Ideogram and Flux smartphones make no sense for 2015, I think that recraft is actually more accurate there, it does look like an old phone. Also you missed the fact that you can create your own image styles.
I think flux makes sense other than the multi-lens camera. The actual shape and look of the case looks exactly like what you'd see back in 2015. And the image quality looks way more like what my old 2015 photos looked like.
i still think from an artistic and cinematic viewpoint is MJ, i just had a go at this and it made boring pics, i came back to MJ and my god the camera shots, the light, the coloring was off the chart. MJ weakness is prompt adherence , but it should be top of that leaderboard.
You did specify 2015, so before you say the phone looks weird or unrealistic, look up how phones looked like in 2015. There was no such thing as multiple lenses, and most of them had a simple small lense near the top in the middle.
The flux phone looks closer to a phone you would see in 2015. The ideogram photo looks like a modern phone, and the image quality looks like a modern photo, just with an older 2015 style Instagram filter on it. The flux image actually looks like the quality phone photos were taking back in 2015
I chose the far right side selfie due to the single camera on the phone... even with the hallucinated "center cam"... a flip phone in the prompt could have killed it! ;)
14:46 Modern web apps MUST adjust for the mobile phone screens. As 95% of the users will use them from the smartphone. So showing one on mobile does not violate the condition. If we go from the statement of training, even professional UI designers sometimes could not tell if the UI is native or a web app (once displayed on mobile), so when image is tagged "web app" it can be either.
I'm not sure I've seen him take these simple criticisms into account in future videos. He reports on a lot of stuff, but he leaves in enough small problems that I think it heavily limits his growth.
Recraft makes odd-looking head and face, look at the Yoga-poses. I bought access to the model, and I find it does this a lot for my generations. Also, when asking it to do fantasy/fictional, it tends to often look like cosplay instead of FLUX which makes it looks stylized. YMMV.
I have to say, you get the best results at 4MP or higher which they do state. So if you do less than you get bad results. You did do most of the generations at 1024. Can't say if it was a fair assessment. @25:00 If you would have picked the style from the list you may have gotten better results, however it wouldn't have been using their best model. I think for a more fair assessment, you'd have to render them all at close to the same pixel rate. There was also a whole section of 20B styles styles at recraft that you missed. I don't know why they don't automatically put all the styles in the list without selecting the combo box first. Great job on showing how to do the layers. I kept only getting recraft option and was getting annoyed with it. I didn't realize that you had to merge down the layers. Overall great job!
Recraft has the most pleasing results, regarding small details it messes up , such as shape of the smartphone one can simply give a little more detailed prompt about the phone he wants to see
"if you wanted to swap this background in photoshop you're going to have a really painful time (...)" nope... you click on the subject to AI-select it, then you inverse the selection and you click "generate" and you change it to whatever background you need. easy as 1-2-3
Must note that most of the teens in that era (especially the hairstyle) did look like the output of recraft. The teens in other 2 images look like today's teens, or young adults. Even the phone looks like its actually from 2014-15.
try packing it, i just got an 'aerial /overhead/ from above' shot... Keep dropping these descriptions into the prompt, dont write proper english, write like a child. - overhead shot of a man in a hallway, i can see the top of his head from this overhead shot, hes walking forward one step at a time as seen in this angle from above . mention things that you would see from above - i can see the persons top of their head,
@@Betonbent try add the words, - symmetry, well balanced, perfectly aligned, and eyes looking straight forward. staring directly at you i sometimes use mugshot or passport photo. If you ever stuck try find artists or photographers who specialise in that pose... wes anderson? Stanley Kubrick? david bailey. The AI might be confused with "camera"? Where is the camera? I'd try, - I am holding a camera, i look thru the lense and looking back is... a woman, head on, perfectly aligned shot
How about jenna ortega makes a handstand on a tree stump taken with a alpha 7 on a rainy day in her garden? Or a sword master cuts a apple falling down with his long sword while using a skateboard? Or a young german man with a body like bruce lee trains with nunchacs while wearing a suite from loose cotton?
09:36 You asked for a 2015 snapchat mirror selfie. In 2015 phones didn't have clusters of multiple cameras like in the Ideogram image (look at IPhone 6S Plus or Samsung Galaxy Note 5 as references for top 2015 phones) so this image is a fail. I would say Recraft actually got this one most period correct. Flux is somewhere in the middle, as Flux shows a poorly defined multiple lens cluster on the camera.
Can the recraft generate an image like "a man is sitting in an aeroplane seat; the seat is very lowered; the woman sitting behind him is very annoyed"? I mean more precise images, not just very, very general.
would be nice to see more good ai generators that can create animestyle. Or maybe some ai tool that can colorize manga and comics or uncensor. I am asking for a friend.
prob just confuse the AI. You'd end up with cats eating a deer, but it would look more like a nature shot. If you found some real gory movies or directors and placed them in the prompt you would get better visuals
From the perspective of the dog and the cat, the dog is on the right, by the viewer yes it's wrong, if you said from the perspective of the viewer it might do it correctly. But it's not 100% wrong.😉
Yoga pose goes to Flux by a mile. You’re reaching when you say recraft was better. Recraft wins the phone shot. Recraft loses tea with the queen. Loses the web landing page. A toss up on heart hands. Loses the snail challenge. So how is it “the best’?
that's what i'm hoping to convey in this video: there's no clear winner. it really depends on the content. recraft is only 'the best' according to the leaderboard
8:58 "This doesn't look like a real phone" Come one. It looks like Nexus 5. 9:07 looks like iPhone 6. You should take a look at actual phones from 2015. 9:37 That is "legit looking phone" from the future.
I don't care how well AI can do images if I can't do nsfw with it. As far as I'm concerned stable diffusion is still kind if you know how to prompt. I just need better coherence.
Wonder how it's even no 1 on the leaderboard seems most of these AI are curating/cherry picking best results to beat the benchmarks yet the performance is average
Are you for real? Did you even live here in 2015 to experience what cheap phones looked like back then? Ideogram got the worst image there cause it's an iPhone. The rest are Android phones... and is thus more prompt coherent.
In 2015, when I was no longer a teenager, I couldn't afford better than a Kazam Trooper: I invite you to google this name, you will find photos of a smartphone no less "ugly" than the one presented by Recraft
Pages that make the rankings receive money from projects to increase their visibility and appear to be of better quality. It really bothers me that they don't notice the post-editing that they have uploaded on their networks. Better learn how to run a local AI and train it, stop feeding those fat parasites.
For me recraft is total fail it try to use buttons and settings. what my envision is buttons, slide bar, settings, etc must be replaced by chat like interface or even natural human AI Conversation interface
Thanks to Mureka for sponsoring this video, a versatile AI platform to create music! bit.ly/4ehrdaq
👋 hi
“This might be the best AI generator” everytime you say that for a new video I’m going to do a shot.
clickbaiting at its finest
💯
*What type of shot are you talking about* 😯
@@DjHazardous Backshot
haha yes, and I'm surprised it's not "insane" and "game changing"
Ideogram and Flux smartphones make no sense for 2015, I think that recraft is actually more accurate there, it does look like an old phone.
Also you missed the fact that you can create your own image styles.
Exactly. That ideogram iPhone must have time traveled. Recraft got it right.
up
I think flux makes sense other than the multi-lens camera. The actual shape and look of the case looks exactly like what you'd see back in 2015. And the image quality looks way more like what my old 2015 photos looked like.
Nice vid ! Flux with loras still wining the war so far
True. I prefer Flux over any other text-to-image model so far.
@@DmitryRomashovit's open source and does not censor images.
i still think from an artistic and cinematic viewpoint is MJ, i just had a go at this and it made boring pics, i came back to MJ and my god the camera shots, the light, the coloring was off the chart. MJ weakness is prompt adherence , but it should be top of that leaderboard.
@armondtanz it's cuz it's not open source. No one talks about MJ. It's not bad but not worth the price.
You did specify 2015, so before you say the phone looks weird or unrealistic, look up how phones looked like in 2015.
There was no such thing as multiple lenses, and most of them had a simple small lense near the top in the middle.
i thought the same thing. Either this dude is younger than 20 or this video was created by AI 🤣😂
I hate when the 'Public' option is mandatory!
Thank you buddy for your effort :)
I got baited by feet
Same, he’s leveraging foot fetish to get clicks.
Or maybe he’s a foot fetishist himself.
The flux phone looks closer to a phone you would see in 2015. The ideogram photo looks like a modern phone, and the image quality looks like a modern photo, just with an older 2015 style Instagram filter on it.
The flux image actually looks like the quality phone photos were taking back in 2015
Why is AI so fast it’s faster than a trend
I chose the far right side selfie due to the single camera on the phone... even with the hallucinated "center cam"... a flip phone in the prompt could have killed it! ;)
man Im hoping someone does a open source and UNCENSORED tired of censorship garbage... nothing good today I'll wait next year..
14:46 Modern web apps MUST adjust for the mobile phone screens. As 95% of the users will use them from the smartphone. So showing one on mobile does not violate the condition. If we go from the statement of training, even professional UI designers sometimes could not tell if the UI is native or a web app (once displayed on mobile), so when image is tagged "web app" it can be either.
Ideogram looking the best to me
Am I blind or where are the links in the description to these topics??? Wtf!
there ain't i've been a subscriber of his and there isn't
I'm not sure I've seen him take these simple criticisms into account in future videos. He reports on a lot of stuff, but he leaves in enough small problems that I think it heavily limits his growth.
Recraft makes odd-looking head and face, look at the Yoga-poses. I bought access to the model, and I find it does this a lot for my generations. Also, when asking it to do fantasy/fictional, it tends to often look like cosplay instead of FLUX which makes it looks stylized. YMMV.
I'll still stick with SD1.5 with controlnet because of the NSFW 😈😈😈
😃😃😃 sdxl is also pretty good
I have to say, you get the best results at 4MP or higher which they do state. So if you do less than you get bad results. You did do most of the generations at 1024. Can't say if it was a fair assessment. @25:00 If you would have picked the style from the list you may have gotten better results, however it wouldn't have been using their best model. I think for a more fair assessment, you'd have to render them all at close to the same pixel rate. There was also a whole section of 20B styles styles at recraft that you missed. I don't know why they don't automatically put all the styles in the list without selecting the combo box first. Great job on showing how to do the layers. I kept only getting recraft option and was getting annoyed with it. I didn't realize that you had to merge down the layers. Overall great job!
To me the Recraft image of the young man with the phone was probably the most accurate for a 2015 phone
Recraft has the most pleasing results, regarding small details it messes up , such as shape of the smartphone one can simply give a little more detailed prompt about the phone he wants to see
"if you wanted to swap this background in photoshop you're going to have a really painful time (...)"
nope...
you click on the subject to AI-select it, then you inverse the selection and you click "generate" and you change it to whatever background you need. easy as 1-2-3
Must note that most of the teens in that era (especially the hairstyle) did look like the output of recraft. The teens in other 2 images look like today's teens, or young adults. Even the phone looks like its actually from 2014-15.
9:33 A phone camera from 2015 wouldn’t look like that.
the dog in recraft IS actually on the right as prompted (and the cat IS on the left), if you consider their position from their POV :)
🤯
Ideogram definitely looks the best to me
For the Snapchat image, recraft did great. Remember, the iPhone 15 was not released in 2015!
NOT THE FEET IN THE THUMBNAIL BRO 😭😭😭😭
Testing text in ai creation is just bonkers, it is just the most easy to change per hand with PS or his clones.
One thing I noticed is that Recraft can't really generate front view shots. Anyone else noticed that?
yes thats my experience as well
try packing it, i just got an 'aerial /overhead/ from above' shot... Keep dropping these descriptions into the prompt,
dont write proper english, write like a child. - overhead shot of a man in a hallway, i can see the top of his head from this overhead shot, hes walking forward one step at a time as seen in this angle from above .
mention things that you would see from above - i can see the persons top of their head,
@@armondtanz i tried frontal view of a woman looking directly into the camera, and i still get this odd side pose shot lol, still has a long way to go
@@Betonbent
try add the words, - symmetry, well balanced, perfectly aligned, and eyes looking straight forward. staring directly at you
i sometimes use mugshot or passport photo.
If you ever stuck try find artists or photographers who specialise in that pose... wes anderson? Stanley Kubrick? david bailey.
The AI might be confused with "camera"? Where is the camera? I'd try, - I am holding a camera, i look thru the lense and looking back is... a woman, head on, perfectly aligned shot
flux all the way . impressive
ideogram looks better
Unrealistic llama sunglasses, they need to be at more of an angle as llamas have a pointy face.
Whats the best for anime style AI image generation? I used to use SD last year
How about jenna ortega makes a handstand on a tree stump taken with a alpha 7 on a rainy day in her garden? Or a sword master cuts a apple falling down with his long sword while using a skateboard? Or a young german man with a body like bruce lee trains with nunchacs while wearing a suite from loose cotton?
09:36 You asked for a 2015 snapchat mirror selfie. In 2015 phones didn't have clusters of multiple cameras like in the Ideogram image (look at IPhone 6S Plus or Samsung Galaxy Note 5 as references for top 2015 phones) so this image is a fail. I would say Recraft actually got this one most period correct. Flux is somewhere in the middle, as Flux shows a poorly defined multiple lens cluster on the camera.
Can the recraft generate an image like "a man is sitting in an aeroplane seat; the seat is very lowered; the woman sitting behind him is very annoyed"? I mean more precise images, not just very, very general.
no, it only generates image with weird man and woman faces
@@Rilex037 Thanks.
would be nice to see more good ai generators that can create animestyle. Or maybe some ai tool that can colorize manga and comics or uncensor. I am asking for a friend.
Does this man not know what a phone looked like in 2015?
How come people who make these A.I. generator videos never do weird prompts like "starving stray feral cats eat roadkill maggot infested deer carcass"
i don't think they wanna see that
prob just confuse the AI. You'd end up with cats eating a deer, but it would look more like a nature shot. If you found some real gory movies or directors and placed them in the prompt you would get better visuals
RUclips TOS
Also the AI companies' TOS.
Lots of ai companies have TOS so strict that you couldn't even recreate most movies.
Which AI image generator is the best at creating hands and feet?
In 2015 there were no phones with cameras like that
Not the dreaded feet pick test 😭😭😭
From the perspective of the dog and the cat, the dog is on the right, by the viewer yes it's wrong, if you said from the perspective of the viewer it might do it correctly. But it's not 100% wrong.😉
Yoga pose goes to Flux by a mile. You’re reaching when you say recraft was better. Recraft wins the phone shot. Recraft loses tea with the queen. Loses the web landing page. A toss up on heart hands. Loses the snail challenge. So how is it “the best’?
that's what i'm hoping to convey in this video: there's no clear winner. it really depends on the content. recraft is only 'the best' according to the leaderboard
So Ideogram is the best!!! 😅
We know that Flux can produce more realistic images with finetuning the settings. I am surprised that by default it produces these "plastic" images.
"no no no, you're better than that, watch you profanity please" ... no profanity was used. stable diffusion still king.
That iphone is definitely not something from 2015 🤣
Cant wait to 3d print my future AI wifey 🤑
Amazing!
flux with loras and controlnets smokes all of them
I tried it and I'm very much not impressed
I’m surprised that people still pay for image generation. Unless they have low end PC I understand. I’m happy with SDXL.
8:58 "This doesn't look like a real phone" Come one. It looks like Nexus 5. 9:07 looks like iPhone 6. You should take a look at actual phones from 2015. 9:37 That is "legit looking phone" from the future.
honestly im sick of closed-source garbage. It's like selling umbrellas to passing cars because it's raining. Things are moving to fast for this.
29:18 jackie legs!!!!
HE CAN'T KEEP GETTING AWAY WITH THIS
But recraft exist for a long time now
Unable to access. Ad blockers and vpn are off, keep getting an aw snap page
9:30 i think recraft generated old phone as compared to quality of picture ,
It not created apple device with 3 cameras
I don't care how well AI can do images if I can't do nsfw with it. As far as I'm concerned stable diffusion is still kind if you know how to prompt.
I just need better coherence.
Wonder how it's even no 1 on the leaderboard seems most of these AI are curating/cherry picking best results to beat the benchmarks yet the performance is average
My reaction on 8:52 having the exact same phone while he calls it ugly and not looking real 😞
Sir , why ai does not sleep ?
22:10 incorrect. That's a pyramid.
i seen this exact video before on another channel
PonyXL >>>
Actually, Imagen 3 is the best overall image generator, and nobody is using it.
ay you post this in all of these videos i tried using it and they require you to pay to even make humans lol that's wild.
Lol ikr! Imagen 3 is garbage! @@brockhampton3078
2.7 on the App Store, yeah no thanks
How..cool..is..THAT?
Ai Jesus Facebook accounts: 🤑🤑🤑🤑
F E E T
it's the best
26:12 🤨
If it's not open source, I don't give a...
but i need offline solutions. online ones are way costly to try and learn. :(
Are you for real? Did you even live here in 2015 to experience what cheap phones looked like back then? Ideogram got the worst image there cause it's an iPhone. The rest are Android phones... and is thus more prompt coherent.
Still looks bad. We are not there yet.
In 2015, when I was no longer a teenager, I couldn't afford better than a Kazam Trooper: I invite you to google this name, you will find photos of a smartphone no less "ugly" than the one presented by Recraft
Pages that make the rankings receive money from projects to increase their visibility and appear to be of better quality.
It really bothers me that they don't notice the post-editing that they have uploaded on their networks.
Better learn how to run a local AI and train it, stop feeding those fat parasites.
i like ideogram more
Let me guess. Captain Kirk school of diction and public speaking?
But it's not open-source so I won't use it.
For me recraft is total fail it try to use buttons and settings. what my envision is buttons, slide bar, settings, etc must be replaced by chat like interface or even natural human AI Conversation interface
i think by the time 2025 hits you will be out of ideas for cool video titles :DD
WTF is a teenage man or teenage woman? Are you trying to confuse the AI? Sneaky…
Too bad again it’s not open source.
Bro why you always put feet on the thumbnail 😭
Is it censored?
It all looks fake af😂
3rd
😃
Spoiler: It's not the best picture generator. It's about as close to flux as I am to the moon.
So no local install 💩😒
it can do feet pic ;)
Nope
Why does bro put feet in every thumbnail💀
22:10 incorrect. That's a pyramid.