Best C-Clamp? Let’s Settle This! $4 vs 252, Wilton, Yost, Irwin, Wright Tool, Harden, WEN, Proto

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 дек 2024

Комментарии • 4,4 тыс.

  • @ProjectFarm
    @ProjectFarm  3 месяца назад +2

    Here’s the list of products reviewed. More details in the video description. Thank you!
    Wilton 6 FC: amzn.to/42u8Hpv
    Crescent: amzn.to/3qzs0Aw
    Shop-Tek: amzn.to/45WYaWJ
    Stanley Proto: amzn.to/3NmPtxW
    Wilton (high visibility): amzn.to/42xzOjt
    Bessey F-Style: amzn.to/42w8t1k
    Pony: amzn.to/3MZS5QL
    Performance Tool: amzn.to/3N1NQ7c
    Wright Tool: amzn.to/3X2OFkP
    Yost Tool: amzn.to/3ClTiwN
    Bessey C-Clamp: amzn.to/3CjsX2H
    Groz: amzn.to/3J1fBvp
    Kanka: amzn.to/3X1dGx1
    Lincoln Electric: amzn.to/43PZvNd
    Irwin: amzn.to/3J56ude
    WEN: amzn.to/43ufWzh
    Pittsburgh: Available at Harbor Freight

  • @avlisk
    @avlisk Год назад +841

    I can't believe I just watched 16 minutes of C clamp testing and was thoroughly entertained and informed beyond expectations. Well done, sir.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +42

      Thanks!

    • @bm5298
      @bm5298 Год назад +5

      @@ProjectFarm
      Super happy with the video.
      I just cant believe you havent done a gas trimmer breakdown. there are no good destructive tests on youtube on any of the major bands or the less known. especially to your or torque test channel standard.

    • @jon24444
      @jon24444 Год назад +2

      😂😂😂

    • @ahow8017
      @ahow8017 Год назад +1

      Yes, happy to snappy got a good laugh from me. Thank you.

    • @sonnyD1987
      @sonnyD1987 Год назад

      @@ProjectFarmcan you do a video on pass through ratchets?

  • @realaccount2000
    @realaccount2000 Год назад +416

    Loved the inclusion of an absolute overkill option in the lineup

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +32

      Thanks!

    • @barakobama8194
      @barakobama8194 Год назад +33

      That's an ironworker tool. We used bridge clamps often. I would be 10+ stories on the side of a building standing on one while bolting up.

    • @Qualicabyss
      @Qualicabyss Год назад +23

      Yeah this is like comparing cars and then you pull up a tank

    • @TheSlimCognito
      @TheSlimCognito Год назад +23

      @@Qualicabyss it would be more accurate to say it's a comparison of a Toyota corolla vs a Ford f550. I grew up working on boats and dealing with ship yards and they got clamps way bigger for way more clamping. Every last one of them had square heads and the lightest ones were about 45 pounds and we had some that hit 105 pounds. A 24 inch pipe wrench was the tool of choice to tighten and a 36 inch was the one to loosen them. Never mess with commercial ship yard workers.

    • @Qualicabyss
      @Qualicabyss Год назад +3

      TheSlimCP nah those are like pulling up the bagger 288

  • @narref04
    @narref04 Год назад +442

    You Sir, are what consumer reports should have become in the age of social media. Thank you for all your work and methodical processes!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +22

      Thanks and you are welcome!

    • @larrybe2900
      @larrybe2900 Год назад +6

      CR asks questions and the "results" are the combined responses of those who have been polled. It's been awhile since I was a subscriber.

    • @mixeddrinks8100
      @mixeddrinks8100 Год назад +9

      consumer reports... hate their paywall... so stupid, PF is better. Now if PF only extended out into more product range for EVERYTHING. Perhaps PF will do a compare video of best chips for april 1st.

    • @nmatthew7469
      @nmatthew7469 Год назад +8

      Yes, back in the day CR was the stamp of approval you looked for first.

    • @deejayimm
      @deejayimm Год назад +13

      I lost all trust in consumer reports back when Suzuki sued them over the samurai rollover thing.
      They clearly lied, and they were bragging about it on video.
      It was supposedly because of a bad experience one of the higher-ups had in a big lifted Samurai, which are definitely prone to roll over, but if you see how Jeep was getting their asses kicked in sales, I would not be surprised at all to find out some money changed hands.
      Especially when you find out via the lawsuit that the Wrangler was actually more of a rollover risk by substantial margin.

  • @philgoodinc2
    @philgoodinc2 Год назад +232

    A common thing ive noticed over many tests is Irwin does pretty well in the hand tool category while remaining pretty competitive on price. Ive made a few Irwin purchases over the last few years and haven't let me down (mostly DIY around the house things). Gotta give them props!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +20

      Thanks for the feedback.

    • @Blaquer17
      @Blaquer17 Год назад +15

      I did the same. Nice to know there are good budget friendly options out there.

    • @skoalsoldier
      @skoalsoldier Год назад +24

      Irwin is one of my go-to brands. Not sure if I’d outfit a construction company with it, but for DIY and light duty home use they are hard to beat.

    • @woopimagpie
      @woopimagpie Год назад +3

      Yeah I've been surprised how good they are considering the price they sell for.

    • @Josh-ol7jg
      @Josh-ol7jg Год назад +2

      I was gonna say this...decent performance for a very reasonable price on a lot of their products

  • @DeadShotX-X
    @DeadShotX-X Год назад +915

    What a lineup. That's heavy duty wilton was seriously impressive.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +47

      Thanks for the feedback.

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад +63

      It is stupid expensive but I can think back to a number of times where I could have really used it.

    • @lparsons6977
      @lparsons6977 Год назад +2

      Thanks

    • @ABEW19043
      @ABEW19043 Год назад +33

      I was expecting it to be maybe a little bit better and more just paying for the "heavy duty" tax. I'm happy I was wrong

    • @gordonbeiser5431
      @gordonbeiser5431 Год назад +23

      Sometimes we use that in ironwork to keep chokers from slipping or even just putting that on a beam to have something to rig off of

  • @joemad4110
    @joemad4110 Год назад +247

    Those heavy-duty Wilton's really hold up. I worked for an industrial steel fabrication company, and we used some of those Wilton clamps whenever the beam was over 3 tons. They never broke, twisted, stretched, or needed repair after 10 years of service. Definitely worth the price in that application because we could not afford those beams falling over.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +32

      Thanks for sharing.

    • @nmatthew7469
      @nmatthew7469 Год назад +36

      For $252 it's pathetic really that the US owner of Wilton can't find a way to manufacture it in the USA.

    • @KennyRedSocks
      @KennyRedSocks Год назад +8

      @@nmatthew7469 Wright Tool does.

    • @nmatthew7469
      @nmatthew7469 Год назад +8

      ​@@KennyRedSocks correct but the Wilton is a custom thickness made for bridge building etc.

    • @diditwork370
      @diditwork370 Год назад +31

      Most of the stuff made in America is with foreign processed goods anyway. It's a global economy. Made in doesn't mean what it used to.

  • @AIRDRAC
    @AIRDRAC Год назад +159

    Thanks for including the heavy-duty Wilton! It's great to see underlined just why heavy duty industrial tools can be so much more expensive! That thing is monstrous!

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад +15

      Yeah if you're doing heavy work it's the one to have. In a class all by itself.

    • @HerbaMachina
      @HerbaMachina Год назад +16

      @@1pcfred yeah there's a reason why it's specifically marketed for bridge building and boat building lmao

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад +15

      @@HerbaMachina they're not pushing it in the amateur market. I swear there's times when I could have used one though.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +12

      You are welcome!

    • @nominalvelocity
      @nominalvelocity Год назад +10

      I've got a few old USA made wiltons of various sizes, they are most prized possessions of mine. They don't get used every day, but when there's no substitute they're invaluable

  • @doozer2726
    @doozer2726 Год назад +71

    One of the best channels on RUclips. No filler, just Facts stats and real world tests👍

  • @Brogboolius_Maximus
    @Brogboolius_Maximus Год назад +207

    This is such an unbelievably invaluable channel. The simple fact that you even know what tests to run on these tools (and have the instruments to set up those tests!) is a level of knowledge and experience I don't think I will ever have, but I'll take advantage of the results you share nonetheless. 😀
    Truly amazing work, PF!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +9

      Thank you

    • @eugenetswong
      @eugenetswong Год назад +1

      Ben, I agree. I usually try to guess how he will test them to see if I can think as well as he can, but I never guess which tests he will use. In all fairness to me, I don't a workshop like his, and he has experience with tools, but still.

  • @InstructorRandy
    @InstructorRandy Год назад +271

    Thanks for what you do and not being bought out. It has saved hardworking Americans time, money and kept people safe by letting us choose good products .

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +59

      Thank you! That's my goal! I'll keep going as long as finances allow

    • @konsta0415
      @konsta0415 Год назад +22

      Has saved plenty of money and time of non-americans too

    • @mackaronen
      @mackaronen Год назад +10

      It's impossible to know, but it would be funny to know exactly how much he have saved people, and how many tonnes of broken machines/tools that didn't end up in landfills because people didn't buy them.

    • @MAGGOT_VOMIT
      @MAGGOT_VOMIT Год назад

      I love my "Kant-Twist" brand the best!!! Their design makes them much easier to use than standard C-clamps. Been using them for about 20yrs and wouldn't trade them for anything.

    • @chadclark2070
      @chadclark2070 Год назад +2

      Love this channel

  • @boppins
    @boppins Год назад +273

    That Wilton is a beast, and once again Irwin does amazing for its price point.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +13

      Great point

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад +8

      I can recall a number of times when I needed a beast mode C clamp and just ended up mangling what I had.

    • @Miked1332
      @Miked1332 Год назад +14

      Absolutely. When it comes to clamps of any sort, Irwin is usually the best for the price. Locking pliers, C-clamps, trigger clamps, and so on.

    • @zacharysmith2983
      @zacharysmith2983 Год назад +8

      It really seems like Irwin is one of the best value for money brands out there for hand tools

    • @bluedogtransportwa
      @bluedogtransportwa Год назад +2

      Can confirm this channel is why i have a hole in my leg thanks to an irwin carbide blade

  • @therealjoshtodd
    @therealjoshtodd Год назад +18

    No Todd, WE don't say it enough. You put so much work into these videos. I think I've said this before, but you have the patience of Job! Really appreciate these videos!!

  • @corey6393
    @corey6393 Год назад +68

    Another brilliant test! Well Done.
    A tip for everyone out there that uses C-clamps. A drop of oil in the swivel cup and on the threads will make a big difference on how they work for you. And instead of tediously hand winding the length of the threads, hold the winding handle in your fingers while letting the clamp body hang down. Now swing your hand in a small circle and watch that clamp screw up or down quickly in whichever direction you need. It will take only a few seconds to thread all the way from one end to the other.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +9

      Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks for sharing.

    • @Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co
      @Ea-Nasir_Copper_Co Год назад +2

      You have just made my job a little bit easier. Thank you!

    • @Bandicoot803
      @Bandicoot803 Год назад +2

      Good time-savi g tip! 👍

    • @additudeobx
      @additudeobx Год назад

      My old girlfriend used to use that same technique with her pasties....

    • @corey6393
      @corey6393 Год назад +1

      @@additudeobx That is actually a perfect analogy to describe this move!

  • @RickBaconsAdventures
    @RickBaconsAdventures Год назад +73

    I like when the test rig evolves in the middle of testing, like the wires holding the force sensor up after the first clamp split! Let's take a moment to appreciate how perfect the audio always is on this channel! Noticed some channels lately where some things are too loud then too quiet. It's always perfect with Project Farm!

  • @brandonmckibben1164
    @brandonmckibben1164 Год назад +16

    As a woodworker firstly I'd like to thank you for all your great work over the last few years, secondly I'd love to see some parallel bar clamps or pipe clamps tested if you can. Thank you for the great content!

  • @NoTimeForThatNow
    @NoTimeForThatNow Год назад +121

    That $250 clamp is basically tool porn! I couldn’t justify buying it, but love to see one contender in that kind of category for each test, whenever possible of course.

  • @alexdeleon7135
    @alexdeleon7135 Год назад +77

    The clamping strength of the heavy-duty Wilton is staggering! Then again, so is its price. Great episode today. Thanks for posting.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +3

      Thanks and you are welcome!

    • @fattydaddy4285
      @fattydaddy4285 Год назад +3

      We use those bridge clamps in ironworking field , that Wilton one was a cheap brand. They are beasts!! Can hold the world up with one of those

    • @allanm4848
      @allanm4848 Год назад +1

      Those heavy duty Wiltons are indeed awesome! They make an in-between series which is not as heavy duty or as expensive as the F.C. models but is still much better than their Chinese-made clamps. If you need something heavy duty but not THAT heavy duty check out the Wilton 100 series. I.e. No. 103, 104, 106, 108, etc.

    • @alexdeleon7135
      @alexdeleon7135 Год назад

      @@allanm4848 Thank you for that information!

  • @garagebuiltprojects
    @garagebuiltprojects Год назад +35

    Irwin seems to be the gold standard for quality budget tools. I've watched most of your videos and Irwin almost always does great. Its become my go to brand for random purchases

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +1

      Thanks for the feedback.

    • @agcons
      @agcons Год назад +3

      I've only just started acquiring tools (new home owner) and I needed a couple of larger clamps a while back to glue a wooden chair seat back together. The local hardware store had Irwin clamps on sale half-price, and I picked up two 24-inch trigger clamps.
      No complaints from me at all, and as I need different clamp types and sizes I'll look at Irwin. I'm very unlikely to need a clamp like the Wilton as I've no plans to build a bridge.

    • @LucificNight
      @LucificNight Год назад +3

      Absolutely. I'm glad for the inclusion of the heavy duty Wiltons, but I don't foresee ever needing that level of clamping force & durability.
      The Irwins are more in line with the "occasional handyman" budget and use-case. I don't subscribe to this channel to find the $252 Ultra-Hardcore-Super-MAX C-Clamps, I subscribe to find the $14 value-for-money Irwins.

    • @davec2397
      @davec2397 Год назад +1

      Same here, Irwin always seems to do well considering its lower price point. I certainly go for it over other brands thanks to PF now.

  • @lprocter1982
    @lprocter1982 Год назад +21

    You know you're in for a great test when things go from happy to snappy!
    Have you ever tested oil filter wrenches, both the chain and band types? I bet those would be fun to destructively test!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +5

      lol Thanks for the suggestion.

    • @rm3141593
      @rm3141593 Год назад +1

      Nice!👍. (I also got a chuckle out of happy to snappy)😅

  • @Chamdar17
    @Chamdar17 Год назад +34

    Very impressed by the resilience/ductility of the YOST clamp! Where others snapped or necked, it kept coming back! 2x more than an Irwin but pretty cool feature! I wonder if they all do that or if this one was special. Great video as always!

  • @CMDR_CLASSIFIED
    @CMDR_CLASSIFIED Год назад +61

    Pro Tip: Always lubricate the threads on the screw. This not only makes the clamp easier to use, but allows for more clamping force, and will prevent premature wear caused by the threads galling up.
    Great work as always, Todd! Have a great day, Sir! o7

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +15

      Great point and thank you!

    • @MAGGOT_VOMIT
      @MAGGOT_VOMIT Год назад +3

      Pro Tip?? No way!! Grease and even light-oil will collect dirt and metal shavings. Better to just keep your threads clean.
      I love my "Kant-Twist" brand the best!!! Their design makes them much easier to use than standard C-clamps. Been using them for about 20yrs and wouldn't trade them for anything.

    • @bigj231
      @bigj231 Год назад +4

      A dry wax chain lube is the way to go for a C-clamp lube. Keeps it from picking up chips and grinding dirt, but also helps prevent the threads from galling and binding.

    • @MAGGOT_VOMIT
      @MAGGOT_VOMIT Год назад +2

      @@bigj231 I keep a small bottle of Graphite powder and give 'em lil puff if they're squeaky but nothing more than that.

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад +2

      While what you say is true we can see from this that the failure point is the frames themselves. I've tweaked countless C clamps in my lifetime. Hammered some of them back into shape too. There's nothing more annoying than a clamp where the pads don't line up anymore.

  • @BmhJap
    @BmhJap Год назад +5

    So happy to see something I recommend being tested! You asked, I answered, you delivered. I appreciate all of your videos and have seen them all. Great knowledge to have when I make purchases. You are my reference in that aspect. Keep them coming please!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +1

      Thanks, will do! Thanks for suggestion this video.

  • @FauxRaidenator
    @FauxRaidenator Год назад +7

    I'm continually impressed at how creative and thorough your tests are. Any time I'm looking to buy a new piece of equipment - your channel is one of the first places I look to make sure I get what I need.

  • @MattTrevett
    @MattTrevett Год назад +83

    I like the Yost. If you take out the clamping force at a specified torque then its average score would have been much higher, and it wasn't damaged by the ultimate torque test. Also punches equivalent output to the $60 and $70 clamps at half the cost while still having the second largest opening.

    • @LukeTheJoker
      @LukeTheJoker Год назад +6

      I was thinking the same thing!

    • @haphazard1342
      @haphazard1342 Год назад +19

      It's place in the maximum torque test with the breaker bar also shows that it is a well engineered tool: instead of breaking, the handle bends first acting as a sacrificial part. Coupled with the fact that the clamp did not fail dramatically under the applied loads, this seems like the safest clamp to operate since the risk of fracture from excess clamping force is greatly reduced. And for the price, hard to beat!

    • @Maxire
      @Maxire Год назад +17

      Just the fact that it returned to its original shape and didn't snap or permenantly become bent is incredible to me. That alone is a massive win.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +8

      Thanks for the feedback.

    • @willusher3297
      @willusher3297 Год назад +7

      The clamping force at specified torque is going to be highly dependent on if/what lubricant is used on the threads. As OP notes, the Yost would have performed much higher if you ignored this test, so consider buying the Yost and applying a lubricant to the threads (a moly grease would probably perform very well, but would be messy)

  • @josephpacchetti5997
    @josephpacchetti5997 Год назад +67

    All of your time & effort making these tests possible is very much appreciated, Thanks Todd. 👍🇺🇸

  • @steveasher9239
    @steveasher9239 Год назад +106

    Irwin just seems to keep being right up there in many price vs function tests.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +6

      Thanks for the feedback.

    • @skylined5534
      @skylined5534 Год назад +5

      I was going to say for the price point Irwin is superb. But to be fair Irwin usually exceeds their price point! Rather like Draper of old in the UK and currently Halfords tools.

    • @littlejimmy7402
      @littlejimmy7402 Год назад +7

      @@skylined5534 I've been working on building up my tool collection. I've been trying to keep with great quality tools, even buying from Europe a lot. Irwin makes so many really competitive products at price points that don't make any sense. My hammer drill and sawzall bits are all Irwin.

    • @johnsanko4136
      @johnsanko4136 Год назад +5

      I've used Irwin stuff for a long time. Never been dissatisfied. There's almost certainly better options than Irwin out there, but rarely at the same price point.

    • @dougerrohmer
      @dougerrohmer Год назад +2

      Definitely the go to tool if you are in the middle of the project and don't have time to analyse bang for buck, because you can be sure that you will get a lot of bang for buck.

  • @zcl812
    @zcl812 11 месяцев назад +1

    No, thank you! Your videos go beyond entertainment and are more like a public service. You make it much easier to make informed decisions on very important purchases and it is something that is clearly valuable to so many. We are all very grateful for what you do.

  • @cyphre
    @cyphre Год назад +44

    Great set! Irwin and Yost seem to really deliver on price for performance.
    Maybe sliding clamps next time?

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +5

      Great suggestion! Thank you

    • @MAGGOT_VOMIT
      @MAGGOT_VOMIT Год назад +1

      I love my "Kant-Twist" brand the best!!! Their design makes them much easier to use than standard C-clamps. They'll never "walk" off your work. Been using them for about 20yrs and wouldn't trade them for anything.

    • @goodun2974
      @goodun2974 Год назад +3

      Yup, need reviews of bar clamps and "reach" clamps....

  • @avnut5517
    @avnut5517 Год назад +5

    Nice group of tests. Surprising results.
    I have a few ancient Cincinnati tool clamps from my grandfather that have been indestructible for over 80 years. I still cherish them.

  • @thirdrail9295
    @thirdrail9295 Год назад +5

    This test is extremely helpful. Over the years can’t say how many C clamps I’ve destroyed.

  • @Supaman1212
    @Supaman1212 7 месяцев назад +2

    You don't understand how happy I was when I typed in Best C clamps and Project Farm popped up! 😊😊 Thank you.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  7 месяцев назад

      You are welcome! Glad to hear!

  • @stringsalive20
    @stringsalive20 Год назад +8

    Some great results, and really clever testing - as always! I’m really impressed by the Irwin. When it was time for me to upgrade from cheap no-name clamps, I ended up going with Yost because I’d heard good things, and had good experience with their vises. They’ve been great for me.

  • @jeffjankiewicz5100
    @jeffjankiewicz5100 Год назад +22

    Once again Todd, your tests are amazing. Outstanding work Sir.

  • @moo3993
    @moo3993 Год назад +7

    The amount of stress and anxiety you go through testing these tools at these pressures, I can't imagine! Freaking awesome!

  • @Ride420Dirty
    @Ride420Dirty Год назад +1

    Your exuberance is amazing. I also like how you don't don't talk down or inject any negativity into some of the "Less quality" products. The "Pay once, Cry once." hit hard. As always, thank you for quality testing methods, transparency and most of all, not taking corporate sponsors.

  • @user-pk2fg8im4u
    @user-pk2fg8im4u Год назад +13

    Todd, you always provide useful information, my shop looks a lot different than I might have expected. I'm often surprised, and always better informed. Thank you for all the effort that you put into your videos.

  • @stephenbridges2791
    @stephenbridges2791 Год назад +51

    That Wilton is impressive, without a doubt. One very serious clamp.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +1

      Thanks for sharing!

    • @additudeobx
      @additudeobx Год назад +3

      Yea, everyone needs one in their tool box ... ya know, just in case 😀😀

    • @joshsafar5556
      @joshsafar5556 Год назад

      Ball joints lol

  • @ydna
    @ydna Год назад +11

    awesome tests! good to remember that the tools aren't really intended to be stressed like mad, but seeing the durability really shows the build quality. good to have a variety of sizes for that reason!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks! Thanks for the feedback.

  • @willusher3297
    @willusher3297 Год назад +22

    The clamping force at specified torque is going to be highly dependent on if/what lubricant is used on the threads. As @MattTrevett notes, the Yost would have performed much higher if you ignored this test, so consider buying the Yost and applying a lubricant to the threads (a moly grease would probably perform very well, but would be messy)

    • @lolbuster01
      @lolbuster01 Год назад +5

      Very true, but many consumers will attempt to use them out of the box, so I think this is a better "regular person" test.

    • @willusher3297
      @willusher3297 Год назад

      @@lolbuster01 true - I've only lubercated the ones I was going to put a high load on.

    • @cliffords.8341
      @cliffords.8341 Год назад +1

      @willusher3297 Never seize works very well too, but is even messier. Very difficult to clean off your skin.

    • @Blazer-fp8fo
      @Blazer-fp8fo Год назад +3

      @@cliffords.8341 Orange GOOP Ruff Towels. Takes anti seize right off. Since finding that out I keep them in my shop at all times.

    • @mauritsvw
      @mauritsvw Год назад +1

      A less messy lubricant would maybe be some graphite powder.

  • @watchingdanny
    @watchingdanny Год назад +8

    Forget UL ratings or CE approved... Before buying things I check to see if they're PF tested. Great video as always. Excellent work.

    • @skylined5534
      @skylined5534 Год назад

      Yes sir! This is why I own a chunk of Irwin stuff and I have not been disappointed!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks and you are welcome!

  • @chinesemassproduction
    @chinesemassproduction Год назад +20

    The Yost holding up to the destruction test was the most impressive in my opinion. Probably going to go with that one. Thanks.

  • @rickmcdonald1557
    @rickmcdonald1557 Год назад +8

    As you would say="Very impressive"!! As I have owned my "C" Clamps for over 30 yrs. I had no idea they were this expensive now days and will be sure to value them much more from now on. Your tests are getting better and better all the time and you are quite a Star on You Tube and I see you are right at THREE MILLION SUBSCRIBERS~!!
    You couldn't be more deserving and thanks for being YOU~!!!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +1

      Thank you very much!

    • @tubastuff
      @tubastuff Год назад

      My old Craftsman C clamps are going on 50 years. Still work like new.

  • @louisrichards3702
    @louisrichards3702 Год назад +2

    i have used those bridge clamps in a fabrication shop,, we clamp 2- 1 inch steel plates,6ft X 10ft together ,then drill a bunch of holes through both plates ,so they are exactly the same.with.a half dozen of these bridge clamps ,,,all look like they are at least 50 years old and they still work great...Constuction workers use these bridge clamps to hold and support things while they are working on them ,.thats why you pay 250$ a clamp.when you absolutely CANNOT have failure or movement,as someones life IS depending on it. its great to see this 25 ton bridge clamp in the test to show people what a real HD C clamp is ..

  • @Druid_Plow
    @Druid_Plow Год назад +7

    That Wilton showed exactly what it's built for.
    Sure at 50 in/lb it was just on par with everyone else, but its raw strength is why it's truly industrial.
    As for a daily driver, I think my Pittsburgh clamps are plenty capable for my uses. I did like the WEN and Irwin as well.
    Would like to see a similar video for smaller clamps, like 2-4", or larger F clamps and bar clamps like 2-4' long.

  • @Manu__R
    @Manu__R Год назад +4

    I'm a welder, and we use the Wilton (the lighter one) clamps at work - except ours aren't neon green 😄. Very tough clamps, and when they do fail, it's exactly as your tests showed - the screw bends. We abuse our clamps though, I'll clamp it onto a steel beam that weighs over a ton, wrap a chain around the clamp and something heavy, and drive off to get the beam off the truck 😂.
    It's cool to see that these clamps can put down thousands of pound of force, kind of crazy what a little mechanical advantage can do.

  • @woopimagpie
    @woopimagpie Год назад +6

    I got a couple of those Irwin clamps in a set of Irwin tools in a groovy carry bag when it was on special a while back. Pretty happy with their performance considering how cheap they were, I'm even happier now seeing how they outperformed many more expensive brands. Factoring in the cost of the whole set I think they cost about 7 bucks each. Can't complain about that.

  • @jesscneal
    @jesscneal Год назад +11

    Looked like the Groz was right in there for the price too. You're the best Todd. Thank you for all your hard work. The only channel I support on Patreon :)

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks and you are welcome! Thanks so much for being a Patreon supporter!

  • @mookietkm3624
    @mookietkm3624 Год назад +4

    I like how the Irwin and Yost performed. I will go with the Irwin for lighter projects and use the Yost for any heavier ones.

  • @dogsbyfire
    @dogsbyfire Год назад

    We all know the engineering behind these tests is excellent, but let’s not forget the script writing and production value. I just flew cross country twice in a week, and I saw a lot of Hollywood movies. Not a single one kept the storyline moving along like Project Farm does over and over. He tells a 16-minute story in 16 minutes, not 60. Thank you!

  • @BL-yj2wp
    @BL-yj2wp Год назад +86

    "Performance tool" never fails to disappoint.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +4

      Thanks for the feedback.

    • @afellowinnewengland6142
      @afellowinnewengland6142 Год назад +4

      It’s comical at this point. Whatever the comparison they always seem to come in last or nearly last. I don’t know who runs the company but they must have some serious contempt for their customers.

    • @crash5811
      @crash5811 Год назад +2

      I have a few Performance Tool sockets in my box at work. Mostly the very short allens and some cheap cheap "precision" screwdrivers... but theyve all handled my abuse decently well...

  • @BurntToast1717
    @BurntToast1717 Год назад +16

    You should do a video on shoelaces for workboots. Might be interesting to see which ones wear the quickest

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +3

      Thank you for the video idea!

    • @WalterMelons
      @WalterMelons Год назад +2

      @Project Farm If you do, make sure to add ironlaces to the list of ones to try. They sell them at Nicks boots.

    • @hazardweldz
      @hazardweldz Год назад +2

      Do this please! Cuz as a welder I'm buying laces once a month!

    • @lunchboxproductions1183
      @lunchboxproductions1183 Год назад

      ​@@ProjectFarmMake sure to add a long term eyelet wear test. The more durable laces can wear them really fast.

    • @WalterMelons
      @WalterMelons Год назад

      @@hazardweldz should get some wellies then. Thorogood has a nice pair I wear daily.

  • @averykeeling1167
    @averykeeling1167 Год назад +10

    I would love to see this with other types of clamps too especially pipe clamps

  • @johnme7049
    @johnme7049 Год назад +1

    OK, I admit to being a bit jealous. You get to have SO much fun breaking things! Keep up the good work that you do, you are so helpful to so many showing the strongest and the best value. For the average guy the Irwin is Hard to beat! Thank you and be safe.

  • @Nocare89
    @Nocare89 Год назад +7

    I am always impressed by the level of creativity that goes into these tests your perform.

  • @randysavage8963
    @randysavage8963 Год назад +4

    Happy Sunday Todd ! Thank you for what I know will be another fantastic test and video

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +4

      You're a legend!! Thank you Randy Savage!

    • @randysavage8963
      @randysavage8963 Год назад +1

      @@ProjectFarm YOUR WELCOME TODD

  • @treboris
    @treboris Год назад +9

    Recently subscribed to the channel. I really appreciate the effort you put into designing tests that not only provide scientifically measurable results, but are also easy to understand and visually appealing to watch.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks! Thanks for watching and subscribing!

  • @Jpres
    @Jpres Год назад +2

    I don't even need any new C clamps I just love watching Project Farm's tool comparisons.

  • @CreepSoldier
    @CreepSoldier Год назад +12

    Now you need to do one for Trigger Clamps

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +1

      I'll do it if there's enough interest. Thank you

  • @Nuke8401DaveE
    @Nuke8401DaveE Год назад +3

    Great video! As much as finding the Big Dog, your testing and unbiased opinion on the best value for most of us means the most to me in all of your tests.

  • @johnmcclane4430
    @johnmcclane4430 Год назад +6

    It’s a shame that you’re from the US. Your videos are so good and broad in scope that I wish we had someone test European brand stuff in the same way.
    Keep up the good work, all your videos have been very informative.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thank you!

    • @tomk3732
      @tomk3732 Год назад

      I think he is Canadian. From Prarie provinces.

    • @gavinmclaren9416
      @gavinmclaren9416 Год назад

      ​@tomk3732 There is no Harbor Freight in Canada. We have Princess Auto, which is similar but not quite as broad ranged as HF. For this and other reasons, I'm pretty sure Todd is not Canadian. Not that it matters even a little. The sound engineering principles that he uses are valid everywhere.

  • @T.C.-st8uz
    @T.C.-st8uz 7 месяцев назад

    Glad to see that Irwin did so well. I teach woodworking and have used primarily Irwin and Bessey clamps for about 17 years. The rubberized handles on the Irwin bar clamps do start to gum up / deteriorate after 5 to 7 years of use. Otherwise, I've been very pleased.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  7 месяцев назад

      Thanks for the feedback.

  • @shanesmith6242
    @shanesmith6242 Год назад +6

    Great info as always. A really interesting video I'd like to see is a showdown on octane boosters!!!

  • @ronkemperful
    @ronkemperful Год назад +4

    I bought a very generic C-clamp many years ago that claimed it was made with a drop forge. After using it I suspect that yes, the forge was indeed dropped during manufacture, maybe in an earthquake!

  • @mattwaier1243
    @mattwaier1243 Год назад +5

    A similar test with F style clamps would be interesting too! Great evaluation as always

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.

  • @jozjonlin3170
    @jozjonlin3170 Год назад

    I think my favorite thing is the many ways you've figured out how to measure and test nearly every aspect of the items you've chosen to torture. Bravo sir!

  • @ChessIsJustAGame
    @ChessIsJustAGame Год назад +4

    I made a mistake and bought an assortment of clamps made in China and all but one has broken. The one that hasn't broken hasn't been used. I just tossed it. Spent a bit more money to buy a couple of clamps that fit the need at the time, still have them. That was about 20 years ago. Bought at a real HW store.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Great point!

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад

      Whenever I see C clamps being sold used and they're a good price I usually pick them up. Because when you need a C clamp it's handy to have a C clamp.

  • @JonDeth
    @JonDeth Год назад +9

    *I am not surprised but I'm still unnerved by the cost of manufacturing the 252.* Because these are primarily iron or an iron alloy, you know they aren't expensive to manufacture compared to that selling price, but if you are working on tractors, land moving equipment etc., you will absolutely need it.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Great point!

    • @Maplenr
      @Maplenr Год назад +3

      Definitely an 'economy of scale' cost. They make hundreds of thousands of the smaller ones annually. They might make 3k of those big bastards annually; Even that would be impressive numbers considering that thing is effectively impossible to break lol. Such a fun video

    • @JonDeth
      @JonDeth Год назад +2

      @@Maplenr you are absolutely correct. A detail I generally don't overlook too! *The cost for that small production run requires changing tooling and surely adjustments to the crucible being used if not changed entirely.*
      At the end of the day though, I am confident many of us could and would just build an industrial grade clamp. *A laminate of plates would most likely crush that 252's performance.*
      I never go beyond an SUV though, and majority of my work these days is on my 250cc Raptor-clone.

    • @riotrob
      @riotrob Год назад +6

      I’d imagine that every 252 is receiving additional quality inspections and testing, while not a single Irwin is.

    • @JonDeth
      @JonDeth Год назад +1

      @@riotrob so will I but when you see how these machines are tested, it's never something so brutal as most will imagine.
      My formal background is particle physics *and engineering,* so when we design these devices, the test equipment etc., it's still a very instant process that isn't adding significant costs once the test equipment has been built or purchased.
      For every $10,000 piece of equipment in any industry out there, it is still often a horrifying revelation when you find out the true costs.

  • @pavelkolp
    @pavelkolp Год назад +8

    Another great production as always 👍🏻

    • @JSFGuy
      @JSFGuy Год назад

      One you haven't even watched yet?

    • @spyrosbellos2522
      @spyrosbellos2522 Год назад +2

      Bro this is 16 min and it came out 4 minutes ago

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +4

      Thank you

    • @JSFGuy
      @JSFGuy Год назад

      @@spyrosbellos2522 .....🦗....🎵....🎶

  • @dustinf11
    @dustinf11 Год назад

    I love when this channel shows and verifies the quality of tools I use daily. I have drawers full or Irwin clamps. More than enough for simple wood working.
    Great channel, quality content.

  • @madjdfgplayz9734
    @madjdfgplayz9734 Год назад +8

    You should make a video on portable phone chargers! Solar and non solar chargers to see how they perform!

  • @JamesFNomar
    @JamesFNomar Год назад +6

    Keep it up man! You’ve got the best channel on RUclips.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      I appreciate that!

    • @chubbyjohnson5480
      @chubbyjohnson5480 Год назад

      I certainly agree with that

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад

      Todd's content is in the must watch category that's for sure. We need more cousin Eddy though.

  • @PilotDamian
    @PilotDamian Год назад +3

    Two words for your videos Todd: very impressive!! Once again wonderful video!!

  • @acappellahymns
    @acappellahymns Год назад

    So glad to see Wright Tool on there. They did not disappoint!

  • @Wildland_Firefighter
    @Wildland_Firefighter Год назад +4

    Hope all is well, bud. Thanks for these videos! It'll be interesting to see you do a hydraulic ram kit test.

  • @fatthumbs2020
    @fatthumbs2020 Год назад +5

    Great one!

  • @golnectr
    @golnectr Год назад +7

    Irwin. Never the best, but always the best value.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Great point on value!

    • @1pcfred
      @1pcfred Год назад

      I can relate to that. I'm never the best either.

    • @ljprep6250
      @ljprep6250 Год назад

      You misspelled Pittsburgh. LOL

  • @aisforannihilation1662
    @aisforannihilation1662 Год назад +1

    Tbis reminds me to see if I still have a C clamp these days. If I don't, at least I know which 1's r better than others thanks to u!
    Still hoping for that pellet/BB gun comparison to help me find a good 1 for my old man with diminishing eyesight & ease of use (co2 or gas over pump or manual cocking). Not having a lot of luck without prices I could buy a real gun for😂

  • @charliesullivan4304
    @charliesullivan4304 Год назад +9

    Is a test of F-clamps next? I prefer them almost always.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +8

      I'd really like to compare F-clamps, if there's enough interest from viewers on this review

    • @Outlaw653
      @Outlaw653 Год назад +4

      I’d like to see an F-clamp video also.

  • @I_SuperHiro_I
    @I_SuperHiro_I Год назад +8

    Been holding off on new C Clamps because I wasn’t sure which was best. Now I am!

  • @docthompson1
    @docthompson1 Год назад +4

    You know you have to do the best ball joint press next 😊

  • @mo3ath21621
    @mo3ath21621 Год назад +1

    Thanks

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks for supporting the channel! I really appreciate it!

  • @RKarwecki77
    @RKarwecki77 Год назад +3

    Wilton? more like WOW-ton!

  • @NotSoGoodGamer18
    @NotSoGoodGamer18 Год назад +6

    There has to be an “Approved by Project Farm” sticker on all the good products you test. Maybe even with a “very impressive” quote aswell

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +1

      That would be great!!

    • @tiagoferreira086
      @tiagoferreira086 Год назад

      Definitely PF should become an certified quality control authority, if he can make this level of testing by himself alone in a his humble workshop, imagine if he had a good team help him with a proper lab, calibrated instrumentation, and a way bigger budget for test rigs and instrumentation.

  • @stansbornak8116
    @stansbornak8116 Год назад +12

    Now that we've settled this.....let's move on to World Peace!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад +3

      lol. That indeed is a much bigger challenge

    • @ShugoAWay
      @ShugoAWay Год назад +1

      ​@Project Farm i can see the review now "and the US made it to 3.38 seconds before picking a fight and moves into 2nd to last place, now for our next test..."

  • @MichaelGreene-y7p
    @MichaelGreene-y7p Год назад +1

    Thanks!

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      Thanks for supporting the channel! I really appreciate it!

  • @genjitsu7448
    @genjitsu7448 Год назад +1

    OK - I have to admit, I did not know how you were going to test C clamps but these tests made some good sense! Nicely done like usual.

  • @d.ricc6421
    @d.ricc6421 Год назад

    This guy is unbelievable. Can he test all of our senators to see how many knuckle heads are hiding in plainview. Love your vids. You cover 110 % of testing without loop holes, ty sir.

  • @1947froggy
    @1947froggy Год назад

    Hi Todd, I destroyed 2 Pittsburg clamps yesterday working on brake calipers. One bent and the other cracked thru. Shopping for an Irwin now. You rock.

  • @lucascady4992
    @lucascady4992 Год назад

    Every tool has it's place.. If you're holding wood or your wife's DIY project, use a $5 C-clamp, I used to run a boring mill and would use 1 Machinest clamp to pick up a 1000lb plate of steel without concern.. As with everything, you get what you pay for, and you got to have the right tool for the job.. Great Video as always 👍

  • @oKeNSchWarZo
    @oKeNSchWarZo Год назад +1

    I would like to point out I've gone through a few of these in my field of work, and one thing I can attest to with frequent heavy use, that if the threaded bolt in these clamps do not have a black coating on them, the threads WILL wear TREMENDOUSLY quicker. This alone should help get you a half decent one even with all the other down sides. Also avoiding anything made in china helps too. The thorough testing was fantastic though! You are doing gods work =).

  • @avedesco
    @avedesco Год назад

    I watched this with my dad in mind. He's mid 60's, does metalwork (nothing huge) and honestly I think the Yost is the best clamp for someone like him. Reasonably affordable for a quality tool, and easy to tighten, reposition, and has good reach.

  • @sneakitiki9767
    @sneakitiki9767 Год назад

    Your videos are very helpful and always full of unbiased testing. I do have some reservations about the clamp force test…
    The clamp crank arms were different lengths, so a constant of 50LB on the torque wrench would lose its “constant” quality when not at the same lever distance from the screw. Additionally, it appeared that the sleeve you had set up to go over the crank, when attaching your wrench set up, was used at full depth on some but only partial depth on others. This would suggest that the 50LB “click” may not be delivering the same torque to each of the different screws. Test…Imagine if one of the screw crank arms was 4 feet long, you could get some serious leverage on that crank before your torque wrench ever knew about it. So if length (lever) matters, it must be exactly the same for each test.

  • @gregparrott
    @gregparrott Год назад +1

    Great test! I have one 'quality' C clamp, and the difference between it and the rest is dramatic
    The bulk of clamps I have that are mediocre, and most of them are from Harbor Freight
    Irwin has done well on a multiple of different product that you've tested. So that's what I'll buy next.

  • @TheWtfnonamez
    @TheWtfnonamez Год назад

    Great video
    The irony of course is that most people have a huge range of clamps because they start out buying cheap ones, and then progressively buy more expensive ones as they get more frustrated.
    Also using lots of smaller clamps adds up to the same compression force of one really big one.
    Thank you for what you do. Glad my investment in Irwin clamps seems vindicated lol

  • @RTC_SA
    @RTC_SA Год назад +1

    i have an idea which will help a lot of people, 1- car radiator additives ( the ones that claims to make it cooler) 2- car ac additives leak stop or cooling additives (cool shot, supercool etc,,,).

  • @stanwooddave9758
    @stanwooddave9758 Год назад +1

    Once again I thought this was going to be a bad video, and was simply amazed at how informative this video was. As a welder, metal fabricator I use the "Besty-"F" Clamps in all different sizes from little 3 inch up to 24 inch capable. I have no way of knowing, but if I were to make a guess at my average overall clamping force needed, I what guess somewhere @ 150 pounds or less. This is in no way a scientific number, just a "SWAG-Guess!!!" What does SWAG mean? Scientific Wild A$$ Guess. Thank you for making these video's, you continue to be the bench mark for fair ness in testing. God Bless, and stay safe, we need you. No Saber Tooth Tigers were hurt or injured during the making of this video. Wink, wink, Does RUclips know you keep Saber Tooth Tigers in your shop, against their will. Where's PETA when you need them. When are you going to demonstrate water skiing with your Pterodactyl you keep in the shop basement, people would love to see that.

  • @AdamFazari2004
    @AdamFazari2004 5 месяцев назад

    As soon as I saw this video and saw the $252 Wilton 6FC clamp I was like "This is where the fun begins". The Wilton 6-FC clamp is just pure insanity. This is more proof that Project Farm is the real MVP when it comes to power tool videos. Makes me wish he tests more overkill and heavy duty tools. 👍💯

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  5 месяцев назад

      Thanks! Thanks for the suggestion.

  • @NHHalKnowsHow
    @NHHalKnowsHow Год назад

    I really love how you can tell these items are "Farm Tested" with the non-professional fixtures but as with most other farm fixes, they get the job done!

  • @beerdrinker6452
    @beerdrinker6452 Год назад +1

    You are a real scientist. Thank you.

    • @ProjectFarm
      @ProjectFarm  Год назад

      You are welcome!

    • @beerdrinker6452
      @beerdrinker6452 Год назад

      With so many subscribers how do you manage to always provide a two word reply when most posters with one third of the subscribers never reply?