bruh they the best band since the beatles. they all are exceptionally talented and charismatic. too bad they didn't break through to the mainstream they really could have been legendary and have a place in an evolution of a poprock movement.
@@incription i mean is it really? When the Beatles first got their fame they weren’t all that impressive. Just a couple of kids writing silly love songs for a quick buck. When they got their fame however they suddenly had a lot of room to experiment, with a big audience waiting to hear whatever it was the boys could come up with. The result was an audience that ate up everything the Beatles put out, even though it was so weird and different, and thereby changing music forever. If tally hall would’ve written just regular pop songs and gathered a large audience in the mainstream because of it, they would be able to drop an album like mmmm or good & evil and it would be considered legendary.
i love the concept with it, especially with the robotic voice and i really love that but it's very jarring to hear especially in the beginning. i think i prefer the remastered version but there's always the small little touches in the 2005 versions that brings you back to them...
also the vocal tracks are totally different on the 2005 mix of this song, the instrumental is mostly the same but things like ross's drums have different eq and no reverb.
I wouldn’t say the best of Tally Hall, but definitely one of the best from their album, at the end is all just personal tastes (i prefer The Ruler of everything or Spring and a Storm)
Taken for a ride is probably my favorite song on MMMM, and one of my favorite tally hall songs, and while there aren't that many differences, it's still interesting to see an alternative version of one of my favorite songs from the band
Lyrics: Marvin walked into a helpless land and wondered lightly am I happy, is this happy Following the footsteps left by man he stepped to reprimand the mystic who's sadistic Took a step into the elevator who said guess I'll see you later, don't you worry Fifteen flights that lasted nights and days that spent without a cent for creatures with their beat shirts Listening to painted whispered light on top forgotten hill Next the stranded senate of the white brick house with flowers asked some questions for their story All feeling now he took his bow and left the stage of time with no answers to no questions Lonely paperbacks that wanted just a taste of feeling to implode them before living Tiptoed to that wooden sign that said now take your place in line for happy, this is lovely Listening to painted whispered light on top forgotten hill One secondary smile To go that extra mile To make me feel today To make it go away The chemistry is gone Taken for a ride Far away from you No longer left inside The actor with his world renowned was thinking ‘bout his last real day of silence, was it over Or is it just we all think that our answer isn't real it's just a picture of a letter Bumble mumble make the rounds no matter what you'll seem profound it's useless just to worry Something normal happens somewhere far away in clouds so please stop thinking this is happy Listening to painted whispered light on top forgotten hill One secondary smile To go that extra mile To make me feel today To make it go away The chemistry is gone Taken for a ride Far away from you No longer left inside One secondary smile To go that extra mile To make me feel today To make it go away The chemistry is gone Taken for a ride Far away from you No longer left inside There're no secrets in the door Just a moment doing chores And there's something And there's something And there's something And there's something next to nothing And there's something And there's something But you're gone
Listening to this with one earbud in is an experience that sounds like how pizza without sauce tastes like. Also is it me or does the "Secondary Smile" part here fit alot better?
For me that difference ALONE greatly improves the song, nice & groovy tbh. Still not a great fan of the outro, but everything (even the outro) is a little better in this version, especially that final chorus.
while i will say some parts are good, this version’s andrew absolutely murdered my ears and the drums are mixed a bit weird. They also butchered the sax solo >:(
id ont remember andrew's vocals sounding this off what the scallop like i knew they were weird and were DEFINITELY an acquired taste but was it that off??? 😭
Final Version: Vocoded Robot Andrew
Demo: ELECTRIC GUITAR ANDREW
This voice sounds like it’s trying not to like a little, it’s actually pretty nice sounding
Whitty?
it's actually not a demo, this was actually done in a professional studio! just a very different mix of mostly the same tracks
@@modemcat98 Mfw people don't realize that these aren't demoes but the first release of MMMM.....
@Pip200ne what is this trying to say I'm confused
I JUMPED WHEN THE SINGING STARTED GOD DANG
big same
The robotic voice is atrocious.. But I love this version, just like the others.
@@itslenderman9858meh i Love it
REAL
Every copy of Tally Hall is personalized.
The Marvin Apparition
bruh they the best band since the beatles. they all are exceptionally talented and charismatic. too bad they didn't break through to the mainstream they really could have been legendary and have a place in an evolution of a poprock movement.
Oh yeah this meme
@@sandervandenbroek8508 big claim
@@incription i mean is it really? When the Beatles first got their fame they weren’t all that impressive. Just a couple of kids writing silly love songs for a quick buck. When they got their fame however they suddenly had a lot of room to experiment, with a big audience waiting to hear whatever it was the boys could come up with. The result was an audience that ate up everything the Beatles put out, even though it was so weird and different, and thereby changing music forever. If tally hall would’ve written just regular pop songs and gathered a large audience in the mainstream because of it, they would be able to drop an album like mmmm or good & evil and it would be considered legendary.
“And he turned himself into an electric guitar, funniest shit I’ve ever seen”
When was that
sounds something stanleymov whould say
@@rapvelasco193269:42:00
I think the more robotic effect on Andrew's voice makes the harmonies with the other members stand out more in comparison to the 2008 version
i love the concept with it, especially with the robotic voice and i really love that but it's very jarring to hear especially in the beginning. i think i prefer the remastered version but there's always the small little touches in the 2005 versions that brings you back to them...
Especially when the beat drops i guess it would be? It comes a lot sooner and is much more sudden
Robo Andrew persist through the entirety of the song in every version if you listen hard enough
remixed*
also the vocal tracks are totally different on the 2005 mix of this song, the instrumental is mostly the same but things like ross's drums have different eq and no reverb.
Unpopular opinion? Every version of this song is the best. Like not just saying they are all equal but that this is the best Tally Hall song.
I would agree.
I prefer A Hymn For A Scarecrow
I wouldn’t say the best of Tally Hall, but definitely one of the best from their album, at the end is all just personal tastes (i prefer The Ruler of everything or Spring and a Storm)
I agree so much
Hear me out, spring and a storm
Everything is off and I’m so confused-
Trust me bud there are several versions of these song from this album.
Guess you could say you where taken for a ride
@@Prgrant-gj6stMister where is my meatloaf
i love how horrendous the vocoder is, i do prefer the 2008 version. BUT... that chorus... the drums.... it's so good dude
YOOOOO HI
@@modemcat98 YOOOOOO
i’d like to imagine that this version is the only thing evil andrew can sing
Oh my god, I forgot it was like THIS
I see what you did there.
i ALSO see what you die there. (i am adding no value to this thread)
I am ALSO not adding any value to this comment
Listening to this with headphones is the best thing I’ve ever experienced
same.
my ears tho
I first heard this in a terraria tally hall mod and it scared the crap out of me
Truuuue 😂
@@Themothman1852 you heard *THIS* in a *_what????_*
Taken for a ride is probably my favorite song on MMMM, and one of my favorite tally hall songs, and while there aren't that many differences, it's still interesting to see an alternative version of one of my favorite songs from the band
somehow even less understandable than the current version
Yes
I like that Andrew put a broken, old, Chinese microphone in the toilet and every time someone flushed that toilet, he yelled from another room
it's like a more extreme version of taken for a ride, i love it
Lyrics:
Marvin walked into a helpless land and wondered lightly am I happy, is this happy
Following the footsteps left by man he stepped to reprimand the mystic who's sadistic
Took a step into the elevator who said guess I'll see you later, don't you worry
Fifteen flights that lasted nights and days that spent without a cent for creatures with their beat shirts
Listening to painted whispered light on top forgotten hill
Next the stranded senate of the white brick house with flowers asked some questions for their story
All feeling now he took his bow and left the stage of time with no answers to no questions
Lonely paperbacks that wanted just a taste of feeling to implode them before living
Tiptoed to that wooden sign that said now take your place in line for happy, this is lovely
Listening to painted whispered light on top forgotten hill
One secondary smile
To go that extra mile
To make me feel today
To make it go away
The chemistry is gone
Taken for a ride
Far away from you
No longer left inside
The actor with his world renowned was thinking ‘bout his last real day of silence, was it over
Or is it just we all think that our answer isn't real it's just a picture of a letter
Bumble mumble make the rounds no matter what you'll seem profound it's useless just to worry
Something normal happens somewhere far away in clouds so please stop thinking this is happy
Listening to painted whispered light on top forgotten hill
One secondary smile
To go that extra mile
To make me feel today
To make it go away
The chemistry is gone
Taken for a ride
Far away from you
No longer left inside
One secondary smile
To go that extra mile
To make me feel today
To make it go away
The chemistry is gone
Taken for a ride
Far away from you
No longer left inside
There're no secrets in the door
Just a moment doing chores
And there's something
And there's something
And there's something
And there's something next to nothing
And there's something
And there's something
But you're gone
We know
@@29485webp As a person who struggles at understanding the lyrics of English music, I didn't know lol.
wdym the lyrics are actually
WASAWFJDXWWAWWAWWawwASWswDUKBC
@@29485webp not
andrew with the xbox live mic
I really like this version
You forgot your quirk fishboy
Thank you Eridan Ampora, very cool!
ye, wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww
Sorry I can’t like it’s at 69
@@harrythemoth180 now is a 70
This has to be one of my favorite song in tally hall because, for some reason, this gives me some sci fi and nostalgia vibes (if that makes sense).
I was not prepared for Andrew's voice
THIS VERSION SLAPS HOLY
They must’ve really hated andrew’s singing in this one to do this to him
Lyrics: *phaser noises*
I was expecting him to just scream ‘EXTERMINATE’ half way through
3:34 i love how they kept joe being weird in the final release
true
IM CHOKING ON AIR STOP YELLING IN MY LEFT EAR HELP
For me this one's the best
thank you so much, this is the version i know
"we cant complete the album, theres a bee in the studio"
YEAHHH GET IT ON ANDREW
joe hawley's guitar can talk now
andrew sounds like a corrupted mp3
I thought I was having a stroke when the singing started.
Whichever version you prefer is best
I would probably like this version more if the robotic effect on andrew’s voice wasnt as strong
yeah its dogshit
what on god's green earth is that username
@@WD_RatLadhe’s a gay femboy that games, not that hard to understand
@@WD_RatLadaint no way 💀
Bro who let the alien into the band
Andrew was gnarp gnarp👽👽👽
@@mihimelolz746 gleebiest tally hall member
I like how as the beginning part progresses the instrumental sounds less like its being plaed in a mall.
Listening to this with one earbud in is an experience that sounds like how pizza without sauce tastes like. Also is it me or does the "Secondary Smile" part here fit alot better?
I have to say I really prefer this version to the Album version.
i love this version of taken for a ride so much
God damn it... it's so good.
andrew on that zaza 🔥
the synth singing at the start ; )
This is horrendous I love it
Ow my ears
Good song
DAMN that intro
ANDREW UR MIC
The only diference is the Andrew's robot voice
only major difference yeah, ross's drums sound kinda different and joe, zub, and rob's vocal tracks are slightly different
0:24 this sound of the voice and music changed sound like a horror thing the voice is very nerveracking
This made me incredibly anxious
I LOVE THE END PART EVEN MORE NOW??? SOMEONE NEEDS TO EXTEND IT DUDE WHAT.
i love how chaotic this one is along with the fact you can barely make out the lyrics in the beginning
Andrew the vacuum cleaner
Incomprehensible have a nice day
I love old tally halla
OMG THIS IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN THE NEW ONE BEST EXPERIENCE OF MY LIFE
I'm glad Andrew sang on the 2008 version instead of whatever robot abomination Joe created for this.
IIRC that’s still Andrew, there’s a video of him singing with the robotic vocals somewhere
yup, it’s either on some boralogue or an episode of this, but I’m not sure of this
but it’s still Andrew
Andrew is secretly a robot abomination
Sey
@@krowta2062 always has been andrew.
THE NEW VOICEROID ⁉️⁉️⁉️⁉️⁉️
For me the drums are a bit too heavy in the chorus, but other than that it slaps
For me that difference ALONE greatly improves the song, nice & groovy tbh. Still not a great fan of the outro, but everything (even the outro) is a little better in this version, especially that final chorus.
Ahead of Time
i honestly think that this is the only 2005 song that is worse then the 2008 version
same im very concerned with everyone who thinks its way better
@@Punzil0-0 bro no iffin way there's people that think this is better 😭
I am certain this is the version sung in the promo for MMMM
i think you’re right
I LOVE THIS MORE THAN THE FINAL VERSION
OMG THIS IS BEUTIFUL
I love this song tbh!!!
yayy electric guitar andrew
this is the better version ngl
this version is pretty epic
Here’s a neat detail I noticed it sounds like the robot voice is speaking gibberish but once you actually know the lyrics, you can hear them
does anyone know if these versions are on the 2005 cd?
They are
Why do people hate the vocals in this one I think I makes it sound cooler imo :p
wtf Glados
this song is the reason why the 2008 version exist
behold, the only 2005 version of a song from marvin's marvelous mechanical museum that isn't better than the rerelease
The robotic voice is so brain scratchy omg 😭
4:19 and there's something × infinity
i knew exactly what was gonna happen and i SITLL jumped 😭😭
I belive in Robot Andrew, supremacy
The voice in the beginning is atrocious, not gonna lie, but all the other parts of the song SLAP SO MUCH HOLY SHIT
the snare drum sounds strange in this version. Is this just me?
vocals sound wrong when wearing headphones
brad should be grateful cause he didn't have to listen to this version of tfar
Unpopular opinion: this song's robotic voice is better than the original
not to be that guy but this one is the original
@@visibly-tirednot to be that guy but leave people be they didnt spit on your mother's grave or something
@@GOATTRANSLATIONE wdym i wasn't aggressive or anything?
Andrew sounds like he has a stuffy nose
Tally Hall does NOT need autotune!!!! (Andrew does tho)
Alright, what the hidden meaning in this song?
there's no secrets in the door
It could be about someone dealing with depression
I think it's about terraforming places becuase of the taken for a ride far away from you and marvin walked into a hopeless land
The song dosen't have a meaning, it can be anything
yummy vocoder
Sick
Eh the Stuido version is better.
It's easier to hear for sure
This is Studio
Matipedia yeah, I guess they touched it up in 2008 and re-released it so both are studio
...this was recorded in a studio.
holy fuck the first part scared me LIKE THAT IS NOT MELODIC LIKE THE 2008 VERSION BUT ITS STILL SO GOOD
SUPER MARIO MAKER
Took me a while but I get it
@@dani.munoz.a23 enlighten me I’m brain dead
@@Its_NEX123 i may be wrong but i think its the robot voice at the beginning, the one narrating Marvin's story
@@dani.munoz.a23 i get it now lol
while i will say some parts are good, this version’s andrew absolutely murdered my ears and the drums are mixed a bit weird.
They also butchered the sax solo >:(
ROBO ANDREWWWWW!!!
honestly i kind of prefer this one over the 2008 one.
same, this one sounds better
This is the song I heard noice.
id ont remember andrew's vocals sounding this off what the scallop
like i knew they were weird and were DEFINITELY an acquired taste but was it that off??? 😭
im assuming it's cuz i havent listened to it in a while and i lost that taste
update: yeah thats what it was
update: yeah thats what it was
@@CASTLECALAMITY update: yeah thats what it was
Marvin walked in to help a friend w Ww WHATS THAT SUPPOSED TO MEAN
It’s “Marvin walked into a helpless land”
bro this is atrocious
Love this song, but this is just…too much. This version sounds like a bad Xbox 360 mic being sang through a tube