Great. What a genius Nietzsche was! He drew inspiration from Zoroaster as he knew the relevance and impactful teachings of Zoroaster. Arda Viraf Namag was a priest of Zoroaster who wrote a book on mignight metaphysical journey of Zoroaster and even gave 5 times prayers model with Sun movement. This shows civilizational pertinence of Zoroaster. Good to learn from you sir. Known pashto poet philosopher and Sculptor, Ghani Khan used to focus on personalities like Buddha and Zoroaster i can recall his sculpture....Smiling Buddha. Anyway thanks again. Regards. Asar ahmadzay
علامہ اقبال بھی ایک فلاسفر تھے اور فرڈرک نطشے بھی ایک فلاسفر نیٹشے اقبال سے پہلے ہو کر گزرے ہیں جن کا مشہور قول ہے کے خدا نہیں ہے علامہ اقبال نے اپنی شاعری میں ان کے لیے کہا ہے .. ❤️اگر ہوتا وہ مجذوب فرنگی اس زمانے میں... ❤️تو اقبال اس کو بتاتا کہ مقام کبریا کیا ہے..
45:01 original sin(bag, bagicha garden, park wala episode)ka first concept introduce kiya gya tha torat(torah) me Waha se thoda bohat editing kar ke fir is theory ko introduce kiya gaya Bible me Fir waha se thoda bahut plus-minus karke ise introduce kiya gaya Quran me.
ماشاءاللہ، آپ نے بہت عمدگی سے بات کو واضح کیا۔ پہلے سنتے تھے، سید مظمل حسین صاحب کو بھی اس موضوع پر سنا، لیکن آپ نے جس انداز میں وضاحت کی، وہ بے مثال ہے۔ ہم نے تاریخ اور مذہب کے مطالعے میں ہمیشہ یہ سمجھا کہ بہت کچھ حاصل کر لیا ہے، لیکن جب فلسفہ کی دنیا میں جھانکا تو محسوس ہوا کہ ابھی بہت کچھ باقی ہے۔ فلسفہ ہمیں ان پہلوؤں کو سمجھنے میں مدد دیتا ہے جو مذہب اور تاریخ کے مفاہیم کو مزید واضح کرتے ہیں۔ یہ علم کی گہرائی کو بڑھانے اور مختلف نظریات کو سمجھنے کے لیے ایک بے مثال ذریعہ ہے، جو ہماری سوچ کے
Kudos Ali Sahib. Indeed your knowledge worth appreciation. Am new to the subject of Philosophy and found myself attracted towards Philosophy of Science. Couple of recommendations requested.
The most understandable and beautiful discussion on "thus spoke zarathustra". In the past watched few videos on youtube. So far this discussion is the best and quite insightful.
सर आप बताते है तो लगता है कोई मूवी चल रही है, बहूत अच्हे से बताते है और समझाते है एकदम सरल तरीके से आपकी विडिओ खतम होती है जैसे कोई मूवी खत्म हुई हो। एसा लगता है कि मूवी और लम्बी होनी चाहिए थी जल्दी खत्म हो गई। 🙏 धन्यवाद सर बहुत बहुत अभार आपका बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिला है आपसे, ऐसे ही सिखाते रहिए आप गुरु के समान है हमारे लिए।
Nietzsche's philosophy is full of life. It gives us an entirelry different direction to see the world with. He was very wise in rejecting all these obsolete and deteriorated values which had been culminated in humans by religions for thousands of years. Keep it up really enjoying your videos!
48:19 mai neitshe se puchna chahta hu ki "neitshe ji aap bataye insan kya kare ? Kya apne five senses ko jyada se jyada satisfie kare ? Jam ke khana Jam ke Pina Or Jam ke aish-moj karna Yehi hai intensely me totality me Jina??
nietzsche ke words aise h mtlb nhi , eye toh apke instinct h jam ke khana jam ke pina moj Krna ok , but unhi five sensors se app hard work kr skty ho , apka khna ankhe toh sirf Enjoy Krna chahti h jisam bhi enjoy Krna chata h eye apka tought but kya eye hi main kam h jism eye ap pr nirbhar krta h , uska at the last khna Superman Bano but perfection main mat jao balance kro .... Baki eye app pr hi totally depend krta h ki apke senses ki need sexuality h ya usi energy ki transform Krna ... Baise thoda correction ho skta h main abhi bacha hun , baki balance hi best h
46:31 sir mai apki majburi samjh sakta hu Charo taraf pagal bhare pade hai Zehni bimaro ki koi kami nahi hai Pata nahi kis mental problem ko kya bura lag jae.
Please keep up the good work , we like your style - it's Raw and Admirable. Say whatever you have at the moment which is your original style. Not all ( including me ) know Ur journey so we are not here to judge you. For us at the moment u r Uber man or at least progressing. Thanks for your content.
Just a suggestion for your editor: maybe they could increase the bass a bit and reduce the treble in the voice editing. Your explanations and the way you present information are fantastic! Your content is always so well-thought-out and engaging. I always look forward to your videos and find them incredibly helpful. Thank you so much for all the hard work you put into them!
Side kicks are your forte sir, plz add the max u can. u got the cunning wisdom to choose those notes & syllables rightly which is most needed for survival in a place you reside... Salute your knowledge and way of teaching sir. Love from Punjab India
Aap videos continue rakhna,yeah mujhe kaafi easy way lagta hai philosophy smjhne ka... Thankuu and keep it up Dont bother about what people comment on ur videos becaus3 ur content is awesome✌✌😊
thx a lot bro main nishay k qoutes partha rehta tha inky baray main janana chaa raha tha bht time sy achanak ye video maray samnay ayee mainy sochla chlo sunta hn but you explain him very well bht deep andaz main thx again stay bless with health and happiness
@@3rd_POV Sir i Have Little request (or say suggestions) When you start TSZ's series again please explain or provide your thoughts on Chapter 15th of Part two "Of The Immaculate Perception."(Because for me it was very Hard to UNDERSTAND.)
I would strongly encourage you to continue incorporating side notes in your videos. They are a distinctive feature of your channel and contribute significantly to your effective teaching method.
Such a profound thinker being explained in very easy words. Nietzsche must be followed in asian countries aswell. I believe his thinking and philosophy has deeply affected western culture and morality. Thanks bro 😍
50:39 lashkar e tayiba Lashkar ke jhangwi Al kaida Isis Tahrik e labbaik Taliban Hijbulla Hamas Huti Or bahut sare "baag, bagiche, garden, park" ke khwahishmand.
I have developed a very close relationship with you. When I started reading Nietzsche's Thus spake Zarathustra, I got goosebumps, my throat was choked, tears were coming out of my eyes, it felt as if I could break stones with my mere thought. Whatever this great man wrote, he wrote with his blood. The poetic glimpse that we get in it is an exception in itself. Well, I will not be able to express my feelings in real, but I would definitely like to say that I am a student of Philosophy Masters in India and accidentally reached your channel. Most of the books kept in your shelf are also adding beauty to my shelf, from this you can understand that there is some internal relationship between me and you. If possible, I would like to contact you personally, whether it is through mail or WhatsApp or in any other form. I have also been studying these subjects for a long time, so probably there can be some relevant discussion between us. At present I am reading around 80 books together, this is one of them. And yes, in this video, you and I got emotional at the same time..
Respect Sir. I love Osho too. Osho sbha sbha exercise krty hoy ziada samajh ata hy , kionky us waqt Hawa mn pure oxygen hoti hy. dmagh ziada kam krta hy
It’s important to consider different philosophical perspectives on Nietzsche’s views to better understand various arguments and derive a balanced understanding. Nietzsche’s idea that pity and compassion make a person weak, and that one should strive to become an “Übermensch” or “superhuman” by overcoming these emotions, has been highly controversial in philosophy. Various philosophers have presented arguments both for and against this view, and here we’ll discuss the thoughts and perspectives of some renowned philosophers on Nietzsche’s ideas: 1. Bertrand Russell - Critique of Nietzsche: Bertrand Russell strongly opposed Nietzsche’s ideas. According to Russell, Nietzsche’s philosophy limits human life to concepts of “power” and “strength,” ignoring higher emotions like compassion, love, and cooperation. Russell believed that compassion and empathy are essential for human society’s progress, fostering brotherhood and social harmony. For Russell, these qualities form the foundation of civilization. 2. Jean-Paul Sartre - Defense of Nietzsche: Jean-Paul Sartre partially supported Nietzsche’s theory. Sartre’s philosophy of “existentialism” emphasizes that a person is responsible for their actions and life choices. He believed that individuals should make their own decisions and be self-reliant. Sartre thought that if compassion limits one’s autonomy, it could indeed be a burden. In his view, people should take responsibility for their lives while relying less on others. 3. David Hume - Opposition to Nietzsche: David Hume considered pity and compassion as essential elements of human morality. He believed that humans are naturally social and empathetic beings, and through compassion, we feel others’ pain and help them. According to Hume, without compassion, people would become self-centered, and social cohesion would erode. For Hume, Nietzsche’s view that compassion makes one weak goes against basic moral principles. 4. Arthur Schopenhauer - A Strong Stance Against Nietzsche: Schopenhauer praised pity and compassion as noble human qualities. He argued that individuals should go beyond self-interest and show empathy for others. Schopenhauer believed that compassion is necessary to alleviate the suffering and pain in the world. Nietzsche’s theory, which labels compassion as a weakness, could make society harsher and more indifferent, according to Schopenhauer. 5. Ayn Rand - Support of Nietzsche’s Theory: Ayn Rand incorporated some of Nietzsche’s ideas into her philosophy of “Objectivism.” She argued that individuals should be self-interested and prioritize their own needs. Rand believed that compassion and pity for others divert people from their goals and make them weak. In her view, if everyone took full responsibility for their lives and prioritized their own happiness, it would lead to individual strength and societal progress. 6. Albert Camus - A Different Perspective on Nietzsche: Albert Camus, a philosopher of “Absurdism,” partly agreed with Nietzsche’s ideas but did not completely reject compassion. Camus believed that life is inherently meaningless, but that doesn’t imply people should be indifferent. He proposed a balanced approach, suggesting that individuals accept life’s absurdity while embracing compassion as part of personal fulfillment. Like Nietzsche, Camus valued autonomy but also saw compassion as meaningful. Conclusion Philosophers who opposed Nietzsche argue that compassion and pity are foundational to society, making us morally better individuals. They see Nietzsche’s theory as leading toward self-centeredness and eroding social bonds. On the other hand, philosophers who support Nietzsche’s ideas argue that prioritizing self-reliance and individuality can make people stronger and more independent. Thus, Nietzsche’s theory is somewhat valid in emphasizing self-reliance and strength, but rejecting compassion and pity altogether might make humanity indifferent and unbalanced.
Sir ap hamesha kamal k analysis krty hain. khobsurat content share krty hain. Please make some video on Arthur Schopenhauer. aur sath me ye bhi btain k is sab german philosophers ka aj kal ki german society per kya asar para ha?
Osho is the true modern Buddha. He is the voice of Buddha. People never truly listened to the voice of Buddha; they merely heard about him. If anyone listens to Osho, they will realize that he is the voice of Buddha in this modern world.
I love Osho - I very recently started reading him and I am very impressed. Although I am greatly impressed by many philosophers and thinkers- I don’t completely agree with any one of them.
He didn't the voice of buddha, balki you only listen or read that type of thought , he is not buddha he is not like anyone he is only Osho.. he totally different from any other philosopher
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Great. What a genius Nietzsche was! He drew inspiration from Zoroaster as he knew the relevance and impactful teachings of Zoroaster. Arda Viraf Namag was a priest of Zoroaster who wrote a book on mignight metaphysical journey of Zoroaster and even gave 5 times prayers model with Sun movement. This shows civilizational pertinence of Zoroaster. Good to learn from you sir. Known pashto poet philosopher and Sculptor, Ghani Khan used to focus on personalities like Buddha and Zoroaster i can recall his sculpture....Smiling Buddha. Anyway thanks again. Regards. Asar ahmadzay
Thanks for sharing the above insight brother-
علامہ اقبال بھی ایک فلاسفر تھے اور فرڈرک نطشے بھی ایک فلاسفر نیٹشے اقبال سے پہلے ہو کر گزرے ہیں جن کا مشہور قول ہے کے خدا نہیں ہے علامہ اقبال نے اپنی شاعری میں ان کے لیے کہا ہے ..
❤️اگر ہوتا وہ مجذوب فرنگی اس زمانے میں...
❤️تو اقبال اس کو بتاتا کہ مقام کبریا کیا ہے..
Iqbal was a confused person@@alshamsvlogs7628
45:01 original sin(bag, bagicha garden, park wala episode)ka first concept introduce kiya gya tha torat(torah) me
Waha se thoda bohat editing kar ke fir is theory ko introduce kiya gaya Bible me
Fir waha se thoda bahut plus-minus karke ise introduce kiya gaya Quran me.
ماشاءاللہ، آپ نے بہت عمدگی سے بات کو واضح کیا۔ پہلے سنتے تھے، سید مظمل حسین صاحب کو بھی اس موضوع پر سنا، لیکن آپ نے جس انداز میں وضاحت کی، وہ بے مثال ہے۔ ہم نے تاریخ اور مذہب کے مطالعے میں ہمیشہ یہ سمجھا کہ بہت کچھ حاصل کر لیا ہے، لیکن جب فلسفہ کی دنیا میں جھانکا تو محسوس ہوا کہ ابھی بہت کچھ باقی ہے۔ فلسفہ ہمیں ان پہلوؤں کو سمجھنے میں مدد دیتا ہے جو مذہب اور تاریخ کے مفاہیم کو مزید واضح کرتے ہیں۔ یہ علم کی گہرائی کو بڑھانے اور مختلف نظریات کو سمجھنے کے لیے ایک بے مثال ذریعہ ہے، جو ہماری سوچ کے
Kudos Ali Sahib. Indeed your knowledge worth appreciation. Am new to the subject of Philosophy and found myself attracted towards Philosophy of Science. Couple of recommendations requested.
The most understandable and beautiful discussion on "thus spoke zarathustra". In the past watched few videos on youtube. So far this discussion is the best and quite insightful.
Thx
Found a brilliant channel here today. Good production
Welcome aboard!
सर आप बताते है तो लगता है कोई मूवी चल रही है, बहूत अच्हे से बताते है और समझाते है एकदम सरल तरीके से आपकी विडिओ खतम होती है जैसे कोई मूवी खत्म हुई हो। एसा लगता है कि मूवी और लम्बी होनी चाहिए थी जल्दी खत्म हो गई।
🙏 धन्यवाद सर बहुत बहुत अभार आपका बहुत कुछ सीखने को मिला है आपसे, ऐसे ही सिखाते रहिए आप गुरु के समान है हमारे लिए।
Thanks!!!
@@koham_000 ये भाई सच कह रहा हैं सर ऐसा ही लगता है
Lambi video banya kariye
@@3rd_POV sir aap kamal ho
Nietzsche's philosophy is full of life. It gives us an entirelry different direction to see the world with. He was very wise in rejecting all these obsolete and deteriorated values which had been culminated in humans by religions for thousands of years.
Keep it up really enjoying your videos!
Thanks man!!!
@@3rd_POV you should make more videos on this book bro!
Yes I will cover a few more chapters
ظاہر ہے نطشے تو بڑا تھا ہی لیکن نطشے کو جس طرح آپ سمجھاتے ہیں یہ بھی قابل تعریف ہے علی حسن صاحب
Thanks brother
I've read this book myself, but dont get anything out of it, but now all concepts are clearing, such in depth explanation ALI bhai maza a gia. love u
Is it that difficult. ? I am not a pro at reading yet haha.
Extremely hard to read.@@nowshadk07
@@nowshadk07 it is to difficult book 📚
Salute to you, excellently explained.
Your side note are very remarkable plz always continue
Thx
I'm addicted to philosophy due to your lectures.
Thanks brother
❤
48:19 mai neitshe se puchna chahta hu ki "neitshe ji aap bataye insan kya kare ?
Kya apne five senses ko jyada se jyada satisfie kare ?
Jam ke khana
Jam ke Pina
Or Jam ke aish-moj karna
Yehi hai intensely me totality me Jina??
nietzsche ke words aise h mtlb nhi , eye toh apke instinct h jam ke khana jam ke pina moj Krna ok , but unhi five sensors se app hard work kr skty ho , apka khna ankhe toh sirf Enjoy Krna chahti h jisam bhi enjoy Krna chata h eye apka tought but kya eye hi main kam h jism eye ap pr nirbhar krta h , uska at the last khna Superman Bano but perfection main mat jao balance kro .... Baki eye app pr hi totally depend krta h ki apke senses ki need sexuality h ya usi energy ki transform Krna ... Baise thoda correction ho skta h main abhi bacha hun , baki balance hi best h
Thank u very very much sir for fulfulling my request.
Great lecture..... Beyond description Sir ❤❤❤
Thanks. U was waiting for next video ❤
46:31 sir mai apki majburi samjh sakta hu
Charo taraf pagal bhare pade hai
Zehni bimaro ki koi kami nahi hai
Pata nahi kis mental problem ko kya bura lag jae.
I admire your side notes,poetry,quotes…please keep going ✍️
Thank you, I will
Sides notes are the best, keep going! They are the most interesting part. Love from India!
Glad you like them!
Thank you Ali Bhai for another illuminating video. Badly waiting for more, and more, Sir.
Always interesting and entertaining; love your sincere and genuine laughter!
Sir maine aapki ekk ekk video ko 4 se 5 bar dekh rakhi hai pata nhi mai padhta to nhi hun ye sab baate achhi bahut lagti hai
Thanks!!!
Please keep up the good work , we like your style - it's Raw and Admirable. Say whatever you have at the moment which is your original style.
Not all ( including me ) know Ur journey so we are not here to judge you.
For us at the moment u r Uber man or at least progressing.
Thanks for your content.
Hahaha
حسب ضرورت اُردو ادب سے اشعار کا خوبصورت استعمال سامعین کو قریب کر دیتا ھے ۔ آپ کی آمد ھمارے لئے باعث تقویت ھے ۔ صدا خوش وخرم رھو ۔
Bohat shukriya
Ek din me 2 bar ye video dekha itna pasand aaya aapki presentation
Thanks- please share in your groups
Mangne mein tumhari or meri izzat chali jayegi.....what a thoughts
Bhai kya keh gaye...jawab nahin h❤
Just a suggestion for your editor: maybe they could increase the bass a bit and reduce the treble in the voice editing. Your explanations and the way you present information are fantastic! Your content is always so well-thought-out and engaging. I always look forward to your videos and find them incredibly helpful. Thank you so much for all the hard work you put into them!
Thanks for the suggestion - I will let the editor know.
Sir amazing. Love your content and the way you explain. Your expression makes the video more fun
Thx brother
Bahut hi lajawaab n shandar video h salute to you to teach us philosophy.aapka andaj e baya bahut hi beautiful h .nitse akela sab dharmiko se uper h
Thanks
@@3rd_POV your welcome sir
You are doing a great work. Well done. I leart a lot from your videos. Thanks
Glad to hear that
Side kicks are your forte sir, plz add the max u can. u got the cunning wisdom to choose those notes & syllables rightly which is most needed for survival in a place you reside... Salute your knowledge and way of teaching sir. Love from Punjab India
Thanks for appreciating my work brother- will keep adding side “KICKS” - I know what you meant
Once again great lecture. While watching videos my misconceptions are minimising. Thanks. Love from India ❤
Glad you like them!
Nietzsche : 🧓🏻
Nietzsche's Philosophy : 🗿
Sir ALi Shah : 😎
Me : 😘
Aap videos continue rakhna,yeah mujhe kaafi easy way lagta hai philosophy smjhne ka...
Thankuu and keep it up
Dont bother about what people comment on ur videos becaus3 ur content is awesome✌✌😊
Thanks a lot!
I have discovered your lecture today, and I hope within a week, I will see all your videos. ❤❤❤ thanks, Sir. Keep it up
Thank you
Your video always full of knowledge and lot ideas and theory clear in very easy style plz carry on and upload videoes minimum twice in a Saturday
Thanks for appreciating Sir, I will try to be more consistent.
itni mushkil BOOK itni asani say bata di THANKS... LOVE From Pakistan
Thanks
thx a lot bro main nishay k qoutes partha rehta tha inky baray main janana chaa raha tha bht time sy achanak ye video maray samnay ayee mainy sochla chlo sunta hn but you explain him very well bht deep andaz main thx again stay bless with health and happiness
Thanks
8:25 Sir whare can i find osho's exegesis on Nietzsche?
(Searched on internet but couldn't find it completely)
Yar I googled it and found it- did not save the link
Search (osho + laughing+ prophet)
@@3rd_POV Sir i Have Little request (or say suggestions)
When you start TSZ's series again please explain or provide your thoughts on Chapter 15th of Part two "Of The Immaculate Perception."(Because for me it was very Hard to UNDERSTAND.)
@@3rd_POVFind It.Thank you sir ❤
@@ADayDreamerOwl do you know the concept of immaculate conception of Mary - as believed by Catholic Church??
Love and respect from Taxila,wah cantt, for such great information ,and knowledge
Thanks
There is more wisdom in your body than in your deepest philosophy. ~ Friedrich Nietzsche
This channel is going to be the biggest philosophy channel. I can see it coming. ❤
Thanks
Sir Aap Ek Superman Hai..Philosphy Ki Itni Books Apne Pdhdi Hai..Hume Apse Reading Motivation Milti Hai
Haha
Wonderful lecture sir❤
Thx
Thanks a ton
it feels illegal to watch ur content for free... this should be in you tube premium...✨✨
Hahahaha
Great explanation. Need to be continue for next chapter even made numerous videos.
Yes, I will cover a few more chapters of Zarathustra
Excellent 🎉🎉🎉🎉 waiting for the complete coverage of philosophers
Beautiful. You correlate philosophy well
.
Thx
Wow ❤ .. Very nice explanation
इस तरह की वीडियो बनाते रहिए, सर......
You made my day sir , more videos on Nietzsche ❣️
Thank you, I will
Great explanation ❤
I would strongly encourage you to continue incorporating side notes in your videos. They are a distinctive feature of your channel and contribute significantly to your effective teaching method.
What a beautiful explanation sir!!! ❤❤❤
Thanks a ton
Thank you Sir 🙏
Nowadays i am reading Thus Spoke Zarathustra
Excellent work sir
You made me a philosophy nerd ❤
I am in the same boat. 😂
Such a profound thinker being explained in very easy words. Nietzsche must be followed in asian countries aswell. I believe his thinking and philosophy has deeply affected western culture and morality. Thanks bro 😍
Thanks brother
Please include Urdu couplets more frequently ❤❤❤🥰
❤ loved it Sir ❤️
Thx
This is the video I needed thanks very much❤
Thx
Beautiful. Excellent insight. Love your work
Thanks for watching
Amazing Sir what a knowledge ❤
Thanks a ton
Great sir ❤
From india
Great explanation❤
Awesome ❤ Sir You deserve Millions Subcriber . Thanks for uploading new vedeo ❤ Keep it up
Thx
jab apko sunte hai to sochte hai ke kash ap jaisa teacher milta
Haha thanks brother
50:39 lashkar e tayiba
Lashkar ke jhangwi
Al kaida
Isis
Tahrik e labbaik
Taliban
Hijbulla
Hamas
Huti
Or bahut sare "baag, bagiche, garden, park" ke khwahishmand.
sir i love ❤your laughter during explaining serious topics ❤❤❤❤love you
Thx
6:27 Jab aap Chand ki taraf ungali karte h kisi ko chand dikhane ke liye to log chand nahi ungali dekhane lagate h😂
Bahut badhiya .shandaar ...idhar udhar bhatakne me sankoch Naa karen aapke reference bahut achche hote hai unse bhi new information milti hai ...😊
Thanks
یقیں محکم ، عمل پیہم، محبت فاتح عالم۔۔۔۔۔
Great work keep it up brother
Thanks brother
Wonderful explanation.
Thx
I have developed a very close relationship with you. When I started reading Nietzsche's Thus spake Zarathustra, I got goosebumps, my throat was choked, tears were coming out of my eyes, it felt as if I could break stones with my mere thought.
Whatever this great man wrote, he wrote with his blood. The poetic glimpse that we get in it is an exception in itself. Well, I will not be able to express my feelings in real, but I would definitely like to say that I am a student of Philosophy Masters in India and accidentally reached your channel. Most of the books kept in your shelf are also adding beauty to my shelf, from this you can understand that there is some internal relationship between me and you. If possible, I would like to contact you personally, whether it is through mail or WhatsApp or in any other form. I have also been studying these subjects for a long time, so probably there can be some relevant discussion between us.
At present I am reading around 80 books together, this is one of them. And yes, in this video, you and I got emotional at the same time..
Wow - this message made my day brother
Thanks for your message
@@3rd_POV How can I contact you..
My email is given
Great ❤❤❤
excellent combination of words to understand theme of the topic ❤❤❤
Thx
Nice video Sir…. Beyond good and evil pr bhi banaiye please
Finally sir can't wait to watch it..
Thx
Great sir. You are doing great.
Thx
Bhaiya Bhale 10 ghante ki bane ek baar poori video bataiye aapse request hai, maza aa gaya.
Respect Sir. I love Osho too.
Osho sbha sbha exercise krty hoy ziada samajh ata hy , kionky us waqt Hawa mn pure oxygen hoti hy. dmagh ziada kam krta hy
Agreed - I love Osho too
Ku6 Log Janglo Main Rhte Hai With full of oxygen 😅 .... joke 🤣
@@misterliquidity jungle mn information mily apko . ap ziada acha consume krengy, mind it
@@ShahRukh-mu8ry I m with uhh brother bo joke tha ✅
It’s important to consider different philosophical perspectives on Nietzsche’s views to better understand various arguments and derive a balanced understanding. Nietzsche’s idea that pity and compassion make a person weak, and that one should strive to become an “Übermensch” or “superhuman” by overcoming these emotions, has been highly controversial in philosophy. Various philosophers have presented arguments both for and against this view, and here we’ll discuss the thoughts and perspectives of some renowned philosophers on Nietzsche’s ideas:
1. Bertrand Russell - Critique of Nietzsche:
Bertrand Russell strongly opposed Nietzsche’s ideas. According to Russell, Nietzsche’s philosophy limits human life to concepts of “power” and “strength,” ignoring higher emotions like compassion, love, and cooperation. Russell believed that compassion and empathy are essential for human society’s progress, fostering brotherhood and social harmony. For Russell, these qualities form the foundation of civilization.
2. Jean-Paul Sartre - Defense of Nietzsche:
Jean-Paul Sartre partially supported Nietzsche’s theory. Sartre’s philosophy of “existentialism” emphasizes that a person is responsible for their actions and life choices. He believed that individuals should make their own decisions and be self-reliant. Sartre thought that if compassion limits one’s autonomy, it could indeed be a burden. In his view, people should take responsibility for their lives while relying less on others.
3. David Hume - Opposition to Nietzsche:
David Hume considered pity and compassion as essential elements of human morality. He believed that humans are naturally social and empathetic beings, and through compassion, we feel others’ pain and help them. According to Hume, without compassion, people would become self-centered, and social cohesion would erode. For Hume, Nietzsche’s view that compassion makes one weak goes against basic moral principles.
4. Arthur Schopenhauer - A Strong Stance Against Nietzsche:
Schopenhauer praised pity and compassion as noble human qualities. He argued that individuals should go beyond self-interest and show empathy for others. Schopenhauer believed that compassion is necessary to alleviate the suffering and pain in the world. Nietzsche’s theory, which labels compassion as a weakness, could make society harsher and more indifferent, according to Schopenhauer.
5. Ayn Rand - Support of Nietzsche’s Theory:
Ayn Rand incorporated some of Nietzsche’s ideas into her philosophy of “Objectivism.” She argued that individuals should be self-interested and prioritize their own needs. Rand believed that compassion and pity for others divert people from their goals and make them weak. In her view, if everyone took full responsibility for their lives and prioritized their own happiness, it would lead to individual strength and societal progress.
6. Albert Camus - A Different Perspective on Nietzsche:
Albert Camus, a philosopher of “Absurdism,” partly agreed with Nietzsche’s ideas but did not completely reject compassion. Camus believed that life is inherently meaningless, but that doesn’t imply people should be indifferent. He proposed a balanced approach, suggesting that individuals accept life’s absurdity while embracing compassion as part of personal fulfillment. Like Nietzsche, Camus valued autonomy but also saw compassion as meaningful.
Conclusion
Philosophers who opposed Nietzsche argue that compassion and pity are foundational to society, making us morally better individuals. They see Nietzsche’s theory as leading toward self-centeredness and eroding social bonds. On the other hand, philosophers who support Nietzsche’s ideas argue that prioritizing self-reliance and individuality can make people stronger and more independent.
Thus, Nietzsche’s theory is somewhat valid in emphasizing self-reliance and strength, but rejecting compassion and pity altogether might make humanity indifferent and unbalanced.
Great job Ali Bhai
Thx
It is delusional to think that everyone is wrong! The wise never ignore the option of being wrong.
May be you are wrong and me too!!!
Sir, What 1 Teaching You Like The Most From Nietzsche ??
Amor fati
Bahut hi badhiya... thank you.
Thx
I tried long time ago to read this book. Couldn’t understand & dropped. Thanks for great summary & sharing ❤
Thx
sir plz upload other parts. thora jaldi upload kia kren
Sir sir ... Lot's of love
Sir ap hamesha kamal k analysis krty hain. khobsurat content share krty hain.
Please make some video on Arthur Schopenhauer.
aur sath me ye bhi btain k is sab german philosophers ka aj kal ki german society per kya asar para ha?
Thanks
Thanks
Sir videos thoda jaldi laaya Karo morning coffee ke saath videos dekhne ki aadat lag gyi hai 😅
Hahaha I will try my friend
I subscribed to ur channel...believe me bro...I found a gold mine.
Thanks for the sub
Kamal Kamal Ali bhai♥️♥️♥️ Bhai Yuval Noah ki books ka bhi review karay ap please. Thanks❤
Glad to know that you started reading Osho. 🎉🎉
Sir side information diya kro bahut jaruri hota hai or mazza bhi aata hai aesa osho krte hai ❤ ye wisdom ko dikhata hai
Ok
Man u r so hard working. Thank u sir with lots of love❤
Thanks
Osho is the true modern Buddha. He is the voice of Buddha. People never truly listened to the voice of Buddha; they merely heard about him. If anyone listens to Osho, they will realize that he is the voice of Buddha in this modern world.
I love Osho - I very recently started reading him and I am very impressed.
Although I am greatly impressed by many philosophers and thinkers- I don’t completely agree with any one of them.
He didn't the voice of buddha, balki you only listen or read that type of thought , he is not buddha he is not like anyone he is only Osho.. he totally different from any other philosopher
Sir ziada videos banao. Roz aik