary detention, lack of transparency, and unfair judicial proceedings.
What we are talking about here is safety, not freedom. There's no freedom unless you leave earth🤣
I have lived in China for over 13 years. I have lived all over the world, and to be honest I have never felt this safe anywhere in the world. Nobody carry guns because it is not necessary. Every government in the world are doing things that not everybody agree with. The same is here in China, a woman can walk by herself day or night in China and nobody will harm or steel from you. No comparison when it comes to safety between the west and China.
You are comparing Heaven and Hell......nothing to compare!!
You can walk safely in Taiwan too.
The difference is that you can call out Government leaders on Social Media or even protest without fear of the police.
The freedom in Taiwan to be as you are & shape change as a citizen is uncomfortable to China.
Look how China has controlled HK.
- Don't forget that the HK Police shot 3 protestors. One protestor ( who was an organiser) mysteriously dropped to his death from a car park 2nd floor.
It is no wonder that the majority of people in Taiwan; citizens and others FO NOT WANT CHINA to take over.
China is a neighbour but not family.
@@morejoy5188 does Taiwan government respond to what citizens need? you can protest all you want the most important thing is does the government respond to the citizens?
@@morejoy5188 Shut up, when those 'protesters' executed Chinese ppl in HK just cuz they speak Mandarin, where were u, the west hypocrite?
@@melloyellow1836 yes, because otherwise another party will win the next elections
China you are completely free. Walk anytime in 24 hours completely safe hardly any police on the streets and if there is no guns just walking around. China is the safest Country in the world
Especially during Zero Covid!🎉
(when China was a prison for people)
@@i-eat-you You saw what happened in USA, didn't you? They forced their citizens to go to work during Covid-19 for $7.50 an hour, helping USA Corporations making more PROFITS than ever before, during the Covid pandemic.
As a result, USA had 1.4 MILLION citizens die from Covid, more than any other country in the world.
China, with 5 times the population of USA, had under 6,000 Citizens die from Covid during the same period.
The difference, China cares for all of its Citizens. In Corporate USA, they only cared about their profits, regardless of whether they were sending their citizens to their death. USA always idolises money of citizens (including their OWN citizens). So called USA freedom to their DEATHS!
@@i-eat-you when 6 month old babies were separated from their parents and elderly people had to sleep on the floor for weeks.
@@VerkaterterStiefel
While over 1 million Americans were dropping de.ad all over USA!!!
@@Anonymous------ and 3 miilion in China
In China, I don't need to worry about my child being exposed to drugs, guns, violence and other crimes. The only thing I need to worry about is his academic performance.
But Chinese educational system sucks, so there are pros and cons everywhere, choose at your own risk 😂
@@leoholy9818well how do you know that? Rate of entry to a Uni? How smart they are(compare with our kids)? Doesn’t make any sense about what you’ve been mentioned.
@@leoholy9818 It is hard so say, on the one hand their is a large population to be educated, the resources is indeed lacking, but the internet somehow release a part. But kids do study hard for more resources. That is same in USA, once you settle a goal you have to bring more effort
@@leoholy9818中国的教育是最公平的教育，在九年义务教育中所有的学生都在一个起跑线上进行精英教育，而不是像西方国家的普通人民快乐教育，只有那些有钱有权的人孩子进行精英教育！在中国除非学生特别不喜欢学习才上完九年义务教育之后让他们去上职业技术学院在高中阶段进行技术培训成为进入社会有用出的人。那些喜欢学习的考上高中就有上大学进行更高学历的学习中国的教育是最公平的教育，在九年义务教育中所有的学生都在一个起跑线上进行精英教育，而不是像西方国家的普通人民快乐教育，只有那些有钱有权的人孩子进行精英教育！在中国除非学生特别不喜欢学习才上完九年义务教育之后让他们去上职业技术学院在高中阶段进行技术培训成为进入社会有用出的人。那些喜欢学习的考上高中就有上大学进行更高学历的学习
@@leoholy9818 Education in China is the most equitable form of education. In the nine-year compulsory education, all students receive elite education from the same starting line, rather than just like the happy education of ordinary people in Western countries. Only those who have money and power receive elite education! In China, unless students are particularly disinterested in learning, they are only allowed to attend vocational and technical colleges for technical training in high school after completing nine years of compulsory education to become useful individuals in entering society. Those who enjoy learning will be admitted to high school and have the opportunity to pursue higher education in college
In China, u can hold a bottle of wine or beer on your hand and drink it in the streets and not get arrested and in America u will be jailed.
If you talk about drug, there are tons of freedom in the States.
@@JJr-ce3vv your only drug addiction is bashing the West and giving Chinese people a bad name
@@JJr-ce3vv
Alcohol aren’t drugs
Yeah, that different states. Where did you get information from.
😮美国不能在街上喝酒吗 我就是住纽约刚刚21不太懂
It has come to the attention of many that certain RUclipsrs have seared their conscience and have no guilt to make money hating China simply for profit. Stay away from these wicked people, there is no joy or peace with them !
Let me just name a few. Laowhy86, SerpentZa, China Uncensored Chris Chappell and the Firstpost Palki.
@@panyaboonc5621 thanks for these recommendations. You got some more to add?
@@panyaboonc5621 Thanks! Any more recommendations?
thats right
@@panyaboonc5621 So true. These evil YTubers are a disgrace..
China is actually freer and safer than US. Standard of living for Chinese in China is higher and better in China too.....better living conditions....better affordable healthcare for Chinese in China.
Present some results instead of pie in the sky fairy tales
Entonces explicame por qué son los chinos que inmigran a Estados Unidos y no al revés 😅
I can't refuse what you say, that is fact. Freedom for Amrc is like free to do anything(more to immorality) there is no place is safe from stalker/ psych/ weird fetishes/ pervrt and looter
@@i-eat-you China can safely wander outside in any city at any time and freely
@@i-eat-youWhen you think someone is lying, it should be up to you to prove that they are lying, rather than biased to make someone prove that they are not lying
underated channel
I truly appreciate your support. 🙏🏾😊
In the US the criminals have freedom to commit any crimes they want. The law abiding citizens have freedom to fear for their lives everyday.
Some yes, other nope. Is depending on the states, country or any places that you go to. Is quite depending on it. That why, you need to research it before you go anywhere on it.
@marinaliu7213 Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
犯罪分子有抢劫的自由
The main difference is US is freedom to ME and only ME. In China, most willingly sacrifice freedom for ME for the sake of freedom for ALL.
Stop the bs. Obviously u have never been to China
@@peanut0brainhave u? 😅
That last sentence sounds like Jesus sacrifice himself for us to live in light. that's deep man
@@impopquiz I'm living in China right now for 11yrs already... People who know sheet shouldn't comment like they know sheet
@@impopquiz Some like @peanutbrain will talk rubbish of China and even claim that they live in China but when you challenge them to prove the veracity of their claims, will shut up and slink away like the curs that they are.
China is more free. Thanks for making this video. ❤️
Thank you too for watching and commenting 🙏🏾😊
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
I’m initially from Massachusetts but moved to NYC when was in my late 20s and both States are dangerous and there’s no difference in any other part of the United States Of America. I have seen mice & rats before but in NYC, the rats are the same as house cats in the Metro System in NYC and the entire NYC is filthy and unsafe! I moved back to Massachusetts in 2004 but it’s not much better than New York City. Who say that we here in America is free or freedom? That’s a fallacy and it doesn’t exist! Official Law Enforcement Servicemen here in America actually killed people and it’s all over the News all the times so, I stopped watching the News completely! There’s so much Racism and Hypocrisy throughout the entire Nation of America but this is all that I know about America so, I just with it the best that I am able to get through life here in the United States of America!🤢🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
Politician says that "American are free" China is oppressive.
You never been to America. Fake.
I understand you very much and I hope everyone in the world can feel safe and happy🙏
过来中国旅游一下❤
Speaking about racism, the Chinese are more racist among themselves than foreigners. Like where you live, how much you make, what kind of car you drive, what's even better is where your kid attends school.
I am a Malaysian who travel a lot to Europe and Asia, 48 countries so far. No contest, countries like China, Japan, Singapore, Malaysia are much safer than countries in Europe. China was not very safe 30 years ago, but the safety level is now world topping.
身为一个1985年出生的中国普通人,我从小接收到的关于美国关于西方的讯息都是完美的,社会是开放的,人民是自由的,总之都是正向的美好的,这些通过报纸,通过杂志无时无刻都在告诉我,美国是天堂,而我在地狱,甚至我到今天还记得华盛顿砍樱桃树的故事.但是在大概是我35岁的时候,我意识到一切的根源都在于经济,军事,就是整个国家的综合实力,这就解释了为什么西方世界一直在对中国造谣,抹黑,而中国确很少反击,因为当时中国无论在各个方面都没有实力反击,说以中国在那个时候默认国内亲西方的媒体对整个西方世界的过分吹嘘,默认中国被叫做公知的人,把西方形容成天堂,这也是中国政府说的韬光养晦的一部分,好的,这些都2021年改变了,在2021年中美高层战略对话中,杨洁篪对美方代表国务卿安东尼·布林肯、总统国家安全事务助理杰克·沙利文。这两位先生说出,你们没有资格在中国的面前说，你们从实力的地位出发同中国谈话。这让我一个普通的中国人意识到,我的国家要开始反击了.欢迎理智的朋友一起讨论一些观点,但是请一些水军不要来,你们的那些话术真的很傻
是的 誠如 孫中山先生所言 廿一世紀是中國人的世紀
以前是实力不允许，现在还是实力不允许。
说的好
Here are some examples of areas where the United States is generally considered to offer more freedom compared to China:
Freedom of Speech: In the United States, individuals have the right to express their opinions and viewpoints freely without fear of government reprisal, whereas in China, there are strict limits on freedom of speech, with censorship and government control over media and online content.
Freedom of Religion: The United States guarantees freedom of religion, allowing individuals to practice their faiths without interference from the government, whereas in China, religious practices are tightly regulated, and minority religious groups often face persecution and restrictions.
Political Freedom: The United States has a democratic political system where citizens have the right to vote and participate in the political process, whereas China is governed by a single-party authoritarian regime with limited political freedoms and no competitive elections.
Personal Privacy: In the United States, individuals have a right to privacy protected by law, including limitations on government surveillance and data collection, whereas in China, government surveillance and monitoring of citizens' activities, both online and offline, are widespread and extensive.
Rule of Law: The United States operates under the rule of law, with an independent judiciary and legal system that protects individual rights and ensures due process, whereas in China, the rule of law is often subordinated to the interests of the ruling Communist Party, leading to arbitrary detention, lack of transparency, and unfair judicial proceedings.
@@albertlee18 如果单纯从经济实力和经济实力来说够了 现在缺的是媒体和影响力 不过这些多是需要时间建立的
I am a Chinese citizen. When the Chinese government handles public incidents, it adheres to the principle of seeking truth from facts. This means that before establishing the true facts, it is necessary to prevent the spread of rumors, which can harm the families of victims and cause social panic.
Most people are unable to immediately discern right from wrong. But to be honest, sometimes the judgment may not be well-balanced. However, at least our government is making sincere efforts to progress. If I were to rate the CCP, I would give it a score of 9 out of 10.
Thank you so much for these details! Everyone really needs to understand the truth!
中国共产党的英文是"Communist Party of China", 简称"CPC". 最好不要用CCP这个缩写
I 've lived in both Canada and the United States for many years, and currently I am at my home in Xi'an, China, basking in the sun and enjoying delicious Chinese cuisine while watching this program. I can't help but reflect on the freedom I experience here. A woman can go for a night run or a morning jog at any time she pleases. The subway is clean, affordable, and the people are peaceful and courteous. Incidentally, I have lived in Calgary for 7 years, which is normally considered a very peaceful city in North America. However, I once had a terrifying experience where a mentally ill drug addict pushed me off the subway platform. Unfortunately, such individuals are becoming increasingly common in Canada. Canada, please give this some serious thought.
你的经历太恐怖了？
@@MidiZhang9853 不要对有这种遭遇的人阴阳怪气吧。
woc
@@MidiZhang9853 在受害者这里玩反讽可不好哦
没有约束的自由不是自由，是失控
Freedom without restraint is not freedom, it is loss of control
💕@@karmarleekl
Great China 🇨🇳 peaceful helpful freedoms country in the world 🌎 ❤️💐
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
China is just China
I am a Chinese person who were born and raised in Taiwan, and I feel much more freedom of freedom of speech and freedom of thinking in Mainland China than in Taiwan, it’s not only about safety, but everything, the true principles of freedom are all better in China
欢迎台湾同胞来大陆游玩
這種鬼話都編的出來😂
睜眼瞎話是中國小粉紅標配。
台灣太自由，自由到容許台灣人在台灣公開支持敵對國家--中國，這種自由縱容讓敵對宣傳有機可乘，混水摸魚。
@@Rooboofish 你自己想想是不是这样的，在大陆，其实你私下里或者和朋友们谈论什么都可以的，只是不能造谣，或者如果你是一个名人，不能公开发表反党反国家的言论，仅此而已，你们自诩自由民主的弯弯和美国，反而有太多的不能说和政治正确，是不是这样？
Lmao freedom of speech in China?
The place where you can’t even talk about the historical event 64 Tiananmen Square publicly ?
You call that freedom of speech 😂
❤ Excellent comments about the freedom. You really understand the meaning of freedom and I totally agree with you.
Thank you too for your support. We’ll keep sharing our experiences. 🙏🏾😊
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
Thanks for sharing and surfacing the truth. 👏👍
Always! Thanks for your support 🙏🏾😊
Thank you very much for sharing. One thing I must clarify is that in China, Chinese citizens over 18 years old can vote as long as they register. However, they vote to elect their own local officials, and continue at each level. Elect people's representatives until the highest-level People's Congress finally elects the highest national leader, instead of every citizen who can vote directly choosing one between two national candidates. Because China has a large population, hundreds of millions of people Choosing one of the two is not the best choice for China. On the contrary, local citizens are familiar with their local officials and choose people they recognize to represent their own interests. People's representatives in each locality will then elect people to represent them layer by layer. Representing local interests is the most suitable method for China at present.
中国是选拔制度，要走官场也是每个人的自由，你目标是国家主席都没问题，就是一步一步干上去，首先考个公务员，从小官员慢慢做上去，科长 乡长 县长 市长 省长 慢慢干上去，靠你的政绩，能力 ，关系 ，人脉 ，跟选举有毛关系。
中國屬於菁英政策...
直接由人民直接選擇候選人有時候不是一件好事...
美國自己的電影(大獨裁者落難記 The Dictator)
裡面就有說過一個觀點...好人有一票...壞人也有一票...
甚至講得更直白一點...聰明的人有一票...弱智的人也會有一票...
我必須說句話，我們沒有投票，但是我們有大局觀。
为什么我有选票？选票是需要你自己去注册的，有些地区是天然拥有，有些地区需要个人去社区注册。拿到选票后你就会发现真的很烦，鸡毛蒜皮的事都要给你打电话投票。烦不胜烦。@@黄鹏-q5h
Actually.most of people here dont care aboit vote.
OK, I'll speak as a person who grew up in China. Firstly, having millions of cameras might feel repressive to Western citizens, to us Chinese citizens, we feel like it is a commitment by our government that they always have our back, even if our two eyes fail us. The cameras have helped us solve many crime cases and act as a deterrent for criminal activity, and that's why we support it. Secondly, most people do not know this, but protests are actually allowed in China. It is in our constitution that people are allowed to voice our opinions (or at least, when Deng Xiaoping came around, and most people agree that Mao was a dick during the central period of his rule). The only reason the police will ever get involved is if the protest is a really big one (such as the Hong Kong ones) or it is done in front of a government facility, or the protests get violent. In fact, the police were created due to the Tiananmen Incident, because the government thought that the PLA should only focus on the defence of the nation, and not managing protests, and the PLA back then did most of the policing too. Thirdly, Xinjiang and Tibet are pretty thankful that the CCP decided to exert some control over them. not a lot of people know this too, but Tibet and Xinjiang were very violent regions before the CCP stepped in. After our government got there, they upheld peace for the people by eliminating all the destabilising factions that were inside these two provinces. They also upheld human rights there. One example: The Dalai Lama(in the past) would sacrifice virgin girls for some inhumane ritual every month or so. When the CCP stepped in, they abolished this practice and cracked down on such inhumane rituals and gave everyone in Tibet freedom from the totalitarianism of the Tibetian monastery. From what I learned, it seems that China has a much stellar record of human rights, liberation, freedom and safety compared to the West
??? Wtf???
You can right about china. But you can be wrong about west as well. Is depends on which of country that are corrupt or not corrupt. Most state and country are not that bad. Some can be awful and other are not. The most funny part that no one ever not even talking about the state the most. They only talk about country like the usa and china. No offense. But they mostly talk about new york, California, Texas, and Florida of how bad was or whatnot. But most never talk about kentucky, tennessee, Ohio and other places. They only talk about most popular place right there. From their hometown. Hell, they not talk about the people who live in unpopular state that live and have no crime rates or what so ever. Hell, even china and russia are the samething even eu or whatnot. People, never talk about the less or good state or whatnot. They only talk the most of popular state most of their home town. Which is just haliorus of horse crap or whatnot. I can see you point. But don't get to attach from your own country. Sometimes they can do nice thing. But other time, they are looking themselves out. Samething in usa. That I not getting to attach. Which I saying is more a trust issue of which person say the truth the most but other tell the lies. Or can be both.
@@zombieghostguy3434 I have travelled through the entirety of my country. Reality speaks for itself
I have lived in China for over 15 years, and the idea that China is freer than the US is extremely laughable and absurd. Try criticizing Xi in public and you will be hauled off and disappeared real quick. In America, you have the Freedom of Speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly. In China, you have none of these rights. In China, as a foreigner, you have to constantly check in with the police wherever you go to a new city. Christianity is not allowed to be freely practiced. The CCP persecutes minority groups both religious and nonreligious. Anything that exposes CCP corruption online is wiped off the internet. You have to use a VPN to access Western websites like google and twitter since the government censors everything. You have cameras everywhere. Big brother is always watching. Wechat is monitored and censored. Chinese social media is monitored and censored. I could give countless more examples
Nonsense about Dalai Lama sacrificing virgin girls.
As an ordinary Chinese, I truely hope there is no violence in the world. Let peace spread and stay in every corner of the world. In spite of all the diferences, we can be trading partners, coworkers, friends, neighbours, even competitors, but not enemies. Now passing 40s, with all these conflicts in the world, I truely understand the words of Mao in Tiananmen, "世界人民大团结万事"
1.国家这个概念就注定了你没有绝对的自由，毕竟你与他人组成了族群，并形成了秩序。
2.言论自由，某种意义上我们都拥有言论自由，但是相关言论都会收到相对应的反馈。表现程度上的差异。
3.中国战后并没有禁枪，回归生活后很多人产生了矛盾就会械斗，甚至有两个村子几千人的对峙，之后索性禁止了枪支。没有什么自由的问题，枪支就是执行暴力的工具，能够高效的管控对手。出现问题并解决问题，更为重要。
禁不禁枪并不是绝对的正确或者错误，我理解应该要符合当地情况。
美国某些州的确不适合禁枪：假如你在南卡罗来纳州，自己最近的邻居需要开车至少半个小时才能到他家。如果你禁枪了，但是罪犯们会有渠道搞到黑枪，来你家抢劫，你报警，然后警察告诉你大概2个小时之后能到你家……
说到底不禁枪只是一个社会治理能力不足的办法，当然会导致很多反社会的枪击案，但是也的确制止了一些有预谋的恶性犯罪。
禁枪其实和械斗关系并不大，主要还是犯罪率的问题，经济下行犯罪率上升，并且禁枪之后黑枪反而泛滥导致了几个重大案件，解决枪械问题除了例行的缉枪治爆外，很大程度得益于经济回暖和提升，毕竟冒着丢工作的风险去弄一条枪，实在没必要。
@@user-lv9jk7zj7kIf the crime rate is low, people won't even need to ban guns because no one uses guns to begin with.
Look at Iceland or (please excuse me for that) Japan
Both Japan and Iceland have very low crime rates. Compared to the US or Israel that's almost 55 percent absent. The US has a crime rate of almost 77.0 percent.
China, Iceland, Japan, and Korea have only 3 percent. Even less in China due to the cameras.
Freedom is to use Huawei, Tiktok etc.. and my comments don't get deleted by media if it's not in their agenda.
What’s funny is that the U.S. Congress believes that Huawei affects U.S. national security, but U.S. President Biden and many U.S. congressmen actively use TikTok
China needs more people to speak for her because ordinary people elsewhere are getting distorted information.
My Uncle and Dada told us in the late 80;s and 90's there were alot of bad crimes in China especially Shenzhen close to Hong Kong, we as the people wanted our Chinese government to have cameras everywhere and police in the police in the streets. Freedom in China where my niece and nephew can play in the evening with no worries and freedom in China where we as girls can wear sexy clothes at night with our smart phones in the open, you 'Willene Business & Lifesty' youre very lucky to be in China, best of luck brother 兄弟
No,it was not true. There were some than now, but not very bad that like you said
In China, you can do almost everything a normal citizen wants. If you dress sexy, you probably won't get harassed, but you WILL draw a lot of attention. Just make sure you have you phone on all the time... You'll have to pay for everything from it.
@@lenaw4161 没啥好否认的，千禧年之前中国治安就是很烂，全智贤来参加活动半路被抢，老电影经常有村民拦路抢公交车的桥段。但中国只用了二十年的时间，就变成了最安全的国家之一，这个才是真正牛逼的地方。
你出生在什么时代，经历过90年代吗？ 中国在90年代00年初期的治安比我去年去的埃及还糟糕。
@@xuliu8062 當然啊，在那時候深圳關口任何一個天橋，只要你看到美女都是在賣的。到處都是（對我來説）匪徒與垃圾。不過看看現在？
中國沒有犯罪的自由卻有免於恐懼的權利
“China does not have the freedom to commit crimes but has the right to be free from fear.” LOUD AND CLEAR.
死人不会说话。没人能问出死人想要活着还是自由
It’s their democratic right to commit crime and freedom from prosecution in America - no photographic not video evidence.
Photographic or video evidence without prior expressed consent, is not permitted nor permissible in court.
Always bashing the US. Amazing how touchy and sensitive Chinese get when dealing with criticism. US criticism on a different level. You guys are turning into the worst type o online US right winger spewing shite.
@@JohnSmith-sm7ez haha... ya, cos US government and politicians are shameless, and yes their shamelessness is definitely on a different level.
Thanks for this insight 🙏🏾😊
You put all these crucial arguments in a small package. You discussed almost everything. Very clear! Well done!!! I think everyone should see this video. I saw your previous videos. This is the best one!!! Thank you!!!
I did not know about those events happende in US, thanks for telling the truth.
Glad it was helpful. 🙏🏾😊
In china , it’s freedom from drugs and homelessness . In america, it’s freedom of speech and a ban on tik tok( how’s that for freedom of speech? ) and homelessness can be cured by billions of $$$ spent on ukraine wars and israeli wars against the Palestinians 😂😅😂
One thing I'd like to add some nuance to is the "freedom to loot" that was brought up around 11:15. In the US at least, when looting does occur it's almost never portrayed as a freedom to do so. It's almost unanimously an act of either retaliation or desperation for disenfranchised American people who feel they are left with no other option. And it goes hand in hand with riots that happen for similar reasons.
We have a saying here that "riots are the voices of the unheard". This is especially true for black Americans who are routinely and violently ignored and subjugated by the ruling class in the US. When every nonviolent option is exhausted and ignored, the only option left is destructive action.
Even the rioting and looting that happened on January 6th, while done so for much more malicious reasons and was not at all justified, still has its root cause in an oppressive government that ignores the will of its people in order to further enrich the privileged few. (For Jan. 6th the perpetrators weren't the ones being killed in the streets, they were deranged white supremacists who felt they'd been wronged.)
I really hope this adds some much needed context to the topic, and shows just how little freedoms those in the US have (if they're not the ruling capitalist class) and the desperation that causes compared to countries like China.
Wow, insightful! Thank you for sharing these details. 🙏🏾
The Chinese government will try its best to balance and control the unlimited expansion of the interests of the privileged few. This is why some wealthy Chinese choose to immigrate, because these wealthy people have discovered that money is not everything in China. If you have money in the United States, you can find the best lawyers without going to jail. However, if you have money in China, you cannot avoid jail.
@@anonymintheworld9781 ...wihout trial and without having done anything wrong. Peng Shuai.
我在各大社区经常会问到，我们美国可以骂总统，你们可以么？我个人认为，美国的选举制度，是需要各大财团进行赞助总统候选人才有资金进行游说和拉选票，那么如果这个财团赞助的总统候选人当选了总统，之前赞助他竞选资金财团算不算贿赂总统，总过有句古话说得好，吃别人的嘴短，拿别人的手段。当选后的总统会不会成为精选赞助商的傀儡？美国人口中的我可以自由的去骂我们的总统，其实你的总统也只是一个站在资本前面的演员而已。其中挨骂也只是他身为一个演员的工作之一而已。美国的媒体全部掌握在各大财团手中，美国人从媒体上获取的咨询也只是财团想让你看到的信息。TIKTOK给了美国人民真正可以言论自由的地方，不受美国财团控制的平台他们是不会接受的。所以极力的想将它收入囊中，或者彻底滚蛋，这样才可以让美国人民只能获取他们想让你获取的资讯，这比中国的“墙”还可怕，并且美国的媒体还总是而已的抹黑中国。因为美国人没有其他接受信息的渠道，信息茧房就形成了。中国的监控摄像头确实很多。正式因为这样，在中国犯罪后逃脱的机率微乎其微。正因为中国的安检机制保证了危险品不可能进入地铁，火车，飞机等公共交通设置，也不可能通过公共交通系统运输到其他地方。在药品管控方面做的也非常到位。正因为这样滥用药物才不会出现。在中国黄赌毒几乎绝迹。反观美国，枪支泛滥，药品不管控，案件机制松散。天黑后不敢出门。这就是你们美国公民想要的自由么？
雖然您說得很好，但是唯一一點就是對掃黃的力度還需要加深😂
@@ParkChungHeeinSouthKorea 大可不必！！🙏
@@yipan8997 您黄先生发誓与赌毒不共戴天😂
The "soul of freedom" is "safety", so that one can move around day or night on will with "no death threats from crimes". And, the "partner of freedom" is "respects and understandings in-between people" .
Depends on from what angle you see freedom. In the West, freedom is seen from individual interests or individual liberty. In the East, including China, freedom is seen as society's liberty. In the East, the common good is held above individual liberty.
我们中国也有相对的自由，因为你的自由不能影响到别人和法律，中国有句古话：无规矩不成方圆。什么事情都要有一条线，不能超过那条线
That's a really wise thing to say 😊
You are smart to have a comparison between two countries. Hope people around the world willing to see the fact.
China is not part of the west or USA.
So it doesn’t have to abide by USA’s standard of freedom.
Freedom in China is freedom to education, safety, drinking, leisure etc.
While freedom in USA is speech and vote.
Are you kidding me? Does the United States have freedom of speech? So why is Trump’s freedom of speech restricted? China has never advocated absolute freedom like USA. China’s freedom of speech means that what you say must be based on facts. You cannot create lies out of thin air to incite emotions and create chaos, which will bring serious and huge negative impacts to society. As long as you do not cause serious Social harm, your speech is still very free
Comments will be censor by TicTok, FB....
Free speech in USA? I don't think so. Why do you think Julian Assange is jailed. So many of the channels that don't parrot the mainstream narrative are either shut down or demonetized. Comments being sensored or deleted. Tiktoc is about to get banned. Where's the speech freedom you're talking about?
there are some group which you can't talk about in US
I learned, March 28 is the date of Tibet slavery emancipation, done in 1955. And the emancipated slaves (no more Dali Lama and his cohorts) have been Chinese citizens and celebrated this date, since. And they call their home, Xizang (not Tibet).
Ours emancipation proclamation was January 1, 1863 and we’ve been fighting for freedom all the way till August 28, 1963, Dr King’s “dream” speech.
The process have taken a whole 100 years!
I have no idea why all these celebrities wanted to shake hands with Dali Lama?
Yeah, the dream speech, by King, “freedom’s ring”!
Because they want to help the Dalai Lama split China, not just the Dalai Lama, but also many people who want to subvert the Chinese regime. These people just want to become dictators themselves, not really for the benefit of ordinary people, but the Communist Party of China Uniting 1.4 billion people and helping everyone eventually become rich is not what the United States and Western forces want to see. If China is turned into a dozen or so small countries, China will no longer be able to threaten the United States.
Because those people just want to break the peace. Just like in the Middle East. Support those terrorists. Most people actually prefer peace, but profit will drive many to become mercenary. They are actually the same as those Dalai speakers. Treating people like pigs or sheep to create value for them. There is also a possibility that things come together, I am curious about free speech why no one Falun Gong? It seems to have disappeared.
The power of propaganda by USA.
Those Tibetans in Western countries who hold the snow-capped lion flag and shout "Free Tibet" are not even willing to admit that their grandfathers or fathers were serfs or slaves before 1955. Ridiculous.
As a Chinese, I want to say our lives are free. What foreigners perceive as our lack of freedom is actually our morality and responsibility. Do you think people don't need morality and responsibility?
Do you think that the CCP still has the mandate of heaven ?
不如说我相信中华民族的天命 @@khanyakwezigenu9755
中国人并不像你们那么关注政治，我们不在乎执政的是谁，他是什么属性，我们只在乎他有没有给我们带来美好的生活，你们鄙视的中共自从执政以来，我们的生活好了很多倍，不要用你们的眼光定义我们的生活，我们不需要从个个财团的推荐下挑选我们的领导人，我们只需要让我们过的更好的领导人。@@khanyakwezigenu9755
Thank you!
You bet! Thank you too
The difference between the two is in the US is me, me ,me vs. we, we, we in China. Just pick one because it's just how one prefers.
Pre COVID approximately 150 m Chinese made trips abroad that is 45% of the US population
About 150 million Chinese people traveled abroad, and 99.99% of them voluntarily returned to China because they knew they would enjoy life better in China. Even many Chinese people living overseas did not change their nationality because they eventually Will still go back to China to spend their remaining years in peace
Now, they cry because of the absent of China tourists.
I have never been to the United States, so I do not know and am not qualified to evaluate the freedom of the United States.The price of freedom in China is not to do illegal things, and not to publicly promote and spread divisive rhetoric and ideas on the Internet.(No one cares if people do this in private.My friends and I often talk about or insult the government and the Communist Party when we meet in restaurants, and the police will not rush into my house to arrest me).If you don't do the above two things, you can do whatever you want at any time and place.Any foreigner who has lived in China for a long time understands what I am talking about.Chinese people never worry about offending anyone because of their race, color, religious beliefs, and sexual orientation.I won't worry about being robbed or shot when I go out to buy a pack of cigarettes at night.I won't worry about a lunatic with a gun rushing into my child's school.(But I envy American citizens the right to own guns because I like guns very much)😂
exactly , my city in malaysia is known as mat rempit (mid night rider robber) , while i am in china i felt extremely safe when going out in midnight for food.
Amazing video. Keep up the good work. Support
Beautiful work ❤❤❤
Thanks fam!🙏🏾😊 you guys are doing great too.
this is the first i happen to find the channel and the video, actually the point is so much neutral, and Willene is really what the freedom is, and how to lead the people's idea to the right path. thanks, Willene.
Glad you enjoyed the video. Welcome on board our channel. I hope you’ll keep enjoying more future videos 🙏🏾😊
China is not perfect, but as you said it is trying to improve! It’s sad to see so many people with racist stereotypes despite all the evidence available. Anyways, I love how you always stress the idea of world peace, because ultimately - that is my dream too! But it’s is sad to see so much conflict between humans whether it is war or politics etc.. It’s hard to stay positive when I people see purposely spreading misinformation or just people being haters without trying to research and educate themselves. World peace may be close to impossible but it’s definitely my dream one day, progress can be possible when we appreciate each others culture and understand at the end of the day.. we are all human🌎❤️
My thoughts, too. Thank you, xmayx.
We have everything written in the middle school textbook 30 years ago in China to explain what freedom is which many westerners have not figured out even now.
You're jolly right about freedoms and more sir.
there are laws in every countries to keep balance in society. No such thing as freedom, there are certain rules you have to abide.
Lol, come Malaysia, you will truly know American freedom got big big issue
Agree with u
I agree with your point of view about freedom.(I'm from Taiwan)
Hello, I know you are speaking for true of what your experienced. However, your comment may ONLY caused U.S. politician who wants to criticize more about China. The worst part is ---- majority American rather believe their politician than someone speak for truth.
I am very glad, brother, that you made a video specifically to continue to explore this issue in depth.😀👍❤🧡💛💚💙💜🤎
Thanks brother! Glad you enjoyed the details of the video. I think many people misunderstand this concept so I just thought I should share my personal experiences for more people to understand that cultures are different. Thanks for your support. 🙏🏾😊💙🎉
@@WilleneBusinessLifestyle ❤💙🙏
自由的定義：以不妨害他人的自由的自由才是真正的自由
現在自由的定義：我愛幹嘛就幹嘛！誰也管不著！
surely, freedom is not in USA !!!
The very fundamental of "Freedom" is Personal Safety, everything else comes after the fact. Without Personal Safety, the fear and stress levels are high, and your "freedom" diminishes significantly.
Appreciate you mate. Vv good ty
Much appreciated! Your support means a lot to me 🙏🏾😊
No doubt Freedom of life is the mother of all freedom n it's in China 🇨🇳
You are confusing safety with freedom
一句话，中国，适合普通人；美国，适合有钱人~
Hello! As someone from China, I truly appreciate your efforts in introducing China to your RUclips audience. To be honest, for many Chinese people, the sound of gunshots might be mistaken for the sound of fireworks or firecrackers cause we may we may have never heard the sound of gunfire actually. Thank you for sharing the rich and diverse aspects of Chinese culture with the world!
Wish the world will be freedome and peaceful in totally! ！
謝謝！
谢谢您. 🙏🏾😊💙
As a Chinese, I don’t want to compare which country is freer or better with the United States. We just strive to become better than ourselves.
Many people who indulge in language attacks and laugh at us say that China is a dictatorship. They flaunt freedom by saying that they can freely criticize their government. What I want to ask is what happens next? Has your situation improved? Has your government really improved after listening to your criticism? Or do you just need a channel to vent your dissatisfaction and don't care about the results?
In China, we have our own channels to contact the government. The mayor’s hotline is a good example. It can effectively and quickly solve various problems in your life. As for higher-level problems, the government will solve them. Because the government has gained our trust. We don't think we can handle it better than the government.
For me, the most dangerous thing about going out at 1am in China is that I may be tempted to buy high-calorie gourmet food, which will cause my body fat to increase. It's so tempting!😮
中国和美国的制度不同，我们各有优劣，让我们互相学习，对抗是解决不了任何问题的！
Amen, brother. But sadly that not going to happened samething with russia and eu the world always fight each other with their own greed and bloodlust for war. That's just not right.
美洲印第安人从几千万降至如今的几十万，新疆人口从几百万升至几千万，人家硬是说我们搞种族灭绝，你跟它讲道理互相学习？你觉得行得通？
Compared freedom China vs US.
It's so easy to answer this.
China freedom from violence.
US freedom for violence.
This the big different between China & US ok.
Easy answers are opium of the Chinese people.
thx 4 ur clarification.I copied some comments on Chinese video sites: We respect the American concept of freedom, and we ask the United States to respect China's concept of freedom. We don't want a drug epidemic, we don't want gun violence, and we don't want labeled groups that cause social division and discrimination. One more thing: we'd better not put too much emphasis on the concept of freedom and forget the purpose of the struggle for freedom.
I’m packing moving to china for more freedom right now lol.
I am escaping US to enter China illegally for freedom.
It's the first time I heard that people from the United States are seeking freedom in China. It seems that China is really getting better and better.
On the point! You are right!
safety is our natural need, just as multiply and live.
This is a good topic for discussion. So many people talk about 'freedom' without realising that they are actually on different notes.
我们需要的是有秩序的自由不是无序的混乱😅
What is freedom? FREEDOM is the will to do what is right and good for others.
Thank you ,man. Africans are rising to show the world that their sense of justice, equality,human rights ,compassion , civility and peace is world class. I have great respect for Africans especially their women folks. Thank you.
The difference is the culture. Americans treasure individual freedom, whilst others treasure collective freedom. It is a me me me culture in America whilst others seek the common good. Remember you can't protect yourself when you only want to protect yourself, it takes everyone who wants to protect everyone else to have safety. To give you an analogy, if I think that everyone is not littering, I should litter to create jobs for the cleaners, then if everyone else think like me, there won't be enough cleaners to clean the streets.
人间清醒～The blogger is a wise man. It's great that I heard such a clear explanation from a foreign population for the first time!
Thank you for the amazing video! To me, it's simply about differences. Both countries are far from perfect, and the world isn't black and white.From the perspective of personal freedom and power distribution, the United States and China hold different views on wealth and authority. In the United States, individual wealth often symbolizes personal freedom, while in China, wealth brings additional responsibilities and regulations. This contrast reflects differing ideologies and practices in social governance, individual rights, and governmental oversight between the two nations.Having lived in both the United States and China for considerable periods, I've firsthand observed the contrasting attitudes towards wealth and its implications. In the United States, affluent individuals enjoy the liberty to pursue their desires without restraint. With increasing wealth comes the realization of the ability to explore desires beyond the confines of ordinary life. However, this disparity in personal freedom can be seen as a form of inequality in human rights, as there are fewer constraints.Conversely, in China, wealth entails a heightened level of caution and responsibility. As one ascends to a certain level of affluence capable of influencing significant matters, they also bear greater accountability. The Chinese government scrutinizes whether individuals are willing to shoulder this responsibility. Furthermore, if exceptionally wealthy individuals in China exceed the boundaries of ordinary rights or societal norms, they face more severe repercussions.This discrepancy prompts many affluent Chinese to choose immigration to the United States, where they perceive fewer constraints on their actions.
that only means u never be in china....
Are you suggesting that I am a liar? The truth is, I was born and raised in China, pursued my undergraduate and graduate studies in the United States, and spent some time working there before returning to China to embark on my entrepreneurial journey. Before responding, please take a moment to read carefully; I did not assert that China is flawless, but rather, I was conveying my personal perspective. In the United States, the privileged class typically comprises the affluent, who undeniably hold significant sway, resulting in numerous injustices. In China, the privileged class is often associated with the Communist Party, which also grapples with issues of corruption and inequity; for instance, the progeny of influential figures often enjoy preferential access to resources. I firmly believe that there is no utopia nor inferno on this earth. The majority of individuals worldwide belong to the non-privileged class, endeavoring to lead meaningful lives, yearning for security, love, and liberty. Before responding, I encourage you to reflect, or at the very least, read my message in its entirety.
或者？你是看不懂英文？需要我给你翻译一下吗兄弟？还是你觉得我会中文也是装的？
误伤误伤 sry@@jinweizeng8650
Wow, thank you for this detailed analysis of both sides. Your unbiased opinion is definitely something everyone needs to understand. I’m glad I can learn from you too 🙏🏾😊
As a Chinese, I basically agree with what the up owner said. China may really be safer. But freedom does not equal security. If it were, North Korea would be safer. It is obvious that North Korea is not free.
Life is very difficult for ordinary people in China. Many people work non-stop throughout the year and can barely maintain food and clothing for their families. But it is extremely difficult to have a quality life, so many people want to immigrate to the United States.
You may want guns to be controlled, but you definitely don’t like “North Korea-style” security and freedom
快走，走线没多少钱，如果你连走线的不够，你的智商不足以去美国，因为生存都困难。快快快，再不走，特朗普上台就收紧非法移民了。
@@whatswhite110个人认为没啥必要争论，每个人都有自己的想法和偏好，比如有的人更加期待美国自由和工作方式，他可以选择移民；同理如果希望更加安全且不是这么在意存在监控和控诉政府的自由，外国人也可以移民中国（尽管当前极少有人可以真正移民中国就是了）
And thats a problem - they think that life is easier on the other side. Its not. Hell, in majority of cases immigration leads to actually lowering standards, as you end up doing job that is below your skill level. And if you had low level job in your county, dont expect to suddenly get better job abroad. You may end up doing better finacially after some time, but you would be doing worse socialy. So unless you migrate from some really bad country, you arent going end up in better place. And China isnt that far when it comes to living standards anymore - unless you live in some rural village. And if you live there, then you know why you doing bad and its not because of country, rural live is equally bad in majority of places, there is a reason why everybody around the world goes to cities.
I believe freedom is not about do whatever you want to do, but refuse to do whatever you don't want to do.
It can be concluded that freedom of expression in Asian countries such as China, Korea, Japan, Indonesia and the Arab world is a basic right that is protected, but still has limitations, namely that it does not violate religious values, morality, order, public interests and the integrity of the state.
在中国很多人会大喊：我要自由。但你要具体问他，想要什么自由？或者国家限制了你什么自由？不让出门？不让喝酒？不让抽烟？不让说话？不让看外国新闻？不让用手机？不让旅游？一条条问下来，你会发现他说不出什么，包括他大喊“我要自由”的权利都没被禁止。很多诉求没被满足，本质是因为欲求不满，比如想让孩子去更好的学校，买更大的房子，赚更多的工资，看更好的医生…但这些愿望要个人努力，且没人禁止他们努力
国内目前最不自由的就是墙，其他的感觉还好吧，外汇那些也是和墙挂钩，有办法弄到，但要比正常渠道付出多得多的代价
@@莫绍东我觉得我挺自由的了，就现在这样我已经很满意了
@@莫绍东如果墙真的限制了我们的自由，那我们也不会在油管聊天了😂
@@莫绍东那我为什么能回复你😢
@@kki1915 vpn除了政府提供的都是违法的，clash的作者都已经进去了，我都不敢用校园网上梯子，毕竟电信想查我还是得麻烦点的，学校管理员一看一个准，我们学校有人翻墙看片直接被通报了🤣
Bonjour frère, bravo pour votre justice👍
Merci beaucoup frérot!🙏🏾😊
谢谢你让更多人了解到真实的中国，Thank you for letting more people understand the real China
truthly world need your help ,everybody will enjoy their freedom finally😘
I am in favor of what PRC can achieve thru their governmental and economic system that really serves the people not the selected few.
True freedom is when there is all freedom to BE LOVE and no freedom at all to be EVIL...!
Worldly freedom in its highest possibility is what comes most near to the above...!
🙏❤❤🙏
TRUE GOD, YOU ARE LOVE - AND WE, WHO WE ARE OUR SOULS, DO LOVE YOU ABOVE ALL AND IN ALL OUR LOVING - FOR WE ARE BORN FROM YOU TO BE WHO WE ARE, BEING LOVE....!
All freedom is superficial or relative freedom. Westerns value more on individual freedom rather than collective freedom (asians). When come to safety, education, happiness, etc, its will come to different matter.
In South Asia country, freedom depend on which caste you are born to. The upper castes definitely have more freedom than the lower caste communities like the Dalits.
The super rich are more free in the US
...than in China.
I think happiness is the standard that can measure whether a society is free, rather than the word freedom itself.
In America they will turn off the camera cause they don't want you to see the truth behind 👌👍😭
安全是自由的根基
Can't agree more, I am chinese, living in Australia for 15 years.
首先一點即，你拿全民自由和政府集權對比就是一個天大的笑話！
舉一個不是特別恰當的例子“你在監獄裡，獄警手裡有槍，允許犯人在他認為合理的情況下做所謂的任何事！犯人沒有權利不做！不做就是錯！獄警就可以採取任何措施進行無限制懲罰！你覺得如果你是那個因為跨出牢房時先邁出左腳而被獄警槍擊的囚犯，你是自由的嗎？”當然，像美國一樣極度自由也是存在很多問題的，正如全世界都知道的槍擊案頻發！可槍擊事件不是自由導致的，而是人，是一個心懷惡意的人導致的！你不能說因為有了自由，所以才有槍擊，恰恰相反，正是因為有自由，所以在受到槍擊的時候，受到侵害的人有能力和權利選擇反擊，而在你所認為自由的國家裡，民眾沒有這種自由裁定權和防衛權，尤其是受到公權力或權貴階層和黑惡勢力侵害時，只能忍氣吞聲默默享受你所謂的自由帶來的結果！
同時，一些自詡在中國所謂生活過一段時間的人，你們不是中國本土人，是享受特權的，只是你們不知道而已！
當然有一說一，如果你們因為受到自由的庇護而認為槍擊案件或者說治安問題是困擾你們感受自由的核心關鍵，那確實中國確實如你們所謂的“自由”！因為武器在中國絕對不允許除了黨以外的任何勢力染指，觸及即死！
對了，你可以了解一下近代的8964事件、文化大革命運動、上山下鄉知青運動等等不勝枚舉，現代的就太多了，只是你們不可能從一個“自由的”國家裡傳播出來，比如唐山打人、鐵鏈女、蘇丹紅、三鹿奶粉、地溝油、疫情期間的政府對人民做出的恐怖行為等等……正如全世界可以通過互聯網聽到你們抱怨美國歷史上的印第安人種族滅絕、黑奴等等不光彩的歷史，而我們的聲音卻在中共建政之後幾乎不太可能被外界聽到，因為我們有屬於你們無法理解的所謂“自由”！政府官員可以上B(X)，民眾不允許否則就是違法！政府官員的資產可以存在你們認為不自由的美國，民眾不允許否則就是違法！政府可以強行拆除你家的房子，但是你不能反抗，否則就是違法！如果遇到了不公平的政府行為，不准上訪(可能你們都不懂這個詞的意思，意思是由於受到當地政府的不公平違法行為，無法投訴起訴只有奢求向更高一級政府部門尋求解決方法)，否則就是違法要被拘役或監控！你們認為不自由的國家可以在網上發表對政府的不滿，可在你們認為自由的國家，這樣就是違法會被公安抓捕拘役判刑！並且你的孩子和親屬也會連帶受到政治審查！
其實我有一個一勞永逸的辦法，能夠解決你們這些受到不自由美國、不自由加拿大、不自由澳洲等國家民眾的困擾！如果你們，以自己身在“不自由”的國家而感到困惑和煩惱，想獲得中國式“自由”以享受餘生，請與我聯繫，我們盡一切可能達成雙方的利益互換！我成為你，生活在你那個“不自由”的國家，而你成為我，沐浴在“自由”的陽光裡，溫馨的提醒你，不是以一個“外國人”的身份，而是一個地地道道的“中國人”或者說“韭菜”的身份。正如中國現在流行的一句話“不要看那個人說什麼，而要看他做什麼！說的再好看，行動總不會騙人！”引申到現在就是“不要看嘴巴說什麼，而要看錢放在哪裡？”為什麼在你們認為自由的中國，官員和富豪們都把資產或公開或隱蔽的偷偷配置到你們深惡痛絕的不自由的美國、加拿大、澳洲、歐洲呢？
I don't intend to translate it into English, because the RUclipsr marked the subtitles in Chinese and English, and even talked about the so-called "freedom" of the CCP. So I will use the freedom I enjoy to express my opinions. you want to know more? you can be translated by yourself!
笑死了。《唐山打人、鐵鏈女、蘇丹紅、三鹿奶粉、地溝油、疫情期間的政府對人民做出的恐怖行為等等》，我能找到台湾也有的类似新闻，甚至更厉害的。你信不信。你居然把这种犯罪问题，当成政治制度的差异。顺便说一句，唐山打人这种在欧美完全上不了台面的事情，居然还是个轰动全国甚至国际的新闻，可见中国治安之好。
另外，《因為武器在中國絕對不允許除了黨以外的任何勢力染指，觸及即死！》中国禁枪是80-90年代才开始的。90年代以前，甚至90年代初，几乎家家户户都是民兵都有枪，甚至8964时，都有一个刘晓波在天安门砸枪的名场面。
不仅是枪，各个单位，工厂，学校还有美国老百姓一辈子也没有的，触及即死的加农炮和坦克车。直到2000年左右中国各个银行还有自己的武装力量。
所谓集权社会害怕老百姓有了武器，改革开放前都不害怕，改革开放20年后突然害怕了。不奇怪吗？
中国禁枪的原因简单明了，80-90年代，社退资进，悍匪频出，治安严重下滑，就和现在的美国一模一样。不得已才禁枪（实际上不是禁枪，是禁武器）。
你的所有论点，不值一驳，味如嚼蜡。
唐山打人也值得说？一个打架斗殴的案子在美国连新闻都上不了。就算以台湾地区来对比，唐山打人案发生的同一时间，台湾地区发生了至少3起类似的恶性案件--也都是深夜小吃店，有人被活活打死，就因为认错人了；有人被枪击致死；有人被打成重伤。可是，那时候两岸媒体全都在热炒唐山打人事件，而同一时间台湾的3起类似案件却一点热度都没有。你知道这是为什么吗？你有没有想过这背后的原因？一个小小的台湾，常住人口比上海还少，却在短时间内如此频繁地发生恶性案件，非常离谱，却得不到关注，你不觉得奇怪吗？
现在移民很贵吗？再不济拿着护照去走线啊，怎么两千块都拿不出来？那你可真失败…
@@yimu1799台灣人幹嘛需要走線？美簽很容易就辦到的事
i m a Chinese.i ve saw so many people said that live in the USA is better than in China.but i don't think so,i think if u want to live in a good place in the USA,u need so much money and power to make sure u can live peacefully.
Freedom benefits most people under one condition, which is rightful limitation.