1.처음에 현주를 싫어하고 괴롭혓던건 에이프릴 전멤버 전소민임 2.채원이 소민과 친해지려고 현주를 이간질함(현주가 하지않은 말을 전함) 3.현주가 할머니한테 받은 텀블러를 숙소에 두엇는데 회사 냉장고에서 발견. 알고보니 나은이 말도 없이 청국장을 넣어둠 그리고 사과도 없이 몇개월 방치함. 4.나은이 현주 운동화 훔쳐가고 자기가 신을거라고 우겻는데,현주가 자기 신발에 적어놓은 이름보여주니까 그냥 가져가라면서 사과안함. 5.방송에서 카메라 돌아가기전 센터인 현주에게 "이년 또 지만 얼굴 작아보이려고 뒤로간다"라며 멤버들이 꼽줌. 6.그외,예나 진솔은 계속 비꼬면서 놀리고 발걸고 발을 밟으면서 괴롭힘. 7.김채원은 당시 매니저와 연애중이엿음.그래서 매니저도 왕따 사실을 알면서 묵인함. 8.현주 자살시도이후 ,회사에서 멤버들이 반성중이라고 해서 현주와 어머니가 회사에 찾아감. 멤버들 마주쳣는데 자기들끼리 웃으면서 무시함. 에이프릴 현주의 친구분이 쓰신거 널리 퍼뜨립니다 이나은도 문제지만 제일막내고 당시 16살이엿던 진솔이 현주가 말하는데 조용히하고 무시하는등 괴롭힘이 많앗음.
Kalian sadar gasi slama vdeo ini dia ga ada ngomong sndri gtu depan kamera, kya pegang kameranya gitu kya member lain.. Ga bnyak di sorot juga di kamera kya member lain, kadang posisi nya paling blakang, gada yg ngajak ngomong..klopun ngomong kya yg di cuekin gtu, atau di tanggepinnya kya yg males sinis gtu, Kasian bgt sumpah..jahat bgt inisi..keliatan bgt dia di kucilin nya.. Kuat bgt dia masih brusaha buat ceria, pdhl kliatan juga dia keq ga nyaman. Jahat bgt mereka astaga.
솔직히 나보단 모두 이쁘겠지만 현주가 진짜 제일 이쁘다... 이 왕따 사실을 알고 보니까 더 소름이다...... 현주에겐 카메라 거의 한번도 안 비춰주고..... 현주 지금 눈치 보면서 아무말도 못하자나ㅠㅠㅠ 아니 애초에 그렇게 왕따를 해도 카메라 앞에서는 명랑한 척하고....... 맴버들 진짜 소름이다..... 나 진짜 이나음 되게 좋아했었는데 충격이다.....
Basically April is jealous of Hyunjoo's visual. After Hyunjoo left, Naeun claim the title "visual of the group". If Hyunjoo is still there Naeun probably is nothing. Some people said Naeun's father owned share in DSP that's why she are popular & has a lot of job.
@MARTLA ILYNWe don't care how she looks. We just care about the bullying culture. Do a plastic surgery surely can fix an ugly face but can never fix the person attitude.
I watched a few videos about April... and the worst one was Jinsol, she is so rude. But I guess girl with mole on nose is one who tried to hear Hyunjooo
I heard from Korean netizens Chaewon just wanted to bring conflict. so he sometimes approached hyunjoo, sometimes approached other members just bring conflict for hyunjoo with other member
에이프릴이간다에서도 현주 절뚝 거리면서 걷는데 아무도 안도와주고 심지어 밖에서 고기 먹을때 다리도 절뚝 거리는 상태로 짐 많이 들고 오는데 도와주는 애 없고 나은이 뒤돌아보다가 짐 들어주려고 도와주는줄 알았는데 현주인거 알게되고 안도와주고 자리 피하는 장면도 있는데 너무 슬픕니다 ㅠ
YES ME TOO! But I think is cuz jinsol & chaewon are closer so naturally they will reply to each other more I guess. Then hyunjoo just replies when they ask her things & stuff like that
Your comment was from 5 years ago... How do you feel today when you know she was really bullied/leftout by the other members back then? I hope you are still supporting Hyunjoo
@@cosmicspeachy damn I just read the article now. I'm so shocked. I'm still supporting April and Hyunjoo but this was hell of a mess. If this issue turns out to be true idk what to feel. I really felt bad for Hyunjoo back at that time when she was still in the group. 😥💔
so apparently the first one that bullied hyunjoo is somin, a former member of April that left and join KARD omg thats why April and KARD is underrated. somin you better left the industry
@@farihahmohd if anything, it looked like Jinsol and Somin were having an inside joke. But these are all assumptions. With the way it was edited, you won't fully know until you have seen the rest of the context or clip to understand what the scene was about. These videos are really making people work their deduction skills.
은근히 따돌리는데 느껴지는데 아무렇지 않은척 하는게 얼마나 고통스러운데. 뇌가덜자란 비정상들 속에서 혼자 힘들었겠다 정말ㅜㅜ현주야 저들은 지금부터 나락으로 떨어질일만 남았어 그동안 힘들었던 기억을 다 잊을순 없겠지만 너를 이해하는 사람들이 많다는걸 꼭 기억해줘 현주 화이팅
If this is true, isolation is a type of social bullying where you and a gang of people purposely isolate or ignore your targeted victim. This type of bullying can't be seen physically but can affect mental health seriously. I hate social bullying as I was also a victim in the past. I didn’t do anything...like why they do that to me...🥲 I still remember it and it effect me a lot..
Exactly! This is exactly what happened to my little sister, she was bullied like this from her old “best friend” for some reason we don’t know, she manipulated their two other friends and ignore my little sister in everything! As an older sister I can’t help but get so angry when I see my little sister running after them because she wanted to talk to them and hang out with them so bad! I’m so disgusted at April members especially the one who first started to bully Hyunjoo
@@peonies6385 I don't know what made them start bullying me either. It could be that they thought I was an easy target.. idk.. it's really saddening. I hope your sister is alright and that she has better friends now. She didn't deserve that.
Yeah, but we must strong 🦾♥️ don’t give up and feel depress, i just think karma will hit them soon and successful will come to us if we strong and be patient God will help kind people
Bahkan 5 tahun lalu udah ada fans yg notice kalau hyunjoo terus menerus di perlakukan tersisih atau sendirian. Tdi liat di video eps 2 klo gak salah yg ber 3 an ke itaewon.. jelii skali itu fans.. 5 tahun kemudian bru terkuak ke permukaan hyunjoo kuaat sekalii kamu 😢
@움치치 미운 놈은 숨 쉬는 것만 봐도 꼴뵈기 싫다니 과민반응이라면 과민반응이긴 한데... ㅋㅋ 평소 행실에서 집안 수준이 보인다고 여러사람이 먹으라고 시식대에 음식 담겨있는걸 즈그집 자취방마냥 더럽게 손으로 툭툭 집어다 먹어대는 꼬라지가 가정교육 수준이 높아 보이지는 않는 것도 팩트지 ㅇㅇ...
YES FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT. I have experienced the same thing from my "friends" and even my own relatives. It hurts like a bitch. The moment when u are there wanting to hang out with them but they dont say A SINGLE WORD to push u away but the fact that they are ignoring you is loud n clear babe. There are people who dont understand which i guess meant they are the ones who usually ostracise a single person out of their so called friend group🤷🏽♀️
Probably because they ignore her , talk over her, they leave her by herself, etc. I had friends like them. I thought they were my friends turns out I was the person they were bullying.
at 1:54 you can see jinsol said something to somin about hyunjoo who is standing right in front of her and when hyunjoo turns around to look, jinsol looks the other way. jinsol is just human trash. how dare you treat your unnie like this???
Why had only Hyunjoo carried her bag while others were carrying nothing when they were playing? Did they even ask her to carry their stuff Poor Hyunjoo was alone and upset during the whole trip.
3:57 i’m not trying to said chaewon is rude, but if i was on hyunjoo’s side, it will hurt so much:” like...should she really say that infront of hyunjoo?
semua member kek berlomba2 pengen jadi center dan selalu disorot njirr. the real caper sihh trs kek kelakuan norak bangett ngomong dan ekspresinya bener2 ga disaring apa
Why i think she look so lonely and uncomfortable but pretend to be happy with other girls, when the other girls not even try to look and talk with she T.T In the last vidio, Look like every member get a thing. Only hyunjoo hand is empty poor girl, she deserve better, you can see she working hard in a program that call ( the unit)
She was really trying her best to get along with them. They treated her like crap. I've had the same thing happen to me. You just feel like 💩. It's not ok to treat others like that.
somin... as the oldest you could've said something, you could've told the members to cut it out. as the leader you should've helped hyunjoo. you deserve to lose everything you have just like the rest.
@@shamsom i know :( i wrote that comment bc everyone else seems to be focusing on naeun only but ALL OF THEM should've held accountable for what they did to that poor girl. someone who enjoys making others miserable can never be truly happy, she'll need more therapy than hyunjoo to heal her shitty soul.
It's so weird though. The dynamics in this group was way off. It seems like somin started this all. Her bestie was Jinsol. Naeun kinda seems to be an outcast at times or is trying to fit in so she helps them and sucks up to somin. Chaewon is kinda odd. At times she seems to feel bad so she does something nice for hyunjoo .she's most likely a bystander who doesn't say stop. So they all participated in the bullying I'd say one way or the other. They definitely had a clique in the group. A lot of them suvked up to jinsol and somin. I'm assuming they didn't get bullied too in a way but not as obvious as hyunjoo. I bet it's in form of backhanded compliments, jokes etc. In another video where they are bungee jumping you can see Naeun glare at Somin's back while she's talking to the camera. Naeyn even looked her up and down.
@@Tearsofblood25 jinsol wasn't even 15 when this happened.... what a cursed child, how can you bully someone, see how much what you're doing is affecting them and CONTINUE to bully them without feeling like a monster? she probably has no empathy at all, it's disgusting. idk about the clique or if there was some sort of hierarchy within the group but it wouldn't surprise me. I hope they know their careers are over and I also hope no one lets them forget what they've done. Hyunjoo could've taken her life because of them, this should follow them for the rest of their lives.
@@Tearsofblood25 i think chaewon was as bad as the other not just a bystander U can see when hyunjoo shaked chaewon’s little brother, her eyes looked so pissed and said” dont give ur hand easily” like whattt??
![[Episode] APRIL(에이프릴)'s ON AIR PRIL(온에어프릴) Ep.32](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z0XWE4qhhuU/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Episode] APRIL(에이프릴)'s ON AIR PRIL(온에어프릴) Ep.32](/img/tr.png)
![[Reality] 에이프릴이 간다 제10화(Here Goes April Ep.10)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Haf-zbCsHV4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[#가수모음zip] 에이프릴 모음zip (April Stage Compilation) | KBS 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/B8DBDP8zmac/mqdefault.jpg)
에이프릴은 매니저부터 잘못됐네
소속사들도 똑같은 새끼들임
7:22 둘이 친한데?
1.처음에 현주를 싫어하고 괴롭혓던건 에이프릴 전멤버 전소민임
2.채원이 소민과 친해지려고 현주를 이간질함(현주가 하지않은 말을 전함)
3.현주가 할머니한테 받은 텀블러를 숙소에 두엇는데 회사 냉장고에서 발견. 알고보니 나은이 말도 없이 청국장을 넣어둠 그리고 사과도 없이 몇개월 방치함.
4.나은이 현주 운동화 훔쳐가고 자기가 신을거라고 우겻는데,현주가 자기 신발에 적어놓은 이름보여주니까 그냥 가져가라면서 사과안함.
5.방송에서 카메라 돌아가기전 센터인 현주에게 "이년 또 지만 얼굴 작아보이려고 뒤로간다"라며 멤버들이 꼽줌.
6.그외,예나 진솔은 계속 비꼬면서 놀리고 발걸고 발을 밟으면서 괴롭힘.
7.김채원은 당시 매니저와 연애중이엿음.그래서 매니저도 왕따 사실을 알면서 묵인함.
8.현주 자살시도이후 ,회사에서 멤버들이 반성중이라고 해서 현주와 어머니가 회사에 찾아감. 멤버들 마주쳣는데 자기들끼리 웃으면서 무시함.
에이프릴 현주의 친구분이 쓰신거 널리 퍼뜨립니다
이나은도 문제지만 제일막내고 당시 16살이엿던 진솔이 현주가 말하는데 조용히하고 무시하는등 괴롭힘이 많앗음.
헐 채원.......
와... 근데 나이를 보니 정말 다들 어리네요.. 생각도
채원이랑 소민 진짜 충격이다...레이첼은 정말 착하네 아무 짓도 안 하고...
@@Muntange_11 레이첼 현주 나가고 들어왔음 그냥 잘한것도없고 잘못한것도없고 그냥 들어온 애임
@@롤리폴리롤리롤리-d7x 아하
채원이 진짜 여우인듯 진짜 레알 가리지않고 시비털듯이 말하네 묘하게 기분나쁘게 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 짜증남 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ그냥 나오지마라 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
시비털듯이 말한데가 몇초임?
ㄴㄴ 여우가 아니라 쟤는 눈치가 없는거임.
성향상 나은진솔예나 랑 안맞음.
그래서 어떻게든 어울리려고 쩔쩔매면서까지 어울리려는거고
난 이진솔도 이진솔인데 김채원 쟤가 제일 얄미움 약간 그런 포지션인거같은데 앞에선 챙겨주는척 그래놓고 여왕벌이 욕하면 같이 욕하는
박쥐같은 얀임 ㅋㅋ
한국에 많은 유형이져~~어딜가나 꼭 껴있는타입
현주라는 분 진짜 예쁘네요...ㄷ ㄷ ㄷ 다른 멤버 다 합친거보다 100배 이쁜듯..연예인에 관심없는데 현주밖에 안보임! 눈이 완전 사슴처럼 초롱초롱해..
@@별-q2p 실제로 이나은이 원래 인기 더 많았어요 파트도 더 많았고요..
0:18 와 맨 왼쪽 비주얼...ㅋㅋ충격이다. 와 쟨 노래도 못불러. 춤도 그닥 .얼굴도 저래..끼도 하나도없어봬던데 무슨 포지션으로 들어간거임? 현주랑 얼굴비교하니까 더 극대화됨ㅋㅋ
초기에 구하라닮은꼴로 언플함ㅡㅡㅡ
@@jusaintle6927 그사람은 전소민이예요
8:46
얜 회사에서 메댄으로 밀어줌 ㅋ
@@이주원-o7z6m 와 ㅈㄴ 거울본걸 귀신봣다고 착각하나
0:49 김채원? 표정 봐 ...
진짜 제일 불쌍하네요 현주...ㅜㅜ
그게 지 힘들때 도와줬던 애를 쳐다볼 표정인가,,박쥐같은년 진짜;;
으 역겨워 표정
ruclips.net/video/oNRtYcZiYvA/видео.html
아 1000개 내꺼하고 싶은더ㅔ쿸ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 하나가 모잘랔ㅋㅋ
Kalian sadar gasi slama vdeo ini dia ga ada ngomong sndri gtu depan kamera, kya pegang kameranya gitu kya member lain.. Ga bnyak di sorot juga di kamera kya member lain, kadang posisi nya paling blakang, gada yg ngajak ngomong..klopun ngomong kya yg di cuekin gtu, atau di tanggepinnya kya yg males sinis gtu, Kasian bgt sumpah..jahat bgt inisi..keliatan bgt dia di kucilin nya.. Kuat bgt dia masih brusaha buat ceria, pdhl kliatan juga dia keq ga nyaman. Jahat bgt mereka astaga.
Ya Allah Nemu komen bahasa Indonesia 😭
Ya bnr bgt th ka,kalo ak jd dia udh out dr kpn tau
@@ainunazizah2537 haha 😂
@@rimatrisnandi959 kuat bgt dia, mngkin inget perjuangan nya utk jd idol ga mudah, makanya ttp bertahan mski di gtuin.
Akhirnya nemu komen indo😂
채원이년도 존나 악질임 채원 이분이 원래 좀 따돌림 당하고있었는데 현주가 도와줬는데 채원이 자기 살라고 중간에서 이간질 시킨거였다함 근데 이건 현주 그분만 말한거라서 사실인지 아닌진 제 3의입장으로선 확실하단못하지만 채원도 그렇고 주변에서 무시하는건 눈에 뻔히 보임; 현주님 화이팅
영상보면 채원이가 그런 모습 보이는걸 아예 못찾엤어서 그부분에 대한 의구심이 든다 ㅠㅜ
@@junhahwang 당연하지;;자기 도와주던 사람이였으니까 양심은 쥐풀정돈 있으니까 다른애들처럼 못되게 굴진않겠지;;
전 그냥 그부분은 너무 뇌피셜만 있어서 채원이에대해선 중립지킬라구여..
이나는 이진솔 양예나 세명이 우선 나쁘다고 보고!!
@@junhahwang 영상 다 본거 맞아요? 3:55 만봐도 표정 팍 구린데,, 방송이라서 표정관리 한게 이정도
이게 5년전 영상인데 아무도 현주눈을 제대로 맞춰주는 사람도 없고... 있으나 마나 이런 취급하는거같음 현주 혼자 열심히 노력하는것만 보임....
솔직히 나보단 모두 이쁘겠지만 현주가 진짜 제일 이쁘다...
이 왕따 사실을 알고 보니까 더 소름이다......
현주에겐 카메라 거의 한번도 안 비춰주고.....
현주 지금 눈치 보면서 아무말도 못하자나ㅠㅠㅠ
아니 애초에 그렇게 왕따를 해도 카메라 앞에서는 명랑한 척하고.......
맴버들 진짜 소름이다.....
나 진짜 이나음 되게 좋아했었는데 충격이다.....
Basically April is jealous of Hyunjoo's visual. After Hyunjoo left, Naeun claim the title "visual of the group". If Hyunjoo is still there Naeun probably is nothing. Some people said Naeun's father owned share in DSP that's why she are popular & has a lot of job.
Totally agree with you... & Naeun also did plastic surgery,, but what the point of have a beautiful face when her heart is ugly!!!!,,
Hyunjoo is visual of grup right?
@@syifacamila7405 yup
@MARTLA ILYNWe don't care how she looks. We just care about the bullying culture. Do a plastic surgery surely can fix an ugly face but can never fix the person attitude.
@MARTLA ILYN hyunjoo's left april bcs of health problems that confirmed by DSP that time when it's first of second half promotion tinkerbell!
카메라 앞에서만 친한척 오지고요
논란 터지고 보니까 이나은 극켬ㅋㅋㅋ
와 전소민인가 뭔가 나이많은애 진짜 무섭다;;;
주동자인데 운좋네
ㅇㅈ 듣보라 잘 피해가네 ㅋㅋㅋ
What’s sad is that unlike AOA Mina, it seems Hyunjoo did not have any member that was kind to her or felt bad for her.
I watched a few videos about April... and the worst one was Jinsol, she is so rude. But I guess girl with mole on nose is one who tried to hear Hyunjooo
@@rianesse yess some moment i can see ,she is on side of hyunjoo, chaewon
Based on this video many knet dislike chaewon though i also think chaewon isnt that rude like jinsol ew
I heard from Korean netizens Chaewon just wanted to bring conflict. so he sometimes approached hyunjoo, sometimes approached other members just bring conflict for hyunjoo with other member
@@badutmpl7047 🔥
기분탓인가?
매니저도 현주를 카메라앵글에 덜 잡는 것 같고
기분탓인가?
혼자 겉도는 게 보이네.
힘들었겠다.ㅜㅜ
저 당시 김채원님이 매니저님이랑 연애중이여서 매니저님도 알면서 방관했다해요 현주님 고등학교 친구분께서 그렇게 말씀하셨습니다
그룹매니저가 그룹멤버랑사귐? ㅋㅋㅋㄹㅇ
1:53 시장에서 현주 뒤에서 진솔이랑 나머지한명 의미심장하게 눈빛 교환하고 쎄한거 눈치챈 현주가 뒤돌아보는데 진솔 바로 눈 위로 쳐다보고 아닌척 하는것 보삼 브이로그 찍는대도 이렇게 대놓고 ..?!?!
그러게요 소민 웃는 것도 진짜 개꼴보기 싫네요
3:55 개소름이네
미친;;;;ㅋ
와 표정 싹 변하는 거 봐 ㅁㅊ;;; ㄹㅇ 소름 돋음...
시어매같노
표정 싹 변했다가 카메라 앞인거 생각 나서 뒤 보는척 하는거 같은 느낌..
진짜 개 지렸다.....오ㅓ 말도안나와
소민 제일 무섭다...ㄷㄷ 펜트하우스 천서진이랑 똑같아 진짴ㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ 전소민이 제일 소름끼침 주동자였으면서 자기랑 상관없는척 현주기사 터진날 유투브쳐올리고있음
천서진은 예쁘기라도 하지.. 소연님❤️
얼굴은 안똑같쥬 ㅎㅎ
@@김솔비-b5e 헐~~~ 유튜브 올렸다고요?? 거기가 대체 어딥니까?!
이 영상 보고 느낀건데 예나라는 애는 어떻게 아이돌이 된거죠? 신기하네...
예나라는 애가 누군지 모르겠는데 7:46 맨왼쪽에 있는애죠?ㅋㅋㅋㅋ아님 죄송
@@silver0336 맞아뇨
역시 사람보는눈은 비슷한가봐요 ㅋㅋㅋ
솔직히 현주빼고 나머지는 그닥..??
ㄷㄷ................ 이게 뭐야 시볼 에이프릴에 관심없을때라서 왕따 터지고 이 영상 처음봤는데 현주님 중심으로 보니깐 방송에서도 이정돈데.. ㄷㄷ 처음 주동자라는 소민이 그 kard의 소민아님?
마즘
맞음
Jinsol is the worst... Totally rude girl.
And ugly
Lol don’t say that she’s literally satan’s twin
😂👍
9:14 맨뒤에서 현주 혼자 절뚝거리면서 오고 있음.. 넘어질뻔했는데 아무도 안잡아주고.. 너무 안쓰럽다 너무 애기였는데ㅠㅠㅠ
헐 ㅠㅠ 절뚝거리는데 어떻게 아무도 안 도와줄 수가 있지
에이프릴이간다에서도 현주 절뚝 거리면서 걷는데 아무도 안도와주고 심지어 밖에서 고기 먹을때 다리도 절뚝 거리는 상태로 짐 많이 들고 오는데 도와주는 애 없고 나은이 뒤돌아보다가 짐 들어주려고 도와주는줄 알았는데 현주인거 알게되고 안도와주고 자리 피하는 장면도 있는데 너무 슬픕니다 ㅠ
몇몇분들이 이진솔이랑 이나은만 욕하는데 채경이랑 레이첼 빼고 그냥 다 망했으면 좋겠음 딴 멤버들도 티 많이 나던데..
채경님이랑 레이첼님은 왜요..? 현주님이 에이프릴 나간 뒤에 들어오신 분들인데.. 채경님이랑 레이첼님은 아무것도 안 하시지 않았나요?
@@라일락-c8s3s 네 그래서 빼고라고 하시네요
@@키워-s2b 아하 그렇네요. 저는 레이첼이랑 채경을 빼고 다 망했으면 좋겠다는 게 팀에서 빼버리고 걔네도 다 망했으면 좋겠다는 뜻으로 이해해버렸네요ㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋ
카메라 앞에서는 예나도 꼽주는거 많이 보이더라구요.
카메라 뒤에서는 다들 똑같아겠지만..
@@라일락-c8s3s 현주 나가고 나서 채경이랑 레이첼이 다음 타켓이 된거 같더군요.
썸네일부터 현주얼굴없이 나온거 선택한거 실화냐
I kinda feel that Hyunjoo is sometimes left out for some reason ..
YES ME TOO! But I think is cuz jinsol & chaewon are closer so naturally they will reply to each other more I guess. Then hyunjoo just replies when they ask her things & stuff like that
YoonBomiLove i think your right maybe thats one of the factors
Your comment was from 5 years ago...
How do you feel today when you know she was really bullied/leftout by the other members back then? I hope you are still supporting Hyunjoo
@@cosmicspeachy damn I just read the article now. I'm so shocked. I'm still supporting April and Hyunjoo but this was hell of a mess. If this issue turns out to be true idk what to feel. I really felt bad for Hyunjoo back at that time when she was still in the group. 😥💔
wow u really have a good eyes tho
so apparently the first one that bullied hyunjoo is somin, a former member of April that left and join KARD omg thats why April and KARD is underrated. somin you better left the industry
which one is somin?
@@moonblahblah9407 the one in black at 1:55 , she also ignoring hyunjoo and making face at that time
@@farihahmohd if anything, it looked like Jinsol and Somin were having an inside joke. But these are all assumptions. With the way it was edited, you won't fully know until you have seen the rest of the context or clip to understand what the scene was about. These videos are really making people work their deduction skills.
@@m.k.1559 i actually didn’t realized it before but I knew after many koreans commented it
카메라 앞에서도 현주 존나 싫어하는 티 내는데 실제로는 얼마나 심했을까
카메라 앞에서도 저렇게 단체로 현주 싫어하는게 티가 나는데 카메라 없을때는 오죽했을까...
1:53 쯤 전소민이랑 이진솔 표정 나만 이상해 보이나?
하
아이돌의 얼굴과 표정이 아닌건 확실함
@@빈기노 아이돌의 얼굴과 표정이 따로 정해져있나요?
@@이지수-w9h 당연히 정해져있죠 예쁜얼굴과 착한표정
@@성이름-e6w 그건 좀 아닌데
If they could treat her this horrible in front of the camera, can you even imagine how they acted behind the camera?
nice
up
Horrible? I didn't see one time in the video that they treated her horribly🙄
@@Angel-ej4ui they isolated her
@@chelz4057 yes
Mentang mentang kita introvert kadang gak dihargain kita juga gatau salah kita apa kok gak ada yg mau nemenin.. jahad kalean
은근히 따돌리는데 느껴지는데 아무렇지 않은척 하는게 얼마나 고통스러운데. 뇌가덜자란 비정상들 속에서 혼자 힘들었겠다 정말ㅜㅜ현주야 저들은 지금부터 나락으로 떨어질일만 남았어 그동안 힘들었던 기억을 다 잊을순 없겠지만 너를 이해하는 사람들이 많다는걸 꼭 기억해줘 현주 화이팅
진솔 까불거리는거 ㄹㅇ 보기 싫다
썸넬에서도 현주가 맨뒤에 어정쩡하게 얼굴 간신히 보이고 있네.. 참..
If this is true, isolation is a type of social bullying where you and a gang of people purposely isolate or ignore your targeted victim. This type of bullying can't be seen physically but can affect mental health seriously. I hate social bullying as I was also a victim in the past. I didn’t do anything...like why they do that to me...🥲
I still remember it and it effect me a lot..
Honeslty you can't forget that kind of treatment. I still remember it all. I haven't seen my bullies since 7-8 years now. It just stays with you...
Exactly! This is exactly what happened to my little sister, she was bullied like this from her old “best friend” for some reason we don’t know, she manipulated their two other friends and ignore my little sister in everything! As an older sister I can’t help but get so angry when I see my little sister running after them because she wanted to talk to them and hang out with them so bad! I’m so disgusted at April members especially the one who first started to bully Hyunjoo
@@peonies6385 I don't know what made them start bullying me either. It could be that they thought I was an easy target.. idk.. it's really saddening. I hope your sister is alright and that she has better friends now. She didn't deserve that.
lol this type of bullying really hurt, i've experienced it while im working in office
Yeah, but we must strong 🦾♥️ don’t give up and feel depress, i just think karma will hit them soon and successful will come to us if we strong and be patient
God will help kind people
이나은 진짜 개이쁜데 나만 이나은이 넘 이쁘나 다른 멤들도 다 이쁘지만
Bahkan 5 tahun lalu udah ada fans yg notice kalau hyunjoo terus menerus di perlakukan tersisih atau sendirian. Tdi liat di video eps 2 klo gak salah yg ber 3 an ke itaewon.. jelii skali itu fans.. 5 tahun kemudian bru terkuak ke permukaan hyunjoo kuaat sekalii kamu 😢
Tull trending 1 komennyap
pas aku ke eps 2, ga nemu lg komennya yg mana :'
Liat mukanya naeun serem bgt aneh gitu mukanya pantes klo iri ama hyunjoo
Di video ini ada hyunjo? Yg mana ya dia soalnya gw liat mukanya sama semua😭
@@ilham6360 baju putih yg paling cantik
Jinsol is the main character, she is the bully. NOT SURPRISED
But... She was just a kid in that time, she just was 12-13 years old, please 🙄
현주가 제일 예쁨ㅋㅋ 나머지 아이돌 어떻게 됐냐 지금 그나마 용된거네
이때싶 얼굴로 패는 건 진짜 오바지 쟤네가 아무리 못났어도 방구석에서 비판인지 비난인지 구분도 못 하고 욕이나 하는 너보다 못할까
근데 현주가 이쁘긴하네...
14:02 손으로 집는 거 경악스러움 가지가지한다 진짜
@움치치 그니까요,,
@움치치 쟤 혼자만 이쑤시개안쓰고 손으로 먹는데 개념이 없는거지ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@움치치 쟤네들만 먹으라고 해논것도 아니고 시식용으로 여러사람 먹으라고 해놓은 건데 손으로 먹질않나.... 2개를 먹지 않나... 당연히 욕먹을 짓이짘ㅋㅋㅋ
@움치치 미운 놈은 숨 쉬는 것만 봐도 꼴뵈기 싫다니 과민반응이라면 과민반응이긴 한데... ㅋㅋ 평소 행실에서 집안 수준이 보인다고 여러사람이 먹으라고 시식대에 음식 담겨있는걸 즈그집 자취방마냥 더럽게 손으로 툭툭 집어다 먹어대는 꼬라지가 가정교육 수준이 높아 보이지는 않는 것도 팩트지 ㅇㅇ...
아니 저걸 손으로 집는게 그러면 정상적인건가????사람들이 많이 먹는 음식인데 손으로 집으면 개더러운데
08:49 뒤에서 혼자 터벅터벅ㅜㅜ
아....이건 진짜 마음아파ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
슬프다 진짜...
착하게 사시길 바라본답니다. ★
ruclips.net/video/qtmbeOQ255c/видео.html
진솔이랑 같은선에있다가 카메라 나올라고 뒤에간걸 혼자 터벅터벅 ㅇㅈㄹ
I know exactly that feels, when you were in a group and you left alone..
Even they didn't physical bully, but that atmosphere it self is suffocated!
Suffered the same treatment from 3 grade to 11 th grade...
YES FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT. I have experienced the same thing from my "friends" and even my own relatives. It hurts like a bitch. The moment when u are there wanting to hang out with them but they dont say A SINGLE WORD to push u away but the fact that they are ignoring you is loud n clear babe. There are people who dont understand which i guess meant they are the ones who usually ostracise a single person out of their so called friend group🤷🏽♀️
Yeah I had the same thing happened to me in 7th grade I felt like I wanted to die honestly
hyunjoo got exposed for lying lol
by looking many comments of korean here..seemed this case is bit serious.. but what i see thro this video..hyunjoo lil bit uncomfortable with them
Probably because they ignore her , talk over her, they leave her by herself, etc. I had friends like them. I thought they were my friends turns out I was the person they were bullying.
@@Tearsofblood25 they're toxic and pretentious
@@Tearsofblood25 somin and jinsol are the worst ones. Somin is just escaping from this controversy.
@@junzheyizhan she's starting to get seen just not as much as the others.
@@junzheyizhan I hope she gets called out more
at 1:54 you can see jinsol said something to somin about hyunjoo who is standing right in front of her and when hyunjoo turns around to look, jinsol looks the other way. jinsol is just human trash. how dare you treat your unnie like this???
This is the first time I saw Somin like that...sad
진짜 현주는 어떤 삶을 산거지,,,,,ㅠㅠㅠ
@@gommgamm idk about that. She sometimes gives jiwoo the stink eye...
Lol somin and jiwoo doesnt speak at all on cam i think almost more than a year now so tbh i’m not surpised bout somin’s rumor 🤣
@@farahfitriani dang Somin ignoring my jiwoo
현주는 원래 비주얼이었다
@내 이름은 가난,돈이없죠 ㅂㅈㅂ가 괜히 있는말이 아님
아니라고 말하고 싶어도 진짜 종특이라 해야되나..
내 친구들도 한다리 건너보면 같이 지내면서 한명꼽주는건 다들 있더라
@@user-9mo4kw3i 내친구들은 안그러는데
@@우와-s9h 보적보...ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 사용하는 워딩하곤 진짜 저급하다 성폭행 가해자 중 대다수가 남자라고 해서 남자들이 전부 성폭행 가해자가 되는건 아니잖아요...ㅋㅋ 서로 기분 나쁠 말은 하지 맙시다
@@우와-s9h 이런애들은 고등교육을 왜 받는걸까.. 시간 아깝고 돈 아깝게 논리적인 사고회로로 생각을 못하면 그냥 말 하지마세요
@@우와-s9h 군대 내 괴롭힘 문제로 수많은 군장병들이 자살하는데 어떻게 생각함?ㅎ 시야가 좁은게 잘못은 아니지만 이리 당당할건 또 뭐람ㅎ
Why had only Hyunjoo carried her bag while others were carrying nothing when they were playing? Did they even ask her to carry their stuff
Poor Hyunjoo was alone and upset during the whole trip.
현주님만 카메라 앵글 잘 안잡히고, 구구단 게임 할 때도 멤버들 눈치 보는게 안타까움,,ㅠ
멤버들 다 같이 이동 할 때도 혼자서만 겉도는 것도 보이고,,,ㅠㅠ
와 알고봐서 그런지 분위기가 완전 망이네 웃어도 보여주는 느낌이고 진정 즐거운 느낌이 아니야
1:22초에 현주 창문볼때 표정 굳는거 봐여유ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
이나은도 원래부터 예뻤던 건 아니구나;;
8:54 hyunjoo tried to talk to the girl with red stripe but she ignored her
Not really
She was just pointing at the map to find where to go
Not really seems like Yena is the follower type. most of the time she is just clueless but still didnt really help hyunjoo
카메라가 피해가도 현주만 보게된다
ㄹㅇ
3:57 i’m not trying to said chaewon is rude, but if i was on hyunjoo’s side, it will hurt so much:” like...should she really say that infront of hyunjoo?
she just laughed it off :((( i feel uncomfortable
@@mayggish she was laughed but it was hurt so bad
It's a joke and alot of Koreans say it to their kids to not fall easily
@@unir-rahma yea i know that, but if she recognize hyunjoo as a friend she would not say that infront of her
@@kampaginsungan_ it's because she's a friend and she can take the joke the jokes for strangers????
Suddenly all april's video are pop off on my recommendation
semua member kek berlomba2 pengen jadi center dan selalu disorot njirr. the real caper sihh trs kek kelakuan norak bangett ngomong dan ekspresinya bener2 ga disaring apa
Aku juga mikirnya gini juga,, dan keliatan banget pas di dingo music kalo mereka berebut jadi center, pantesan sih susah keangkat ini grup
Sabar sabar 😂
Hyunjoo must have been so uncomfortable omg ;-;
진짜 숨막혔겠다.. 어떻게 버텼을까
이나은 코...
Pantesan hyunjoo dibully, dia keliatan paling imut dan pure bgt
@@rizkaintan9090 ?
@@rizkaintan9090 itu dulu, kalo ga slh mereka itu dulu ber enam trs pas dia keluar ada yg masuk 2 org
@@rizkaintan9090 itu somin namanya klo gasalah yang member keenam....dulu dia itu member yang duluan keluar sebelum si hyunjoo keluar
@@alianadhifaazzahra6253 Hai Salken aku dari Jawa Timur
@@rizkaintan9090 salken aku dari jakarta
They propably bullied hyunjoo bcause she have more charms and is way prettier than all of them
9:50 그냥 좀 맞춰주지
으~~별게 다 미워보이네
ㅋㅋㅌㅋ그니깐 현주는 맞춰주는데 못된년
예난가 젤못생김
사람 무안하게 만드네요 ㅋㅋ 으이구
얘가 현주 젤 싫어함
@@Peko-chan 지금은 채경이때리고 반말하고 레이첼질투함ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
현주는 저때 얼마나 괴롭고 힘들었을까
.. 진짜 전소민도 이나은 이진솔 너무 싫다 이나은 착한척 하는것도 ㅈㄴ 꼴보기 싫었음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 가해자 아닌척 이진솔이랑 개웃기네 ㅋㅋ 꼴아보는것도 재수없음ㄷㄷ ㅋ
1:05 부터 보면 ㄴㅇ 이때는 ㅈㅅ도 무시조로 대함. ㅈㅅ은 현주를 자기가 주도해서 괴롭히면서 자기에 대한 무시와 괴롭힘을 두배, 세배로 늘려서 현주한테 뒤집어 씌운 듯.. 진짜 너무들 한다..
Why i think she look so lonely and uncomfortable but pretend to be happy with other girls, when the other girls not even try to look and talk with she T.T
In the last vidio, Look like every member get a thing. Only hyunjoo hand is empty poor girl, she deserve better, you can see she working hard in a program that call ( the unit)
She was really trying her best to get along with them. They treated her like crap. I've had the same thing happen to me. You just feel like 💩. It's not ok to treat others like that.
Wtf are you seeing? None of that is true lnao
@@Xgennn57 it actually is...
her brother got some very concrete evidence, there is no way for the company to deny anymore
@@anaavila9326 We'll see the concrete evidence when her lying *** gets sued
@@Xgennn57 lol what makes you think all these things arent true ? is it because dsp sued hyunjoo and her family ? like really ?
아예 대놓고 현주 쌩까고 무시하고 왕따시키네..
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
현주가 제일 이쁘네 나머지 걸그룹 어케했대,,많이 이뻐졌네,,
JINSOL OUT!!! THIS PROVES DOGS AND COWS CAN BECOME IDOLS. HOW DARE YOU TREAT YOUR UNNIE LIKE THIS??? EVEN IN FRONT OF CAMERAS???!!!
현주가 여기서 제일 이쁘네
진짜 현주가 제일 이쁘구나 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 거의넘사벽인데
ㅋ
hyunjoo is very few in the camera, they are really bad, like a great bully
와 근데 현주님 진짜 귀엽고 이쁘다.. 저것들이 시기질투할만 하네. 이쁜데 기약하고 착한애들은 악녀들한테 먹잇감이 되기 쉽지...
@움치치 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 너 이나은 시녀였구나 어쩐지 ㅋㅋ
현주가 한마디하면 정색하고 은근슬쩍 눈치주면서
1:21 나은이가 머리로 채원 얼굴 쳤는데도 웃네
11:44 에서 매니저.. 채원 남친이었다던 사람인가
ㄹㅇ채원 분량 많고 굳이 채원팀이라고 한거보니깐....
근데 진짜 매니저도 생각이 있으면..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 지 여친 아이돌 데뷔하는데 사귀고 자빠졌네..
끼리끼리죠 뭐 ㄱㅇㄷ
1:54 눈빛봐라;
진솔언니가 예나언니 카메라에 안잡혀서 힐끗 보고서 손잡고 앞으로 끌어주는 모습 너무 감동 ㅠㅠ 언니 생각하는 모습이 참 예쁘다
근데 이 영상만 봐도 현주 말에 아무도 대꾸랑 리액션을 안 하는데 혼자 꺄르르 웃고 있음... 진짜 태생적으로 잘웃고 밝은 사람인 것 같은데 얼마나 힘들었으면
현주님이 무슨옷인지 알려주실수 있나요..?
헷갈려서ㅠㅠ
@@핫핑크 오프닝 기준 왼쪽에서 네번째입니다 근데 굳이 몰라도 영상 보면안 알 수 있을듯요...
@@몽상가-b4g 영상 계속 보다보니 얼굴이 구분가네요
현주님이 제일 이쁘신듯..
제일 피곤하게 굼
현주 혼자 연예인처럼 생겼네 ㅋㅋㅋ
잘못한게 있어도 얼굴로 까는건 아님
솔직히 나은도 이쁨 ㅋㅋ 악마의 재능임 ㄹㅇ 예뻐도 알고 나니까 존나 악마같이 생김
@@wheneverwhatever 이마까진 지석진같이 생겼는뎅
@@user-gp2km6mh8f ㅇㄴㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 그건 좀 아니고 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 걍 이나은이 성격이 개ㅈ같이서 그렇게 보일 수도
ruclips.net/video/qtmbeOQ255c/видео.html
Can't believe they did this to Hyunjoo. So this is the reason why she left? Tsk T.T Sorry for not noticing it Hyunjoo T.T
9:12 poor hyunjoo always left out
15:30 what's wrong with the cameraman??? she's still not done talking. I feel so bad for my baby Hyunjoo!!!
I wonder if the camera person is the manager Chaewon was dating.
와 ㄹㅇ 현주가 제일 예뻐서 눈에 띄네
3:57 여기에서 동생이 손 줄 때 표정 무엇...
somin... as the oldest you could've said something, you could've told the members to cut it out. as the leader you should've helped hyunjoo. you deserve to lose everything you have just like the rest.
Lmao she was the one who started bullying her
@@shamsom i know :( i wrote that comment bc everyone else seems to be focusing on naeun only but ALL OF THEM should've held accountable for what they did to that poor girl. someone who enjoys making others miserable can never be truly happy, she'll need more therapy than hyunjoo to heal her shitty soul.
It's so weird though. The dynamics in this group was way off. It seems like somin started this all. Her bestie was Jinsol. Naeun kinda seems to be an outcast at times or is trying to fit in so she helps them and sucks up to somin. Chaewon is kinda odd. At times she seems to feel bad so she does something nice for hyunjoo .she's most likely a bystander who doesn't say stop. So they all participated in the bullying I'd say one way or the other. They definitely had a clique in the group. A lot of them suvked up to jinsol and somin. I'm assuming they didn't get bullied too in a way but not as obvious as hyunjoo. I bet it's in form of backhanded compliments, jokes etc.
In another video where they are bungee jumping you can see Naeun glare at Somin's back while she's talking to the camera. Naeyn even looked her up and down.
@@Tearsofblood25 jinsol wasn't even 15 when this happened.... what a cursed child, how can you bully someone, see how much what you're doing is affecting them and CONTINUE to bully them without feeling like a monster? she probably has no empathy at all, it's disgusting.
idk about the clique or if there was some sort of hierarchy within the group but it wouldn't surprise me. I hope they know their careers are over and I also hope no one lets them forget what they've done. Hyunjoo could've taken her life because of them, this should follow them for the rest of their lives.
@@Tearsofblood25 i think chaewon was as bad as the other not just a bystander
U can see when hyunjoo shaked chaewon’s little brother, her eyes looked so pissed and said” dont give ur hand easily” like whattt??
3:55 ...?
엥 저건 누가봐도 장난인데 ..
존나 정색하는데 뭐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
정색하는거봐 와 ...
@공주 아닠ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 이건 에바 잖아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 딱 봐도 장난인데 이런거 가지고 그러는건 좀 ;;
@@raclemi1302 ㅈㄹ하넼ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
와 나은 코 성형 어디서했는지 궁금하당 ㅋㅋ
0:49 눈빛..
헉 진짜 무서운
말 한마디 했는데 표정 다 썩어지면서 분위기 싸해지는것 보소..
와.. 무섭
not this being on my recommended after the scandal
개인적으로 3:59에는 장난 으로 말한거고,16:56에도 현주는 짐안들고 애들만 든거 보면 현주가 주작 아님? 다른건 다 같이 놀고,그러는데 그리고 애들이 피해자 아님?
ㅇㅈ
전 아닌듯
@@채윤-e4n 아..제생각인데..나쁘게 읽으셨다면 죄송해요!개인적으로 붇일께요!
괜찮아요! 전 현주가 괴롭힌 당한 영상이 있어 그렇게 생각했어요
@@채윤-e4n 아~
ada pernyataan katanya manager selalu cewek tp di 12:51 jelas bgt suara cowok... agensi aja udh bohong fix bgt tukang bully
On 9:14 did u see guys? No one care to baby hyunjoo :(( feel sad for her :(((
Hyunjoo who?
@@myhouse4279 she's wearing grey skirt one
Will why chaewon went to film with her in 9:09??????
Chaewon keep stay with her...dont over blamed
Chaewon was still with her!
1:54 현주가 진솔 쳐다보는데 눈 돌리네 ㅎ
현주는 실제로보면 진짜여신일듯...
9:09 진솔님 원래 길치여서 무섭다고 했으면서...ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ진짜 현주 어떻게 견뎠냐ㅠㅠ
@@뇸뇨로뇨로뇸 ㅇㅈㅠㅠ
에이프릴 노래 하나도 모르는데 오늘 얘네 영상만 20개 넘게 본 것 같네 뭐여 시펄
ㅋㅋㅋ 저도
나도
나도x2
이나은 코 성형 정보좀요
너무 잘됨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ̌̈ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ̌̈ㅋㅋㅋ
코 했으면 더 예뻐야함...ㅋㅋㅋ 코 똑같음
@@fnqldk10 지금도 안예쁜 코지만 예전에는 걍 돼지코였음 팅커벨때 기사사진 한장만 봐도 알수있음
@@Kimbangjeon 사진말고 영상보면 똑같음
코하기전에 옆모습 메부리 느낌영상 있더라구요
현주랑 둘이서 얘기하는 영상
7:15초 와 진짜 이쁘다 왜케 화가나지 팬도아닌데.. 줜나 열받는다 현주팬 됐다 현주를 응원합니다 여신님
얼굴 크기차이봐봐...
4:40 청국장도 있네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
현주야! 절대 자책감 갖지 말고 보란듯이 잘 살면 되는거야!
님이 말한데로 살아서 문제.
Espero que ella esté bien
와 전소민? 쟤랑 예나? 얘네둘은 어케연옌된거냐 와꾸가 걍;;
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㅆㅇㅈ
전소민 무섭게 생김ㄷ ㄷ 랩퍼인줄