Why Jarrad Branthwaite Is NOT Worth More Than £50m...

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 май 2024
  • Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code HOWSON for an extra 3 months free at surfshark.deals/howson
    Welcome Everton fans... The response from you lot to my tweet has been electric (they are not happy.) In the original tweet, Branthwaite was pictured alongside some elite centre-backs with some very high ceilings, yet he is the one being quoted for the highest price? Todibo, Araujo, Antonio Silva, De Ligt, Lucami, Tapsoba, Bremer, Kilman, all of the names that were pictured in this post alongside Branthwaite. Today I am going to dive in and show you why Jarrad Branthwaite is not worth what he is being valued at...
    🔔 Subscribe now for the freshest Football and Manchester United updates straight from Old Trafford. Here, you’ll be the first to catch:
    🏟️ Football News: From the Premier League to the Champions League, we have all the hottest news covered.
    🥅 Man Utd News: Get the latest scoops straight from Old Trafford.
    🌟 Man United Academy News: Keeping tabs on the future stars of the club.
    🎥 Live Stream Reactions: Join us as we share live reactions to all the Premier League and Champions League matches.
    🎬 Manchester United Documentaries & Vlogs: Deep dives and behind-the-scenes insights into your favourite team.
    ⚽ Goals, Highlights & Player Analysis: Detailed analyses focusing on stars such as Bruno Fernandes and Marcus Rashford.
    🎧 Podcasts: Tune in for rich discussions featuring special guests and Erik ten Hag's press conference reactions.
    📢 Transfers & Premier League Buzz: Be the first to know all the freshest transfers and Premier League news.
    Your support is our strength! Contribute and enjoy exclusive perks:
    💖 Patreon: Access behind-the-scenes and more here: bit.ly/HowsonPatreon
    💎 RUclips Membership: Unlock exclusive perks: / @stephenhowson
    Deepen the conversation:
    Check out Howson IRL here: / @howson-irl
    💬 Reddit: Engage with our community: / howson
    🎤 Podcast: Tune into our in-depth discussions: apple.co/1qQHSdF
    Stay Connected:
    👍 Facebook: / mrstephenhowson
    🐦 Twitter: / mrstephenhowson
    📸 Instagram: / mrstephenhowson
    🎵 TikTok: / mrstephenhowson
    🌐 For more, visit: www.stephenhowson.com
    #ManchesterUnited #JarradBranthwaite #Branthwaite
  • СпортСпорт

Комментарии • 350

  • @mundolioknows6447
    @mundolioknows6447 29 дней назад +135

    Remember when Evan Ferguson was worth £120m about a year ago? Not sure i've heard his name since.

    • @patrickmullins7981
      @patrickmullins7981 28 дней назад +7

      He's 19 and has had a couple injuries , struggled to find form in a disrupted season for him. You writing him off completely is such a social media age thing to do.

    • @retrorunner984
      @retrorunner984 28 дней назад +11

      Writing off a 19 year old who scored a hatrick ar 18 is proper tik tok behaviour. As is calling him a £120 million striker off the same performances. Let the lad play, time reveals all.

    • @mundolioknows6447
      @mundolioknows6447 28 дней назад

      @@patrickmullins7981how did I "write him off completely"? I'm saying while he was playing well just a year ago, everyone was throwing crazy price tags around for him. Here we are a year later and he barely gets a mention.
      This is not a dig at Ferguson, I think he's got a good future. It's a dig at people that get carried away by a decent breakthrough season. People get carried away. Same as Neto back in September when he got 8 assists in the first few weeks, people saying we should get rid of Rashford and bring in Neto, prices of £70-£80m being thrown around. He's gone on to get 2 goals and 1 assist since then.
      Your response is pure social media age. Over emotional about an emotionless comment. Quick to defend something without even understanding the point. Go dye your hair blue and join a protest.

    • @mundolioknows6447
      @mundolioknows6447 28 дней назад +2

      @@retrorunner984 see my response to the other guy who's comment you copied almost word for word.

    • @mundolioknows6447
      @mundolioknows6447 28 дней назад +10

      @@patrickmullins7981 ok my first reply to you was deleted for some reason.
      But basically I said that this isn't a dig at Ferguson. I happen to think he's got a good future. It's about the ridiculous price tags that get bounded about when a young player has a decent breakthrough. One year on, that hype has fizzled out along with his goals.
      The video is about Branthwaite, who's had a pretty decent season. But there's no way he's a £70m player.
      Your response is typical of the social media age. Quick to get emotional over an emotionless comment without even understanding the point.

  • @TheManchesterUnitedWay
    @TheManchesterUnitedWay 29 дней назад +114

    Finally someone speaking sense about Branthwaite.. 40 to 50 mil MAX defenders like Silva,Inacio,Todibo,Simakan those are some of the CB that ar WAY BETTER than him !

    • @rustanpienaar
      @rustanpienaar 29 дней назад +1

      100%

    • @TheBatmanWhoReacts
      @TheBatmanWhoReacts 29 дней назад +2

      Only one of those is the left footed CB 10hag loves for his system

    • @user-ig1ps2mr2r
      @user-ig1ps2mr2r 29 дней назад +4

      Imo, we should go for CBs who play in a more progressive system. Inacio/Diomande from Sporting, Tapsoba/Hincapie from Leverkusen, Hato from Ajax, Scalvini, Simakan (can play CB/RB), Geertruida from Feyenoord. There are so so many options!! Jarrad might develop to be one of the best CBs in the league but the fee demanded and the system he plays currently don't make this signing a sure shot success.

    • @Zeppelin180
      @Zeppelin180 29 дней назад +1

      @@TheBatmanWhoReactsNo one’s being bought for Ten Hag’s ‘system’ anymore, mate

    • @kofiboakye6173
      @kofiboakye6173 29 дней назад

      He'll never develop to be one of the cbs in the league. ​@@user-ig1ps2mr2r

  • @gazb0075
    @gazb0075 29 дней назад +22

    I’ve been saying for weeks Branthwaite was a rip off and I’d questioned his decision making and was slated for it in the comments. Nice to see someone actually giving some thought about him instead of just reading and siding with media bs.

  • @Slayer-xc1ug
    @Slayer-xc1ug 29 дней назад +16

    Spot on Steve. My dad is 83 on Tuesday. He's been watching united since 1950. He was right off on one when he heard Branthwaite was being linked. He can't stand him. Can't say his exact words on here but he was spot on. I'm sending this to his phone. He'll love how you pointed out what he he's been saying. Well said mate. Never a united player. 👏👏👏

    • @oldjoeclarke.
      @oldjoeclarke. 28 дней назад

      Happy birthday to your dad from me and all real United fans.🎂🍰🧁

  • @arubeian5461
    @arubeian5461 29 дней назад +85

    Finally someone not falling for the hype

    • @billbaggiotmua372
      @billbaggiotmua372 29 дней назад +3

      He was on the floor more than on his feet against united at o.t. , he's bloody useless.

    • @derekgraham1570
      @derekgraham1570 29 дней назад +1

      Being saying this for ages

    • @derekgraham1570
      @derekgraham1570 29 дней назад +1

      Any defender on the ground shows no positional sense. Look at Paul McGrath never was on the ground with last ditch tackles

  • @tobyli52
    @tobyli52 29 дней назад +52

    The fact that we didnt sign Akanji for free and is looking at Brathnwaite for £50mil….

    • @directorme6669
      @directorme6669 29 дней назад +8

      Man united have NEVER had a plan in place for their transfer business for the las 10 years! For club of Man united's stature, it's beyond embarrassing! That's why we've overpaid for flops

    • @prajyotraikar8553
      @prajyotraikar8553 29 дней назад

      And also we sign Varane for 40m when Captain Ramos was available for Free

    • @JoeChard
      @JoeChard 29 дней назад

      @@prajyotraikar8553ramos didn’t want to come tho

    • @kane2418
      @kane2418 29 дней назад +2

      Annoying because Akanji is also a United fan

    • @damilolapaul993
      @damilolapaul993 29 дней назад +4

      You’ll hate akanji at United. City covers a lot of his deficiencies

  • @user-rn2dg1lj7w
    @user-rn2dg1lj7w 29 дней назад +34

    Absolutely agree! Have been saying this for ages since the links to Man Utd came, and as a norwegian non-english biased fan, he's just hyped up bc of his nationality as you said.

  • @user-uw4yw6bc8k
    @user-uw4yw6bc8k 29 дней назад +40

    TODIBO 40 MIL

    • @andrewtomlinson5237
      @andrewtomlinson5237 29 дней назад +1

      Plays well in a team that looks to play long balls against the press... I thought that was the style we want to move away from?

  • @LeeTAZ-sl7de
    @LeeTAZ-sl7de 29 дней назад +19

    If we are signing a player just because we need to keep our English quota up ide rather go for Guehi at Palace I recon we would get him for a bit cheaper and he's a solid CB. I like Braithwaite but he's been a bit up and down whenever I've watched him for every good thing he does he makes two bad choices, I know he's young but for that money it's a risky move.

    • @user-ig1ps2mr2r
      @user-ig1ps2mr2r 29 дней назад

      Yes, we have been linked to Olise from Palace but instead it should be Guehi who must be the more prior signing from Palace. He has played for England 2-3 times and looked very comfortable on the ball.

    • @rana1561
      @rana1561 29 дней назад

      That's absolutely right, people are mixing the 2 things, he is not generational, he is a good young talent, but extremely overpriced. At the same time, if his price tag lowers in coming season, him being young, he'll be a good purchase to any stable team that can give him time to develop.

    • @Alex-cm7hr
      @Alex-cm7hr 26 дней назад

      Liverpool want Guehi and will probably get him.

  • @SneakyB
    @SneakyB 29 дней назад +21

    Tosin Aradabaiyo is available for free btw.

    • @ILKILO1
      @ILKILO1 29 дней назад +1

      Quality player but also one of the most injury prone Cb's in the league.

    • @SneakyB
      @SneakyB 29 дней назад +5

      @@ILKILO1 hmmm... he's only had 4 injuries since 2018 while maguire had double that in the same period; branthwaite had 6; todibo had 11 in the same period.

    • @ILKILO1
      @ILKILO1 29 дней назад +2

      @@SneakyB i mean from what I can see here he's approximately missed 1 season and a half out of his 4 season at Fulham due to injury, which isn't exactly the worse injury record I've seen but not great either. I suppose if he did come in as 3rd or 4th choice it won't be as much of a problem

    • @SneakyB
      @SneakyB 29 дней назад

      @@ILKILO1 I'm comparing records from transfermarkt by the way.

  • @garysmith1206
    @garysmith1206 28 дней назад +5

    Should be interesting coming back to this in 5 years times. I think this will be up there with some of Howson classics like "Lukaku is better than Kane" and " We need to buy Koulibaly ". The stats hes looking at mean nothing. Branthwaite is playing in a lower end side in the PL. Where as the other players are playing in good sides in other leagues. So of course there stats are better.

  • @stevenhardware7404
    @stevenhardware7404 29 дней назад +13

    We will end up getting Maguired again😅

  • @user-uw4yw6bc8k
    @user-uw4yw6bc8k 29 дней назад +20

    HAS MANU MUG RECRUITMENT ALL OVER IT. 80 MIL TROUSERS DOWN😂

    • @jimharris1358
      @jimharris1358 29 дней назад +5

      Who’s manu? Don’t he play rugby

    • @victorokeke3395
      @victorokeke3395 29 дней назад

      ​@@jimharris1358yeah, in the Gallagher Premiership (as of 2023)

  • @Nightsu
    @Nightsu 29 дней назад +7

    Everton fans backing their own player is one thing, twitter tacticos forcing a narrative to make themselves sound smart to their robotic followers is another thing.
    *Tosin on a free is a better player and deal.

  • @user-ig1ps2mr2r
    @user-ig1ps2mr2r 29 дней назад +6

    Look, he has some traits, PL experience, set-piece threat, and having a homegrown player helps but the main issue is we don't know whether he is comfortable playing on the front foot. Ofc, with his qualities, he could adapt easily like Rice did from West Ham to Arsenal but for the fee we are paying, it has to be an absolute guarantee. All the world class CBs like Kim (€50M to Bayern), De Light (€70M to Juve), Van Dijk (€75M), White (€55M), Laporte (€65M) and many more have gone for a similar range of fee which Everton would demand. So, would it be wise? For eg, Real Madrid and many other clubs are looking at Yoro who will go for €70-80M. Scalvini, Simakan, Geertruida, Hato, A Silva, Tapsoba and so many options are there. The best decision would be to get 2 CBs in the range of €40-45M (like Todibo) and then for the 2nd CB signing, target cheap/free options like Tosin from Fulham. It's not about getting "world class or big names" but it's about getting the right "profile" in. Our recruitment has to be focused on the latter part. Jarrad would make sense if we sell our English players and get some fee for them, like Maguire for €30M and AWB for €15-20M. So, the net spend would be less and our homegrown quota won't be compromised.

  • @MrFemiOwoeye
    @MrFemiOwoeye 29 дней назад +6

    If United signs him for exorbitant fees, they’re still making the same errors of the past. He’s not all that.

  • @anup300684
    @anup300684 29 дней назад +4

    Brilliant analysis. I had my doubts about Branthwaite and this confirms it. I see him more as in 40-50 range as someone who would be a backup to Licha and also sometimes to Shaw, in case we don’t buy a new LB this summer.
    Lucumi at Bologna for the reported 25m is a better deal if we want to use funds better this summer

  • @gustaaf1892
    @gustaaf1892 29 дней назад +6

    Totally agree. The moment a young player strings a few decent games together in England the hype begins and players almost overnight are valued at astronomical sums of money. English hype is worse than hype in any other country. Howson needs to send this video to United because we will once again be wasting our money on a player who is going to disappoint. I don't want him even for 30m because I doubt he'll ever be of the standard that we require if we are to return to the top. Big money should only be invested in players who will definitely improve us.

    • @gustaaf1892
      @gustaaf1892 23 дня назад

      @@shadow_realm47 United is NOT buying. He is 95m now? Tomorrow it will be 100m I suppose. Did you even listen to the analysis presented in this video? Get a mental health check because there is something seriously wrong with your brain.

  • @thebizness5596
    @thebizness5596 29 дней назад +5

    Finally, he is another bang average english defender. We have been stung with Maguire and Shaw and we don’t need another. Rather we got Ignacio.

  • @ufokemo
    @ufokemo 29 дней назад +7

    To be honest. Only generational defenders are worth above £50m

  • @Luna-zp3mt
    @Luna-zp3mt 29 дней назад +23

    Ste, we need this video on Onana. Too many people are inflating his technical ability

    • @someasiandude8645
      @someasiandude8645 29 дней назад +14

      oh thank god someone actaully points this out thought i was the only one. never understood the overwhelming hype

    • @g0320
      @g0320 28 дней назад

      I have been saying that fir ages! One game vs Spurs at Spurs…. In ONE game he let the ball go under his foot three or four times! In one fucking game. Just a shitter Fellaini essentially. At least Fellaini was actually unconventionally ‘tidy’ with his touch

    • @Sam-bd7gp
      @Sam-bd7gp 28 дней назад +1

      Yep. We need midfielders to dictate, not just tackle

    • @0ijm3409fiwrekj
      @0ijm3409fiwrekj 28 дней назад

      Onana in last years champions league final, showed how we he can get the ball to the strikers consistently, city had no answer to him

    • @ayaanlatif2296
      @ayaanlatif2296 28 дней назад +3

      @@0ijm3409fiwrekjI think they’re talking about amadou not Andre

  • @jeee6835
    @jeee6835 26 дней назад +2

    You could make clips of every single defender in the world making what you think are mistakes. Van dijk is making them week in week out. Everton are just outside the relegation places and they have the 4th best defence in the league. Thats crazy. Not all down to branthwaite but he's a big part of it.
    This lads a very good defender who's going to get better. The hype has nothing to do with him.

  • @olliemorland249
    @olliemorland249 2 дня назад +1

    As an everton fan, If you dont want, we will happily keep him.

  • @tobyli52
    @tobyli52 29 дней назад +7

    Kambwala looks as good as him

  • @sibusisongcobo6635
    @sibusisongcobo6635 29 дней назад +5

    I'm so glad you did this video Ste, the 1st thing that stood out to me when we played them at OT is how much he dives in and goes to the ground. People need to stop with the hype over this kid, fucking Maldini? Really? Fuck me

  • @ElEmElEkv13
    @ElEmElEkv13 29 дней назад +4

    English tax is a real thing as is homegrown registration rule. With United needing to offload mostly homegrown players, they need to take every single opportunity to bring in home grown talent. That's why Branthwaite will be too expensive and that's why we should be bringing Frimpong in.

  • @XboneMalone
    @XboneMalone 29 дней назад +4

    Not worth paying more than £40m for him. Which means we'll sign him for £70m. BUT Murtough ain't here no more!

    • @shadow_realm47
      @shadow_realm47 23 дня назад +1

      naah I'm not selling him for a penny less than 95m. More goals than Anthony :P

  • @ChipHound
    @ChipHound 29 дней назад +7

    That's worrying Ste...
    Would be interesting to hear your thoughts about Antonio Silva (Benfica) and Giorgio Scalvini (Atalanta).

    • @ShaunWiesner
      @ShaunWiesner День назад

      Nobody mentions scalvini that boy looks like a legend in the making i don't even know if he's for sale if we can get him he would be the perfect replacement for varane

    • @ChipHound
      @ChipHound День назад

      @@ShaunWiesner Fully agree. Really impressed with his IQ and pace after watching several Atalanta games this past season 👍🏼👏🏽

  • @jessetaylor4357
    @jessetaylor4357 29 дней назад +10

    We should avoid him at all costs he’s not worth the money and I agree with Ste he’s not all that there are much better and much cheaper CB’s around than him imo

    • @InfamousWarriorFC
      @InfamousWarriorFC 29 дней назад

      name them (excluding todibo)

    • @jessetaylor4357
      @jessetaylor4357 29 дней назад

      @@InfamousWarriorFC ok smartass Todibo Silva Bremer Tapsoba De ligt Kilman Lucumi and Araujo so Yh think I put you in place m8 👌😂

    • @InfamousWarriorFC
      @InfamousWarriorFC 29 дней назад

      @@jessetaylor4357 i litterally said excluding todibo, and bremer is fucking 27 in his prime and ur comparing him to a 21 year old + we r building the future bremer is out in like 3 years lmao, and if u think chelsea is selling silva ur dumb

    • @InfamousWarriorFC
      @InfamousWarriorFC 29 дней назад +1

      @@jessetaylor4357 I said excluding todibo, silva is not going and bremer is 27 they r not youngsters which is what united is looking for + they r in their prime and ur comparing them to a youngster, tapsoba already said he wont leave bayer as he wants to be part of the project, and de ligt snubbed united just like 2-3 weeks ago, kilman is 5 years older too and in his prime, araujo is 100m+ lmao only reasonable one is lucumi

    • @InfamousWarriorFC
      @InfamousWarriorFC 29 дней назад

      @@jessetaylor4357 no response? haha I owned ur dumbass and put u in ur place

  • @ManchesterUnitedcallouts
    @ManchesterUnitedcallouts 29 дней назад +11

    HANCKO has all branthwaite strengths plus more , cheaper aswell , can play left back and centre back , technical , pro active , physical , can strike the ball well , good in the air , recovery pace , 1v1 solid

    • @thomasgrant8074
      @thomasgrant8074 29 дней назад

      If he goes anywhere he'll go to Liverpool

    • @harrywood6083
      @harrywood6083 29 дней назад

      And he’s 5 years older……

    • @ManchesterUnitedcallouts
      @ManchesterUnitedcallouts 29 дней назад +2

      @@harrywood6083 thats also fine ...... the whole team dont need to be 20 , 26 for a defender is also young , could get 7 years out of him

    • @berserker135
      @berserker135 29 дней назад

      too old

    • @ManchesterUnitedcallouts
      @ManchesterUnitedcallouts 29 дней назад +2

      @@berserker135 26 is not old
      this aint fifa

  • @ankitrawat4736
    @ankitrawat4736 28 дней назад +2

    Exactly ste. Thanks for calling this out. Silva and diomande or todibo are the ones to go for.

  • @g0320
    @g0320 29 дней назад +4

    I have commented on him about 4 times since this Branthwaite talk started. I didn’t watch him closely but didn’t see anything great in his matched I did see.
    I watched the game at OT though. so decided to watch him closely and he was average. Twice he tried to drive out with the ball but miscontrolled the ball and we broke on them.
    If he was not English and not playing already in the Prem, he’d be a decent ‘prospect’ buy at £20m. To have this talk of £60m to even £80m (🤣🤣🤣) is just embarrassing

  • @larryjohnston5995
    @larryjohnston5995 28 дней назад +2

    I think it is actually true, he is not worth the hype. Antonio Silva is worth more taking a risk than Jarred. He is bullied easily especially how Halaand exposed him when he bullied him one on one. He is not physically good as Todibo or Tapsoba.

  • @RedDevilDog1207
    @RedDevilDog1207 29 дней назад +2

    Spot on, for 70M plus you should get Branthwaite and Todibo, with croissant and a coffee change to spare. Also why we connected to a deep playing CB to replace a ... deep playing CB who may be better on ball and in air aka Maguire. Faster and younger, but priority?

  • @ethans9105
    @ethans9105 29 дней назад

    Video analysis is a great addition, what would be good is comparing the player to one we're linked to for much less or a player in our squad who's deemed not good enough showing they're better than the target

  • @Sam-bd7gp
    @Sam-bd7gp 28 дней назад +1

    Completely agree. Names just get elevated for no reason these days.

  • @josefstalin4418
    @josefstalin4418 26 дней назад +3

    We'll keep him then, go after another defender

  • @TheDeadlyTikka
    @TheDeadlyTikka 29 дней назад +1

    He is undeniably a good centre back. He's worth 30 to 40 million in today's market.
    However with the English and Manchester United tax he will end up being 80+ million

  • @dmaunsell88
    @dmaunsell88 29 дней назад +2

    Coming after and tearing apart a 21 year old learning his trade in the premier league. Classy as always Ste.

    • @Jakeindbox
      @Jakeindbox 29 дней назад

      For the price tag we should be expecting a ready quality premier league centre half. The video is justified!

    • @shadow_realm47
      @shadow_realm47 23 дня назад +1

      @@Jakeindbox united cant really afford him. City will get him if they lose the league. He's better for Pep's System anyway.

  • @JakeDriver
    @JakeDriver 29 дней назад +1

    It reminds me a lot of when we where first being linked with Maguire and you heard all the shite about how he was suppose to be elite with the ball at his feet.

  • @rana1561
    @rana1561 29 дней назад +1

    The price on Branthwaite will obviously be overblown, he is not worth that much money, but he definitely is a good player, but judging by how people are already looking down on him, people will either regret when he joins some other good side in the league and improves, or if he joins us, will incessantly shit on him the way people did on Maguire even when he was alright, and pounced even harder after the Greek incident destroyed his confidence, and the price tag was the major factor in all this. Also, his PSV stint showed more glimpses of him being good in a more proactive side than what regimented approach Dyche needs to make clubs survive and stay in premier league.

  • @Njpro
    @Njpro 29 дней назад +1

    I love to see content creators shouting each other out. Let's keep up that vibe

  • @pujanmaharjan9718
    @pujanmaharjan9718 29 дней назад +1

    Now this is what we call a calculated analysis of a player. Ofc he's a good player with a high ceiling but the hype has gone way too far. This is the problem with most PL viewers too. If a player has one good season, all of sudden he's next big thing.

  • @higgsboson2280
    @higgsboson2280 3 дня назад

    I think he plays backup LB and backup LCB. At LB he'd be the one that inverts into midfield or stays back during attacks to make a back 3.

  • @afaangrewal1427
    @afaangrewal1427 6 дней назад

    Wouldn't say getting beat by Cole Palmer is something to criticise too hard as we've seen it time and time again even with Vidic vs. Fernando Torres that was far more consistent of a tearing and TAA albeit criticised a lot for defensive ability (Though it's not that bad) was down on the ground in his first season, remember Rashford putting him on his back vs us but he's grown a lot and plenty can see he could play for any team in the world. Serious talent is Branthwaite positional awareness comes with age and training.

  • @davidgevans8932
    @davidgevans8932 28 дней назад +1

    He's raw but there is real potential there

  • @danielberry4765
    @danielberry4765 29 дней назад +1

    Muppetiers was absolutely convinced he was a serious target, so then I started watching him more closely, and have become more unimpressed as time has passed. I do really like his passing out from the back on his left foot between the lines. That stat is misleading because of the team he is in. I think he's very rash like Bailly just rushing in and getting beaten. He also goes to ground too much. I think there is a player there and some improvement will occur but the 70m price is unrealistic.
    Everton have to sell players before July for P&S, so prices might come down for him and Onana.

  • @Givin_it_a_go
    @Givin_it_a_go 28 дней назад

    Incredible research, and Superbly presented - Your points have been well and truly Proven!... Case Closed mate! 👍🏻

  • @neilmorgan3040
    @neilmorgan3040 28 дней назад +2

    Palmer rinsed him , Haaland left him on his arse , English hype as usual . He’s on Harry Maguires level

  • @user-zc2sz1os3j
    @user-zc2sz1os3j 28 дней назад +1

    If Brantwaithe is a generational talent, then football is dead.

  • @davidpeters8821
    @davidpeters8821 3 дня назад

    Thank you. This is a bench player to me. Needs a lot more time to develop. Goes to ground way too quickly for someone of that size and pace. Stay up man...

  • @alderazi7
    @alderazi7 28 дней назад

    Great video, lets have more videos like this of other players were gonna be linked to

  • @anonymohs8394
    @anonymohs8394 28 дней назад

    Well said! For me, Todibo, Tosin + Lucumi for a combined £65m-£70m is the way to go. Brainthwaite is ok but not at the price being quoted. We need to make value for money signings this window.

  • @Mrricko.
    @Mrricko. 28 дней назад

    Can’t forget how Harland just brushed him off and ran through to score

  • @mikecramman498
    @mikecramman498 29 дней назад +1

    Absolutely agree with you on this Ste, he's had a good season but that's it

  • @Lange2284
    @Lange2284 29 дней назад +1

    Finally someone addressing this. Hes like a mcsauce defender...
    Im sure he has potiential , but he gets caught out soooo many times

  • @scottellis2410
    @scottellis2410 28 дней назад

    Ste is 100% right.
    I said on Twitter a while ago that I bet Gareth Southgate was disappointed when he joined up with the squad and saw enough in training to know he wernt ready yet
    I’ve seen pundits put him in their starting 11 for England… Embarrassing

  • @goalsforgeorge9096
    @goalsforgeorge9096 29 дней назад

    Very good video!Better defenders in the championship, Portuguese league and French league that would cost 20-30M!
    Hype job as usual!

  • @WesternSydney10
    @WesternSydney10 23 дня назад

    People forget he's young, English, fast and has incredible potential he's easily 80 mill. The transfer fee especially for young players represent their potential.

    • @ekuniverse1
      @ekuniverse1 4 дня назад

      City can have him, I'd rather take Tomori.

  • @wobbphillipworrall1426
    @wobbphillipworrall1426 29 дней назад

    Kind of agree with you on that Stephen, he doesn't seem a cultured centre half seems more of a modern maguire, he's a good player but he's not the 50 to 60 million. 35 or 40 maybe if we could only get 1 centre half it would be Todibo but Branthwaite is left footed and a left footed centre half seems to be priority for Ten hag

  • @cameronhirtle7316
    @cameronhirtle7316 4 дня назад

    As an Everton fan, please overlook Jarrad and I hope we sell Onana, anybody we can to keep this partnership alive. You can keep Maguire.

    • @ekuniverse1
      @ekuniverse1 4 дня назад

      100% City and Real Madrid will never buy him. United need to buy world class players if we want to win UCL and Premier Leagues.

  • @davidpearson6785
    @davidpearson6785 28 дней назад

    100% agree again, if we buy this profile of player then we have learnt absolutely zero lessons from the past 10 years. It's too much money to pay I'm guessing the English tax but let's pay a third of that money for someone equally as good from elsewhere

  • @johnpembroke4899
    @johnpembroke4899 29 дней назад +1

    Gareth Bale and Gary Neville were total laughing stocks when they started out in defense for Spurs and Utd. It takes time for young players to adapt. Only a proper expert like Wilcox can judge Branthwaites ceiling

  • @wh906
    @wh906 29 дней назад

    What some are forgetting compared to other defenders we are interested in. He hasn't played in Europe on a weekly

  • @willg8637
    @willg8637 29 дней назад

    Fundamentally agree. Know an Everton season ticket holder said he is the only player since Rooney 100% sure will reachthe top, whih surprises me, I think heis reallygood but we don need to spend that ona left cb. Personally think Lukeba better there and a few others for the righ cbwhich is morei mportant.....However, we SHOULD be selling British players, areliterallyonly two we should def hang on to....so we maybeneedto sign some and outside of Braithwaite and far less so Archie Gray, which others are there we havea chance of signing?

  • @AnCacaMilis
    @AnCacaMilis 29 дней назад

    He has potential for certain. But ineos cant be taking massive risks in transfers like we have previously. Someone like Todibo is a risk too (poor mentality in the past) but for 30-40 mill you almost cant go wrong

  • @hovsepfestekjian1375
    @hovsepfestekjian1375 29 дней назад

    Nicholas Williams(Spain)LM RM 21y.o.181cm 67kg************50 Mill (Perfect For M.U.

  • @35andyman
    @35andyman 29 дней назад

    I'm old-fashioned maybe, but for me an £80 million centre half should be the finished article, or on the brink of being so. He has good potential that I'd take a punt on for half that amount.

  • @hovsepfestekjian1375
    @hovsepfestekjian1375 29 дней назад

    Ousmane Diomande(Cote d'Ivoire)CB20y.o.190cm 86kg*********25 Mill
    David Hancko(Slovakia)CB LB 25y.o.188cm 80kg**************35 Mill LF

  • @pawal_1999
    @pawal_1999 29 дней назад

    The halfway line challenge , i dont see it as a bad thing in itself . .... Part of our problem is because we dont attempt / win that ball....we retreat ...so rather than try & have the chance towin it high and continue in their half , & stopping the potential oppo atack early enough for it to not registerasanything .... weve dismissed that option in favour of retreating & hopefully dealing withit much closer to goal .
    Im not convinced of branthwaite either for that money , but that is the aggression i want to see , the mentality to realise that challenge has a big plus side , rather than instinctively retreating ..... Close the hole starts with that aggressive mentality imo

  • @3mielu88
    @3mielu88 29 дней назад +1

    Bro, you said Amrabat is better deal than Rice

  • @Chriztefur
    @Chriztefur 29 дней назад +2

    United need to show their steel here and not get baited by it. INEOS have the chance to start strong and go down a different path with recruitment.
    Branthwaite has £75m-80m flop written all over him. English tax and Everton being difficult to negotiate with won’t help any club, let alone United who are prone to signing players for double their worth.

    • @InfamousWarriorFC
      @InfamousWarriorFC 29 дней назад

      then in a few years when he does amazing yall would say u always believed in him

    • @Chriztefur
      @Chriztefur 29 дней назад

      @@InfamousWarriorFC United have missed out on far better players than Branthwaite. Could have signed Hazard before he went to Chelsea, could have signed Haaland, etc.
      Won’t lose sleep over missing out on an overpriced, left footed Maguire. There are CB’s with a better profile all over Europe who would be cheaper.

    • @InfamousWarriorFC
      @InfamousWarriorFC 29 дней назад

      @@Chriztefur name the players who u think is better than branthwaite and would cost cheaper

    • @kylereed3357
      @kylereed3357 29 дней назад +1

      ​@@InfamousWarriorFCCould sign about 40 cbs for cheaper than 80 million. He's also not very good. Just another case of the kids overhyping a bang average player

    • @shadow_realm47
      @shadow_realm47 23 дня назад +1

      Everton being difficult to negotiate with is the most delulu United fan take Ever.

  • @RSPMUFC
    @RSPMUFC 29 дней назад

    Can’t see us signing any single player for 80m plus. Maybe this is a case of us trying to take advantage of Everton’s financial situation, for a player that has the potential to grow with the club. I also think we’re likely to bring in two CBs.

  • @guesswho5905
    @guesswho5905 29 дней назад

    Reminds me of Maguire with a bit more pace. Todibo and Bastoni are where I'd spend money.

  • @LeaoK2
    @LeaoK2 18 дней назад +1

    Not another Maguire!!!!
    This Club will actually be the death of me!!!

  • @patrickmullins7981
    @patrickmullins7981 28 дней назад

    We probably should have stopped using these stats as a barometer of a players quality after we signed Amrabat. I thought we were signing prime Busquets.

  • @wiZZO2204
    @wiZZO2204 5 дней назад

    Scalvini of Atalanta has a far higher ceiling and is double the player he is already and yet he is worth 40 mil..... We should not sign any English players from any clubs in the PL

  • @carldarville8700
    @carldarville8700 29 дней назад +1

    Agree with most of your video, however you can analyse any defender and get the worst clips up and say they aren’t very good.
    Same as you can get clips/highlights of players and make them look good.
    Stats and clips can be manipulated to fit an agenda

    • @StephenHowson
      @StephenHowson  29 дней назад +3

      Can’t show clips of mistakes if there’s no mistakes.

    • @carldarville8700
      @carldarville8700 29 дней назад

      @@StephenHowson agreed but ‘everyone’ makes mistakes. I am ok with that as long as the player learns and grows from it.
      Literally every player on your original Utd shortlist has made mistakes and there will be clips out there to show their deficiencies also.
      I agree that he’s not worth over £50mill and his tag is heightened due to him being english.
      Defo one of future though

    • @directorme6669
      @directorme6669 29 дней назад

      ​@@carldarville8700he's not worth anything above 40M.
      Personally, I stopped replying on RUclips clips to judge a player long time ago. They're very manipulative. For the matches I have watched this boy, I haven't seen anything out of the ordinary

  • @stevejm3557
    @stevejm3557 29 дней назад

    Spot-on Mr Howson. Worth nowhere near the quoted fee. A decent prospect/player but not the finished item, by a long way.

  • @andrewchong5823
    @andrewchong5823 29 дней назад

    Credit to this guy he didn’t jump on the cringe ineos PR stunt Ala Neville interview ten hag. That stunt seals the deal ten hag is staying. The other RUclipsrs are celebrating keeping someone we only keep cause there is no one else

  • @emkiandthesundolls757
    @emkiandthesundolls757 27 дней назад +2

    Sorry but having watched him over the past season every week he is worth far more 50.
    John stones cost city 50mil when they bought him from Everton and jarrad is a far superior cb. He’s calm on the ball doesn’t make big errors ever. Positionally he’s always in the right place and is fast enough to recover when he is out of position.
    If he isn’t a 70mil plus defender I don’t know who is because the lad is a mountain. Two more years he will be at one of the biggest clubs in the world.

    • @shadow_realm47
      @shadow_realm47 23 дня назад +1

      yup, City will make a bid for 95m or 50m + Ake if they lose the league. United will get out priced like usual and overpay for an unknown from league 2.

    • @ekuniverse1
      @ekuniverse1 4 дня назад

      he can go to city, united need pacy defenders.

  • @banterclaus7963
    @banterclaus7963 26 дней назад

    His pass percentage is poor because passing from centre back to midfield is absolutely secondary for Everton and I bet my life on him being adviced to just put the ball long towards dangerous areas where the likes of Calvert-Lewin and Doucoure can flick it or then we can fight for the second ball. That and set pieces is the core of how we play. This passing statistic is entirely on the way team plays. The defending clips, fair play, can't really argue with that actually

  • @kokohaha3604
    @kokohaha3604 28 дней назад

    People see a young tall English centerback playing in the prem and immediately start suggesting he is the next best things. If he makes those mistakes at United, fans will cook him.

  • @nephilim811
    @nephilim811 29 дней назад

    I’m with you on this one, purposely watched him a few times because of the links and I just don’t see the hype.

  • @afaangrewal1427
    @afaangrewal1427 6 дней назад

    This lad is very much looking like a Rio Ferdinand / Sergio Ramos hybrid - wasn't too fond of him towards the start of the season but he's really shown his welly at the back end. 110% a definite signing to be done.

    • @ekuniverse1
      @ekuniverse1 4 дня назад

      ramos is way more quicker on his feet and much more aggressive.

    • @afaangrewal1427
      @afaangrewal1427 4 дня назад

      Nonono Ramos has many more years training, this is a very special defender.

    • @ekuniverse1
      @ekuniverse1 3 дня назад

      @@afaangrewal1427 So is he Real Madrid quality?

    • @afaangrewal1427
      @afaangrewal1427 3 дня назад

      @@ekuniverse1 Are you asking me if he could match and exceed the feats of the great Thomas Gravesen? my honest opinion is he is beyond Real Madrid quality he is Manchester United quality.

    • @ekuniverse1
      @ekuniverse1 3 дня назад

      @@afaangrewal1427 No because if he's that good he's better for Real Madrid like Jude, Barcelona, Bayern or Man City. Don't waste his career at United. They'll end up sacking Ten Hag next season. Also I'd rather have Tomori at United to be honest.

  • @noobgonebad9860
    @noobgonebad9860 29 дней назад

    Finally someone with a voice is saying what i have been saying

  • @currentstate8473
    @currentstate8473 29 дней назад +1

    Ten Hag likes center backs that have progressive passes

  • @febian1529
    @febian1529 29 дней назад

    His main strength is his speed, serial duel, i think his style is looks similar to Van de ven. But i agree, more than 50M is too much for him, now we are under INEOS, i hope they could find similar player from other league with cheaper price. This summer we need to be smart, we cant spend more than 50M on 1 player and we need some free transfer player.
    I think llyod Kelly and Tosin adarabioyo are gonna free this summer and they are decent player, we need these kind of signing first. Then we sell maguire-lindelof an use the money to buy todibo.

    • @berserker135
      @berserker135 29 дней назад

      Kelly and adarabioyo are both too old

  • @chrissilvester5663
    @chrissilvester5663 28 дней назад

    Everton might be forced to sell him for far cheaper than they want due to their financial situation. He's a class act Branthwaite but no way I'd pay mote than 50m for him. Maybe we could offer someone like Maguire in a swap deal who knows but honestly I'd just buy Todibo, Anselmino & maybe Adarabioyo on a free

    • @shadow_realm47
      @shadow_realm47 23 дня назад +1

      nope. City has a pre summer bid in for 70M each for both him and Onana. Both have also had talks with Bayern in January. United is not in the Equation.

  • @anthonyy616
    @anthonyy616 29 дней назад

    playing FM as im watching this vid and he literally just got sent off for my united team 😂 you can’t make this up. anyways great vid Ste

  • @hamlet2924
    @hamlet2924 29 дней назад

    Did you watch Cubarsi? That's a generational talent... I don't think Branthwaite is even been considered. Media just loves to link players with United.

  • @nhider21
    @nhider21 27 дней назад

    He goes to ground way too much, the fact that he relies on going down for a slide tackle just tells me he not suited to a big club. They wouldn’t put up with that shit

  • @liamr194
    @liamr194 29 дней назад

    Victor Lindelof and Johnny Evans can play 50yard passes into space down the channels... That doesn't make a United CB

  • @tc.4757
    @tc.4757 29 дней назад

    When Ste said "I've watched enough Everton game to like Onana, but not Branthwaite", I couldn't agree more

    • @thebizness5596
      @thebizness5596 29 дней назад +4

      Even Onana is not impressive.

    • @Jamiestanlee471
      @Jamiestanlee471 29 дней назад +2

      If wer looking at any everton players we have a problem

  • @Premier7768
    @Premier7768 28 дней назад

    I saw a picture of him and looks like a player at Manchester United. I hope we don't get the CB Scott Mctominay

  • @directorme6669
    @directorme6669 29 дней назад +1

    Finally, I have been waiting for this. Branthwaite is overrated and overpriced! Not worth more than Todibo which is something around 40M

  • @Brendan_M_
    @Brendan_M_ 29 дней назад

    Remember Maguire was supposed to be elite too? Maybe the most promising young English centre back but nothing more than that

  • @ssheldon1616
    @ssheldon1616 29 дней назад

    Dental work alone takes off at least 15M.

  • @callumbrown2898
    @callumbrown2898 29 дней назад

    Todibo £40m and Kelly from Bournemouth on a free, pretty much fixes the defence considering both Varane and Lindelof will probably leave

  • @larryjohnston5995
    @larryjohnston5995 28 дней назад

    Thanks to INEOS, overspending will be limited. Plus Wilcox seems meticulous.